ACCEPTING ALI SINA CHALLENGE Dear Mr.

Ali Sina I myself IBRAHIM DEWASWALA from INDIA accept your challenge of disproving all accusations you made against MUHAMMAD and ISLAM All what I am doing is not for fame or your 50000$.Its not even for getting FFI removed or you confessing truth about ISLAM .It is just for self satisfaction. Dear Sir as per you and your research,quran was written by MUHAMMAD himself for his own self motives.Ok ,for instant let us suppose this as a truth.But you answ er these few questions of mine so as to let me accept your claim. 1) WHY WOULD MUHAMMAD WRITE THE QURAN The reasons you give are as follow. Narcissism particularly cerebral narcissism Mythomania Convulsions/epilepsy/seizures High activity of pineal gland i.e ability to see near and distant future His madness His personal glory His lust for money and sex. Lets discuss each of the above points in detail. 1) Narcissism:- As per your research MUHAMMAD was a narcissist.In order to satisfy all 9-10 criterions of narcissism MUHAMMAD wrote a book. Now logically thinking there are many aspects behind this accusation. a) If MUHAMMAD was a narcissist and he wrote a book that is non comparabl e to any scriptures mankind had ever seen,then in a span of 1400 years had there been not a single arabic or non arabic ,muslim or non muslim narcissist who had written a single verse like what MUHAMMAD had written.Narcissism is about grand eosity and self importance. If even a single man would have written even a singl e line he would have got much more praise than MUHAMMAD both from muslims and no n muslims.Tell me have you met or have read about any such personality in presen t or in past . b)Quran is not just a book that describes about a few historical events or bibil ical prophecies. Neither it just boast about prophet or praises prophet as in th e entire book there are only 20 verses where prophet is praised.It contains a la rge number of topics ,some of them being wrongly interpreted by many of us.It co ntains descriptions about geology ,embryology,hydrology,cosmology and many other scientific aspects. If MUHAMMAD was a narcissist it was easy for him to boast about himself and his unequalled brilliance and poetic talents by describing a lot more of bibilical p rophecies and about himself and much more of his personal desires.What was a nee d to tell about earth ,mountains,embryo,universal creations,barriers that seprat es the sees,lost nations one like that of Iram,production of fruits in pair,red rose in the sky,origin of entire universe from smoke,splitting of moon and so on to a society which was completely unaware of all this aspects.Didnt MUHAMMAD fea red that whatever he is saying if he would be asked about there explanations wha t would he tell them? Even a narcissist requires a great command over all this s ubjects and detailed knowledge of the relative aspects.Where did MUHAMMAD got al l this knowledge from? As per your research the possible sources for MUHAMMAD ga thering that knowledge were:I. Before his marriage at age of 25 he was a wanderer and he might have got that knowledge during that wanderings. II. After marriage to KHADIJA he got involved in her business and during tri ps farther places he gathered that knowledge. III. His Christian friend would have told him about the stories of Bible. Lets discuss all the possibilities in detail:A. Before his marriage MUHAMMAD was a wanderer and he gathered all that kno wledge during his wanderings.Logically thinking is it logical for a man of 16-25 to think about writting a book in order to be the greatest among his own commun ity.Let us assume that MUHAMMAD had seen how MOSES and JESUS became great after giving a book. So he thought he would also become great like them repeating the same thing but in a different manner.Even if this was the case was MUHAMMAD not able to think even a bit logically the things I am going to mention now?As per y

our challenge islam was nothing but a poliitical cult. If a man could write such a book and do such a great politics he must have a great political mind. Even i f MUHAMMAD got fantasized with the success of MOSES and JESUS was he himself not able to think about his coming future. He must have learned the entire TORAH an d BIBLE in order to get to those histories. Was there even a single arabic versi on of bible or torah available at his time. Ok let us say there was a arabic bib le that MUHAMMAD destroyed in order to get his work greater affiliation. Not eve n a single islamic or non islamic or pre islamic source have confirmed about MUH AMMAD reading a arabic bible in his home or during his wanderings. The second lo gical thing is that even if MUHAMMAD had read the entire bible by any means ,he would have definitely learned that there were numerous unearthly sings from God that made MOSES and JESUS got easily accepted to their respective people. If MUH AMMAD was a false prophet was he not able to think even a bit that there would b e no clear signs for him that can make him acceptable to arabs before starting t he composition of quran. A great politician before venturing ever thinks about a ll the possible dangers. The third thing is that already there were large commun ities believing in MOSES(THE CHILDREN OF ISRAEL) and JESUS(THE COMMUNITY OF JEWS ) although they had great opponents Pharoah in case of MOSES and Rome in case of JESUS. Was MUHAMMAD not able to think that there was not even a single man beli eving in him. How would he accomplish his task without a single follower. All th is is before his marriage when he was just known to not more than a handful peop le. MUHAMMAD would definitely be knowing his community ,their dealings,their way s of wars, their ways to handle religious rebellions,their ways of punishing,the ir love for their gods and business and to things of daily life they cannot give up like drinking and gambling. No miraculous signs, no followers, no listeners ,no caretakers, and a period of early adulthood. Do it seems even a bit logical for a boy to gather such vast knowledge so as to start such a impossible cult ju st to get a bit of fame among his community??? Even he was a narcissist a great mind like that of his would not have risked his whole life,business,lust for sex or money,and almost everything just to get admiration. He would have got much m ore admiration from his people if he would be a good businessman or it would be much easier for him to get on the throne of Mecca rather than writing a book bec ause a man who can make such a cult can do anything. B. Now lets talk about what did MUHAMMAD did after his marriage. Muslims as well as non muslims scholars says that MUHAMMAD was good at business. Seeing hi s business skills it was KHADIJA who proposed MUHAMMAD for marriage. Islamic as well as non islamic sources says that after the marriage MUHAMMAD got engaged in his wifes business. So he went far of places leading caravans there. Non muslims say that during his journeys he gathered that knowledge which he later produced as a book. Ok taking this possibility I ask whether is it possible that MUHAMMA D got knowledge of such vast subjects just by going on a few of such trips. MUHA MMAD would have never gone to city of Iram nor he would have seen barriers betwe en two sees the most prominent example of which is in Atlantic ocean. Neither I think any tribe on MUHAMMADS way would have told him about the oneness of matter before the creation of this universe or about differnt embryonic stages of life or about flowers having male and female sexual parts. Even though if we take a p ossibility of great civilizations of world like Rome,Egypt,Chinese,Indian etc. k nowing all these sciences in the 7th century and MUHAMMAD would have gathered fr om them these knowledge why MUHAMMAD described it to a illiterate society like t hat of his which knows nothing more than doing good business. If MUHAMMAD was re ally a narcissist he would have a great need of admiration and grandiose. Apart from a few bibilical stories he would have mention about a few gods of kaaba or about some heads of Mecca or would have cursed their evils in a bit good manner. In that way MUHAMMAD would have got much more praises and in a much easier way. Even a narcissist is not a complete mad man. He also properly plans the means h e adopted to get admiration and adulation. Did not MUHAMMAD ever thought the thi ng he is going to do would lead him to such dangers. The above discussions was for non muslims who says that MUHAMMAD intensely got i nvolved in her wifes business. Now Mr. Sina as per your accusations in your secti on(MUHAMMAD as looter) you declare that after marrying KHADIJA ,MUHAMMAD did not

paid attention to her business as he withdraw himself to a cave to either medit ate or to compose a scripture. If MUHAMMAD was a man who had a great lust for mo ney and other worldly pleasures why would he willingly loose those easy gains? W hy would he go to a cave rather than handling his family business which could fu lfill both his narcissism as well as his earthly desires. With a prosperous busi ness he would be easily able to get on the throne of mecca and then he would hav e done so many other things. The second thing is that you yourself declared that women in pre islamic era were more powerful than in post islamic era. Why did K HADIJA didnt stopped MUHAMMAD from those nonsense things. And if MUHAMMAD didnt li sten to her why did she remained in marriage with that mad man for 25 years. A p owerful woman in arab would definitely had a right to divorce her husband. And f inally as per this claim of yours MUHAMMAD could have gathered only a bit of kno wledge before his marriage in his early adulthood because after marriage he woul d just isolate himself to a cave where he would find nothing more than stones. Now taking the possibility of excess narcissism of MUHAMMAD it might be assumed that he would have seen how MOSES and JESUS suffered before they became great. S o he took to this exhaustive hardships. If really this was the case then MUHAMMA D cannot be a looter as he can either be a narcissist or a looter or a man with great lust for money and sex because both narcissism and lust cannot logically g o together in case of MUHAMMAD. The second logical thing is that how lucky this mad man was that inspite of 13 years of severe hardships in hometown Mecca, cons piracies in Medina, lost battle of Uhud, breakdown of the treaty of Hudeibiya an d many more of such attempts that he was not massarced. Islamic as well as non i slamic sources confirmed that people of Mecca left no way to kill or persecute M UHAMMAD. Its not much logical but its a thing to think as to how a false prophet didnt got killed inspite of years attempts and finally had success in changing t he face of world. C. The above point was about what MUHAMMAD did after his marriage. Now the th ird source of his gathering of knowledge was his Christian friend. Sources revea l that MUHAMMAD had a Christian friend just for a little span of time. Is it eve n a bit logical that friend would have told the entire bible in that short span of time. Even if this was the case how MUHAMMAD got the other knowledges that ar e revealed in the book. Surely that Christian friend would not have that knowled ge too. The second thing is that why did that Christian friend didnt said anythin g when MUHAMMAD told Christians as wrong or why he himself didnt claim the author ship of the book? The above three points were about the sources from which MUHAMMAD would have gra bbed the knowledge which he later produced as a book. c. If MUHAMMAD was a narcissist then in that case all the great people be it MOSES,JESUS,RAM ,KRISHNA,BUDDHA,MAHAVIR,ZORASTER BILL GATES,AMBANI,NEWTON ,EINS TEIN and many more like them ,they all are narcissist. Considering religions onl y you mean to say that BIBLE was a consequence of JESUS narcissism and TORAH of that of MOSES and BHAGWAD GEETA of that of KRISHNA and VEDAS of that of the grou p of sages to whom it was given. As per this claim there is no god in the world and all scriptures are a consequence of somebodys narcissim. d. If MUHAMMAD claimed himself as KHAIRUL KALKH the best of all creation and that he was created before this world due to his narcissism what is a big deal i n it? Jesus do claimed himself as THE LIGHT OF THE WORLD (When Jesus began his min istry, his miracles and radical teaching immediately drew huge crowds, creating a frenzy of excitement. As his popularity swelled with the masses, the Jewish le aders (Pharisees, Sadducees, & Scribes) began to see Jesus as a threat. Suddenly they began looking for ways to trap him. One day Jesus was debating some Pharisees at the Temple, when suddenly he told t hem he is the light of the world. It is almost bizarre to picture this scene, wher e a traveling carpenter from the lowlands of Galilee tells these PhDs in religion that he is the light of the world? Believing that Yahweh is the light of the worl d, they replied indignantly: You are making false claims about yourself (John 8:13 NLT). Then Jesus told them that, 2,000 years earlier, Abraham had foreseen him. Their response was incredulous:

You arent even fifty years old. How can you say you have seen Abraham? (John 8:57 NLT) Then Jesus shocked them even more: The truth is, before Abraham was, I AM. (John 8:58 NLT)) I am not dealing with Christianity but the reference was a bit necessary to be s hown. In this manner JESUS too was a narcissist. Indian lord KRISHNA himself dec lared that he is god. In that manner he too should be a great narcissist. Moses was asked the same thing by his own people when he went to mount Sinai for 40 n ights that he is not the messiah and he doing all that for getting praise. In th at manner MOSES should be a great narcissit. All the above blog was on MUHAMMAD narcissism. This is a brief answer to your ve ry first accusation (MUHAMMAD AS NARCISSIST). There is much more to be said on t he same thing but it is bit difficult to be published on net. 2. Convulsions/epilepsy/seizures:- Let us assume that MUHAMMAD wrote QURAN as a consequence of his epilepsy or convulsions. Is it even a bit logical to assume an epileptic man writing such a scripture? When the first verse was revealed to MUHAMMAD in the cave definitely he was in a position as if he was an epileptic man. But what about the subsequent verses and that too for 23 years of his life. Didnt he got noticed even a once of his disease by the arabian pagans who were e ager to prove him wrong or by his own family members even before the revelations started. There were several verses that were revealed in public. It is illogica l to assume of MUHAMMAD not getting noticed even once for his convulsions or sei zures. The second thing is that a epileptic man during his seizures says some no n sense things which he later forgets. I dont think that QURAN contains nonsense neither it was that MUHAMMAD forgot it after it has been revealed. In daily pray ers he used to recite the verses of QURAN and he didnt forget even a single verse in his lifetime. No resources describe MUHAMMAD forgetting the verses once they were revealed or MUHAMMAD reciting them wrongly. The third thing is that you yo urself accused ISLAM as a political cult and MUHAMMAD as a clever politician. Is it possible for an epileptic man to hold out such great politics that changed t he face of history and gave a new religion? All the sources confirmes about the healthy life of MUHAMMAD. The above was an answer to your accusation (MUHAMMAD AS AN EPILEPTIC). 3. The third and the most important reason for MUHAMMAD writing the book as per almost all the non muslim critics was his lust for money and sex. This is a point that needs centre attention and a very long discussion. Let us discuss thi s point in details.Starting from the birth of MUHAMMAD the following points illu strates different aspects. MUHAMMAD was born 6 months after death of his father (ABDULLAH) to AMENA BINT WA HAB in the year 570 A.D. He belonged from Quraiysh of Mecca. At the age of 6 MUHAMMAD lost his mother and then his uncle ABU TALIB became his caretaker. At the age of 12 MUHAMMAD made his first trip to Syria with his uncle and after this he got engaged in his business. Sources say that he was good at business. At the age of 25 seeing MUHAMMADs business skills KHADIJA proposed him for marria ge. MUHAMMAD accepted the proposal and married her. After this he was now a weal thy man of Mecca and he got a status in the society. At the age of 40 the first verse of QURAN was revealed to MUHAMMAD in the cave a nd after that the whole thing started.