8'.

  3ULPTHQR

 PDM 

32/,7,A.$ 5(9,-$
NATO POLITICAL REVIEW *RGLQD (XVI) IV, vol 
%U    VWU 

3ULKYD`HQR
 MXQ 

3UHJOHGQL UDG

9LQNR?XUL`
,VWUDLYDa ,36 %HRJUDG

/$#.$235(7+2'1,&$1$72$.&,-$ 6DHWDN
6YH VYRMH DNFLMH DJUHVLYQRJ LQWHUQDFLRQDOL]PD 1$72 MH ]DSRaHR QD ODL aDN MH L WH]D R ^LUHZX GHPRNUDW VNRJ PLUD WROLNR UDZLYD GD VH MHGQRVWDYQR PRH SRL VWRYHWLWL VD LGHROR^NLP QHLVWLQDPD /D MH X PH_X QDURGQRM SROLWLFL SRVWDOD SUHWKRGQLFD JRWRYR VYLK UDWQLK RSHUDFLMD PLOLWDULVWLaNRJ KXPDQL]PD .TXaQH UHaL OD 1$72 GHPRNUDWVNL PLU PLOLWDUL VWLaNL KXPDQL]DP DJUHVLYQL LQWHUQDFLRQDOL]DP

DYQH  JRGLQH X 9D^LQJWRQX MH RVQRYDQ YRMQL VDYH] SRG QD]L YRP 1$72 2G GYDQDHVW ]HPDTD RVQLYDaD 6$' .DQDGD 9 %UL WDQLMD ,VODQG 1RUYH^ND 'DQVND +RODQGLMD %HOJLMD /XNVHPEXUJ )UDQFXVND 3RUWXJDOLMD L ,WDOLMD QDUDVWDR MH QD RUXDQX VLOX NRMRM GDQDV SULSDGD  ]HPDTD 8 WHNVW VSRUD]XPD R RVQLYDZX X]HWD MH 3RYHTD 81 X aLMHP VH  aODQX SRWYU_XMH LQGLYLGXDOQR L NROHNWLYQR SUDYR QD VDPRRGEUDQX 8 VNODGX VD 3RYHTRP 8MHGLZHQLK QDFLMD 1$72 VH REDYH]DR GD QH`H VSURYRGLWL RUXDQH DNFLMH L GUXJH PHUH  D GD R WRPH RGPDK QH REDYH VWL 6DYHW EH]EHGQRVWL 6YH PHUH `H ELWL REXVWDYTHQH GRN 6DYHW EH] EHGQRVWL QH SUHGX]PH NRUDNH NRML VX QHRSKRGQL ]D XVSRVWDYTDZH L RGUDYDZH PH_XQDURGQRJ PLUD L EH]EHGQRVWL LOL GUXJLP UHaLPD 1$72 QH`H GHORYDWL EH] RGREUHZD 6DYHWD EH]EHGQRVWL 81 0H_X WLP YL^HPHVHaQD ERPEDUGHUVND DNFLMD SURWLY 6UELMH L]YHGHQD  QLMH LPDOD PDQGDW 81 2YR MH ELOD VDPR MHGQD RG ODL NRMD MH SRPRJOD GD 1$72 IXQNFLRQL^H L GHOXMH SRVOH UDVSDGD 9DU^DYVNRJ SDNWD +DQD $UHQW MH SRWSXQR ELOD X SUDYX NDGD MH QDSLVDOD GD MH SUDYD VX^WLQD LVWLQH X ZHQRM QHPR`L D SUDYD VX^WLQD PR`L X SRGPXNORVWL DOL $UHQWRYD QH EL ]DPHULOD GD X] SRGPXNORVW VYUVWDPR L OD 1DM


+DQD $UHQW ,VWLQD L OD X SROLWLFL )LOLS 9L^ZL` %HRJUDG  VWUDQD 
  

9LQNR ?XUL`

/$# .$2 35(7+2'1,&$ 1$72 $.&,-$

ERTD SRWYUGD UD]PL^TDZD QHPDaNH SHUMDQLFH VDYUHPHQH ILOR]RIL MH MH SRQD^DZH 1$72 /D L VLOD SRVOH SDGD %HUOLQVNRJ ]LGD SRVWD OH VX aLQLRFL RGUDYDZD 6HYHUQRDWODQWVNH DOLMDQVH 8]LPDMX`L RYX aLZHQLFX NDR SROD]QX RVQRYX ODNR MH L]YU^LWL SRSLV ODL 1$72 NRMH VX QDQHOH L NRMH `H X VNRURM EXGX`QRVWL QDQRVLWL GRVWD ]OD YH`HP GHOX aRYHaDQVWYD 'UXJD YHOLND OD PR`QLND NRML VX NUHLUDOL VYHWVNX XORJX 1$72 ELOD MH GD VH RYD YRMQD RUJDQL]DFLMD SRVOH SDGD %HUOLQVNRJ ]LGD QH`H ^LULWL QD ,VWRN 6YL ]QDaDMQLML SROLWLaDUL VD =DSDGD +HOPXW .RO ;RQ 0HM[RU 'DJODV +HUG )UDQVRD 0LWHUDQ VX GR SDGD %HUOLQVNRJ ]LGD L QHSRVUHGQR SR ZHJRYRP UX^HZX XYHUDYDOL UXVNH ]YDQLaQLNH GD QHPD QLNDNYH ERMD]QL RG ^LUHZD 1$72 SDNWD QD ,VWRN 7DNR MH ;RQ 0HM[RU SUHPLMHU 9HOLNH %ULWDQLMH UHNDR PDUWD PHVHFD  PLQLVWUX RGEUDQH 6RYMHWVNRJ 6DYH]D ' -D]RYX GD VH QH SUHGYL_DMX XV ORYL GD EL VDGD D QL X EXGX`QRVWL LVWRaQRHYURSVNH ]HPTH PRJOH ELWL X 1$72 VDYH]X 0H_XWLP VYH VRFLMDOLVWLaNH ]HPTH NRMH VX VYRMH YUHPHQR SULSDGDOH LVWRaQRP EORNX RVLP 5XVLMH L EDONDQVNLK L]X]H WDND GDQDV VX X 1$72 SDNWX 1HNROLNR PHVHFL SRVOH UDVSDGD 9DU^DYVNRJ SDNWD X QRYHPEUX  JRGLQH 1$72 MH QD VDVWDQNX X 5LPX QD SURPHZHQX SROLWLaNX VL WXDFLMX X VYHWX UHDJRYDR VD QRYLP VWUDWH^NLP NRQFHSWRP 8 WRP NRQ FHSWX MH SRWYU_HQD GRNWULQD ]DVWUD^LYDZD X] ]DGUDYDZH RSFLMH SUDYD SUYRJ SRVH]DZD ]D DWRPVNLP RUXMHP ^WR MH X VXSURWQRVWL VD 3RYHTRP 81 7DNR MH SRVWDOR VDVYLP RaLJOHGQR GD MH 1$72 DOLMDQVD SRG UHLPRP RIDQ]LYQH YRMQH GRNWULQH NRMRM VX ]D SUDYR SUYRJ XGDUD QHL]RVWDYQR SRWUHEQL XYHUTLYL SRYRGL SD PDNDU ELOL L ODQL NR MH GR RWSRaLZDZD NRQNUHWQLK DNFLMD EH]UH]HUYQR SRGUDYDMX PHGLML JOREDOQH PUHH $JUHVLMD 1$72 VQDJD QD 5HSXEOLNX 6USVNX RWSRaHOD MH SRVOH QDYRGQRJ VUSVNRJ ]ORaLQDaNRJ PLQREDFDaNRJ JUDQDWLUDZD VDUDMHY VNH SLMDFH 0DUNDOH JGH MH DNWLYLUDZHP HNVSOR]LYD SRGPHWQXWRJ SRG SLMDaQX WH]JX XELMHQR YL^H RG ^H]GHVHW L UDZHQR VWRWLQX FLYLOD PX VOLPDQVNH QDFLRQDOQRVWL 3RWYUGX ODL R 0DUNDODPD X YL^H QDYUDWD GDR MH UXVNL SXNRY QLN $QGUHM 'XPXUHQNR NRPDQGDQW UXVNRJ PLURYQRJ NRQWLQJHQWD WR NRP UDWD X %L+ 6UHGLQRP PDUWD PHVHFD  'HPXUHQNR MH GDR LQWHU YMX VUSVNRM DJHQFLML 6UQD X NRP MH SRQRYLR RQR ^WR MH UHNDR L SUH GH VHW JRGLQD GD JUDQDWD QD VDUDMHYVNX SLMDFX 0DUNDOH  QLMH LVSD THQD QL VD VUSVNLK QL VD KUYDWVNLK SRORDMD YH` GD MH UHa R PLQL NRMD MH SRVWDYTHQD LVSRG WH]JL GD EL ELR LVSURYRFLUDQ 1$72 QDSDG QD VUSVNH SRORDMH 3XNRYQLN 'HPXUHQNR WYUGL GD QLMH ELOR WUDJRYD QD


,]MDYX MH SUHQHR *ODV MDYQRVWL  PDUWD 

  

32/,7,A.$ 5(9,-$ EU  JRG

(XVI) IV vol=7

VWU 

WUDYL NRMLK XYHN LPD SR LVSDTLYDZX JUDQDWH NDR L GD MH QD ORNDFLML JGH MH WUHEDOR GD EXGH VUSVNL PLQREDFDa  ELOR ^XPRYLWR $ SR UHaL PD 'HPXUHQND GREUR MH SR]QDWR GD VH PLQREDFDaHP QLNDNR QH JD_D L] ^XPH MHU JUDQH PRJX GD ]DXVWDYH JUDQDWX 5XVNL SXNRYQLN WDNR_H WYU GL GD ]ERJ ]JUDGD NRMH RNUXXMX SLMDFX JUDQDWD QL VOXaDMQR QLMH PRJOD GD VWLJQH VD VUSVNLK SRORDMD 2Q VH VH`D L GD VX $PHULNDQFL SRVOH ZHJRYLK WYUGZL SREHVQHOL L WUDLOL GD EXGH YUD`HQ X 5XVLMX DOL VX RG WRJD RGXVWDOL GD QH EL GR^OR GR VNDQGDOD 'HPXUHQNR MH GXERNR XEH _HQ GD `H MHGQRJ GDQD LVWLQD LSDN L]D`L QD YLGHOR  GD MH PLQD DNWLYL UDQD GDTLQVNLP XSUDYTDaHP AHWYUWD YHOLND OD NRMD MH VWDMDOD 6UELMX GYH KLTDGH L SHWVWR WLQD FLYLOQLK L YRMQLK UWDYD ELOD MH YH]DQD ]D QDYRGQH PDVRYQH JUREQLFH QD .RVPHWX X NRMLPD MH WUHEDOR GD EXGH L]PH_X  L  KL TDGD XELMHQLK $OEDQDFD 2YD OD SRWSRPRJQXWD L]PRQWLUDQRP SUL aRP R VUSVNRP PDVDNUX X VHOX 5DaDN ELOD MH LVIDEULNRYDQD GD EL RW SRaHOD YH` RGDYQR LVSODQLUDQD ERPEDUGHUVND DNFLMD 1$72 SURWLY 6UELMH ,QWHUYHQFLMD 1$72 VQDJD QD ,UDN WDNR_H MH RWSRaHOD ]ERJ OD L R WDNR]YDQRP SRVWRMDZX RUXMD ]D PDVRYQR XQL^WDYDZH TXGL 6OHGH`D YHOLND OD 1$72 aHOQLND VDGUDOD MH WYUGZX GD VX VQDJH 1$72 DOLMDQVH X^OH X ,UDN NDNR EL VYUJOL QHGHPRNUDWVNL UHLP 6DGDPD +XVHLQD VD YODVWL 0H_XWLP VYLPD MH GREUR SR]QDWR GD MH ,UDN ]DX]HW ]ERJ NRQWUROH QDIWQLK L]YRUD NRML REH]EH_XMX FUQR ]OD WR $PHULFL ,SDN GHVHW ]HPDTD aODQLFD 1$72 DOLMDQVH RGELOR MH GD ^DTH VYRMH YRMQLNH X ,UDN QH HOH`L GD VDXaHVWYXMX X ODLPD NDR QL GD VOXH DPHULaNLP LQWHUHVLPD DOL L RSUDYGDQR VWUDKXMX`L RG WHUR ULVWLaNH RGPD]GH PLOLWDQWQLK PXVOLPDQD ,VWLQD R SUDYLP UD]OR]LPD LQWHUYHQFLMH QD ,UDN REHORGDZHQD MH SRVOH HNVSOR]LMH NRMD VH GRJRGLOD X 5DILQHULML %ULWL^ SHWUROH XPX  PDUWD  L] NRPHQWDUD RSR]LFLRQH 'HPRNUDWVNH VWUDQNH SRYRGRP RYRJ GRJD_DMD 1DLPH GHPRNUDWH ]DPHUDMX ;RU[X %X^X 7HN VD^DQLQX SRYH]DQRP VD V SHWUROHMVNLP NUXJRYLPD GD MH VNRN FHQD QDIWH GRND] QHXVSH^QRVWL RSHUDFLMH X ,UDNX -HU NDNR NDX GHPRN UDWH RG WH DNFLMH MH WUHEDOR GD GRELMX MHIWLQLMH D QH VNXSTH JRULYR 

/DL1$72SDNWD
1$72 `H VH YRMQR DQJDRYDWL VDPR X] RGREUHZH 6DYHWD EH] EHGQRVWL 8MHGLZHQLK QDFLMD 1$72 VH QH`H ^LULWL QD ,VWRN SRVOH SDGD %HUOLQVNRJ ]LGD (NVSOR]LMD QD SLMDFL 0DUNDOH SRVOH NRMH GROD]L GR DJUHVLMH 1$72 QD VUSVNH SRORDMH X %RVQL


3ROLWLND  PDUW 

  

9LQNR ?XUL`

/$# .$2 35(7+2'1,&$ 1$72 $.&,-$

1D .RVPHWX VH QDOD]H PDVRYQH JUREQLFH VD  GR  KLTDGD $OEDQDFD ,UDN SRVHGXMH RUXMH ]D PDVRYQR XQL^WDYDZH TXGL 8 ,UDN VPR GR^OL GD VUX^LPR GLNWDWRUVNL UHLP 3URQD`L `HPR L XKDSVLWL 0ODGL`D L .DUD[L`D 8ODVNRP X 1$72 aH^ND YRMQD LQGXVWULMD `H SURVSHULUDWL 0HFL VD RVLURPD^HQLP XUDQLMXPRP QLVX ^WHWQL SR TXGH L LYRWQX VUHGLQX 3DQaHYDaND $]RWDUD QLMH JD_DQD QDPHUQR 1$72 XVSRVWDYTD L ^WLWL ^LURP VYHWD GHPRNUDWVNL PLU
2EH`DZH GD `H 1$72 VQDJH X %RVQL SURQD`L L XKDSVLWL .DUD[L `D L 0ODGL`D GDQDV SRND]XMX VYX QHPR` QDMMDaH RUXDQH VLOH QD VYHWX NRMD VYH VYRMH XVSHKH ED]LUD QD ODLPD L SUHNRPHUQRM XSRWUHEL VLOH PDGD VX SRQHNDG RYD VUHGVWYD VWDURPRGQD L QHHILNDVQD EDU NDGD VX SRMHGLQFL X SLWDZX AH^ND MDYQRVW VH VYRMHYUHPHQR QDVOX^DOD PQRJLK REH`DZD PH_X NRMLPD MH L RQR GD `H ZHQD YRMQD LQGXVWULMD GRLYHWL SUDYL SURVSH ULWHW WHN NDG RYD ]HPTD X_H X 1$72 0H_XWLP AH^ND MH SRVOH SHW JR GLQD SURYHGHQLK X 1$72 DOLMDQVL GRLYHOD QL] UD]RaDUHZD SD L RQR GD MRM MH YRMQD LQGXVWULMD SRaHOD GD SRVU`H ,VWX VXGELQX LPDMX L RVWD OH ]HPTH ELY^HJ VRFLMDOLVWLaNRJ ODJHUD NRMH VX X^OH X 1$72 (NVSHULPHQW NRML VX 6$' RWSRaHOH GYD SXWD X ,UDNX L WRNRP  GDQD QD .RVPHWX L SHW ORNDFLMD X 6UELML L &UQRM *RUL VD PXQLFLMRP RG RVLURPD^HQRJ XUDQLMXPD YH` MH GRYHR GR PDVRYQRJ RERTHYDZD ND NR X UHGRYLPD YRMQLND L RILFLUD NRML VX UXNRYDOL LOL ELOL EOL]X PH VWD GHMVWDYD RYH PXQLFLMH WDNR L NRG VWDQRYQL^WYD NRMH LYL QD SUR VWRULPD JGH MH GHMVWYRYDQR PXQLFLMRP VD RVLURPD^HQLP XUDQLMXPRP 1DMYDQLMH MH UH`L GD VX SRVOHGLFH RVLURPD^HQRJ XUDQLMXPD WUDMQD PXWDFLMD JHQD L EU]R UD]ERTHYDZH RG UDND SOX`D 1D FHORM WHULWRULML ,UDND QLYR R]UDaHZD MH YH`L ]D  SXWD RG QRUPDOQRJ D QD .RVPHWX X ]RQDPD GHMVWYD RVLURPD^HQH XUDQLMXPVNH PXQLFLMH UDN SOX`D NRG VWDQRYQL^WYD MH GXSOLUDQ X RGQRVX QD YUHPH SUH ERPEDUGRYDZD 1$ 72 DOLMDQVH 7UHED UH`L L WR GD MH JODYQL SUREOHP ]DJD_HZD 3DQaHYD QDPHUQR JD_DZH MHGQH RG WUL FLVWHUQL X NUXJX $]RWDUH SRVOH WHUPRYL]LM VNRJ DYLR RVPDWUDZD ^WR MH SURX]URNRYDOR  WRQD D]RWQRJ RWSD GD 2YDM RWSDG MH SXWHP YRGH L YD]GXKD ]DJDGLR aRYHNRYX VUHGLQX SUHNR VYLK JUDQLFD 3UDYD LVWLQD R SDQaHYDaNRP ]DJD_HZX QDOD]L VH X SR VOHGLFDPD 1$72 ERPEDUGRYDZD D QH X ]DJD_HZX YD]GXKD RG LQGXVWUL MVNLK SRVWURMHZD NDNR WR HOH GD SUHGVWDYH QHNL ]YDQLaQLFL
  

32/,7,A.$ 5(9,-$ EU  JRG

(XVI) IV vol=7

VWU 

0H_XWLP LGHROR^NL SRVPDWUDQR OD NRMD GDQDV GRPLQLUD FH ORP RUJDQL]DFLMRP 1$72D MH GD RQD SRVWRML NDNR EL ^LULOD VYHWRP GHPRNUDWVNL PLU 6X^WLQD WHRULMH R ^LUHZX GHPRNUDWVNRJ PLUD NRMX GDQDV %X^ NYDOLILNXMH NDR DJUHVLYQL LQWHUQDFLRQDOL]DP NR ML SRGUD]XPHYD ^LUHZH VORERGH L RNRQaDZH WLUDQLMH QD JOREDO QRP QLYRX VDGUDQD MH L X WYUGZL GD GHPRNUDWLMH QH YRGH PH_XVREQR UDWRYH 7DNR )ULGRP +DXV  QDYRGL GD RG  JRGLQH RG  UDWD QLMHGDQ QLMH YR_HQ PH_X GHPRNUDWVNLP GUDYDPD 0LW R GHPRNUDW VNRP PLUX UDVSU^LR MH 1RUYH^NL LVWUDLYDa PLUD -RKDQ *DOWXQJ  NRML MH VLVWHPDWVNL LVSLWDR RYX WHRULMX L XWYUGLR GHYHW IDNWRUD NRML MH RSRYUJDYDMX ,QGLYLGXDOL]DP L NRQNXUHQFLMD X MHGQRP GUX^WYX SRYH`DYDMX VSUHPQRVW QD UDW 6WUDK RG RGPD]GH ]ERJ ]ORaLQD NRML VH X SUR^ORVWL SULSLVXMH GUXJLP QDURGLPD YRGL GR SUHYHQWLYQH XSRWUHEH PR`L -HU QL NR VH QH SOD^L YL^H SRURETDYDZD RG RQRJD NRML MH L VDP SRUR ETDYDR .RPIRUDQ SRORDM X HNRQRPVNRM SLUDPLGL ]HPDTD EUDQL VH WDNR_H XSRWUHERP VLOH DNR MH SRWUHEQR L YRMQLP VUHGVWYLPD >WR VX XQXWUD^ZD L JOREDOQD VRFLMDOQD VWUXNWXUD VOLaQLMH XWROLNR MH ]HPTD GHPRNUDWVNLMD L PLOLWDQWQLMD >WR MH ]HPTD GHPRNUDWVNLMD XWROLNR MH VSUHPQLMD GD GRQRVL RGOXNH D ^WR MH VSUHPQLMD GD GRQRVL RGOXNH XWROLNR MH PDZH PLOLWDQWQD >WR MH ]HPTD GHPRNUDWVNLMD YL^H VX LPSOHPHQWLUDQD TXGVND SUDYD D ^WR VX TXGVND SUDYD YL^H LPSOHPHQWLUDQD XWROLNR VX aRYHNRYH REDYH]H YH`H >WR MH ]HPTD GHPRNUDWVNLMD YH`D MH XQXWUD^ZD NRQNXUHQFLMD ]D RVYDMDZH PR`L D ^WR MH XQXWUD^ZD NRQNXUHQFLMD ]D RVYDMD ZH PR`L YH`D YH`L VX SRNX^DML GD VH GR SRGU^NH GR_H SXWHP VSRTQH DJUHVLMH >WR MH ]HPTD GHPRNUDWVNLMD YH`L MH XQXWUD^ZL PLU NRML VH PRH NRULVWLWL ]D VSRTQH DNFLMH ELOH RQH YRMQH LOL QH >WR MH ]HPTD GHPRNUDWVNLMD TXGL L HOLWH VX XYHUHQLML X VYRMX QHSRJUH^LYRVW D ^WR VX TXGL L HOLWH XYHUHQLML X VYRMX QHSR JUH^LYRVW ]HPTD MH PLOLWDQWQLMD 0RH VH VWH`L XWLVDN GD QL GHPRNUDWLMH QLVX VSUHPQH QD PLU QL GLNWDWXUH QD UDW

8OL .UHPHU 1RYL 1$72  QRYL UDWRYL )LOLS 9L^ZL` %HRJUDG  VWUDQD  
  

9LQNR ?XUL`

/$# .$2 35(7+2'1,&$ 1$72 $.&,-$

1RDP ARPVNL GHPRNUDWVNL PLU SRLVWRYH`XMH VD PLOLWDULVWLa NLP KXPDQL]PRP D QD^ SUDYQRSROLWLaNL DQDOLWLaDU 0LOR^ .QH HYL` VD GHPRNUDWVNLP DSVROXWL]PRP LOL NUVWDUH`RP GHPRQNUDWL MRP 6YH XNXSQR PQRJR MH WHRUHWLaDUD VYHWVNLK SULOLND NRML VX R]ELTQR SRUHNOL WHRULMX R GHPRNUDWVNRP PLUX 1D NUDMX WUHED UH`L L WR GD MH VDYUHPHQL 1$72 SUDYL SULPHU VWDUH .ODX]HYLFRYH GHILQLFLMH UDWD NRML VH SUHGVWDYTD NDR SURGX HZH SROLWLNH GUXJLP VUHGVWYLPD D PH_X WLP GUXJLP VUHGVWYLPD 1$72 MH L]GD^QR SUH L SRVOH NRUL^`HZD VLOH NRULVWLR OD

LIE AS A PREDECESSOR OF NATO ACTION Summary NATO based all the actions of the aggressive internationalism on lies, even the thesis on spreading the "democratic peace" is so weak that it can be simply identified as an ideological lie. A lie in the international politics has become a predecessor of almost all war operations of a military humanism. Key words: lie, NATO, democratic peace, military humanism, aggressive internationalism...

1RDP ARPVNL 1RYL PLOLWDULVWLaNL KXPDQL]DP )LOLS 9L^ZL` %H RJUDG  0LOR^ .QHHYL` .UVWDUH`D GHPRNUDWLMD '3 ?XUR 6DODM