Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF PUERTO RICO CDIGO PUBLISHING, CDIGO MUSIC, LLC Plaintiffs, Vs. ANTHONY FELTON ANTHONY COMPANY COMPANY CINEMAS BREACH OF CONTRACT AND FELTON ENTERPRISES; COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT ENTERTAINMENT, INC.; FELTON, INSURANCE XZY, INSURANCE ABC, AND CARIBBEAN Defendants COMPLAINT TO THE HONORABLE COURT: COME NOW plaintiffs Cdigo Publishing, LLC and Cdigo Music, LLC (Cdigo), through the undersigned attorneys, and LLC AND CIVIL NUM.:
respectfully state and pray as follows: I. Nature of the Action 1. This is an action requesting resolution of an
agreement for breach of contract and damages under the laws of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, 31 L.P.R.A. 3018, 3023,
3024, 3052, 3373, 3496 and 5141, and for direct and contributory infringement under the Copyright Act of 1976, 17 U.S.C 101 et seq. (the Copyright Act) against Anthony Felton Enterprises; Felton Entertainment, Inc., Anthony Felton (individually and
collectively referred to as Felton), Insurance Company XYZ (XYZ) and Caribbean Cinemas (Caribbean).
Page 1 of 14
2.
the plaintiffs and Felton (Agreement) as a result of Feltons breach of the Agreement. The Agreement was for the licensing
and use of several musical compositions and recordings owned by the plaintiffs (Work). 3. Therefore, plaintiffs seek damages suffered as a
direct consequence of Feltons breach of contract. 4. In addition, plaintiffs seek to restrain the
defendants from continuing using and infringing the Work in an illegal and unauthorized manner. 5. As set forth below, Felton breached the material
provisions of the Agreement and thus the defendants have been and continue to illegally infringe the plaintiffs copyrights upon the unauthorized exploitation of the Work. II. 1. This Jurisdiction and Venue Honorable this Court action has for original copyright and exclusive
jurisdiction
over
infringement
pursuant to 28 U.S.C. 1331 and 1338(a). 2. In addition, this Honorable Court has diversity
jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. 1332(a)(1) since the matter in controversy exceeds the sum or value of $75,000.00, excluding interests and costs, and the parties are citizens of different states. The plaintiffs principal place of business is located
Page 2 of 14
in Florida and the defendants residences and principal places of business are located in Puerto Rico. 3. 1391(b); Venue is proper and in this court under 28 U.S.C. are
1391(c)
1400(a)
because
the
defendants
residents of this district and because a substantial part of the events giving rise to the claims occurred in this district. III. The Parties 4. Cdigo Publishing, LLC is a Florida limited liability
company with its principal place of business at 5400 NE 4th Ct., Miami, FL 33137. 5. Cdigo Music, LLC is a Florida limited liability
company with its principal place of business at 5400 NE 4th Ct., Miami, FL 33137. 6. Upon is information a d/b/a for and belief, Felton Anthony and/or Felton Felton
Enterprises
Anthony
corporation with the registration number 149346 and with its principal place of business located at Cond. Marbella Oeste
5347, Suite 1002, Isla Verde, Puerto Rico 00979. 8. Anthony Inc. Felton and his is the president is Cond. of Felton Oeste
Entertainment,
address
Marbella
Page 3 of 14
9. an
Upon information and belief, Insurance Company ABC is company at this time used to designate any
insurance
insurance company that may have available insurance coverage for Anthony Felton Enterprises as a d/b/a for Anthony Felton and/or Felton Entertainment, Inc., on any of the actions herein
presented.
known, it will be duly announced and the complaint amended. 10. an Upon information and belief, Insurance Company XYZ is company at this time used to designate any
insurance
insurance company that may have available insurance coverage for Caribbean Cinemas, on any of the actions herein presented. Once
a specific name for the insurance company is known, it will be duly announced and the complaint amended. 11. Upon information and belief, Caribbean Cinemas is
composed of various Puerto Rico corporations with registration numbers State 95485 and 111598 from the Puerto Rico Department of and its addresses are 1512 Fernndez Juncos Ave.,
Santurce, Puerto Rico, 00909 and PO Box 19116, San Juan, Puerto Rico 00910-9116. IV. Factual Allegations 12. The plaintiffs are the rightful owners of all title to the Work. The Work includes various master
and interests
recordings and compositions, a list of which has been included as an exhibit herein. See Exhibit A.
Page 4 of 14
13.
The
Work
contains
wholly
original
materials
constituting copyrightable subject matter under the Copyright Act of 1976, 17 U.S.C. 101 et seq. ( Copyright Act). 14. The plaintiffs have complied at all relevant times and
in all respects with the Copyright Act, and have a registered copyright for the master recordings and compositions included in the Work. 15. Since have the date of the copyright the registrations, Work in the
customarily
licensed
interstate
On October 12, 2010 the plaintiffs and the defendants upon and and signed masters the use Agreement, licenses for regarding a film to the be
synchronization
produced by Felton titled Lavoe: The Untold Story (Film). See Exhibit B. 17. In essence, the plaintiffs licensed the Work according
to several essential terms included in the Agreement. A total license fee of $250,000.00, payable by Felton in four
installments was agreed upon (Licensing Fee). 18. The first payment would be a down payment in the
amount of $22,000.00, payable within the next five (5) days after executing the Agreement. This payment was the only payment satisfied by Felton.
Page 5 of 14
19.
The
second
payment
for
$28,000.00
was
due
40
days
after the initial down payment and it was to be followed by a third installment of $100,000.00 within 30 days of the Films theatrical release in the United States or no later than
November 30, 2011, whichever came first, by written warranties. 20. payable The within fourth 30 installment of the of $100,000.00 was due and in
days
Films
theatrical
release
Mexico and Latin America or no later than January 30, 2011, whichever came first. 21. Additionally, the Agreement included a clause that
stated that Cdigo was to receive seven percent (7%) of the Films gross profits, starting at the Films launch and
continuing through all the Films exploitation. 22. Felton was to personally guaranty payment of the
Licensing Fee, in other words, of all the payments mentioned in paragraphs 16, 17, 18 and 19 of this Complaint. 23. On December 20, 2010, Cdigo sent a letter to Felton
stating that the first two payments agreed upon had not been received and that Felton and Caribbean had continued to use and exploit the Work in trailers and advertisements for the Film. See Exhibit C. 24. Payment was demanded by the plaintiffs, who advised
Felton that if the Licensee Fee payments due were not received within five days of the aforementioned
Page 6 of 14
letter,
Felton
and
Caribbean were to cease and desist from using the Work. Exhibit C. 25. Feltons On January 10, 2011, a in second letter to was a sent
See
to
legal
representative,
response
previous
communication from Felton where the latter had admitted failure of payments due as set forth in the Agreement and had proposed a revised payment schedule due to a delay in the release of the Film. See Exhibit D. 26. not The plaintiffs responded by stating that Felton did the right to rewrite the contractual payment
possess
schedule unilaterally.
provided through the letter by including a list of websites that continued to air and exploit the Work illicitly. 27. See Exhibit D.
and desist from using and exploiting the Work and was informed that it had no right to use Codigos masters and/or
compositions. 28.
See Exhibit D.
the theatrical release of the Film was delayed until February 8, 2011, and that the balance on the Agreement Licensing Fee would be satisfied on or before February 28, 2011. again failed to comply with such promise. Felton once
See Exhibit E.
Page 7 of 14
29.
requesting the immediate payment of all box office receipts in its possession. 30. As of See Exhibit F. this date, the plaintiffs have not received
payment for the amounts owed in royalties and the Licensing Fee provided for in the Agreement. 31. The Film was eventually released on February 14, 2011.
Since Felton did not make the corresponding payments, the Work was commercially exploited without authorization. 32. Upon information and belief, the Work continues to be
used throughout the Internet to promote the Film and continues to be reproduced, distributed, exhibited and used without
authorization V. FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION DECLARATORY JUDGMENT AS TO BREACH OF CONTRACT AND CONTRACT TERMINATION 33. The plaintiffs reallege and incorporate by reference
paragraphs 1 through 30 as if fully set forth herein. 34. As of today, Felton is in breach of contract and owes
the plaintiffs an amount of no less than $228,000.00 and seven percent (7%) of the gross profits earned from the Film. 35. amounts Although overdue, the as plaintiffs as gave Felton notice to of the the
well
ample
opportunity
cure
Page 8 of 14
36. failed
Since Felton has materially breached the Agreement and to respond then the to plaintiffs must multiple be requests of
compliance,
Agreement
deemed
terminated
pursuant to Art. 1077 of the Puerto Rico Civil Code, 31 P.R. Laws Ann. 3052. 37. The defendants have openly admitted and recognized
failure to make the agreed upon payments, thus acknowledging their breach of contract. 38. that the Thus, the plaintiffs request a declaratory judgment was terminated and as such request the
Agreement
resolution of the same. VI. SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION DAMAGES AND MONIES OWED 39. The plaintiffs reallege and incorporate by reference
paragraphs 1 through 36 as if fully set forth herein. 40. for the As previously stated, Felton failed to make payments remaining, and agreed upon, $228,000.00 as a total
plaintiffs were also entitled to seven percent (7%) of the gross profits earned from the Film, amount which was not compensated to plaintiffs. 42. Code, 31 Pursuant P.R. to Article Ann. 1077 3052, of and the as Puerto a Rico Civil the
Laws
result
of
Page 9 of 14
plaintiffs request for the resolution of the Agreement, the plaintiffs seek damages in an amount of $228,000.00 and seven
percent (7%) of the gross profits earned from the Film, plus interest, costs and attorneys fees. VII. THIRD CAUSE OF ACTION DIRECT AND/OR CONTRIBUTORY INFRINGMENT (17 U.S.C. 101 ET SEQ.) 43. The plaintiffs reallege and incorporate by reference
paragraphs 1 through 40 as if fully set forth herein. 44. have the The plaintiffs are the sole owners of the Work and exclusive exploit included right and in to copy, prepare it. The are derivative works, and
distribute, compositions
transmit the
recordings original
Work
works,
copyrightable under Copyright Act. 45. At all times relevant herein, the plaintiffs have
complied with the Copyright Act and have secured the exclusive rights and privileges in and to the copyrights in the Work. 46. payments, Due to the defendants failure to make the required plaintiffs revoked their authorization and the
letter requesting payment of the Licensing Fee, dated December 20, 2010, defendant copyright Feltons unauthorized See use of v. the LAMCO, Work 161
constitutes
infringement.
Peer
Page 10 of 14
the licensor to rescind the license and hold the licensee liable for infringement for uses of the work thereafter.) 47. The plaintiffs are informed, believe and based thereon
allege that the defendants have, knowingly and willfully and without authorization from the copyright owners as of December 25, 2010, distributed, disseminated and/or otherwise continued to exploit or facilitate the exploitation of the Work through Caribbeans theatrical facilities and through the Internet. 48. The defendants acts constitute direct and/or
contributory infringements of the plaintiffs copyrights in the Work and constitute a clear violation of the Copyright Act. 49. The defendants infringements have been committed
willfully, and have been and are being engaged in with total disregard for the plaintiffs intellectual property rights. 50. The defendants direct and/or contributory copyright has caused, and will continue to cause, the
infringement
plaintiffs to suffer substantial injuries, losses, and damages to their rights in the Work. The plaintiffs have not received
the Licensing Fee nor any revenues from the defendants wrongful conduct and their distribution of the infringing Work. 51. In addition, the defendants have been unjustly
enriched by their exploitation of the Work. 52. By means have of the actions or complained of herein, the and
defendants
directly
contributorily
infringed
Page 11 of 14
continue to infringe the plaintiffs copyrights in and relating to the Work, by reproducing, distributing, and placing upon the market artistic works or portions thereof from the plaintiffs copyrighted music and masters. 53. The plaintiffs are informed, believe and based thereon
allege that unless enjoined by this court, defendants intend to continue their course of conduct, and to wrongfully use,
infringe upon, sell, and otherwise profit from the plaintiffs Work. 54. In addition, as a result of the defendants actions,
the plaintiffs have suffered and will continue to suffer damages in an amount to be determined at trial. VIII. PRAYER FOR RELIEF WHEREFORE, the plaintiffs pray for judgment against the
defendants as follows: 1. That the court enter judgment in favor of the plaintiffs on all the claims for relief set forth herein; 2. That the court acknowledges the resolution of the
Agreement as correct due to the defendants willful breach of contract; 3. That judgment is entered for the plaintiffs against the defendants, for damages based upon the resolution of the
Page 12 of 14
in
$228,000.00,
plus
seven
percent
of
the
gross
profits
generated by defendants; 4. That the defendants and or any of their representatives, agents or partners in active concert of privity or in
participation with them, be enjoined from directly or indirectly continuing to infringe upon the plaintiffs copyrights of the Work or continue to market, display, advertise, reproduce, or exploit the Work or to participate or assist in any such
activity; 5. That judgment is entered for the plaintiffs against the defendants for damages based upon defendants breach of
contract, losses amounting to seven percent of profits generated by defendant and statutory damages based upon the defendants willful infringement, pursuant to 17 U.S.C. 504(c), of the Copyright Act, estimated in $2,628,500.00. 6. That the plaintiffs have judgment against the
defendants for costs and attorneys fees; 7. That the court grants such other and further relief as
the court deems just and proper. Respectfully submitted in San Juan, Puerto Rico, this 18th day of August, 2011. s/YOLANDA LVAREZ USDC. No.223509 yalvarez@ferraiuoli.com
Page 13 of 14
s/MARISTELLA COLLAZO USDC. No.228606 mcollazo@ferraiuoli.com s/LAURA BELNDEZ-FERRERO USDC. No. 216301 lbelendez@ferraiuoli.com
FERRAIUOLI LLC 221 Ponce de Len Ave., 4th Floor Hato Rey, Puerto Rico 00917 Tel. (787) 766-7000 Fax. (787) 766-7001
Page 14 of 14