- -- - - -- --- -- ---- --- -- - - - - -----

~
- - - - -- --- -- -- - - -
P"
H a r t y ~ Puckar.e,
11
Nenagh, Co Tipperary_
The submission raises a number 01 issues:
(1) Zoning ot>;ectives wrthin the Puckar.e Village Settlement Plan_
Seeks to have srte 4_6 hectares immediately to the west 01 Rural Housing
Organisation houses zoned lor housing development Srte adj oins settlement
boundary_ Public water supply is located on the public road and Council
sewage pumphouse is located to the north 01 the RHO houses adjoining the
S........,
land and there is a manhole and sewer pipes constructed on these lands_
Existing open drain to deal wrth surlace water_ Srte is immediately outside
50kph speed limrt but coukJ be relocated_
(2) Submission raises concern at the lack 01 provision lor the proposed
expansion 01 the recreationallacilrties 01 Killadangan GAA Club_ Provision
shoukJ be made lor same wrth appropriate zoning_
(1) The srte in question is located to the west 01 the village centre and outside
the settlement boundary lor the village as defined wrthin the draft plan_
However having regard to proximrty 01 the srte to existing housing rt is
CommIInt considered
<h" U'"
srte woukJ be surtable
,,,
Ow densrty housing
development
(2) The extension 01 the Village boundary and area 01 amenrty zoning
shoukJ be amended to rovide lor extension 01 the GAA lacilrties_
6
End Note 2
Recommendation:
Zoning of site to the west of the RHO houses to be amended to New
residential low density to include serviced sites and a large centrally
located overlooked open space I village green.
Recommend that the amenity zoning be extended northwards adjoining
the GAA fi eld to rovide for ex nsion of the existin faciliti es.
12
Housing Section. North Tipperary
Count Council.
Zoning ot;eclive. Proposes addrtional zoning of land at Puckane.
S........,
The srte proposed is located to the south-west of the village centre and
outside the settlement plan boundary as set out in the draft plan. Mjoining
lands to the north and east are zoned R Residential existing and residential
new respectively. The land to the north west is zoned C commercial.
Access to the proposed srte is from the north east through an existing
housing development.
Permission granted
'"
this srte 1811212000
,,,
Housing development
comprising of 27 no. two storey detached houses and 3 no. single storey
ComnMI nt detached houses and also associated entrance from public road, estate
roadway and all related srte works.
Having WJjlli\ to the planning history on this srte and the availabilrty of
access from the north rt is considered that an application for residential
development coukJ be considered. Development of the srte will have to
compliment the topography of the srte.
Recommendation:
Recommend that the site be zoned R1 new residential.
End Note 2
12
ComnMInt
from rear
the village cores or mixed
densnrties may be more appropriate. Village design statement could
provide 1001 lor the allocation or location 01 densrties as appropriate 10
particular town or village.
Earlier submission raised concern in respect 01 the oversupply 01 land
zoned lor residential purposes in some villages and proposed that the
issue 01 phasing be addressed 10 ensure an efficient and orderly use 01
the laOO_ Proposed amendments provide lor OOdrtional zoning.
Submission raises concern that this reed lor this OOdrtionallarod has 00\
been j ustified
resources_
addressed_
and may lead 10 the ur.ecooomic use 01 inlrastructural
Issue 01 phasing or priorrtisirog development should be
' _ ~ ' h . ' h is a feature 01 design should be addressed
statements.
I 01 zoned land is ackJ)()W1edged and
the members_ See
End Note 3
-----------, Puckane_
Recommendati on:
5_2 Housing Village Housing objective_ Objective 5 to be amended as
lollows:
Objective 5 To promote the preparation 01 Village Design Statements
(VDS) in consukation wrth the village residents and land owners_ The
VDS is designed to provide an agreed description 01 the character 01 the
village and provide guidance that addresses the qualrties which local
residents and land owners consider 01 protection and
The VDS will also provide and
01 In
Statements lor
End Note 3
23
Elizabeth MacGrath, Oromir.eer, Nenagh.
Count Ti raIY_
Letter re-rterates COJ)Cftns that the provisions 01 Section 20 of the
Planning and Development Act 2000 have 00\ been complied wrth in the
cOJ)Sukabon process adopted by the Planning Authorrty 10 date_
As regards the amendments the submission raises the following issues:
S........,
PropQSed amendment 5_2 provides lor the promotion 01 preparation 01
Village Design Statements in cOJ)Sukabon wrth village residents and
landowners_ Document does 00\ provide lor specific village design
statement lor Dromir.eer as was passed by resolution at the December
Council meeting. Ot;ective should be included_
Provision for low densrt housi in Gar kenr.ed should be rovided for
16
End Note 4
also in Dromineer.
A, regards procedural

U'"
Council carried
0"
extensive
p," 01
U'"
plan process
'"
accordance wrth
U'"
requirements 01 Section 20 01 the Planning and Development Act 2000.
5.2 Text
'"
respect 01 Vill<Jge Design statement outlined in the
amendments indicates that a commrtment has been given to the carrying
out 01 Village Design Statements lor Garrykennedy and Dromineer in
2006.
Issue 01 housing densrties to be addressed also by way 01 Vill<Jge Design
Statement See response to submission 12 above.
Whilst amendments text indicated a commrtment to carry out Vill<Jge
Design Statement lor Garrykennedy in Spring 2006 wrth a completion
date 01 Summer 2006 this is not leasible having regard to the stalling
ComnMI nt
levels and rt is envisaged that the VDS will begin in late 2006.
Recommendation. See submission 12 above.
Objective 12 to be amended as follows:
Objective 12 To prepare
,
Village De5ign Statement (VDS)
'"
consultation with the village re5idents and land owners. The VDS is
de5igned to provide an agreed de5cription of the character of the
village and provide guidance that addresse5 the qualitie5 which
local re5idents and land owners consider worthy of protection and
improvement. Th, .oS will also provide de5criptive
,"d
Pre5criptive guidance on the nature and extent of new development
in the vill age. The Village De5ign Statement will take place in SpRRfI
20Qfi with a GQmplet.;QR date Summe, 2006.
End Note 4
Ful Commentary
on Submission
"-
7 ._ ...... ~ - -.:-!" ... !...:,-;"' ........


.. _,"' ___ " __ ""0
-
. .. .. _ .... _.....-
J , .. n., _. 7' ..... ' _ ... _
""' .. _ .... ,_ .. .... __ ... _ ..
-.. -'--" .......... .,,",
_. __ ...... __ ........ ..-<-
(_ .... __ .. __ .. .. ..
""_ .. o-. __ .... r __ OJ
.... _ .. .- .... _ .. ,_ ... _ ...
' .... .. " .- .. __ r "
---
.... -_ .. -.........
-p' ..... _- ..--
..... _-
r __ .... _ .... _<' "" ....... ..., ..
_._,"' h .......... _ .... '\ ' _
_ .... ,.-.L
......... .. ' .... "' -""-
-.. _._-
.. -
" ~ t " " T _ ~
.... .......... ,.,. , ''''. - "0
-
- .... ,.._ .... P .-......... _ ...
'" ... --' ' .. -...... _ ...
1>0 ,t , .... ____ .. _ ......
_ ..... _-..---- r __
End Note 5
Version Given to
Prime Time
Investigates under
FOI
Full Page
II.",
H. t<I!;C
Qu .... rl y 11..,.. ...
Consider:tllQfI oflhe COnlnl\l; of!he lioustni Qwmedy Repor1, copy of
"h..,h ... ,-,a emal l ""U 10 the AdJoorncd Janllary
meeting oflhe CounCIl.
Mr. P Ilcffeman ad.",sed!he Mcrnben lhoil 16 hoo$Q had bc-m
purchased IIMer Ih 'um key de"elopmnlt"' al Knoxk RoaJ. Roscrca.
TIlls de.elopment ... ,,elromed by all the Members present
Mr T BafT)' Introduced ilem ad.,sed the Members th:ll large
number of subm,sslOflS haJ bttn rtte,,ed ,,",m regard 10 !he Oraft. Mr
P. Slallery then 10 I numbe:. of me<:Llngs Ihal had lalcn place ,n
rttnll ... eels and h,ghlighled ceftam cl\anges IU1d relt''nt maps 10 the
."VlOW SlIbm,SS'ons "h"h ,,"n-\: handed 011110 the Memben for the ..
cOfls,dCl':lllon. 1.1111",,"<:$ no,sed by the Mcrnbe:rs ,,ere ..."hc:d 10 by Mr
T BaITY and M. I' Slallery. 11" noled lhal the Repor1 10
Mcmben unJer Sechon 20(3) ofw PlaMUl, lind Dc.dopmc:nl Act
2000 (Wlc:d N'l.ember 2005) IS \0 be: ammdc:d by
1 Proposed Ammdme"ls Secl,on 20(3)(e) of the Planmnlland
Dc,"elopmrnt Act 2002 (Wled Dember 2005) and,
2. Maps rele .. anl 10 the Proposed Amendments ref...-.ed to al No. (I)
.blwe (c,rculaled by hard copy. III posl on Ihe 19th Dc<- 200S) ."d.
3. Addnldum 10 Rcpon Ofl Proposed Amerldmnll:i IIndtr Secl10n
20(3)(e) 'lfthe Plann'ng.nd Dc,elopmenl A(( lOOl ( .... 'rc .. Jalc:d II
adJolirned momhly meelilli oCCoune,1 helJ on nn;] Oo:c. lOOS)
On Ihe JIfOP"$'II ofCIl. T Hamnilon, SC"ConJc:d b) Clir T IkrlCf) anJ
r.:liOh ed
'nwr purSlNlll1 101M Pf'O'U'OItJ ofSwI'OII 10 o/I/w PI"'III1'''S wwI
De>Y'/opMf"lIt Art. 1()()() us _ellfkJ bI S/HNI \I o/I/w PI"'II",,! .. ltd
1Jjo,'CiopmcNI (AmcN<1",<'MJ Arl. 1001 ...... lIere/1\ /kt-,Je 10 .. ",A:." LtKlll
End Note 5
Primetime
Investigates FOI
Copy Close up
-.
-
--
.....
-' .. --
_ ... _-
-_._--
-.----""----... -- -
-.
----_ .. -
-----_ .. _-
-- ------
--
, .
-----
-
-- -
-
_ ....... ..
----_ ... _-
---- --
------- ----
-
~ - "
-_ ...
-- ---
.. -_ .. _ .
. _-
.. _ ...
"-
--_.
-- :0';;-
-
--.-":--
-.-
---... --- --
-
---
--,.---,,-
.. _--
--
--
-
--
--
--
--- -----
-00 __ -
--._--
--
---_ ... _-
--
End Note 5 Copy of Official Book of
Council Minutes of Monthly Meetings.
December 22nd 2005
Draft WALAP Text
Draft WALAP Text
Items referring to
Addendum,
Amendments etc in
wrong Item No.
We were not aware
of these additions to
Draft.
IJrm 41
1I.!lfl ld!
annuli 8.oon
11m S,!
PClfl '" d'IIJl
Am l ett' n ...
LOIIl>I<lerduon 01 lilt 01 u,,, I 'I,l..,,"'t; ",,"'''''''-' ' J ..... 1')' ."
wh.eh was C:lreulaud \' i. e. mail ",-as d"feTTDd to tbc: AdJoumed Junult)'
ITlt'ellngofthe Council
Mr P JiefferNn adl;J(X! the Members thai [6 holl5eS hIId been
under 1M "urn key II Knock RoseTeB.
was .... ,clcomod I '-
"'"
,
3 hi..,. (tj.,....", to 1M 10 No (2) lbove
D'I' hatd c::opy ..... PD'-I on IIWI 19tM
AdOen(I"m to RtoPOtI 01'1 P'OPC ,.a Amendmetltf under S,nton 20(3)(1' 01
IIlII Pt.MIIIII and Aa 2002 (on::uIIIled II edJOUll'll monlnty
_rog 01 Counat held on 2200 Dec 200!!)
Mr T 9.rry mtroduced 1hI. Hem and adwJOd the Members \lun IIDrge
numhtr oj sul>m,ulOIU had been rcaeiltld wllh reprd [0 the Dnil'\' Mr
p 51.flery tbc:n ""felled 10 numbC'l' of meetinG' lhol h.ld 1.Ilcen place In
16l1 ween ItId IughllghlDd eertlnn ch.ngclllllld rTIIps 10 the:
\'mOllJl .UI>m'A-lon.t which WI!fC hllldc:d 0111 to tbc Membc:n lor their
coru:,J(DlIun Ail quenCi ralJed by the Memben "'en: replied 10 by Mr.
T BIIT) and "'-if P SI.llery [I 'has nolcdlhll tht; ManOieT'. RqJOrt "
10 he fUQeIIdcid b)' the conlc:nll orlhe Report prerarc.l IInJtt Secllon 20
u' the PIDnnma ,nd Dc\elOjlflKnl Ac. lOCl2 wluch eonlDmed Ihe
from Ihe Menlbefa ,I the An:Ii MC:C:llnjp, .nd .1., by
til<' addendum 10 tha, TqlOrt which ...... clI''tul.It:d.1 the prcxnl mco::uni
On IIIOjIl!.oa/ 01 Cllr T Illmnl'OIl. tOno.lod hy Cllr 1 Ikrkery.nd
rft;<Il \ a:I
.. 7lI,,1 f'1In'"'''' ,,, IAr f'ffTI1l/'H/S "/.\<"("1"''' JI) "/the "'''''flwg flnJ
Addendum and
other Amendment
Information is in
wrong Item No.
This is North
Tipperarys Official
Minutes of Meeting
Book Copy.
December 2005
End Note 5
' ..
_. I
"
75
,

".,a.,_ ...
"'_"'" I _ ... _ ....... __
;
= ~ : ... - ... --....... -
-_ .. --.-.--
_ ... _ .. __ .... " I .. _
-
,,- --"'-" ,,' .. __ ... _---_.
---_ ...... _-_ .. _ ....
__ " _ .. _._ .. _,
... __ ... _ ,c' __ .. __
---_ ....... _ .... _-
End Note 5
Full Page Version
2 as obtained by
Hard Copy from
Council Official in
2007
Mr. T B!lI1)' introduced this Item and advised the Members that a large
number of $Ilbmissions had been received with regard to the Draft . Mr.
P Slattery then Termed to a number of meetings that had taken place in
recent weeks and highlighted certain changes and relevant maps to the
various $Ilbmis5ions \\hich were handed out to the Members for theIr
consideration. All qUeries raised by the Members were rephed to by Mr.
T. B!lI1)' and ~ i r . P. SlaneT)'. It was noted that the Manager's Report to
Members Imder Section 20(3) of the Planning and Development Act
2000 (dated No\'ember 2005) is to be amended by:
1. Proposed Amendments under Section 20(3)(e) of the Planning and
Development Act 2002 (dated December 2(05) and;
2. Maps relevant to the Proposed Amendments referred to at No. ( I )
above (circulated by hard copy via post on the 19th Dec 2005) and;
3. Addendum to Report on Proposed Amendments under Secllon
20(3)(e) of the Planning and De\'elopment Act 2002 (circulated at
adJowned monthly meeung of Council held on 22nd Dec. 2005).
On the proposal orOlr. T Harrington. seconded by Clir. T. Berkery and
resolved:
""'17wI, pursuanl to Ihe prOl1Sl0flS o/&cllon 20 o/Ihe Planmng und
Dew!lopment Act, 2000 os amended by SectIon 9 o/the Planning and
Dew!lopmefl/ (Amendmenl) ACI, 2002, I<e hereby decIde 10 make a /"ocal
Area Plan/or Ine Western Area 0/ North Tipperary olherwist I"an as
recommended In Ihe County Manager's Report and proposal by Ihe
County Manager 10 make a Plan shall be vaned or modified 1/1
accordance wllh Ihe allached report and Ihe proposed 1'0"01;011 or
modificatlall would, if made, be a matenal alleralion o/Ine County
Manager 's proposol ..
End Note 5
Hard Copy Version
ComnMInt
This detailed submission raises a number of important issues.
(i) ~ (iii) Having regard to the population projections for the village as
outlined in Section 3.2.3. m the Plan and genuine level of concern
expressed in respect of the extent of lands zoned for residential
development wrthin the village of Puckane, rt is considered zoning
should be reviewed and a surtable phasing programme for future
development identified.
(ii) As regards infrastructural provision the availabilrty I provision of
surtable infrastructure services and facilrties to cater for development is a
pre-requisrte to development of zoned lands.
(iv) It is considered that issues of development control guidance and
master plan landscape and visual impact assessment will be addressed
by way of the Village Design Statement as set out in ot>;ective 5 Village
Housing Ot>;ective included in proposed amendments January 2005.
Village Design Statements (VDS) are to be prepared in consukation wrth
the village residents and landowners. The VDS is designed to provide an
agreed description of the character of the village and provide guidance
that addresses the qualrties which local residents and landowners
consider worthy of protection and improvement, and will provide
prescriptive guidance on the nature, extent and densrty of new
development in the village. See also proposed amendment to VDS text
in response to submission 12 above.
A meeting has been arranged between the members and the ~
Development Association to discuss the level of zoning set out in the
proposed amendments and to discuss the required infrastructure to deal
wrth the projected increase development in the village. The minute of this
meeting will be reported to the council as part of the consideration of the
ado tion of the Plan.
End Note 6
Managers Report
March 2006
Page 20 of the Speed Limit Bye L:.1WS 2006 Adopted
42. The following roads at ~
a) The (R493) Nenagh-CoolbawnR()<lcl from a point 445 ~ southeast
2fits jllllction with the (L-5006) ~ R o a d to a point 390
~ north of the saidjllllction.
b) The (L-5006) DromineerR()<lcl for a distance of 677 ~ southwest
2fits junction with the .
End Note 7
677 Metres
.. .. .. --.,-..... -_ .. _ .. ...... .
P. Puckar.e,
11
Nenagh, Co Tipperary.
The submission raises a number of issues:
(1) Zoning objectives wrthin the Puckar.e Village Settlement Plan.
Seeks to have srte 4.6 hectares immediately to the west of Rural Housing
Organisation houses zoned for housing development Srte adjoins settlement
boundary. Public water supply is located on the public road and Council
sewage pumphouse is located to the north of the RHO houses adjoining the
S........,
land and there is a manhole and sewer pipes constructed on these lands.
Existing open drain to deal wrth surface water. Srte is immediately outside
50kph speed limrt but could be relocated.
(2) Submission raises concern at the lack of provision for the proposed
expansion of the recreationalfacilrties of Killadangan GAA Club. Provision
should be made for same wrth appropriate zoning.
(1) The srte in question is located to the west of the village centre and outside
the settlement boundary for the village as defined within the draft plan.
However having regard to proximity of the site to existing housing rt is
Commli nt considered <h.
,""
srte would be surtable
,,,
Ow densrty housing
development.
(2) The extension of the Village boundary and area of amenrty zoning
should be amended to rovide for extension of the GAA facilities.
6
End Note 9
Moving Speed
Signs to
accomodate
request
" :
I
,
I
,
,
,-
,
, " ,
i
" --' -
,
\--
-
\? "-
I
' ~ _ - t
, ---
,
\
<;:" . ,
~ '
,.-L __
J
. - '
\
, .'
-
j.
"
,
, \.
\y
r
~ ", .
r- ;,
-(
,
;', [ :
"
Puckane
,
,
'----->- --
i--
I \
!
,
,
i
,
!
-,
,
1
,
,
'"''
':c:- ./
""
" >-
'"
-
;1\
,i
.
""
,
,
, ,- - \
,
!
i
, ,
"
,

,
" ~
I
,
-
,
,
1
-,
,
I,
-
>, I
,
,
1
I
,
,
"
"
.,
,
End Note 10 Map
o
BEGII ygraggan
st ate
53.2
57.Q
{(
End Note 10
Proposed Entrance to this site.
showing Former Location of Speed
Signs and current location as moved
on January 24th 2007
To:
"',
From:
Oati:
Applicant:
location:
."
NORTH TIPPERARY COUNTY COUNCIL
WATER SERVICES SECTION
JIM MCGUlRE, SENIOR ENGINEER, WATER SERVICES
PLANNING SECTION
EOWARD TREACY, WATER SERVICES
"",,,--"
07m3Jl1
~ /
7
..
TOM & PADDY HARTY
BALL YCRAGGAN, PUCKANE, NENAGH
12 NO. HOUSES
REF: 1015 11(1328
1. The appl'_ ." "" .. 5e$ 10 connect the exi sting toul sewage Pumping Station. The eXIsting fOUl sewage
Pumping 51" ~ . " . ,dY not haye sufficient capacily 10 caler lor the proposed development and may not ........
5uffiCler1! capaay for \he adjoining land proposed lOt development by the applicanl in fUlUre phases, "'12 :1
to pl 3I'Vl11lg 1)f:tm'I" ,on.
2. The applicant has not submitted details 01 the pr:ljected foul sewer loadIngs for the adjoining land pitJi)JOll ll
for development by the appl k:arliin future ph3ses_
3. The applieatanl has not indi cated Storm water 10 be discharged 10 the nearest water course. The appIiMnt
proposes discharging storm to ground based on anecdotal evidence. This is totally unacceptable. TIw
appl\e8nt has not carried out any site invesligationlinfillration tests.
End Note 11
End Note 12
AnnMarle
kleran Callanan
14 MarCh 2011 16:53
Ann Marie Deaney
RE: 101510328, Tom & Paddy Harty, PtK;kaun
With regard to FI supplied bV above In relation to Roads. I note that
Sightl ines shown on Site laVoul Plan 08/166-401 ale unacceptable as Ihev require removal of boundaries outSide the
applicants "redhne" and cannot be achieved without the removal of said boundaries
They concede t h ~ I Items SA, 8, C and 0 are only partially answered and speclflcaliV 8\ a TIA Is nOl att ached, and 0\
details of roads, drainage ,etc
In addlUon, Item 2v, "provide connect lvitv 10 village" hu not been addreued. This requires a path and public Ilgl\l lnl
and the provision of a path would require setback a boundarv outside the applicants site.
In Hghl of above I recomend refusal
I(leran Callanan
SEE, Nenagh Borriokane area
End Note 14


, . . . . : , ~ _ TO PUMPING
STATION



,
\

~ '.
,


\

,
,

,
,
,
EXISTING SEWAGE
PUMPING STATION

End Note 15
1st proposed
connection Plan
prior to Further
Information
Request
Hfll'5Ho U
.. "",.", ..
P\.OT &IZE IoU ....
fl'\. UII)OO
End Note 16
2nd Proposed
Connection that
does NOT Connect
given after Further
Information
Request
".
c. S'te Layout Plan
d. longrtud'nat
8. The applicant 1 I be requested to submit documentation and maps setting out the develope(s Iegat
enWemenl .. ( '"J I g Waj"fe;.'o'es. 10 traverse lands oulside lhe site boundaries. in order to put i'110 effect
such method. pCIa! of StOlTl1 water shaft be submitted to tho Planning OlflCe. North Topperary County
Councit for...,.; {""lval. A min t Orn Wayleave be required for any pipework passing through
property Ihat I n Lib!,.: open space_ ALI wayleaves shatl be accessibte 10 vehicular " alflC.
S. 1 ne applicant shalt be requesled to submit a ptan layout drawing showing 1M proposed water mains_ TM
df3wtno shaft show the location or:
(a) Watermains and fittongs shaft be taid in roads. or pubtic open spacas. No waler mains other Ihan
individuat connections shalt be taid in any private property or under iooIpaths.
(b) Water Meters and Waler Meter Boundary ,nstalled to each oonncction on public property for
easy access and reading. location and type of meter 10 be agreed with Water services Section' ___
End Note 17
,-\PP[;WIX
I- I\'QRJB mPER.\RY CO\;;"O"I1" PRJORlW LIST
r"",lotuohy,
End Note 18
3. 2 Water Services Needs 2010-2014.
The identified to meet the water o\-er the period 2010-2014 are
included in Table 3. The new identified include work new treatment
new collection and plant upgruding and network upgrading
throughoU1the COImty. The new fonn the for the development
of the County.
Location Description Estimate O J Statm
COImty Rural Water Program
+10_00
Ongoing yearly
Thudes Town Sewerage treatment plant
+4_00
Need Identified
extension
T emp[enlOre Sewer Network upgrade +1.00 Need Identified
Town
Nenagh Town Sewer Network upgrade +1.50 Need Identified
BaI1ina Sewer Network Upgrade +1.30 Need Identified
Rnral Villages 10 No_ Wastewater Treatment +:?O.OO Need Identified
& Collection Systems
Puckane. Upgrade Sewerage Treatment
+9_00
Need Identified
T oomeVanI, Plant
8orrisokane.
Holycross, Two-
Mile-Borris,
T empletuohy.
Littleton. Portroe.
Ne\\10wn.
COImty Telemetry +1.00 Need Identified
End Note 18
".",.:
,.,..:
10:
sub/o<t:
Ann-Marie
klernn Callanan
14 March 2011 16:53
Ann Marie Devaney
RE: 10/510328. Tom & Paddy Harty. Puckaun
With regard to FI suppUed by above in relation to Roads. I note t hat
Sightlines shown on Site layout Plan 08/166-401 are unacceptable as they requi re removal of boundaries outside the
applicants "redline" and cannot be achieved without the removal of said boundaries,
They concede that Items SA, B, C and 0 are only partially answered and speclflcally B) a TIA Is not attached, and 0)
details of roads, drainage ,etc
In addition, Item 2v, "provide connectivity to village" has not been addressed, This requires a path and public lightln,
and the provision of a path would require setback a boundary outside the applicants site,
In light of above I recomend refusal
Kieran Callanan
SEE, Nenagh Borriokane area
End Note 19
.;

_.-
,

-
-
*-
--
_.-

End Note 20
Sightlines and STOP Lines do
not match
End Note 20
STOP Line
&
SIGHT Line
Do Not Corrospond
STOP Line
Sight Line

.. .. 7' .... _ .... ___
-.. "'"'" ..... , ..... -.. "".
'-"""'--
r .
HF
- (0 ...
W;u.ooprdlO .... p"-_k, W i ' .... "-'!IOd.l "' ......... _ .. Jot"""'"
ne ..,." ...... , ... , ___ 11>1 _ tho <1<-..... ,,. ""' .. f .. n ......

.lll < .. .0.-... ,nj<maJ 0(Cft0 roads req .... , ......... ,.. (r.r ... 10 ...... ,'_S,lO 0..
Works, :'191).
Si!il1: Di.....,.
Clear ''fh' ", ..... vi,;bi locy not ..,b"'<C "'"' 10 ldJ'"'" PfOI"'''Y ,,,,"h,. "'"
..,..., " "!'PI-........... pkp! ent,U.,..,..,l
s..,,...,..-'" Dm_
Dooo",_"" IP"tIo< ... , ... __ N""'-'"
....... ..1 ...... _ 0' ,II< ,.fiI_ I<>U.... .. .....1<Yd .. pet
BR)65 .. COP, lOO9...., __ ( __ c"ed,Jdilo__ .......... 'Ii..,.,, ' :':..
, .. ';,_.-.. "',"'401 ........ ' .... ..,01:,:: MID.""
_6 .. , , .. . ' " 10" ' ] .I0"'"'""lyefdoolp_ ... -. .... -n
,
ceo CGu>lIL
. ,
I
,

,

:llIP"'lnr
End Note 21
kletan Callanan
14 March 2011 1653
Ann Marie Devaney
RE: 1015 10328, Tom & PllCkly Harty, P\lCklun
,"'inMarle
WI th regard to FL supplied by above In reLation to Roads, L note t hat
SLshtlines shown on Site layout PLan 0Sj166-401 lire unaccepuble n they requLre removal 01 boundaries oulil6e the
applicants "redhne" and cannOI be achieved wlthoullhe removal of said boundaries
They concede Ihal Ltems SA, B, C and 0 are only partially answered and spedlkalloi 8) a TIA Is not an lched, and D)
details of roads, drainage ,etc
In addition, Item 2v, "provide conne<:lkl lly to vlllale" has not been addressed. This requLres a p"' t h and public Ii&htrnl
and Ihe pr oviSion of a palh would r ~ u l r e setback a boundary ouu lde the applinnts site.
In light of above Irecomend refuul
Kieran Callilnan
SEE, Nenillh Borriokane area
End Note 22