Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Screening for Alternative Antibiotics: An Investigation into the Antimicrobial Activities of Medicinal Food Plants of Mauritius
M.F. MAHOMOODALLY, A. GURIB-FAKIM, AND A.H. SUBRATTY
ABSTRACT: The present study was designed to evaluate the antimicrobial activities of 2 endemic medicinal plants; Faujasiopsis flexuosa (Asteraceae) (FF) and Pittosporum senacia (Pittosporaceae) (PS) and 2 exotic medicinal plants, Momordica charantia (Cucurbitaceae) (MC) and Ocimum tenuiflorum (Lamiaceae) (OT) that forms part of local pharmacopoeia of Mauritius and correlate any observed activity with its phytochemical profile. Aqueous and organic fractions of the leaves, fruits, and seeds of these plants were subjected to antimicrobial testing by the disc diffusion method against 8 clinical isolates of bacteria and 2 strains of fungus. It was found that MC, OT, and FF possessed antimicrobial properties against the test organisms. The MIC for MC ranged from 0.5 to 9 mg/mL and that of FF from 2 to 10 mg/mL and the lowest MIC value (0.5 mg/mL) was recorded for the unripe fruits of MC against E. coli. On the other hand, higher concentration of the unripe MC fruit extract of 9 mg/mL was needed to be effective against a resistant strain of Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA). The antimicrobial effect against MRSA was lost upon ripening of the fruits. The methanolic extract of both MC and FF showed highest MIC values compared to the corresponding aqueous extract, which indicates the low efficacy and the need of higher doses of the plant extract. Phytochemical screening of the plants showed the presence of at least tannins, phenols, flavonoids, and alkaloids, which are known antimicrobial phyto-compounds. In conclusion, the observed antimicrobial properties would tend to further validate the medicinal properties of these commonly used endemic medicinal and food plants of Mauritius. Keywords: antimicrobial, endemic, exotic, medicinal plants
erbal medicine is holistic medicine (Bagchi 2001). It is, in fact, able to look beyond the symptoms to the underlying systemic imbalance; when skillfully applied by the trained practitioner, herbal medicine offers very real and permanent solutions to very real problems, many of them seemingly intractable to pharmaceutical intervention (Gogtay and others 2002). The use of and search for drugs and dietary supplements derived from food plants have accelerated in recent years. Ethnopharmacologists, botanists, microbiologists, and natural-products chemists are combing the Earth for phytochemicals and leads that could be developed for treatment of infectious diseases (Balandrin and others 1985). Traditional healers have long used plants to prevent or cure infectious conditions; Western medicine is trying to duplicate their successes. For instance, medicinal herbs now constitute the most rapidly growing segment of the total U.S. pharmaceutical market. Figures show that about 25% of all prescription sold in the United States are from natural products, while another 25% are from structural modifications of a natural product (Mathews and others 1999). Indeed knowledge gained from the use of medicinal herbs and their active ingredients serve as the foundation for much of modern pharmacology (Ang-Lee and others 2001). Additionally, the development of modern chemistry permitted the isolation of chemicals from medicinal herbs have served as drugs or starting materials for the synthesis of many important drugs used today. Drugs such as aspirin, digitalis, morphine, and quinine were all originally isolated
MS 20090654 Submitted 7/7/2009, Accepted 1/19/2010. Authors are with Dept. of Health Sciences, Faculty of Science, Univ. of Mauritius, Reduit, Mauritius. Direct inquiries to author Mahomoodally (E-mail: f.mahomoodally@uom.ac.mu).
Introduction
or synthesized from materials derived from plants (Mathews and others 1999). Mauritius also has a long-standing tradition in use of phytomedicines. Furthermore, being a tropical island, Mauritius has a very rich and diverse flora and many of the plant species are used for their medicinal virtues. Nonetheless, even with this vast array of data, few medicinal plant species of Mauritius have been scientifically evaluated for their possible medicinal application. Among the vast number of medicinal plants in current use in Mauritius, are Momordica charantia, an exotic vegetable (Subratty and others 2005) and 3 commonly used endemic/indigenous medicinal plants; Faujasiopsis flexuosa (Lam.) C. Jeffrey; Pittosporum senacia (Pittosporaceae); and Ocimum tenuiflorum (Lamiaceae) (Gurib-Fakim and others 1996a, 1996b, 1996c) were evaluated in the present study for their antimicrobial properties. Therefore, as part of a systematic study on the flora of Mauritius, these 4 plants were subjected to standard antimicrobial screening in an attempt to assess their current use in the traditional medicine of Mauritius. In addition, this investigation also endeavors to compare the antimicrobial activities of different extracts by finding their minimum inhibitory concentration.
Extraction
Crude aqueous extract of the plant material was used as per local pharmacopoeia. Freshly collected plant materials were either airdried or dried in a drying cabinet at 50o C for 5 to 7 d. Total of 10 g of the dried plant materials (fruit, leaves, and seeds) of the plant species were separately crushed and ground into fine powders using a food blender. The outer rind of MC fruit was removed before drying. The solvent was distilled off under reduced pressure to afford crude plant extract. The paste was collected in water for examination. Percentage yield was calculated and the paste-like water suspension was diluted for further experiments.
The MIC of each plant extract was determined by a slight modification of the tube dilution method (Omoregbe and others 1996). In a set of 10 sterile capped test tubes using the extraction solvent as diluent, serial dilutions were made from the different extracts to get graded concentration in milligrams per milliliter and a tube containing only diluent as the sensitivity control. Sterile filter paper disks (6 mm in diameter) were impregnated with the different dilutions of the plant extract were aseptically transferred to the surface of the inoculated plates using flamed but cooled forceps. The disks were sufficiently spaced to avoid overlapping of zones of inhibition. Test culture The test organisms used for the screening of antimicrobial activ- The MIC of the different plant extracts that inhibited the growth of ity were Bacillus cereus, Bacillus subtilis, E. coli, Staphylococcus au- the test organism other than inhibition due to the diluent (water) reus, methillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA), Enteroccous was taken as MIC. faecalis, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, and Salmonella typhimurium. Phytochemical screening Stock cultures of the bacteria and fungus used were obtained from Fruits, seeds, leaves, and twigs where appropriate were subjected Bacteriology Section of the central laboratory Candos, Victoria Hosto a thorough phytochemicals screening using standard protocols pital. Cultures were maintained as nutrient agar slants in screw (Mahomoodally and others 2005) to detect the presence of the folcapped bottles and stored at 4 C. All cultures were checked for vilowing secondary metabolites: alkaloids, coumarins, terpenes, anability and purity by regular plating. Test cultures were prepared thraquinones, tannins, phenols, leucoanthocyanins, flavones, and by transferring a loop full of bacteria from stock culture nutrient saponins. broth and incubated at 37 C for 24 h. Fungus were transferred into freshly prepared dextrose agar plates and incubated at 25 C for Results 3 d. The fungi used in the study were Aspergillus niger and Candida esults obtained for the antimicrobial tests performed on aquealbicans. ous and methanolic extracts of OT, MC, PS, and FF are presented in Table 1. Results showed that the crude aqueous and Antimicrobial bioassay procedure methanolic extracts of the plants showed broad spectrum of acSterilized filter paper disks (6 mm in diameter) were placed in tivity, being active almost to both the Gram-positive and Gramappropriate concentration of each plant extracts in screw-capped negative organisms in the antimicrobial assays. MC leaves, twigs, seeds, and unripe fruit showed variable degrees bottles. The disks (made from Whatman nr 1) were allowed to absorb the plant extracts. Plates of MuellerHinton sensitivity agar of antibacterial and antifungal activities against the test microor(oxoid) were aseptically inoculated with broth cultures for the test ganisms. Our results also showed that the aqueous unripe fruit of
Table 1 --- Antimicrobial activities of aqueous and methanolic extracts of PS, OT, FF, and MC against the test microorganisms. PS Stda 14 12 10 13 7 9 10 L 5(4) 7(2) 13(6) 6(4) () () () () () () T 3(2) () 6(8) () () () () () () () L 7(5) 8(4) (4) 7(8) (6) 10) () 6() () () OT T () () () (6) (10) () () () () () Diameter of zone of inhibition (mm)b FF L 5(5) 10(9) 8(8) 6(5) () 5(3) 8(6) 10(8) () () T 3(3) 4(2) 5(3) 5(5) () 3() 6(3) 7(5) () () L () 3(2) 11(9) () () 4(2) 3(3) 10(8) () () UF 4(3) 8(6) 15(10) 17(16) 5(2) 4(2) 7(7) 13(12) 3(2) 8(6) MC RF 2() 6(3) 10(5) 12(8) () 5(2) 5(2) 10(8) 2() 7(4) T () 3(2) 10(8) 9(4) () 5(3) 3() 5(3) () () S () 2() 10(8) 9(9) () () 3() 5() () ()
Microorganism BC BS EC SA MRSA EF PA ST AN CA
(Inhibition zone of methanolic extract.) a Standard antibiotic Ampicillin tested at a concentration of 10 g/disc (oxoid). b Zone of inhibition; average duplicates of 3 independent experiments. = Complete lack of activity. L = leaf extract; T = twigs extract; UF = unripe fruit; RF = ripe fruit; BC = Bacillus cereus; BC = Bacillus subtilis; EC = E. coli ; SA = Staphylococcus aureus; MRSA = methicillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus; EF = Enterococcus faecalis; PA = Pseudomonas aeruginosa; ST = Salmonella typhimurium; AN = Aspergillus niger ; CA = Candida albicans.
M174
Discussion
MIC
All extracts that showed antibacterial activities by the disc diffusion method were further tested by the broth dilution assay to determine the MIC. Results of the MICs of the different plant extracts are shown in Table 2. The MIC value for aqueous extract of leaves and twigs of PS ranged from 0.5 to 16 mg/mL and 2 to 12 mg/mL, respectively; 4 to 8 mg/mL and 1 to 8 mg/mL for leaves and twigs
nterest in higher plant extracts exhibiting antimicrobial activity has increased in recent years, and several reports on this subject have been published (Farnsworth 1994; Benzi and Ceci 1997; Bagghi 2001; Rangasamy and others 2007; Thakurta and others 2007). In the present study, the 4 medicinal plants were selected as they have been documented to possess antimicrobial properties and used traditionally by the local population to treat minor infections (Gurib-Fakim and others 1996a, 1996b, 1996c). To this effect, standard antimicrobial assays were carried against key pathogenic bacteria and fungi to validate their use in the traditional medicines and also the consumption MC as a common vegetable in Mauritius. The exotic plants; MC and OT and the endemic medicinal plants; PS and FF possess antimicrobial properties against the test microorganisms. In the local traditional pharmacopoeia of Mauritius, MC is extensively used to treat DM. However, it is also used against diarrhea, stomach colic, and to combat intestinal infections. On the other hand, FF is known to possess astringent properties and is used by the local population against dysentery (Narod
Table 2 --- Minimum inhibitory concentrations (mg/mL) PS, OT, FF, and MC plant parts for the 10 strains of microorganisms. Minimum inhibitory concentration (mg/mL) PS Microorganism BC BS EC SA MRSA EF PA ST AN CA L 10 (8) 8 (12) 2 (4) 6 (8) () () () () () () T 12 (8) () 6 (6) () () () () () () () L 4 (6) 8 (8) (8) 8 (8) (8) (6) () 8 () () () OT T () () () (8) (8) () () () () () L 1 (1) 4 (6) 4 (4) 6 (8) () 2 (4) 8 (8) 4 (6) () () FF T 8(8) 8 (8) 6 (7) 4 (6) () 4 (6) 6 (7) 4 (6) 6 () () L () 4 (8) 1 (4) () () 7 (4) 4 (6) 2 (8) () () UF 5 (8) 3 (8) 0.5 (1) 2 (4) 9 (8) 5 (8) 2 (8) 1 (4) 2 (4) 3 (6) MC RF 8 () 6 (8) 4 (8) 4 (8) () 8 (8) 6 (3) 2 (4) 4 () 8 (8) T () 6 (8) 1 (2) 4 (8) () 8 (4) 8 () 2 (4) () () S () 8 () 1.5 (3) 5 (6) () () 8 () 3 () () ()
(MIC of methanolic extract.) L = leaf extract; T = twigs extract; UF = unripe fruit; RF = ripe fruit; BC = Bacillus cereus; BC = Bacillus subtilis; EC = E. coli ; SA = Staphylococcus aureus; MRSA = methicillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus; EF = Enterococcus faecalis; PA = Pseudomonas aeruginosa; ST = Salmonella typhimurium; AN = Aspergillus niger ; CA = Candida albicans. = Complete lack of activity.
M175
+ = presence; = absence.
and others 2004), which is classified as an infectious disease (Bloom 1994). Additionally, it has been found that species from the same genus of OT possess antimicrobial properties (Aqil and others 2005; Chah and others 2006). Recently, Aqil and others (2005) reported the inhibitory activities of Ocimum species against clinical isolates of -lactamase producing MRSA and methicillin-sensitive S. aureus (MSSA). Therefore, these documented properties are in conformity with the results obtained in this study, since these plants have been shown to possess the ability to inhibit growth of both pathogenic Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria. However, the plant parts differ significantly in their activity against the test microorganisms. The differences observed in the antimicrobial activities assays suggest the susceptibility of the test microorganisms to various secondary metabolites present in these medicinal plants. The composition of these secondary metabolites in turn varies from species to species, climatic conditions, and the physiological state of developments of the endemic plants (Hussain and Deeni 1991). Available reports tend to show that alkaloids and flavonoids are the responsible compounds for the antimicrobial activities in higher plants (Cordell and others 2001). Moreover, it is also claimed that secondary metabolites such as tannins and other compounds of phenolic nature are classified as active antimicrobial compounds (Mitscher and others 1972; Rojas and others 1992). In this study, it has been found that these 4 plants possess important phytochemicals such as saponins, flavonoids, tannins, and alkaloids Additionally, Welininda and others (1982) have isolated steroidal glycosides, alkaloids, momordicosides, and insulino-mimic proteins from MC. Recently, Braca and others (2008) identified 25 components from MC, representing 90.9% of the oil. The main constituents were trans-nerolidol, apiole, cis-dihydrocarveol, and germacrene D. Furthermore, they tested the oil for its antibacterial and antifungal activities and found that Staphylococcus aureus was the most sensitive microorganism (Braca and others 2008). Therefore, the presence of these phytochemicals could to some extent justify the observed antimicrobial activities in the current study. It is worthwhile to note that since the current antimicrobial evaluation was done using the same aqueous preparation as prescribed by the traditional healers, these results would support the way people use these herbal remedies. MC fruit was found to have bactericidal effect on 1 strain of Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA), which is resistant to the antibiotic methicillin. In Mauritius nosocromial infection caused by MRSA is a serious problem in many hospitals of the island. These MRSA are difficult to treat because they are also multiresistant and up to now there are no satisfactory antimicrobial drugs (Bartzokas 1984; Beck and others 1986; Berman and others 1986). Therefore, with respect to the present result, MC fruits seem to be a potential tool to combat the problem of MRSA. Moreover, in the light of the emergence of resistant strains of pathogens to known drugs and the high cost of health care in developing countries, the WHO recommendation
suggests the use of medicinal plants as alternative antibiotics in these countries (Mathews and others 1999). Thus MC fruit, which is widely used as a vegetable in the diet should not be ignored or neglected as dietary adjuncts. Findings from the present study also showed that MC extracts gave the lowest MIC values. In addition, MC plant parts seem to have a broader spectrum of antimicrobial activities against the test microbes. These results clearly prove the possible greater efficacy of MC extract at a lower dose than the endemic plant FF. Results from present study also showed that methanolic extract of both plants gave poor inhibition zones. Indeed, Cragg and others (1994) reported that there are great differences between the activities of aqueous and organic extracts in their anti-HIV screening: about 34% of the plants were active in aqueous extract and only 4% in organic extract. Moreover, the antibacterial substance within these plants in the current study seemed to be most prominent in the leaves and least in the twigs, and the best inhibitory activity was observed for Gram-positive bacteria. This may be attributed to the fact that cell wall in Gram-positive bacteria consists of a single layer, whereas Gram-negative cell wall is a multilayered structure bounded by an outer cell membrane (Yao and Moellering 1995). On the other hand, the extracts were not highly efficient against the test fungi. Such results indicate that antibacterial agents are more common in the plants studied than antifungal agents. This may be attributed to structural differences between prokaryotic bacteria and eukaryotic fungal agents; antimicrobial agents should bind to sterols in eukaryotic membrane so as to exhibit their action, whereas this step is not needed for bacterial cells (Medoff and Kayashi 1993; Ali-Stayeh and others 1998). Results from the current study also show that methanol extracts of these plants tend to give poor inhibition zones.
Conclusion
t is possible that these endemic/exotic medicinal plant extracts can be used as antibacterial agents in food or other ingredients. However, the exact mechanism of antibacterial effects needs to be further examined for potential uses. In conclusion, the current study advocates the need for continuing screening for antimicrobial agents from local endemic plants of Mauritius.
Acknowledgment
The authors are grateful to the Tertiary Education Commission and The Univ. of Mauritius for Financial support. We are also thankful to Dr. Issack, Senior specialist/Clinical Microbiologist, Victoria Hospital, Ministry of Health & Quality of Life for providing us with clinical isolates.
References
Ali-Stayeh MS, Yaghmour RMR, Faidi YR, Salem K, Al-Nuri MA. 1998. Antimicrobial activity of 20 plants used in folkloric medicine in Palestinian area. J Ethnopharmacol 60:26571.
M176
M177