Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
The overall aim: provide the church and citizenry with effective overview of the main issues!
Corrections? Suggestions? Need help/clarifications?: E-mail: RogerWilli@Yahoo.com
"But what does the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child have to say on the matter of
corporal punishment? It may be eye-opening to some that the Convention does not
mention the term ‘corporal punishment’ at all. Article 28(2) which is used as the basis for
the call to abolish corporal punishment in schools states:
“States Parties shall take all appropriate measures to ensure that school
discipline is administered in a manner consistent with the child’s human
dignity and in conformity with the present Convention”
“Guyanese should decide what parts of the CRC mandate are applicable to Guyana”;
http://www.stabroeknews.com/index.pl/article_archive?id=56510565
In today’s relentless barrage of words, images, slogans, and ideas that assault us from all
sides, many of us have become dependent on sound bites – short, simple, predigested,
emotion-laden, one-stop conclusions. We have neither the time nor the ability to sort through
the primary information for ourselves in order to arrive at our own considered conclusions. …
To disentangle this confusion and form solid principles by which to reach responsible
conclusions requires effort …” (Jeffrey Satinover, M.D., circa 1996).
SUBMITTED BY
ROGER WILLIAMS
AS A PERSONAL OPINION
APRIL-JUNE 2007
! " #$$" %
&
'( ' '
) &
* % % !&
, - . / %
& 0 - % 10 2! 3
4 5
67 ' 4
5 & & 8, % ! 3 9! 3 :
. 1 7 %
% - & " $ & $' ( )"
" $ - & .
% % %
% % &
% ; / <'== %& * &
! &
)
% 4 7 & " $ * $' + )" " $ -
1 7& *
1 ) 7 % , , => %&
? 8 =< # 8 #@9#: 91 / -
% 5
% 7: %
2! '
+ ,- 2 3 A ,.-
; 3 A ,- / 3 A ,'-
. A ,-
A ,)
-
; A ,- % % . 5
%&
% / #= .
; 51 7
8 #$$# B " $/ )" " $ 93 : &
* *
- %
1 7
& * - % .
; & * - % %
- 1
&7 0 . 8 =< #@
% - & " $+ )" " $
&
" " "" " . ' $' $ " "0" $ " 0 "0 1 $' $ 0" $ 2 $"3+
! " " # E
$ =<"$ .
8 3 E% " & '
E
$ % ,
2&!&F ' % %
% 2&!&
3 &
3
, . / . % 7 "8 9
@ " $( )" " $ 3 5
9 . % : & * %
% '
+
: * 3 % % &
: * 92G: % % % )'
% % % &
: / 5
H 2
3 A ; 3 A
/ 3 &
& " 2 " !! "" $" " )" ' 2 "0 30$ ! " ' ;
0 ' " $A
: * 3 &
: % 5 '%
: - % & 8
. 8 %
H % 5 &
: !.I 2!& ;) ? /
/ 8 0 8 J 8 /
8 3 % / &
: ! % - '
!.I C &
: * & % - 5
&
: * % &
: * C
&7
: ( % - % -
&
: 8 % 5
&
: * ?
% &
: % % C
C % % % &
% 8 % &!
2! 9 . :&
" " . $' #0 0 " ) '0. 0 # " $' " " ' " ! $" )" $" $ "
, % % & 0 %
, , 3 #$$K C 2 !
3 E E E
E& 8 ! / . %
%% & %
% - ) &0 ## #> #L
% B % %
&, , 2G5 B ! 3 % -
E E
& 0 => K$ & 0
% % * " == =<
& * (4=> ' '
% 1 7 &
4
* ) C , ,
C F
& 0 % ( =# %
9( ! ) * ) )+ ) :
? & % , ,
1M % 1 , - .+
% % 2 ! 3
E/ E #$$=&
* B % % %
% % %
C % ) % %
&7 * 1 , - 01 =K =" &
="
% % , , 3 !
% % !&
%
/
- &
) / / %
K$' &
* 0" $ % %
C . 5 & ' $" ) %
% 1; N 7 1 7& # $"
'
& 0" " % '
% & 8 1 7
' ' - %
) ) % &, ' ! $" " %
' ' . 5 B &
0 % % )
; &* ) % 8,
%
& &
* 9 . : ) &
& 0 & #$$D
. % 9 ""#% 888 #0$ ! 3 ??6?* "!
% - , & * C %
E! E /&
3 0
. % .
#$$L
Disclaimer:
" ' 0! $" ' "3 ' $ @ '2 3@ 8 $3 # $ $A " $ $ " ' #"1
" " "" " :" )" $" ' 0! $" . $ $'" # $" $' ) " #0 3# $ # $ $1
$' 0' $ " . $" 0' " " "! " # $ $ )" " $ !!0$ "3 $ B03 $ " # "2
0 ' ) 0 " " " ! !. # $" , ' "3 ' $ " 2 $ ! ' "
'2 3" " " $ !!0$ "3- 2 " '" . ' $" $ " '" # 1 $3"3# #
$" 0" $ " " " 7 8 3) ! " $" 3 !3 # $ . "31 $' 0' . . 0 " " !3
"" $" $ !! ' " 3 #0. # 3 $' " $8 . ) ) ' !! ' " 3
!
5
TABLE OF CONTENTS
$" :"% B ' 8 0' . . ' $ '' " C DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD *
FH )
G $' F' " 'G " I0 ) AB )
)9 2 8 ) # #0$ ! $"C &4
$ 0 $ DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD &/
1 / -
% 5
% 7
FD #=
. ; 5 $0 )B0 ' $ ) " $" $ $ ) '
$' #$ $ 8 #$$# B & *
- %
( -
& * - % .
; & *
- % % - 1
&7
$ 0'9 )
0 " :" $ = )" ' 0! $"C
6
GOOD LAW SHOULD BE BASED ON GOOD DATA AND EVIDENCE
1 B & - & *
- - % % &2 C
- &79
+ %%%& & & - % O - & : A 1# 4= )" ' 0! $"
1I C - %
% 7
9 + & & &L>& : A # $' " 0 $"9 " ! )' 0! $"
.2&
10 " $$
$+
2 " "
$+
" $
" 3
" &
$
$$+
" "
3 $,
* * *
& $+
"
& 7
4
7
INTRODUCTION
* % % '
& *
% ; 5 $0 )B0 ' $ ) " $" $ $ ) ' $' #$ $
* 1 ' 7 18 7 & 8 ) )
? & * % %1 7 )
- &
% % ( % %
& * / ?
""#% 888 " $ " # #0$ ! $" "! & ? #>'#L &
3 %' %
- ! *
% &
* % %
M% C
C &
&* - &
* ? &!%
( 5 % -& H $ " '
% . . +
4 H $" ' 8" " 2 8F " # #0$ ! $" ' " .0 G1 $' 8 0 8 3C
& H $" ' 8" " 2 8F " # #0$ ! $" ' ' $ G1 $' " $ A 8 3C
< H $" ' 8" " 2 8 F " # #0$ ! $" " ! ) ! $' 0 :0 ' 2 $ G1
$' 8 8 3$ "C
6 H $" ' 8" " 2 8F " # #0$ ! $" " " 8 $ $G1 $' " $
8 3$ "C
( H $" ' 8" " 2 8F " # #0$ ! $" $ 3 $;
0 0" "3 " $ #G
* H $" ' 8" " 2 8F " # #0$ ! $" ' $ " ' " G $' 0" $ 8 3C
+ H $" ' 8" " 2 8 F " " 0! $" .2 " 7$ " " ) . "" G1 $'
" $ A 8 3$ "C
( %+
/ ; &
!
B " 8$1B03 $
35L0$ &??+ , ) " ' ! $# 6-
8
IMPLICATIONS OF THE CRC FOR SOVERIGNITY
" + 15 6 .7 $ $# - #
& 8 - 6 , *9 # 1
& % 3 % +
& " 2 " !! "" $" " )" ' 2 "0 30$ ! " ' ;
0 ' " $A
: the CRC gives the committee a virtually unlimited mandate to insert itself in the affairs of a nation.
: It can demand wholesale changes in a country’s legal system, education system, and social-welfare institutions
: In fact, the lack of an enforcement mechanism is what gives the committee its broad reach. Any enforcement
mechanism approved by the General Assembly would include provisions for due
process and appeals—and would thereby limit the committee’s discretion.
1* 2&!& E $" $" $ ' M $N 0" A " $" ' " $ "
$" 2 $ $ ! "" 8 $" 38 " $ " ' ! " ; 0 ' " $ ) $3 " "
6
I0 " !. " 0.! " 0 ! "" " "" ! $" 0$' " # $" " E 8
=<"$ . 8 3 E8
(
) &E
H0" " O $ 5 " $' $ # " ) " " ) 2 $$ " $ " " " 8$ ' ! "
# 3 ' ' " $8 0$" 0 "0 $' #0 ' $ !! "" # " $'
' 0! $" 1# " 0 3" "$ " " !# ! $" " $ )" $2 $" $ $ " " )
*
" ' , - $' " $2 $" $ $ " ! $" $ ) ! ) ! $" $ $"
+
! $, -& , # 46 )" ' 0! $" ) ! )" 0! $":
9
IS THIS CHALLENGE TO SOVERIGNITY EVIDENT IN GUYANA?
" + 1/ 1A =$ #$$D
" $+ 3 B % !
, #$$D 8 2 ! 3 92! 3 : %
% ? . & / # , " " . 7
8 18 / ' 2! . 7& * 8
#$$D 2! 3 => 8 & ##D & K= K# % %
. +
1* ) %
&
* / P. Q
• ) % 7
) ! 3 9! 3 :
% - 1 7 & * 0 - ="'=L
#$$D / & =D 8 #$$D
! 3 ;) R , 3 . +
1* C 0 - +
• ;) A
• 3 % %
A
• 7&
B D #$$D ! 5 *
. % & 3& 8 8
% &
8 ) % +
, & ! 3
* % % ; %
% ; 6 * 6
&
% 6
* & C 0 - 1
7 C - &
) &
0" 3 ' ) 2 "$ ! $' " ' $" ! '' 3 8 $ ' 3 6 L0$
" " ' 2' 2 $! $" !! "! $" 8 " ' " " $ " . #
#0$ ! $" " " "1 )" 0 1! 7 " . 2 ! $" $ ' 7 # 8 $' ) 6
1 / -
% 5 % 7&
10
* % 5 -
&
5 % &
#= . ; 5 $0 )B0 ' $ ) " $" $ $ )
' $' #$ $ 8 #$$# B & *
- %
' ! $ 0 H 7
& * - % .
$ " 3 ) '0 " $& * - %
% - 1
&7
$ B03 $ !0 " $" # " " &/%& ) 0 2 $' ") $ $" # " " $ 8 7
" !# 2 0 $" 0 0 "0 P 0 8 ) 0 " 8" $" ' " $ 0 "
. " $ ) # #0$ ! $" $ $' " ! .0" " . "3 " #0 0$ 0$'
" 0 )" "" . ! &
* " $ !! $ % %
& C %
% . & *
% 5 5 ) -
- % & * %
& * % 4 5 4 5
% & 5 % - % 5
&
. 8 %
% % . &
• " $ " " " " $ " #$ . " 1 $' '0" )# $" , "
(-
• " $A " " ) 2 3 '" ) , " *-
• "" 7 0$" )" " " ! $" $ " F " $ )" " )" 'G " " F"
'1.3 $ ) # 3 $' ! $" !! "0 "31$ ' # ) 0 ' $'
1 $ 0' $ ## # " # " " $. ) 8 )" . " G , !. -
• " ) # " )" '9 $ $' " " )" '9 # $" 1 0 ' $
) ! 3! !. K , " 46-
• " " " " " " " " ! 7 '0 " $ . " K, " &/-
• " " " " " " " " 0$' " 7 " # " " " ' ) ! ) ! ) :0
:# " " $ $' :0 .0 , " <6-
" " " " " $ !! $ 0" ' " # "3 " $" 2 0 )
# #0$ ! $" 8 $ " 8 " ! "" " ' .2 . $ "" $" $&
8 #@ & . #
=$$$ % % ==
% & %
- &
* . " $ 8 %
3 % ?
& 0 % - %
&
, % ?? " $ !! $
3 ?G ) =K & &
5 ! %
11
& 8 1 =@
&&7
&
! 3
' %
. 5 2! 3 &
& % %
8 / % &
/ MR %
=$ #$$D
8 3;/I3* F
; &
'0 " $ $ " A $$ $ 1 $ $ " # " 3 " ' 3 " " " $
$ ' '1 ' ) ! $1 0" )" # "18 !! $' "
" 8$ " $' ) $' #$ $ $' ! 0# 8 " "
$ 3 0" $ &
#$$$ % %
B %
&
%
&
% % %
- B
B &
*
E ' %
% B E&
EI A
)
E &
E
B & $" " " " " $' # $" 8 $ 0 " '1
! " 0$ $ ! 0 3, 1 : #" "8 0" )46(-1 0## " ' " # " ) #
#0$ ! $" $ 1.0" 8 " O ! $" OE
E%
E - % %
& % &
12
DEFINING “CORPORAL PUNISHMENT”
" + 1 / 1A * N/ =<<@ R & #D # &#KL
0" + ( A/ 2 * % 8
" $+ ""#% 888 #0$ ! .$" "!A !
# #0$ ! $" 1I0 " " 31" $) " $ ) #0$ ! $" $" . '3& ;
E E E E &
% &
% '' "
$) " $ )# 3 # $8 " 0 3&K
0" $;
% & , % C
- -
B C &
E E E E E - E
E EE % E E &E
&
M&
$ 0 $
% &0
& * % & *
? % %
% & %
- & 2 0 " ' . "" 3 ) 0! $" $" " ## $ $" ) # #0$ ! $"
! # "2 0! $" ) " ) ! ) #0$ ! $" 8 ' ! 3 " "
!# $" " ! $ 2 0 ' )$ ). " $ ' $) 8 $ ' $ $ ) "1$ " $
0' . ) 0" ) ! " " 0" &
$" ) " $ " $ 1!3 0! $" 1 " 0 $ " 31 2 . $ ' " ' $" ' 3"
!! $ 3 ' 2 8 55 " " # #0$ ! $" 0 ' $ 2 . $) " ' 2 0 " " 8
" " " # " $ 0$" $ . 1 2 $ " 0 " 0! $" ) " ' 8 " " ) I0 $" $' 2
# 3 #0$ ! $" ! 38 $
- C
&
&
& % -
% & *
C &, ) C -
F ' % % C -
C - & 8 -
% C &
, B &
32 8 " " " &
!# ' " 1$ ) 2
0$' " ' " !1 $ 0)
) $" " ' ) $' " :" ! 2 8 " " # 3 #0$ ! $" 0'
$ 2 . '! $ " '& 2 " 8 0' ! $ # $" " )0 " ))
0" $' .
# # '" ' #" 0 2 8 ' $ 3K=
13
PLACE OF PHYSICAL CORRECTION IN THE DISCIPLINE OF CHILDREN
8 + 1 , - . 7
+ ""#%
888 $ ' 0 " " &/ ! " #')A
B !K , " 1 $ 0 " ) $ "
" ! " $ !. &??*1 0$' # 0 0 '3 ! 2' "
" $ 2 $ ) ! " 8 . " 18 ! $" $ $ " $" 5 ) $ "
$ . $ "0 $ ' 8 2 1" 7$' )# 0 0$ #" . $'
' " " ) 0 ! " 8 "" $ " $ "8 7 # )" # "
2 . .38 " $ !-
: #" 0!! 3%
4R 8
- -
&
&R * % %
)
&
<R 8 C %
B - ' &
- &
6R * %
% % =<L<&
(R %
% %
&
*S 3 %
- &
+R %
% &
/R 3 % - %
) %
' &
=R / %
% ) %
&
4?R 3 %
% % &
44R / % - - 1 ) -
7% 5 &
4&R %
& /
% &
14
A COUNTER-CULTURAL AGENDA?
8 + E7 # , : # : -
5 &- & E
8 + * , A/ -,& , A ## A
* 2&!& E " $ $" $ ' M $N 0" A " $" ' " $ "
$" 2 $ $ ! "" 8 $" 38 " $" ' ! " ;0 ' " $ ) $3 " "
6
I0 " !. " 0.! " 0 ! "" " "" ! $" 0$' " # $" " E 8 =<"$
. 8 3 E8
(
) &E
H0" " O $ 5 " $' $ # " ) " " ) 2 $$ " $ " " " 8$ ' ! "
# 3 ' ' " $8 0$" 0 "0 $' #0 ' $ !! "" # " $'
' 0! $" 1# " 0 3" "$ " " !# ! $" " $ )" $2 $" $ $ " " )"
*
' , - $' " $2 $" $ $ " ! $" $ ) ! ) ! $" $ $" ! $
, -& + 2 2&!& 3
+
T 3 ? A ) ; 80
. ''% ? '' % E
/
) C %P . QE
T - E E % %
- ' &
8 ) E
=
C &&&P Q % F &E
0" + , , A #$$K 3
4 O B H P Q B
1M % % )
% &
% % % %
% % % % &
) )
E ) E
#@
. 8 =<@" B &
0 % % & *
& I
% ) % %
& *
& 2 " ! $ $ $ . 0" " !! "" O ## +
H " 0$' ! $ $ # $" $' " 0" $ !3 )" )! 3 " " 7$ " " $ " 4+5# # "1
" !! "" ) 0 : 0 2 3 $" # $ . "3 )" " " ) ' $18 " 0" 2$ $3
$" $" " $' #$ . " )" # $" )" ) ! 30$ "A
H " ' $" # ! " ! $3 8 " $ " ! " " $71 # 7 $' " $" ! )" @ " @ )
$ ) ! 3! !. 2 $" $ " 18 " " ) ! 3! !. '0 " ' $&
&
$" ' " $ !! "" $ " " )" ' $ ' " " " @ $.
"
! $"@ ' ) $ # $" @ 0 2 " $ )" ' $ "3 )" '@ 0## " $
2' $ 0## ' " 0. " $" " " 2 8 8 ## " ) " # ' " ! $' '
!! "! $"& * -
E E &
I ) , ,
C
F & $ $ $ 8" " #3 ) 0 0.! $
## F , - .+ ;18 8
0.! "" ' " " $" ' " $ !! "" $" " )" ' $ '2 $ )" ' 3 )
$ ' 0 $ $ @P $ $" ' $8 " $" ) ! 3 $' $ @ $ L0$ &??4& *
B % % %
% % %
C % ) %
% M&7
16
WHAT HAPPENS IF “CP” IS REMOVED FROM A RANGE OF MEASURES?
" + 1 , - . 7
" $+ ""#%
888 $ ' 0 " " &/ ! A
" #')
B !K , " 1 $ 0 " ) $ "
" ! " $ !. &??*1 ' 0$' # 0 0 '3 ! 2' "
" $ 2 $ ) ! " 8 . " 18 ! $" $ $ " $" 5 ) $
7$' )# 0 0$ #" . 10$ #" . $' ' " " )0 1 $' ! "1
2 8 "" $ " $ "8 7 # 2 . .3 8 " $
!-
1*
%
&
( 9=<LK: % % -
% - +
1 ) - % C
&&& /
5 &7(+
% C ? +
1M - -
9/ =<@#:& 2
- -' B -
* % %
% % =<L<& 0 % %
% % -
- % %
&
* - C
& $" $$ " $1 " ) $" " " $ " " " " $" B 0# # " < #
=> 1) 0$' " " **> )# $" 8 )$' $ " ! ') ) 0" " ' #$ " ' $. 0 )
) ). $ 0 ' ) .0 ! 0 2 3 ) 0$' " " /&> 8 $" ' " # $" # 8 "
' #$ ' $ 8 " 0" ) )# 0" $
* +
1M
% &7(=
SEE ALSO …
!# $ ) 8 $" 2 8 ) $" ) "0' ) 3 0$ ! $" .3 $"
9 + & & ? $#& : ? #$$#& %
. F ? % E %
% % &
% B C &
* ) &E
17
UN CONVENTIONS UNDERMINE FAMILY, RELIGION AND SOVERIGNITY
" + E7 # , : # : -
5 &- & E
0" + 8 , 3 A / -,& ,
* , F ##' '
3 9 3 : &0
- . % &
2&!& % %
% H
F 2 3 % + E/
(6
- &E *
'
2&!& - % % &
* 2&!& +
T ""
# 2 31 2 $ $ " 0 'K
T ""
# ) $ 0$ $ 8 " 0" # $" $ $" 0' $ K
T )
0 " " . " $ $' $" #" 2 1 2 $ 8 $ " " 8 0' 2 " " # $" O
" $' ' K
T "" ) 0 ) ' ! ) :# $ " ! $' $ K
T ! $ ! " $ $ 0" " # $"O 0" "3 $ " !
, ) 2&!& 3 L# $
((
E F &E %
% % & ! %
% &J 2&!& %
&
8 E E 3 ) A
%
(* (+
F A A & *
) % F
(/
& I E E
% !.I
&
2&!& H A
- E ' E
(=
E % &E
% 3
( ? F &* 3
+ E % %
- % %
*?
&E * F
% % % % F
3 &
* 2&!&
*4
18
/ 9 /: =<<D ( C
0 0 =<<> / U> =<<< ( C U> #$$$&
* - F
& * 8 8
*&
& 8 ( C U> % % %
%
&
* 2&!& F
3 - $" ' Q $ ' ! =<<>& *
) %
; 0 % % )
& )
) % B
*<
=# &
* 2&!& % " # $
*6
% E &E
% 3 0" F F
+ E8 %
% &&& P Q B %
*(
- C &E 8 -
% & *
2&!& -
F
F ) &
* 2&!& % % % % ">
' &8 =$
**
@$ & / . / =<<@ %
VL<$& J 2&!& E B
' % %
*+
% &E *
( C =<<> - E E E E E2&!&'
-E !.I %
*/
% &
* - % % % -
& !% 3
&
* 2&!& , 2 !
3 J % 2&!& J
*=
8 =<<@& 2&!& C
& * 2&!&
C R % F
%
&&&& C &&&P Q -
% &&&& P*Q
+?
&
8 - F
F % A % &* 2&!&
2
+4
3 &
19
SWEDEN’S SMACKING BAN: MORE HARM THAN GOOD
" + E 2 3 9 . 7 + ;
0" + 3 ; ? / A8 / / A2 ! -
2
* % => % %
- & * =>'=< ' % %
$'D % %% =<L<& * - -
% &
% 6 ,
% % B & *
%
& % &
8 =<@D 9( J : =<<D 9( J :W
. 4 % L'=D ' % #>'#< '
&/ % =$ % - % =<L<& (
% #$'#D ' %
& % %
&
C - %
=>'=< ' L'=D ' =<@D =<<D
% =>'=< ' &
! . 4 % L'=D ' % =>'
=< ' & )
- % (4=> =<@D =<<D& * %
&
20
L % L'=D ' & 8 L'=D '
L B %
(4=> % . 4M&
0!! 3
% C % 5 =<L< - & I
& 8
=<L<&
% =<L<&
% 6/=> % =<@='
=<<D& B % =<L<
% &
* L'=D '
% - % &* 5
&
I ) % %
%
&
) & %
- - &3
% & (
% %
&
% ' 2 & /
% ) &I &
8 % ) %
% ) & 0 C
& ) &=
* =<<< % ( / 2 %
- & *
5 % 5 -
% &
M&
$ 0 $
8 & 5 & * -
% =<L< - & *
' )'
- & ,
&
( % % 5 ) - ) % 5 B
B % ) &
8 % % )'
& - )' &
B & - & *
- - % % &2 C
- & 0
' -
& & =<<"&#L 0
' -
% C &
9 - : &
21
1
A CRITIQUE OF DR. LIZ GERSHOFF’S REVIEW OF CORPORAL PUNISHMENT
3 ;& ? / & &A + & & ? "$#& A #$$#
&. 5 % % -
% C & & .
+ E
&&& E 9 & >>$:& - %
% %& ( % )
% & * )
B C - &
=K
% ' % &#'==
8 ">W & . 5 %
9L : 9K : %
9= :&
- & * % )
&# K> " =# =K
% - % '' % &
&. 5 % - % #'
"' ' % - &=D =>
%
- &, &. 5 %# K > "
D L @ ="
& % B
&
''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''
. 5 % ? 9E E: & (
% 9 & & - : - &
? & * % 9 :
9 : 9 : 9 :&
- % &
8 9 : % %
' % &I
% % % '
% % 9E E: &
3
X =& . ;*& / ) +8 ' %&
#$$#&
#& ( 80 3 0& * ' &
=<@=A<+<>'=$>&
K& ;3 0& 8 &
=<@KA==+=D='=>#&
D& 3 0& ; % & ! =<@@A=#+K>K'KL$&
>& 3 0 /% 0& 8 C & ! " =<<$A#=+#>L'#L=&
"& ? 3; 0! ( /- / & * & #
$ ! " =<<"A=@+K>'>L&
L& ? 3; /3 0! ( /- / & / F
& $ =<<@A"$+K@@'D$K&
@& ( ; / ( ( &( &
=<"@AK#+DDL'D>>&
<& 8 R;& & !
% & =<<@A="+K>K'KLD&
=$& 33& 3 ? ) & %
=<"=A"K+D""'D<#&
==& J % 3 ( 3R& ' ( & , + '( =<"@&
=#& R &/ ' & ! =<LKA@+="'#D&
=K& &/ & =<@@A>=+=D'#K&
=D& ? 3;& & +0 & & 0 +2
0 / #$$=+@='@<&
=>& ? 3;& +8 %&
$ )! #$$$AK9D:+=<<'##=&
="& 3 0& 3 + & ! =<@#AD+#K<'#D@&
&3 ;& ? #$ ) #$
C -& 8 / /
2 ! - &
8 % &. 5 1 !# $ ) 8 $" 2 8 )
$" ) "0' ) 3 0$ ! $" .3 $" 9 ""#% ) 0 "3. '0 # 0 # A ?& "! :
22
Resources: Corporal Punishment of Children
http://faculty.biola.edu/paulp/
B H C
• , ? G F
! ' * B ? Y &
% % &
• ? " $ & % *
2 ( - & 0!! 3
9 + & - & ? & : ) B -
& % )
% - &*
% % &
• 3 ;? * . / % / ( 9#$$#:
% ) & " I0
9 + & & ? "$#& : ? %
% + =:
- #: & 8
( % N ? I / / + 6 .
9#$$#: =#@ >@$'>@<&
• A " 0 ." ,L0$ 1 4===-; [ ""#% ) 0 "3. '0 # 0 # ' . " "! N 8
& ? F % - &
? N. '
9=<<L: "' <' ' B - & 8 &
%
"' <' ' 9
- % % :& * % !
, , 3 ; ( 8 &
• $ H 0! $'% E
- % % &&
& - C - %
&E * B ( F 92 ( - :
=$< 8 8 / 8 8 #D #$$=&
- E 3 3 8( - C 8 -
/ 6E
• ? 3 %
."$ ' $O 2 9=<<D: 9 ""#% #0.# 0$ '0 U! & * #'):
• 8 ' $5 0" $ ' $ $ 8 ' $ 9 ""#% ) 0 "3. '0 # 0 # 8 ' $& "! : &
? % 9=<<<:
% F - &8 " I0 8 #$$=
, , 9 =#: &
• " " " ) ! 8 ' $5 0" $ ' $ 9 ""#% ) 0 "3. '0 # 0 # 8 ' $& "!
""#% ) 0 "3. '0 # 0 # 8 ' $ " " "! : '
L 90 - =<<# =<<>:&
• H "7 8 71L $ $' H ') ' : @ $ 2"2 " " $" ' #$%
) $" $ &E& / ! ' 8 %
/ &
• A H. # 3 & ?
% % ) - &
o I % & 8 =D
=<<L * ; 1% ) .
9 + %%%& & ? $ <=L= <@"@<$ $$& : & * F
&
25
Corporal Punishment (spanking) is strongly supported by God in the Bible
Secular "experts" who dispense advice to the contrary are responsible
for many of the discipline problems experienced by parents and schools
http://www.creationists.org/corporalpunishment.html
) % E E
E E % +
W 3 )" $ I0 " "0' 8 "0 .0 ! : ' $8 " # #0$ ! $" " "
'! $ " ' 0" ) 2 ) " '
W 3 8 3 $ 8 "" " " 3 $" ! "" 1 $ $" ) " )" 3
! " . " $ 1" 3 ## " .. "0'3 $ " ! "" 0 $ $" '
) : $" ## 0 " " 3 $' 0# $ $ $ 7$' )" "0 ' . .
$" # " " $ $ $ "" !#" " " 3" ) " H. " 0## " 8 " " 3. 2
W 3 # 2 0 $ 0 "0' $' ) . ' " 1#3 " " $'
#3 " $ " ' ) . 3$ " '2 )" $) . B ' 8 " ' " !1 $' 8
' ! $' )0 " " 8 ' " $ 8 3
F % % -%
E ) E& - ) &
8 ) - % ' ) % - % &
2 . 4<%&6 +
&
2 . &&%4( , P Q AP Q
&
2 . &<%4<546 0 + P Q %
&* % &
2 . 4?%46 % + P Q -
&
2 . 4<%&6 +
&
2 . &&%4( , P Q AP Q
&
2 . &<%4<546 0 + P Q %
&* % &
2 . 4=%4/ % &
26
6 '8 O" 8$ " !# " $" 0! 0' $ " . )
" $ " 3" 0"K 0'
. # !#" 3' # $ '+
2 . &=%4( * % + P Q
&
2 . &?%44 ; - % % % -P Q % P Q
&
2 . &&%* * % + % % &
2 . &<%4<546 0 + P Q %
&* % &
2 . &<%&65&( * C + %
P Q C & *
C &
" 6%4< ( P Q % - % %
&
! " 3 <%65( I % % C % A
9, - % % % % - . 6:
! " 3 (%456 3 - P Q A P Q
A * % A % & % %
% % & ( % % % %
B + . &
+ $" 0 '$O
" .0 " ' $ " ! $" 3 # 3 3+
# $ *%6 8 - % +
&
$ <%&4 , - P Q &
0 ? ( -
-& 0 C-
( % - C &
, % - ) % .
- % % ' . '
& . % . &
& %
' & I 9 : % & *
% % F % &
27
- % ) - %
& ; - ' ' %
& 0 % )
&
0
( -
0 ( *
8 + &3 ,
(!+ $'@"L=L'$$$'Z
* '0
8 + &
(!+ $'@D#K'$""D'=
&
(!+ $'@D#K'$"K='>
- B %
&+ %%%& & & 6 [#<#
% %
8 + & & &
0 ( -
8 + & & &
, % B %
+ %%%& & #
, % % '% %
% . F % + %%%& & ==
& R %
% & 0 9% % #$ :&
-& * %
& %%%& &
, , 3
J -% % &
) &
28
ARE WE READY FOR THE ABOLITION OF CORPORAL PUNISHMENT?
$ # $ "" " $" ! " 5
0 =$ #$$L
""#% 888 " . 7$ 8 ! $' : # " E 'X(*(44<(=
* % % %
- %
5 &
& % B %6
&
G! 9L #$$L:& 8 / 9 /:
+
=& 0 /6
#& 0 % / 6
K& 8 / .
. 2 86
D& 8 2 8 .
F6 % %
6
>& 0 /6 ! %
& /
&
"& 0 \K \D
L& 0 / % 6
@& 0 %%
% - 6
<& 0 ; F
C 6
=$& /
9 :
6 % % 6
==& % \@ < =$ % / C
-
6
=#& F % % / 6 0 %
9 :&
=K& ( % \ = =# . % B
% /6
J
C *
29
CONCLUSION
& 8, % 18, 7
L #$$L+
F 7$ 8 " " ! $3 " 3" " " 3 ' $ " 7 " . " "0' $" .0" )$' " "
" " " ) # #0$ ! $" " $3 " $ " 3 2 " 7 # " "0' $"
!# $" G
I0 " $ %
$ 31 ! " 0 "$ " "" $' '! $ " " $ " " 3$ " 0"! "" 8 7
8 " $ $5 ! 0 1 $' $ "0 $ " "E
% /
% :
0 6 8 +
• " $ " " " " $ " #$ . " 1 $' '0" )# $" , "
(-
• " $A " " ) 2 3 '" ) , " *-
• " " 7 0$" )" " " ! $" $ " F " $ )" " )" 'G " "
F" '1.3 $ ) # 3 $' ! $" !! "0 "31$ ' # ) 0 '
$' 1 $ 0' $ ## # " # " " $ .) 8 )
" . " G
, !. -
• " ) # " )" '9 $ $' " " )" '9 # $" 1 0 ' $
) ! 3! !. K , " 46-
• " " " " " " " " ! 7 '0 " $ . " K, " &/-
• " " " " " " " " 0$' " 7 " # " " " ' ) ! ) ! ) :0
:# " " $ $' :0 .0 , " <6-
" " " " " $ !! $ 0" ' " # "3 " $" 2 0 )
# #0$ ! $" 8 $" 8 " ! "" " ' .2 . $ "" $" $&
8 #@ &
. # =$$$ % % ==
% & )" " ' " #3 ! $" )) " 8 '
"3" $ "0 #3" ' $ 7 "
1 38 2 " " F 3# 2 G " " # $7$ ' " 3 ) 5 " !1# ! " 2 $"
. 2 1 $' $ " $7 )" $" $ "0'3 $" " )
) " )
# $7$ $ ' $ " "9 8 " " # # "9 8 "" $ $ 2 3 $ $ )" ! , 9
2
2 8 ' " ! 1 " $7- ) 8" ' $ # . ! 5 ' 8 0' .
' 0 ' $ # ! 0 $ :# ! $" #3 3&7 9 G& 3 :
“… Like cars, computers, knives and needles, physical punishment may be misused, but not all
use is misuse. While there may be a place for public education to discourage the improper use of
physical sanctions and encouraging their proper use, there is no basis for stigmatising it and
rejecting its use wholesale. Indeed, in many situations it is arguably a more kind and merciful
response than other approaches which may be more drawn-out or risk causing emotional
damage. We fully endorse a statement issued by the Children and Young People's Unit:
"We believe our policy reflects common sense views of the vast majority of people.
It is not only wrong but dangerous to link smacking and child abuse deaths. It
diverts attention from those children most at risk."
By putting this issue high on its agenda, the children's rights lobby is misrepresenting the
concerns of children. As Mr Denham commented in his evidence before the Joint Human Rights
Committee in November 2002, children are far more concerned about other issues such as their
experience of being victims of crime in the streets. Certainly children do not enjoy being
corrected, whether physically or otherwise, but where physical correction is used in response to
the child's misbehaviour in a moderate, careful and consistent manner, it is accepted as a
consequence of wrongdoing, does not cause resentment and, indeed, is often preferable to the
child than more protracted disciplinary strategies.”
FINAL THOUGHTS