Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
23
22 Price
21
20 EUR 21.43
19
18
Target Price
17
16
15
EUR 22.90
Oct 05 Nov 05 Dec 05 Jan 06 Feb 06 M ar 06 Apr 06 M ay 06 Jun 06 Jul 06 Aug 06 Sep 06 Oct 06 Nov 06
(EUR) 12/04 12/05 12/06e 12/07e 12/08e Share price on 02/11/2006 (EUR) 21.43
Total Income (m) 2,330 2,484 2,732 2,937 3,139 Target price (EUR) 22.90
Gross Operating Profit (GOP) ( 870 1,097 1,322 1,467 1,609 Market capitalisation (EURm) 8,043.0
EBT (m) 712 981 1,296 1,288 1,408 No. of shares (m) 375.3
Net Profit (reported) (m) 412 597 816 773 845 Free float 100.0%
Shareholders Equity (m) 3,717 4,021 4,576 4,992 5,477 Daily avg. no. trad. sh. 12 mth 2,462,700
GOPPS 2.35 2.94 3.52 3.91 4.29 Daily avg. trad. vol. 12 mth (m) 51.19
EPS (adj.) 1.19 1.54 1.92 2.06 2.25 Price high 12 mth (EUR) 23.42
BVPS 9.17 9.92 11.33 12.44 13.73 Price low 12 mth (EUR) 15.80
DPS 0.50 0.70 0.95 0.96 1.00 Abs. perf. 1 mth -2.6%
P/GOP 5.9 5.1 6.1 5.5 5.0 Abs. perf. 3 mth -5.0%
P/E (adj.) 11.7 9.8 11.1 10.4 9.5 Abs. perf. 12 mth 35.5%
P/BV (adj.) 1.5 1.5 1.9 1.7 1.6
Dividend Yield (%) 3.6 3.3 4.4 4.5 4.7 Local index S&PMIB
Cost/Income (%) 62.7 55.8 51.6 50.0 48.7 DJ Stoxx or EuroStoxx 50 No
ROE (adj.) (%) 12.2 14.9 16.8 16.2 16.1 EPS 06-04 CAGR 27.4%
Shareholders:
CONTENTS
Investment case......................................................................................................3
Creating Italy’s biggest Popolare bank ................................................................4
The Cattolica option....................................................................................................5
Active capital management.........................................................................................5
Value creation .........................................................................................................6
The effect on our estimates ........................................................................................8
Conclusions ............................................................................................................9
Banca Pop. Verona Novara: Summary tables ...................................................10
Il presente documento è stato redatto da Luigi Tramontana che svolge funzioni di analista presso Banca Akros SpA ("Banca
Akros"), soggetto responsabile della produzione del documento stesso.
Banca Akros - banca autorizzata anche alla prestazione di servizi di investimento con provvedimento di Banca d’Italia del
14/11/1996, iscritta all’albo delle Banche al n. 5328, appartenente al Gruppo Bipiemme Banca Popolare di Milano (il
“Gruppo”) e soggetta all’attività di direzione e coordinamento di Banca Popolare di Milano (la “Capogruppo”) - ha prodotto il
presente documento per i propri clienti istituzionali (“operatori qualificati” così come definiti all’art. 31 del Regolamento
Consob in materia di Intermediari). Esso è distribuito dal giorno 3 novembre 2006.
Banca Akros, ai sensi degli artt. 69 quater e quinquies del Regolamento Consob in materia di Emittenti, dichiara di non
avere propri rilevanti interessi finanziari negli strumenti finanziari oggetto del presente documento ovvero rilevanti conflitti di
interesse derivanti da rapporti con l’emittente detti strumenti finanziari (l’”Emittente”) ovvero, più in generale, derivanti da
operazioni descritte nel presente documento. Banca Akros dichiara di non essere a conoscenza della sussistenza di
rilevanti interessi finanziari e/o di rilevanti conflitti di interesse della Capogruppo nei confronti dell’Emittente.
L’analista Luigi Tramontana, che ha redatto il presente documento, ha maturato una significativa esperienza presso Banca
Akros e altri intermediari. L’analista e i suoi familiari non detengono Strumenti Finanziari emessi dall’Emittente, né svolgono
ruoli di amministrazione, direzione o consulenza per l’Emittente, né l’analista riceve bonus, stipendi o altre forme di
retribuzione correlate, direttamente o indirettamente, al successo di operazioni di investment banking.
Banca Akros, nell’ultimo anno, ha pubblicato sulla società oggetto di analisi tre studi in data 26 e 31 ottobre 2006.
La Banca rende disponibili ulteriori informazioni, ai sensi delle disposizioni Consob di attuazione dell’art. 114, comma 8 del
D.Lgs 58/98 (TUF) ed in particolare ai sensi dell’art. 69 quinquies, comma 2, del Regolamento Emittenti, presso il proprio
sito internet (si veda http://bancaakros.webank.it/akros/sito.nsf/homepage).
Le informazioni e le opinioni contenute in questo documento si basano su fonti ritenute attendibili. La provenienza di dette
informazioni e il fatto che si tratti di informazioni già rese note al pubblico è stata oggetto di ogni ragionevole verifica da
parte di Banca Akros. Banca Akros tuttavia, nonostante le suddette verifiche, non può garantire in alcun modo né potrà in
nessun caso essere ritenuta responsabile qualora le informazioni alla stessa fornite, riprodotte nel presente documento,
ovvero sulla base delle quali è stato redatto il presente documento, si rivelino non accurate, complete, veritiere ovvero
corrette.
Il documento è fornito a solo scopo informativo; esso non costituisce proposta contrattuale, offerta o sollecitazione
all’acquisto e/o alla vendita di strumenti finanziari o, in genere, all’investimento, né costituisce consulenza in materia di
investimenti. Banca Akros non fornisce alcuna garanzia di raggiungimento di qualunque previsione e/o stima contenuto nel
documento stesso. Inoltre Banca Akros non assume alcuna responsabilità in merito a qualsivoglia conseguenza e/o danno
derivante dall’utilizzo del presente documento e/o delle informazioni in esso contenute. Le informazioni o le opinioni ivi
contenute possono variare senza alcun conseguente obbligo di comunicazione in capo a Banca Akros, fermi restando
eventuali obblighi di legge o regolamentari.
E’ vietata la riproduzione e/o la ridistribuzione, in tutto o in parte, direttamente o indirettamente, del presente documento,
non espressamente autorizzata.
Page 2
Banca Pop. Verona Novara
Investment case
After an initial negative reaction due to the high price paid to win BPI’s approval of
the merger project, we believe that the market will find solace in a rapid and
effective integration of the two banking groups, thanks to the proven track record of
the BPVN management team. The successful execution of revenue synergies will
be crucial, and we prudently include in our numbers only half of the target, or
EUR 140m vs. EUR 280m. Despite our prudent approach, BPVN is still trading at a
P/E of 12.1x in 2007 and 10.2x in 2008 post-synergies, at a discount to other
Italian peers. Therefore we give to BPVN an Accumulate rating and EUR 22.9
target price.
On the revenue side, the targeted synergies (EUR 280m) correspond to 6.8% of
the combined revenue base (or almost twice the new assessment in the BIN-SPI
merger) and half of it is expected to come from a partial realignment of BPI’s
employee productivity to the best practice of the BPVN group.
We cast some doubts on this productivity realignment, mainly concerning its
phasing, considering that:
• the productivity realignment is still under way in the BPN network, 5 years after
the announcement of the BPV-BPN merger; although it is true that BPV
announced these productivity-alignment targets only 3 years ago (in November
’03), it confirms our view that more time is needed to deliver them compared to
the current merger plan;
• prior to the merger with BPV, the BPN network was selling a limited product
range, due to the lack of product factories in the group; this is not the case of
BPI, which has a wide product range in wealth management, in investment
banking and in other niche markets;
• the BPI network is characterised by a majority (55%) of small branches (less
than 5 employees), where cross-selling opportunities are more limited than in
large branches; the 2006-09 business plan that BPI presented last April
provides for the grouping of these branches and the consequent disposal of
the smaller ones and of those located in areas where BPI has less than 2%
market share – therefore we see a risk of double counting between this plan
and the merger plan with BPVN.
To conclude, we expect only EUR 360m synergies vs. EUR 500m targeted by
2010. This implies a dilutive effect of nearly 7% on our 2008e pro-forma numbers
and an almost neutral effect only in 2009.
The ongoing analysis with respect to Cattolica Assicurazioni concerning a partial
integration with BPVN will continue until end November and will be submitted to
BPI’s BoD, which should evaluate with complete freedom whether to launch the
project. Potential synergies of a partial Cattolica-BPVN merger should be mainly
on the revenue side and should exceed EUR 200m after the BPVN-BPI deal.
According to press rumours, prior to the tie-up Cattolica could spin-off 100% of
Duomo Assicurazioni, 50% of Lombarda Vita and 3% of Banca Lombarda to other
parties. Our preliminary assessment on the value of these assets is in the region of
EUR 0.8-1bn. If the partial integration with Cattolica goes through, it will give the
new group the opportunity to rationalise its Life bancassurance agreements, as
BPVN currently has two joint-ventures (one with Cattolica and the other with
Fondiaria-Sai), while BPI has a joint-venture with UK’s Aviva and a distribution
agreement with Unipol group. But the merger with Cattolica is primarily aimed at
developing P&C bancassurance, both via the bundling of P&C policies with
banking products (like mortgages) or the direct sale of P&C products at banks’
branches, and via the cross-fertilisation of the two customer bases, turning
Cattolica’s clients into customers of the banking group.
Page 3
Banca Pop. Verona Novara
The new group will have total assets worth EUR 111bn, total loans and direct
funding of EUR 73bn (5th in Italy), AUM worth EUR 48bn (4th in Italy), ranking as
the largest cooperative bank in the country.
Page 4
Banca Pop. Verona Novara
Page 5
Banca Pop. Verona Novara
Source: BPVN
According to our numbers, the Tier1 ratio should be equal to 6.2% in 2007 pro-
forma (Core Tier1 at 5.7%), as the EUR 500m of ex-BPI preference shares will be
fully booked, while they currently exceed the 15% threshold of BPI Tier 1 ratio and
are therefore booked at half of their value. To raise the Tier1 ratio to 6.5%, the new
group would have to raise EUR 250m of Tier1 capital or reduce RWA by
EUR 3.5bn. We remind investors that the new group could also raise up to
EUR 544m from ex-BPI warrant conversion between 1st July 2008 and 21st
December 2010 (exchange ratio 0.526 and EUR 11 strike price).
2007e Tier1 ratio
(EUR m) 2007
BPI BPVN New group
RWA 34,322 56,144 90,466
Tier 1 2,762 4,164 7,161
extra-dividend - 1,520 0 - 1,520
Tier1 ratio 3.6% 7.4% 6.2%
Core Tier1 2.8% 7.4% 5.7%
Source: Banca Akros
Value creation
One-off integration costs are seen at EUR 300m, while expected synergies are
equal to EUR 500m at run rate in 2010, o/w EUR 220m (or 44%) on the cost side
and EUR 280m (or 56%) on the revenue side.
Source: BPVN
Page 6
Banca Pop. Verona Novara
On the cost side, the targeted synergies (see next chart) correspond to almost 9%
of the combined cost base (in line with the first assessment in the B. Intesa –
SanPaolo IMI merger) and should come from personnel lay-offs (41% or EUR
90m) through management of employees’ exit due to running churn-rate (3% per
year), corresponding to ca. 1,300 redundancies; from IT/back-office rationalisation
(30% or EUR 66m) thanks to the migration to the single BPVN IT platform; and
from rationalisation of head offices and improved purchasing power (29% or EUR
64m). These synergies do not look aggressive, especially concerning personnel
costs. We believe the mgmt has given up the idea of heavy cuts in the workforce to
gain BPI’s personnel approval of the merger in the EGM.
Source: BPVN
On the revenue side, the targeted synergies (see next chart) correspond to 6.8%
of the combined revenue base (or almost twice the new assessment in the BIN-
SPI merger) and half of it is expected to come from a partial realignment of BPI’s
employee productivity to the best practice of the BPVN group.
Source: BPVN
Page 7
Banca Pop. Verona Novara
’03), it confirms our view that more time is needed to deliver them compared to
the current merger plan;
• prior to the merger with BPV, the BPN network was selling a limited product
range, due to the lack of product factories in the group; this is not the case of
BPI, which has a wide product range in wealth management (Bipitalia Gestioni
and Arca in Asset Mgmt, Eurovita in Life assurance, Banca Valori in Private
banking), in investment banking (Efibanca in corporate finance, Centrosim in
brokerage) and in other niche markets (Bipitalia Ducato in consumer credit,
Bipielle Leasing (recently sold to Banca Italease) in leasing, etc.);
• the BPI network is characterised by a majority (55%) of small branches (less
than 5 employees), where cross-selling opportunities are more limited than in
large branches; the 2006-09 business plan that BPI presented last April
provides for the grouping of these branches and the consequent disposal of
the smaller ones and of those located in areas where BPI has less than 2%
market share – therefore we see a risk of double counting between this plan
and the merger plan with BPVN.
In conclusion, we believe than in the 4-year plan horizon only half, or EUR 140m,
of the targeted synergies will be delivered.
n.shares 682 375 669 682 375 669 682 375 669
EPS (EUR) 0.57 2.06 1.78 0.68 2.25 2.10 0.78 2.46 2.42
BPVN dilution -13.4% -6.7% -1.6%
P/E (x) 19.2 10.4 12.1 16.1 9.6 10.2 14.0 8.7 8.9
Source: BANCA AKROS
Page 8
Banca Pop. Verona Novara
Considering also the issue of up to 49.5m shares consequent upon the conversion
of ex-BPI warrants between 1st July 2008 and 21st December 2010, we calculate a
fully diluted EPS of EUR 1.95 in 2008 and of EUR 2.25 in 2009, with a potential full
dilution of BPVN shareholders of 13% in ’08 and 8.4% in ’09 (see next table). In
the hypothesis that the EUR 544m deriving from the warrants’ exercise are
reinvested at CoE of 7.4%, the fully diluted EPS would be EUR 2.0 in ’08 and
EUR 2.3 in ’09, while the full dilution would be equal to 10.5% in ’08 and 6% in ’09.
BPVN full dilution
2008e 2009e
Shares fully diluted (m) 718 718
EPS fully diluted (EUR) 1.95 2.25
BPVN full dilution -13.1% -8.4%
P/E (x) 11.0 9.5
Source: BANCA AKROS
Conclusions
After an initial negative reaction due to the high price paid to win BPI’s approval of
the merger project, we believe that the market will find solace in a rapid and
effective integration of the two banking groups, thanks to the proven track record of
the BPVN management team. The successful execution of revenue synergies will
be crucial, and we prudently include in our numbers only half of the target, or EUR
140m vs. EUR 280m. Despite our prudent approach, BPVN is still trading at a P/E
of 12.1x in 2007 and 10.2x in 2008 post-synergies, at a discount on other Italian
peers (see next table). The valuation discount would be confirmed also with fully-
diluted EPS figures. Therefore, we give BPVN an Accumulate rating and EUR 22.9
target price.
Page 9
Banca Pop. Verona Novara
Page 10
Banca Pop. Verona Novara
Recommendation system
From the 18th October 2004, the Members of ESN use a New Recommendation System.
The new ESN Recommendation System is Absolute. It means that each stock is rated on the
basis of a total return, measured by the upside potential (including dividends) over a 6 months
time horizon.
The ESN spectrum of recommendations (or ratings) for each stock comprises 5 categories:
Buy, Accumulate (or Add), Hold, Reduce and Sell (in short: B, A, H, R, S).
Banca Akros Ratings Breakdown • Buy: the stock is expected to generate a total return of over 15% during the
next 6 months time horizon.
• Reduce: the stock is expected to generate a total return of 0 to -15% during the
next 6 months time horizon
• Sell: the stock is expected to generate a total return below -15% during the
next 6 months time horizon
Page 11
Banca Akros
Viale Eginardo, 29
20149 Milano
Italy
Phone: +39 02 43 444 389 Bank Degroof
Fax: +39 02 43 444 302 Rue de I’Industrie 44
Caixa-Banco de Investimento
1040 Brussels
Rua Barata Salgueiro, 33-5
Belgium
1269-050 Lisboa
Phone: +32 2 287 91 16
Portugal
Fax: +32 2 233 99 97
Phone: +351 21 389 68 00
Fax: +351 21 389 68 98
Caja Madrid Bolsa
Equinet AG Serrano, 39
Gräfstraße 97 28001 Madrid
60487 Frankfurt am Main Spain
Tel: +49 69 – 58997 – 400 Phone: +34 91 436 7813
Fax:+49 69 – 58997 – 299 Fax: +34 91 577 3770
Egnatia Finance
CM - CIC Securities 8 Dragatsaniou Str.
Avenue de Provence 6 105 59 Athens
75441 Paris Cedex 09 Greece
France Phone: +302 10 32 79 200
Phone: +33 1 4596 7700 Fax: +302 10 32 48 694
Fax: +33 1 4596 7788