Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Examples of Clinical Cases in Learning Disorders
Examples of Clinical Cases in Learning Disorders
LEARNING
Pablo Cazau
The cases presented refer to schoolchildren who allegedly have learning problems. In each case the
clinical case is presented, then the multiaxial recording is indicated, and finally some additional
comments are made.
1 of 11
teacher reported that the girl speaks and reads poorly: "she eats the final s, uses one letter for
another," etc. The mother says that Rocío was always like this, and her husband and she thought that
she would grow out of it when she grew older, because the same thing had happened to another girl
they had known.
The teacher points out that Rocío's difficulty in speaking also causes her to read poorly, although she
writes relatively well and understands much of what she reads. Her difficulty speaking makes her feel
bad at school for not being able to make herself understood by her classmates, and sometimes her
mother caught her crying silently. She was examined by a neurologist two years ago and is perfectly
normal.
In the psychopedagogy service, an intelligence test was performed, resulting in an IQ = 62, and it was
considered that his speech problem could not be attributed to this low IQ. This IQ allows you to explain
your difficulties in understanding arithmetic problems and stories.
Rocío is a physically healthy girl, and her mother says that the move seems to have bothered her a lot
because she doesn't go to school with the same pleasure as before and she always misses her old
classmates. However, she became good friends with a neighbor who lives on the other block, and
whom she goes to visit every afternoon.
2 of 11
Consultation in November 1984, at 2 years and 9 months, referred by a psychologist due to lack of
language development, hyperactive and aggressive behavior. According to his parents, Gustavo began
to have such symptoms at the age of one and a half, coinciding with the birth of a cousin and the
mother's pregnancy; They accept that he was a hyperactive baby.
Father with sequelae of poliomyelitis. Born of normal pregnancy and childbirth, normal neonate. He
walked at 16 months and still had no sphincter control and only babbled some monosyllables or
unintelligible sounds. Normal neurological examination, normal skull X-ray, normal fundus. normal
EEG. Normal auditory evoked potentials. He had been medicated by a neurologist with CMZ, which had
a paradoxical effect.
Due to his behavior, lack of language and play difficulties, the psychologist's impression was that of a
psychotic child; however, during our consultation the child behaved more like a DCM. Given the
suspicion of the referring professional, no medication was instituted.
At 3 years and 2 months he controls his sphincters and develops gestural language. The suggestion for
speech support is postponed by the primary psychotherapist. 3-year-old kindergarten begins, where
according to the teacher report, correct integration occurs. Deficiencies remain in language and motor
clumsiness becomes evident in the neurological examination, while hyperactivity decreases slightly.
In 1986 he began working with a speech therapist who considered language delay as simple, with a
good prognosis; However, in that year, his difficulties in the garden became evident, with severe
attention and motor problems. Thinking of a DCM, he is medicated with Deanol.
In 1987, he studied again in a 4-year-old group, his graphics and language improved. Although the
latter passes into the speech therapy diagnosis of simple delay, it appears to be a cortical-type
phonological programming deficit. He continues in psychotherapy and psychopedagogical support is
suggested.
In 1988, preschool began; In April, following a comment from the mother, what until now was a
jealously guarded secret became evident: the existence of other delays in the family. A genetic study
is requested that reports the fragility of the X chromosome. Observing the family's genealogical tree,
one notices the randomness of the distribution of retardation, with variable mental disorders, all males.
In this case the transmission seems to originate via the maternal grandfather, which indicates the
confusing way in which this syndrome appears.
This tree is unfinished, since efforts are being made to carry out genetic studies on direct and indirect
relatives in order to finally reveal this jealously and unjustifiably kept secret.
The child continues to slowly improve in his hyperactivity, attention, motor skills and language.
Provides psychotherapy, speech therapy and psychopedagogy. He is promoted to 1st grade, currently
looking for the right school for him.
3 of 11
Luis is a child with no significant personal history, whose father is an epileptic who presents
generalized tonic-clonic and absence seizures. Both the paternal aunt and the grandfather are type G
epileptics. Evil.
He consulted in August 1983, at the age of 9, due to a state of absence for which he was admitted to
our service. His illness began when he was two years old, and his attacks were never completely
suppressed. He received Ethosuximide and Clonazepam. Near the consultation, he had been prescribed
Phenobarbital (FB), which apparently had precipitated the status crisis. The FB is suspended and the
patient is left on Ethosuximide and Valproic acid (VA), yielding the absence status.
This medication is continued and his seizures decrease from four to five attacks a day until they
completely disappear after 8 months of treatment. EEGs show typical spike-wave discharges during
hyperventilation up to a year after the disappearance of clinical seizures, although small absences not
detected by parents and teachers cannot be ruled out. The dosages of Ethosuximide and AV are in
therapeutic ranges.
In the period of disappearance of the crises, in the 4th grade, a teacher report indicates elements of
learning commitment and emotional: "regular learning, sometimes almost deficient with low
performance. He is a very distracted child which harms him considerably. "Cordial relationship with his
colleagues, very shy, cries when his mistakes are pointed out to him."
The normalization of the EEG, achieved in 5th grade, coincides with an improvement in their academic
performance; at this time the AV is suspended.
In 6th and 7th grade there is no crisis and there is good learning.
In 1987 he began industrial school with 3 years without clinical seizures and 2 with normal EEG. After
a good start, in June there is a deterioration in performance that coincides with separation from the
parents and the reappearance of typical spike-wave discharges during hyperventilation, without
apparent clinical manifestations. Repeat the year.
In March 1988, with the reconstitution of the couple, they returned to the consultation, Ethosuximide
was replaced by AV. The last control was carried out in August 1988, there were no absences, his
school performance was satisfactory and the EGG only showed slow waves during hyperventilation.
4 of 11
two grades behind. He began school at the age of five in a bilingual school where he had difficulty
learning to read. At seven years old he was just a very ordinary student. Then he suffered a choreic
condition that kept him in bed for three months and which became chronic. The choreic movements,
according to the parents, evolved in the form of chronic tics, of which there are many family histories.
Currently the child has the greatest problem with mathematics and is self-conscious. His hobbies are
painting, drawing, reading history, mineralogy, etc. His humanistic knowledge contrasts with his
difficulty in mathematics. In character, he is a child adapted to the family environment, perhaps a little
aggressive. He has few friends for his age, "because he retires rather than looking for them," and he
feels more comfortable with older people.
He is an only child. He grew up very healthy until Korea. He has always been clumsy in psychomotor
activities; Today it still inverts words and syllables. He is, like his father, left-handed. The parents are
both painters and, as artists, have given him a liberal education. The father identifies with the son
because, in addition to being left-handed, he considers himself slow in learning things; For
mathematics it was a real disaster. "Then I learned in seven days what I haven't learned in seven
years." José Manuel is very fond of drawing and painting, where he shows brilliant results.
During the psychological examination we found a cooperative child. His verbal expression is not very
fluid; It lacks rhythm and speaks like blows. He has multiple tics that are accentuated when we discuss
conflictive topics or he has to perform tasks that require concentration. Regarding his school failures,
they accentuate his difficulties in mathematics and his poor relationship with teachers, for all of which
he feels very guilty. What he likes least is mathematics and language. It narrates dreams with frankly
persecutory content. His behavior is very unstable.
His drawings are balanced and of great artistic quality. In his projections, a castrating relationship with
the maternal figure and identification difficulties with the paternal figure stand out.
On the WISC he obtains a total IQ of 115, with 101 on the verbal and 124 on the manipulative. There
is difficulty expressing oneself verbally. Their lowest scores are "comprehension", "arithmetic", and
"keys", with large discrepancies of up to 13 points between the various subtests.
In psychoneurological tests, Bender estimates visual-motor maturation, still slow, appropriate for his
age. The Galifret-Granjon laterality tests, even within the limits of ambidextrism, estimate a left-
handed predominance of the eye and hand, and a right-handed predominance of the foot. In the
Piaget-Head spatial orientation test, he found difficulties in recognizing the position of objects in space
relative to each other, reversing the left-right position. Mira-Stamback rhythm tests show no
abnormalities.
The Rorschach assesses an intratensive, rationalizing, oppositional attitude and psychological conflicts
with parental figures. All this together with a strong self with a good capacity to adapt.
5 of 11
She was born after an 8-month pregnancy and weighed 2500 g. Psychomotor patterns developed
normally. When he was three years old, his next sister was born: she reacted with jealousy, envy and
aggressive attitudes.
At school they say he has some signs of dyslexia. He is doing worse in English, although before that
was what he was better at, and in writing. If parents force her to pay attention, she does better. In
any case, he seems to be behind in school in almost everything. She is a very overprotected and self-
centered girl who has had a hard time adapting to schooling. The parents emphasize that the girl
shows great intelligence for life, which contrasts with her clumsy schooling. The mother is an unstable
personality who has been on antidepressant treatment and experiences the anorexia of another of her
children with great anxiety.
During the psychological examination, we found a harmonious and active girl, who seemed appropriate
to the situation, although somewhat childish for her age. Language is correctly developed and reading
is correct for his age. The writing shows dysgraphic signs such as directional reversals and phonetic
changes. His motor coordination is correct, but he becomes disorganized when he writes more quickly.
He explains the tics in his nose by saying that he does it because his nose is itchy and because he
doesn't scratch it.
His drawings are well structured and proportioned for his age, with no conflicting elements evident in
his projections. In the projective tests - Duss, Three Wishes and CAT-H - he projects his fraternal
rivalry, the experience of loss or inner emptiness and the desire for compensation.
The WISC estimates a total IQ of 108, with a 109 on the verbal scale and a 104 on the manipulative
scale. Its highest scores are in "similarities", from which a capacity for abstract-logical reasoning at a
ten-year-old level can be deduced, and the lowest in "incomplete figures", which place it at a six-year-
old level, which which could be pointing towards the existence of a perceptual, concentration and
attention problem.
In psychoneurological tests, ambidextrism and crossed eye-hand laterality (Galifret-Granjon) are
estimated. His right-left orientation -Piaget-Head- is slightly below his age. His motor speed is higher
than the average limits for his age and the rhythm tests - Mira - Stamback - show irregularities in
terms of excessive speed and abruptness. The Bender places her at the lower limit of the average
range of her age, corresponding to a visual-motor maturation of six years and six months.
The Rorschach shows an average intellectual level and some conflicts in relation to the maternal figure.
6 of 11
Parents describe him as an independent, irascible child and, in general, well adapted to the family and
school environment. It seems she suffered from labor anoxia. He had daytime enuresis until he was
five years old and nocturnal enuresis until he was seven. He was undergoing dyslexia re-education
treatment.
At school he gets better grades in mathematics and worse in natural sciences and language.
During the psychological examination we found a child who seemed friendly, smiling and cooperative.
In language it presents tonic-clonic arrests, which interrupt its course; Sometimes the arrests are so
intense that we have difficulty understanding what he is saying. It is a stutter. Its verbal expression is,
however, correct from a phonetic and grammatical point of view.
A lack of coordination is observed in the writing, remains of a dysgraphic picture. His reading level is
appropriate for his age. He does not express conflicting psychological themes, except those created by
his language difficulties.
The drawings he makes are very childish for his age and not very coordinated. Obsessive and
perfectionist traits can be seen in Corman's family. Those who relate best, according to their
projections, are the father and the son. He also projects fears in relation to the maternal figure, which,
in another drawing, he renders without arms.
The conflicts with the maternal figure also seem to be confirmed in the fables of Duss and the CAT-H.
He experiences his mother as not providing him with the emotional support he demands, which gives
rise to aggressive and self-destructive experiences.
On the WISC he has an IQ of 82, with a verbal score of 88 and a manipulative score of 79. In an
intertest analysis, significant differences are seen, with achievement levels ranging between 6 and 14
years. Their best score is in "arithmetic" and their worst, already below average, in "information",
"vocabulary", "comics" and "puzzles". In this last test, which measures shape memory, spatial
orientation and structuring, their performances correspond to those of six years old. His language
difficulties place him in a conflictive situation when faced with verbal tests, showing signs of insecurity,
anxiety and negativity. Their slowness and psychomotor clumsiness when organizing the tests in a
limited time undoubtedly negatively influence the results of the manipulative scale. The Raven General
Scale placed him in the 50th percentile.
In psychoneurological tests we found visual-motor maturation appropriate to his age -Bender-; a right-
left orientation -Piaget-Head- corresponding to a nine-year-old level, a consequence of a deficient
lateralization of the body scheme that is not intellectually compensated; In the laterality tests -
Galifret-Granjon - eye-hand ambidextrism and a right-handed predominance in lower limbs with great
clumsiness are observed; Their movements, within the ambidextrous category, correspond to 7 years;
In the rhythm tests -Mira- Stamback- a level corresponding to 7 years is estimated.
The psychomotor tests -Pic-Vayer- offer an 8-year level in manual coordination, being more precise
when performed with the left hand than with the right. General dynamic coordination is also at an 8-
year level. In postural control and balance it can reach a level of 9 years; However, he does the 8-
year-old level with difficulty, since this level requires staying on the balls of his feet.
The Rorschach shows a neurotic inhibition of thought and a tendency to escape into fantasies. Their
experiential type is limited and their adaptation to the environment is very reduced. There are also
depressive type traits, insecurity and anxiety.
7 of 11
found alterations in the verbal area -stuttering- and psychomotor areas important enough to justify his school
difficulties. The IQ estimated by the WISC does not correspond to their true intellectual possibilities, since both their
verbal and manipulative difficulties greatly increase their completion time; Hence, in another test like the Raven, in
which the incidence of these factors is limited, their score is average.
Stuttering, as in this case, usually coincides with poor lateralization, spatial organization and poor sense of rhythm.
Their better performance in mathematics is clearly reflected in the tests. The low scores in "information" and
"vocabulary" respond, without a doubt, both to their verbal difficulties and to the conflictive experiences involved in
any communication process. The low scores in "comics" and "puzzles", in addition to their poor understanding of
social situations, reveal their imperfect spatial organization. Both the psychoneurological and psychomotor tests
strikingly reflect the alterations in spatial organization, psychomotor and rhythm, which justify the dysgraphic
picture and the motor clumsiness that he always showed.
The condition, as a whole, could be diagnosed as minimal brain dysfunction, because although we do not know the
existence of any certain brain insult, there are antecedents compatible with it and, above all, the symptoms found
are those of a child with brain damage.
There is also a whole emotional conflict, we do not know if it is a condition of some aspects of the condition or just
a result of it, which further reduces the child's performance."
Source: Monedero C., "Evolutionary Psychopathology", Labor Universitaria, Barcelona, 1982.
8 of 11
In the Rorschach, a type of personality is found with a low level of structuring and control, which
prevents better contact with the outside world, with a predominance of hypomanic mechanisms and
instability factors.
9 of 11
pedagogical diagnosis. He didn't repeat it but he "scraped by." The neurological studies revealed
nothing although, according to the mother, they spoke to her of a certain degree of immaturity. They
recommended treatment but he stopped because improvements occurred after 2 or 3 months.
He continued well until fourth grade, when he began to have to take exams. He always had a private
teacher. It was difficult for him to learn to read and his difficulties always appeared in the area of
Language.
He never had problems with social integration at school, he was very talkative although, according to
the teacher, somewhat distracted and reluctant to do his homework.
10 of
11