BERLIN CRISIS

Some New Insights

By Neil Carmichael and Brewer Thompson

The 1961
F
ifty years ago, talks between the United States and the Soviet Union broke down over the status of Berlin, capital of the defeated and divided Germany. At the end of World War II, Germany was divided into occupation zones, with each allythe United States, France, Great Britain, and the Soviet Union in control of a zone. Berlin was in the Soviet sector, but it was agreed that it, too, would be divided, and the Soviets would allow the other allies access to it. By the end of the 1950s, however, the Soviets wanted the other allies out of Berlin. They refused, and tensions escalated over the next few years.
Right: President Kennedy meets with Chairman Khrushchev at the U. S. embassy residence in Vienna, Austria, June 3, 1961.

46 Prologue

Fall 2011

When Soviet Premier Nikita Khrushchev met the new U.S. President, John F. Kennedy, in Geneva in June 1961, he reiterated his desire for the western allies to leave West Berlin and proposed a peace treaty on Soviet terms. The Western allies, however, had no intention of giving up their right of access to Berlin. In early August 1961, the Soviet-controlled East Germans began cutting off all avenues of escape to West Berlinthe 97 miles surrounding the city and the 27 miles that cut through the heart of the city. The Soviets and East Germans moved in with a massive show of force, and Kennedy called 148,000 National Guardsmen and Reservists to active duty. And the East Germans began to build a wall,

a tangible symbol of what Winston Churchill had called the iron curtain dividing Sovietcontrolled Eastern Europe and Western Europe. Once the wall was up, the access checkpoints became points of contention. On October 27, 1961, the Soviets deployed 10 tanks on their side of Checkpoint Charlie, and U.S. and Soviet tanks stood a mere 100 yards apart from each other. The confrontation made headlines around the world, and until Moscow and Washington mutually agreed to pull back, it looked as if the Cold War would become hot. Throughout the summer of 1961, the story unfolded in dozens of reports, meetings, and discussions on an Allied response against a backdrop of possible nuclear war.

Roughly 500 recently declassified documents will be published jointly by the National Archives and Records Administrations National Declassification Center and the Central Intelligence Agencys Historical Publications Office and distributed in conjunction with a conference on A City Torn Apart: Building the Berlin Wall at the National Archives in Washington, D.C., on October 27, 2011. The Berlin Wall would stand for another 28 years before the people of East Germany would peacefully rise up and regain their freedom. All documents declassified in accordance with E.O. 13526

A section of the Berlin Wall. As the wall wove through the city, it was often a series of barriers and obstructions with watchtowers and checkpoints.

48 Prologue

Fall 2011

A Department of State memorandum of April 13, 1961, summarized a meeting with the President on contingency plans in the event of a blockade of Berlin.The President was concerned about commitment and concerted actionhow the United Kingdom, France, and West Germany, as well as the United States, would respond to the pressures which may arise. Memo of Conversation re: Berlin Contingency Planning and Related Matters, April 13, 1961; Policy Planning Council; Subject Files, 19541962; General Records of the Department of State; Record Group 59.

Below: An August 11 summary reports Ambassador George F. Kennans belief that the time might be right for an acceptable deal
over Berlin. Kennan felt that the United States was misreading Khrushchevs overbearing posture and believed the Soviet premier respected U.S. might and sought a way out. Interview with Ambassadors Kennan and Thompson, August 11; Berlin Germany Group 1961; Policy Planning Council; Subject Files, 19541962; General Records of the Department of State; Record Group 59.

A State Department analysis of the June 4 Kennedy-Khrushchev meeting reported on the Soviet premiers hard stance, that his nation would defend any violation of the German Democratic Republics borders on land, sea, or in the air, thus cutting access to West Berlin. Kennedy responded that the USSR was presenting him with the alternative of accepting the Soviet Unions action on Berlin or having to face confrontation. United States Department of State. Historical Studies Division (February 1970). Crisis Over Berlin, American Policy Concerning the Soviet Threats to Berlin November 1958December 1962. Part V. Developments in the Early Phase of the Kennedy Administration and the Meeting with Khrushchev at Vienna, January-June 1961 (Research Project 614-E). Washington, D.C.

50 Prologue

Fall 2011

Above: A report on construction of the Berlin Wall, begun in August 1961, describes it as a system of barriers and obstructions not always parallel to the sector boundary and most formidable in the densely populated central core of Berlin. East German officials, it noted, planned to clear a 100-meter-wide strip along the East Berlin side of the wall. The Berlin Wall; Berlin Handbook; p. 11; Executive Secretariat: Records Relating to the Berlin Crisis, 19611962; General Records of the Department of State; Record Group 59. Above right: A confidential report on information gathered from wouldbe refugees attempting to escape during the early months of the Berlin Wall notes the assistance of East German guards, the use of borrowed passports at checkpoints, and an order to shoot at escapees. Summary of Reports Given by Refugees During the Period September 28October 5, 1961; Bureau of European Affairs, Country Director for Germany: Records Relating to Berlin and East German Affairs, 19571968; Lot 70D4; General Records of the Department of State; Record Group 59. Right: A U.S. Army Intelligence Summary of early November 1961 reports the presence of two Soviet battalions of 122mm Howitzers near Berlin and that several one-story barracks were being constructed near August Bebel Platz. ISUM #13a; pg.1; Berlin Brigade; Intelligence Reports, 19541962; Records of United States Army, Europe; Record Group 549.

With the threat of an East German shutdown of the last access point to East Berlin, a Berlin Command Op Plan for November 1961 recorded the plan to demolish any barriers and knock down the wall and any associated obstacles along the U.S.-Soviet Sector.The document also recorded British, French, and West German police patrol activities. BC Op Plan 3-7; pg. 1; Berlin Command Ops Plans 1961; Berlin Brigade; Operations Planning Files, 19541965; Records of United States Army, Europe; Record Group 549.
52 Prologue Fall 2011