Sie sind auf Seite 1von 6

Must Reads: BP's New License to Drill | New t Endorser: OWS is a Muslim Brotherhood Plot!

| Europe's Real Problem | House Panel to Vote on "Internet Censorship" Search

Ene rgy, Environme nt, He alth, I nte rnational

There's No Hiding From Tar Sands Oil

Keystone XL pipeline or no, America is awash with the dirty oil from Canada. Here's our interactive map revealing the refineries near you.
By T im McDonnell | T h u Dec. 1 5 , 2 0 1 1 1 2 :2 0 PM PST

Your em ail

Tw eet




Recent debate over the Keystone XL oil pipeline has turned a spotlight on Canada's controversial and oil-rich tar sands, which would be the source of crude oil flowing through the pipe to the Gulf of Mexico. Tar sands oil has faced stiff criticism from environmental groups, which say that it's far dirtier than its Middle Eastern counterpart despite claims from the Canadian government and industry groups that they keep a close
An oil refinery in Edmont on, Albert a bulliver/Flickr
Adve rtise on Mothe rJone

eye on environmental impact.

But long before the Keystone XL became a cause clbre, tar sands oil was already ubiquitous in America: It goes to fuel our cars and corporations' trucking fleets, and it's used in the production of products from aluminum cans to asphalt. Starting last year, San Franciscobased environmental advocacy group Forest Ethics launched a campaign to encourage American companies to boycott tar sands oil and, specifically, the refineries that process it (below).

The 1 Percent , Rev ealed

The supe rrich ha ve dra wn a cle a r line in the sa nd be twe e n the m se lve s a nd e ve rybody e lse . How did we ge t he re ? By Barbara Ehrenreich and John Ehrenreich

There's No Hiding From Tar Sands Oil

Ke ystone XL pipe line or no, Am e rica is a wa sh with the dirty oil from C a na da . He re 's our inte ra ctive m a p re ve a ling the re fine rie s ne a r you. T im McDonnell

Jersey Score: Inside Mit t Romney s Million-Dollar Dinner

The priva te confa b ha d m usic by Springste e n a nd Bon Jovi, che e rle a ding by C hris C hristie , a nd pra ise from a R om ne y donor for O ba m a 's he a lth ca re policy. Michael T racey

Using data from the federal Energy Information

Michael T racey

Administration (which tracks imports of unprocessed crude oil), Forest Ethics compiled a list of nearly 50 US refineries that handle tar sands oil (MoJo made the above map based on that list). In these refineries, the heavy, molasses-like "bitumen" from the tar sands undergoes heating, blending, and other refining steps and comes out as useable fuel, ready to be pumped into a long-haul semi. What the map shows, Forest Ethics campaign director Aaron Sanger said, is that "unless you take action to take tar sands oil out of your footprint, you've got it in your footprint." By "you," of course, Sanger doesn't mean you, dear reader: When you fill up at the local gas station, there's really no way to know from which refinery your fuel is coming. (Chances are it has been blended from several before reaching the pump.) Instead, he's referring to companies whose in-house or contracted trucking fleets buy fuel in bulk directly from refineries or through a broker (known as a "jobber" in industry parlance). Forest Ethics has persuaded 14 such companies, including Trader Joe's, Whole Foods, and LUSH Cosmetics, and Chiquita, to downsize their transportation footprint, in part by avoiding fuel from any of the refineries on the map. "You and I as individuals don't have much leverage over the fuel sources," Sanger said. "But big companies do." At stake is a serious chunk of change: The tar sands industry was worth $13.4 billion in 2009 (down from $20.5 billion in 2008), and oil from Alberta, the western Canadian province the tar sands call home, made up 15 percent of American crude imports, according to statistics from the Albertan government. Consequently, applying that leverage is no easy task. Over the last couple years, Sanger and colleagues have reached out to 200 big companies, and in every instance when one agreed to investigate its fuel sourcing, there was tar sands oil in the mix, he said. TA Travel Centers, a major "over-the-road" fuel supplier to trucking fleets, found that it buys fuel directly from a quarter of the refineries on the map. For companies on the Forest Ethics list like Walgreens, cutting tar sands oil out means negotiating with fuel brokers and/or truck refilling stations and the possibility of not renewing contracts with those who are unable or unwilling to avoid tar sands oil. Sanger said that Trader Joe's, for example, has made avoidance of tar sands oil a contractual obligation for its distributors. On top of all that, there's the issue of bad press. The oil industry is an economic behemoth in Alberta; according to the Albertan government, it employs some 136,000 people and constitutes roughly 30 percent of Alberta's GDP. Boycotting tar sands oil means turning a cold shoulder to potential customers in the region, which some companies have been loath to do. Last year, a handful of companies (including The Gap and Levi Strauss) lashed back at Forest Ethics for being included on the anti-tar-sands list, claiming that although they were investigating their fuel sources, they weren't necessarily giving the ax to the tar sands. ("We do not take a position opposing or supporting any fuel or energy source from any country or geography," a Levi Strauss spokesperson said then). Earlier this year, an Albertan business advocacy nonprofit called Alberta Enterprise Group (AEG) launched a counter-boycott campaign on Facebook, calling Forest Ethics' bluff and urging Canadians not to buy products from businesses who have agreed to cut out tar sands oil. Companies with an interest in Albertan business "ought to think twice about discriminating against Alberta's energy," said AEG Vice President David MacLean. "We want to push back on behalf of Albertans who benefit from this industry."
First name Mother Jones' reporters were on the front lines all yeargetting pepper-sprayed at protests, poring through legislation to expose hidden attacks on reproductive rights, and risking their lives to document human rights abuses. Now they need your help. Even $5 will make a difference. Please give to the Mother Jones Investigative Fund as we gear up for this important election year.
Advertise on

Baby Seal Breaks Int o Home | Mot her Jones

Mo ther Jo nes

Home From Iraq, Vet erans Seen as Perfect Candidat es for Green Jobs - Aust in B. Smit h Life - The At lant ic

2C or not 2C: That is t he quest ion about t he Durban deal | Grist

Gris t

Science journalism guidelines might be a good idea - Slat e Magazine


Copenhagen's Trash Incinerat or Ski Slope Is Dead - Design - The At lant ic Cit ies
theatlanticcities .co m


The 1 Percent , Rev ealed

The superrich have drawn a clear line in the sand between themselves and everybody else. How did we get here?

Baby Seal Breaks Int o Home

This burst of extreme cuteness comes to you all the way from Welcome Bay, New Zealand.

Meet t he Financial Wizards Working Wit h Occupy Wall St reet

The bankers, quants, and hedge fund gurus who want to reform our financial systemby helping OWS kick ass.

No Count ry for Innocent Men

How a rapist's confession forced Rick Perry, champion of Texas justice, to pardon a dead man.

kate_sheppard: Police Seize Computers in "Climategate" Investigation kate_sheppard: "If this is w hat happens w hen 'traditional' families are destroyed by gay couples, then sign me up." kate_sheppard: Gingrich Endorses Zygote Personhood G6Qh

MacLean added that good environmental stewardship has always been a component of the oil sands industry. But projections from Canada's environmental ministry point to an estimated 740,000 acres of boreal forest being chopped down over the next decade to make way for tar sands development, and some estimates peg the carbon footprint of tar sands oil extraction at up to 70 percent higher than other crude oil sources.
Last name Address C ity

up to 70 percent higher than other crude oil sources. Moreover, environmental groups have raised concerns about negative health impacts in the neighborhoods surrounding refineries that process tar sands oil and even at the extraction sites themselves: A few years ago, MoJo reporter Josh Harkinson described seeing his small airplane reflected in "a shimmering reservoir of oil waste" near Alberta's Athabasca River. Tar sands oil is much heavier than conventional oil and, to ease transportation to refineries via pipeline, it must be watered down at the extraction site with a natural gas byproduct that is later burned off in the refining process. At the same time, sulfur (with which tar sands oil is notoriously loaded) and a slew of heavy metals are extracted and either sold off or released into the environment. A December 2010 Sierra Club report linked tar sands refineries emissions to prenatal brain damage, asthma, and emphysema, and it also suggested a disproportionate placement of tar sands refineries in low-income minority neighborhoods. "We do believe that tar sands refineries are dirtier and more dangerous" than other refineries, Sanger said. In any case, there's little disagreement that avoiding tar sands oil is a sticky situation for American consumers. MacLean even scoffed at the basic premise of the Forest Ethics push to cut tar sands oil from supply lines: "I think that's technically impossible." Still, Sanger said, pressure from consumers on big trucking companies like UPS and FedExand the retailers who rely on themcould help rein in our dependence on the tar sands. Convincing truckers to drop tar sands oil could in turn convince refineries to drop it too. "Let's contain it," he said. "Let's not let this problem get outside the regions where it already is." Tim McDonnell is an editorial fellow at Mother Jones. For more of his stories, click here. Follow him on Twitter or send him an email at tmcdonnell [at] motherjones [dot] com. Get Tim McDonnell's RSS feed.




Your Em ail Let MoJo send our best stories to y our inbox three tim es a w eek.

Tw eet




Meet t h e T a r Sa n ds PR Wi za r d
Ezra Levant spins tar sands crude as ethical oilwith the same tricks he used in his tobacco lobbyist days.

T a r Sa n ds Pr om ot er s T u r n t o Opr a h Fa n s for Su ppor t Nor t h A m er i ca 's T a r Sa n ds: T h e New Mi ddl e Ea st

Its either a "yes" or a "no" for the climate-killing Keystone XL oil pipelineand Obama gets to make the call.

Fi r st T a r Sa n ds Mi n e A ppr ov ed In US En er gy Is Ugl y : T a r Sa n ds Edi t i on

Oil imported from Canada's tar sands has twice the environmental cost of normal crude. Did we mention that they're our biggest supplier?

Y our Email

Showing 7 comments
Sort by Oldest first Subscribe by em ail Subscribe by RSS

Gdm ac Today 12:41 PM

America the beautiful.tar sands, coal soot, crude, fracking fluids, pipe and pow er lines w ith breathtaking view s of refineries.damn! w hy am I not feeling better? must be aftereffects of that acid rain w e had years agow heres my plastic coffee cup


Ma r cu s_fr om _t h e_Nor t h a n d 2 m or e lik ed t h is



AGW Today 12:50 PM

Cheer up. BP got drilling permits! Flag

1 per son lik ed t h is. Like Reply

Uber Snotling Today 01:24 PM

Isn't a better strategy to reduce America's use of energy through conservation and education efforts? W hile tar sands oil is dirtier than other oil, it isn't like oil is ever going to be clean and if one company doesn't buy it, someone else w ill. The best w ay to influence the market is to drive the cost for gasoline dow n, since oil sands extraction is relatively expensive compared to other options at this time.

Of course in ten to tw enty years, most oil sources w ill be in hard-to-reach places w ith larger environmental impacts. The overall goal should be to reduce fossil fuel use, not to target a type of fossil fuel w hich is essentially interchangeable in use w ith other fossil fuels. Flag
Ma r cu s_fr om _t h e_Nor t h a n d 2 m or e lik ed t h is Like Reply

Marcus_from _the_North Today 02:00 PM

I w orked for both of the oil refineries right outside of the Tw in Cities.. Pine Bend[ ("Koch Oil")yes the same dufus kids that inherited billions from daddy] in Rosemount MN. and Marathon Oil (Super America) in St. Paul Park MN.. The refinery is Rosemount, MN is designed to crack sulfur from sour crude oil.. The place stinks like shit and all of the trees w ithin a 5 mile radius of the place are stunted in grow th.. The refinery in St. Paul Park, MN. is a decrepit piece of shit that is human death trap.. Not only do they manufacture hydrofluoric acid that is piped to the 3M plant right dow n the freew ay, but the place is also ready to burst into a ball of Hellfire.. Shithole, shithole, shithole!!! w as out there w hen a lighting strike blew up a holding tank and killed a guy but I also saw some unfortunate fool get his leg snapped like a tw ig from a refinement vessel shock absorber... Flag
Like Reply

Stoney jack Today 02:07 PM

W e need an "all-of-the-above" effort to supply our energy needs, provide much-needed jobs, and assure our national security. Don't listen to tree-huggers, AlGorites, Hollyw ood humming-birds, & latte-liberals w ho float in the Zone. This is about real people. Get that Keystone XL pipeline up & running. Flag
Like Reply

Marcus_from _the_North Today 02:25 PM

So piping Canadian oil to Houston Texas to be sold in the Chinese marketplace is a great solution for job recovery??? Like I usually do to all of your post Stoney I am going to pull the "bullshit" card on you... Flag
Like Reply

Gnom o Today 02:19 PM

the oil belongs to the Goverment and the oil payment should go to the Goverment and not to those backw ard racist in the South, The oil companys should be confascated by the Goverment and ow ned by the people. This is enough, those Southern rubes are killing Mother Earth. Flag
Like Reply

Add New Comment

Post as

MoJo Troll Patrol encourages readers to sign in with Facebook, Twitter, Google, Yahoo, Disqus, or OpenID to comment. Please read our comment policy before posting.

Optional: Sign In to

Sponsored Links

Groupon Deals
Save in hundreds of cities worldwide w/ the original daily deal site!
w w w

Mortgage Refinance at 2.50%

$200,000 mortgage for $699/month. See Lower Payment NOW - No SSN Reqd.
Buy a link here

Pot Shots: How to Sm oke Medical Marijuana

Portraits of patients in the act of inhaling.

"2nd T our, Hope I Don't Die"

The chaos and humanity of war.

T hese Haiti Photos Will Make Y our Heart Stop

Exclusive images from a country searching for stability.

Ev ery thing Must Go

Dark times and dead malls.

A bout Us Jobs Contact Us Priv acy Policy

Make a Donation Leav e A Legacy Ben Bagdikian Fellowship Terms of Serv ice

A dv ertise Press Subscribe Ev ents

Copyright 2011 Mother Jones and the Foundation for National Progress. All Rights Reserved. - Inmate Search

C rim ina l re cords, insta nt public re cords & pe ople se a rch & curre nt court re cords.

Real Viagra, Cialis Levitra Deal

Se cure , Discre e t a nd R e lia ble . Da re to com pa re our com pe titive price s.

U.S. Public Records Search

Se a rch C ounty & Sta te C ourt R e cords, C rim ina l re cords, Vita l a nd Adoption R e cords

A tre a sure trove of libe ra l wit, wisdom a nd quota tions, from a ncie nt to m ode rn, on colorful, cotton te e s. - People Search

Support Independent Artists

P ublic R e cords a nd Ba ck ground C he ck s. Insta ntly Se a rch C rim ina l R e cords, Addre sse s a nd C ourt R e cords

Am a zing a rt, cra fts, a ppa re l, pa pe r-goods a nd m ore . A ca re fully cura te d se le ction of sundrie s since 1999.


Court Records & County Records

Find Insta nt P ublic R e cords, C rim ina l R e cords a s W e ll a s C ounty P rope rty R e cords Se a rch.

Me e t progre ssive single s in the e nvironm e nta l, ve ge ta ria n & a nim a l rights com m unity who sha re your va lue s