Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
r
X
i
v
:
h
e
p
-
t
h
/
0
7
0
1
2
1
0
v
2
2
F
e
b
2
0
0
7
Domain wall cosmology and multiple
accelerations
Bum-Hoon Lee
,1
, Wonwoo Lee
2
, Siyoung Nam
3
, and Chanyong Park
4
. We shall
denote the two sides of as
. We
assume that each metric in the bulk M
+
A
(1)
where each A
g (R 2), (4)
S
GH
=
1
2
_
d
D
x
hK, (5)
S
DW
=
_
d
D
x
hL
DW
. (6)
We set
2
= 8G and cosmological constants. n
= g
. K = h
ij
K
ij
is the trace
of the extrinsic curvature K
ij
= h
k
i
h
l
j
k
n
l
on
. S
EH
is the ordinary
Einstein-Hilbert action. For a good variational problem we must include
the Gibbons-Hawking action S
GH
[20]. Varying S
EH
with respect to each
3
bulk metric generates boundary terms which contain normal derivatives of
the metric variations and their presence will spoil the variational principle
leading to Einsteins equations. The terms from the metric variations of S
GH
exactly cancel the boundary terms of the normal derivatives of the metric in
S
EH
[21]. Due to discontinuities of K
need not cancel each other. Thus we need a domain wall action. In general,
when the gravitational back-reaction of a domain wall is included, the global
causal structure of the resulting spacetime is usually modied. For simplicity,
we assume that no bulk elds do not couple to the domain wall, whose world
volume can be described as a Nambu-Goto action
S
DW
=
_
d
D
x
h (7)
where is a parameter which corresponds to a tension or energy density of
the wall . There can be no transfer of energy between the bulk matter and
the wall because the energy density of the wall is xed. In this case, the
stress-energy tensor of the domain wall is proportional to the walls induced
metric tensor h
ij
. Now the metric variations of the total action S
total
give
the Israels junction equations
[K
ij
] =
2
_
S
ij
1
D 1
Sh
ij
_
(8)
where a stress tensor of the wall, tangential to the domain wall, is dened by
S
ij
2
h
S
DW
h
ij
. (9)
With S
ij
= h
ij
, then the junction equations take a simple form
[K
ij
] =
D
h
ij
(10)
where
D
=
8G
D+1
D 1
. (11)
For applications of the junctions equations, we assume that each bulk has a
spherical symmetry such that the bulk metric has the form
ds
2
= H(R)dT
2
+
dR
2
H(R)
+R
2
d
2
D1
(12)
4
where
H(R) 1 AR
2
Bw
D
G
D+1
M
R
D2
, (13)
w
D
16
(D 1)V
D1
, (14)
V
D1
2
D/2
(D/2)
, (15)
and M is a black hole mass if any. The parameters represent the followings
: If a bulk resembles a black hole-like one, B = 1. Otherwise, B is zero.
The constant A is related with a cosmological constant, so that A = e/L
2
=
2e/D(D 1) with e = +1 for dS space and e = 1 for AdS space. We
choose a positive direction so that makes the radial coordinate with xed
angular components increase. Due to the spherical symmetry, the induced
metric on the wall can be rewritten as
ds
2
wall
= d
2
+r()
2
d
2
D1
(16)
where is the proper time of the world line of the observer on the wall and
satisfy the relation
d
2
= H(r)dt
2
1
H(r)
dr
2
(17)
with our convention that the bulk coordinates on the position corresponding
to the domain wall use lowercase letters. We will interpret the radial coordi-
nate of the domain wall as a scale factor r() from the viewpoint of the wall
observers. At this point, we introduce the Gauss normal coordinates near
the wall , which require
g
= g
= 1. (18)
In these coordinates, the extrinsic curvatures take very simple forms
K
= K
= =
_
r
2
+H(r)
r
(19)
K
=
_
r
2
+H(r)
_
r +
1
2
dH(r)
dr
_
(20)
at the location of the wall R = R(r()). If the spherical surface area in-
creases with the radial coordinate, = +1 and = 1 otherwise. The dot
5
represents a derivative with respect to the proper time of an observers
worldline on the wall. Note that the angular parts of the extrinsic curvature
are diagonalized and have the same value at each point of the wall due to
the spherical symmetry. Plugging (19) into (10) results in the equation
out
_
r
2
+H
out
(r)
in
_
r
2
+H
in
(r) =
D
r, (21)
or
r
2
(H
out
H
in
)
2
4
2
D
r
2
1
4
2
D
r
2
+
1
2
(H
out
+H
in
) = 0 (22)
where the subscripts out(or +) and in(or ) represent the outer side and the
inner side of the wall respectively. After a short algebra with the explicit
forms of H
2
D
+
2
D
+ 2(A
out
+A
in
)
_
G
D+1
w
D
4r
D2
_
(A
out
A
in
)(B
out
M
out
B
in
M
in
)
2
D
+ (B
out
M
out
+B
in
M
in
)
_
G
2
D+1
w
2
D
(B
out
M
out
B
in
M
in
)
2
8
2
D
r
2D2
. (24)
This equation of motion describes a ctitious particle moving under the eec-
tive potential V (r) with the energy
1
2
analogous to a 1-dimensional classical
particle of energy E inuenced by the potential V , which we know how to
deal very well. The remaining thing is classifying the allowed solutions of
the wall under the given eective potential. The strategy is as follows. At
rst, we start to nd out the possible shapes of the potential by collecting
information about the extreme values of the potential. The second, we sim-
ply compare the extreme values of the potential with the energy 1/2. If
the maximum of the potential is always lower than 1/2, then we call the
motion of the wall as a monotonic motion because it expands monotonically
without bounds. If there is a region in which the potential is higher than the
energy of the wall, the walls motion will also be restricted. In this case, if
the wall has a maximum(minimum) radius to which it expands, we call the
corresponding solution as a bounded(bounce) solution whose meaning is
clear.
6
3 Classications of the wall motions
Now, consider the junction equation describing the connection between a
maximally symmetric spacetime at center and a black hole type spacetime
in the outside region. In general, the junction equation is given by
in
_
r
2
+H
in
out
_
r
2
+H
out
=
D
r (25)
with
H
in
= A
in
r
2
+ 1
H
out
= A
out
r
2
+ 1
Bw
D
G
D+1
M
r
D2
. (26)
Though the solution of the junction equation is obtained from solving (24),
we can nd some constraints for the region of r from (25). Since the tension
is positive and r runs form 0 to , depending on the sign of the region
of r having a solution is restricted:
1)
in
=
out
= 1
Having a solution, the position of the wall is located at the restricted region
r
D
<
Bw
D
G
D+1
M
A
in
Aout+
2
D
, where we set A
in
A
out
to a positive number.
2)
in
=
out
= 1
In this case, the region of the wall position is restricted as r
D
>
Bw
D
G
D+1
M
A
in
Aout
2
D
.
3)
in
=
out
= 1
The wall is located at the region
Bw
D
G
D+1
M
A
in
Aout+
2
D
< r
D
<
Bw
D
G
D+1
M
A
in
Aout
2
D
in r-
direction.
4)
in
=
out
= 1
In this case, there is no region having a solution.
When solving (24), the above restricted region corresponding to each case
is also considered.
3.1 (D+1)-dimensional M-SAdS Junction
In this section we consider the M-SAdS type junction which is described by
the parameters
A
out
=
2
out
D(D 1)
, B
out
= 1 , M
out
= M , and the others zero. (27)
7
A positively-dened quantity
+
is related to the vacuum energy of the outer
SAdS space. For convenience, we introduce the ratios among the parameters
by
u
1
2
out
D(D 1)
and v
m
(D1)
D
(28)
where
m = (D 1)w
D
G
D+1
M (29)
roughly corresponds to the mass density proportional to the black hole mass
divided by the volume of the unit sphere S
D1
. The eective potential (24)
becomes to
V (r) =
1
8
(u
2
1)
2
2
D
r
2
+
v(u
2
1)
D
4r
D2
v
2
8r
2D2
=
1
8
_
(u
2
1)
D
r
v
r
D1
_
2
(30)
Therefore, the scheme of classifying the possible wall motion of M SAdS
junction can depend on the signs of u and v.
3.1.1 u > 1
The value of the eective potential asymptotically diverges to as the
radial coordinate goes to zero or innity. This means that there exists one
critical point at which the potential has a maximum value. The point is
given by
r
D
c
=
v
D
(u
2
1)
, (31)
at which the potential really has a maximum value equal to zero. Therefore,
the motions of the wall are limited to the bounded one or the bounce one(Fig.
1(a)). In the bounce solution, the late time behavior of the solution(large r)
is
r e
D
(u
2
1)
2
(32)
independent of m.
3.1.2 u = 1
The eective potential is
V (r) =
v
2
8r
2D2
. (33)
8
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
0.5
1
r
V
/
1
0
0
0
0
(a) u > 1 bounded and bounce solutions
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
1
0.5
0
0.5
r
V
(b) u=1 bounded solution
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
0.5
r
V
(c) u<1 monotonic solution
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
0.5
r
V
(d) u<1 bounded and bounce solution
Figure 1: Classication of the possible motions of the wall in the 5 dimen-
sional M-SAdS junction. We set w
4
G
5
M = 1 in all case for simplicity. (a)
u = 50 and
4
= 1 (b) u = 1 and
4
= 10 (c) u = 0.2 and
4
= 1 (d) u = 0.4
and
4
= 2.5.
9
The only allowed solution of the junction equation is a bounded type(Fig.1(b)),
which can expand to a maximum radius
r
max
=
_
v
2
_ 1
D1
(34)
and then shrink. In terms of r
max
, the potential can be rewritten by
V =
1
2
_
r
max
r
_
2D2
(35)
and the trajectory r = r() of the wall can be found by integrating
=
_
r()
r(0)
dr
_
_
rmax
r
_
2(D1)
1
(36)
and getting the inverse of it. Around the origin the behavior of the radius of
the wall is
r
_
Dr
D1
max
_ 1
D
. (37)
3.1.3 u < 1
The eective potential of this case resembles the shape of the u > 1 case. A
extreme point of the potential occurs at
r
D
c
=
(D1)v
D
(1 u
2
)
. (38)
V (r
c
) corresponds to the maximum of the curve of the eective potential
and is always negative. Therefore, the possible solutions can be classied by
comparing V (r
c
) and the energy of the virtual one-particle. If V (r
c
) < 1/2,
then a monotonic motion is possible(Fig. 1(c)). If V (r
c
) > 1/2 , then a
bounced or bounded motion is allowed(Fig. 1(d)).
3.1.4 Summary of the M-SAdS Junction
We can classify the wall motions under the M-SAdS junctions by u, v and
D
. The extreme points r
c
are the solutions of the ordinary second equation
with respect to the variable r
D
c
. The classication corresponds to the regions
separated by surfaces in the 3-dimensional parameter space (
D
, u, v). For
10
u > 1, the allowed solutions are bounded or bounce ones. For u = 1, the
possible solution is limited to a bounded type. For u < 1, we need further
information about v and
D
to classify the wall motions completely in this
parameters ranges. We found that all the 3-type motions are allowed in that
case.
3.2 (D+1)-Dimensional AdS-SAdS Junctions
We set
H
out
= 1 +
2
out
D(D 1)
R
2
w
D
G
D+1
M
R
D2
, (39)
H
in
= 1 +
2
in
D(D 1)
R
2
. (40)
For simplicity, we introduce another parameter ratio
w
1
2
in
D(D1)
. (41)
According to (24), the eective potential is given by
V (r) =
1
8
2
D
r
2
+
D
v
4r
D2
v
2
8r
2D2
(42)
where
=
2
4w
2
and = u
2
w
2
1. (43)
Thus, the classication corresponds to divide the 4-dimensional parameter
space (
D
, u, v, w) into regions by the judicious surfaces of the parameters.
The regions described by the curves u > w in the u w plane represent the
junctions of the true-false vacuum type. Since we want to concentrate on
the false-true vacuum types, the regions with positive are discarded. To
see this, note that u = w are asymptotes of the hyperbola = 0 in u w
plane. In this section, we have always the condition 0 < u < w in mind. We
also set every parameters to be positive. Of course, we could deal with the
cases allowing the negative ranges of the parameters but that simply results
in the mirror image with respect to the appropriate axes or curves in the
u w plane. In this paper, we ignore the possibilities of those regions and
the physical meanings of the negative range of the parameters.
11
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5
4
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
0.5
1
r
V
u=0.25, w=0.5, v=1/64
u=0.25, w=0.5, v=0.25
(a) Positive
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5
4
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
0.5
1
r
V
u=1, w=2, v=1
(b) Zero
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
r
V
u=0.5, w=1, v=1
(c) Negative
Figure 2: Classifying the possible motions of the wall in the AdS-SAdS junc-
tion by
12
3.2.1 > 0
The condition > 0 is translated into < 2w(Fig. 2(a)). There are two
regions in u w plane. The rst region is surrounded by
0 < u < w and u +w 1 < 0 (44)
and the second is enclosed by the curves
0 < u < w and u w + 1 < 0. (45)
From the analysis of the asymptotic behaviors of the eective potential, it is
expected that the potential have only one extreme point r
c
. By an explicit
calculation, we nd that it really does so that the extreme point is
r
D
c
=
v
2
D
_
(D 2) +
_
(D 2)
2
2
+ 4(D1)
_
, (46)
at which the potential has a maximum. The solutions in the ranges of these
parameters can be classied by comparing the value of the maximum of the
potential V (r
c
) and the energy. If V (r
c
) is greater than the energy, the
motion of the wall can be either bounded or bounced type. Otherwise, the
possible motion of it should be a monotonic one.
3.2.2 = 0
The condition = 0(Fig. 2(b)) corresponds to a straight line
u =| w 1 | (47)
for 1/2 < w except a point (u, w) = (0, 1). Therefore, two dierent modes
may exist. One corresponds to w u = 1 and the other corresponds to
w +u = 1. From the analysis of the potential, it is easy to see that there is
only a bounded motion of the wall.
3.2.3 < 0
The negative means that is in the range
2w < < 0, (48)
13
which corresponds to a strip in the u w plane surrounded by
0 < u < w and u =| w 1 | (49)
for 1/2 < w except a point (u, w) = (0, 1)(Fig. 2(c)). The eective potential
can be rewritten as
V (r) =
1
8
| |
2
D
r
2
+
D
v
4r
D2
v
2
8r
2D2
, (50)
which is expected to have two positive real critical points of the potential or
no such ones to explain the asymptotic behaviors of the potential naturally.
Since the expressions for two extremal points are given by
r
D
c
=
v
2 | |
D
_
(D2)
_
D
2
2
16(D1)w
2
_
, (51)
with a negative , the potential can not have two extreme points. We con-
clude that the motion of the wall is always bounded in the range of negative
.
3.2.4 Summary of the AdS-SAdS Junctions
The possible types of the motion of the wall is more complicated than the ones
of the previous section since we turned on the negative cosmological constant
inside the wall and set the outer metric to be the form of the Schwarzschild
AdS type. We can classify the motions of the wall simply as dividing the
rst quadrant in the uw plane into several regions according to the sign of
and . The monotonic type solution can only exist in the case of < 0.
3.3 Classifying Scheme to the other (D+1)-dimensional
Junctions
In this section, we will apply our classifying scheme to the other spherical
false-true vacuum type of junctions. The dS-S, dS-SdS, dS-AdS cases have
been handled in many other papers about the bubble dynamics and their
possible wall motions are a bounded or bounce or monotonic type again.
But their classications dependent on the parameters used are not given
completely. As an exercise for applying our scheme, we consider and try to
classify them again.
14
3.3.1 (D+1)-dimensional dS-SdS Junctions
To classify solutions of a junction, we must know what eective potential it
has. There are two ways that we can do this. The one is that we simply
assume the forms of the bulk metrics as in the equation (12) and use the
formula (24) and the other is that we change the signs of the combinatory
parameters u
2
and w
2
appropriately. We follow the latter way in this sub-
sections. Given the eective potential, we can classify the wall motions from
a wall observers view. The coecients of the bulk metrics in the dS-SdS
junction are
A
in
= w
2
2
D
, A
out
= u
2
2
D
, M
out
= M and the others zero. (52)
Because one of the dierences between the dS space and the AdS space is
that they dier each other in the vacuum energies, we ip the signs of u
2
and
w
2
and substitute them in the AdS-SAdS case. Thus the eective potential
is given by
V (r) =
1
8
2
D
r
2
D
v
4r
D2
v
2
8r
2D2
(53)
where
=
2
+ 4w
2
and = u
2
w
2
+ 1. (54)
Since the eective potential is given, we can classify the solutions by the signs
of and and the expected forms of the potential. We omit the detailed
analysis of this junction.
3.3.2 (D+1)-dimensional dS-AdS Junctions
In this case, we can get the eective potential by u
2
u
2
and v = 0 in
the potential of the dS-SdS junction (53) or by w
2
w
2
and v = 0 in the
potential of the AdS-SAdS junction (42). The result is
V (r) =
1
8
2
D
r
2
D
v
4r
D2
(55)
where
=
2
+ 4w
2
and = u
2
+w
2
+ 1. (56)
15
3.3.3 (D+1)-dimensional dS-S Junctions
This case simply corresponds to the dS SdS junctions with replacing u by
zero, that is, we turn o
out
. Thus the eective potential is
V (r) =
1
8
(1 +w
2
)
2
2
D
r
2
D
v(1 +w
2
)
4r
D2
v
2
8r
2D2
. (57)
4 AdS - RN AdS Junctions
In this section we will deal with the junction equation which connects the
inner AdS space to the outer Reissner-Nordstr om AdS space. To describe
the Reissner-Nordstr om AdS space, we consider the charged particles spread
uniformly on the domain wall. In string theory set-up, the domain wall in
the asymptotically AdS space corresponds to the D3-brane and the charged
particles correspond not to the uctuations of open string on D3-brane but
to D5-branes wrapped on S
5
in AdS
5
S
5
. After some compatication
mechanism, these D5-branes look like charged particles in AdS
5
space and
become the sources of the bulk 1-form gauge eld. So the action describing
this situation is
S =
1
2
2
_
M
d
D+1
x
g (R 2)
1
4
_
M
d
D+1
x
gF
2
+
1
2
_
d
D
x
hK
d
D
x
h +
_
d
D
x
hqC
0
(58)
with
F
r0
=
r
C
0
, (59)
where q is a constant charge density on the domain wall and the total charge
Q is given by Q =
_
3
d
3
x
w
D
G
D+1
M
R
D2
+
Q
2
R
2(D2)
,
H
in
= 1 +
2
in
D(D 1)
R
2
. (61)
Under these, the junction equations are
1
2
r
2
+V =
1
2
(62)
where the eective potential is
V (r) =
1
8
2
D
r
2
+
D
v
4r
D2
Q
2
4r
2(D2)
v
2
8r
2(D1)
+
vQ
2
4
D
r
3D4
Q
4
8
2
D
r
2(2D3)
. (63)
Again, the possible motions of the wall can be classied by the similar
procedures as in the previous cases of Sec. 3. Here we only concentrate on a
solution which can behave like experiencing a multi-acceleration phase. From
the form of the induced metric on the wall, we may regard r() as a scale
factor. Let the initial radius of the wall be r
0
. Refer to Fig. (3). When time
goes on, the wall will expand. As the radius of the wall approaches a point
A at r = 5, the scale factor behaves as r and the rst acceleration, the
so-called early ination, ends. After that, the expansion rate of the wall will
be decelerated during some time. After the wall goes over the point B at
r = 15, the secondary acceleration will occur and the scale factor be given
by
r exp
_
1
2
D
_
| |
_
(64)
at = .
17
0 10 20 30 40
200
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
r
V
B
A
(a) Effective Potential in AdSRN AdS
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
r
B
A
(b) Scale Factor r vs. Proper Time
Figure 3: An example of the junction between RN AdS and AdS with mul-
tiple accelerations
5 Conclusions and Discussions
In this paper, we classied all possible cosmological behaviors from the view-
point of an observer on the domain wall moving in 5-dimension. The wall
plays a role of a partition that separates the whole manifold into two bulks
M