India vs. China: Which Economy Is Better After Recession?

- TIME

http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1957281,00.html

TIME

MAGAZINE

SUBSCRIBE

PHOTOS

VIDEOS

LISTS

APPS

TOPICS

Follow TIME

NewsFeed

U.S.

Politics

World

Business

Money

Tech

Health

Science

Entertainment

Opinion

Subscribe to TIME Give a Gift

SEARCH TIME.COM Main Global Spin Intelligent Cities Videos

By MICHAEL SCHUMAN / HONG KONG

Thursday, Jan. 28, 2010

Newsfeed

Kazakhstan's Growing Film Insdustry Aims to Counter Borat Image Djokovic Beats Nadal to Win Australian Open in Longest Final Game Police Arrest More Than 300 Occupy Oakland Protesters As Tensions Flare
Workers install scaffolding at a construction site in Suining, Sichuan province, China, on Jan. 25, 2010 Reuters

1 of 7

30-01-2012 03:03

India vs. China: Which Economy Is Better After Recession? - TIME

http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1957281,00.html

More on TIME.com

Most Popular
PRINT EMAIL REPRINTS Like 146 Tweet 9 SHARE 1 Share 5 MOST READ MOST EMAILED

Full List

1. Don't Call Introverted Children 'Shy' 2. The Pregnancy Project: Why One Girl Decided to Fake Her Baby Bump 3. Interview: Lionel Messi on His Sport, Cristiano Ronaldo and Argentina 4. Happy Birthday Opportunity! The Mars Rover Turns Eight 5. Quiz: Are You an Introvert or an Extrovert? 6. The Upside Of Being An Introvert (And Why Extroverts Are Overrated) 7. Can Computers Replace Teachers? 8. The Dealer 9. 50 Best iPhone Apps 2011 10. LIVE VIDEO: Police Arrest More Than 150 Occupy Oakland Protesters As Tensions Flare

In the inevitable comparisons that economists and businesspeople make between Asia's two rising giants, China and India, China nearly always comes out on top.

Top 10 Not-SoExtinct Animals

Top 10 Memorable Movie Character Names

The Chinese economy historically outpaces India's by just about every measure. China's fast-acting government implements new policies with blinding speed, making India's fractured political system appear sluggish and chaotic. Beijing's shiny new airport and wide freeways are models of modern development, contrasting sharply with the sagging infrastructure of New Delhi and Mumbai. And as the global economy emerges from the Great Recession, India once again seems to be playing second fiddle. Pundits around the world laud China's leadership for its well-devised economic policies during the crisis, which were so effective in restarting economic growth that they helped lift the entire Asian region out of the downturn.
(Read "Amid Recovery, China's Property Market Soars.")

More News from Our Partners

U.N. nuclear team lands in Iran Sudan: Rebels kidnap 70 workers, including Chinese nationals Arab League suspends Syria mission amid violence

7 Standout

Now, however, India may finally have one up on its high-octane rival. Though India still can't compete on top-line economic growth the World Bank projects India's gross domestic product (GDP) will increase 6.4% in 2009, far short of the 8.7% that China announced in mid-January India's economy looks to be rebounding from the downturn in better shape than China's. India doesn't appear to be facing the same degree of potential dangers and downside risks as China, which means policymakers in New Delhi might have a much easier task in maintaining the economy's momentum than their Chinese

Robert Hegyes Dead: 'Welcome Back Kotter' Actor Dies At 60 Eggner Ferry Bridge Hit By Delta Mariner Ship In Kentucky (PHOTOS) The Funniest Animal Photobombs Ever

2 of 7

30-01-2012 03:03

India vs. China: Which Economy Is Better After Recession? - TIME

http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1957281,00.html

Looks by Jason Wu for Target

counterparts. "The way I see it is that the growth in India is much more sustainable" than the growth in China, says Jim Walker, an economist at Hong Kongbased research firm Asianomics. India's edge is due to the different stimulus programs adopted by the two countries to support growth during the downturn. China implemented what Walker calls "the biggest stimulus program in global history." On top of government outlays for new infrastructure and tax breaks, Beijing most significantly counted on massive credit growth to spur the economy. The amount of new loans made in 2009 nearly doubled from the year before to $1.4 trillion representing almost 30% of GDP. The stimulus plan worked wonders, holding up growth even as China's exports dropped 16% in 2009. But now China is facing the consequences of its largesse. Fears are rising that Beijing's easy-money policies have fueled a potential property-price bubble. According to government data, average real estate prices in Chinese cities jumped 7.8% in December from a year earlier the fastest increase in 18 months. The credit boom has also sparked worries about the nation's banking system. Many economists expect the large surge in credit to lead to a growing number of nonperforming loans (NPLs). In a November report, UBS economist Wang Tao calculates that if 20% of all new lending in 2009 and 10% of the amount in 2010 goes bad over the next three to five years, the total amount of NPLs from China's stimulus program would reach $400 billion, or roughly 8% of GDP. Though Wang notes that the total is small compared with the level of NPLs that Chinese banks carried in the past, she still calls the sum "staggering." Policymakers in Beijing are clearly concerned. Since December, they have introduced a series of steps to cool

(PHOTOS)

Weekly Ketchup: Hugo and The Artist Top Oscar Nominees Critics Consensus: The Grey is Certified Fresh Total Recall: Ed Harris's Best Movies

Top Stories

Egyptians Gather Together (But Not United) in Tahrir S With Gingrich on the Trail
in Florida, Romney Sarkozy Unexpectedly Calls Earlier French Troop Exit The Dealer

Today in Pictures

3 of 7

30-01-2012 03:03

India vs. China: Which Economy Is Better After Recession? - TIME

http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1957281,00.html

down the housing market and restrict access to credit by, for example, reintroducing taxes on certain property transactions and raising the required level of cash that banks have to keep on hand in an effort to reduce new lending.
(Read "Foreign Luxury Cars: Picking Up Speed in India.")

India, meanwhile, isn't experiencing nearly the same degree of fallout from its recession-fighting methods. The government used the same tools as every other to support growth when the financial crisis hit cutting interest rates, offering tax breaks and increasing fiscal spending but the scale was smaller than in China. Goldman Sachs estimates that India's government stimulus will total $36 billion this fiscal year, or only 3% of GDP. By comparison, China's two-year, $585 billion package is roughly twice as large, at about 6% of GDP per year. Most important, India managed to achieve its substantial growth without putting its banking sector at risk. In fact, India's banks have remained quite conservative through the downturn, especially compared with Chinese lenders. Growth of credit, for example, was actually lower in 2009 than in 2008. As a result, economists see continued strength in India's banks. A January report by economic-research outfit Centennial Asia Advisors noted that based on available data, "there was no sign that domestic banks' nonperforming assets were deteriorating materially." Nor do analysts harbor the same concerns that India's monetary policies are sending prices of Indian real estate to bubble levels. "India's growth, though less stellar, does have the reassuring factor that the [risks of] asset price bubbles are less," says Rajat Nag, managing director general of the Asian Development Bank in Manila. India maintained robust growth without Beijing's hefty stimulus in part because it is less exposed to the international economy.

4 of 7

30-01-2012 03:03

India vs. China: Which Economy Is Better After Recession? - TIME

http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1957281,00.html

China's exports represented 35% of GDP compared with only 24% for India in 2008. Thus India was afforded more protection from the worst effects of the financial crisis in the West, while China's government needed to be much more active to replace lost exports to the U.S. More significantly, though, India's domestic economy provides greater cushion from external shocks than China's. Private domestic consumption accounts for 57% of GDP in India compared with only 35% in China. India's confident consumer didn't let the economy down. Passenger car sales in India in December jumped 40% from a year earlier. "What we see [in India] is a fundamental domestic demand story that doesn't stall in the time of a global downturn," says Asianomics' Walker.
(See pictures of India's "slumdog" entrepreneurs.)

The Indian economy is not immune to risks. The government has to contend with a yawning budget deficit, and last year's weak monsoon rains will likely undercut agricultural production and soften rural consumer spending. But rapid growth is expected to continue. The World Bank forecasts India's economy will surge 7.6% in 2010 and 8% in 2011, not far behind the 9% rate it predicts for China for each of those years. Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, when speaking about his country's more plodding pace of economic policymaking, has said that "slow and steady will win the race." The Great Recession appears to have proved him right.
See the best pictures of 2009.
Sponsored Links

China Trade Fair

Shenzhen International Trade Fair From 20-23,October.Welcome to join.
www.chinagiftsfair.com

Made In China

5 of 7

30-01-2012 03:03

India vs. China: Which Economy Is Better After Recession? - TIME

http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1957281,00.html

Inquire for Lower Prices in China Contact Quality Manufacturers Now!

www.GlobalMarket.com

Study Economic Freedom

Learn Benefits and How to Measure. Online Course. Enroll Today!
Academy.Mises.org

PRINT EMAIL REPRINTS

SHARE

Techland
How One Little Android Update Caused a Big Headache Report: Facebook IPO Filing Could Come Next Week Move Over PSN and Xbox LIVE: Here Comes the Nintendo Network

Moneyland
Romneys Tax Returns Show He Paid More in Taxes Than He Owed The Top 1% Feels An Obligation to Give Bernanke to Income-Starved Retirees: Tough Luck

Top Stories on TIME.com

Egyptians Gather Together (But Not United) in Tahrir Square With Gingrich on the Trail in Florida, Romney Surrogates Are Never Far Behind Sarkozy Unexpectedly Calls Earlier French Troop Exit From Afghanistan

Quotes of the Day "The onus is on Iran, they have to prove themselves that their nuclear development program is genuinely for peaceful purposes."
BAN KI-MOON, U.N. secretary, speaking at Davos Friday, encouraging the reopening of talks between Iran and Western powers on their nuclear program More Quotes

6 of 7

30-01-2012 03:03

India vs. China: Which Economy Is Better After Recession? - TIME

http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1957281,00.html

Stay Connected with TIME.com

Subscribe to RSS Feeds Sign Up for Newsletters Get the TIME Magazine iPad Edition Read TIME Mobile on your Phone Become a Fan of TIME Get TIME Twitter Updates

NewsFeed

U.S.

Politics

World

Business

Money

Health

Science
RSS

Entertainment
Mobile Help

Photos

Videos
LIFE.com

Specials

Magazine

2012 Time Inc. All rights reserved Subscribe Contact Us

Privacy Policy Media Kit

Newsletter

TIME For Kids Site Map

Terms of Use

Reprints & Permissions

Ad Choices

Our partners

7 of 7

30-01-2012 03:03