b8Vb8Y8R

"UV8<D 

$]

Rc*((
*
E
k
XDW 8
Ra

8 Xk lO
8 X?Y8 XJ

8p8 8 t*
;_
*c
,(

Q

' k
M
V m*  89WK

8U
 n%
@
8Ux'ilDDcXDWH8
-


(
+T8l0V^S
8V8DW;% o*,kV

8 3Dx

FZaXD 
0
H8D+6 m8Va$]u#
< , ,

E
u
D;
V'
DvSulaE
k
lDk8D
  

8 3DxXD8
FWD<DD
0LFKHDO+

y 6y #_S

x Xj DW8 V8[ 8
a ~ T ~8
D

]c 8
8 x[ :
8 
a7+( 9 c +DUW
|8D }D #
c H86 XD 48Wa
6u &<%
@iH8;~WDW8

$MDFFLR&RUVLFDU ; fW

 XM
1
E
JS
8
8  6W+DOLQDU ;~W

cH84WDW86 m8+^lU [k
$]aN
! c :DWHUORR4

KDW8 E
m;~W c$]u
'+
8
a XD 
 k F8q<6 mDv;~W

6 j m8DS%
Fe j
+

%X @
<D1;
j 8WlD ; H8DW8liT-UV8<D 

$]}
8

6 47 8D 5c @i4kWP hDW8aKH8u

DW8 T9[ %C
RfHDW8CDW8T;.C
G
S
8 XWu #
%B 

F c$]

6 mQ 8@bH8 XW8MH8DW86 m
PD;D
J^aliD 8
B;fT

5

J

c
{f*

4

D
;D

XWDW86 m
'+w
i a [D 8!~8
,Xk XD* |8D cH8z &RUVLFD _

Tu ; DW8

<S
8a 4 F 5 

F .8 $] H8 T $] 78

<8
.8 l H8W
y
H86 m#
i,
%q&RUVLDQ SDW86 m#
i

w
i Da zD 5 }
liF8}
aXW4 c n 4WD 8 8 O
)
6
'F 5 )UHQFK5HYROXWLRQTD H76 8

> 8 8 [k

j 7RXORQ l 48
a 7 =
 %
h W H8 ;j$]

ZdT X
)
cH8 46 m >D8 [D 5$]aFH8
'T 8W

8 '

< G8 .8 l H8DW8 [ 
Vc > 8 8 ~8
a 28$] a 7 4DW86
l$]a7 6 j8
8WDvWS
8DW8;T4[
+ [D DW8

BDfX 8

X[([k
$]D

8D

8TWW
[ )


%F6 E
U 8}

W}A

6
'98
8WU R
DvYi 98;
WJ

4

liV 4
Yu ay
y


X, ,9S
8aiC[D xcA}

%%

E ^V6Zi  ^S
8:8WZD cG
8" D[5
x/8  l$] , ,

4 U46 UUjUD ;6 }D 8 U6%8

UW6U(TW86 m
'+$
DW8
4
y ymE
i y
V8H8DW8;8D DW8J

WDW8V5t
l$]a]t8H86 V
 

 6)
WD 8 y y<D 

$]K8WD }
, ,


X

u aT8M8A}c$]a98o2

+ S8U 28 A;oDW8 +Phao)

cU 28A
h W&8l$], ,
6uD5
(
*
$ )
;S
8SXW76 | 5DW88XD H8sh

[D 8XZi1V4S+D 8 H@ )
Kc9#
c4W
R H8 l

l H8 *#
DW8+D 8 4k H@V l $]6 D D #
8 H@H8 f
ZH8
;XW=
H8
@i%
A Vja *
n(
  k FH8cV86 ;a
q4k

y 6y 4<
4k aH8a mVE
i ;

 6)
WD 8 y y<D 

$]K8WD }
, ,


X


BDW8 ;E
DWgc4WDW8 U /8 v<aA C V 4

$] 
+ H@ /8DW86 DDxU mcfHDW8 
C c<D
 $] a l
6
t
cQ.8
q H8 E
lfUV8 /8 E
D 8 t
;fTAl

F 8iD XW4D7VcV<T E
DW8D y m 
PWFaPH8o2

E
V88T [D XZ a x c 4DW8 4xTDW8X 4vS /:5 , ,

V8[8
=
 dx<5 E
X%
A :5 1 <i R a H8a ;D T

}D#
cUV8 li}A$]6 j> D8&
X 8BH86 88 4W cV $]
V8 4DW8u <<+}m5
^U H8 m'8DW8 m>iB9W

8
6 0
S
Fi8 G
MV" 4C
/8 l$]6u <<W ;

B
H8 .8  W liU x 2 4z 4z  1DWLYHVWRNLOOQDWLYHVu  8D

H< a5
D 8 [7 /8 l H8 6 +918  J^S
8 l H8 Q l] < L

a V8\Z x 8 a5
D 8 H8 7 IV =
 6 E
;~7 IF
t
 1Ff8

N 8 k 8a 7
'+U 8 l8H86 +
5P 5BD d8 l 4DW RH

4W;D\Sa T V
i jxS
87 IV8l6gTb0Dk < T
U O8W

c `
5 UV8DW8
, &ecUV8 lH86 + NWf9l$]DW8
'E
q
a F8

8 l1 D
U
nUi8 f =
 XW V8DW M

6 +iC 4v8 =

7 IV8 S l H8 M
6 #
;
8 ~ 5 U
V8% U 88DW8
#<
*D 

V8BDW8 +D

c:5y
V :5l aV4#
i
8SD .JS
8 :5a DW8

n
T6 v %4i

B4cI
XWV5t
;
V8Z"
6 Q!
B


5P 5BD du X 8 }D#
cA4DW8DxQ
D5P 5BD dDW8T/8  > XD 
W
F 8 D8 08 $] 4 7 IV E
 :
8 XW l m8W8
c BDW8 ; cM
DW8 c 4W
y 6y uD 'iDW8 '

 

8  
5| 8
FWD y y
+ c9DZ, ,V<T E
DW8F 8 yF 8DPZ, 
u >DS
8a;fT,
6T4Wi 98
8WA$]

.846 ' < Q Q H8 Q 8 S

>%

`=
 $], ,

mT N$]K
CPi

 6)
WD 8 y y<D 

$]K8WD }
, ,


X

$] 8
X
i D4DW8 ;< j 8W l5a l5< A

FFiVdS
8 TT8 &8CDW8H8DW8 'icUV8H8 rh;k 88

Dx83vS
8 H8 c<D 

$]DPh4x<a6 'Ur
8

NWfP hU
i R l $]lLUZD4WDW8}A6u D <+iC

3 7 V8DW vf
XDq H8 x< Vk
V $] V8DW U A}
86 c

8
S
+ liT-  H8DW8L z8DvJ^$] uD <* >D5;X8W
_6 'Up kS
8 DW8 TG8 H86 m H
iX%
E aSm8W
,}S
8 4WDW86 +}U
i RizAQ4n[ <l $]

DW8 .8iY 
^9c DW8 8M
lH8Ql,  c > 8 8 .8
6 E
8QN
! -DW8 E
98X 

;E
li24^U V8U t((l H8 V8DW vaU
i R4

8P
*
V8 m+4WD 8X$]:5/8LfH8l4WD 8D 8&
V8DW8 m *
n(
D nli y
V8W
l'VHWdH8 l $]6 6 x<V< c

[ 8 V )4E
# cV8DW8
'E
V 4&ZD  E
D 4^

V8DW86 E
i
q<6 8
8
X VW-Q;jc$]a k FH8a:D ZD U x2t((
6 D

< cV8 ;
H8 [^XW BT8 S
8%
m
*8 Q h8DW8 8 U 8l
6
'+ 8
<DM{

'iTu 4DWg [Ms 8 l $] a A~DW8 8

I
a U
i R

[a 8D6 *lX c$]iH8 E

l98Zh}aU
i x
c
D'f V8 XW}
8DW8 Ia'$] K 88 *6 * TT8 S)DW81D x
(
a;fT8  <<E
D 8 t
[

4 4X8

X> DW8 j#
S
8 cH8V$

Vm:8Wli 

;WS
8aV W\l$]Ql, v 
O
{8
/8

   [X 8Si^aH86d8 /8H

 
+ VDW84WD 8XF /8 $]
+ ;WY DW8 [c8WA4

 [DA%V8W

8SDD 
D 
cV8DW86 E
EJQla}
8 4
W

E
1QV8 E
l$]V8 m8E
98%a7 88 l4;D8XF XW6 c
t((l $] xH86 8 5X c$] l
WxS
8 V8DW 8W X%

6 x<

8u P8a 8c4 8W l6 E

S
lD k iZ V$84/8 > M
Fa TJ

6Z, T-
Dr7u U8S
8VDW8upU8V

T
# i1 8
>U X E
F <fl $]l84a X%
,
, u

4WV86 +%
t 8.8 D C4W[DX.fDW8 &

&=8Pic &

y D4.8DW8 +V%Q 8P4n[.8lH8a

 )
WD 8 y y<D 

$]K8WD }
, ,


X

liX"[ Dx8Y DW8 

g &DWV

V a 8
' U 88 Dx

a Q > 8 8 .8 XWDW86 DvX A$] Kcliw

i ~8

DW DW8 8 d
8
S

F cH8 46
'z8WDvY%43 SiEJ
6 8F 5

H8 'i V
*cTG88$] V8DWvH8DW8A ;X8W3f
XDT

6 i8WG
X E
FTuliT-UV8

8VV8DWv< .8aA$]Q
NDVV SH /
H8

6DWDQLF9RLFHV$QFLHQW 9 c 'DYLG03LGFRFN w DfV XWm

9 H8u #
< 8M ,6%1  DQG 0RGHUQ

al $]jc 
i S
8 l/H0RQLWHXUD 8 [D XS
8u 

/8 l $]6u
'D y y<D 

 $] =, ,U
zV8 H8 E
%DW86u iT-UV8
(Y8T , ,U
W.*
H86
'VXWDW8 E
% aZD 
H8 -DFTXHV0HQRX
V8

^UV8;D~V c[
i y yXF $
, ,;D~[AS
8al %C
86
'D y y

H8e m#
i +D 8 t
8 SPh 4nS c fzV8 l $]6 j&< % j 8W S
ND P

& Q;J



H8DW8UV8$]6 mX k 5li z8Da[D .8a

6u #
<E
8M
1DSROHRQ$QG,VODP
9c &KHUILOV

*
;U E
a n(
*
8 [W
5 

FD v=
 8
X
i DW8 %C
~Vu 4

U 9S
8DW86 E
98 X
SDx8

FDW8;fu /8 l H8 6 mDD 8
[8n
D

;~WcH8 7KH7KRXJKWVRIWKH3ULVRQHURIWKH,VODQGRI6W+HOHQD

F c [^S
8lJTDW8 >W)
U /8 $]=
 uDW XWV6 
i g
u 0TV$]a8o26 mDi

7KHH[LVWHQFHRI2QH*RGLVXQGRXEWDEOHEXWDOO

UHOLJLRQVDUHFUHDWLRQVRI0DQ

6FL)RUXPVFRP:RUOG3ROLWLFV

1DSROHRQ%RQDSDUWHZDVD086/,0

KWWSZZZVFLIRUXPVFRPVKRZWKUHDGSKS"S SRVW


E
mVXW ' XF 8

8S ; ;T8 8 UC >D$]@i8
l$]6 m8VF 8

0RVHVKDVUHYHDOHGWKHH[LVWHQFHRI*RGWRKLV

QDWLRQ-HVXV&KULVWWRWKH5RPDQZRUOG0XKDPPDGWR

WKHROGFRQWLQHQW

$UDELDZDVLGRODWURXVZKHQVL[FHQWXULHVDIWHU-HVXV
0XKDPPDGLQWURGXFHGWKHZRUVKLSRIWKH*RGRI

$EUDKDPRI,VKPDHORI0RVHVDQG-HVXV7KH$UL\DQV
DQGVRPHRWKHUVHFWVKDGGLVWXUEHGWKHWUDQTXLOLW\RIWKH

HDVWE\DJLWDWLQJWKHTXHVWLRQRIWKHQDWXUHRIWKH)DWKHU
WKHVRQDQGWKH+RO\*KRVW0XKDPPDGGHFODUHGWKDW
WKHUHZDVQRQHEXWRQH*RGZKRKDGQRIDWKHUQRVRQ

DQGWKDWWKHWULQLW\LPSRUWHGWKHLGHDRILGRODWU\

ml$]

,KRSHWKHWLPHLVQRWIDURIIZKHQ,VKDOOEHDEOHWR
XQLWHDOOWKHZLVHDQGHGXFDWHGPHQRIDOOWKH

FRXQWULHVDQGHVWDEOLVKDXQLIRUPUHJLPHEDVHGRQ
WKHSULQFLSOHVRI4XUDQZKLFKDORQHDUHWUXHDQG

ZKLFKDORQHFDQOHDGPHQWRKDSSLQHVV

U [D a d4v <
H8a=
 DW X E
F
h WXWaTuZ, ,)
m5t
m
"c7d4WiD xl
 8S
8c4k 8[DW86 d4i S
84&E
DW8T
y 6y u j 8WljSd
,
*8 [D DW8(XWcV5t
DW8
48

>4XRWHGLQ&KULVWLDQ&KHUILOV%RQDSDUWHHW,VODP3HGRQH(G

3DULV)UDQFHSS


2ULJLQDO5HIHUHQFHV&RUUHVSRQGDQFHGH1DSROpRQ,HU7RPH9

SLqFHQGX@

 KWWSZZZLVODPUHOLJLRQFRPDUWLFOHV
0HPRLUV

9 l/RXLV $QWRLQH )DXYHOHW GH %RXUULHQQH

S
8 48
J

;u aRI 1DSROHRQ %RQDSDUWH

(
V
y
VV8DW v< [A.8 $ )
u DW86u +
8
EUV8T-$]lH8DW8u 8W
S
8
,WKDVEHHQDOOHJHGWKDW%RQDSDUWHZKHQLQ

(J\SW WRRNSDUWLQWKHUHOLJLRXVFHUHPRQLHVDQGZRUVKLS
RIWKH0XVVXOPDQV EXWLWFDQQRWEHVDLGWKDWKH

FHOHEUDWHGWKHIHVWLYDOVRIWKHRYHUIORZLQJRIWKH1LOHDQG
WKHDQQLYHUVDU\RIWKH3URSKHW7KH7XUNVLQYLWHGKLPWR
WKHVHPHUHO\DVDVSHFWDWRUDQGWKHSUHVHQFHRIWKHLU

QHZPDVWHUZDVJUDWLI\LQJWRWKHSHRSOH %XWKHQHYHU

FRPPLWWHGWKHIROO\RIRUGHULQJDQ\VROHPQLW\+HQHLWKHU
OHDUQHGQRUUHSHDWHGDQ\SUD\HURIWKH.RUDQDVPDQ\

SHUVRQVKDYHDVVHUWHGQHLWKHUGLGKHDGYRFDWHIDWDOLVP

SRO\JDP\RUDQ\RWKHUGRFWULQHRIWKH.RUDQ%RQDSDUWH
HPSOR\HGKLPVHOIEHWWHUWKDQLQGLVFXVVLQJZLWKWKH
,PDQVWKHWKHRORJ\RIWKHFKLOGUHQRI,VPDHO7KH

FHUHPRQLHVDWZKLFKSROLF\LQGXFHGKLPWREHSUHVHQW
ZHUHWRKLPDQGWRDOOZKRDFFRPSDQLHGKLPPHUH

PDWWHUVRIFXULRVLW\ +HQHYHUVHWIRRWLQDPRVTXHDQG
RQO\RQRQHRFFDVLRQZKLFK,VKDOOKHUHDIWHUPHQWLRQ

GUHVVHGKLPVHOILQWKH0DKRPHWDQFRVWXPH+HDWWHQGHG
WKHIHVWLYDOVWRZKLFKWKHJUHHQWXUEDQVLQYLWHGKLP+LV
UHOLJLRXVWROHUDQFHZDVWKHQDWXUDOFRQVHTXHQFHRIKLV

SKLORVRSKLF VSLULW


'RXEWOHVV%RQDSDUWHGLGDVKHZDVERXQGWRGR

VKRZUHVSHFWIRUWKHUHOLJLRQRIWKHFRXQWU\DQGKHIRXQG
LWQHFHVVDU\WRDFWPRUHOLNHD0XVVXOPDQWKDQD

&DWKROLF$ZLVHFRQTXHURUVXSSRUWVKLVWULXPSKVE\
SURWHFWLQJDQGHYHQHOHYDWLQJWKHUHOLJLRQRIWKH

FRQTXHUHGSHRSOH%RQDSDUWH
VSULQFLSOHZDVDVKH

KLPVHOIKDVRIWHQWROGPHWRORRNXSRQUHOLJLRQVDVWKH
ZRUNRIPHQEXWWRUHVSHFWWKHPHYHU\ZKHUHDVD

SRZHUIXOHQJLQHRIJRYHUQPHQW+RZHYHU , ZLOOQRWJRVR
IDUDVWRVD\WKDWKHZRXOGQRWKDYHFKDQJHGKLVUHOLJLRQ
KDGWKHFRQTXHVWRIWKH(DVWEHHQWKHSULFHRIWKDW

FKDQJH$OOWKDWKHVDLGDERXW0DKRPHW,VODPLVPDQG
WKH.RUDQWRWKHJUHDWPHQRIWKHFRXQWU\KHODXJKHGDW

KLPVHOI+HHQMR\HGWKHJUDWLILFDWLRQRIKDYLQJDOOKLVILQH
VD\LQJVRQWKHVXEMHFWRIUHOLJLRQWUDQVODWHGLQWR$UDELF
SRHWU\DQGUHSHDWHGIURPPRXWKWRPRXWK7KLVRI

FRXUVHWHQGHGWRFRQFLOLDWHWKHSHRSOH

, FRQIHVVWKDW%RQDSDUWHIUHTXHQWO\FRQYHUVHGZLWK

WKHFKLHIVRIWKH0XVVXOPDQUHOLJLRQRQWKHVXEMHFWRIKLV
FRQYHUVLRQEXWRQO\IRUWKHVDNHRIDPXVHPHQW7KH
SULHVWVRIWKH.RUDQZKRZRXOGSUREDEO\KDYHEHHQ
GHOLJKWHGWRFRQYHUWXVRIIHUHGXVWKHPRVWDPSOH

FRQFHVVLRQV%XWWKHVHFRQYHUVDWLRQVZHUHPHUHO\

VWDUWHGE\ZD\RIHQWHUWDLQPHQWDQGQHYHUFRXOGKDYH
ZDUUDQWHGDVXSSRVLWLRQRIWKHLUOHDGLQJWRDQ\VHULRXV

UHVXOW,I%RQDSDUWHVSRNHDVD0XVVXOPDQLWZDVPHUHO\
LQKLVFKDUDFWHURIDPLOLWDU\DQGSROLWLFDOFKLHILQD

0XVVXOPDQFRXQWU\7RGRVRZDVHVVHQWLDOWRKLV

VXFFHVVWRWKHVDIHW\RIKLVDUP\DQGFRQVHTXHQWO\WR
KLVJORU\,QHYHU\FRXQWU\KHZRXOGKDYHGUDZQXS

SURFODPDWLRQVDQGGHOLYHUHGDGGUHVVHVRQWKHVDPH

SULQFLSOH,Q,QGLDKHZRXOGKDYHEHHQIRU$OLDW7KLEHW

IRUWKH'DODLODPDDQGLQ&KLQDIRU&RQIXFLXV


>0HPRLUVRI1DSROHRQ%RQDSDUWHE\/RXLV$QWRLQH)DXYHOHWGH

%RXUULHQQHHGLWHGE\5:3KLSSV9RO1HZ<RUN&KDUOHV
6FULEQHU
V6RQVS@

DW8  6LU*HRUJH%HUQDUG6KDZ 
i BD

>D <X @i7uV _8D


DfD pmDW8  'U:LOOLDP'UDSHU7DB #W 8 BDW8  %HUWUDQG5XVVHOD K5

UV8 m
DW8UV8 lx[ XW 3KLOOLS+LWWL $ 7KRPDV&DUO\OH

$]DW8 4

DW8 ;8.<D 

 $]@i8 d
u cRy c `
5



m
6 k
D X E
F L~ 4
V8 c$]u H t
X E
F
:
#
V aZD 
4 8W 8D 8c9[8.xXi8D :5DW8eccWPY8ifUV8

[S
8SUWD X
i aD ,;ccWPY8:5Su u Uv

x< j k 4xV8Z `
5  XW F
Nu V s "}
8  ,
, mV l mW

4v 
H8 #
H
H8a}
8DW86 #
i
8

~Q;cH8DWga

  I
X9
N 87

9 [D I y y#

; ;cl
' k
U"8P~x>;_

D `
5 ;5 8 > 5}
8 T8V :5 , ,

8}
8 m8W:56 &i + H8 D #
a k F[ O
{8

}&8 [D 8
5cV/DT; ;V'a k FDH1

y 6y m88-/i1M

PhUWD
q 

 t8
mTWDUW]V5c8Dk 

UV8 $]u<< m5

V c"8[YDW8 &<8Mx9 8 
c
R ((
*
Rk 8W
HAS
8Vu ;
S
8DWgO8 X?Y8XJ
8p8 8 t**
;_M g8

f

y 6y #_, ,



D UW8 8

7KH$5DQNLQJRI7KH0RVW,QIOXHQWLDO3HUVRQVLQ+LVWRU\


 ?AD [M
fx)
WD 8 y y<D

$]K8WD }
, ,


X


4F
W


/RXLV$QWRLQH)DXYHOHWGH%RXUULHQQHF8 0HPRLUVRI1DSROHRQ%RQDSDUWH


 uxa( OLEHUDU\c?AD 6RIW)LOHc9H8 


5| 8
FWD

[D8 


t8
mTWD y Uy W]V5c8Dk , ,


?AD6 ;QD