2/29/12 10-1167 Docke

General Docket
United States Court of Appeals for District of Columbia Circuit

Court of Appeals Docket #: 10-1167 Docketed: 07/06/2010

American Chemistry Council v. EPA
Appeal From: Environmental Protection Agency
Fee Status: Fee Paid

Case T pe Information:
1) Petition for Review
2) Review
3)

Originating Court Information:

District: EPA-1 : EPA-43FR26388
Date Filed:

Prior Cases:
None

Current Cases:
Lead Member Start End
Consolidation
10-1092 10-1094 08/05/2010
10-1092 10-1134 08/05/2010
10-1092 10-1143 08/05/2010
10-1092 10-1144 08/05/2010
10-1092 10-1152 08/05/2010
10-1092 10-1156 08/05/2010
10-1092 10-1158 08/05/2010
10-1092 10-1159 08/05/2010
10-1092 10-1160 08/05/2010
10-1092 10-1161 08/05/2010
10-1092 10-1162 08/05/2010
10-1092 10-1163 08/05/2010
10-1092 10-1164 08/05/2010
10-1092 10-1166 08/05/2010
10-1092 10-1182 08/05/2010
10-1167 10-1168 08/04/2010
10-1167 10-1169 08/04/2010
10-1167 10-1170 08/04/2010
10-1167 10-1173 08/04/2010
10-1167 10-1174 08/04/2010
10-1167 10-1175 08/04/2010
10-1167 10-1176 08/04/2010
10-1167 10-1177 08/04/2010
10-1167 10-1178 08/04/2010
10-1167 10-1179 08/04/2010
10-1167 10-1180 08/04/2010
Related
10-1092 10-1167 11/02/2011

Panel Assignment:
Panel: DBS JWR DST
Date of Hearing: 02/29/2012 Date of Decision:

American Chemistry Council Leslie A. Hulse

Petitioner Direct: 703-741-5165
Email: leslie_hulse@americanchemistry.com
[COR LD NTC Retained Atty]
American Chemistry Council
Firm: 202-249-7000
700 2nd Street, NE
Washington, DC 20002

h p ://ecf.cadc. co .go /cmecf/ e le /T an po Room 1/18

2/29/12 10-1167 Docke
James W. Coleman
Direct: 202-736-8721
Email: jwcoleman@sidley.com
[COR NTC Retained Atty]
Sidley Austin LLP
Firm: 202-736-8000
1501 K Street, NW
Washington, DC 20005

Peter Douglas Keisler, Esquire

Email: pkeisler@sidley.com
[COR NTC Retained Atty]
Sidley Austin LLP
Firm: 202-736-8000
1501 K Street, NW
Washington, DC 20005

Timothy Kenly Webster

Email: twebster@sidley.com
[COR NTC Retained Atty]
Sidley Austin LLP
Firm: 202-736-8000
1501 K Street, NW
Washington, DC 20005
v.

Environmental Protection Agency Jon M. Lipshultz, Senior Counsel

Respondent Direct: 202-514-2191
Email: jon.lipshultz@usdoj.gov
Fax: 202-514-8865
[COR LD NTC Gvt Atty US Agency]
U.S. Department of Justice
(DOJ) Environment & Natural Resources Division
PO Box 7611, Ben Franklin Station
Washington, DC 20044-7611

Amanda Shafer Berman, Esquire, Trial Attorney

Direct: 202-514-1950
Email: amanda.berman@usdoj.gov
[COR NTC Gvt Atty US DOJ]
U.S. Department of Justice
(DOJ) Environmental Defense Section
Suite 8000
601 D Street, NW
Washington, DC 22204

Howard J. Hoffman
Direct: 202-564-5582
[COR NTC Gvt Atty US Agency]
Environmental Protection Agency
(EPA)
401 M Street, SW
Washington, DC 20460

Perry M. Rosen
Direct: 202-353-7792
Email: perry.rosen@usdoj.gov
Fax: 202-514-8865
[COR NTC Gvt Atty US DOJ]
U.S. Department of Justice
(DOJ) Environment & Natural Resources Division
PO Box 23986, L'Enfant Plaza Station
Washington, DC 20026-3986

Elliott Zenick, Assistant General Counsel

h p ://ecf.cadc. co .go /cmecf/ e le /T an po Room 2/18
2/29/12 10-1167 Docke
Elliott Zenick, Assistant General Counsel
Direct: 202-564-1822
Email: zenick.elliott@epa.gov
[COR NTC Gvt Atty US Agency]
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
(EPA) Office of General Counsel
Firm: 202-564-7606
1200 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW
Ariel Rios Building
Washington, DC 20460-0000

Lisa Perez Jackson, Administrator, U.S. Environmental Protection Jon M. Lipshultz, Senior Counsel
Agency Direct: 202-514-2191
Respondent [COR LD NTC Gvt Atty US Agency]
(see above)

Howard J. Hoffman
Direct: 202-564-5582
[COR NTC Gvt Atty US Agency]
(see above)
------------------------------

Chamber of Commerce of the United States of America Paul D. Clement

Intervenor for Petitioner Direct: 202-234-0090
Email: pclement@bancroftpllc.com
Fax: 202-234-2806
[COR NTC Retained Atty]
Bancroft PLLC
Firm: 202-234-0090
1919 M Street, NW
Suite 470
Washington, DC 20036

Ashley Charles Parrish

Email: aparrish@kslaw.com
[COR NTC Retained Atty]
King & Spalding, LLP
Firm: 202-737-0500
1700 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW
Suite 200
Washington, DC 20006-4706

Cynthia Anne May Stroman

Direct: 202-737-0500
Email: cstroman@kslaw.com
[COR NTC Retained Atty]
King & Spalding, LLP
Firm: 202-737-0500
1700 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW
Suite 200
Washington, DC 20006-4706

Conservation Law Foundation Ann Brewster Weeks, Esquire, Senior Counsel

Intervenor for Respondent Email: aweeks@catf.us
[COR NTC Retained Atty]
Clean Air Task Force
Firm: 617-624-0234
18 Tremont Street
Suite 530
Boston, MA 02108

Environmental Defense Fund David S. Baron

Intervenor for Respondent Email: dbaron@earthjustice.org
[COR NTC Retained Atty]
Earthjustice Legal Defense Fund
h p ://ecf.cadc. co .go /cmecf/ e le /T an po Room 3/18
2/29/12 10-1167 Docke Earthjustice Legal Defense Fund
Firm: 202-667-4500
1625 Massachusetts Avenue, NW
Suite 702
Washington, DC 20036-2212

Pamela A. Campos
Direct: 303-447-7216
Email: pcampos@edf.org
Fax: 303-440-8052
[COR NTC Retained Atty]
Environmental Defense Fund
Firm: 303-440-4901
2060 Broadway
Suite 300
Boulder, CO 80304

Sean H. Donahue
Direct: 202-277-7085
Email: sean@donahuegoldberg.com
Fax: 202-315-3582
[COR NTC Retained Atty]
Law Office of Sean H. Donahue
Firm: 202-466-2234
2000 L Street, NW
Suite 808
Washington, DC 20036-0000

Vickie Lynn Patton

Direct: 303-447-7215
Email: vpatton@edf.org

Fax: 303-440-8052
[COR NTC Retained Atty]
Environmental Defense Fund
Firm: 303-440-4901
2060 Broadway
Suite 300
Boulder, CO 80304

Peter Michel Zalzal, Esquire, Attorney

Direct: 303-447-7214
Email: pzalzal@edf.org
[COR NTC Retained Atty]
Environmental Defense Fund
Firm: 303-440-4901
2060 Broadway
Suite 300
Boulder, CO 80304
Natural Resources Defense Council David D. Doniger
Intervenor for Respondent Direct: 202-289-6868
Email: ddoniger@nrdc.org
Fax: 202-789-0859
[COR NTC Retained Atty]
Natural Resources Defense Council
Firm: 202-289-6868
1152 15th Street, NW
Suite 300
Washington, DC 20005

Meleah Anne Geertsma

Direct: 202-289-2382
Email: mgeertsma@nrdc.org
Fax: 202-289-1060
[COR NTC Retained Atty]
Natural Resources Defense Council
Firm: 202-289-6868
h p ://ecf.cadc. co .go /cmecf/ e le /T an po Room 4/18
2/29/12 10-1167 Docke
1152 15th Street, NW
Suite 300
Washington, DC 20005

Colin Casey O'Brien, Esquire, Attorney

Direct: 907-500-7134
Email: cobrien@earthjustice.org
Fax: 907-463-5891
[COR NTC Retained Atty]
Earthjustice
325 Fourth Street
Juneau, AK 99801

John DuVal Walke, Esquire

Direct: 202-289-2406
Email: jwalke@nrdc.org
[COR NTC Retained Atty]
Natural Resources Defense Council
Firm: 202-289-6868
1152 15th Street, NW
Suite 300

Washington, DC 20005
Sierra Club Craig Holt Segall
Intervenor for Respondent Direct: 202-548-4597
Email: Craig.Segall@SierraClub.org
[COR NTC Retained Atty]
Sierra Club
Firm: 202-547-1141
50 F Street, NW
Eighth Floor
Washington, DC 20001

Joanne Marie Spalding

Direct: 415-977-5725
Email: joanne.spalding@sierraclub.org
Fax: 415-977-5793
[COR NTC Retained Atty]
Sierra Club
85 Second Street
Second Floor
San Francisco, CA 94105-3441

------------------------------

Center for Biological Diversity Kevin Patrick Bundy

Amicus Curiae for Respondent Direct: 415-436-9682
Email: kbundy@biologicaldiversity.org
Fax: 415-436-9683
[COR NTC Retained Atty]
Center for Biological Diversity
Firm: 415-436-9682
351 California Street
Suite 600
San Francisco, CA 94104

Brendan Ridgely Cummings

Direct: 760-366-2232
Email: bcummings@biologicaldiversity.org
Fax: 760-366-2669
[COR NTC Retained Atty]
Center for Biological Diversity
Firm: 760-366-2232
PO Box 549
Joshua Tree, CA 92252-0000

h p ://ecf.cadc. co .go /cmecf/ e le /T an po Room 5/18

2/29/12 10-1167 Docke

Vera P. Pardee, Esquire

Direct: 415-436-9682
Email: vpardee@biologicaldiversity.org
Fax: 415-436-9683
[COR NTC Retained Atty]
Center for Biological Diversity
Firm: 415-436-9682
351 California Street
Suite 600
San Francisco, CA 94104

h p ://ecf.cadc. co .go /cmecf/ e le /T an po Room 6/18

2/29/12 10-1167 Docke

American Chemistry Council,

Petitioner

v.

Environmental Protection Agency; Lisa Perez Jackson, Administrator, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency,

Respondents

------------------------------

Chamber of Commerce of the United States of America,

Intervenor for Petitioner

Conservation Law Foundation; Environmental Defense Fund; Natural Resources Defense Council; Sierra Club,

Intervenors for Respondent

------------------------------

Center for Biological Diversity,

Amicus Curiae for Respondent

h p ://ecf.cadc. co .go /cmecf/ e le /T an po Room 7/18

2/29/12 10-1167 Docke

07/06/2010 PETITION FOR REVIEW CASE docketed. [10-1167] (Lister, Mary)

07/06/2010 PETITION FOR REVIEW filed [1254058] by American Chemistry Council of a decision by federal agency
3 pg, 2.64 MB [Service Date: 07/06/2010 ] Disclosure Statement: Attached; Certificate of Parties: Not Applicable to this
Filing [10-1167] (Lister, Mary)

07/08/2010 CERTIFIED COPY [1254061] of Petition for Review sent to respondent [1254058-2] [10-1167] (Lister,
1 pg, 27.45 KB Mary)

07/13/2010 CLERK'S ORDER filed [1254894] consolidating cases 10-1175, 10-1178 (Consolidation started
2 pg, 35.46 KB 07/13/2010) with 10-1167; directing party to file in 10-1167 initial submissions: PETITIONER docketing
statement due 08/12/2010. PETITIONER certificate as to parties, etc. due 08/12/2010. PETITIONER
statement of issues due 08/12/2010. PETITIONER underlying decision due 08/12/2010. PETITIONER
deferred appendix statement due 08/12/2010. PETITIONER procedural motions due 08/12/2010.
PETITIONER dispositive motions due 08/27/2010; directing party to file in 10-1167 initial submissions:
RESPONDENT entry of appearance due 08/12/2010. RESPONDENT procedural motions due
08/12/2010. RESPONDENT certified index to record due 08/27/2010. RESPONDENT dispositive motions
due 08/27/2010; directing party to file in 10-1175,10-1178 initial submissions: PETITIONER docketing
statement due 08/12/2010. PETITIONER statement of issues due 08/12/2010 [10-1167, 10-1175, 10-
1178]

07/15/2010 ENTRY OF APPEARANCE filed [1255375] by Jon M. Lipshultz on behalf of Respondents EPA and Lisa
2 pg, 25.8 KB Perez Jackson in 10-1167, Respondent EPA in 10-1175, 10-1178. [10-1167, 10-1175, 10-1178]
(Lipshultz, Jon)
07/19/2010 NOPPO ED MOTION filed [1256039] by American Chemistry Council in 10-1167, Clean Air
10 pg, 41.03 KB Implementation Project in 10-1175, American Frozen Food Institute, American Petroleum Institute, Brick
Industry Association, Corn Refiners Association, Inc., Glass Packaging Institute, Independent Petroleum
Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers Association, Mississippi Manufacturers Association,
National Association of Home Builders, National Association of Manufacturers, National Oilseed
Processors Association, National Petrochemical & Refiners Association, Specialty Steel Industry of
North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry, West Virginia Manufacturers
Association, Western States Petroleum Association and Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-
1178 to consolidate cases Pages: 1-10. [10-1167, 10-1175, 10-1178] (Webster, Timothy)

08/04/2010 CLERK'S ORDER filed [1258951] granting motion to consolidate [1256039-2] in 10-1167,10-1175,10-
1 pg, 40.06 KB 1178, granting motion to consolidate [1256042-2] in 10-1168,10-1173,10-1179, granting motion to
consolidate [1256044-2] in 10-1170,10-1176,10-1177, granting motion to consolidate [1256043-2] in 10-
1174,10-1180,10-1169 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-
1178, 10-1179, 10-1180 (Consolidation started 08/04/2010) with 10-1167 [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170, 10-
1173, 10-1174, 10-1180, 10-1176, 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179]
08/05/2010 MODIFIED PARTY FILER--MOTION filed [1259225] by Sierra Club, Natural Resources Defense Council,
63 pg, 4.18 MB Environmental Defense Fund, Conservation Law Foundation for leave to intervene [Disclosure Listing:
Attached] [Service Date: 08/05/2010 ] [10-1167]--[Edited 08/06/2010 by JMC] (Segall, Craig)
08/05/2010 MODIFIED PARTY FILER--MOTION filed [1259235] by CHAMBER OF COMMERCE OF THE UNITED
10 pg, 28.02 KB STATES OF AMERICA for leave to intervene [Disclosure Listing: Attached] [Service Date: 08/05/2010 ]
[10-1167]--[Edited 08/06/2010 by JMC] (Parrish, Ashley)

08/12/2010 NOPPO ED MOTION filed [1260197] by EPA and Lisa Perez Jackson in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170,
5 pg, 28.58 KB 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1180, 10-1176, EPA in 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179 to extend
time to file initial submissions to 09/10/2010. [Service Date: 08/12/2010 ] Pages: 1-10. [10-1167, 10-
1168, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1180, 10-1176, 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179]
(Lipshultz, Jon)

08/12/2010 DOCKETING STATEMENT FILED [1260224] by Clean Air Implementation Project in 10-1173, 10-1174,
5 pg, 710.24 KB 10-1175, 10-1177 [Service Date: 08/12/2010 ] [10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1177] (Lewis, William)

08/12/2010 STATEMENT OF ISSUES FILED [1260226] by Clean Air Implementation Project in 10-1173, 10-1174,
4 pg, 86.21 KB 10-1175, 10-1177 [Service Date: 08/12/2010 ] [10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1177] (Lewis, William)

08/12/2010 CERTIFICATE AS TO PARTIES, RULINGS AND RELATED CASES FILED [1260262] by American
5 pg, 14.02 KB Chemistry Council in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170, 10-1169 [Service Date: 08/12/2010 ] [10-1167, 10-1168,
10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1180, 10-1176, 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179] (Webster,
Timothy)
08/12/2010 DOCKETING STATEMENT FILED [1260263] by American Chemistry Council in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-
4 pg, 39.53 KB 1170, 10-1169 [Service Date: 08/12/2010 ] [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1180, 10-

h p ://ecf.cadc. co .go /cmecf/ e le /T an po Room 8/18

2/29/12 10-1167 Docke
1176, 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179] (Webster, Timothy)
08/12/2010 ENTRY OF APPEARANCE filed [1260269] by Timothy K. Webster and co-counsel Roger R. Martella,
2 pg, 27.03 KB Jr., William E. Gerard, James W. Coleman on behalf of Petitioner American Chemistry Council in 10-
1167, 10-1168, 10-1170, 10-1169. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1180, 10-1176, 10-
1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179] (Webster, Timothy)

08/12/2010 STATEMENT OF INTENT REGARDING APPENDIX DEFERRAL FILED [1260270] by American

3 pg, 10.32 KB Chemistry Council in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170, 10-1169 [Service Date: 08/12/2010 ] Intent:
AppxDeferred [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1180, 10-1176, 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-
1169, 10-1178, 10-1179] (Webster, Timothy)

08/12/2010 STATEMENT OF ISSUES FILED [1260273] by American Chemistry Council in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-
3 pg, 10.95 KB 1170, 10-1169 [Service Date: 08/12/2010 ] [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1180, 10-
1176, 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179] (Webster, Timothy)

08/12/2010 INCORRECT DOCKET ENTRY-DISREGARD--DOCKETING STATEMENT FILED [1260280] by American

7 pg, 53.17 KB Frozen Food Institute, American Petroleum Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners
Association, Inc., Glass Packaging Institute, Independent Petroleum Association of America, Michigan
Manufacturers Association, Mississippi Manufacturers Association, National Association of Home
Builders, National Association of Manufacturers, National Oilseed Processors Association, National
Petrochemical and Refiners Association, Specialty Steel Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber
of Commerce and Industry, West Virginia Manufacturers Association, Western States Petroleum
Association and Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-1176 [Service Date: 08/12/2010 ] [10-
1176, 10-1180, 10-1178, 10-1179]--[Edited 08/12/2010 by LMC] (Knauss, Charles)
08/12/2010 DOCKETING STATEMENT FILED [1260285] by American Frozen Food Institute, American Petroleum
7 pg, 53.17 KB Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners Association, Inc., Glass Packaging Institute,
Independent Petroleum Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers Association, Mississippi
Manufacturers Association, National Association of Home Builders, National Association of
Manufacturers, National Oilseed Processors Association, National Petrochemical and Refiners
Association, Specialty Steel Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry,
West Virginia Manufacturers Association, Western States Petroleum Association and Wisconsin
Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-1176, 10-1180, American Frozen Food Institute, American
Petroleum Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners Association, Inc., Glass Packaging
Institute, Independent Petroleum Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers Association,
Mississippi Manufacturers Association, National Association of Home Builders, National Association of
Manufacturers, National Oilseed Processors Association, National Petrochemical & Refiners
Association, Specialty Steel Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry,
West Virginia Manufacturers Association, Western States Petroleum Association and Wisconsin
Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-1178, 10-1179 [Service Date: 08/12/2010 ] [10-1176, 10-1180, 10-
1178, 10-1179] (Knauss, Charles)

08/12/2010 STATEMENT OF ISSUES FILED [1260287] by American Frozen Food Institute, American Petroleum
5 pg, 15.59 KB Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners Association, Inc., Glass Packaging Institute,
Independent Petroleum Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers Association, Mississippi
Manufacturers Association, National Association of Home Builders, National Association of
Manufacturers, National Oilseed Processors Association, National Petrochemical and Refiners
Association, Specialty Steel Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry,
West Virginia Manufacturers Association, Western States Petroleum Association and Wisconsin
Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-1176, 10-1180, American Frozen Food Institute, American
Petroleum Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners Association, Inc., Glass Packaging
Institute, Independent Petroleum Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers Association,
Mississippi Manufacturers Association, National Association of Home Builders, National Association of
Manufacturers, National Oilseed Processors Association, National Petrochemical & Refiners
Association, Specialty Steel Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry,
West Virginia Manufacturers Association, Western States Petroleum Association and Wisconsin
Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-1178, 10-1179 [Service Date: 08/12/2010 ] [10-1176, 10-1180, 10-
1178, 10-1179] (Knauss, Charles)

08/12/2010 UNDERLYING DECISION IN CASE submitted [1260288] by American Chemistry Council in 10-1167, 10-
211 pg, 27.67 MB 1168, 10-1170, 10-1169 [Service Date: 08/12/2010 ] [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-
1180, 10-1176, 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179] (Webster, Timothy)

08/12/2010 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE [1260289] to statement [1260287-2], statement [1260285-2] filed by

2 pg, 10.44 KB American Frozen Food Institute, American Petroleum Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners
Association, Inc., Glass Packaging Institute, Independent Petroleum Association of America, Michigan
Manufacturers Association, Mississippi Manufacturers Association, National Association of Home
Builders, National Association of Manufacturers, National Oilseed Processors Association, National
h p ://ecf.cadc. co .go /cmecf/ e le /T an po Room 9/18
2/29/12 10-1167 Docke
Petrochemical and Refiners Association, Specialty Steel Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber
of Commerce and Industry, West Virginia Manufacturers Association, Western States Petroleum
Association and Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-1176, 10-1180, American Frozen Food
Institute, American Petroleum Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners Association, Inc.,
Glass Packaging Institute, Independent Petroleum Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers
Association, Mississippi Manufacturers Association, National Association of Home Builders, National
Association of Manufacturers, National Oilseed Processors Association, National Petrochemical &
Refiners Association, Specialty Steel Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and
Industry, West Virginia Manufacturers Association, Western States Petroleum Association and
Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-1178, 10-1179. [10-1176, 10-1180, 10-1178, 10-1179]
(Knauss, Charles)
08/17/2010 CLERK'S ORDER filed [1260829] granting in part motion to extend time [1260197-2]; extending order
1 pg, 41.01 KB initial submissions -- dispositive motions for all parties due 09/10/2010; certified index to record due
09/10/2010. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1180, 10-1176, 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-
1169, 10-1178, 10-1179]

08/31/2010 MODIFIED PARTY FILER--MOTION filed [1263424] by Center for Biological Diversity to participate as
16 pg, 33.36 KB amicus curiae. [Disclosure Listing: Attached] [Service Date: 08/31/2010 ] [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169,
10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180]--[Edited 08/31/2010
by JMC] (Pardee, Vera)
09/10/2010 MOTION filed [1265173] by EPA and Lisa Perez Jackson in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-
75 pg, 3.13 MB 1174, 10-1180, 10-1176, EPA in 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179 to dismiss case for lack of
jurisdiction (Response to Motion served by mail due on 09/23/2010) [Service Date: 09/10/2010 by
CM/ECF NDA] Pages: 16-20. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176,
10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Lipshultz, Jon)
09/10/2010 NOPPO ED MOTION filed [1265267] by EPA and Lisa Perez Jackson in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170,
4 pg, 68.93 KB 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1180, 10-1176, EPA in 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179 to extend
time to file certified index to 14 days following decision on motion to dismiss. [Service Date: 09/10/2010 ]
Pages: 1-10. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-
1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Lipshultz, Jon)
09/13/2010 RESPONSE FILED [1265543] by American Frozen Food Institute, American Petroleum Institute, Brick
8 pg, 19.41 KB Industry Association, Corn Refiners Association, Inc., Glass Packaging Institute, Independent Petroleum
Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers Association, Mississippi Manufacturers Association,
National Association of Home Builders, National Association of Manufacturers, National Oilseed
Processors Association, National Petrochemical and Refiners Association, Specialty Steel Industry of
North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry, West Virginia Manufacturers
Association, Western States Petroleum Association and Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-
1180, 10-1176, American Frozen Food Institute, American Petroleum Institute, Brick Industry
Association, Corn Refiners Association, Inc., Glass Packaging Institute, Independent Petroleum
Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers Association, Mississippi Manufacturers Association,
National Association of Home Builders, National Association of Manufacturers, National Oilseed
Processors Association, National Petrochemical & Refiners Association, Specialty Steel Industry of
North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry, West Virginia Manufacturers
Association, Western States Petroleum Association and Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-
1178, 10-1179 to motion to participate as amicus curiae [1263424-2] [Service Date: 09/13/2010 by
CM/ECF NDA] Pages: 1-10. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176,
10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Knauss, Charles)

09/15/2010 CLERK'S ORDER filed [1266050] granting motion of Center for Biological Diversity to participate as
1 pg, 39.37 KB amicus curiae [1263424-2]; considering response [1265543-2] [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-
1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180]

09/17/2010 NOPPO ED MOTION filed [1266396] by American Chemistry Council in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170,
5 pg, 13.14 KB Clean Air Implementation Project in 10-1173, 10-1174, American Frozen Food Institute, American
Petroleum Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners Association, Inc., Glass Packaging
Institute, Independent Petroleum Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers Association,
Mississippi Manufacturers Association, National Association of Home Builders, National Association of
Manufacturers, National Oilseed Processors Association, National Petrochemical and Refiners
Association, Specialty Steel Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry,
West Virginia Manufacturers Association, Western States Petroleum Association and Wisconsin
Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-1180, American Petroleum Institute, Brick Industry Association,
Corn Refiners Association, Inc., Glass Packaging Institute, Independent Petroleum Association of
America, Michigan Manufacturers Association, Mississippi Manufacturers Association, National
Association of Home Builders, National Association of Manufacturers, National Oilseed Processors
h p ://ecf.cadc. co .go /cmecf/ e le /T an po Room 10/18
2/29/12 10-1167 Docke
Association, National Petrochemical and Refiners Association, Specialty Steel Industry of North
America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry, West Virginia Manufacturers Association,
Western States Petroleum Association and Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-1176, 10-
1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, American Frozen Food Institute, American Petroleum Institute, Brick Industry
Association, Corn Refiners Association, Inc., Glass Packaging Institute, Independent Petroleum
Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers Association, Mississippi Manufacturers Association,
National Association of Home Builders, National Association of Manufacturers, National Oilseed
Processors Association, National Petrochemical & Refiners Association, Specialty Steel Industry of
North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry, West Virginia Manufacturers
Association, Western States Petroleum Association and Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-
1178, 10-1179 to extend time to file motion to 09/30/2010. Pages: 1-10. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-
1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Webster, Timothy)
09/22/2010 INCORRECT PDF WAS ATTACHED--RESPONSE IN SUPPORT FILED [1267523] by Conservation Law
0 pg, 0 KB Foundation, Environmental Defense Fund, Natural Resources Defense Council and Sierra Club in 10-1167
[Service Date: 09/22/2010 by CM/ECF NDA] Pages: 1-10. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-
1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180]--[Edited 09/24/2010 by JMC]
(Weeks, Ann)

09/24/2010 CO EC ED RESPONSE IN SUPPORT FILED [1267864] by Conservation Law Foundation,

3 pg, 114.8 KB Environmental Defense Fund, Natural Resources Defense Council and Sierra Club in 10-1167 [Service
Date: 09/24/2010 by CM/ECF NDA] Pages: 1-10. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-
1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Weeks, Ann)
09/30/2010 JOIN RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION lodged [1269170] by American Chemistry Council in 10-1167, 10-
182 pg, 2.14 MB 1168, 10-1170, Clean Air Implementation Project in 10-1173, 10-1174, American Frozen Food Institute,
American Petroleum Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners Association, Inc., Glass
Packaging Institute, Independent Petroleum Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers
Association, Mississippi Manufacturers Association, National Association of Home Builders, National
Association of Manufacturers, National Oilseed Processors Association, National Petrochemical and
Refiners Association, Specialty Steel Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and
Industry, West Virginia Manufacturers Association, Western States Petroleum Association and
Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-1180, 10-1176, 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, American
Frozen Food Institute, American Petroleum Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners
Association, Inc., Glass Packaging Institute, Independent Petroleum Association of America, Michigan
Manufacturers Association, Mississippi Manufacturers Association, National Association of Home
Builders, National Association of Manufacturers, National Oilseed Processors Association, National
Petrochemical & Refiners Association, Specialty Steel Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber of
Commerce and Industry, West Virginia Manufacturers Association, Western States Petroleum
Association and Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-1178, 10-1179 to motion to dismiss
case for lack of jurisdiction [1265173-2] [Service Date: 09/30/2010 by CM/ECF NDA, US Mail] Pages: 16-
20. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-
1179, 10-1180] (Knauss, Charles)

10/12/2010 REPLY FILED [1271129] by EPA and Lisa Perez Jackson in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-
13 pg, 35.97 KB 1174, 10-1180, 10-1176, EPA in 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179 to response [1269170-2]
[Service Date: 10/12/2010 by CM/ECF NDA] Pages: 1-10. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-
1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Lipshultz, Jon)
10/25/2010 CLERK'S ORDER filed [1273459] granting motion to extend time [1265267-2]; certified index due 14 days
1 pg, 40.19 KB after disposition of motion to dismiss. Granting motion to extend time to file response [1266396-2]; The
Clerk is directed to file lodged response [1269170-2] [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-
1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180]
10/25/2010 PER ABOVE ORDER lodged response [1269170-2] is filed [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-
1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180]
12/14/2010 PER CURIAM ORDER filed [1282866] referring motion to dismiss case for lack of jurisdiction [1265173-2]
2 pg, 42.95 KB to the merits panel to which this case is assigned. FURTHER ORDERED, on the court s own motion,
that the parties show cause, within 30 days of the date of this order, why these consolidated cases
should not be held in abeyance. Each party may respond, within 15 days, to the response to the order to
show cause filed by the other party. Response may not exceed 10 pages Before Judges: Ginsburg, Tatel
and Brown. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-
1178, 10-1179, 10-1180]

01/13/2011 RESPONSE FILED [1287874] by EPA and Lisa Perez Jackson in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170, 10-1173,
8 pg, 21.5 KB 10-1174, 10-1180, 10-1176, EPA in 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179 to order [Service Date:
01/13/2011 by CM/ECF NDA] Pages: 1-10. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-

h p ://ecf.cadc. co .go /cmecf/ e le /T an po Room 11/18

2/29/12 10-1167 Docke
1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Lipshultz, Jon)
01/13/2011 JOIN RESPONSE FILED [1287900] by American Chemistry Council in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170,
12 pg, 106.9 KB Clean Air Implementation Project in 10-1173, 10-1174, American Frozen Food Institute, American
Petroleum Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners Association, Inc., Glass Packaging
Institute, Independent Petroleum Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers Association,
Mississippi Manufacturers Association, National Association of Home Builders, National Association of
Manufacturers, National Oilseed Processors Association, National Petrochemical and Refiners
Association, Specialty Steel Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry,
West Virginia Manufacturers Association, Western States Petroleum Association and Wisconsin
Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-1180, 10-1176, 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, American Frozen Food
Institute, American Petroleum Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners Association, Inc.,
Glass Packaging Institute, Independent Petroleum Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers
Association, Mississippi Manufacturers Association, National Association of Home Builders, National
Association of Manufacturers, National Oilseed Processors Association, National Petrochemical &
Refiners Association, Specialty Steel Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and
Industry, West Virginia Manufacturers Association, Western States Petroleum Association and
Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-1178, 10-1179 to order [1282866-3],[1282866-2] [Service
Date: 01/13/2011 by CM/ECF NDA] Pages: 1-10. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-
1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Webster, Timothy)

01/28/2011 JOIN REPLY FILED [1290639] by American Chemistry Council in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170, Clean Air
12 pg, 26.32 KB Implementation Project in 10-1173, 10-1174, American Frozen Food Institute, American Petroleum
Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners Association, Inc., Glass Packaging Institute,
Independent Petroleum Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers Association, Mississippi
Manufacturers Association, National Association of Home Builders, National Association of
Manufacturers, National Oilseed Processors Association, National Petrochemical and Refiners
Association, Specialty Steel Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry,
West Virginia Manufacturers Association, Western States Petroleum Association and Wisconsin
Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-1180, 10-1176, 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, American Frozen Food
Institute, American Petroleum Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners Association, Inc.,
Glass Packaging Institute, Independent Petroleum Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers
Association, Mississippi Manufacturers Association, National Association of Home Builders, National
Association of Manufacturers, National Oilseed Processors Association, National Petrochemical &
Refiners Association, Specialty Steel Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and
Industry, West Virginia Manufacturers Association, Western States Petroleum Association and
Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-1178, 10-1179 to response [1287874-2] [Service Date:
01/28/2011 by CM/ECF NDA] Pages: 1-10. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-
1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Webster, Timothy)

02/02/2011 INCORRECT PDF WAS ATTACHED--CLERK'S ORDER filed [1291130] granting motion for leave to
1 pg, 40.24 KB intervene. [1259235-2], granting motion for leave to intervene. [1259225-2] [10-1167]--[Edited 02/02/2011
by JMC]

03/18/2011 PER CURIAM ORDER filed [1299003] ORDERED that the order to show cause be discharged. [1282866-
3 pg, 46.77 KB 2], setting briefing schedule: PETITIONER Brief due 05/10/2011. INTERVENOR for PETITIONER Brief
due 05/24/2011. RESPONDENT Brief due on 06/23/2011. INTERVENOR for RESPONDENT Brief due
07/07/2011. AMICUS for RESPONDENT Brief due 07/07/2011. PETITIONER Reply Brief due 07/21/2011.
INTERVENOR for PETITIONER Reply Brief due 07/21/2011. Appendix due 07/29/2011. PETITIONER
Final Brief due 08/05/2011. INTERVENOR for PETITIONER Final Brief due 08/05/2011. RESPONDENT
Final Brief due on 08/05/2011. INTERVENOR for RESPONDENT Final Brief due 08/05/2011. AMICUS for
RESPONDENT Final Brief due 08/05/2011. PETITIONER Final Reply Brief due 08/05/2011.
INTERVENOR for PETITIONER Final Reply Brief due 08/05/2011. The Clerk is directed to schedule this
case for oral argument before the same panel that is hearing Nos. 09-1322, 10-1073, and 10-1092. Before
Judges: Henderson, Garland and Kavanaugh. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174,
10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180]

04/29/2011 ENTRY OF APPEARANCE filed [1305629] by Amanda Shafer Berman on behalf of Respondents EPA
2 pg, 8.28 KB and Lisa Perez Jackson in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1180, 10-1176, Respondent
EPA in 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-
1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Berman, Amanda)
04/29/2011 CERTIFIED INDEX TO RECORD [1305642] by EPA and Lisa Perez Jackson in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-
199 pg, 10.71 MB 1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1180, 10-1176, EPA in 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179
[Service Date: 04/29/2011 ] [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176,
10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Berman, Amanda)

05/10/2011 ENTRY OF APPEARANCE filed [1307217] by Charles H. Knauss and co-counsel Shannon S. Broome

h p ://ecf.cadc. co .go /cmecf/ e le /T an po Room 12/18

2/29/12 10-1167 Docke
4 pg, 75.13 KB Bryan M. Killian on behalf of Petitioners American Frozen Food Institute, American Petroleum Institute,
Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners Association, Glass Packaging Institute, Independent
Petroleum Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers Association, Mississippi Manufacturers
Association, National Association of Home Builders, National Association of Manufacturers, National
Oilseed Processors Association, National Petrochemical & Refiners Association, Specialty Steel
Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry, West Virginia Manufacturers
Association, Western States Petroleum Association and Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-
1180, 10-1176, 10-1178, 10-1179. [10-1167, 10-1176, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Knauss, Charles)
05/10/2011 PETITIONER BRIEF [1307254] filed by American Chemistry Council in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170, Clean
0 pg, 0 KB Air Implementation Project in 10-1173, 10-1174, American Frozen Food Institute, American Petroleum
Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners Association, Glass Packaging Institute, Independent
Petroleum Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers Association, Mississippi Manufacturers
Association, National Association of Home Builders, National Association of Manufacturers, National
Oilseed Processors Association, National Petrochemical & Refiners Association, Specialty Steel
Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry, West Virginia Manufacturers
Association, Western States Petroleum Association and Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-
1180, 10-1176, 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179 [Service Date: 05/10/2011 ] Length of Brief:
11,932 Words. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-
1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Knauss, Charles)

06/09/2011 ENTRY OF APPEARANCE filed [1312507] by Amanda Berman and co-counsel Perry M. Rosen on
1 pg, 402.13 KB behalf of Respondents EPA and Lisa Perez Jackson in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174,
10-1180, 10-1176, Respondent EPA in 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179. [10-1167, 10-1168,
10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Rosen,
Perry)
06/17/2011 ENTRY OF APPEARANCE filed [1313830] by Peter Zalzal on behalf of Intervenor for Respondent
1 pg, 53.23 KB Environmental Defense Fund. [10-1167] (Zalzal, Peter)

06/22/2011 RESPONDENT BRIEF [1314737] filed by EPA and Lisa Perez Jackson in 10-1167 [Service Date:
0 pg, 0 KB 06/22/2010 ] Length of Brief: 14000 words. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-
1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Berman, Amanda)

06/24/2011 MODIFIED DOCKET TEXT--NOTICE FILED [1315150] by American Petroleum Institute in 10-1178, 10-
5 pg, 13.69 KB 1179 to substitute attorney Michele Schoeppe substituted by Wayne D'Angelo [Service Date: 06/24/2011
] [10-1167, 10-1178, 10-1179]--[Edited 06/24/2011 by JMC] (Knauss, Charles)

07/07/2011 ENTRY OF APPEARANCE filed [1317372] by Sean H. Donahue on behalf of Intervenor for Respondent
1 pg, 420.2 KB Environmental Defense Fund in 10-1167. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-
1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Donahue, Sean)
07/07/2011 INCORRECT DOCKET ENTRY-DISREGARD--MODIFIED EVENT FROM FILED TO LODGED--AMICUS
0 pg, 0 KB FOR RESPONDENT BRIEF [1317373] lodged by Center for Biological Diversity in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-
1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1180, 10-1176, 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179 [Service Date:
07/07/2011 ] Length of Brief: 4,241 Words. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-
1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180]--[Edited 07/08/2011 by JMC] (Pardee, Vera)

07/07/2011 INTERVENOR FOR RESPONDENT BRIEF [1317374] filed by Conservation Law Foundation,
0 pg, 0 KB Environmental Defense Fund, Natural Resources Defense Council and Sierra Club [Service Date:
07/07/2011 ] Length of Brief: 8695 word. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-
1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Donahue, Sean)

07/11/2011 MODIFIED PARTY FILER--CO EC ED AMICUS FOR RESPONDENT BRIEF [1317845] filed by Center
0 pg, 0 KB for Biological Diversity [Service Date: 07/11/2011 ] Length of Brief: 4,241 words. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-
1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180]--[Edited
07/11/2011 by JMC] (Pardee, Vera)
07/19/2011 LETTER FILED [1319592] by EPA and Lisa Perez Jackson in 10-1167 pursuant to FRAP 28j advising of
2 pg, 18.39 KB additional authorities [Service Date: 07/19/2011 ] [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-
1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Berman, Amanda)

07/21/2011 JOIN PETITIONER REPLY BRIEF [1320046] filed by American Chemistry Council in 10-1167, 10-1168,
0 pg, 0 KB 10-1170, Clean Air Implementation Project in 10-1173, 10-1174, American Frozen Food Institute,
American Petroleum Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners Association, Glass Packaging
Institute, Independent Petroleum Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers Association,
Mississippi Manufacturers Association, National Association of Home Builders, National Association of
Manufacturers, National Oilseed Processors Association, National Petrochemical & Refiners
Association, Specialty Steel Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry,
West Virginia Manufacturers Association, Western States Petroleum Association and Wisconsin
h p ://ecf.cadc. co .go /cmecf/ e le /T an po Room 13/18
2/29/12 10-1167 Docke
Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-1180, 10-1176, 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179
[Service Date: 07/21/2011 ] Length of Brief: 6,949 words. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173,
10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Knauss, Charles)
07/29/2011 NOTICE FILED [1321592] filed by American Chemistry Council in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170, Clean Air
5 pg, 67.59 KB Implementation Project in 10-1173, 10-1174, American Frozen Food Institute, American Petroleum
Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners Association, Glass Packaging Institute, Independent
Petroleum Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers Association, Mississippi Manufacturers
Association, National Association of Home Builders, National Association of Manufacturers, National
Oilseed Processors Association, National Petrochemical & Refiners Association, Specialty Steel
Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry, West Virginia Manufacturers
Association, Western States Petroleum Association and Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-
1180, 10-1176, 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179 Notice of Intent to file Joint Appendix in
paper format. [Service Date: 07/29/2011 ] [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-
1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Knauss, Charles)

07/29/2011 JOIN RESPONSE FILED [1321675] by American Chemistry Council in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170,
2 pg, 23.72 KB Clean Air Implementation Project in 10-1173, 10-1174, American Frozen Food Institute, American
Petroleum Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners Association, Glass Packaging Institute,
Independent Petroleum Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers Association, Mississippi
Manufacturers Association, National Association of Home Builders, National Association of
Manufacturers, National Oilseed Processors Association, National Petrochemical & Refiners
Association, Specialty Steel Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry,
West Virginia Manufacturers Association, Western States Petroleum Association and Wisconsin
Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-1180, 10-1176, 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179 to
letter Rule 28j authorities [1319592-2], letter [1319592-3] [Service Date: 07/29/2011 by CM/ECF NDA]
Pages: 1-10. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-
1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Knauss, Charles)

07/29/2011 APPENDIX [1325447] filed [Volumes: 3] [Service Date: 07/29/2011 ] [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-
1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180]

08/03/2011 RESPONDENT FINAL BRIEF [1322352] filed by EPA and Lisa Perez Jackson in 10-1167 [Service Date:
88 pg, 233.77 KB 08/03/2011 ] Length of Brief: 13,963 words. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-
1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Berman, Amanda)

08/05/2011 JOIN PETITIONER FINAL BRIEF [1322724] filed by American Chemistry Council in 10-1167, 10-1168,
116 pg, 2.26 MB 10-1170, Clean Air Implementation Project in 10-1173, 10-1174, American Frozen Food Institute,
American Petroleum Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners Association, Glass Packaging
Institute, Independent Petroleum Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers Association,
Mississippi Manufacturers Association, National Association of Home Builders, National Association of
Manufacturers, National Oilseed Processors Association, National Petrochemical & Refiners
Association, Specialty Steel Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry,
West Virginia Manufacturers Association, Western States Petroleum Association and Wisconsin
Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-1180, 10-1176, 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179
[Service Date: 08/05/2011 ] Length of Brief: 11,942 Words. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-
1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Knauss, Charles)

08/05/2011 JOIN PETITIONER FINAL REPLY BRIEF [1322726] filed by American Chemistry Council in 10-1167,
39 pg, 175.59 KB 10-1168, 10-1170, Clean Air Implementation Project in 10-1173, 10-1174, American Frozen Food
Institute, American Petroleum Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners Association, Glass
Packaging Institute, Independent Petroleum Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers
Association, Mississippi Manufacturers Association, National Association of Home Builders, National
Association of Manufacturers, National Oilseed Processors Association, National Petrochemical &
Refiners Association, Specialty Steel Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and
Industry, West Virginia Manufacturers Association, Western States Petroleum Association and
Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-1180, 10-1176, 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-
1179 [Service Date: 08/05/2011 ] Length of Brief: 6,955 Words. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-
1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Knauss, Charles)
08/05/2011 INTERVENOR FOR RESPONDENT FINAL BRIEF [1322849] filed by Conservation Law Foundation,
62 pg, 1002.16 KB Environmental Defense Fund, Natural Resources Defense Council and Sierra Club [Service Date:
08/05/2011 ] Length of Brief: 8690 words. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-
1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Donahue, Sean)

08/25/2011 AMICUS FOR RESPONDENT FINAL BRIEF [1326092] filed by Center for Biological Diversity in 10-1167,
34 pg, 66.25 KB 10-1168, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1180, 10-1176, 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179
[Service Date: 08/25/2011 ] Length of Brief: 4241. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-

h p ://ecf.cadc. co .go /cmecf/ e le /T an po Room 14/18

2/29/12 10-1167 Docke
1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Pardee, Vera)
11/02/2011 CLERK'S ORDER filed [1339580] scheduling oral argument before Judges SENTELLE, ROGERS, TATEL
1 pg, 40.46 KB Wednesday, 02/29/2012 AM. The court anticipates that argument will be schedule over two days [Nos.
09-1322, 10-1073, 10-1092, 10-1167]. Counsel will be notified of the argument format and allotted times
at a later date. All counsel in each of these cases, therefore, should plan to be available for argument on
both February 28 and February 29, 2012. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-
1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180]
12/14/2011 NOTICE FILED [1347520] by American Frozen Food Institute, American Petroleum Institute, Brick
3 pg, 9.71 KB Industry Association, Corn Refiners Association, Glass Packaging Institute, Independent Petroleum
Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers Association, Mississippi Manufacturers Association,
National Association of Home Builders, National Association of Manufacturers, National Oilseed
Processors Association, National Petrochemical & Refiners Association, Specialty Steel Industry of
North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry, West Virginia Manufacturers
Association, Western States Petroleum Association and Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-
1176, 10-1180, 10-1178, 10-1179 to withdraw attorney Bryan Michael Killian who represented Wisconsin
Manufacturers and Commerce, Western States Petroleum Association, West Virginia Manufacturers
Association, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry, Specialty Steel Industry of North America,
National Petrochemical & Refiners Association, National Oilseed Processors Association, National
Association of Manufacturers, National Association of Home Builders, Mississippi Manufacturers
Association, Michigan Manufacturers Association, Independent Petroleum Association of America, Glass
Packaging Institute, Corn Refiners Association, Brick Industry Association, American Petroleum Institute
and American Frozen Food Institute in 10-1176, Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce, Western
States Petroleum Association, West Virginia Manufacturers Association, Tennessee Chamber of
Commerce and Industry, Specialty Steel Industry of North America, National Petrochemical & Refiners
Association, National Oilseed Processors Association, National Association of Manufacturers, National
Association of Home Builders, Mississippi Manufacturers Association, Michigan Manufacturers
Association, Independent Petroleum Association of America, Glass Packaging Institute, Corn Refiners
Association, Brick Industry Association, American Petroleum Institute and American Frozen Food
Institute in 10-1178, Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce, Western States Petroleum Association,
West Virginia Manufacturers Association, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry, Specialty
Steel Industry of North America, National Petrochemical & Refiners Association, National Oilseed
Processors Association, National Association of Manufacturers, National Association of Home Builders,
Mississippi Manufacturers Association, Michigan Manufacturers Association, Independent Petroleum
Association of America, Glass Packaging Institute, Corn Refiners Association, Brick Industry
Association, American Petroleum Institute and American Frozen Food Institute in 10-1179 and
Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce, Western States Petroleum Association, West Virginia
Manufacturers Association, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry, Specialty Steel Industry of
North America, National Petrochemical & Refiners Association, National Oilseed Processors
Association, National Association of Manufacturers, National Association of Home Builders, Mississippi
Manufacturers Association, Michigan Manufacturers Association, Independent Petroleum Association of
America, Glass Packaging Institute, Corn Refiners Association, Brick Industry Association, American
Petroleum Institute and American Frozen Food Institute in 10-1180, David B. Salmons who represented
Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce, Western States Petroleum Association, West Virginia
Manufacturers Association, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry, Specialty Steel Industry of
North America, National Petrochemical & Refiners Association, National Oilseed Processors
Association, National Association of Manufacturers, National Association of Home Builders, Mississippi
Manufacturers Association, Michigan Manufacturers Association, Independent Petroleum Association of
America, Glass Packaging Institute, Corn Refiners Association, Brick Industry Association, American
Petroleum Institute and American Frozen Food Institute in 10-1176, Wisconsin Manufacturers and
Commerce, West Virginia Manufacturers Association, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry,
National Petrochemical & Refiners Association, National Oilseed Processors Association, National
Association of Manufacturers, Michigan Manufacturers Association, Independent Petroleum Association
of America, Corn Refiners Association and Brick Industry Association in 10-1178, Wisconsin
Manufacturers and Commerce, West Virginia Manufacturers Association, Tennessee Chamber of
Commerce and Industry, National Petrochemical & Refiners Association, National Oilseed Processors
Association, National Association of Manufacturers, Independent Petroleum Association of America,
Corn Refiners Association and Brick Industry Association in 10-1179 and Wisconsin Manufacturers and
Commerce, Western States Petroleum Association, West Virginia Manufacturers Association,
Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry, Specialty Steel Industry of North America, National
Petrochemical & Refiners Association, National Oilseed Processors Association, National Association of
Manufacturers, National Association of Home Builders, Mississippi Manufacturers Association, Michigan
Manufacturers Association, Independent Petroleum Association of America, Glass Packaging Institute,
Corn Refiners Association, Brick Industry Association, American Petroleum Institute and American
Frozen Food Institute in 10-1180 [Service Date: 12/14/2011 ] [10-1176, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180]
(Salmons, David)
h p ://ecf.cadc. co .go /cmecf/ e le /T an po Room 15/18
2/29/12 10-1167 Docke

01/06/2012 LETTER SENT [1351509] concerning oral argument format - Proposed formats due 02/03/2012 . (SEE
1 pg, 57.11 KB LETTER FOR DETAILS) [1339580-3] [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1175,
10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180]

01/31/2012 NOTICE FILED [1355721] by National Petrochemical & Refiners Association in 10-1180, 10-1176, 10-
3 pg, 9.18 KB 1178, 10-1179 Notice of Name Change. [Service Date: 01/31/2012 ] [10-1167, 10-1176, 10-1178, 10-
1179, 10-1180] (Broome, Shannon)

01/31/2012 AMENDED STATEMENT FILED [1355728] by National Petrochemical & Refiners Association in 10-1180,
3 pg, 10.25 KB 10-1176, 10-1178, 10-1179 with Disclosure Listing [Service Date: 01/31/2012 ] [10-1167, 10-1176, 10-
1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Broome, Shannon)

02/03/2012 ENTRY OF APPEARANCE filed [1356523] by (Lead counsel already established) and co-counsel Peter
1 pg, 37.99 KB D. Keisler on behalf of Petitioner American Chemistry Council in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170, 10-1169.
[10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170] (Keisler, Peter)
02/03/2012 ENTRY OF APPEARANCE filed [1356528] by (Lead counsel already established) and co-counsel Peter
1 pg, 37.52 KB D. Keisler on behalf of Petitioners American Frozen Food Institute, American Fuel & Petrochemical
Manufacturers, American Petroleum Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners Association,
Glass Packaging Institute, Independent Petroleum Association of America, Michigan Manufacturers
Association, Mississippi Manufacturers Association, National Association of Home Builders, National
Association of Manufacturers, National Oilseed Processors Association, Specialty Steel Industry of
North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry, West Virginia Manufacturers
Association, Western States Petroleum Association and Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce in 10-
1176, 10-1180, 10-1178, 10-1179. [10-1176, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Keisler, Peter)

02/03/2012 RESPONSE FILED [1356560] by EPA in 10-1167 to letter oral argument format [1351509-2] [Service
10 pg, 28 KB Date: 02/03/2012 by CM/ECF NDA] Pages: 1-10. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-
1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Berman, Amanda)

02/03/2012 JOIN RESPONSE FILED [1356584] by American Chemistry Council in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170,
20 pg, 48.15 KB Clean Air Implementation Project in 10-1173, 10-1174, American Frozen Food Institute, American Fuel &
Petrochemical Manufacturers, American Petroleum Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners
Association, Glass Packaging Institute, Independent Petroleum Association of America, Michigan
Manufacturers Association, Mississippi Manufacturers Association, National Association of Home
Builders, National Association of Manufacturers, National Oilseed Processors Association, Specialty
Steel Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry, West Virginia
Manufacturers Association, Western States Petroleum Association and Wisconsin Manufacturers and
Commerce in 10-1180, 10-1176, 10-1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179 to letter oral argument
format [1351509-2] [Service Date: 02/03/2012 by US Mail, CM/ECF NDA] Pages: 1-10. [10-1167, 10-
1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180]
(Burgess, William)

02/08/2012 PER CURIAM ORDER filed [1357330] allocating oral argument time as follows: Tuesday, February 28,
5 pg, 50.11 KB 9:30 A.M.; I. No. 09-1322 (and consolidated cases), Endangerment Finding – 1 hour, 30 minutes total.
(Petitioners and Supporting Intervenors -- 45 minutes; Respondents and Supporting Intervenors-- 45
minutes); II. No. 10-1092 (and consolidated cases), Tailpipe Rule – 40 minutes total (Petitioners and
Supporting Intervenors -- 20 minutes; Respondents and Supporting Intervenors -- 20 minutes).
Wednesday, February 29, 9:30 A.M.; III. No. 10-1167 (and consolidated cases), Historic Regulations; No.
10-1073 (and consolidated cases), Timing and Tailoring Rules – 2 hours, 30 minutes total (Petitioners
and Supporting Intervenors -- 75 minutes; Respondents and Supporting Intervenors-- 75 minutes). The
panel will hear consolidated argument for Case Nos. 10-1167 and 10-1073. The parties are instructed to
address the jurisdictional issues specific to each case first (i.e., the timeliness of the challenge to the
historic regulations and standing to challenge the Timing and Tailoring Rules). In each case, parties may
divide argument time among counsel for Petitioners/Respondents and supporting Intervenors as they see
fit. Form 72, which may be accessed through the link on this order, must be completed and returned to
the Clerk s office by February 17, 2012. directing party to file Form 72 notice of arguing attorney - due
02/17/2012 Before Judges: Sentelle, Rogers and Tatel. [09-1322, 10-1024, 10-1025, 10-1026, 10-1030,
10-1035, 10-1036, 10-1037, 10-1038, 10-1039, 10-1040, 10-1041, 10-1042, 10-1044, 10-1045, 10-1046,
10-1073, 10-1083, 10-1099, 10-1109, 10-1110, 10-1114, 10-1118, 10-1119, 10-1120, 10-1122, 10-1123,
10-1124, 10-1125, 10-1126, 10-1127, 10-1128, 10-1129, 10-1131, 10-1132, 10-1145, 10-1147, 10-1148,
10-1199, 10-1200, 10-1201, 10-1202, 10-1203, 10-1206, 10-1207, 10-1208, 10-1210, 10-1211, 10-1212,
10-1213, 10-1216, 10-1218, 10-1219, 10-1220, 10-1221, 10-1222, 10-1092, 10-1094, 10-1134, 10-1143,
10-1144, 10-1152, 10-1156, 10-1158, 10-1159, 10-1160, 10-1161, 10-1162, 10-1163, 10-1164, 10-1166,
10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179,
10-1180, 10-1182, 10-1234, 10-1235, 10-1239, 10-1245, 10-1281, 10-1310, 10-1318, 10-1319, 10-1320,
10-1321]--[Edited 02/08/2012 by MCM]

h p ://ecf.cadc. co .go /cmecf/ e le /T an po Room 16/18

2/29/12 10-1167 Docke

02/16/2012 FORM 72 submitted by arguing attorney, Peter Keisler, on behalf of Petitioner American Chemistry
Council in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170, Petitioners American Frozen Food Institute, American Fuel &
Petrochemical Manufacturers, American Petroleum Institute, Brick Industry Association, Corn Refiners
Association, Glass Packaging Institute, Independent Petroleum Association of America, Michigan
Manufacturers Association, Mississippi Manufacturers Association, National Association of Home
Builders, National Association of Manufacturers, National Oilseed Processors Association, Specialty
Steel Industry of North America, Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry, West Virginia
Manufacturers Association, Western States Petroleum Association and Wisconsin Manufacturers and
Commerce in 10-1180, 10-1176, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-
1176, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Keisler, Peter)

02/17/2012 FORM 72 submitted by arguing attorney, Sean H. Donahue, on behalf of Intervenors for Respondent
Conservation Law Foundation, Environmental Defense Fund, Natural Resources Defense Council and
Sierra Club in 10-1167. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-
1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Donahue, Sean)

02/17/2012 FORM 72 submitted by arguing attorney, Perry M. Rosen, on behalf of Respondents EPA and Lisa Perez
Jackson in 10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1180, 10-1176, Respondent EPA in 10-
1175, 10-1177, 10-1169, 10-1178, 10-1179. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-
1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180] (Rosen, Perry)

02/17/2012 FORM 72 submitted by arguing attorney, Amanda Shafer Berman, on behalf of Respondent EPA in 10-
1167. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-
1179, 10-1180] (Berman, Amanda)

02/29/2012 ORAL ARGUMENT HELD before Judges Sentelle, Rogers and Tatel. [10-1167, 10-1168, 10-1169, 10-
1170, 10-1173, 10-1174, 10-1175, 10-1176, 10-1177, 10-1178, 10-1179, 10-1180]

h p ://ecf.cadc. co .go /cmecf/ e le /T an po Room 17/18

2/29/12 10-1167 Docke

Clear All

Documents and Docket Summar

Documents Onl

Include Page Numbers

Selected Pages: 0 Selected Si e: 0 KB (Ma : 15 MB)

Totals reflect accessible documents onl and do not include unauthori ed restricted documents.

View Selected

PACER Service Center

Transaction Receipt

DC Circuit (USCA) - 02/29/2012 14:13:14

PACER ThinkProgress
cf4713 Client Code:
Login: Blog
Docket Report Search
Description: 10-1167
(full) Criteria:
Billable
15 Cost: 1.20
Pages:

h p ://ecf.cadc. co .go /cmecf/ e le /T an po Room 18/18