Sie sind auf Seite 1von 16

This copy of Campus Firewatch is provided to you by EIIA

NOVEMBER 2008
IN PUBLICATION SINCE 2000

From the Editor ................................2 Alcohol and its impact on fire safety
Campus Firewatch Media Project
Trapped in Flames ............................8 By Ed Comeau
Campus Fire Log ..............................9 Ask any fire chief in a college community about the dangers of alcohol and students,
and they will all invariably agree that it is a problem. Furthermore, in looking at fatal
Legislation Update ..........................11
campus-related fires since 2000, a contributing factor in a number of them has been
Campus Firewatch Resources ........16 impaired judgment from alcohol consumption. However, the direct impact of alcohol
on evacuation times has never really been directly evaluated.

Drinking on campuses
There is little doubt that alcohol is a factor on many campuses when it comes to stu-
Remembering Julie dent safety. According to a recent study looking at the impact of the minimum legal
In October, the Pi Beta Phi drinking age on campuses by the National Institute of Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism:
Fraternity for Women launched the Drinking is deeply ingrained in the campus culture at many universities across the
program “Remembering Julie” in Nation. Eighty-three percent of college students drink, and 41 percent report
honor of Julie Turnbull who died in
Continued on page 4
a tragic off-campus fire at Miami
University in Oxford, Ohio, in 2005
along with Kathryn Welling and
Stephen Smith. Julie was a mem-
Smoke alarm testing program at NIST
ber of Pi Phi and a great-great In 2001, the National Institute of Standards and Technology did a series of smoke
granddaughter of one of the alarm tests to evaluate the effectiveness of the alarms under different fire scenarios
founders, so there is a special (the test reports and revision history can be downloaded at smokealarm.nist.gov).
connection for all Pi Phi’s. However, the results from these tests had received criticism from several different
The goal of this program is to organizations and publications (including Campus Firewatch) and the results had to
raise awareness of fire safety be revised several times. A major point of contention was around the performance of
among students by selling flame- the different smoke alarm technologies (photoelectric, ionization and dual-sensor
less candles from Candle smoke alarms) in relation to the tenability conditions. (For more information, a two-
Impressions and is a collaboration part series on this appeared in Campus Firewatch in February and March 2008. In
between the People’s Burn addition, two podcasts on this topic were done on Fire Marshal’s Corner, hosted by Ed
Foundation, Campus Firewatch Comeau, on at www.firehouse.com).
and Pi Beta Phi. Each of the In 2008, NIST undertook another series of tests to again determine the operational
seven chapters in Ohio are selling characteristics of smoke alarms with some changes from the original testing pro-
the candles with 100 percent of gram. According to Tom Cleary, a chemist with NIST’s Building and Fire Research
the proceeds going to fund the Laboratory (BFRL), the testing program involved purchasing a number of off-the-shelf
People’s Burn Foundation’s cam- smoke alarms from retailers and testing them in a full-scale mockup of a residence
pus fire safety education program, using standardized fuel packages, which was not done in the previous tests. In addi-
igot2kno.org (www.igot2kno.org). tion, the actual alarm times of the smoke alarms were monitored and recorded. In
the 2001 tests, this was done through calibration data instead of monitoring actual
alarm activation.
Continued on page 3 Continued on page 7

© 2008 Campus FirewatchTM


2 CAMPUS Firewatch November 2008

Campus Firewatch is a publication of


writer-tech.com, llc, a technical writing
firm specializing in fire safety. All of the
material contained in Campus Firewatch
is copyrighted and may not be reproduced
or distributed without permission.
Campus fire safety is a complex issue.
The information in this newsletter is
In today’s Internet information age, people are drowning in information. There is provided to help you in your efforts to
so much of it coming at them from so many sources that they are having a hard provide as fire-safe a community as
possible. However, it is no replacement
time filtering it and deciding what they need to read and what they have to read
for professional advice. For further assis-
and for this reason you have to prioritize what you are looking at and making tance, contact your local fire department.
decisions on the quality and value of the information.
Subscribe Today!
One thing that I have taken pride in since I started publishing Campus Firewatch You can subscribe to Campus Firewatch,
in 2000 is the fact that the material in here is new and original – it is not simply online, and receive your own copy each
month, right to your email address.
a reprint to fill up space of material that you can get somewhere else. I write Simply visit our web site at
about information that can help you, the campus fire safety professional, in www.campus-firewatch.com.
doing your job better. I take the time to interview experts in the field and get Reprints
their perspectives on issues or problems and do the research to find reports and We welcome reprints of the articles
information that gives more dimension to the articles and I hope that you find it that appear in Campus Firewatch.
informative and useful. Please contact us at
publisher@campus-firewatch.com
Another component of Campus Firewatch that I know I have found invaluable for permission to reprint material.
has been the Firelog which has been reporting on campus-related incidents for Campus FirewatchTM
over eight years. These incidents are gathered from media sources since there a publication of writer-tech.com, llc
is no other source of information on incidents that we can draw on and, prior to P.O. Box 1046
the launch of Campus Firewatch in May 2000, this information was not being Belchertown, MA 01007
PH: (413) 323-6002
compiled anywhere else. This has provided a tremendous amount of data that FX: (413) 460-0092
people can use in making the case for improved education and fire safety on publisher@campus-firewatch.com
their campuses. www.campus-firewatch.com
In order to help you in your efforts I am now posting the information that I have Design and Layout:
McCusker Communications, Inc.
been compiling for over eight years on fatal fires on www.campus-
103 Fensview Drive
firewatch.com. This is being offered in several different ways – as a spread- Westwood, MA 02090
sheet, compiled into a PDF document and visually by using Google Maps. You PH/FX: (781) 762-5030
can look at the very source material that I use regularly and that I am frequently cmccusker@cmccusker.com
asked for. Starting in 2009 I am planning on developing different ways of look- www.cmccusker.com
ing at the information such as geographically, building type, and other cate-
gories.
In 2009 there will be other changes in Campus Firewatch that will help to WANTED-AUTHORS!
streamline it and make it more informative than ever. Do you have any ideas or
Do you have an article that
suggestions? Please let me know! This is the time as I get ready for a new
you would like to write for
year ahead. Campus Firewatch?
Thanks! We’re always looking for articles
on what is happening at
Ed Comeau, the editor of Campus Firewatch, is the former chief fire investigator for the
campuses and in communities
National Fire Protection Association. He began his involvement in campus fire safety as a
across the country.
fire fighter with the Amherst, Massachusetts, fire department while pursuing his degree
Contact us at
in civil engineering. He can be reached at ecomeau@campus-firewatch.com.
ecomeau@campus-firewatch.com
and let’s talk!

© 2008 Campus FirewatchTM


3 CAMPUS Firewatch November 2008

Remembering Julie Continued from page 1

“We did this in memory of Julie,” said In addition to the undergraduates, can- The Ohio Eta chapter at Denison
Katherine Niesen, vice president of dles are also being sold online through University conducted an extensive out-
member development at the Pi Beta Phi Pi Phi Express (www.pibetaphi.org). “We reach campaign that included a table in
chapter at Miami University. While the purchased candles to be a support for the student union, talked about the pro-
fire occurred before any of the present the chapters to ship them extras if they gram during a house brunch with
students came to Miami University, “she needed them,” explained Nicholson. alumni, parents and other Greek houses.
was one of our sorority sisters and all of “We have sold well over half of our “The program has really benefited our
our members knew this and were glad inventory from headquarters. What I chapter as well as our campus with its
to be involved.” think is great bout Pi Phi Express is that original and proactive approach,” said
it hasn’t just limited the program to Ohio Caitlin Kelly, vice president of member
What was the reaction of the other and it lets us reach out to other places development for the chapter.
students? and people can buy a candle and make
a contribution to PBF.” Since the program has not finished up
“They thought it was great that we were yet, final figures are not available.
working to keep her memory alive,” said On the packaging for each candle was a However, by all indications it has been
Niesen. sticker promoting the campus fire safety very successful in helping to bring
education website igot2kno.org that was awareness of fire safety to today’s stu-
“Our original goal was that the program
developed by the People’s Burn dents and to raise funds for the People’s
would only be in October but it is so
Foundation under a Department of Burn Foundation. “We were so happy
successful that some are carrying it
Homeland Security Fire Prevention and with the effort and so happy to keep
through November as well,” said Emily
Safety Grant. In addition, a flyer about Julie’s memory alive,” said Niesen. “It
Nicholson, manager of the Pi Phi
Julie and fire safety tips were also pro- was very successful and we are looking
Express®. According to Nicholson, there
vided to everyone that bought a candle. forward to doing it again next year.”
are over 500 women involved in the
program and the goal was for each of Each chapter was also provided with In addition to being successful, it is a
them to sell two candles, but it has gone copies of the DVD from igot2kno.org wonderful way to remember a wonderful
beyond the undergraduates. “The uni- that had an impactful video program woman.
versities and the alumnae clubs have about fire safety. “A lot of the chapters
showed them in a chapter meeting and If you want to learn more about Julie
been supportive and a key part of the
then also took them to the Pan-Hellenic and the scholarship established in her
campaign because they have gone out
meetings (meetings of all of the sorori- memory, visit www.julieturnbull.com.
with them (the undergraduates) and
ties on a campus) and shared it there,” nnn
have been a support group, helping
them to execute it.” said Nicholson. “It went extremely
well.”

You can subscribe ONLINE at www.campus-firewatch.com, or Fill out the following form and send it with your check.
Name: ________________________________________________________________________________________________

Street Address: __________________________________________________________________________________________

City: ________________________________________________________________________State: _______Zip:___________

Daytime telephone number: ( ______ ) ________________________________________________________________________

Email address: __________________________________________________________________________________________


(Note: this is the address where each issue of Campus Firewatch will be sent)

Please enclose a check for $169.00, payable to: writer-tech.com, llc. Mail this form, with your check to:
Campus Firewatch, c/o writer-tech.com, llc, P.O. Box 1046, Belchertown, MA 01007. Contact us at any time if you
have any questions support@campus-firewatch.com, or 1-413-323-6002

www.campus-firewatch.com
© 2008 Campus FirewatchTM
4 CAMPUS Firewatch November 2008

Alcohol and its impact on fire safety Continued from page 1

drinking five or more drinks on an aren’t too many outreach programs one student was placed in the bedroom
occasion in the past 2 weeks, a par- between the department and the univer- with a safety officer while the other stu-
ticularly dangerous pattern of con- sity. They have their own fire marshal dents were staged in the adjacent bed-
sumption. In addition, anecdotal on campus but there is a gap in off- room. The first evolution was done
reports and some research studies campus housing that no one reaches without any smoke, but there was
indicate that many college students out to.” essentially zero visibility because all of
drink far more than five drinks per MFRI is located right off of the univer- the window shutters were closed. All
occasion. An extreme example is the sity campus and had a training tower ten of the students were run through
practice of attempting to drink 21 that was well suited for simulating con- and this established the baseline time
shots within the first hour starting at ditions that could be found in any stu- for each of them while they were sober.
midnight of one’s 21st birthday, which dent housing. The research program The students were then taken down to
has resulted in alcohol poisonings. was designed with the assistance of the second floor where they were given
The same study goes on to state, MFRI’s research director, Angela controlled amounts of beer based on
“Although colleges may “inherit” drink- Bennett. their body weight to achieve a blood
ing problems, many students do “A simulated apartment on the fourth alcohol concentration (BAC) of 0.03.
increase their consumption when they floor was used,” reported Pantelis. “The National Highway Transportation
get to college.” “Some adjustments were made to make Safety Administration has a chart that
it similar to a dormitory apartment or an shows how many ounces of alcohol a
Measuring the impact of alcohol off-campus apartment with two bed- subject can consume in relation to their
on egress time rooms, a kitchenette, a living room and body weight to achieve target levels of
two hallways.” inebriation,” said Pantelis. It is corre-
An innovative study was undertaken
lated to how much alcohol is consumed
recently at the Maryland Fire Rescue The exercise started with the students over specific periods of time and the sex
Institute (MFRI) in College Park, lying down on a bed in one of the bed- of the subject and, according to
Maryland, to look at this problem. rooms at the end of the hallway in total Pantelis, “That chart worked out better
Andrew Pantelis, a fire technician and darkness. A smoke alarm was activated than anticipated…it was on target 90%
paramedic with the Prince George’s and they then had to get up and navi- of the time.”
County Fire and Rescue and a vice pres- gate out of the room, along one hallway,
ident with the county’s Firefighter and open a door and then along a second After consuming their beer, the students
Paramedic Association, designed this hallway until they encountered a stair- then went back up to the staging area
study as part of his Executive Fire way. The times were recorded from where a University of Maryland police
Officer (EFO) program at the National when they first started evacuating until officer administered a breathalyzer test
Fire Academy. they reached the stairway. and the students’ vitals were taken
again. The group was then taken to the
“This component is for the second year Prior to starting the test, all of the stu- simulated apartment and the evolution
of the program which is the community dents were taken through the simulated was repeated but with one difference –
risk component,” said Pantelis. “Each apartment and shown the layout and the the rooms and hallways were filled with
person has to do an applied research route that they were taking. According theatrical smoke to provide even more
project as part of the four-year program. to Pantelis, this was done because it of a realistic environment.
Basically, what we want to do is gauge was assumed that the students would
the relationship between alcohol con- be familiar with their living environment There were a total of five evolutions
sumption and how long you have to and would know the route to travel to where the students had increasing lev-
escape from a simulated fire.” escape from a fire. els of BAC starting with zero and mov-
ing upwards with 0.03, 0.06, 0.09, 0.12.
Since College Park is the home of the Once this orientation was completed, In between, measured amounts of
University of Maryland, there is a large the students were then taken down- Budweiser beer were provided to the
student population in the area and, trag- stairs where they were divided into two students to raise their BAC to the target
ically, it has also been the site of fatal teams of five. The first team was taken levels. Budweiser was selected,
off-campus student fires. “Over the to a staging area on the third floor according to Pantelis, because it con-
past few years we have responded to where a paramedic took baseline vitals tained 5% alcohol which is what the
two fire fatalities in off-campus hous- on each of the students. The team was NHTSA charts are based on.
ing,” explained Pantelis, “and there then taken up to the fourth floor where
Continued on next page
© 2008 Campus FirewatchTM
5 CAMPUS Firewatch November 2008

Continued from previous page


Throughout the evolutions, safety was a end of the testing, it ranged from 52 the report, “During evacuation of multi-
paramount concern. Whenever a stu- seconds to 1 minute and 25 seconds. unit residential buildings, it was found
dent was moving around, either during What was telling was the perception of that on hearing a fire alarm without any
an evolution or in between, they were the students as they were going through other fire cue, residents generally
escorted by a fire fighter or paramedic. the evolutions. According to Pantelis, “A engage in approximately three minutes
During each evolution a safety office common theme was that each of the of pre-movement activity before begin-
with a thermal imaging camera accom- participants thought they were complet- ning active evacuation. The evacuation
panied each student and monitored their ing the course quicker each time.” movement itself took one minute or
progress and ensured that they were However, the data clearly showed that less. Two-and-a-half minutes of prepa-
not going to be injured. Each student they were actually going slower each ration time was added to this timeframe
was outfitted with a hardhat, gloves and time which was contrary to their per- for a drill conducted during winter con-
knee pads. ception – but expected. ditions.”
Prior to taking part there was an exten- What has also been found by Proulx and
sive screening process for each of the How does this correlate with other researchers is that people often
subjects. The subjects had to be egress times from a house? need at least two cues to believe that it
between the ages of 21 and 26, a med- is not a false alarm but a genuine emer-
Essentially, time is of the essence
ical history was taken to ensure there gency. Even then, research has found
whenever there is a fire in a house. In
were no complicating factors and all of that males are more likely to try and
the 1970’s, the National Institute of
the female subjects were given a preg- fight a fire rather than evacuate while
Standards and Technology (NIST) did a
nancy test. Each person was also women will focus on warning other and
series of tests to determine the amount
administered a standardized Cage ques- evacuating. This is attributed more to
of time that an occupant might have to
tionnaire to ensure that there was no individual’s conventional role in society
escape from a house. These tests were
history of alcoholism. rather than gender and could easily
recently updated and it was found that
Since the research project included live change for a single-parent household
fires are burning hotter and faster
human subjects, it was required to go where the woman may investigate and
because of the high usage of plastics
through an Institutional Review Board fight a fire. The bottom line, however, is
and combustibles in furnishings. This
(IRB) to ensure that all of the proper that all of these activities can decrease
reduces the amount of time that an
safety precautions were taken. This is a the amount of time available for an
occupant has to react from 17 minutes
routine, but comprehensive, process, occupant to safely exit from a building.
in the tests conducted in the 1970’s to
administered by the University on any three minutes in today’s fires, a signifi- Other factors that can contribute to the
research project to ensure that there cant and dramatic reduction in available escape time is searching for a means of
would be no harm to the subjects and it escape time. egress. In a home, where people are
took four months to complete this assumed to be familiar with their sur-
“Some studies on the effectiveness of
process. “They were very concerned roundings, they may not necessarily use
smoke alarms show that it might take a
about safety,” said Pantelis, including the closest means of egress, such as a
minute for people to wake, get their
making sure the students were sober window, but instead attempt to use a
bearings and react,” said Dr. Guylène
before being allowed to leave at the end familiar egress path, such as trying to
Proulx, senior researcher with the
of the project. get to a door.
National Research Council Canada and
an expert in human behavior in fires.
Findings Alcohol and smoke alarm
“Now we are left with a minute to do
“Consistently, across the board, the the pre-evacuation activities and get response
egress times increased with each evolu- out. In a single-family house, the time Some of the most compelling research
tion,” reported Pantelis. “Some partici- to get out might be only 10 seconds.” was conducted by Dr. Dorothy Bruck
pants doubled their times from the and Michelle Ball from Victoria
In a 2006 NRC report co-authored by
baseline evolution to when their BAC University in Melbourne, Australia.
Proulx, it was found that the required
was 0.12 while others increased 125
safe egress time to escape from a sin- In a study conducted by Bruck and Ball,
percent.” The average baseline evolu-
gle-family home could range from 2 students were given controlled amounts
tion when the students were sober was
minutes to 16 minutes. According to of alcohol to drink and then allowed to
between 25 and 35 seconds. By the
Continued on next page
© 2008 Campus FirewatchTM
6 CAMPUS Firewatch November 2008

Continued from previous page


fall asleep in their own beds. Once they across all age groups.” The report con- • Adolescent smokers appear to have a
were fully asleep, they were exposed to tinues, “The increased mortality rate for greater vulnerability to developing
gradually increasing levels of sound that those who have been drinking is a very alcohol-use disorders.
simulate smoke alarms and their important issue for young adults, who • Results indicate that smoking
response was measured. Their are perhaps less experienced drinkers “primes” the brain for subsequent
response while sober was measured to than their older counterparts, and whose addiction to alcohol and possibly
determine a baseline response as well lifestyle traditionally provides more other drugs.”
as their response at 0.05 BAC and 0.08 opportunities for partying, but who also
BAC. have more deep sleep.” The 2006 report by NRC also discussed
the correlation between drinking and
It was found that when students have The report lists a number of ways that smoking by reporting, “It has been sug-
been drinking it takes a much louder alcohol impairment can impact upon a gested that smoking and drinking are
alarm sounding (95 dBA) to respond to person’s response (or non-response) to correlated behaviors – households with
smoke alarms than when they are a fire alarm, including: drinkers tend to be households with
sober. The normal smoke alarm is • Failure to hear alarm smokers.”
required to sound at 75 decibels (dBA)
at the pillow. • Failure to correctly interpret alarm
Drinking and fire safety
What was troubling is the low level of • Inappropriate response, such as a
failure to avoid a dangerous pathway Anecdotally, fire chiefs in college com-
inebriation (0.05 BAC) that caused the
munities agree that alcohol consump-
response capability to significantly dete- • Poor motor functioning, e.g., poor bal-
tion among students is a significant
riorate. In 36% of the trials the test ance and coordination
problem that needs to be addressed. In
subject did not respond until the alarm • Recovery rate from burns is signifi- a number of fatal fires looked at by
level was at 95 dBA or did not respond cantly worse for alcoholics, meaning Campus Firewatch, impaired judgment
at all when they were at 0.05 BAC. This that they may suffer death from more from alcohol consumption has been one
increased to 42% at the 0.08 BAC. minor injuries than non-alcoholics. of the contributing factors to the deaths.
What is notable is that while the
The NRC report states, “Alcohol con-
response capability decreases as the Smoking and alcohol sumption greatly increases the risk of
blood alcohol level increases, it is not as
In an effort to determine the linkage initiating a fire by impairing the judg-
significant as the increase from sobriety
between smoking and alcohol abuse, a ment and coordination of the person.
to 0.05 BAC. In other words, it does not
study was undertaken by Drs. Grucza Intoxication also acutely diminishes a
take much alcohol to cause a significant
and Chen. In it, they found that there is person’s ability to notice the smell of
decrease in the ability to react to an
a definite connection between alcohol smoke or to hear the sound of a smoke
alarm. According to the study, “The
abuse and smoking among adolescents alarm. Escape from a fire can be ham-
meaning of this is that even at what
aged 12 to 20. According to their pered by the loss of motor coordination
many would consider to be low to mod-
research, “Both academic studies and and mental clarity caused by alcohol.”
erate levels, alcohol can seriously affect
casual observation support the view that Campus Firewatch worked closely with
a sleeping person’s ability to respond to
smokers tend to drink, and drinkers USA TODAY in helping the newspaper
their smoke alarm. In fact, many partic-
tend to smoke. New research using prepare a major story on the impact of
ipants reported feeling only slightly
nationally representative data from the alcohol on campus-related fire deaths.
‘tipsy’ at bedtime in the 0.05 BAC con-
U.S. finds that smokers – particularly Research conducted by USA TODAY of
dition.”
adolescent smokers – clearly have a 43 fires that killed 62 students found
Alcohol is a significant problem on greater vulnerability to alcohol-use dis- that:
many campuses, and it has a direct orders (AUDs) than do non-smokers.”
impact upon fire safety as well. • In 59% of the fatal fires, at least one
They go on to point out three key find- student who died had been drinking
According to the study, “Under benign
ings of their research:
circumstances, unimpaired adults aged • In 28% of the fires the smoke detec-
18 to 64 respond well to smoke alarm • “Popular and clinical lore support the tor was absent or had been discon-
signals, and are at a comparatively low strong connection between smoking nected
risk for death. However, alcohol inges- and alcohol consumption.
tion greatly increases fire fatality risk
Continued on next page
© 2008 Campus FirewatchTM
7 CAMPUS Firewatch November 2008

Continued from previous page Smoke alarm testing program at NIST Continued from page 1

• 66% of the victims were juniors or “The method was that the alarms (activation times) were determined from a calibra-
seniors tion, which is valid,” explained Cleary, “but we got to pick the alarm point versus the
actual alarming. They were reasonable alarm points but they weren’t necessarily the
• 65% of the victims were male
ones you would find off-the-shelf.”
• 25% of the fatal fires occurred fol-
In the original testing as well there were some inconsistencies regarding what smoke
lowing a party
alarms were co-located at each testing site and how they were reported. This testing
• In 21 of the cases where an autopsy program has tried to address that issue by trying to have a broader and more consis-
indicated the blood alcohol content, tent placement of photoelectric, ionization and dual sensor smoke alarms.
the average was 0.12 with a high of
This testing program also used standardized fuel packages that were made up of two
0.304
types of fabric, cotton and polyester, over two different types of foam filler (high den-
• Over half, 56%, of the fires occurred sity and low density) all on a metal frame that simulated a chair fire. Two types of
on the two weekend days, Saturday fires, an open flaming fire and a smoldering fire, were used in the testing program.
or Sunday, with 44% occurring during
The tests were conducted in a full-scale mockup of a residence built in the BFRL fire
the rest of the week
research laboratory. The mockup simulated a one-story residence or apartment with
a kitchen, dining room, living room, hallway and a master bedroom. A total of 24 fires
Training is critical were set and the data gathered included alarm times, gas production (carbon monox-
According to Proulx, the training that a ide, carbon dioxide, hydrogen cyanide as well as oxygen levels), visibility, temperature
person receives in how to react during and heat flux.
an emergency is absolutely vital and One of the difficulties that fire professionals grapple with is that of defining tenability.
can play a role throughout their life. Currently, there is no broadly-accepted definition and Cleary is hoping that this testing
“Studies in psychology show that peo- program will provide scientific data to help create that definition. This will be useful
ple that have thought about it (how to in helping to determining optimal smoke alarm activation times so that they sound an
react) beforehand and have a plan of alarm well before conditions become untenable.
action, even years later, it will come Another component of the testing program that Cleary will be undertaking in early
from your long term memory to short 2009 is conducting nuisance alarm testing. This will include testing off-the-shelf
term memory very quickly…if you have smoke alarms under real-world nuisance alarm conditions brought on by cooking.
a plan of action for something you are
going to sue this plan (during an emer- Through this testing, Cleary is hoping that it will be possible to develop more perfor-
gency) because it is something that has mance-based siting criteria instead of the present prescriptive criteria. In regards to
worked in the past rather than creating the photoelectric versus ionization debate that is currently going through the fire ser-
a new solution, especially when time is vice, Cleary said that this testing will provide more data to the people making deci-
limited.” Proulx goes on to explain that sions.
people who survive fires and plane The preliminary results of this testing should be available in approximately February
crashes are typically those that have on the NIST website and they will be reported in Campus Firewatch.
thought through where the closest nnn
means of egress is located and have
talked about it with their family or
roommates.
“What you learn in college may serve
you for the rest of your life,” Proulx
Campus Firewatch Website
explained. The value of this newsletter doesn't stop with just this copy.
nnn
Visit its companion website at www.campus-firewatch.com,
where you will find a wealth of information relating to campus fire safety.
If you have something that you would like to contribute,
please send it to us at
publisher@campus-firewatch.com
See you there!

© 2008 Campus FirewatchTM


8 CAMPUS Firewatch November 2008

Campus Firewatch Media Project


www.campus-firewatch.com

Trapped in the Flames


By Brittany Cagle
This is the November winner of the Campus Firewatch Media Project, co-sponsored by Campus Firewatch, the People’s Burn
Foundation and the Michael H. Minger Foundation. Brittany Cagle is a freshman at Florida Gulf Coast University.

The Station nightclub fire on the evening of Thursday, February 20, I didn’t have a father in the months following. To just look at him was
2003, was the fourth-deadliest nightclub fire in U.S. history, killing heart-wrenching. The image of the four-hundred-and-sixty-two peo-
100 people and injuring more than 200. Ninety-six perished on the ple trapped in the flames made a permanent stamp on his mind. Each
night of the fire, and four died later from their injuries at local hospi- time he closed his eyes he would visualize these faces, and experi-
tals. The Station, which regularly hosted glam metal and 1980s rock ence the pain all over again. With each thought would be the victims
bands, was a nightclub in West Warwick, Rhode Island – In the words he could not rescue. In an instant he had watched these people burn
of Providence Place Journal right before his eyes, unable to reach them in time.
Expect nothing from life, because in an instant all things ordinary can Bewildered, without truly understanding, separated, and young, I had
turn to chaos. Although we can never prepare for these moments, we trouble accepting how fast our lives had changed. My father’s friends
can survive them. My family and I did survive and are stronger from could not help or support the emotions that my father experienced,
the experience. Though I had not known it at the time, the evening of because they did not want to accept what was real. It’s the police-
February 20th, 2003 would flip my world and place my family a thou- man’s way to make light of a tragedy in order to cope. Therefore they
sand miles away from home. The event itself led to the loss of a hun- would mock him, in a joking matter, when the idea of retirement
dred lives in a time span of a few hours and it led to a new finally reached my father’s lips. He was giving it all way, his master’s
perspective of life for thousands. degree and Lieutenant’s rank in police work. He distanced himself
It is now that I visualize my father coming home from his week in from his job- how could he face another episode of such violence?
hell. I am looking at his hands and realizing they are the ones pulling The fire surrounded us everywhere- my neighbors too had been
out the bodies. He is hearing the shrieking screams; witnessing the involved in the fire. Their two bodies could only be identified by
bodies stacked on each other. His mind is reliving it all, I can tell in recovered DNA sampling of teeth found on the floor of The Station.
his eyes; his stare. This is not my father. Amidst all this chaos something truly remarkable occurred. The two
Looking back, I can’t imagine how horrible it must have been for trees standing next to our neighbor’s house, turned completely black.
those people; being trampled and suffocating in an effort of escape. The whole presence of the house then became terrifying because
Their screams roaring through the building, their panic eating at them nothing could explain why the trees became burnt.
from the inside. The fire nipping at their feet, filling their lungs; burn- I’m not sure what sent us packing. It could have been the trees or our
ing their eyes. The echo of a piercing shrill of a fire alarm shrieking realization that we just needed to start a new life. It could have been
into their ears alerting them to the impending danger. my father’s need to escape, to become normal again. Whatever the
I try to visualize a moment of this tragedy. I allow myself to become a reason, we came to Florida. My father began to recover but there will
victim stampeding in the blazing inferno, being crushed into one nar- always be an open wound somewhere inside. Mention the word fire,
row hallway leading to escape; my destiny. As I make my way and his face returns to the same stare as the day I witnessed him
towards an exit I see the injured, the burned, those who had let standing in the kitchen.
smoke inhalation take over their lungs. Videos exist of this horrific I will always be concerned about my dad, and I will worry about any-
event, but these I can not watch because I can barely stand the real- thing that might trigger these harsh memories that play like a
ity of my own creation. slideshow in his head. I don’t want to have him relive this tragedy;
I was thirteen at the time, and was unaware of what was happening hearing those shrieking screams and piecing cries of help. I also
all around me. The smell of smoke lingered on my father’s clothes. I worry about the two children our neighbors left behind. Then there is
remember standing in the kitchen beside him and taking it all in. His also the constant thought of the day an event may happen that sends
eyes were red, and his face was a ghastly white. What I witnessed us packing once again. This is why now I define life as a succession
was terrifying. This was not the man I knew as my father. His smile of moments that must be survived in order to succeed.
was gone, his body trembled from lack of sleep and nutrition. I knew
even though his body was standing before me, his presence was not
there.

Continued on next page


© 2008 Campus FirewatchTM
9 CAMPUS Firewatch November 2008

October 28, 2008


Off-campus apartment
Western Michigan University
Kalamazoo County, Michigan

A massive fire destroyed more than 50 stu-


dent apartments. The cause of the fire was a
single cigarette. The Western Michigan
University has now housed these students in
one of its residence halls. The students are
being helped by the school authorities to get
back into the routine. The fire has affected
The following are brief summaries of incidents that have occurred the studies and professors are working hard
in college occupancies. Unless noted otherwise, they have been to restore the student's schedule.
taken from press accounts and have not been verified for accuracy.
Several of these incidents will be profiled in future issues of October 29, 2008
Campus Firewatch. Washburn University
Topeka, Kansas
If you have an incident that you would like to contribute for this
column, please contact us at publisher@campus-firewatch.com. Heavy smoke was seen coming from the top
floor of the Washburn University Living
October 19, 2008 Learning Center. Students were able to
October 20, 2008
quickly evacuate without anybody getting
Residence Hall Fire Residence hall hurt. The fire was intentionally set and
McMaster University University of Central Florida Police are looking for the suspect. Cash
Mcleans, Canada Orlando, Florida reward of up to $5,500 has been offered to
anyone with information regarding this inci-
There was fire in the university's Branon Hall There was explosion in one of the rooms in dent.
residence building. There were no injuries the UCF residence halls. A student who was
and the extent of damage is still not known. attempting to make Adderall, a prescription October 29, 2008
psychostimulant used to treat attention House fire
The cause of the fire is under investigation. deficit hyperactivity disorder when the Texas State Technical College
explosion happened. There was no fire from
October 19, 2008 the explosion and fortunately no one was
Baylor University, Texas
Off-campus arson injured. Everybody was aske to evacuate.
After a few hours students were allowed to A fire broke out at one of the houses on the
UNM campus campus of Texas State Technical College.
reenter. Investigation is underway.
New Mexcio (Subsequent news reports stated that this The fire was contained in time hence there
may have been a drug lab.) were no injuries. The school structure has
There were 3 fires overnight at the UNM weakened and this is the fourth fire in five
campus. Arson is suspected as the cause. days. The cause of these fires is still
October 22, 2008
unknown. Arson is suspected.
Firefighters struggled to get the fires under Residence Hall Fire
control. Students were asked to evacuate. University of Michigan October 30, 2008
Fortunately the homes were not occupied at Detroit, Michigan Off-campus house
the time of the fire.
Boone, North Carolina
Students were on fall break when a fire
There was a lot of damage to the two broke out at the University of Michigan's
homes. The old Kappa Sigma house was to A cigarette smoldering in a trash can started
Mary Markley Hall. The cause was a small
be demolished soon. a fire at one of the student houses. The Oak
fan that caught fire in an empty room. The
street home was in flames when the fire-
few students that were present quickly
fighters arrived. The students got themselves
evacuated the building. No injuries reported.
out just in time. No one was hurt. The stu-
dents were relocated to a nearby hotel. The

Continued on next page


© 2008 Campus FirewatchTM
10 CAMPUS Firewatch November 2008

Continued from previous page quickly but it did cause extensive damage. November 11, 2008
The students have been temporarily relo- Clemson University
Watauga County Fire Marshal and cated some place on South Green. No
Emergency Management Office is offering a injuries reported.
Clemson, South Carolina
class on Fire safety this November.
A fire started in a utility tunnel outside
November 04, 2008
October 31, 2008 Littlejohn Coliseum. Firefighters were able to
Residence hall contain the fire. Fortunately no one was
Suicide
Weber State University injured as there was nobody present in the
University of Washington
Ogden, Salt Lake City, Utah building at the time of fire. The cause is
Seattle, Washington being investigated.
A man set a fire inside one of the school's
A man set himself ablaze in the University dormitories. Fortunately no one was injured. November 11, 2008
campus. He was one of the former employ- There was some damage done to the car-
ees of the University. The reason why he did
Off-campus apartment
pets and a sofa. The accused has been Radford University
such a tragic thing is still being investigated. booked into the Weber County Jail.
One of the students saw the man pouring Roanoke, Virginia
gas on himself but could not figure out what
exactly it was at that time. Bystanders did
November 06, 2008 A fire broke out at the Radford University
try to stop him but it was too late. The man Residence hall Monday evening. The cause was a burning
died few hours later at the Harborview Indiana State University candle. University students were relocated to
Medical Center. Terre Haute, Indiana an alternated housing. The incident is still
under investigation. The apartments suffered
November 03, 2008 Students at the ISU had to be temporarily extensive damage.
Residence Hall - sprinkler save relocated due to a fire in the dorm. There
Greenville Technical College was a lot of water damage. The cause of the November 14, 2008
fire is believed to be accidental. This was Residence hall
Greenville, South Carolina the second fire this year. University of Wisconsin -
A stove inside one of the dorm rooms caught Green Bay Campus
fire setting off the sprinkler system. Students
November 06, 2008
Green Bay, Wisconsin
of the Greenville Technical College had to Administrative building
evacuate the building. There was extensive Vermont Technical College There was a fire in the utility room of the
fire and water damage. No one was hurt. Randolph Center, Vermont R.E. Small Hall on the UW-Green Bay cam-
pus. The cause was an overheated pump.
November 03, 2008 A fire destroyed a building on the Vermont The fire was extinguished and the students
Residence Hall Technical College campus in Randolph. were relocated. No injuries reported.
University of California Firefighters struggled to keep the fire from
spreading. The cause of the fire is still not November 14, 2008
Santa Barbara, California known. Wildfire
A microwave burst into flames following an Westmont College, California
electrical malfunction in the first-floor
November 08, 2008
kitchen of the Santa Cruz Dorm. The fire was Historical building A massive fire destroyed some buildings at
quickly extinguished. There were no injuries University of North Carolina the Christian liberal arts college. Fortunately
reported. Residents were asked to evacuate Chapel Hill, North Carolina no one was injured. Everybody had to be
the building and were later allowed to reen- evacuated and classes were canceled. The
ter. A 19th-century building at the University of fire destroyed several homes in the neigh-
North Carolina at Chapel Hill caught fire. borhood. The flames are still visible but are
November 03, 2008 Thankfully the automatic sprinklers con- under control.
Off-campus house tained the fire from spreading. The fire
Ohio University caused an estimated $50,000 worth of dam-
age to Gerrard Hall. The cause is still under
Athens, Ohio investigation.
It was a traumatic situation for two Ohio
University students when they lost their
house to fire. The fire was extinguished

© 2008 Campus FirewatchTM


11 CAMPUS Firewatch November 2008

HR 592 Campus Fire Safety Right-to-Know Act


Sponsors Status Summary
Congressman Bill Pascrell (D-NJ) August 14, 2008 This legislation was The Campus Fire Safety Right-to-Know
2464 Rayburn House Office Building signed into law as part of the Higher Act calls upon colleges, universities, fra-
Washington, D.C. 20515 Education Act. ternities and sororities to make fire
(202) 225-5751 (tel) safety information about their buildings
(202) 225-5782 (fax) publicly available and report it to the
www.pascrell.house.gov U.S. Department of Education on an
Congressman Joe Wilson (R-SC) annual basis.
212 Cannon House Office Building
Washington, DC 20515
(202) 225-2452 (tel)
(202) 225-2455 (fax)
www.joewilson.house.gov
64 cosponsors

S 354 Campus Fire Safety Right-to-Know Act


Sponsors Status Summary
Senator Frank Lautenberg (D-NJ) August 14, 2008 This legislation was The Campus Fire Safety Right-to-Know
324 Hart Senate Office Building signed into law as part of the Higher Act calls upon colleges, universities, fra-
Washington DC 2051 Education Act. ternities and sororities to make fire
(202) 224-3224 (tel) safety information about their buildings
(202) 228-4054 (fax) publicly available and report it to the
www.lautenberg.senate.gov U.S. Department of Education on an
4 cosponsors annual basis.

Continued on next page


© 2008 Campus FirewatchTM
12 CAMPUS Firewatch November 2008

Continued from previous page

H. Res. 95 Campus Fire Safety Month


Sponsors Status Summary
Congresswoman Stephanie Tubbs This bill recognizes September as This bill will recognize September as
Jones (D-OH-11) Campus Fire Safety Month. This Campus Fire Safety Month. In 2006, for
1009 Longworth House Office Building resolution is also in force for 2008. the first time, the U.S. House of
Washington, D.C. 20515-3511 Representatives passed this resolution.
(202) 225-7032 (tel) In addition, 31 governors across the
(202) 225-1339 (fax) country issued proclamations also rec-
www.house.gov/tubbsjones/ ognizing September as Campus Fire
Congressman Edward Whitfield Safety Month.
(R-KY-1)
411 Rayburn House Office Building
Washington, D.C. 20515-1701
(202) 225-3115 (tel)
(202) 225-3547 (fax)
www.house.gov/whitfield
29 cosponsors

S. Res. 105 Campus Fire Safety Month


Sponsors Status Summary
Senator Joe Biden (D-DE) This bill recognizes September as This bill will recognize September as
201 Russell Senate Office Building Campus Fire Safety Month. This Campus Fire Safety Month. In 2006, for
Washington, DC 20510 resolution is also in force for 2008. the first time, the U.S. House of
(202) 224-5042 Representatives passed this resolution.
http://biden.senate.gov/ In addition, 31 governors across the
4 cosponsors country issued proclamations also rec-
ognizing September as Campus Fire
Safety Month

S 582 Fire Sprinkler Incentive Act


Sponsors Status Summary
Senator Gordon Smith (R-OR) Introduced in the U.S. Senate and To amend the Internal Revenue Code of
404 Russell Senate Office Building referred to the Committee on Finance on 1986 to classify automatic fire sprinkler
Washington, D.C. 20510-3704 February 14, 2007 systems as 5-year property for purposes
(202) 224-3753 (tel) of depreciation.
(202) 228-3997 (fax)
www.gsmith.senate.gov
Senator John Rockefeller
531 Hart Senate Office Building
Washington, D.C. 20510-4802
(202) 224-6472 (tel)
(202) 224-7665 (fax)
www.rockefeller.senate.gov
27 cosponsors Continued on next page
© 2008 Campus FirewatchTM
13 CAMPUS Firewatch November 2008

Continued from previous page

Fire Sprinkler Incentive Act


Sponsors Status Summary
Representative James Langevin 3/28/2007 Referred to House Committee To amend the Internal Revenue Code of
109 Cannon House Office Building on Ways and Means. 1986 to classify automatic fire sprinkler
Washington, D.C. 20515-3902 systems as 5-year property for purposes
Phone: (202) 225-2735 of depreciation.
Fax: (202) 225-5976
147 co-sponsors

HR 642 Stephanie Tubbs Jones College Fire Prevention Act


Sponsors Status Summary
Congresswoman Stephanie Tubbs September 29, 2008 This bill passed This bill will provide matching grants for
Jones (D-OH-11) the U.S. House of Representatives and the installation of fire suppression and
1009 Longworth House Office Building was sent to the U.S. Senate for action detection systems in residence halls,
Washington, D.C. 20515-3511 where it was referred to the Higher fraternities and sororities. In the version
(202) 225-7032 (tel) Education, Labor and Pensions passed by the House, there is no refer-
(202) 225-1339 (fax) Committee for consideration. ence to a specific dollar amount.
www.house.gov/tubbsjones
CongressmanEdward Whitfield (R-KY-1)
411 Rayburn House Office Building
Washington, D.C. 20515-1701
(202) 225-3115 (tel)
(202) 225-3547 (fax)
www.house.gov/whitfield
64 cosponsors

S 3574 Stephanie Tubbs Jones College Fire Prevention Act


Sponsors Status Summary
Senator Sherrod Brown 9/25/2008 Referred to Senate commit- This bill will provide matching grants for
455 Russell Senate Office Bldg. tee. Status: Read twice and referred to the installation of fire suppression and
Washington, DC 20510 the Committee on Health, Education, detection systems in residence halls,
(202) 224-2315 Labor, and Pensions. fraternities and sororities. In the version
passed by the House, there is no refer-
ence to a specific dollar amount.

Continued on next page


© 2008 Campus FirewatchTM
14 CAMPUS Firewatch November 2008

Continued from previous page

HR 643 Collegiate Housing and Infrastructure Act of 2007


Sponsors Status Summary
Congresswoman Stephanie Tubbs Introduced in the House and referred to This bill will allow contributions made to
Jones (D-OH-11) the House Committee on Ways and Greek organizations that are going to be
1009 Longworth House Office Building Means on January 23, 2007 used for physical plant improvements to
Washington, D.C. 20515-3511 be tax-deductible.
(202) 225-7032 (tel)
(202) 225-1339 (fax)
www.house.gov/tubbsjones/
Congressman Paul Ryan (R-WI-1)
1113 Longworth House Office Building
Washington, D.C. 20515-4901
(202) 225-3031 (tel)
(202) 225-3393 (fax)
www.house.gov/ryan
209 cosponsors

S 638 Collegiate Housing and Infrastructure Act of 2007


Sponsors Status Summary
Senator Pat Roberts (R-KS) February 15, 2007 Introduced in the This bill will allow contributions made to
109 Hart Senate Office Building Senate and referred to the Committee on Greek organizations that are going to be
Washington, DC 20510-1605 Finance. used for physical plant improvements to
Phone: (202) 224-4774 be tax-deductible.
Fax: (202) 224-3514
39 cosponsors

© 2008 Campus FirewatchTM


15 CAMPUS Firewatch November 2008

Where’s the Fire?

Locker room? Teachers’ lounge? Storage room? Chem lab?


False alarm?
False alarms jeopardize student safety, disrupt schedules, and
cost schools thousands of dollars. System Sensor, the experts in
the fire protection field, places a premium on research and
development, resulting in products that are reliable,
sophisticated and designed for real-world applications.
Our products can respond to a multitude of environmental
factors with the exact degree of sensitivity and coverage to
minimize false alarms.
System Sensor will match your facility’s needs to our complete
line of fire and life safety products:
• Conventional and intelligent smoke detection
• CO detection with wiring supervision and a trouble relay
• Directional sound egress technology
• Audible/visible notification
• HVAC system monitoring
• Sprinkler system monitoring
We’ve done our homework.
For more information on System Sensor product lines, call
800-SENSOR2 or visit www.systemsensor.com/edu.

© 2008 Campus FirewatchTM


16 CAMPUS Firewatch November 2008

Guide to resources available at www.campus-firewatch.com


Campus Firewatch continues to build its library of resources that are freely available on its website on its RESOURCES.
If you have a suggestion or a contribution you would like to make, please drop a note to ecomeau@campus-firewatch.com.

Current Fire Information pedia. It has resulted in a number of other quently ask for copies of the presentation or
There are two key documents that are avail- projects, one of which is Wikibooks, which is for the information in it. The presentation is
able for download on this page – the regu- the same concept but for textbooks. Campus posted online and will be updated periodically
larly updated Information Sheet and the Firewatch has started writing a book on cam- based on events and activities in the world of
Campus Firelog Compilation. pus fire safety, and here is your opportunity to campus fire safety.
contribute to it! Student housing fire safety ordinances
The Information Sheet is a brief, two-page
summary of current annual fire deaths that Legislation More communities across the country are
have occurred across the country along with Legislative Matrix - One of the areas that starting to adopt ordinances that specifically
a short status report on legislation. The idea Campus Firewatch has been working aggres- address student housing fire safety in areas
behind this is that it will provide people with sively in over the years is legislation at both such as smoke detection, sprinklers and
the most frequently asked for information. the Federal and state levels. In the U.S House egress. This page was created to showcase
The Campus Firelog is a listing of all of the and Senate there have been five bills under existing ordinances and provide a template
fatal student-related fires identified by consideration in this session of Congress. for other communities to use in developing
Campus Firewatch since January 2000. As of Campus Firewatch maintains a Legislative new ones. The reader can download copies
this date, there have been 125 fire deaths Matrix that lists all of the 535 Members of of the ordinances, which are also graphically
compiled. Congress and their positions on the bills. This shown on a map.
matrix also includes a “contact me” link that Video and animations
A map is also posted showing the location of you can click on to send your Representative
these fire deaths with a vast majority of them or Senator an email asking for their support. Flash animations - These are two animations
occurring in the eastern half of the country. relating to the impact of fire on the environ-
Campus Fire Safety Month - Along with the ment that can be downloaded and placed on
Education Resources Federal listing, there is a listing of the states your website. This taps into the student’s
Student views and attitudes towards burn and governors that issued proclamations des- heightened sense of awareness of “green”
and fire safety - This is a landmark study ignating September as Campus Fire Safety issues.
that was done in partnership between Month. This listing also included a “contact
Campus Firewatch and the People’s Burn me” link for the governor’s offices. Campus fire safety videos - There are sev-
Foundation. It provided a glimpse into the eral videos that have be downloaded from
Maps of campus fire safety activity Campus Firewatch, including Domenic’s
student psyche when it came to their percep- across the nation
tion of fire safety and it also provided invalu- Story, The Dana Christmas Story and
able information about how they get their This page contains two maps, one of the fatal Graduation: Fatally Denied.
information in today’s electronic age. This student-related fires identified by Campus Behind closed-dorm room doors - There is
report is extremely useful when developing Firewatch, and another of student fire safety fire-setting behavior that is occurring in resi-
fire safety programs that will effectively reach education and training activities being under- dence halls that is being showcased by the
a targeted demographic – today’s students. taken by schools across the country. If you students on youtube. Campus Firewatch has
have something you would like listed on this created a compilation of these videos which
Live burn mockup plans - More schools map, please send an email to
across the country are using the idea of provide an unparalleled look into what is
ecomeau@campus-firewatch.com. really happening.
building and burning mockups of student
rooms in the middle of campus to demon- Podcasts Videos of student room mockup burns -
strate the speed with which a fire can grow Podcast Matrix - Ed Comeau, the publisher More schools across the country are using
and spread as well as the effectiveness of of Campus Firewatch, hosts two podcasts on the mockup burns as effective learning tools.
sprinklers in controlling a fire. The plans for Radio@firehouse.com called Campus See the videos that have been uploaded onto
building these mockups, along with tips for Firewatch Radio and Fire Marshal’s Corner. youtube.
conducting a burn, are available online. Over 30 interviews on a wide range of topics Student related fire incidents - Shortly after
Videos of mockup burns - A picture is worth have been listened to or downloaded by over many fires occur, video is posted on youtube
a thousand words, and with the introduction 16,000 listeners. You can review the list of of the incident. This is an ongoing compila-
of youtube it is now possible to showcase the interview and click on any one to listen to the tion of these video clips compiled by Campus
effectiveness of these burns through these full show. Firewach.
nnn
videos that are available online. PowerPoint presentations
Wikipedia - For those that aren’t familiar with Ed Comeau does a number of presentations
it, Wikipedia is a online, collaborative encyclo- on campus firewatch and the attendees fre-

© 2008 Campus FirewatchTM

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen