Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Premature failure of bituminous mix has been a serious problem of highway engineer a flexible pavement undergoes different kinds failures like Formation of potholes, ruts, cracks, localized depression and settlement pavement may be considered as failure if there are in excess. For the accurate prediction of pavement performance under fast moving traffic and for reliable design of new pavements, it is necessary to use material properties, fatigue and rutting relationships developed under conditions similar to these expected in the field. Properties of pavement materials are essential inputs for evaluation of existing pavement and design of new pavements. With the increasing use of analytical approach for the design of pavements, the evaluation of elastic modulus, fatigue and rutting behaviour of pavement material has become necessary. An attempt has been made to evaluate the effects of lime filler on the Marshall properties of neat dense bituminous Macadam mix prepared using different percentages of lime filler (0%, 1%, 2%) by weight of aggregates. Number of trail mix were prepared using Marshall method of mix design to determine the optimum binder content and the Marshall properties of the mixture at the optimum binder content are calculated. From the experimental test results, it was observed that neat dense bituminous Macadam mix prepared using neat Bitumen with 2% filler material has higher Marshall stability, bulk density, VFB values and lesser Marshall Flow and VMA values compared to neat dense bituminous Macadam mix prepared using neat bitumen with 1% and 0% filler material. Similarly, neat dense bituminous Macadam mix prepared using neat Bitumen with 1% filler material has higher Marshall stability, bulk density ,VFB values and lesser Marshall flow, VMA values as compared to neat dense bituminous Macadam mix with 0% filler material. The Marshall stability test results clearly
indicate that as the filler content increases the Marshall stability, bulk density and VFB values increases and the Flow and VMA values decreases.
- 2 -
CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION
1.1
GENERAL
Hot mixed asphalt concrete is a composite material of aggregate particle of crushed rock of different sizes glued together by a asphalt binder. The term dense graded is used since the percentage of air voids in it is less than 6%, Dense bituminous Macadam is used in flexible pavement as a binder/base course and profile corrective course. Apart from the constituents properties and their proportions, the performance of HMA in rutting, cracking, as well as the durability is directly related to the mixture response and environmental loads. In recent years, many countries have experienced an increase in tire pressures, axle loads, and traffic volumes. Tire pressure and axle load increases mean that the bituminous layer near the pavement surface is exposed to higher stresses. High density of traffic in terms of commercial vehicles, overloading of trucks and significant variations in daily and seasonal temperature of pavements have been responsible for development of distress symptoms like raveling, undulations, rutting, cracking, bleeding, shoving and potholing of bituminous surfaces. Suitable material combinations and modified bituminous binders have been found to result longer life for wearing courses depending upon the percentage of filler and type of fillers used.When lime is used in hot mix, it reacts with aggregate, strengthening the bond between the bitumen and the stone. At the same time that it treats the aggregates, lime also reacts with the asphalt itself. Lime reacts with highly polar molecules that can otherwise reacts in the mix to form water- soluble soaps that promote stripping. When those molecules react with lime, they form insoluble salts that no longer attract water. The ability of hydrated lime to make an asphalt mix stiffer, tougher and resistant to rutting is a reflection of its superior performance as active mineral filler. Rutting is permanent deformation of the asphalt, caused when the elasticity of the material is exceeded. Hydrated lime significantly improves the performance of asphalt in this respect. Unlike most mineral filler, lime is chemically
active rather than inert. The overall objective of design of bitumen pavement mixtures is to determine an economical blend of lime that yields a mix having good durability.
1.2
Hydrated lime acts as mineral filler, stiffening the asphalt binder. It improves resistance to fracture growth (i.e., it improves fracture toughness) at low temperatures. It favourably alters oxidation kinetics and interacts with products of oxidation to reduce their deleterious effects. It alters the plastic properties of clay fines to improves moisture stability and durability. Hydrated lime when added to marginal aggregates that have plastic fines can improve the aggregates thought the mechanisms of cat ion exchange, flocculation reactions.
1.3
The overall objective of design of bitumen pavement mixtures is to determine an economical blend of lime that yields a mix having. Sufficient bitumen to ensure a durable pavement. Sufficient strength to resist shear deformation under traffic at higher temperature Sufficient air voids in the compacted bitumen to allow for additional compaction by traffic. Sufficient workability to permit easy placement without segregation. Sufficient flexibility to avoid premature cracking due to repeated loading of traffic. Sufficient flexibility at low temperature to prevent shrinkage cracks.
- 2 -
Coarse aggregate: The coarse aggregate should have good crushing strength, abrasion value, impact value.
Its function is to bear stresses coming from wheels. It has a resist wear due to abrasive action of traffic. Fine aggregate: It shall be fractions 2.36mm IS Sieve and retained on 75 micron sieve consisting of crushed stone. Its function is to fill up the voids of coarse aggregate. Fillers: The fillers should be inert materials which pass 75 micron sieve. Fillers may be limestone dust, cement, stone dust, brick dust, flier ash and its function to fill up the voids.
- 3 -
One of the most important aspects of an aggregate affecting the stability any working properties of a mix is a gradation. Maximum aggregate size also has a great effect upon workability and density of bituminous mixtures. It is also observed that use of a maximum aggregate greater than 1 micron in graded mixtures often results in harsh or non-workable bituminous mixtures that tend to segregate in the handing operation. This result in pavement surface that have an objectionable surface voids which may lead to ravelling. The dense graded mix used in this project includes appropriate amount of all sizes from coarse to fine including the dust of the material. Dense graded mixes tend to have large number of point of contact between individual aggregate pieces resulting in high frictional resistances. The increase of contact points of compacted with poorly graded materials also results in great areas of load transfer from one aggregate to another. This decrease the possibility of crushing of the individual aggregate piece by point loading. Strength and Toughness The aggregate in bituminous mixtures supplies most of the mechanical stability. It supports the load imposed by the traffic and at the same time distributes this loads to a subbase at a reduced intensity. The aggregate used in bituminous mixes tend to break or degrade by the load imposed upon them during construction and later by the action of traffic. Degradation may take place by compression failure from a concentrated load at points of contact between aggregate particles and by abrasion action by the individual pieces move with respect to others. The amount of the gradation is affected by both magnitude of applies loads and the resistance of crushing and abrasion value. Particle shape Irregular angular pieces when compacted tend to interlock and this possesses a mechanical resistance to displacement. This interlock is best obtained by cubical particles. The stability of open type mixes where the coarse aggregates is in only contact at few points is almost entirely due to effects of mechanical interlock regardless of grading of the aggregates for those mixes containing fine and coarse aggregates,.
- 4 -
1.6
To conduct basic test on aggregates and access the results as per MORT&H specification To conduct basic tests on bitumen and assess the result as per r MoRT&H specifications To conduct Marshall method of mix design by preparing specimens with neat bitumen without filler and to obtain the optimum bitumen content for the mix. To conduct mix design of the neat dense bituminous Macadam mix prepared with lime as filler at 0%, 1% and 2% by weight of aggregates using Marshall stability test method and to obtain the optimum bitumen content for corresponding % of mix.
To compare the results of Marshall stability test of neat dense bituminous Macadam mix at optimum bitumen content without filler material, with lime filler at 1% and 2% of total mix.
- 5 -
- 6 -
2.3 THE EFFECT OF QUALITY AND QUANTITY OF LOCALLY PRODUCED FILLERS ON ASPHALTIC MIXTURES (3)
A shahrour & Bassam G. Saloukeh have studied the effect of quality & quantity of locally produced fillers on asphaltic mixtures in Dubai (1991).The main objective of this study is to determine the influence of different fillers extracted from different local aggregate sources on performance of asphaltic mixtures, fillers like cement, hydrated lime & sodium silicate which are few fillers among 10 filler materials. were filler added about 0.5 to 1.5%. materials used are asphalt binder of (60\70) grade of 3.5%,4%,4.5%,5% & 5.5% various filler materials used are lime stone, hydrated lime, cement, gibca, Manama, kadra, wad filly ,Altawoon siji ks300. All these materials passing 75 micron sieve, Grading-2 is adopted & fillers are varied from 0%, 2%, 4% & 6%. Binder content is selected from (3.5% to 4.5%)s kept for comparison of different fillers. Wad filly, cement has higher specific gravity; Manama has medium sp gravity & hydrated lime as low sp gravity. Finally he concluded that, the different filler adopted shows improvement in binder stiffening property under extreme high
- 7 -
temperature. Hydrated lime filler shows superior stiffening properties when compared to different fillers. In addition of 0.8ratio of hydrated lime to bitumen. The softening point increases from 51.7 to 79.4 for (60\70) grade. Penetration decreases from 57 to 23 @ 25 degrees. Hydrated lime filler of quantity of 0.5 to 0.8 of bitumen content provides good performance of asphaltic mixtures.
2.4 THE EFFECT OF USING WASTE CEMENT DUST AS MINERAL FILLER ON MECHANICAL PROPERTIES OF HMA (1)
Hassan Y Ahmed, Ayman M Othman & afaf A Mahmoud have studied the effect of using waste cement dust as mineral filler on mechanical properties of HMA (2006).the main objective of this study is to find the optimum cement dust content in the asphaltic concrete by usage of mechanical properties like Marshall stability, Indirect tensile strength & unconfined compressive strength. The materials used are asphalt binder content (60\70),the sp gravity of coarse & fine aggregates are 2.72 &2.67 respectively lime stone is used as mineral filler, along with this cement dust with varying percent of 0%, 25%, 50%, 75%, 100%, with a constant asphalt content of 5%.The basic test on coarse,fine,bitmen, lime are conducted. The specimens are prepared with these materials & subjected to Marshall Stability, indirect tensile, unconfined compressive test. The Marshall Stability value increases as cement dust content is increased, while the flow, % of VMA decreases. In case of indirect tensile strength increases with increase in cement content. The cement content increases, there is increase in compressive strength. Hence cement dust enhances the compressive strength characteristics of asphalt concrete mix & at the same time flow value, void ratio & voids in mineral aggregates decreases. Therefore the optimum cement dust content can replace lime stone as mineral filler.
- 8 -
- 9 -
. 2.6 DIFFERENT LAYERS IN PAVEMENT STRUCTURE Bituminous base course Consist of mineral aggregate such as stone, gravel, or sand bonded together by a bituminous material and used as a foundation upon which to place a binder or surface course. Bituminous binder course A bituminous-aggregate mixture used as an intermediate coarse between the base and surface courses or as the first bituminous layer in a two-layer bituminous resurfacing. It is sometimes called a levelling course. Asphaltic/Bituminous concrete Bituminous concrete consists of a mixture of aggregates continuously graded from maximum size , typically less than 25 mm, through fine filler that is smaller than 0.075 mm. Sufficient bitumen is added to the mix so that the compacted mix is effectively impervious and will have acceptable dissipative and elastic properties. 2.8 DESIRABLE PROPERTIES OF MIX The desirable properties of a bituminous mix are as follows: Stability to meet traffic demand
- 10 -
2.9
Bitumen content to ensure proper binding and water proofing. Voids to accommodate compaction due to traffic. Flexibility to meet traffic loads (cold season). Sufficient workability for construction. Economical mix. REQUIREMENTS OF BITUMINOUS MIX Stability Sufficient binder must be available to coat all the particles at the same time should offer enough liquid friction. However, the stability decreases when the binder content is high and when the particles are kept apart. Stability is defined as the resistance of the paving mix to deformation under traffic load. Two examples of failure are.
Shoving: A transverse rigid deformation which occurs at areas subject to severe acceleration. Grooving: Longitudinal ridging due to channelization of traffic. Stability depends on the interparticle friction, primarily of the aggregates and the cohesion offered by the bitumen.
Durability Durability is defined as the resistance of the mix against weathering and abrasive actions. Weathering causes hardening due to loss of volatiles in the bitumen. Abrasion is due to wheel loads which causes tensile strains. Typical examples of failure are Pot hole: deterioration of pavements locally. Stripping: loss of binder from the aggregates & are exposed. Disintegration is minimized by high binder content since they cause the mix to be air and waterproof and the bitumen film is more resistant to hardening. Flexibility Flexibility is a measure of the level of bending strength needed to counteract traffic load and prevent cracking of surface. Fracture is the cracks formed on the surface (hairline-cracks, alligator cracks), main reasons are shrinkage and brittleness of the binder. Shrinkage cracks are due to volume
- 11 -
change in the binder due to aging. Brittleness is due to repeated bending of the surface due to traffic loads. Higher bitumen content will give better flexibility and less fracture. Skid resistance It is the resistance of the finished pavement against skidding which depends on the surface texture and bitumen content. It is an important factor in high speed traffic. Normally, an open graded coarse surface texture is desirable. Workability Workability is the ease with which the mix can be laid and compacted, and formed to the required condition and shape. This depends on the gradation of aggregates, their shape and texture, bitumen content and its type. Angular, flaky, and elongated aggregates workability. On the other hand, rounded aggregates improve workability.
- 12 -
Aggregates: Aggregates offer good compressive, shear strength; along with this they provide good interlocking facility with sufficient permeability. Aggregates are collectively taken as coarse, fine, crushed aggregates. Generally they account of about 92% to 96% of total mix of the volume, the remaining volume is binding materials used like bitumen etc. Table 3.1: Test results on aggregates
Binder Bitumen is a waterproofing agent. At normal temperature they are in the form semi-solid, it is heated until liquefied before blending it with the aggregates. Various tests have been developed for use in control of quality of bitumen that have been found significant in predicting the stability of bitumen Table 500-8 Requirements as per MORT&H Specifications Max 24% Max30% Max 30% Max 2%
Test Description of aggregate test result (Avg of 2trails) Aggregate impact value (%) Los Angeles Abrasion Value (%) Flakiness and Elongation Index (Combined) (%) Water absorption (%) Aggregate specific Gravity 1.Coarse aggregate 23.8 29.38 31.47 0.6 2.65
-----2.Fine aggregates 2.67 of some given application, basically these tests are used to measure consistency, ability of mixing and placing, durability, the ability to remain effective in hostile environments and rate of loading. In this study the binder of Neat bitumen is used.
Requirements
69.33 52.25
60-70 45-55
Ductility @27oC, cm
80
75 minimum
Specific Gravity
1.01
0.99-1.02
Flash point , oC
215
175 minimum
Filler Filler basically consists of finely divided mineral matter such as rock dust, hydrated lime or cement approved by the engineer. The filler shall be free from organic impurities & have plasticity index not greater than 4.Generally they are taken about 2% by weight of total aggregates. The plasticity index is not applicable if the filler material is cement. The specific gravity test conducted in laboratory & result is tabulated as shown in table below.
FILLER Lime SPECIFIC GRAVITY 2.78
3.2 GRADATION OF AGGREGATES Table 3.3: Aggregate gradation for dense graded bituminous Macadam mix Grade-2 adopted as per Table-500-10, of MORT&H (IV-revision) Specifications.
- 14 -
% Passing IS Sieve specified 100 90-100 71-95 56-80 38-54 28-42 7-21 2-8
There are two major features of Marshall Stability method of designing mixes they are. Density voids analysis. Stability flow test.
- 15 -
Test procedure for preparing Marshall specimens 1) The aggregates were proportioned and mixed as given in table 3.2, (aggregates and filler contribute to 1200 gm) the aggregate were heated to a temperature of 1500 2) Required quantity of bitumen i.e. 4.0, 4.5, 5.0, and 5.5 percent by weight of aggregate was heated to temperature of 120-145 degree C 3) The heated bitumen was added to the heated aggregates and thoroughly mixed at a desirable temperature 1500 1600c. 4) The mix was placed in a pre-heated mould of 10.16 cm diameter and 6.35 cm with base plate and collar. 5) After levelling the top surface, the mix was compacted by means of rammer of weight 4.54 kg and with a height of fall 45.7 cm with 75 blows on either side at a temperature of 1300- 1400 6) The compacted specimens were removed from the mould after 24 hours using the specimen extractor. 7) The diameter, mean height, weight in air, weight in water of the specimen was noted and bulk density is calculated. 8) The specimens were kept in a thermostatically controlled water bath maintained at 6010c for 30 minutes. The specimen were taken out, placed in Marshall Test head and tested to determine the Marshall Stability value, which is the maximum load in kg before failure, and the flow value, which is deformation of specimen in mm at to the maximum load. The equipment used was strain controlled with a strain rate of 5 cm/min. 9) The corrected Marshall Stability value of each specimen was determined by applying appropriate correction factor, if the average height of the specimen is not exactly 63.5 mm Graphs are plotted taking bitumen content (%) on x-axis and Marshall stability value, flow value, bulk density, percentage air voids in total mix, percentage of mineral aggregate and percentage of voids filled with bitumen on y-axis. The optimum binder content for the mix is found by taking the average of following three bitumen content found from the graphs of the results. Bitumen content corresponding to maximum stability, maximum unit weight and maximum of 4% air voids.
- 16 -
- 17 -
Unit Wt Vs Bitumen
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
Flow Vs Bitumen
5.00 Flow Value
VFB % 90.0 85.0 80.0 75.0 70.0 65.0 60.0 55.0 50.0 3.5
VFB Vs Bitumen
Bitum en %
4.00 3.00 2.00 1.00 0.00 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
Bitumen %
Bitumen %
- 18 -
Bitum en%
Figure 4.2: Marshall Properties of neat dense bituminous Macadam mix with 1% lime filler to determine optimum binder content Table 4.2: Marshall Properties of neat dense bituminous Macadam mix with lime filler content of 1%
- 19 -
Bitumen
Marshal Stability Kg
1500
Flow mm
Unit Wt g/C-cm
1100
2.80
5.0
4.5
5.5
2.370
Bitum e n %
2.367 2.366
4.09 3.46
74.28 79.02
Bitu m e n %
15.93 16.47
- 20 -
VFB Vs Bitum e n
90.00 85.00 80.00 75.00 70.00 65.00 60.00 55.00 50.00 3.5 8.0 6.0 % Air Voids 4.0 2.0 0.0 3.5
VFB %
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
Bitu m e n %
Bitu m e n %
Flow Vs Bitumen
4.80 4.20 Flow Value 3.60 3.00 2.40 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0 Bitumen %
Figure 4.2: Marshall Properties of neat dense bituminous Macadam mix with 1% lime filler to determine optimum binder content
- 21 -
Table 4.3 Marshall Properties of neat dense bituminous Macadam with lime filler content of 2% Bitumen content % 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 Marshall stability Kg 1248 1419 1439 1398 Flow mm Bulk density g/cc 2.358 2.394 2.400 2.398 Air voids % 5.76 3.65 2.40 2.11 Voids filled with bitumen % 62.09 74.72 83.33 86.63 Voids in mineral aggregates % 15.19 14.42 14.45 15.31
Unit Wt Vs Bitumen
2.42 2.41 2.40 2.39 2.38 2.37 2.36 2.35 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0 Unit Wt g/C-cm
Bitum en %
Bitumen %
- 22 -
VFB Vs Bitumen
90.00 85.00 80.00 75.00 70.00 65.00 60.00 55.00 50.00 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0
Bitum en%
VFB %
6.0
Bitumen %
Flow Vs Bitumen
4.00 Flow Value 3.80 3.60 3.40 3.20 3.00 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0
Bitumen %
Figure 4.3: Marshall Properties of neat dense bituminous Macadam with lime filler 2% to determine optimum binder content
- 23 -
Table 4.4 Marshall Properties of neat dense bituminous Macadam mix at optimum binder content. Lime filler content 0% 5.03 Lime filler content 1% 4.77 Lime filler content 2% 4.71
Marshall properties Optimum binder content % Marshall stability KG Marshall flow mm Air voids % Voids in Mineral Aggregates % Voids filled with bitumen % .
4.5 minimum
1220
1390
1410
9.0 minimum
3.82
3.57
3.50
2.0 4.0
4.09
3.90
3.88
3.0 6.0
15.92
15.73
15.44
12 minimum
70.69
72.34
73.59
65 - 75
- 24 -
Figure 4.2: Shows graph of Marshall stability vs. bitumen for neat dense bituminous Macadam mix with lime filler content 0%, 1%, 2%
Figure 4.2: Shows graph of bulk density vs. bitumen content for neat dense bituminous Macadam mix with lime filler content 0%, 1%, 2%
- 25 -
Figure 4.2: Shows graph of Marshall flow vs. bitumen content for neat dense bituminous Macadam mix with lime filler content 0%, 1%, 2%
Figure 4.2: Shows graph of % air voids vs. Bitumen content for neat dense bituminous Macadam mix with lime filler content 0%, 1%, 2%
- 26 -
Figure 4.2: Shows graph of voids filled with bitumen vs. Bitumen content for neat dense bituminous Macadam mix with lime filler content 0%, 1%, 2%
- 27 -
- 28 -
Increasing the fines, the bitumen content absorbed into the aggregates is more and thus decreases the value of voids in mineral aggregates. 8. It was observed from the table 4.4 the voids filled with bitumen of dense bituminous macadam for 0%, 1% and 2% lime filler content was found to be 70.69%, 72.34% and 73.49% respectively. Thus by increasing the lime filler VFB value increases, VMA value decreases.
- 29 -