Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
INSIGHT REPORT
MOBILE
EUROPE
ALSO INSIDE:
SFR GOES FEMTO FREE
P07
PRICING STRATEGIES
P34
MOBILE MONEY
with national CityZi plans, but what are the rest of Europes operators doing in mobile money?
P38
Contents
October/November 2011
Operator innovation: augmented reality The price must be right
REGULARS
EDITORIAL
FEATURES
PRICING INNOVATION
The mobile operator of 2011 has to think differently about their customer data, and subscriber experience, to deliver pricing strategies that deliver maximum value to the user, but also deliver increased profitability for the operator. Can they square this circle?
04 06
From mobile money, to pricing, to network architecture, operators are not as conservative as they are portrayed.
34
NEWS
TAG spins out m2m; Tele2 to disrupt Netherlands with LTE; SFR to integrate WiFi with 3G; Bouygues pays top amount for LTE spectrum; Broadcom aims for wireless infra share; Ericsson dominant LTE provider till 2014; Operators integrate MMS with Twitter; Telefonica working on AR; Virgin Media signs 100m Gig-E deal; Huawei biggest gainer in microwave market; Monitise at mobile money "tipping point"; Operator-backed Paypal rival; Telefonica doubles Redknee investment; Traffic management takes central stage.
MOBILE MONEY
Operator-led mobile money and payments services are still thin on the ground, but momentum is growing across Europe, as operators move to commercialisation of NFC technology. So where can we look to for operator-led market momentum?
38
DIARY
A selection of the major mobile events and conferences in the weeks ahead and a glance at some of the stories to have missed the real news pages.
42
INSIGHT REPORT
FULL CONTENTS, FOREWORD
Keith Dyer introduces this issues Insight Report and charts the impact the LTE is having on how mobile network architectures may evolve.
19
VENDOR DEVELOPMENTS
Vendors are taking differing approaches to solving a common operator challenge: from integrated base stations to cloud-based processing. Femtocell and WiFi, and market entries from some new players also promise to shake things up.
26
Mobile Europe | 3
Comment
editor: keith dyer
Operators can innovate, but its about delivery Operators are often castigated for being poor incubators of innovation. Organisations run on spreadsheets, with high volume and low margin services, are poorly positioned to drive innovative services into the market. So it is interesting to view this issue in the light of operator attempts at innovation. A look at both the news and feature pages reveals several aspects where operators are taking INSIGHT steps to innovate. REPORT
cells LTE, outdoor small and the cloud RAN on the analysis and report new vendor strategies
MOBILE
EUROPE
EUROPE
rope.co .uk
MOBILE
S AGAIN! WIFI RIDE
S Octobe r/Novem S issue no. 218 obileeu ber 2011 S www.m
Edit or: Keith Dyer keithd@mobileeurope.co.uk Direct tel: +44 (0) 20 7933 8999 Production Manager: Tania King Sales Manager: Shahid Ramzan shahid.ramzan@mobileeurope.co.uk Direct tel: +44 (0) 20 7933 8980 Commercial Director: Justyn Gidley justyn.gidley@stjohnpatrick.com Direct tel: +44 (0) 20 7933 8979 Publishing director: Chris Cooke
P38
At a network level SFR is moving to a free model for femtocells, a first within Europe, with the aim of providing customers with the best user experience possible in home and small office. Tele2 is considering the transition from MVNO to full operator with LTE and an aggressive marketing approach in the Netherlands. Operators are behind the thrust of our Insight Report, which looks into the drivers and developments in heterogenous networks and Cloud RAN solutions for LTE networks. It is MBNL, which wraps up T-Mobile and Everything Everywhere, as well as Three UK, which has signed an innovative backhaul contract with Virgin Media Business. All of these are developments aimed at innovating at the network level to provide customers an enhanced user experience.
ALSO INSIDE:
SFR GOES FEMTO FREE
P07
PRICING STRATEGIES
P34
MOBILE MONEY
Then, at the service level we see Telefonica, in the news pages, working with Layar, one of the companies driving forward Augmented Reality services and applications. Yet this is far from a case of an operator leaning on a partner for service innovation. In fact, Telefonica has its own well-established project. We also carry news of operator integration of messaging APIs with Twitter, to enable users to upload pictures to their Twitter profiles using MMS. Not too exciting, perhaps, but an example of the If there is a lesson there for reality of 3rd party integration that operators are told they must enable. Our features, too, deliver news of momentum building in the way operators communicate with and view users, and the way they are developing services that could change the way we pay for digital and real world items. Our feature on pricing innovation suggests that operators are dedicated to developing a different view of their customers, so that they can innovate around pricing offers, but also in the way that users can control their own experience. And our article on mobile money projects continues to suggest that if there is a critical party driving forward widespread awareness of mobile NFC payments, then that party is the mobile operator. It is the carriers that are bulk ordering the NFC-enabled handsets, the NFC-compatible SIMs. Finally, even our sponsored feature, written in association with Ericsson, suggests that operators are driving forward with dedicated go-to-market focused strategies for the enablement of services based on the Rich Communications Suite. So, as we enter into iPhone5 territory, and all the hype that that will bring, remember that Apples record is of taking tried and tested industry ideas video calling, instant messaging and making the experience easy to understand and use. If there is a lesson there for mobile operators it is that delivery is what counts, rather than innovation. But the signs are that lesson has been learnt, and real progress is being made.
Free Subscriptions Mobile Europe is a controlled circulation monthly magazine available free to selected personnel at the publishers discretion. If you wish to apply for regular free copies then please write to: Database Services St John Patrick Publishing Ltd PO Box 6009, Thatcham, Berkshire, RG19 4TT. Tel: +44 (0) 1635 879361 Email: mobileeurope@circdata.com or register free online at: www.mobileeurope.co.uk Paid Subscriptions Readers who fall outside the strict terms of control may purchase an annual subscription . UK 1 Year - 96. International 1 Year - 120. Subscription enquiries should be sent to: Saint John Patrick Publishers PO Box 6009, Thatcham, Berkshire RG19 4TT United Kingdom Tel: +44 (0)1635 879361 Fax: +44 (0) 1635 868594 Email: mobileeurope@circdata.com Web: wwwmobileeurope.co.uk
mobile operators, it is that delivery is what counts, rather than innovation. But the signs are that lesson has been learnt.
The views expressed in Mobile Europe are not necessarily those of the editor or the publisher. Mobile Europe is published by Saint John Patrick Publishers Ltd, 6 Laurence Pountney Hill, London EC4R 0BL.
4 | Mobile Europe
News
m2m in Austria l LTE in Netherlands
especially within the vertical industries and the respective account managers, which all in all amount to about 150 people out of those 200. TAG M2M is currently recruiting people to be employed directly at this competence center, and targets a mid two digit number by middle of next year. Are there any partners, developers, etc that Telekom Austria already knows it will be working with? For M2M we leverage the existing network of solution partners, but also aim to further extend our partner network beyond the borders of our traditional footprint and establish a network of best-in-class partners. We are working with our existing partners in all our operating companies and will announce further partnerships as soon as we are agreed on the terms of reference. A clear differentiator is, that TAG M2M actively manages and services its partnerships by expert employees dedicated exclusively to the maintenance and development of the relations. For the time being Telekom Austria Group M2M GmbH approaches about half a million SIM-Cards and records a 50% growth in SIM volume for year to date. Has Telekom-Austria looked at joining the Deutsche Telekom/ FT Orange/ Telia-Sonera M2M interoperability alliance? The Telekom Austria Group M2M GmbH closely looks at the current ecosystem and evaluates and decides each opportunity on a case-to-case basis. For the time being there has been no decision taken regarding the M2M interop alliance, but any future alliances and partnerships will be announced to the public as soon as they are agreed.
6 | Mobile Europe
News
Free French femto l Pricey French spectrum l Swedish LTE
Mobile Europe | 7
Sponsored Feature
the behalf of operators to move to commercial deployments. There is a tangible move to become much more market focused, as evidenced by several ongoing operator development programmes, in Europe, the Americas and Asia Pacific.
8 | Mobile Europe
Sponsored Feature
Developing an ecosystem could enable delivery of RCS services to devices without native RCS support.
operators as they plan and specify services, ensuring compatibility with the standards, and technical assurance. Crucially, the company is also leveraging its close relationships with operators to verify and test service interoperability of clients, services and equipment. Operators are on a tight timeline to get to market; therefore they need to work with a partner that they trust, a partner that will enable them to deliver to the market this collection of business-critical services and applications.
Mobile Europe | 9
News
Base station tech l Ericsson dominant l Twitter MMS
FOUR EUROPEAN OPERATORS integrate MMS with Twitter using messaging APIs
Subscribers of four European operators now have the capability to post photos to their Twitter accounts using MMS, following application level integration with Twitter. Three UK operators, Vodafone, Orange and O2 will offer consumers the service, as will Vodafone Italy. O2 said that users would be charged the usual MMS rate for sending an MMS to their Twitter account. UK users will be able to send photos to Twitter by sending a message to short code 86444. O2 is enabling the service integration through its BlueVia API. A Vodafone spokesperson said that the Twitter integration was not carried out through any particular partner or developer programme, "We just enabled it," he said. O2 seem a bit more excited about the use of its API. Jose Valles, Head of BlueVia, said in a statement, Were very excited about this new service. Our customers in the UK will satisfy a need of tweeting in certain specific circumstances and that, we expect, will help Twitter grow its presence in the UK. On the other side, we in BlueVia are slooking forward to spread this service to the whole footprint of Telefnica. The use cases for using MMS to update Twitter seem limited, however. At the moment, users can either upload photos within dedicated Twitter clients, or from Twitter's own mobile platform. There may be scope for those users with feature phones to use MMS to update a Twitter account. Perhaps of greater importance is that the integration with messaging APIs shows that these operators are relaxed about opening access to a third party messaging platform, and in doing so turn MMS from a peer-topeer to a peer-to-app service.
10 | Mobile Europe
News
l Telco innovation l
that we were building. Our visual recognition engine is a ground breaking technology delivered to users. Empowering Layar with this technology was a natural step.
Mobile Europe | 11
Backhaul News
UK Gig-E backhaul l Huawei gains
VIRGIN MEDIA BUSINESS SIGNS 100M GIG-E BACKHAUL DEAL WITH MBNL
PACKET OPTICAL WIN FOR TRANSMODE
Mobile Broadband Network Ltd (MBNL), the company that operates the 3G network used by Everthing Everywhere and Three UK, has signed an eight year, 100 million deal to upgrade their backhaul network. MBNL has signed a deal with Virgin Media Business (VMB) which will see it become the first customer for VMBs Sync-E solution. The contract will see VMB build 14 regional aggregation networks across the UK to enhance MBNLs bandwidth capacity. A statement said the deployment would be the UKs only synchronous Ethernet mobile backhaul service. The first phase of deployment will see MBNL have access to a 1 Gigabit per second (Gbps) Ethernet service to meet growing mobile data demand. EE and Three have 35.2 million customers between them, and are faced with same the priorities that all mobile operators are in dealing with the growth in mobile data on the dowlink and uplink. Graham Payne, Managing Director, MBNL, said, Mobile data and the increase in smartphone usage is a big growth opportunity for us. Connecting our end users to the online world, from any location and from any device is at the heart of what we do. Working together with Virgin Media Business, the first company in the market to offer this synchronous Gigabit Ethernet service, we will be able to scale for future demand. VMBs service is built on technology from Transmode. Transmode said that it estimates that the new contract is worth up to SEK150 million in 2011 and 2012 and that deliveries will begin in the third quarter 2011. The dedicated networks will rely on Transmodes Native Packet Optical architecture, including the recently-launched Layer 2 Ethernet Muxponder family. Ethernet services will be provided from the mobile operators core node locations right through to the operators cell sites. Transmode said the service would enable VMB to provide highly flexible services with better synchronisation
Transmodes CEO, Karl Thedeen.
performance than alternative solutions in the market. Analysts estimate that by 2015 globally there will be a ten-fold increase to more than two million fibre-connected base stations. We believe that this is one of the biggest packetoptical based mobile backhaul projects in Europe and it will provide Virgin Media Business with a state-of-the-art platform for their Sync-E enabled, Gigabit Ethernet mobile backhaul services, said Karl Thedeen, Chief Executive Officer at Transmode.
12 | Mobile Europe
Payments News
Tipping point l Buyster launches MONITISE BENEFITS from mobile money "tipping point"
Mobile banking and payments company Monitise has hailed its latest financial results as evidence of a breakthrough year for the company. CEO Alistair Lukies said that the mobile money space has reached its own tipping point as the global demand for mobile banking, payments and commerce takes off. This momentum has driven revenues at Monitise up 133% from 6 million in 2010 to $14 million in 2011, for the year ended 30 June. The company reported that platform development and integration revenues were up fourfold on 2010 reaching 6 million. User generated revenues accounted for 6.3m, more than more than double the previous year. The company says it now processes more than 10 million mobile banking transactions a month, with a value exceeding 160 million. Monitise reported a loss for the year of 14.5 million (2010: 16.8 million), a loss per share of 2.1p (2010: 3.7p). It expects to break even in the calendar year 2013. Monitise has a strategic agreement with Visa Europe to develop and supply mobile payments services for Visa Europe's 4,600 member banks and financial institutions across 36 countries. It also has a five-year agreement with RBS Group, announced August 2011, to broaden mobile banking and payments services.
I Google, Citi, MasterCard, First Data and Sprint have announced and demonstrated Google Wallet. Available in the USA for now, the service uses NFCenabled phones and payment terminals to enable users to pay for items using credit cards encapsulated on their phones. With the service still in trial phase, Google has invited additional issuing banks, payment networks, mobile carriers, handset manufacturers, point of sale systems companies and merchants to join the initiative. I Accumulate and PayPal will work jointly on mobile services projects for the Swedish local market, based on Accumulates award winning security platform Mobile Everywhere. The agreement is great news and we look forward to partnering with PayPal and to support the innovative mobile services based on our technology, says Stefan Hultberg, CEO of Accumulate.
enter the code, authenticating them for payment. The operators said that they will market the solution to their combined user base of 50 million subscribers as well as e-tailers. Buyster said that its systems would provide retailers with an improved conversion rate thanks to its ease of use in particular for mobile phone purchases. The mobile phone also offers stronger authentication and reduces the risk of chargeback. Buyster said in a statement that it is already supported by ten partners forming an ecosystem that can reach almost 30,000 eretailers. The partners are: Payment service platforms: Mercanet, Paybox, Payline and Sips e-Commerce platforms: Store Factory and Wizishop Publishers and agencies: Baobaz, eDecision, Kapsicum, Prestashop and Think And Go. E-retailers who will be connected from 13 September include 4 Pieds, AchatDesign, Ada, Allopneus, Aquarelle, Barrire Poker, Boulanger,
Bouygues Telecom, BrandAlley, But, Camaeu, Cariboom, Darty, Easy Fichiers, Feu Vert, reenWeez, Jennyfer, Kiabi, La Boutique Officielle, Monde Bio, National Change, Orange, Partouche, RazWar, RueDuCommerce, Rue Du Tee Shirt, SFR, Spartoo, Surcouf, Tlthon, Ubaldi. The operators and Atos announced their intention to form a payment institution in February 2011, saying they were aiming for a mid-2011 service launch.
I Paypal has announced in-store mobile payments technologies that do not require NFC in PoS terminals or phones. The intention is to let a user enter a telephone number and a personal identification number and the amount will be charged to a bank account or card associated with the number. PayPal added that it also plans to issue a plastic card at the point of sale. There is also an intention to emnable users to scan items in-store using a barcode, pay through Paypal and then exit the store without needing to queue at a till.
Mobile Europe | 13
BSS/OSS News
Telefonica Spain l Fizzback l Orange Switzerland
Historically there has been sufficient room in the market so that precision wasnt necessarily the operating word. That has changed, however, and operators are under greater pressure to identify new customer segments, and address those with the most efficient and profitable tariffs and bundles. We see Price Simulator as a really great way to have a very specific ability added to the operators business which then ties into both marketing and finance roles in the organisation. When we run reports we not only allow our customers to understand how profitable segments are but also how that compares to all other tariffs from their competitors in that market. That means you can say not only if a tariff is likely to be good for you as a business, but you can use it to differentiate, and be sure you have a chance to be successful in a segment, Skoczkowski said. For more, see www.mobileeurope.co.uk/ news/news-analysis/8920
14 | Mobile Europe
News Feature
l traffic management l
Mobile Europe | 15
Advertorial Samsung
HOW CAN OPERATORS MEET THE INCREASING DEMAND FOR MOBILE DATA WHILE REDUCING CAPEX AND OPEX?
While Smartphones are driving the need for network capacity expansion, network operators are targeted with reducing CapEx and OpEx budgets.
The introduction of Smartphones has seen enormous take-up amongst business users and consumers. Smartphones represented 23% of all active handsets in Western Europe in 2010. They will account for more than half by 2014, and will have reached 72% by 2016 (see Figure 1). However the implications for the operators are far reaching as the mobile data explosion puts enormous strain on the operators existing 3G networks. Operators around the world are all facing an exponential growth in data traffic as a result of the rapid uptake in Smartphones. This has led to cell splitting and additional cells being deployed to handle the dramatic increase in data traffic. However, an increase in the number of cells in an urban environment results in smaller cell sizes and reduced performance due to inter-cell interference and thus operators face rising OPEX costs to manage a large number of cell configuration changes, and a subsequent cell optimisation, without fully meeting the capacity requirements. As seen in Figure 2, smart devices have produced a huge mobile data traffic increase, which has reached more than 1 Giga Byte per subscriber per month in Korea.
Figure 2: Average Data Traffic per Subscriber [Source: Korea Telecom, SK Telecom, 2011]
3G networks were not designed for heavy data usage and are now creaking under the load. Whats more, data network performance becomes a key issue for operators as users develop higher expectations and churn to alternative networks that can better support their data consumption needs.
Figure 1: Active handsets by type in Western Europe [Source: Analysis Mason, 2011]
16 | Mobile Europe
Advertorial Samsung
IS WI-FI THE SOLUTION?
Wi-Fi was introduced back in the early nineties as the first way to access the internet wirelessly. Its benefits include less cost, time and space to deploy. In addition, Wi-Fi chipsets are inexpensive, which has led to many mobile devices including Smartphones and laptops being able to connect wirelessly to the Internet via Wi-Fi. According to the Wi-Fi alliance, about 800 million new Wi-Fi devices are introduced every year. However, because the Wi-Fi spectrum is unregulated and open to all, Wi-Fi access points proliferate and compete for the same small piece of spectrum. As a result, interference levels increase and network increasing number of cell sites, without fully meeting the capacity requirements. So, whilst additional cells provide additional capacity they also introduce the unwanted factors of increased interference, CapEx and OpEx.
Figure 3: Average Active
Users per Cell over Time and Effected by Cell Splitting [Source: Samsung, 2011]
February 2011. This solution dramatically reduces OPEX and CAPEX by reducing several cell sites into a centralized one. With easy installation and self-optimization, Centralized Base Station drastically lowers CAPEX and OPEX for network operator while providing all the same Smart LTE advantages. Samsung is also committed to minimize inter-cell interference for Heterogeneous Networks, to enhance cell edge throughput and average cell throughput. Commercial Heterogeneous networks comprising macrocells and small-cells with Samsungs Smart LTE technology will be commercialized in 2012.
CONCLUSION
Increased data demand is a reality for todays mobile network operators and the speed and quality of data access is increasingly a key differentiator for the consumer. The 3G networks are straining both from the data demand and also the associated signalling requirements. Operators not only need to plan their migration to LTE as a matter of urgency but they also need to carefully consider their LTE network architecture; maximising the benefits offered by infrastructure vendors and deploying the most appropriate options in the macro, micro/pico and femto layers. Careful selection of the right Smart LTE Solution can provide operators with improvements in incremental CapEx, OpEx and the user experience, therefore ensuring the satisfaction of both the CFO and the end customer. For more information, visit http://www.samsungnetwork.com
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Mark Thompson is responsible for the Sales & Marketing of Samsung LTE Solutions throughout Europe. Mark is a Fellow of the Institute of Sales & Marketing Managers (FinstSMM).
Mobile Europe | 17
MOBILE EUROPE
INSIGHT REPORT
INSIGHT REPORT
EDITORS FOREWORD
Keith Dyer introduces this issues Insight Report, and traces the course of a network evolution that looks set to take networks smaller, and change the architecture of the networks themselves.
The aim of LTE to provider higher capacities with lower cost of operation has brought with it the need for the Heterogenous Network; small cells layered with the macro network, working together to provide coverage and capacity. The fact that LTE looks like it might work better, or be more spectrally efficient, where small cells operate with large cells in shared spectrum has led many operators to assume they will deploy, at some point, a small cell strategy for LTE. In turn this creates a need for SON capabilities, so that networks can work without interference and disruption, and with handover of sessions and calls between small and macro cells. It also creates a different vision for backhaul. Finally, it has fostered another approach, active intelligent antenna with integrated radio, and plans to pool baseband processing power the Cloud RAN. This vision is being drawn from two ends of a continuous line. Put crudely, the femtocell players, who already have SON elements designed in, and of course low price points and low power operation, address this from the bottom end. The major equipment NEPs, with on or two notable exceptions, have started to address this from the other side by integrating small cells within an overall architecture in LTE, using the SON standards that are written into LTE standards at 3GPP. And they have started to go further, to iterate a vision of a network that makes the most of centralised processing power, the Cloud RAN. This report, drawn together by a Mobile Europe team from a variety of sources, after many conversations, after input from many commentators, is intended to trace the rationale for these two main changes in network design, to put into context the challenges that will need to be overcome, and to guid the reader through the headline strategies of the main players addressing the opportunity. Where we mention specific company names, it is often as a means to illustrate wider market developments, and it should not be assumed these are the only companies active in a certain field, or that any specific endorsement is intended. We have found this an interesting and fruitful report to compile and hope you find value this latest Insight Report from Mobile Europe. Keith Dyer, Editor, Mobile Europe
INSIGHT REPORT
INTRODUCTION
he move to imagining a reformed mobile network architecture starts with accepting the logic that smaller cells, no matter what terminology you apply pico, metro femto, femto will have to play a greater role in mobile network deployments. Despite concerted moves to find a happy medium spectrum range between the 800MHz and 2.6GHz bands, with re-farmed 1800MHz spectrum the favourite LTE target of many operators, there is now growing, if not quite universal, acceptance that small cells will increasingly be deployed to provide spot coverage and capacity in a range of outdoor environments. ABI Research states that the outdoor picocell market, which it characterises as still in the early stages of development, is projected to reach $8 billion in global revenues by 2016.Indeed, ABI points out that while many outdoor microcells are in
operation and have been for years, outdoor picocells are undergoing operator trials, with several companies focusing their attention on alternatives that are designed to be lower cost and easier-todeploy. These outdoor picocells require little of the permissions and supporting plant of macro-base stations. They can plug onto utility poles, lamp-posts, and rooftops, sharing power supplies from cable plant, for example. That then raises the question of how traffic will be backhauled from a multitude of sites an area identified as a major challenge by ABI with the candidates being fibre, copper, microwave, E-band, and point-tomultipoint microwave. ABI thinks that operators are likely to start with identifying specific hot sites in congested metro areas, and start using outdoor picocells to alleviate capacity demand. Metro areas arent the only places where small cells are expected to
appear. Apart from outdoor small cells having a role in urban areas, they also have a role in rural and suburban areas where zoning restrictions prevent macro tower deployments.Yet the potential network of the future, with thousands of small sites dotted into a macro network in shared spectrum, has raised another possibility. For the most cost-efficient deployment and operation, vendors and operators are considering an approach that centralises network intelligence, pooling what would have once been processing power dedicated to the base station, and sharing it across a collection of smaller sites, each of which are equipped with more intelligent, active antennas. This vision, for want of a better word, is known as the Cloud RAN. This report traces that journey, looks at the challenges it presents, and at the offerings of the major companies driving the vision.
example, has said publicly that DoCoMo would have 35,000 eNodeBs by the end of 2014, many of them providing coverage over no more than 100-200 metres. There is an apparent link between LTE deployment and increasing small cell deployment. Although some operators worry that deploying large numbers of LTE sites will bring with it increased costs in terms of new antenna lines, backhaul and network management, there is also evidence that LTE networks will operate at optimum spectral efficiency where
Telefonicas results were showing that with cell sizes three times smaller, or for three times the number of cells, Telefonica was achieving seven times the capacity.
small cells are interleaved with macro layers. Telefonica has presented results of trials in Spain which appeared to show that optimum performance was actually achieved when small cells and macro cells operated together in shared, nonpartitioned, spectrum. Telefonicas radio manager, Jaime LLuch, said that results were showing that with cell sizes three times smaller, or for three times the number of cells, Telefonica was achieving seven times the capacity. This involved a spectrum sharing strategy, where 20MHz was shared between macro and micro layers. This enabled Telefonica to target very precise traffic locations, using clusters of cells to see huge capacity
Mobile Europe Insight Report | 21
INSIGHT REPORT
increases. The optimised location of micro versus using existing macros sites gave 40-50% better throughput per average user, Lluch reported. This small cell performance boost could be crucial to mobile operators. Operators are of course tasked with differentiating on network speeds, and the sorts of offers they can make users perhaps based on location, time of day, traffic type, and quality of service. Being able to This need for targeted, location-specific capacity solutions, operating in harness with macro layer cells, forms the chief driver for small cell LTE deployment. With this demand comes a number of challenges; around interference management, deployment, backhaul, the need for new antenna lines. But it has also led to the creation of a new orthodoxy in the industry, the concept of the heterogenous network.
This small cell performance boost could be crucial to mobile operator tasked with differentiating on network speeds and quality of service
target increased capacity and coverage very precisely is attractive.
HETEROGENOUS NETWORKS
Certainly the big vendors have encouraged the new orthodoxy of the HetNet. Ericsson, which doesnt market anything called a femtocell, is committed to the HetNet, or the heterogenous network, as the dominant strategy for its mobeil broadband network operator customers. As part of that strategy it has announced its Antenna Integrated Radio, marking it as a key step on the road to the integrated, multi-sized network. In January this year Alcatel-Lucent announced a miniature base station called lightRadio a stylistically innovative cube design that packs a large punch in a very small glove. Huawei and ZTE have both announced a focus on ever-smaller microcells, with ZTE also making an announcement that it too would follow a Cloud RAN strategy. Nokia Siemens Networks recently announced Liquid Radio, and its overall cloud network concept, Liquid Net, which uses distributed antennae and virtualised baseband processing to provide a highly distributed architecture built around small cells and miniature basestation designs. Allied to these efforts are those of the dedicated femto vendors, those who are approaching the small cell opportunity from the other end of the size chart looking at a scaling up of capacities, whilst retaining the built in SON and management capabilities of their products. Any HetNet strategy will succeed or fail on the ability of operators to manage this collection of small cells within their existing network management and operating tools. Small cells will need to be as low touch as possible for operators. They will need to be easy to locate, either for regulatory or network management reasons, and will have to manage neighbouring cell relations to cause minimum interference. Heterogenous networks those with small and macro cells will be part of 3GPP Release 10 of the LTE standard, but some are warning network equipment with the required interference management and hand-off support will not be available in time with LTE release dates. This could compromise HetNet plans, although others are viewing it as an opportunity. One such is Wazco, a company that has teamed with Interphase, AirHop Communications and DataSoft to market an LTE, small cell called the MetroStorm. Dubbed LTE in a Streetlamp, Wazcos introduced MetroStorm is a multi-sector, high- small base station for the LTE mobile-infrastructure market that allies the ability to mount the unit on streelights and power poles with selforganizing, self-optimiszing, elements. In fact, most of the dedicated femto players see SON, and advanced interference management, as a natural advantage in the outdoor small cell market over their macro rivals. So Ubiquisy, for example, is one dedicated small cell company that announced an agreement with Texas Instruments to create small cells that will combine TI's infrastructure solutions with Ubiquisys' adaptive and selforganizing capabilities to deliver what Ubiquisys calls an adaptive small cell. The two companies plan to bring to market a range of dual-mode WCDMA/LTE small cells for public-space and metro environments. The first products are expected during the first half of 2012. Although SON elements are specified within 3GPP LTE standards, the delivery of SON within networks is being seen as a market differentiator by equipment vendors, many of whom have launched dedicated SON programmes something that becomes vital in the HetNet.
INSIGHT REPORT
in automated femto derived metro cell deployments, he said. Indeed, Donoso and Maravedis think SON support is essential to success. Adding the massive number of base stations required in the future will demand sophisticated and effective auto-configuration and autooptimization capabilities to minimize deployment and operational costs" said
So who will provide the dominant technology for small cell deployments? That may depend on the overall speed of take-up of LTE.
Tier-2 vendors (plus Alcatel-Lucent) are offering femto cell derived small cells (also known as carrier femto cells or carrier metro cells). Both technologies represent deployable small cell solutions for mobile network traffic. However, both carrier pico cells and carrier metro cells have trade-offs at this time:Macro derived pico cells are more expensive, larger format, and have higher power consumption than femto derived metro cells. SON support for macro derived pico cells as well as their deployment automation features parallel existing macro cells functionality. There is still a lack of clarity concerning whether interference can be adequately managed
24 | Mobile Europe Insight Report
Fernando Donoso, Maravedis Senior Analyst. A vendor's SON suite, Network Management System (NMS), and OSS integration capabilities are likely to become more important to the success of the solution than the actual small cell device. Huawei, for example, has developed a feature called SingleSON (single self optimising network), which extends their SON capability developed for LTE to operate with 3G and GSM too. This automatically reconfigures and tunes the network to match demand and the environment. From their viewpoint, cellsites must be simple to install "plug and
play while operating very efficiently. Donosos view is that femto cell vendors are, overall, more mature in developing the automated deployment and operation features that small cell networks will require. Mravedis expects both pico cells and carrier metro cells to become fully proven, complete solutions in the short to medium term, while increasing SoC sophistication and cost effectiveness drives down costs for both types of solutions. So who will provide the dominant technology for small cell deployments? That may depend on the overall speed of take-up of LTE. Maravedis forecasts that a rapid take off of the LTE market and small cell deployments will tend to favour the metro cell and carrier Wi-Fi providers. On the other hand, a slower take off of the LTE market will favour the Tier-1 incumbent vendors who have folded small cells into their mainstream product offers. Donoso points out that carrier WiFi vendors are also growing quickly and have scored some impressive contract awards with Tier-1 carriers. If the femto cell vendors falter in their promise of hassle-free automated deployment, carrier Wi-Fi vendors could take over a substantial portion of the small cell market, leaving the Tier-1 vendors to provide the larger pico cell equipment. In short, Maravedis sees carrier Wi-Fi, carrier femto and pico cells co-existing as complimentary technologies not only in the short term but in the long, with anticipated future advances in silicon breaking down the distinctions between carrier femto cells and pico cells in two to three years. The adoption of the Cloud RAN model looks set to be a fair way further out. This is mainly because many of these approaches are still on the drawing board, designware rather than hardware or software. Yet the the move to smaller cells, integrated into macro networks, with self organising and self optimising capabilities need not preclude to move to a Cloud RAN. Indeed, in some ways it lays the groundwork, by preparing network planners for a more radical shake-up of network architectures.
INSIGHT REPORT
cost, Ethernet/IP support, and capacity. ABI Research says that by 2016, an estimated 58% of outdoor small cells will be backhauled using wireless techniques. While fiber, copper, and traditional microwave are currently being used to backhaul rooftop micro base stations, the emergence of wireless technologies like NLOS OFDM (sub 6 GHz), MMW (60-80 GHz) and also Wi-Fi backhaul solutions could find preference due to their perceived flexibility, low cost and ability to use point-to-multipoint (PMP) and pointto-point (PTP) techniques to backhaul clusters or rows of small cells. Small cell backhaul space is still in its early days, with a number of small vendors positioning their solutions, especially on the wireless backhaul side. Companies such as Cambridge Broadband networks in P2MP microwave, BluWan and millimeter wave specialists BridgeWave, Siklu and E-Band Communications are all targetting the small cell opportunity, as are the major microwave vendors such as NEC with its ePASOLINK millimeter wave product line. A company like Wazco, mentioned above, has partnered with Athena Wireless Communications, to form MetroHaul, an solution that combines Wazcos multisector LTE small cell with Athenas backhaul radio for backhaul. ABI Research, however, says that the cost of these solutions still needs to come down to allow operators to make a favorable small cell business case. Microwave and millimeter wave technologies are evolving to accommodate
the emerging next-generation radio access network, by offering higher bandwidth, flexible frequency options, and new backhaul radio form factors such as alloutdoor, zero-footprint solutions. The relatively small but fast-growing millimeter wave equipment market jumped 121% in 2010 to $69 million worldwide. By 2015, Infonetics expects that 70% of millimeter wave equipment will be deployed in backhaul networks as the demand for high capacity mobile backhaul solutions for metro areas with high cell density and small cells in particular. At the moment, though, analysis of small cell backhaul is hard, as small cell deployment strategies for LTE are themselves unformed.
SUMMARY
his utopian network of the future the HetNet is a combined mix of macro/pico/femto and relay cellsites using 2G/3G and 4G in a co-ordinated system. That coordination will be key, as we have seen, with SON being a key differentiator. With all of the large basestation vendors now saying that femtocells (whether they call them small cells, picocells or something else) play a part in meeting the
traffic capacity demands of the future, theres no doubt that there will need to be a move to integrated network management. That move to integrated management, SON, across 3G and LTE networks, macro and micro and picocell networks will come to be the defining quality of the Het Net. Another key area will be the developing Cloud RAN strategies of the major vendors. An update on the activities, and
That move to integrated management across 3G and LTE networks, macro and micro and picocell networks will come to be the defining quality of the Het Net.
related developments, of the major vendors and their competitors, is what follows next in this report, on a vendor by vendor basis.
Mobile Europe Insight Report | 25
INSIGHT REPORT
Above: A stack of Alcatel-Lucents lightRadio cubes Below: lightRadio architecture overview, with antennas, radios, baseband, controllers and management
intensity. Therefore, a combination of existing and emerging technologies is required. Al-Lus view is that lightRadio makes this possible, enabling operators to get it right when deploying a solution to match user demand or expectations, while continuously optimising the overall solution all the way from the antenna to baseband processing and controller elements. Baseband digital processing modules are built on a new System on a Chip (SoC) technology that incorporates a number of previously discrete, technology-specific components into a single, low-cost, highperformance device that is technology agnostic. In addition, it is remotely programmable to accommodate changing features and even changing radio technologies. Therefore, when W-CDMA customers shift to new LTE-based devices, the baseband module that has been serving them can be remotely reprogrammed as an LTE baseband module. In addition, increases in spectral bandwidth can be accommodated, when combined with advanced load-balancing and modem-pooling functions. Finally, wideband radios and adaptive antennas enable broadening of an existing spectral band or extension to a new band without adding an entirely new radio and antenna to the cell tower. Five key business enablers of the lightRadio paradigm are all aimed at adding sufficient capacity, in the right place, with the right technology, to optimise end user experience and operator economics. The lightRadio architecture, highlighting two different wireless scale points conventional macro cells and smaller metro cells as well as three different baseband processing configurations: baseband processing in the radio head (all-in one), processing at the base of the tower (conventional baseband units) and centralised,
pooled baseband processing (in the cloud). The five technology components of the lightRadio product family include antennas, radios, baseband, controllers and management. These elements collectively create the following five business enablers,: 1. Increase in spectral bandwidth 2. Optimisation of cell site capacity 3. Optimisation of technology evolution 4. Maximum utilisation of new spectral bands 5. Optimisation of antenna configuration BENEFITS OF LIGHTRADIO, AS SEEN BY ALCATEL-LUCENT: Improves the environment: lightRadio reduces energy consumption of mobile networks by up to 50% over current radio access network equipment. (As a point of reference, Bell Labs research estimates that basestations globally emit roughly 18,000,000 metric tons of CO2 per year). Also, lightRadio provides an alternative to today's jungle of large overcrowded cell site towers by enabling small antennas anywhere. Addresses digital divide: By reducing the cell site to just the antenna and leveraging future advances in microwave backhaul and compression techniques, this technology will eventually enable the easy creation of broadband coverage virtually anywhere there is power (electricity, sun, wind) by using microwave to connect back to the network. Offers major savings for operators: Thanks to lightRadio's impact on site, energy, operations and maintenance costs; when combined with small cells and LTE, this new solution can lead to a reduction of total cost of ownership (TCO) of mobile networks up to 50% (as a point of reference, Bell Labs estimates that TCO spent by mobile operators in mobile access in 2010 was 150 billion Euros). Enhances quality for end users: by doubling macro capacity and reducing the cost per bit lightRadio opens up the possibility to offer new services and price points. Alcatel-Lucent says network operators such as France Telecom/Orange, Telefonica and China Mobile are now engaged in moving to market implementation of lightRadio.
INSIGHT REPORT
turning on of thousands of small cells within a network. The small products will not be commercial until 2012, although operators have had sight of pre-market, larger models, through 2011. Although Ericsson has always resisted the femto words, its arguments in favour of its new product, that it will help carriers add new capacity and coverage with lower cost and power consumption are very close to those used by the proponents of femto technology. Ulf Ewaldson, head of radio, said the AIR product is the first step in a broader 'HetNet' strategy. We are experiencing a tremendous take-off in mobile broadband and the user expectations on speed and coverage are increasing the demands on the networks. In order to cope with the future capacity demands, we have a clearly defined small cell strategy. I am proud to announce that the AIR architecture is the first stepping stone towards a heterogeneous network, he said.
Its important to note that Ericsson positions its Network Integrated WiFi solution as one part of its HetNet concept
INTEGRATED CARRIER WIFI Ericsson has also embraced another small cell technology that is being viewed as an important tool in the need to meet wireless bandwidth demands carrier WiFi. Launched in September 2011, Ericssons Network Integrated WiFi
solution enables seamless connection of smartphones to operatorcontrolled WiFi access without requiring a specific software client in the device and without any user interaction. The Network Integrated Wi-Fi solution is markets as providing an increase to overall network capacity, especially in congested areas. It also supports the fast-growing ecosystem of WiFi enabled devices. Ericsson hopes that operators can benefit from new revenue models from wholesale of WiFi access, by using a carrier WiFi solution to provide the basis for business agreements between themselves and hot-spot providers. Its important to note that Ericsson positions its Network Integrated WiFi solution as one part of its HetNet concept. The solution authenticates SIM based devices in the Home Location Register and connects traffic from the WiFi access network, through the mobile packet network and up to the mobile operator's service environment. As the smartphone user is recognised by the network, the subscription profile is maintained also when connected via WiFi. This provides users with to the same services as when connected to the mobile network. The first release includes local off-load of the traffic from the SmartEdge Border Network Gateway (BNG).
Above left: Ericssons HetNet vision Above: Antenna Integrated Radio (Back view)
INSIGHT REPORT
Huawei says its solutions are geared to being implemented with existing networks
The LTE Micro BTS is part of Huaweis SingleRAN solution, that adopts integrated BTS (base transceiver station), BSC (base station controller), OSS (operating support system) and site solutions to drive the three radio features, including LTE, within a single network. Huawei says this means operators are able to choose different feature combinations to suit their business. For now, Huawei is leaving cloud RAN messaging alone, and trying to capitalise on SingleRAN. The Chinese firms four microcells consist of the BTS3202E for LTE, the BTS3902E for UMTS, and the BTS3702E and BTS3701B for WiMAX, all part of the SingleRAN family and supporting self-organising network capabilities. The new base stations integrate the radio, antenna and baseband in a single compact unit. Huaweis argument against against the Alcatel-Lucent approach, was to point up its reliance on plentiful fibre, and to say that while more radical architectures would be suited to greenfield deployments, its solutions are geared to being implemented with existing sites and networks.
and small, compact micro, pico and femto cells. Nokia Siemens Networks Flexi Multiradio Antenna System is based on active antenna technology that combines antenna and radio part in one functional enclosure, built with dedicated power amplifiers for each antenna element. The active antenna allows beamforming focusing a particular radio connection and directing it to a specific user as well as handling of multiple technologies in one unit. Together with other layers of coverage provided by macro, pico and micro site configurations, beamforming allows capacity to be directed exactly where the user requires it, delivering up to 65% capacity gain. The Flexi Race is the next step in NSNs
INSIGHT REPORT
move to miniaturisation, being described by the vendor as the basic element to build next generation active antennas and future products to build micro and pico cells. Due to its compact size, the Flexi Race is equipped with additional intelligence and scaling options required for this type of deployments. NSN too is committed to the concept of the heterogeneous networks. It describes this approach as key to a reduction of management complexity. Connectivity for different layers of the network in one unified network and user experience will be orchestrated by the companys SON capability and its continuous evolution to fully support cognitive self learning and adaptive networks. Liquid Radio, based on NSNs SONenabled Flexi integrated antennas, itself forms a part of NSNs LiquidNet vision NSNs clearest iteration yet that it too sees the benefits for operators in the Cloud RAN. Liquid Net is NSNs term for the cloudbased network that leverages the capabilities of Liquid Radio. Liquid Net builds on the principles of Nokia Siemens Networks Liquid Radio architecture. It adds Liquid Core and Liquid Transport functionality to the network which can be implemented either separately in multivendor environments or in concert across an operators entire network to bring the full benefits of Liquid Net to bear. It allows an operator to set up its network to self-adapt to meet capacity and coverage requirements based on demand. The new approach also aims to significantly improve the quality of broadband services worldwide. Spectacular broadband growth means networks must be ready to cope with personal data consumption of more than 1GB per mobile user per day. Demand is also highly unpredictable, fluctuating between locations at different times as people use broadband at home, at work and on the move. Abrupt changes in broadband use can also occur when, say, new device software is launched, or updates to popular applications and overthe-top services are released, leaving operators no time to prepare.
Capacity in todays conventional networks is typically frozen in separate places; at individual base station sites, in parts of the core network that manage voice and data services, or in the optical and IP transport networks, says Marc Rouanne, head of Network Systems at Nokia Siemens Networks. Each is a potential bottleneck to someone getting the broadband service they want at a particular moment. Fluctuating, unpredictable demand in one part of the network means huge chunks of capacity can be left idle elsewhere, making poor use of existing investments. For example, as much as 50% of a conventional core networks capacity can be dormant. Instead, Liquid Net unleashes frozen network capacity into a reservoir of resources that can flow to fulfil unpredictable demand, wherever and whenever people use broadband. NSN has created Liquid Net, to free-up unused capacity and allocate it instantly
Where Liquid Radio was about supporting capacity growth and flexibility in the RAN, Liquid Net smartly carries the theme forward to transport and core networks promising an optimisation of not only user traffic but CAPEX investments
across the whole network wherever and whenever it is needed. Liquid Net uses automated, self-adapting broadband optimisation to deliver services and content to ensure the best customer experience by always being aware of the networks operational status and the services being consumed. In addition, Liquid Net channels traffic in the transport network along the path of least resistance and lowest cost between operator sites. NSN claims that not only does Liquid Net help operators to raise customer loyalty, but it also opens up new business opportunities. Where Liquid Radio was about supporting capacity growth and flexibility
in the Radio Access Network (RAN), Liquid Net smartly carries the theme forward to transport and core networks promising an optimisation of not only user traffic but CAPEX investments, said Peter Jarich, Current Analysis, service director for Service Provider Infrastructure. Perhaps most importantly, Liquid Net speaks to a need for solutions rather than point products; while components can be deployed as part of a multi-vendor solution, the combination of Liquid Radio, Liquid Core and Liquid Transport into Liquid Net speaks to holistic thinking around operator concerns and demands, Jarich wrote in NSNs Liquid Net press release. NSN says that Liquid Radio, Liquid Core and Liquid Transport can be implemented together or separately in the network for fluid capacity, coverage and services, and to enable their introduction and management within multi-vendor networks.
Mobile Europe Insight Report | 29
INSIGHT REPORT
ZTE C-RAN
TE is one vendor that has paid lip service to a Cloud RAN wireless networking solution. Its C-RAN vision, which it says has been introduced by Chinese operator CMCC, is also intended to dramatically lower both capex and opex for operators and greatly reduce power consumption through its new wireless-access network architecture. ZTE said that the solution is expected to lower the TCO (total cost of ownership) of wireless networks by 40%. ZTE said that when it comes to lowering the per-bit data costs - day to day operational costs such as base station sites, data centre and day-to-day operations are often over 60% of the overall cost of operation. Therefore, delivering innovation at the wireless architectural level is more impactful, leading ZTE to propose a new generation of C-RAN solutions.
To this end, ZTE points to its activities in China, where it says it has taken the lead to explore a C-RAN solution together with CMCC, to develop a new generation of wireless access networks through centralised processing, collaborative radio, real-time cloud infrastructure, green wireless access network architecture, and cloud computing. As such, it claims to be the the first company in the industry to realise dynamic baseband sharing, and is actively
Based on the case of CMCC ZTE said that the C-RAN architecture could the access network's capex by about 20% and opex by about 63%, reducing the 10-year TCO by about 40%, and reducing the construction cycle by a third
promoting its application by tackling key C-RAN technologies. For example, using Colored Fiber Connection, it says it has solved the problems associated with the consumption of LTE optic fiber resources, completed the Phase I prototype of LTE Advanced CoMP (Coordinated Multippoint), and deployed this with a number of Chinese operators.
ZTEs C-RAN solution realises the separation of the Remote Radio Unit (RRU) and the Baseband Unit (BBU) on the wireless side, and has completed the centralised evolution from base-stations to base-station clusters. On this basis, it can further improve coordination between the stations in a base-station cluster through the upgrade of BBU, and to realise the coordination between the base-station clusters through the interconnection of large-capacity BBUs. The BBU infrastructure can be built using general IT platforms, to realise equipment virtualisation and scheduling ability through cloud computing. It forms part of the continuing and deeper integration between the telecom industry and the IT industry. ZTE says that its trials have demonstrated that C-RAN architecture can realise large-capacity with a small number of nodes, to dramatically reduce capex for operators. Based on the case of CMCC (in which only a small number of new optical cables needed to be deployed, due to the number of pipelines already in use), ZTE said that the C-RAN architecture could the access network's capex by about 20% and opex by about 63%, reducing the 10-year TCO by about 40%, and reducing the construction cycle by a third. It could reduce power consumption by over 80% compared to the traditional macro base-stations.
We are hiring now, said IP Hong Vice President of Marketing at Samsung's Telecom Systems Business. The company is already in trials with one major European operator, Hong said. Although the vendor has little current footprint in European wireless infrastructure, it has won LTE deals in the USA with MetroPCS and Cellular South, with Mobily in the Middle East and will support SK Telecoms commercial launch of LTE in July 2011, according to Hong. Samsung is tying in the launch of its European operations with its Smart LTE
portfolio, an LTE solution that includes features such as intelligent radio resource allocation. Hong added that amongst Samsungs capabilities was a special technology for interference cancellation, that goes beyond current specifications. The company is also marketing its multi-standards base station, with both macro and small cells in its product line. It will include 2G and 3G capabilities within that converged approach, hoping to offer operators flexibility as they swap out ageing equipment for more power and spectrally-efficient designs.
INSIGHT REPORT
Other vendors are taking an approach that views the HetNet as a step towards the dominance of small cells - not just in terms of total numbers of cells (there are already more femtocells than macro cells) but in terms of traffic handled, and even in terms of how operators view network design. Shraram Niri, of NEC, has long proposed the view that if operators want to get the capacity improvements that LTE is intended to deliver, meaning over 25Mbps, then they will need to design networks almost entirely of small cells. Lets be clear. Hes not talking about designing a network that has mainly macro coverage but with some small cells dropped in where capacity demands are highest. No, hes saying that to get the most out of LTE, operators need to deploy networks that are composed mostly of small cells. So what of the argument that tens of thousands of small cells are too expensive to deploy challenging the backhaul network, and driving up opex? Niri said that SON, interference management, and
ease of location will all mitigate the cost of delivering a multiple-small-cell network. Kenny Graham, Head of LTE and Innovation Solutions at Vodafone Group, said that in his view the basic performance of SON has worked well so far in trials Vodafone has carried out. SON is intended to provide automatic functions as interference management, devicebased neighbour relations, mobility load balancing and Cell-iD collision detection. The basics of SON are proven, Graham said, and now we are moving on to the more advanced features, to extract the actual performance gains that SON can bring, and not just the
The basics of SON are proven, Graham said, and now we are moving on to the more advanced features, to extract the actual performance gains that SON can bring
opex improvements. If femtocell proponents are to have a major role in the LTE network of the future, then their ability to interwork with macro elements will be crucial. Work continues to prove that femto elements will be non-disruptive in terms of performance and management. In the summer of 2011 the latest in a series of plugfests used a real network to test hand-over between femtocells and surrounding base stations, as well as using France Telecoms core network to test femtocell integration. 13 companies participated in interoperability tests conducted between femtocell network gateways, security gateways, management systems femtocell access points and chipsets to verify 3GPPs Iuh interface, as defined in the Release 9 series of specifications. The companies involved were Ablaze Wireless, Alcatel-Lucent, Alpha Networks, Askey Computer, Cisco, Continuous Computing, France Telecom, Huawei Technologies, ip.access, NEC, Node-H, NSN and Picochip.
mean that mobile operators would view WiFi providers as trusted roaming partners, opening up new business relationships and increasing the opportunities for data offload and roaming. The WBA calls the programme the Next Generation Hotspot (NGH) programme, and it is working with a pilot group of operators and technology providers to define interoperability requirements for hotspot and 3G/4G operators. One company aiming to give operators increased flexibility between WiFi and cellular networks, and address backhaul at the same time, is BelAir Networks. BelAir launched its100SP Strand Picocell last year, and has an updated product due as Mobile Europe went to press. The Strand Picocell is designed to sit on the end of cable network infrastructure, allowing operators to take advantage of
cable plants power and locations. BelAir says that the unit can sit on overhead cable, or on residential pedestals, or in cabinets. It can use AC power from the cable plant and use the cable network for backhaul. This addresses the three problems mobile operators have in cell site planning site availability, power and backhaul. Because the cells offer radios covering both licensed and unlicensed spectrum, they could be deployed by mobile operators to offer cell site coverage, but also be used to offload traffic from wireless networks directly over the cable network. The WiFi side of the unit would also enable cable operators to offer wireless access to their own subscribers. Of course, if carrier WiFi does take of, major providers such as Cisco will also address carriers with integrated, policy aware, solutions.
Mobile Europe Insight Report | 31
Pricing innovation
Is the price right? Operators are taking steps to make more personal pricing offers.
phone stated that they have encountered problems with the service, while a further 70% of video users have experienced problems when they access video. For video specifically, stalling was found to be the most frequent and least acceptable issue (60%), followed by having to wait a long time for the video to play (26%). Yet in these apparent negatives, lies opportunity. The research also revealed that only 11% of consumers disagree or strongly disagree with operator intervention to optimise video during periods of congestion and 21% of respondents are even willing to pay to prevent the video from stalling and improve the overall quality. The findings also highlight a strong desire among consumers for more context-aware and personal preference-oriented services. 70% of those questioned stated that they would like to be notified in real-time about network congestion, while another 71% wanted to be notified about large download sizes, which may impact their data usage. Greater tariff flexibility and differentiation also appears to be high on consumers wish-lists, with 26% of video users stating that they would be happy to pay for a service that would enable them to save on their bundle. Nearly three quarters (72%) of respondents, meanwhile, wanted the option to delay application updates to a time when downloads are free. Commenting on the research, Steven van Zanen, SVP Marketing at Acision, says, In order to enhance the end user experience, operators need to define new strategies and take a holistic, 360 quality of experience approach, which takes into consideration a number of key factors such as subscriber type, service characteristics/experience,
Pricing innovation
personal preferences, device and content/context awareness. So are operators in a position to do this? Gordon Rawling, Senior Director of Regional Marketing, Oracle Communications, EMEA, says that there is not an operator who hasnt expressed the objective of having a more dynamic pricing and billing structure. Yet Rawling says that although that desire is there, there are still some barriers to overcome. Chief amongst these are business and some technical issues. For instance, the traditional separation of off/on line, pre/post pay is technically driven, yet in theory doesnt mean a lot to consumers. Its just a way of paying. If I happen to be a post-paid customer, it doesnt mean I wouldnt want to take advantage of a pre-paid service opportunity an operator might want to offer me, Rawling says. As for those business issues, this year the the CMO Council, with sponsorship from Openet, surveyed 212 staff at operators, representing marketing and technology functions. It asked if these professionals thought their own companies were equipped to provide consumer-centric services, and respond to the changes in subscriber demands and increasing complexity. Liz Miller, VP of Programs and Operations at the CMO Council, told Mobile Europe that 75% of those surveyed believe that lack of integration between data sources was hampering the introduction of new, more personalised and relevant services. 72% also thought that poor alignment between sales, marketing and IT was hampering efforts. 68% agreed that a traditional corporate mindset was out of sync with new forms of competition. Additionally, 83% felt they needed to get a better handle on the network resource and support challenges presented by a more diverse and demanding customer base and the proliferation of new devices and service offerings. Miller said, There is a sense that operators are dealing with a legacy mindest that responds to subscriber demands by applying traditional infrastructure, operational and pricing solutions. The aftermath of that is that they do not have enough access to the data they need to drive data-driven customer experiences. There is a sense of paralysis to even start to aggregate that data, that they are faced with this overwhemling wave of customer insights that could be aggregated. Then they try to aggregate that data and
VoIP service, operatorprovided or Over the Top are one example of how user profiles are changing.
There is a sense that operators are dealing with a legacy mindest that responds to subscriber demands by applying traditional infrastructure, operational and pricing solutions
end up with soiled data. The problem is to turn that key data into insights that can be actioned. Operators are looking for new revenue streams and to go beyond the new pricing matrix, beyond these legacy conversations, to deliver personalized, hi touch and more profitable customer experiences. Ari Banerjee, senior analyst, Heavy Reading, identifies one of the key technical barriers operators have been facing - that their existing policy and charging tools are not integrated, and cant provide the required functionality. Our research shows there is global consensus that integration of charging and policy management capabilities is required to monetise these new data pricing strategies. Service providers have found attempts to integrate charging and policy management by their internal IT and network departments challenging and too expensive and are now seeking pre-integrated vendor solutions. Amdocs claims that its research findings reveal that charging subscribers based on the customer experience provided is gaining mindshare, but existing systems are challenged to enable it: Its research, carried out with Heavy Reading, found that marketing departments want to introduce more sophisticated data price plans, with 83% of respondents say their marketing organizations are asking IT to enable innovative data price plan. Over 90% say their companies are looking to create packages across lines of business, customer types and payment methods, while 86% of providers plan to launch tiered pricing plans; and 82% plan to launch single data plans for multiple devices (e.g. tablets, smartphones, etc.). To roll out these services, Amdocs says that integrated charging and policy management capabilities are required to enable these more sophisticated data price plans Amdocs says that IT organizations find it difficult to deliver, as 80 percent of respondents do not think their existing policy management systems, deployed to support network-related use cases (bandwidth management, fair usage, bill shock) can support more advanced use cases, such as data plans across multiple lines of business, payment methods and spend limits, and more. 10 percent have tried to integrate charging and policy management systems and failed. This survey validates the need for better integrated charging and policy management capabilities in order for service providers to create, offer and monetize the next generation of data services, says Rebecca Prudhomme, vice president of product and solutions marketing at
Mobile Europe | 35
Pricing innovation
analysis of the impacts of certain tariffs within specific customer segments and benchmark that against other tariffs. All operators are looking at how they can drive an increased understanding of the interaction between complex tariff bundles and the profitability of a subsegment. When we run reports we not only allow our customers to understand how profitable segments are but also how that compares to all other tariffs from their competitors in that market. That means you can say not only if a tariff is likely to be good for you as a business, but you can use it to differentiate, and be sure you have a chance to be successful in a segment, Skoczkowski says. Redknees customer Telefonica is also using Sandvine's Policy Traffic Switch to collect network data and present that to executive management functions to help them to make business decisions and to enforce new policies in the network. As a global company, Telefnicas network insight and business intelligence is key to understanding how we can better serve our vast subscriber base worldwide, says Vicente San Miguel, CTO, Telefnica Corporate. At one subsidiary, Telefnica recently introduced a menu of tiered pricing plans that accommodate subscribers personalised network usage patterns and budgets. Under this model, subscribers can choose from plans that range from a basic email or social networking plan, to more comprehensive plans that also cover real-time entertainment usage. Operators have the tools to make this happen. Companies like Allot who offer application, device and subscriber awareness enable operators to distinguish between applications such video or VoIP or devices such as an Android or iPhone. Subscriber awareness is used in conjunction with application awareness to implement intelligent charging models and policies per subscriber. The ability to service subscribers according to their data usage patterns is especially useful for marketing valueadded services like unlimited social network plans. Good practices in the industry don't always have to focus on premium plans, though. In fact, Telefonica in Latin America offers a variation of a reduced Internet plan. Within the reduced plan, subscribers can pay for just what they use, which is often basic email, chat, and Web surfing. A variation may be a Social Networking package with usage-based pricing for social networking apps like Facebook and Twitter. However, if a subscriber wants a premium service and is educated about the price points associated with the services that matter most to them then this is what should be considered best practice. Allot Communications told Mobile Europe that it believes that within the next 12-24 months operators will move quickly to value-based pricing, enabled by solutions
Amdocs. But we must remember that customers also want to get their new services in a simple and intuitive manner. This is exactly Bandwidth on demand where value-based pricing should come into play. For turbo boost solution flow. example, a movie package that has data and speed (Both use cases from Allot prerequisites already embedded into it for a high-quality Communications) experience will offer end customers the personalised service for which they are willing to pay more. Acisions Van Zanen echoes the theme. In order to maintain a sustainable competitive edge, operators need to evolve from a purely technology-driven approach to a more customer-centric approach and gain control of all aspects of the service. Operators have the opportunity to lead the market on service differentiation, transparency and accountability, by offering clarity on service quality and insight into network performance, he says. Certainly, there is evidence that some operators are taking a more scientific approach to analysing the offers that they make to their customers. Explaining a rising interest in detailed customer analysis, such as that performed by Redknees Price Simulator package, Lucas Skoczkowski, Redknee CEO says, Operators are looking to drive a lot higher efficiency, and more understanding, of how to best tailor their businesses to extract more value from each of their customer segments: so precision becomes much more important. Historically there has been sufficient room in the market so that precision wasnt necessarily the operating word. That has changed, however, and operators are under greater pressure to identify new customer segments, and address those with the most efficient and profitable tariffs and bundles. What we are looking for is agility but with more precision. Sometimes you can create something speedily but lack the precision to ensure you get the result the CFO of the company expects. With operators seeing What we are looking for is agility but increased competition for with more precision. Sometimes you can certain demographic create speedily but lack the precision to segments, there is more motivation to provide ensure you get the result you expect detailed forecasts and
36 | Mobile Europe
Mobile money
MOBILE MONEY
Operator-led mobile money and payments services are still thin on the ground, but momentum is growing across Europe, as operators move to commercialisation of NFC technology. So where can we look to for operator-led market momentum?
the first NFC Android mobile sold in Europe, according to the operator. The phone will be the fourth mobile available from Orange for customers of Cityzi, Orange's brand for mobile NFC services in France. Orange said this device version has been developed by the teams from Orange and Samsung in line with the specifications mapped out by the French mobile contactless association (AFSCM) and relevant international standards. The launch will, the operator claimed, make Orange is the first operator in Europe to offer a SIM-based NFC Android mobile using the SIM card to guarantee the security of contactless mobile services. Orange has already committed to rolling out NFC-enabled secure SIM cards nationally, and has also previously stated that the Group is working with equipment manufacturers to ensure that more than half of the new smartphone models are compatible with the contactless services. Orange has been marketing Cityzi mobiles throughout France since February 2011, making it one of the world's first mobile NFC offers on this scale. It claims to have attracted more than 150,000 Orange customers for services that include passes for local transport, payment in over 1000 partner shops, loyalty, couponing and tag reading. Orange said that the Galaxy launch confirms its ambition to offer an extensive range of Cityzi mobiles, to enable as many of its customers as possible to benefit from contactless services across France. The existing device range includes the Samsung Player City and Wave 578. Orange has said it will extend the CityZi mobile contactless service, currently being piloted in Nice, across the country in 2011. The operator has been marketing the "Player One Cityzi handset across France from January. It has a target of "at least" 500,000 French customers with compatible devices by the end of the calendar year. The operator is also pushing for NFC-enabled SIMs to be made available in all its markets across Europe by the second half of 2011. The Group is also working with manufacturers to ensure that over half of the new smartphone models it buys will be compatible with contactless services when combined with the new, secure SIM card. The Nice pilot involved Orange as well as France's other two major operators, SFR and Bouyges, as well as NRJ mobile and other service providers.
ome 20 countries are expected to launch NFC services in the next 18 months, resulting in transactions approaching $50 billion worldwide by 2014, according to a report from Juniper Research. Following on from the Orange Mobile Payments service launch in the UK, 2012 is expected to be a banner year for NFC service rollouts, Juniper said, with prospects for NFC having improved markedly in the last half year. According to Senior Analyst David Snow, Our view is that the next 18 months will see launches in up to 20 countries. As a result Juniper is forecasting that North America and Western Europe together will exceed the Far East region in under three years based on transaction value. Its tempting to see this as all good news for mobile operators, as if NFC services and payments will necessarily gravitate to a model that sees mobile operators as the chief distributors of the devices and SIMs that make the service possible. Certainly Nav Bains, who leads the NFC service programme at the GSMA is positive. The days for pilots are now over, he said. NFC is now going to market properly, and we will see increasing numbers of commercial launches of NFC, with a lot more operators making commercial SIMbased NFC moves. Bains cant share where he thinks these launches will come from, as it is commercially sensitive, but he is clear that there will be significant progress over the next year. So where can we look to for operator-led NFC mobile payments initiatives?
Staying with Orange, in the UK it has announced that it is launching an NFC-based retail payment service called Quick Tap - intially launched with
Mobile money
Google Wallet launched to fanfare in the USA - with Spring, Citi, Visa and Mastercard as partners. Google said it would welcome more operator involvement in its wallet service as it rolls out the service across different markets.
another Samsung handset, the Toco. O2 is not so far behind. It has announced the technical and service partners it would be working with to deliver a mobile money service later this year, with O2's parent Telefonica probably the most aggressive group operator in the NFC space, outside of Orange. Orange UK customers in the service are able to pay for items up to 15 without entering a PIN, using a Samsung Tocco Quick Tap handset available on Pay As You Go for 59.99, and from free on Pay Monthly contracts from 10 per month on 24 month contracts. The operator has since added the Samsung Wave 578, which will work in accordance with a Barclaycard, Barclays debit or Orange credit The JV, controversial because it excludes card. Customers can load UK, would bring together the operators' up to 100 on the wallet. Gemalto is acting as development efforts in NFC the Trusted Service
Manager, which includes the supply of NFC-enabled SIMs, containing the secure element, to Orange. Orange said the NFC phones can be used at 50,000 stores, mainly at branches of Pret a Manger, EAT, Little Chef, Subway, Wilkinson and McDonalds that already have contactless payments terminals. The company said 12.9 million contactless credit and debit cards are already in circulation, of which over 11.4m have been issued by Barclaycard. O2 confirmed that it too will launch a mobile money and payments service - under the O2 Money brand - after it discontinued current operations in its O2 Money service. Due to relaunch in the second half of 2011, but not visible as Mobile EUrope went to press, O2's service seems to go further than Orange's payments solution. Capabilities planned for the wallet include m-commerce, airtime top ups, contactless/NFC payments and peer-to-peer payments. The operator will also add NFC capabilities to its existing O2 Money Visa pre-paid card service. O2 said that its commercial and technical partners for its service would be Wave Crest, FIS, Intelligent Environments and Visa Europe. Wave Crest will provide and operate the core banking platform upon which the new prepaid card and mobile wallet services will run. Wave Crest will also manage the security and online customer experience. FIS will provide transaction processing and UK-based customer service for both the prepaid cards and mobile wallet. Intelligent Environments has been appointed to develop the wallet application and Visa Europe will be the payment network for the wallet and new prepaid products. Everything Everywhere, Telefonica UK and Vodafone UK are also working on the creation of a joint venture before the end of the year that will act as a single point of contact for marketers, banks, retailers and anyone else that wants to create a mobile commerce service. The JV, controversial because it excludes 3 UK, would bring together the operators' development efforts in NFC, for payments and other services, as well as provide a single contact point for advertisers, media agencies and retailers looking to reach consumers on their mobile phones. The JV will enable brands and service providers to book advertising space and create campaigns as well as provide offers, coupons and loyalty cards which can be stored on the phone and redeemed in shops.
Mobile Europe | 39
Mobile money
The operators said that they would continue to compete, but base their services on "the open platform infrastructure provided by the JV". taking part in the test, which is a cooperation between Telenor, DnB NOR, MasterCard, Teller, Nets and Giesecke and Devrient. The test project is part of a NFC City, a user driven research project which is partly financed by the research council of Norway. The customer will be able to pay by holding their mobile up to the payment terminal at the till. Payment will be faster than and just as secure as paying by card. The money will be debited from the customer's MasterCard. Everybody taking part in the test will be using a Samsung mobile with built-in NFC technology and an adapted SIM card. Most producers of smart phones will include this technology in the time to come. The Oslo test is one of the first in Scandinavia and will be an important milestone towards our use of mobile phones as wallets. We are certain that contactless payment via mobile will become extremely widespread, because we all take our mobiles everywhere we go, and because it's a secure and easy way to pay, says Jon Fredrik Baksaas, President and CEO in Telenor.
SPAIN
Trials continue. One thousand employees on a Telefonica campus in Madrid will use mobile NFC services during their working lives, as Telefonica continues to promote NFC usage. Telefonica said that employees at its District C site (to be renamed District NFC) campus would be given Samsung NFC phones and would be able to use them to gain access to the site and pay for food on campus. in time the number of participants in the project will be increased to include all 14,000 employees on site. Partners in the project include Autogrill,Bankinter, BBVA, G&D, La Caixa, Oberthur, Samsung, Sermepa and Visa. A bigger trial in Spain, an NFC trial in Sitges, has now ended. Telefonica said that its Mobile Shopping Sitges 2010 trial had resulted in customers carrying out 30% more e-transactions, with a 23% increase in average purchase per user with their card.
POLAND
Gemalto, specialist in digital security, has announced that PTK Centertel, an Orange group affiliate, is deploying the largest NFC program in Poland, with a commercial offer targeting several thousand users. Gemaltos already plays an active role in Orange Groups NFC expansion strategy with deployments already in the UK, France (see above) and now Poland. Gemalto provided an end-to-end solution that includes NFC software and user interface applications securely embedded on an NFC SIM, and the Trusted Service Management (TSM) services. PTK Centertel and its partnering bank have entrusted Gemalto with the operation of the TSM platform, to securely personalise and manage the payment application in the device over the air. Krzysztof Sieczkowski, Product and Content Development Director, PTK Centertel, said, We need a complete solution to speed up our time-to-market, and leverage the strong contactless payment network already existing in Poland to make our consumer the first to benefit from the NFC experience.
The level of confusion about who does what in this market was reflected by the warm response to this infographic from mobilepaymentstoday. You can see the full infographic at mobilepaymentstoday.com
TURKEY
Turkcell has announced the official launch of the T20 smartphone, one of the world's first commercially available UICC ("Universal Integrated Circuit Card"), NFC - SWP ("Single Wire Protocol") Android-based device. Turkcell T20 allows consumers to use their phone as a mobile wallet, using MasterCard's contactless technology, the PayPass scheme. The aim of Turkcell Cep-T Czdan, a mobile wallet service from Turkcell, which is already loaded on the Turkcell T20 and communicates with an NFC enabled sim card, is also to provide a comprehensive end-to-end NFC platform open to all service providers and banks. As part of this platform, Turkcell TSM (Trusted Service Manager) was developed and Turkcell became the first telecom operator in Europe to launch an approved TSM solution by MasterCard. Turkcell, working with MasterCard, is the first mobile operator in the world that presents more than one bank application in Cep-T Czdan.
Samsungs Galaxy S II, now available for NFC service use in France through Orange.
NORWAY
Around 250 of Telenor's and DnB NOR's customers will be testing the option of paying via mobile over the coming months. A dozen locations in Oslo are taking part in the test. Shops from the Kaffebrenneriet, Vita and Deli de Luca chains are
40 | Mobile Europe
That Oracle then rubbed salt in the wounds by suggesting that Autonomy had made itself available to Oracle, at a lower price than HP paid, but still a price Oracle found too much, will surely be added to the HP Business School Wiki. Autonomys CEO denied this, then was reminded of the time and date he met Oracle. Then he said that meeting wasnt about a sale, whereupon Oracle said they had his powerpoint slides of the meeting, very financial in nature. The case, as court reporters say, continues. Speaking of courts...perhaps HPs decision to shut WebOS will save it from being caught up in the damaging and high stakes spate of litigation in the mobile device market. Chief agitants, lining up in courtrooms across the world, are Samsung and Apple. But they are by no means the only companies going down the legal route. The trend for suing for breach of IP reached such heights that as Amazon released its Kindle Fire, one of the first questions being asked on Twitter was, whos going to sue them first?
42 | Mobile Europe
LTE promises greatly accelerated data rates even when mobile users are travelling at hundreds of kilometers per hour. However, as LTE moves from the labs into actual deployments, debates over the glaring gap in delivering voice
Keith Dyer,
Editor, Mobile Europe
over an LTE network are growing. Voice is the major revenue generator for operators, and voice-over-LTE (VoLTE) is now being touted as the technology of choice for delivering voice to LTE networks.
EXFO Presenters:
In this webinar EXFOs LTE experts will examine the benefits of VoLTE, and the challenges (both pre-deployment and postMurat Bilgic,
Director of Wireless Technology, CTO Office
deployment) faced by manufacturers and operators developing and deploying VoLTE networks.
Join us on 2 November to learn more about: Why VoLTE and why now? I How operators can guarantee call quality that meets and exceeds expectations of end-users
Uvaiz Ahmed,
Wireless Product Line Manager
I The challenges of interoperating with legacy networks (UMTS, GSM, CDMA, etc.) I The co-existence of data and voice over a shared network I Monitoring, troubleshooting and analyzing a deployed VoLTE network
Wayne Davis,
Service Assurance Product Manager
Please join EXFOs team of experts on 2 November, 2011 to learn everything you need to know about VoLTE.
Visit this URL to REGISTER: https://www1.gotomeeting.com/register/321108553 Email: Shahid.ramzan@mobileeurope.co.uk Tel: +44207 933 8980