Smartphone Patents: The Never-Ending War - WSJ.

com

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303624004577339931...

News, Quotes, Companies, Videos Thursday, April 12, 2012 As of 6:51 PM New York 68 | 49

SEARCH

TECHNOLOGY
U.S. Edition Home World U.S.
Today's Paper People In The News Video Blogs Journal Community Subscribe Log In

New York

Business

Markets
Digits

Tech

Personal Finance

Life & Culture

Opinion

Careers

Real Estate

Small Business

Personal Technology

What They Know

All Things Digital

3 of 12 4 of 12

1 of 12

2 of 12

Smartphone Technology Patents: NeverEnding War

TECHNOLOGY

TOP STORIES IN

Barnes & Noble Hit Hard

Best Buy Probes CEO Relationship

Google Preserves Cash and Control

Infosys Profit 27%

Updated April 12, 2012, 9:51 p.m. ET

Smartphone Patents: The Never-Ending War

Even Minor Features Figure in Big Battles as Rivalry Heats Up
Article
Video Stock Quotes Comments (21)
MORE IN TECH

Save

Recommend

302

Tweet

144

By ASHBY JONES and JESSICA E. VASCELLARO

Customers shopping for Apple Inc.'s AAPL -2.32% iPhone might pay little attention to the gadget's "slide to unlock" feature, but you would never know that from a quick glance at Apple's current roster of patent lawsuits. The technology giant has secured two key U.S. patents on slide-to-unlocka technology that lets users wake a dormant phone with a finger-swipe across the screen. And it is wielding those patents like swords against rivals around the world. In recent months, Apple has sued HTC Corp. in Delaware and Germany over one of those patents and others. It has used the patents to fight back against suits
WSJ photo illustration

Available to WSJ.com Subscribers

Smartphone Patents: Never-Ending War

Motorola Mobility Holdings Inc. MMI -0.08% filed against it in Miami and

Pressure on Oil Supply Eases Costs Hobble Banks' Profits Recession's Pain Hit Men, Women at Different Pace

Germany. And it has invoked them in lawsuits against Samsung Electronics Co. in Australia, the Netherlands, and San Jose, Calif.

When Industries Collide

As competition in the more than $200 billion global smartphone industry becomes more cutthroat, Apple and its competitors argue that even the most minor unique features are crucial to getting an edge. They are engaged in a lawsuit-filing frenzy, asserting their rights to dozens of patents to block rival products. Their goal: to find a patent that sticks, and to force competitors to work around it or strike a licensing deal. Slide-to-unlock is one of those patents, though it hardly seems central to a smartphone. Its historyand futureshow how today's battles are
Apple Launches New Legal Attack on Samsung 03:32 Apple's New iPad Features a New Version of iPhoto That Makes Editin 03:40 Top 5 in Tech Fri, April 6th, 2012 Featuring What Mossberg Thinks 15:44

Don't Miss...

Powered by Taboola

1 of 6

04/13/2012 11:01 AM

Smartphone Patents: The Never-Ending War - WSJ.com

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303624004577339931...

being waged. About five years ago, the computer and mobile-phone industries collided. Technological advances turned phones into minicomputers, complete with email, Web access and other features. Companies from different corners of industry saw opportunityand pounced. Among them: phone makers like Nokia Corp. NOK -4.73% and Motorola; computer-hardware makers like Apple; software giants such as Google Inc. and Microsoft MSFT +0.16% Corp.; and others, including South Korean electronics giant Samsung. From the get-go, companies fought fiercely for consumer dollars with huge marketing blitzes.
Enlarge Image

Most Popular
Read Emailed Video 1. Peggy Noonan: It's Over. What Have We Learned?
Subscriber Content

Read Preview

Peggy Noonan 2. BlackRock's Street Shortcut Most Popular in Tech

'Dollar Shave Club' Has Men in Lather Google Preserves Cash, Control U.S. Alleges Collusion On E-Book Prices Barnes & Noble Hit Hard Seeking 'Second' Life After Facebook

Developing Gripes
Behind the scenes, another battle was brewing over intellectual property. Almost overnight, every player had developed a gripe. The traditional phone makers claimed, for instance, that Apple was abusing their long-held rights to data-transmission designs. Apple complained others were ripping off its designs.

Related Video

Most Popular on Facebook

Create an account or log in to see what your friends are recommending. Best and Worst Jobs 2012 14,767 people recommend this. Hendershott and White: Traditional Catholicism Is Winning 342 people recommend this. Best and Worst Jobs of 2012

Sony will soon debut the SmartWatch, a souped-up timepiece that pairs with Android phones, Ina Fried reports on digits. Photo: Sony.

In the past two years, legal disputes have erupted over digital-image storage methods, camera designs, Wi-Fi technologies and well-known software applications like email and calendars, as well as secondary features most consumers barely notice.

3,427 people recommend this. The New View of Depression 1,634 people recommend this.

Related Reading
Patent Agency Draws Blame for Smartphone Suits Apple Plays Two Ways on Patent-Fight Field

Facebook social plugin

The stakes are rising for Apple. Despite the iPhone's popularity, its market share has been eclipsed by phones that run Android, Google's mobile operating software. Fueling the fire at Apple: a sense among executives there that rivals are blatantly stealing its designs. Apple co-founder Steve Jobs, who died in October, said in an authorized biography that he would "spend every penny" to fight copycats. Tim Cook told investors in October that Apple spends "a lot of time and money and resource in coming up with incredible innovations. And we don't like it when someone else takes those." Related Video

Technology & IT Jobs

GIS Analyst - Randstad Engineering Clinical application Analyst - Invision - Randstad Technologies SMB Account Executive Job - VMware Inc. IT Healthcare Professional Consultants - Resources Global Professionals Great technology careers begin at Accenture
FIND JOBS

The 'Workaround' Effect

Through litigationor the threat of itApple has prompted companies to install time-consuming and, in some instances, costly "workarounds" to avoid infringing its patents. But Apple has yet to permanently knock any of its competitors' products out of the

MORE JOBS AND CAREER NEWS

Finance Jobs | Accounting Jobs | Sales Jobs | Marketing Jobs FINS for Employers & Recruiters
POST A JOB

From Around the Web

Content From Sponsors

Powered by Taboola

A joint effort by the government and major wireless carriers to clamp down on stolen handsets, will likely raise the resale value of used smart phones, Quentin Fottrell reports on digits. Photo: Getty Images

market. Several rivals, meanwhile, have struck back against Apple, accusing the company of using their own patented
10 Cheapest Cars to Own Kiplinger Zuckerberg's $1 Salary and More: Parsing the Facebook IPO Filing Entrepreneur 12 Cities Where Home Prices Have Fallen Most Kiplinger

2 of 6

04/13/2012 11:01 AM

Smartphone Patents: The Never-Ending War - WSJ.com

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303624004577339931...

designs. At the center of the war is slide-to-unlock. It dates to late 2005, more than a year before Apple announced a product with a touchscreen. The first iPhone was in the works at the time, and Apple's software engineers, including one of its current senior vice presidents, Scott Forstall, felt the need for a feature that would prevent the phone from accidentally making a call or sending a text message when pulled from a pocket or jostled in a purse.
Enlarge Image Joe Schram/The Wall Street Journal

More in Tech
Smartphone Patents: Never-Ending War Barnes & Noble Hit Hard Best Buy Probes CEO Relationship Google Preserves Cash, Control Infosys Profit Rises 27%

Latest Headlines
Spotlight on Ann Romney Key to Campaign Strategy Faulty Planning, Stage Cited in Fair Collapse Costs Hobble Banks' Profits Experts Weigh Gulf Spill's Lasting Effects Texas Eyes Change in Stem-Cell Rules College's Future Uncertain After Shooting Political Ad Ban Lifted for Public Stations Arraignment Set for Florida Shooter School Official Charged New NFL Scouting Test: Meet the Wife

Apple's engineers regarded slideto-unlock as important because it flavored a user's first experience with the device, according to a person familiar with the matter. The team tried many iterations, this person said, from different fingerswiping speeds to different-shaped motions. Two days before Christmas 2005, Apple filed a patent application with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office containing a handful of rudimentary drawings with ovals and circles.

More Headlines

No Contract Smartphones The Best Deals On The Best Phones - No Contracts. Learn More Now IncrediCell.com A $6 Trillion Opportunity Learn Why This Penny Stock Could Go Stratospheric www.PennyStockWizard.com Patent Attorney 20 Yrs Experience $2900 Non-Provisional Patent Application www.patent-application.us

Neonode Inc

Three diagrams from a patent awarded in 2012 to Swedish company Neonode that surprised both Apple and Samsung. Neonode first made its patent claim in 2002, three years before Apple's application.

The diagrams showed an early version of the design that current iPhone models use: a white rectangle with rounded edges that, when touched and dragged to the right, slides alongside a horizontal channel

until the device "unlocks" and opens to the home screen.

The Opening Volley

The patent office granted Apple the patent four years later, in early 2010. That March, Apple sued HTC in Delaware for allegedly infringing slide-to-unlock and other features. According to a person familiar with the matter, Apple felt that it would be a good starter case because the company thought it was particularly easy to see that HTC had imitated the iPhone interfaceby using similar rows of icons, for example. A spokesman for HTC declined to comment. Several months later, Apple asserted claims against Motorola in Florida, where Motorola was already suing Apple, alleging that over a dozen Motorola products violated Apple's slide-to-unlock patent. The slide-to-unlock used on many Motorola phones resembles Apple's in many ways. Users open the phone by dragging a finger from left to right across the bottom of the phone's screen. But the visual representations of the sliding motion are somewhat different. Apple users see a white rectangle move across the screen while, with the Motorola phones, the slide of a finger extends a bar across the screen. Partly for this reason, Motorola claims its so-called "stretch to unlock" doesn't infringe Apple's patent.

Samsung's Circle
Samsung, however, posed a unique challenge for Apple on slide-to-unlock. While Apple was waiting for its patent to be issued, Samsung unveiled phones that opened when a user touched the center of a circle on the screen, and dragged a finger to any point outside the circle. Samsung's design was different, but in the mind of Apple executives, not different enough. So, in 2009 Apple went back to the patent office, according to a person familiar

3 of 6

04/13/2012 11:01 AM

Smartphone Patents: The Never-Ending War - WSJ.com

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303624004577339931...

with the matter, and asked for a patent that would cover a wider variety of slide-to-unlock designs. Apple got such a patent last October, and in February the company filed suit in San Jose against Samsung, alleging Samsung violated an array of patents, including slideto-unlock.

An Unexpected Jolt
Earlier this year, the combatants all got a surprise: an obscure Swedish touchscreen maker called Neonode Inc. disclosed that it had received a patent for a version of slideto-unlock. Its technology let a mobile-device user switch from one application to another by swiping a finger across a screen. The company, which briefly made a line of phones prior to a 2008 bankruptcy, had used the mechanism in one of its models. Neonode declined to comment. But in a recent Apple-Samsung battle over slide-to-unlock in the Netherlands, Samsung held up Neonode designs as examples of "prior art," or evidence that Apple's patents on slide-to-unlock should never have been granted in the first place because someone else had actually beaten Apple to the idea. A person close to Samsung said the company is likely to use Neonode's patent to try to knock out Apple in the San Jose case. Samsung has other arguments as well: "Sliding locks have been around since the Middle Ages, and Apple didn't invent touchscreens," this person said. "And the combination of the two fits the definition of obvious." In Apple's only win so far on slide-to-unlock, a judge in Munich ruled in February that two of Motorola's designs violated a European version of Apple's slide-to-unlock patent. Motorola, however, quickly "designed around" Apple's patent, and its phones remained on the German market. Many intellectual-property experts think that the smartphone war will end in a flurry of licensing and cross-licensing agreements, but that it's taking way too much time and money to get there. "When you have companies spending hundreds of millions in litigation, something is seriously wrong with our patent system," said Michael Carrier, a professor at Rutgers School of Law in Camden, N.J. "You've got to wonder whether it's doing more harm than good," he added. Write to Ashby Jones at ashby.jones@wsj.com and Jessica E. Vascellaro at jessica.vascellaro@wsj.com
A version of this article appeared April 13, 2012, on page B1 in some U.S. editions of The Wall Street Journal, with the headline: Smartphone Patents: The Never-Ending War.
JOIN THE DISCUSSION MORE IN

21 Comments, add yours

Tech

Tweet

144

Share

Email

Print

Order Reprints

4 of 6

04/13/2012 11:01 AM

Smartphone Patents: The Never-Ending War - WSJ.com

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303624004577339931...

Patent Attorneys We've Got Your Neighborhood Patent Attorneys. Customer Reviews! Local.com Mortgage Rates Hit 2.50% If you owe under $729k you may qualify for 3.01% APR Govt Refi Plans. www.MortgageRatesExperts.com No Contract Smartphones The Best Deals On The Best Phones - No Contracts. Learn More Now IncrediCell.com Top 10 Phones & Plans Find & Compare The Best Promotional Deals Going on Now. No Contracts. best-cell-phone-plans.net

Add a Comment
View All Comments (21) To add a comment please

JOURNAL COMMUNITY

Community rules

Log in

Create an Account
Your real name is required for commenting.

Track replies to my comment Login with Facebook

Editors' Picks

Spotlight on Ann Romney Key to Campaign Strategy

Chris Berg: The Real Reason for the Tragedy of the Titanic

Starving in India: A Scribe Tries to Save a Life

India's Grain Storage Comes Up Short

BACK TO TOP

Customer Center: My Account My Subscriptions Create an Account: Register for Limited Access Subscribe to WSJ.com Sign up for WSJ Professional Subscribe to WSJ Weekend Print Edition Help & Information Center: Help Customer Service Contact Us

About: Content Partnerships Reprints Advertising Classifieds Advertise Locally Conferences About Dow Jones Privacy Policy - UPDATED 10/18/2011 Your Ad Choices Subscriber Agreement & Terms of Use - Updated Copyright Policy Jobs at WSJ.com

WSJ.com: Site Map Home World U.S. New York Business Markets Market Data Tech Personal Finance Life & Culture Opinion Autos

Tools & Formats: Today's Paper Video Center Graphics Columns Blogs Topics Guides Alerts Newsletters Mobile WSJ Social Tablet Edition Podcasts

Digital Network
WSJ.com Marketwatch.com Barrons.com SmartMoney.com AllThingsD.com FINS: Finance, IT jobs, Sales jobs BigCharts.com Virtual Stock Exchange WSJ Radio Professor Journal WSJ U.S. Edition WSJ Asia Edition

5 of 6

04/13/2012 11:01 AM

Smartphone Patents: The Never-Ending War - WSJ.com

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303624004577339931...

Global Support Print Subscriber Services

Careers Real Estate Small Business Student Journal Corrections SafeHouse - Send Us Information

RSS Feeds Journal Community WSJ on Twitter WSJ on Facebook WSJ on Foursquare My Journal Portfolio WSJ Digital Downloads

WSJ Europe Edition WSJ India Page Foreign Language Editions: WSJ Chinese WSJ Japanese WSJ Portuguese WSJ Spanish WSJ Deutschland

Copyright 2012 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved

6 of 6

04/13/2012 11:01 AM