Search

Subscribe | Web Feed Tuesday 27 Mar 2012

HOME

ECONOMY

B-SCHOOL

BUSINESS

FINANCE

OPINION

PERSONALITIES

SCIENCE & TECH

AFTER HOURS

MAGAZINE

BOOKS

CASES

MORE

Hom e > Opinion > Colum nists

CAUGHT MY EYE 26 Mar 2012

Top Stories in Opinion

Balancing Personal And National Interests A New Direction Changing The Internet Getting Dow n To Business In UP How You Can Learn To Lead

Your Password Or Your Job

Recruiters want to get at your social media, but unlike in the US, we are not quite as concerned as we should be
Mala Bhargava TOOLS
TEXT SIZE : A |

A|A

Just Tw eet Your Beat A Brow ser to Go An Urgent Concern A Fam ily Affair The New Generation

e-mail this story

print view

view only pictures

story in single page

share

Y
(Reuters)

ou cant but help feel outraged at the story of Justin Bassett, Seattle citizen who was asked at a job interview, to hand over his Facebook login and password. Understandably, he withdrew his application and wanted nothing further to do with the company. Id surely have done the same after making a huge noise first. After all, the offline equivalent would be like gate-crashing a party the candidate is attending, landing up to observe him when hes at home, with his friends, or out on a holiday. Not everyone would have walked out. In the US, Bassetts case wasnt a one-off but a trend and people are getting increasingly unsurprised when their social media activities are scanned at hiring time. While you can understand a hiring company wanting to know who would be working for them, there are many hairy issues raised here. One CEO explained to me that information online was now a given. Why would one not use it to research someones background? There was one time when we discovered that a person we were hiring had a police case against him for data theft. And thats hardly something we want happening in our company, he told me. Its now routine to Google someone online and see what the search throws up. Does the person seem active online in which case it may mean he or she is keeping up with new
Are you a developer? Try out the HTML to PDF API

RELATED STORIES Web Exclusive: A Non-Glittery Start Web Ex: Password Or Job?

open in browser PRO version

New hot app: Facebook Albums To PDF

pdfcrowd.com

Market Trips, Economy Falters But Hope Still Lingers Web Exclusive: Spare The StartUps, FM!

technologies instead of being technophobic. Is there a blog? Are there any presentations on SlideShare, useful posts on Twitter? A solid LinkedIn profile and recommendations?

Top Stories

In much the same way, a Facebook page can reveal say, an odd note, or something drastically wrong. HR departments and executive recruitment firms are paying people to do a thorough job of research on each candidate they take up. Fascinatingly, we in India arent half as bothered about privacy. I chatted with Supreme Court lawyer and cyber law expert, Pavan Duggal, who agreed that privacy concerns differ from one culture to another. He said that in India, where weve had a long tradition of joint families, were accustomed to sharing information freely. He even felt job candidates would be unhesitant and perhaps even proud to show off their accounts. But forcing a candidate to give up a password and login would be another matter. Thats punishable under sections 43 and 66 of the IT Act and could land the coercer in jail for three years. But of course, it isnt illegal to ask for the password only to force. India doesnt even have privacy laws, as Pavan Duggal points out. In some countries, even Googling a person to check him or her out is not allowed. And Germany, as we know from recent noise over Facebook privacy, are pretty touchy about who wants to know what. In the US, there is so much sudden outrage sparked off by the Bassett case that several states are working on legislation to stop companies from even requesting access to online accounts. After all, what next email? Facebook says giving your password to anyone is in violation of its user agreement and warns companies that look into accounts and then dont hire a candidate could face charges of discrimination in some situations. Such as when you see that a woman is pregnant and dont hire her, for example. A company may want to find out all it can, but so much of what you find could be anecdotal. Lets say for instance that a person has changed jobs twice over the past few months. He announces the change on Facebook, and a friend or two happen to tease him for being an inveterate job-shopper. But perhaps he isnt one. Perhaps he discovered that a line of work he took up didnt excite him at all. Perhaps he was strong enough to act on the decision to change. Or perhaps there was a brilliant offer he was eager to take up. Now, a researcher may well misinterpret this or not look beyond the surface and report incorrectly. On the other hand, one may find online a clear demonstration of focus on work and evident domain knowledge. But as someone who studied psychology and worked with psychological tests, it occurs to me that, other than ruling out something drastic such as obvious signs that a candidate is say, an active trouble-maker, theres not much you can find out to predict future performance and workplace behavior. It was difficult enough with apparently scientific tests and it would be too anecdotal and open to misinterpretation by scanning random social media activity. Clearly we need to start thinking about how we need to handle online privacy in our country. Tags: exclusive to web | caught my eye | social media | justin b assett | faceb ook | twitter
1 Page Back To Top

Coal's Labour Lost

The battle of words between Coal India and minority shareholder TCI could further damage the foreign investment climate
Warburg Sells Kotak Mahindra Stake Web Ex: Passw ord Or Job? Web Ex: Audi TT On Indian Roads Sensex Dow n 309 Pts; Tum bles To 2-Mth Low

Slideshow s

A Modest Path: Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee said the proposed budget aimed at giving boost to "grow th w ith stability" and there w as a "determined effort to regain the path of fiscal consolidation."

Most Emailed

Most Read

Most Commented

'Focus On Raising Intelligence' Sensex Snaps 6-Day Rally On Profit-Booking In Sm all Tow n For Big Business The Education Barons Of Manipal The Art of the Deal The Cloud Of Opportunities An Unfinished Life A Fair Edge To Business

Bookmark this story:

Del.ici.ous

Digg

reddit

Stumbleupon
New hot app: Facebook Albums To PDF

open in browser PRO version

Are you a developer? Try out the HTML to PDF API

pdfcrowd.com

Comments
Latest Comments
View All Com m ents

Submit your comment

Your name Email * City Comment

C APTC HA Enter the Code in the textbox

open in browser PRO version

Are you a developer? Try out the HTML to PDF API

New hot app: Facebook Albums To PDF

pdfcrowd.com

Math question *

1+0=
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.

Save

Our Other Websites

About Us | Feedback | Advertise w ith us | Contact Us | Disclaimer | Privacy Policy | Subscribe BW ABP Pvt Ltd Publication Copyright All rights reserved

open in browser PRO version

Are you a developer? Try out the HTML to PDF API

New hot app: Facebook Albums To PDF

pdfcrowd.com