Sie sind auf Seite 1von 270

MAIN BEAMS CLEVER SOLVER TEST SCHEDULES

Castalia s.r.l. tel. +39-02-26681083 fax +39-02-26681876 E-mail staff@castaliaweb.com Via Pinturicchio, 24 20133 Milano (Italy)
Rev. 1.0 del 21-5-2007

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

2/270

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

3/270

These test are mainly intented to prove Sargon static solver reliability, and are a first set of tests regarding main beams, that is simple beam models easy to check by hand or using published data. Since in statically indeterminate structure results depend on shear areas, and since usually published results do not take into account the effect of shear deformation energy, shear areas have in these cases been set to 0, thus neglecting shear energy contributions. These tests do use notional section data values, such as 1 for second moment of area and so on. The results obtained are always quite satisfactory, that is error are always almost unexistent. Sometimes the need of defining numbers having periodic set of digits (e.g. 1/3) can lead to error different from 0. Setting up benchmarks like these is not a trivial matter. Extensive work has been done to assure the highest reliability of all data. Errors have been computed automatically by program checksolvers, a software testing tool developed by Castalia srl. This work is open and can be used elsewhere. We ask, nonetheless, to be informed of any use of these data and we ask that these data are used but citing the source, that is the following:
Data have been computed by Castalia srl for its fem static solver CLEVER validation. Castalia srl: http://www.castaliaweb.com Questi dati sono stati calcolati da Castalia srl per la validazione del proprio solutore statico fem CLEVER. Castalia srl: http://www.castaliaweb.com

Milan, May 2007

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

4/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT001 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT001 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Cantilever with end shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

5/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT001 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE Value 7.000e+003 Point of application Free tip Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT001 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
7.0000e+003 -7.0000e+003 -2.1000e+007 0.0000e+000

(Cv Tv)
0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

7.0000e+003 -7.0000e+003 -2.1000e+007 0.0000e+000

0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Cv Tv) / Tv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

6/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT002 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT002 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Cantilever with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

7/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT002 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed Value 2.570e+000 Point of application Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT002 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
7.7100e+003 1.3642e-012 -1.1565e+007 3.2596e-009

(Cv Tv)
-1.8190e-012 1.3642e-012 3.7253e-009 3.2596e-009

100

Tv Cv Cv

7.7100e+003 0.0000e+000 -1.1565e+007 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Cv Tv) / Tv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

8/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT003 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT003 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Cantilever with distributed linear load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

9/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT003 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed Value 2.570e+0000.000e+000 Points of application MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002 fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002 E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005 v 3.000e-001 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT003 CLEVER (SARGON

1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

Fe360

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.8550e+003 -4.5475e-013 -3.8550e+006 -6.9849e-010

(Cv Tv)
9.0949e-013 -4.5475e-013 -5.5879e-009 -6.9849e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.8550e+003 0.0000e+000 -3.8550e+006 0.0000e+000

0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Cv Tv) / Tv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

10/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT004 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT004 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Cantilever with end and internal shear forces

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

11/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT004 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] Dx2 [mm] 1000 2000 Value 7.000e+003 5.000e+003 4.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT004 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE NODAL FORCE NODAL FORCE MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

Point of application Free tip Dx2 Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

v 3.000e-001

1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

Fe360

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
1.6000e+004 1.2000e+004 -1.9000e+007 -7.0000e+006

(Cv Tv)
1.7462e-010 8.7311e-011 -1.6391e-007 -1.0431e-007

100

Tv Cv Cv

1.6000e+004 1.2000e+004 -1.9000e+007 -7.0000e+006

0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Cv Tv) / Tv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

12/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT004BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT004BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Cantilever with end and internal shear forces

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

13/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT004BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] Dx2 [mm] 1000 2000 Value 7.000e+003 4.000e+003 5.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT004BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE force concentrated force concentrated MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

Point of application Free tip Dx1 Dx2 -

Constraints As shown

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm ] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm ] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

W 2 [mm ] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001

IPE200 3 W 3 [mm ] 3.081e+004

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
1.6000e+004 -7.0000e+003 -3.5000e+007 3.7253e-009

(Cv Tv)
-5.4570e-012 5.4570e-012 -1.0000e-001 3.7253e-009

100

Tv Cv Cv

1.6000e+004 -7.0000e+003 -3.5000e+007 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Cv Tv) / Tv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

14/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT005 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT005 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Cantilever with linear load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

15/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT005 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed Value 2.570e+0001.280e+000 Point of application Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT005 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
5.7750e+003 -9.0949e-013 -7.6950e+006 -2.3283e-010

(Cv Tv)
1.8190e-012 -9.0949e-013 -4.6566e-009 -2.3283e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

5.7750e+003 0.0000e+000 -7.6950e+006 0.0000e+000

0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Cv Tv) / Tv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

16/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT006 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT006 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Cantilever with distributed internal constant load (clamped side)

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

17/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT006 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 2000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT006 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application Clamped tip-Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

v 3.000e-001

1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

Fe360

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
5.1400e+003 -9.0949e-012 -5.1400e+006 1.0710e-008

(Cv Tv)
9.0949e-012 -9.0949e-012 -2.8871e-008 1.0710e-008

100

Tv Cv Cv

5.1400e+003 0.0000e+000 -5.1400e+006 0.0000e+000

0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Cv Tv) / Tv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

18/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT006BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT006BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Cantilever with distributed internal constant load (clamped side)

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

19/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT006BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 2000 Value 2.570e+0002.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT006BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed

Point of application Clamped tip-Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL 2 fy [N/mm ] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 2.981e+003 3 W pl2 [mm ] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 2.051e+007 3 W pl3 [mm ] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm ] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm ] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

W 2 [mm ] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001

IPE200 3 W 3 [mm ] 3.081e+004

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
5.1400e+003 0.0000e+000 -5.1400e+006 -6.9849e-010

(Cv Tv)
2.5700e-004 0.0000e+000 -5.1400e-001 -6.9849e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

5.1400e+003 0.0000e+000 -5.1400e+006 0.0000e+000

0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Cv Tv) / Tv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

20/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT007 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT007 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Cantilever with distributed internal constant load (free tip side)

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

21/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT007 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 1000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT007 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application Dx1-Free tip -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
5.1400e+003 -3.6380e-012 -1.0280e+007 5.1400e+006

(Cv Tv)
1.4552e-011 -3.6380e-012 -1.4901e-008 7.4506e-009

100

Tv Cv Cv

5.1400e+003 0.0000e+000 -1.0280e+007 5.1400e+006

0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

22/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT007BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT007BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Cantilever with distributed internal constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

23/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT007BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 1000 Value 2.570e+0002.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT007BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed

Point of application Dx1-Free tip -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL 2 fy [N/mm ] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 2.981e+003 3 W pl2 [mm ] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 2.051e+007 3 W pl3 [mm ] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm ] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm ] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

W 2 [mm ] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001

IPE200 3 W 3 [mm ] 3.081e+004

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
5.1400e+003 -4.5475e-013 -1.0280e+007 -6.9849e-010

(Cv Tv)
2.5700e-004 -4.5475e-013 -2.5700e-001 -6.9849e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

5.1400e+003 0.0000e+000 -1.0280e+007 0.0000e+000

0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

24/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT008 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT008 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Cantilever with internal shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

25/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT008 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 2000 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT008 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
7.0000e+003 -7.0000e+003 -1.4000e+007 -1.8626e-008

(Cv Tv)
3.6380e-011 -3.6380e-011 -1.0803e-007 -1.8626e-008

100

Tv Cv Cv

7.0000e+003 -7.0000e+003 -1.4000e+007 0.0000e+000

0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

26/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT008BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT008BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Cantilever with internal shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

27/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT008BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 2000 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT008BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force concentrated

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm ] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm ] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

W 2 [mm ] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001

IPE200 3 W 3 [mm ] 3.081e+004

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
7.0000e+003 1.8190e-012 -1.4000e+007 1.8626e-009

(Cv Tv)
-1.8190e-012 1.8190e-012 -7.0000e-001 1.8626e-009

100

Tv Cv Cv

7.0000e+003 0.0000e+000 -1.4000e+007 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

28/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT009 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT009 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Cantilever with end bending moment

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

29/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT009 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL MOMENT Value 2.000e+007 Point of application Free tip Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT009 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000 -2.0000e+007 2.0000e+007

(Cv Tv)
0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000 -7.4506e-009 0.0000e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000 -2.0000e+007 2.0000e+007

0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

30/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT010 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT010 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Cantilever with distributed linear load (most loaded tip)

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

31/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT010 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed Value 0.000e+0002.570e+000 Point of application Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT010 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.8550e+003 9.0949e-013 -7.7100e+006 1.6298e-009

(Cv Tv)
-1.8190e-012 9.0949e-013 3.7253e-009 1.6298e-009

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.8550e+003 0.0000e+000 -7.7100e+006 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

32/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT011 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT011 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with internal shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

33/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT011 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 2000 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT011 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
2.3333e+003 -4.6667e+003 -1.8626e-009 -4.6667e+006

(Cv Tv)
3.3333e-007 3.3334e-007 -1.8626e-009 3.3334e-004

100

Tv Cv Cv

2.3333e+003 -4.6667e+003 0.0000e+000 -4.6667e+006

0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

34/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT011BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT011BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with internal shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

35/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT011BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 2000 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT011BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force concentrated

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm ] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm ] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

W 2 [mm ] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001

IPE200 3 W 3 [mm ] 3.081e+004

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
2.3333e+003 4.6667e+003 6.9849e-010 -9.3132e-010

(Cv Tv)
-2.3300e-004 2.3300e-004 6.9849e-010 -9.3132e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

2.3333e+003 4.6667e+003 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

36/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT012 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT012 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with internal shear force (midpoint)

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

37/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT012 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 1500 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT012 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.5000e+003 -3.5000e+003 0.0000e+000 -5.2500e+006

(Cv Tv)
-1.8190e-012 1.8190e-012 0.0000e+000 -1.8626e-009

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.5000e+003 -3.5000e+003 0.0000e+000 -5.2500e+006

-0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

38/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT012BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT012BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with internal shear force (midpoint)

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

39/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT012BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 1500 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT012BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force concentrated

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm ] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm ] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

W 2 [mm ] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001

IPE200 3 W 3 [mm ] 3.081e+004

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.5000e+003 3.5000e+003 -4.6566e-010 -9.3132e-010

(Cv Tv)
0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000 -4.6566e-010 -9.3132e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.5000e+003 3.5000e+003 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000

0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

40/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT013 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT013 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with two equal internal shear forces

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

41/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT013 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] Dx2 [mm] 1000 2000 Value 7.000e+003 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT013 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE NODAL FORCE

Point of application Dx1 Dx2 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
7.0000e+003 7.0000e+003 -6.5193e-009 -7.0000e+006

(Cv Tv)
0.0000e+000 1.4552e-011 -6.5193e-009 -9.3132e-009

100

Tv Cv Cv

7.0000e+003 7.0000e+003 0.0000e+000 -7.0000e+006

0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

42/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT013BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT013BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with two equal internal shear forces

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

43/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT013BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] Dx2 [mm] 1000 2000 Value 7.000e+003 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT013BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force concentrated force concentrated

Point of application Dx1 Dx2 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm ] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm ] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

W 2 [mm ] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001

IPE200 3 W 3 [mm ] 3.081e+004

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
7.0000e+003 7.0000e+003 1.8626e-009 -9.3132e-010

(Cv Tv)
-9.0949e-013 0.0000e+000 1.8626e-009 -9.3132e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

7.0000e+003 7.0000e+003 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

44/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT014 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT014 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

45/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT014 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed Value 2.570e+000 Point of application Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT014 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.8550e+003 3.8550e+003 0.0000e+000 -4.6566e-010

(Cv Tv)
-9.0949e-013 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000 -4.6566e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.8550e+003 3.8550e+003 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

46/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT015 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT015 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with two internal distributed constant loads

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

47/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT015 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] Dx2 [mm] 1000 2000 Value 2.570e+000 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT015 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed force distributed

Point of application Left end-Dx1 Dx2-Right end -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
2.5700e+003 2.5700e+003 0.0000e+000 -1.2850e+006

(Cv Tv)
1.3642e-012 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000 4.6566e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

2.5700e+003 2.5700e+003 0.0000e+000 -1.2850e+006

0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

48/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT015BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT015BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with two internal distributed constant loads

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

49/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT015BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] Dx2 [mm] 1000 2000 Value 2.570e+0002.570e+000 2.570e+0002.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT015BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed force linearly distributed

Point of application Left end-Dx1 Dx2-Right end -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL 2 fy [N/mm ] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 3 W pl2 [mm ] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 3 W pl3 [mm ] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
2.5700e+003 2.5700e+003 -1.1642e-010 -2.3283e-010

(Cv Tv)
-2.5700e-004 -2.5700e-004 -1.1642e-010 -2.3283e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

2.5700e+003 2.5700e+003 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

50/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT016 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT016 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with internal distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

51/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT016 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] Dx2 [mm] 1000 2000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT016 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application Dx1-Dx2 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
1.2850e+003 1.2850e+003 1.2850e+006 0.0000e+000

(Cv Tv)
0.0000e+000 -9.0949e-013 -2.0955e-009 0.0000e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

1.2850e+003 1.2850e+003 1.2850e+006 0.0000e+000

0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

52/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT016BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT016BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with internal distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

53/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT016BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] Dx2 [mm] 1000 2000 Value 2.570e+0002.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT016BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed

Point of application Dx1-Dx2 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL 2 fy [N/mm ] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 2.981e+003 3 W pl2 [mm ] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 2.051e+007 3 W pl3 [mm ] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm ] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm ] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

W 2 [mm ] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001

IPE200 3 W 3 [mm ] 3.081e+004

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
1.2850e+003 1.2850e+003 1.1642e-010 -3.4925e-010

(Cv Tv)
2.5700e-004 2.5700e-004 1.1642e-010 -3.4925e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

1.2850e+003 1.2850e+003 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000

0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

54/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT017 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT017 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with internal distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

55/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT017 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 2000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT017 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application Left end-Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.4267e+003 -1.7133e+003 -2.3283e-010 -1.7133e+006

(Cv Tv)
-3.3333e-007 -3.3334e-007 -2.3283e-010 -3.3333e-004

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.4267e+003 -1.7133e+003 0.0000e+000 -1.7133e+006

-0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

56/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT017BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT017BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with internal distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

57/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT017BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 2000 Value 2.570e+0002.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT017BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed

Point of application Left end-Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL 2 fy [N/mm ] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 2.981e+003 3 W pl2 [mm ] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 2.051e+007 3 W pl3 [mm ] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm ] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm ] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

W 2 [mm ] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001

IPE200 3 W 3 [mm ] 3.081e+004

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.4267e+003 1.7133e+003 0.0000e+000 -4.6566e-010

(Cv Tv)
8.5333e-005 1.7167e-004 0.0000e+000 -4.6566e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.4267e+003 1.7133e+003 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000

0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

58/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT018 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT018 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with two internal distributed constant loads

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

59/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT018 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] Dx2 [mm] 1000 2000 Value 2.570e+000 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT018 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed force distributed

Point of application Left end-Dx1 Dx2-Right end -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 5. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
1.8190e-012 2.0560e+003 -4.1120e+005 1.2336e+006

(Cv Tv)
1.8190e-012 -5.8208e-011 1.1176e-008 -1.6997e-008

100

Tv Cv Cv

0.0000e+000 2.0560e+003 -4.1120e+005 1.2336e+006

0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

60/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT018BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT018BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with two internal distributed constant loads

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

61/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT018BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] Dx2 [mm] 1000 2000 Value 2.570e+0002.570e+000 2.570e+0002.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT018BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed force linearly distributed

Point of application Left end-Dx1 Dx2-Right end -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL 2 fy [N/mm ] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 3 W pl2 [mm ] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 3 W pl3 [mm ] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
2.0560e+003 2.0560e+003 1.1642e-010 -3.4925e-010

(Cv Tv)
-2.9812e-004 -4.9858e-004 1.1642e-010 -3.4925e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

2.0560e+003 2.0560e+003 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

62/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT019 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT019 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with distributed linear load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

63/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT019 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed Value 1.280e+0002.570e+000 Point of application Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT019 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
2.5650e+003 3.2100e+003 4.6566e-010 -4.6566e-010

(Cv Tv)
0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000 4.6566e-010 -4.6566e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

2.5650e+003 3.2100e+003 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000

0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

64/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT020 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT020 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with two distributed linear loads

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

65/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT020 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 1500 Value 0.000e+0002.570e+000 2.570e+0000.000e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT020 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed force linearly distributed

Point of application Left end-Dx1 Dx1-Right end -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL 2 fy [N/mm ] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

Fe360

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm ] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm ] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

W 2 [mm ] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001

IPE200 3 W 3 [mm ] 3.081e+004

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
1.9275e+003 6.8212e-013 -1.9275e+006 -9.8953e-010

(Cv Tv)
-1.1369e-012 6.8212e-013 9.3132e-010 -9.8953e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

1.9275e+003 0.0000e+000 -1.9275e+006 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

66/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT020BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT020BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with two distributed linear loads

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

67/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT020BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 1500 Value 0.000e+0002.570e+000 2.570e+0000.000e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT020BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed force linearly distributed

Point of application Left end-Dx1 Dx1-Right end -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL 2 fy [N/mm ] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 3 W pl2 [mm ] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 3 W pl3 [mm ] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
1.9275e+003 1.9275e+003 2.3283e-010 -4.6566e-010

(Cv Tv)
-1.3642e-012 4.0927e-012 2.3283e-010 -4.6566e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

1.9275e+003 1.9275e+003 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

68/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT021 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT021 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with two internal distributed linear loads

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

69/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT021 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] Dx2 [mm] 1000 1500 Value 0.000e+0002.570e+000 2.570e+0000.000e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT021 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed force linearly distributed

Dx3 [mm] 2000 Point of application Dx1-Dx2 Dx2-Dx3 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL 2 fy [N/mm ] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm ] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm ] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

W 2 [mm ] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001

IPE200 3 W 3 [mm ] 3.081e+004

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 4. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
6.4250e+002 -1.8190e-012 -6.4250e+005 -8.5667e+005

(Cv Tv)
-5.5707e-012 -1.8190e-012 4.1910e-009 3.3342e-005

100

Tv Cv Cv

6.4250e+002 0.0000e+000 -6.4250e+005 -8.5667e+005

-0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

70/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT021BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT021BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with two internal distributed linear loads

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

71/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT021BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] Dx2 [mm] 1000 1500 Value 0.000e+0002.570e+000 2.570e+0000.000e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT021BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed force linearly distributed

Dx3 [mm] 2000 Point of application Dx1-Dx2 Dx2-Dx3 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL 2 fy [N/mm ] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 3 W pl2 [mm ] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 3 W pl3 [mm ] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
6.4250e+002 6.4250e+002 1.7462e-010 -1.1642e-010

(Cv Tv)
1.2850e-004 1.2850e-004 1.7462e-010 -1.1642e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

6.4250e+002 6.4250e+002 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000

0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

72/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT022 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT022 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with two distributed linear loads

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

73/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT022 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 1500 Value 2.570e+0000.000e+000 0.000e+0002.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT022 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed force linearly distributed

Point of application Left end-Dx1 Dx1-Right end -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL 2 fy [N/mm ] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

Fe360

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm ] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm ] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

W 2 [mm ] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001

IPE200 3 W 3 [mm ] 3.081e+004

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
1.9275e+003 -9.0949e-013 6.4028e-010 9.6375e+005

(Cv Tv)
-4.5475e-013 -9.0949e-013 6.4028e-010 1.1642e-009

100

Tv Cv Cv

1.9275e+003 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000 9.6375e+005

-0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

74/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT022BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT022BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with two distributed linear loads

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

75/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT022BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 1500 Value 2.570e+0000.000e+000 0.000e+0002.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT022BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed force linearly distributed

Point of application Left end-Dx1 Dx2-Right end -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL 2 fy [N/mm ] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 3 W pl2 [mm ] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 3 W pl3 [mm ] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
1.9275e+003 1.9275e+003 5.8208e-010 0.0000e+000

(Cv Tv)
0.0000e+000 -9.0949e-013 5.8208e-010 0.0000e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

1.9275e+003 1.9275e+003 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000

0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

76/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT023 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT023 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with distributed variable load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

77/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT023 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] Dx2 [mm] 1000 2000 Value 0.000e+0002.570e+000 2.570e+0002.570e+000 2.570e+0000.000e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT023 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed force linearly distributed force linearly distributed MATERIAL 2 fy [N/mm ] 2.350e+002

Point of application Left end-Dx1 Dx1-Dx2 Dx2-Right end -

Constraints As shown

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 3 W pl2 [mm ] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 3 W pl3 [mm ] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
1.2850e+003 2.5700e+003 3.3469e-010 -2.1417e+006

(Cv Tv)
6.3665e-012 4.0927e-012 3.3469e-010 3.3333e-004

100

Tv Cv Cv

1.2850e+003 2.5700e+003 0.0000e+000 -2.1417e+006

0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

78/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT023BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT023BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with distributed variable load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

79/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT023BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] Dx2 [mm] 1000 2000 Value 0.000e+0002.570e+000 2.570e+0002.570e+000 2.570e+0000.000e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT023BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed force linearly distributed force linearly distributed MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

Point of application Left end-Dx1 Dx1-Dx2 Dx2-Right end -

Constraints As shown

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
2.5700e+003 2.5700e+003 -2.3283e-010 -9.3132e-010

(Cv Tv)
1.2850e-004 1.2850e-004 -2.3283e-010 -9.3132e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

2.5700e+003 2.5700e+003 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000

0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

80/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT024 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT024 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with distributed linear load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

81/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT024 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed Value 0.000e+0002.570e+000 Point of application Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT024 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
1.2850e+003 2.5700e+003 2.3283e-010 -2.3283e-010

(Cv Tv)
0.0000e+000 -9.0949e-013 2.3283e-010 -2.3283e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

1.2850e+003 2.5700e+003 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000

0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

82/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT025 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT025 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with two shear forces

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

83/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT025 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] Dx2 [mm] 1000 2000 Value 7.000e+003 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT025 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE NODAL FORCE

Point of application Dx1 Dx2 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
2.3333e+003 4.6667e+003 2.3333e+006 -4.6566e-010

(Cv Tv)
3.3333e-007 -3.3333e-007 3.3333e-004 -4.6566e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

2.3333e+003 4.6667e+003 2.3333e+006 0.0000e+000

0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

84/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT025BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT025BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with two shear forces

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

85/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT025BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] Dx2 [mm] 1000 2000 Value 7.000e+003 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT025BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force concentrated force concentrated

Point of application Dx1 Dx2 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm ] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm ] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

W 2 [mm ] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001

IPE200 3 W 3 [mm ] 3.081e+004

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
2.3333e+003 -2.3333e+003 2.3283e-010 0.0000e+000

(Cv Tv)
4.6700e-004 -4.6700e-004 2.3283e-010 0.0000e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

2.3333e+003 -2.3333e+003 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000

0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

86/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT026 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT026 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with internal bending moment

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

87/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT026 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 1000 Value 2.000e+007 SOL.SAR.STAT026 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL MOMENT

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
6.6667e+003 6.6667e+003 6.6667e+006 1.3333e+007

(Cv Tv)
-3.3332e-007 -3.3334e-007 -3.3332e-004 3.3333e-003

100

Tv Cv Cv

6.6667e+003 6.6667e+003 6.6667e+006 1.3333e+007

-0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

88/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT026BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT026BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with internal bending moment

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

89/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT026BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 1000 Value 2.000e+007 SOL.SAR.STAT026BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type moment concentrated

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm ] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm ] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

W 2 [mm ] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001

IPE200 3 W 3 [mm ] 3.081e+004

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-6.6667e+003 6.6667e+003 1.5930e-010 -1.8626e-009

(Cv Tv)
3.3333e-007 -3.3333e-007 1.5930e-010 -1.8626e-009

100

Tv Cv Cv

-6.6667e+003 6.6667e+003 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

90/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT027 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT027 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with end bending moment

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

91/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT027 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL MOMENT Value 2.000e+007 Point of application Left end Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT027 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-6.6667e+003 6.6667e+003 2.0000e+007 -1.8626e-009

(Cv Tv)
3.3333e-007 -3.3333e-007 3.7253e-009 -1.8626e-009

100

Tv Cv Cv

-6.6667e+003 6.6667e+003 2.0000e+007 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

92/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT028 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT028 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with bending moments at both ends

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

93/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT028 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL MOMENT NODAL MOMENT Value 2.000e+007 1.500e+007 Point of application Left end Right end Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT028 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-1.6667e+003 1.6667e+003 2.0000e+007 -1.5000e+007

(Cv Tv)
3.3333e-007 -3.3333e-007 7.4506e-009 0.0000e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

-1.6667e+003 1.6667e+003 2.0000e+007 -1.5000e+007

-0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

94/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT029 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT029 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Intermediate support beam with distributed constant load and end shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

95/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT029 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 4000=3000+1000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE force distributed Value 7.000e+003 2.570e+000 Point of application Free tip Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT029 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
1.0933e+003 6.6167e+003 8.2850e+006 2.4447e-009

(Cv Tv)
3.3333e-007 -3.3333e-007 1.8626e-009 2.4447e-009

100

Tv Cv Cv

1.0933e+003 6.6167e+003 8.2850e+006 0.0000e+000

0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

96/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT030 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT030 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Intermediate support beam with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

97/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT030 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 6000=3000+3000 LOAD Type force distributed Value 2.570e+000 Point of application Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT030 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-1.3642e-012 7.7100e+003 1.1565e+007 -4.6566e-010

(Cv Tv)
-1.3642e-012 0.0000e+000 3.7253e-009 -4.6566e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

0.0000e+000 7.7100e+003 1.1565e+007 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

98/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT031 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT031 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Intermediate support beam with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

99/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT031 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 7000=3000+4000 LOAD Type force distributed Value 2.570e+000 Point of application Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT031 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-2.9983e+003 1.0708e+004 2.0560e+007 9.3132e-009

(Cv Tv)
-3.3334e-007 3.3333e-006 7.4506e-009 9.3132e-009

100

Tv Cv Cv

-2.9983e+003 1.0708e+004 2.0560e+007 0.0000e+000

0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

100/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT032 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT032 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Intermediate support beam with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

101/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT032 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 4000=3000+1000 LOAD Type force distributed force distributed Value 2.570e+000 2.570e+000 Point of application Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT032 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.4267e+003 4.2833e+003 1.2850e+006 -3.4925e-010

(Cv Tv)
-3.3333e-007 3.3333e-007 -2.3283e-010 -3.4925e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.4267e+003 4.2833e+003 1.2850e+006 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

102/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT033 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT033 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Intermediate support beam with two distributed constant loads

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

103/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT033 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 5000=1000+3000+1000 LOAD Type force distributed Value 2.570e+000 Point of application Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT033 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

v 3.000e-001

1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

Fe360

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
2.5700e+003 3.8550e+003 1.2850e+006 -1.2806e-009

(Cv Tv)
-9.0949e-013 -4.5475e-013 2.3283e-010 -1.2806e-009

100

Tv Cv Cv

2.5700e+003 3.8550e+003 1.2850e+006 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

104/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT034 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT034 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Intermediate support beam with end shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

105/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT034 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 4000=3000+1000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE Value 7.000e+003 Point of application Free tip Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT034 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
2.3333e+003 7.0000e+003 7.0000e+006 0.0000e+000

(Cv Tv)
3.3333e-007 0.0000e+000 2.7940e-009 0.0000e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

2.3333e+003 7.0000e+003 7.0000e+006 0.0000e+000

0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

106/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT035 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT035 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Intermediate support beam with end bending moment

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

107/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT035 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 4000=3000+1000 LOAD Type NODAL MOMENT Value 2.000e+007 Point of application Free tip Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT035 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
6.6667e+003 2.9104e-011 -1.8626e-009 2.0000e+007

(Cv Tv)
-3.3333e-007 2.9104e-011 -1.8626e-009 2.9802e-008

100

Tv Cv Cv

6.6667e+003 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000 2.0000e+007

-0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

108/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT036 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT036 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Beam (end 1 fixed - end 2 simply supported) with internal shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

109/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT036 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 2000 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT036 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.3704e+003 3.6296e+003 -3.6296e+006 -1.8626e-009

(Cv Tv)
3.7037e-007 -3.7037e-007 3.7037e-004 -1.8626e-009

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.3704e+003 3.6296e+003 -3.6296e+006 0.0000e+000

0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

110/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT036BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT036BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Beam (end 1 fixed - end 2 simply supported) with internal shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

111/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT036BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 2000 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT036BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force concentrated

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm ] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm ] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

W 2 [mm ] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000

Sezione1 3 W 3 [mm ] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.3704e+003 3.6296e+003 -3.1111e+006 -4.6566e-010

(Cv Tv)
-3.1074e-004 3.1074e-004 2.3322e-001 -4.6566e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.3704e+003 3.6296e+003 -3.1111e+006 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

112/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT037 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT037 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Beam (end 1 fixed - end 2 simply supported) with internal shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

113/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT037 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 1500 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT037 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
4.8125e+003 -2.1875e+003 -3.9375e+006 -3.2813e+006

(Cv Tv)
9.0949e-013 0.0000e+000 -9.3132e-010 -9.3132e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

4.8125e+003 -2.1875e+003 -3.9375e+006 -3.2813e+006

0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

114/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT037BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT037BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Beam (end 1 fixed - end 2 simply supported) with internal shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

115/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT037BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 1500 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT037BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force concentrated

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm ] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm ] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

W 2 [mm ] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000

Sezione1 3 W 3 [mm ] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
4.8125e+003 2.1875e+003 -3.9375e+006 -4.6566e-010

(Cv Tv)
0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000 -4.6566e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

4.8125e+003 2.1875e+003 -3.9375e+006 0.0000e+000

0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

116/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT038 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT038 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Beam (end 1 fixed - end 2 simply supported) with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

117/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT038 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed Value 2.570e+000 Point of application Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT038 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
4.8187e+003 2.8912e+003 -2.8913e+006 -4.6566e-010

(Cv Tv)
-9.0949e-013 -4.5475e-013 -9.3132e-010 -4.6566e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

4.8188e+003 2.8913e+003 -2.8913e+006 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

118/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT039 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT039 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Beam (end 1 fixed - end 2 simply supported) with distributed linear load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

119/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT039 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed Value 2.570e+0000.000e+000 Point of application Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT039 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.0840e+003 7.7100e+002 -1.5420e+006 -1.1642e-010

(Cv Tv)
-4.5475e-013 1.2506e-012 -9.3132e-010 -1.1642e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.0840e+003 7.7100e+002 -1.5420e+006 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

120/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT040 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT040 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Cantilever, intermediate support, with end shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

121/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT040 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 4000=3000+1000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE Value 7.000e+003 Point of application Free tip Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT040 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-3.5000e+003 -7.0000e+003 3.5000e+006 7.0000e+006

(Cv Tv)
-7.2760e-012 -1.4552e-011 7.4506e-009 1.4901e-008

100

Tv Cv Cv

-3.5000e+003 -7.0000e+003 3.5000e+006 7.0000e+006

0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

122/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT041 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT041 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Cantilever, intermediate support, with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

123/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT041 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 4000=3000+1000 LOAD Type force distributed Value 2.570e+000 Point of application Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT041 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
4.1762e+003 4.5475e-013 1.2850e+006 5.8208e-011

(Cv Tv)
-9.0949e-013 4.5475e-013 -2.3283e-010 5.8208e-011

100

Tv Cv Cv

4.1763e+003 0.0000e+000 1.2850e+006 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

124/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT042 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT042 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Beam (both ends fixed) with internal shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

125/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT042 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 1000 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT042 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
5.1852e+003 -1.8148e+003 -3.1111e+006 -2.0741e+006

(Cv Tv)
1.8518e-007 1.8519e-007 -1.1111e-004 -7.4074e-005

100

Tv Cv Cv

5.1852e+003 -1.8148e+003 -3.1111e+006 -2.0741e+006

0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

126/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT042BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT042BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Beam (both ends fixed) with internal shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

127/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT042BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 1000 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT042BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force concentrated

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm ] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm ] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

W 2 [mm ] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000

Sezione1 3 W 3 [mm ] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
5.1852e+003 1.8148e+003 -3.1111e+006 1.5556e+006

(Cv Tv)
3.1130e-004 -3.1130e-004 -1.1109e-004 -2.3378e-001

100

Tv Cv Cv

5.1852e+003 1.8148e+003 -3.1111e+006 1.5556e+006

0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

128/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT043 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT043 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Beam (both ends fixed) with internal shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

129/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT043 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 1500 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT043 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.5000e+003 -3.5000e+003 -2.6250e+006 -2.6250e+006

(Cv Tv)
-9.0949e-013 9.0949e-013 4.6566e-010 4.6566e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.5000e+003 -3.5000e+003 -2.6250e+006 -2.6250e+006

-0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

130/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT043BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT043BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Beam (both ends fixed) with internal shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

131/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT043BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 1500 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT043BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force concentrated

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm ] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm ] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

W 2 [mm ] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000

Sezione1 3 W 3 [mm ] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.5000e+003 3.5000e+003 -2.6250e+006 2.6250e+006

(Cv Tv)
0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.5000e+003 3.5000e+003 -2.6250e+006 2.6250e+006

0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

132/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT044 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT044 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Beam (both ends fixed) with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

133/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT044 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed Value 2.570e+000 Point of application Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT044 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.8550e+003 3.8550e+003 -1.9275e+006 1.9275e+006

(Cv Tv)
-4.5475e-013 -4.5475e-013 -6.9849e-010 -4.6566e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.8550e+003 3.8550e+003 -1.9275e+006 1.9275e+006

-0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

134/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT045 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT045 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Beam (both ends fixed) with internal distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

135/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT045 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] Dx2 [mm] 1000 2000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT045 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application Dx1-Dx2 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
1.2850e+003 1.2850e+003 -9.2806e+005 9.2806e+005

(Cv Tv)
-2.2737e-013 -2.2737e-013 4.4445e-005 -4.4445e-005

100

Tv Cv Cv

1.2850e+003 1.2850e+003 -9.2806e+005 9.2806e+005

-0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

136/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT045BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT045BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Beam (both ends fixed) with internal distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

137/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT045BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] Dx2 [mm] 1000 2000 Value 2.570e+0002.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT045BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed

Point of application Dx1-Dx2 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL 2 fy [N/mm ] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 2.981e+003 3 W pl2 [mm ] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 2.051e+007 3 W pl3 [mm ] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm ] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm ] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

W 2 [mm ] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001

IPE200 3 W 3 [mm ] 3.081e+004

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
1.2850e+003 1.2850e+003 -9.2806e+005 9.2806e+005

(Cv Tv)
2.5700e-004 2.5700e-004 -1.7129e-001 1.7129e-001

100

Tv Cv Cv

1.2850e+003 1.2850e+003 -9.2806e+005 9.2806e+005

0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

138/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT046 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT046 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Beam (both ends fixed) with internal distributed constant loads

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

139/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT046 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] Dx2 [mm] 400 1000 SOL.SAR.STAT046 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 Constraints As shown LOAD Type force distributed force distributed

Dx3 [mm] 2000

Dx4 [mm] 2600

Value 2.570e+000 2.570e+000

Point of application Dx1-Dx2 Dx3-Dx4 Fe360 1.200e-005


4

MATERIAL 2 fy [N/mm ] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

v 3.000e-001
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm ] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm ] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

W 2 [mm ] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000

Sezione1 3 W 3 [mm ] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 4. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
1.5420e+003 0.0000e+000 -8.1212e+005 2.6728e+005

(Cv Tv)
-4.5475e-013 0.0000e+000 -9.3132e-010 6.4028e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

1.5420e+003 0.0000e+000 -8.1212e+005 2.6728e+005

-0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

140/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT046BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT046BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Beam (both ends fixed) with two internal distributed constant loads

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

141/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT046BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] Dx2 [mm] 400 1000 SOL.SAR.STAT046BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 Constraints As shown LOAD Type force linearly distributed force linearly distributed

Dx3 [mm] 2000

Dx4 [mm] 2600

Value 2.570e+0002.570e+000 2.570e+0002.570e+000

Point of application Dx1-Dx2 Dx3-Dx4 -

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm ] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm ] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

W 2 [mm ] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000

Sezione1 3 W 3 [mm ] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
1.5420e+003 1.5420e+003 -8.1212e+005 8.1212e+005

(Cv Tv)
-2.2737e-013 6.8212e-013 8.2240e-002 -8.2240e-002

100

Tv Cv Cv

1.5420e+003 1.5420e+003 -8.1212e+005 8.1212e+005

-0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

142/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT047 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT047 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Beam (both ends fixed) with internal distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

143/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT047 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 1000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT047 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application Left end-Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
2.3320e+003 -2.3796e+002 -7.8528e+005 2.1417e+005

(Cv Tv)
3.7037e-008 3.7037e-008 2.2222e-005 -3.3333e-005

100

Tv Cv Cv

2.3320e+003 -2.3796e+002 -7.8528e+005 2.1417e+005

0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

144/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT047BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT047BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Beam (both ends fixed) with internal distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

145/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT047BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 1000 Value 2.570e+0002.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT047BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed

Point of application Left end-Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL 2 fy [N/mm ] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 1.000e+000 3 W pl2 [mm ] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 1.000e+000 3 W pl3 [mm ] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm ] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm ] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

W 2 [mm ] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000

Sezione1 3 W 3 [mm ] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
2.3320e+003 2.3796e+002 -7.8528e+005 2.1417e+005

(Cv Tv)
-1.9033e-004 -6.6667e-005 1.1424e-001 -5.7144e-002

100

Tv Cv Cv

2.3320e+003 2.3796e+002 -7.8528e+005 2.1417e+005

-0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

146/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT048 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT048 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Beam (both ends fixed) with two distributed linear loads

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

147/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT048 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 1500 Value 0.000e+0002.570e+000 2.570e+0000.000e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT048 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed force linearly distributed

Point of application Left end-Dx1 Dx1-Right end -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL 2 fy [N/mm ] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

Fe360

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm ] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm ] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

W 2 [mm ] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000

Sezione1 3 W 3 [mm ] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
1.9275e+003 2.2737e-013 -1.2047e+006 -7.2281e+005

(Cv Tv)
-9.0949e-013 2.2737e-013 6.9849e-010 4.6566e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

1.9275e+003 0.0000e+000 -1.2047e+006 -7.2281e+005

-0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

148/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT048BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT048BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Beam (both ends fixed) with two distributed linear loads

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

149/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT048BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 1500 Value 0.000e+0002.570e+000 2.570e+0000.000e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT048BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed force linearly distributed

Point of application Left end-Dx1 Dx1-Right end -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL 2 fy [N/mm ] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 3 W pl2 [mm ] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 3 W pl3 [mm ] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
1.9275e+003 1.9275e+003 -1.2047e+006 1.2047e+006

(Cv Tv)
-4.5475e-013 3.1832e-012 -3.4925e-009 1.1642e-009

100

Tv Cv Cv

1.9275e+003 1.9275e+003 -1.2047e+006 1.2047e+006

-0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

150/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT049 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT049 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Beam (both ends fixed) with distributed linear load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

151/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT049 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed Value 0.000e+0002.570e+000 Point of application Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT049 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
1.1565e+003 2.6985e+003 -7.7100e+005 1.1565e+006

(Cv Tv)
0.0000e+000 -9.0949e-013 2.3283e-010 -2.3283e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

1.1565e+003 2.6985e+003 -7.7100e+005 1.1565e+006

0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

152/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT050 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT050 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Beam (both ends fixed) with internal bending moment

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

153/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT050 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 2250 Value 2.000e+007 SOL.SAR.STAT050 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL MOMENT

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-7.5000e+003 6.2500e+006 1.0625e+007 -3.7500e+006

(Cv Tv)
1.8190e-012 -1.8626e-009 -1.8626e-009 0.0000e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

-7.5000e+003 6.2500e+006 1.0625e+007 -3.7500e+006

-0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

154/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT050BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT050BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Beam (both ends fixed) with internal bending moment

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

155/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT050BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 2250 Value 2.000e+007 SOL.SAR.STAT050BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type moment concentrated

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm ] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm ] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

W 2 [mm ] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000

Sezione1 3 W 3 [mm ] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-7.5000e+003 7.5000e+003 6.2500e+006 -3.7500e+006

(Cv Tv)
0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

-7.5000e+003 7.5000e+003 6.2500e+006 -3.7500e+006

-0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

156/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT051 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT051 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Continuous beam (2 spans) with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

157/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT051 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 6000=3000+3000 LOAD Type force distributed Value 2.570e+000 Point of application Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione 1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT051 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
2.8912e+003 4.8187e+003 0.0000e+000 -2.8913e+006

(Cv Tv)
-9.0949e-013 -9.0949e-013 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

2.8913e+003 4.8188e+003 0.0000e+000 -2.8913e+006

-0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

158/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT052 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT052 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Continuous beam (2 spans) with internal distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

159/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT052 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 3000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT052 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 6000=3000+3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application Left end-Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione 1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.3731e+003 4.8187e+002 -2.3283e-010 -1.4456e+006

(Cv Tv)
-9.0949e-013 -1.7053e-013 -2.3283e-010 2.3283e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.3731e+003 4.8188e+002 0.0000e+000 -1.4456e+006

-0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

160/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT053 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT053 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Continuous beam (2 spans) with distributed variable load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

161/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT053 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 3000 Value 2.570e+000 4.360e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT053 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 6000=3000+3000 LOAD Type force distributed force distributed

Point of application Left end-Dx1 Dx1-Right end -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione 1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
2.5556e+003 5.2406e+003 2.3283e-010 3.8981e+006

(Cv Tv)
-9.0949e-013 1.8190e-012 2.3283e-010 9.3132e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

2.5556e+003 5.2406e+003 0.0000e+000 3.8981e+006

-0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

162/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT054 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT054 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Continuous beam (2 spans) with two shear forces

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

163/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT054 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] Dx2 [mm] 1500 4500 Value 7.000e+003 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT054 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 6000=3000+3000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE NODAL FORCE

Point of application Dx1 Dx2 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione 1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 4. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-4.8125e+003 -2.1875e+003 -1.7462e-009 3.9375e+006

(Cv Tv)
-9.0949e-013 0.0000e+000 -1.7462e-009 9.3132e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

-4.8125e+003 -2.1875e+003 0.0000e+000 3.9375e+006

0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

164/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT054BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT054BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Continuous beam (2 spans) with two shear forces

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

165/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT054BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] Dx2 [mm] 1500 4500 Value 7.000e+003 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT054BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 6000=3000+3000 LOAD Type force concentrated force concentrated

Point of application Dx1 Dx2 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm ] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm ] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

W 2 [mm ] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000

Sezione 1 3 W 3 [mm ] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
2.1875e+003 2.1875e+003 -4.6566e-010 3.9375e+006

(Cv Tv)
0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000 -4.6566e-010 0.0000e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

2.1875e+003 2.1875e+003 0.0000e+000 3.9375e+006

0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

166/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT055 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT055 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Continuous beam (2 spans, ends fixed) with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

167/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT055 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 6000=3000+3000 LOAD Type force distributed Value 2.570e+000 Point of application Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione 1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT055 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.8550e+003 3.8550e+003 -1.9275e+006 1.9275e+006

(Cv Tv)
-9.0949e-013 0.0000e+000 -4.6566e-010 -2.3283e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.8550e+003 3.8550e+003 -1.9275e+006 1.9275e+006

-0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

168/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT056 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT056 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Continuous beam (2 spans, ends fixed) with one internal distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

169/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT056 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Dx1 [mm] 3000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT056 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 6000=3000+3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application Left end-Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione 1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
4.3369e+003 -4.8187e+002 -2.4094e+006 -4.8187e+005

(Cv Tv)
-9.0949e-013 1.1369e-013 -4.6566e-010 5.8208e-011

100

Tv Cv Cv

4.3369e+003 -4.8188e+002 -2.4094e+006 -4.8188e+005

-0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

170/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT057 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT057 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Continuous beam (3 spans) with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

171/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT057 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 9000=3x3000 LOAD Type force distributed Value 2.570e+000 Point of application Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT057 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

v 3.000e-001

1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione 1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

Fe360

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.0840e+003 4.6260e+003 2.3130e+006 -2.3283e-010

(Cv Tv)
-9.0949e-013 -9.0949e-013 4.6566e-010 -2.3283e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.0840e+003 4.6260e+003 2.3130e+006 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

172/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT058 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT058 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Continuous beam (3 spans) with 2 internal distributed constant loads

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

173/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT058 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 9000=3x3000 LOAD Type force distributed Value 2.570e+000 Point of application First and second spans Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione 1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT058 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
2.9555e+003 2.5700e+002 7.7100e+005 2.6985e+006

(Cv Tv)
-9.0949e-013 -1.1369e-013 -2.3283e-010 0.0000e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

2.9555e+003 2.5700e+002 7.7100e+005 2.6985e+006

-0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

174/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT059 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT059 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Continuous beam (3 spans) with one internal distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

175/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT059 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 9000=3x3000 LOAD Type force distributed Value 2.570e+000 Point of application Central span Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione 1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT059 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-3.8550e+002 3.8550e+003 1.1565e+006 1.1642e-010

(Cv Tv)
0.0000e+000 -4.5475e-013 -4.6566e-010 1.1642e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

-3.8550e+002 3.8550e+003 1.1565e+006 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

176/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT060 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT060 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Continuous beam (3 spans) with two internal distributed constant loads

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

177/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT060 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 9000=3x3000 LOAD Type force distributed force distributed Value 2.570e+000 2.570e+000 Point of application First span Third span Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione 1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT060 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.4695e+003 -4.5475e-013 1.1565e+006 -4.6566e-010

(Cv Tv)
-9.0949e-013 -4.5475e-013 2.3283e-010 -4.6566e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.4695e+003 0.0000e+000 1.1565e+006 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

178/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT061 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT061 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Continuous beam (3 spans, ends fixed) with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

179/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT061 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 9000=3x3000 LOAD Type force distributed Value 2.570e+000 Point of application Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT061 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

v 3.000e-001

1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione 1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

Fe360

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.8550e+003 3.8550e+003 1.9275e+006 -1.9275e+006

(Cv Tv)
-9.0949e-013 -9.0949e-013 2.3283e-010 -4.6566e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.8550e+003 3.8550e+003 1.9275e+006 -1.9275e+006

-0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

180/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT062 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT062 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Continuous beam (3 spans, ends fixed) with two internal distributed constant loads

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

181/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT062 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 9000=3x3000 LOAD Type force distributed Value 2.570e+000 Point of application First and second spans Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT062 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

v 3.000e-001

1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione 1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

Fe360

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.7265e+003 4.2405e+003 1.0280e+006 -1.7990e+006

(Cv Tv)
-9.0949e-013 -9.0949e-013 0.0000e+000 -4.6566e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.7265e+003 4.2405e+003 1.0280e+006 -1.7990e+006

-0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

182/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT063 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT063 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Continuous beam (3 spans, ends fixed) with two internal distributed constant loads

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

183/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT063 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 9000=3x3000 LOAD Type force distributed force distributed Value 2.570e+000 2.570e+000 Point of application First span Third span Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT063 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

v 3.000e-001

1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione 1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

Fe360

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
4.4975e+003 -1.1369e-013 6.4250e+005 -2.5700e+006

(Cv Tv)
0.0000e+000 -1.1369e-013 3.4925e-010 -9.3132e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

4.4975e+003 0.0000e+000 6.4250e+005 -2.5700e+006

0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

184/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT064 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT064 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Continuous beam (3 spans, ends fixed) with one internal distributed constant loads

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

185/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT064 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 9000=3x3000 LOAD Type force distributed Value 2.570e+000 Point of application Central span Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione 1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT064 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-6.4250e+002 3.8550e+003 1.2850e+006 6.4250e+005

(Cv Tv)
-2.2737e-013 -9.0949e-013 0.0000e+000 3.4925e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

-6.4250e+002 3.8550e+003 1.2850e+006 6.4250e+005

0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

186/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT065 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT065 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Continuous beam (4 spans) with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

187/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT065 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 12000=4x3000 LOAD Type force distributed Value 2.570e+000 Point of application Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 0.000e+000 Sezione 1 W 3 [mm3] 0.000e+000 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT065 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 0.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 0.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 0.000e+000 i3 [mm] 0.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 4. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.0289e+003 4.1304e+003 1.6521e+006 -2.4782e+006

(Cv Tv)
-4.2857e-004 1.4286e-004 -1.4286e-001 -2.8571e-001

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.0289e+003 4.1304e+003 1.6521e+006 -2.4782e+006

-0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

188/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT066 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT066 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with internal inclined force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

189/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT066 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS alpha [deg] Dx1 [mm] 45 1000 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT066 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.2998e+003 -1.6499e+003 -1.3970e-009 3.2998e+006

(Cv Tv)
3.5400e-004 -1.7700e-004 -1.3970e-009 3.5400e-001

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.2998e+003 -1.6499e+003 0.0000e+000 3.2998e+006

0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

190/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT066BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT066BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with internal inclined force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

191/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT066BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS alpha [deg] Dx1 [mm] 45 1000 Value 4.950e+003 4.950e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT066BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force concentrated force concentrated

Point of application Dx1 Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm ] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm ] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

W 2 [mm ] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001

IPE200 3 W 3 [mm ] 3.081e+004

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.2998e+003 1.6499e+003 0.0000e+000 -6.9849e-010

(Cv Tv)
5.1899e-004 1.2008e-005 0.0000e+000 -6.9849e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.2998e+003 1.6499e+003 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000

0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

192/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT067 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT067 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Simply supported beam with inclined distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

193/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT067 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS alpha [deg] 45 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT067 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force linearly distributed

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 2.051e+005 i t [mm] 2.887e+001 IPE200 W 3 [mm3] 3.081e+004

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 2.981e+003 W pl2 [mm3] 2.597e+005 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 2.051e+007 W pl3 [mm3] 4.776e+004

J3 [mm4] 1.540e+006 i2 [mm] 8.296e+001

J t [mm4] 6.254e+004 i3 [mm] 2.273e+001

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
2.7259e+003 2.7259e+003 4.6566e-010 -4.6566e-010

(Cv Tv)
-6.4100e-004 -6.4100e-004 4.6566e-010 -4.6566e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

2.7259e+003 2.7259e+003 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

194/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT068 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT068 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Supported cantilever, right bearing translational settle

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

195/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT068 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type Settle Value 250mm Point of application Right end Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT068 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv
5.7222e-003

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
5.7222e-003 -5.7222e-003 -1.7167e+001 7.1054e-015

(Cv Tv)
2.9666e-010 -2.9666e-010 -2.1999e-007 7.1054e-015

100

Tv Cv Cv

0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

-5.7222e-003 -1.7167e+001 0.0000e+000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

196/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT069 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT069 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Supported cantilever, clamping rotational settle

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

197/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT069 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type Settle Value 0,3rad Point of application Left end Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT069 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-2.0600e-002 2.0600e-002 6.1800e+001 0.0000e+000

(Cv Tv)
-2.6798e-010 2.6798e-010 8.0394e-007 0.0000e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

-2.0600e-002 2.0600e-002 6.1800e+001 0.0000e+000

0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

198/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT070 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT070 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Fully restrained beam. Left clamping translational settle.

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

199/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT070 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type Settle Value 250mm Point of application Right end Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT070 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv
2.2889e-002

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
2.2889e-002 -2.2889e-002 -3.4333e+001 -3.4333e+001

(Cv Tv)
-1.1132e-010 1.1132e-010 -3.0190e-009 -3.0190e-009

100

Tv Cv Cv

-0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

-2.2889e-002 -3.4333e+001 -3.4333e+001

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

200/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT071 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT071 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Fully restrained beam. Right clamping rotational settle.

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

201/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT071 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type Settle Value 0,3rad Point of application Left end Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000 Constraints As shown SOL.SAR.STAT071 CLEVER (SARGON

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-4.1200e-002 4.1200e-002 8.2400e+001 4.1200e+001

(Cv Tv)
-5.3596e-010 5.3596e-010 1.0719e-006 5.3596e-007

100

Tv Cv Cv

-4.1200e-002 4.1200e-002 8.2400e+001 4.1200e+001

0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

202/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT072 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT072 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Hinged frame with constant distributed load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

203/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT072 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 4000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT072 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-2.5511e+002 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000 1.0204e+006

(Cv Tv)
8.4235e-006 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000 -3.3294e-002

100

Tv Cv Cv

-2.5511e+002 0.0000e+000 0.0000e+000 1.0204e+006

-0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

204/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT073 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT073 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Hinged frame with shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

205/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT073 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] Dx1 [mm] 4000 1000 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT073 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 4. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-3.0882e+002 3.0882e+002 -1.2353e+006 3.4314e+006

(Cv Tv)
1.0260e-005 -1.0153e-005 4.1441e-002 4.0965e-002

100

Tv Cv Cv

-3.0882e+002 3.0882e+002 -1.2353e+006 3.4314e+006

-0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

206/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT073BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT073BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Hinged frame with shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

207/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT073BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] Dx1 [mm] 4000 1000 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT073BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force concentrated

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm ] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm ] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

W 2 [mm ] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000

Sezione1 3 W 3 [mm ] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-3.0882e+002 3.0882e+002 -1.2353e+006 0.0000e+000

(Cv Tv)
2.5701e-005 -2.5594e-005 1.0321e-001 0.0000e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

-3.0882e+002 3.0882e+002 -1.2353e+006 0.0000e+000

-0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

208/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT074 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT074 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Hinged frame with horizontal force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

209/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT074 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 4000 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT074 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.5000e+003 -4.6566e-010 -1.4000e+007 1.4000e+007

(Cv Tv)
-1.1227e-004 -4.6566e-010 -4.7739e-001 -4.4908e-001

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.5000e+003 0.0000e+000 -1.4000e+007 1.4000e+007

-0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

210/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT075 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT075 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Hinged frame with constant distributed load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

211/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT075 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 4000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT075 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
7.4076e+003 3.2596e-009 -9.0706e+006 1.1489e+007

(Cv Tv)
9.7936e-005 3.2596e-009 -3.9274e-001 -3.6317e-001

100

Tv Cv Cv

7.4076e+003 0.0000e+000 -9.0706e+006 1.1489e+007

0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

212/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT076 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT076 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Hinged portal frame, projecting beam. Constant distributed load.

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

213/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT076 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] Projecting beam [mm] 4000 1000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT076 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Constraints As shown

Point of application Projecting beam Fe360 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

v 3.000e-001

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
8.5037e+001 0.0000e+000 -3.4015e+005 -9.4485e+005

(Cv Tv)
-2.7735e-006 0.0000e+000 1.1054e-002 -1.1054e-002

100

Tv Cv Cv

8.5037e+001 0.0000e+000 -3.4015e+005 -9.4485e+005

-0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

214/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT077 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT077 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Hinged frame with temperature increase

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

215/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT077 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 4000 Value 3.000e+001 SOL.SAR.STAT077 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type temperature

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-2.4538e-006 9.5410e-018 9.8153e-003 9.8153e-003

(Cv Tv)
4.6237e-013 9.5410e-018 1.5050e-010 1.2960e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

-2.4538e-006 0.0000e+000 9.8153e-003 9.8153e-003

-0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

216/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT078 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT078 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Fixed frame with constant distributed load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

217/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT078 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 4000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT078 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-4.3369e+002 4.3369e+002 5.7825e+005 1.1565e+006

(Cv Tv)
6.7086e-005 -6.7086e-005 -1.7076e-001 -9.7580e-002

100

Tv Cv Cv

-4.3369e+002 4.3369e+002 5.7825e+005 1.1565e+006

-0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

218/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT079 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT079 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Fixed frame with constant distributed load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

219/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT079 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 4000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT079 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
2.1845e+003 8.0955e+003 -9.4614e+006 2.3606e+006

(Cv Tv)
-3.3716e-004 3.3867e-004 -2.0656e+000 -7.1089e-001

100

Tv Cv Cv

2.1845e+003 8.0955e+003 -9.4614e+006 2.3606e+006

-0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

220/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT080 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT080 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Fixed frame with shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

221/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT080 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] Dx1 [mm] 4000 1000 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT080 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-5.2500e+002 5.2500e+002 6.1358e+005 -1.4864e+006

(Cv Tv)
8.1147e-005 -8.1275e-005 5.1894e-001 8.4342e-001

100

Tv Cv Cv

-5.2500e+002 5.2500e+002 6.1358e+005 -1.4864e+006

-0.0000 -0.0000 0.0001 -0.0001

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

222/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT080BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT080BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Fixed frame with shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

223/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT080BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] Dx1 [mm] 4000 1000 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT080BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force concentrated

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm ] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm ] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

W 2 [mm ] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000

Sezione1 3 W 3 [mm ] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-5.2500e+002 5.2500e+002 6.1358e+005 -1.4864e+006

(Cv Tv)
1.0749e-004 -1.0743e-004 4.7076e-001 9.0063e-001

100

Tv Cv Cv

-5.2500e+002 5.2500e+002 6.1358e+005 -1.4864e+006

-0.0000 -0.0000 0.0001 -0.0001

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

224/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT081 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT081 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Fixed portal frame, projecting beam. Constant distributed load.

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

225/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT081 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] Projecting beam [mm] 4000 1000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT081 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Constraints As shown

Point of application
Projecting beam

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002 fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002


2

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
1.4456e+002 -1.4456e+002 -1.2136e+005 2.6414e+005

(Cv Tv)
-2.2388e-005 2.2336e-005 1.0441e+000 9.3023e-001

100

Tv Cv Cv

1.4456e+002 -1.4456e+002 -1.2136e+005 2.6414e+005

-0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0009 0.0004

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

226/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT082 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT082 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Fixed frame with horizontal force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

227/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT082 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 4000 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT082 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.5000e+003 3.5000e+003 -7.7778e+006 6.2222e+006

(Cv Tv)
5.4252e-004 -5.4029e-004 -3.8385e+000 -1.6685e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.5000e+003 3.5000e+003 -7.7778e+006 6.2222e+006

0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

228/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT083 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT083 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Fixed frame with temperature increase

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

229/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT083 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 4000 Value 3.000e+001 SOL.SAR.STAT083 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type temperature

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-1.1472e-005 1.1472e-005 -1.6686e-002 2.9200e-002

(Cv Tv)
6.3623e-012 -6.3752e-012 1.9794e-009 -3.4697e-009

100

Tv Cv Cv

-1.1472e-005 1.1472e-005 -1.6686e-002 2.9201e-002

-0.0001 -0.0001 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

230/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT084 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT084 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Half portal frame (hinged) with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

231/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT084 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 4000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT084 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-3.0978e+002 3.4420e+003 0.0000e+000 1.2391e+006

(Cv Tv)
6.3460e-004 8.4586e-004 0.0000e+000 -2.5386e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

-3.0978e+002 3.4420e+003 0.0000e+000 1.2391e+006

-0.0002 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0002

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

232/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT085 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT085 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Half portal frame (hinged) with shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

233/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT085 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] Dx1 [mm] 4000 1000 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT085 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-4.1667e+002 -4.6566e-010 1.6667e+006 -3.5556e+006

(Cv Tv)
7.7955e-004 -4.6566e-010 -3.1184e+000 -2.0783e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

-4.1667e+002 0.0000e+000 1.6667e+006 -3.5556e+006

-0.0002 -0.0000 -0.0002 0.0001

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

234/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT085BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT085BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Half portal frame (hinged) with shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

235/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT085BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] Dx1 [mm] 4000 1000 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT085BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force concentrated

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm ] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm ] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

W 2 [mm ] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000

Sezione1 3 W 3 [mm ] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-4.1667e+002 1.7778e+003 0.0000e+000 1.6667e+006

(Cv Tv)
7.9205e-004 8.2246e-004 0.0000e+000 -3.1684e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

-4.1667e+002 1.7778e+003 0.0000e+000 1.6667e+006

-0.0002 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0002

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

236/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT086 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT086 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Half portal frame (hinged) with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

237/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT086 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 4000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT086 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
9.7905e+002 -9.3132e-010 -2.9371e+006 4.6566e-010

(Cv Tv)
-8.1583e-004 -9.3132e-010 2.4475e+000 4.6566e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

9.7905e+002 0.0000e+000 -2.9371e+006 0.0000e+000

-0.0001 -0.0000 -0.0001 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

238/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT087 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT087 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Half portal frame (hinge) with temperature increase

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

239/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT087 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 4000 Value 3.000e+001 SOL.SAR.STAT087 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type temperature

Point of application Only Transverse -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-5.9593e-006 -7.9457e-006 -1.7347e-017 2.3837e-002

(Cv Tv)
5.6889e-012 -2.4148e-012 -1.7347e-017 -2.7556e-009

100

Tv Cv Cv

-5.9593e-006 -7.9457e-006 0.0000e+000 2.3837e-002

-0.0001 0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

240/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT088 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT088 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Half portal frame (clamped-hinge) with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

241/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT088 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 4000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT088 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-5.4211e+002 7.2281e+005 -1.4456e+006 -4.6566e-010

(Cv Tv)
1.2748e-003 -1.9030e+000 3.1962e+000 -4.6566e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

-5.4211e+002 7.2281e+005 -1.4456e+006 0.0000e+000

-0.0002 -0.0003 -0.0002 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

242/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT089 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT089 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Half portal frame (clamped-hinge) frame with shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

243/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT089 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] Dx1 [mm] 4000 1000 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT089 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-7.2917e+002 1.9444e+006 9.7222e+005 0.0000e+000

(Cv Tv)
1.5851e-003 -3.9529e+000 -2.3868e+000 0.0000e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

-7.2917e+002 1.9444e+006 9.7222e+005 0.0000e+000

-0.0002 -0.0002 -0.0002 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

244/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT089BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT089BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Half portal frame (clamped-hinge) with shear force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

245/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT089BIS SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] Dx1 [mm] 4000 1000 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT089BIS CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force concentrated

Point of application Dx1 -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm2] 3.600e+002
4

E [N/mm2] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001
4

1.200e-005
4

CROSS-SECTION 2 A [mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm ] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm ] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm ] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

W 2 [mm ] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000

Sezione1 3 W 3 [mm ] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-7.2917e+002 1.9444e+006 9.7222e+005 -6.9849e-010

(Cv Tv)
1.6070e-003 -4.0113e+000 -2.4160e+000 -6.9849e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

-7.2917e+002 1.9444e+006 9.7222e+005 0.0000e+000

-0.0002 -0.0002 -0.0002 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

246/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT090 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT090 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Half portal frame (clamped-hinge) with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

247/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT090 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 4000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT090 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
5.7825e+003 -4.2833e+006 1.7133e+006 0.0000e+000

(Cv Tv)
1.7239e-003 -3.9855e+000 -2.9102e+000 0.0000e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

5.7825e+003 -4.2833e+006 1.7133e+006 0.0000e+000

0.0000 0.0001 -0.0002 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

248/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT091 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT091 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Half portal frame (clamped, support) with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

249/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT091 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 4000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT091 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
2.7517e-007 -5.7825e+005 -5.7825e+005 -4.6566e-010

(Cv Tv)
2.7517e-007 1.0787e+000 1.0798e+000 -4.6566e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

0.0000e+000 -5.7825e+005 -5.7825e+005 0.0000e+000

0.0000 -0.0002 -0.0002 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

250/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT092 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT092 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Half portal frame (clamped, support) with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

251/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT092 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 4000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT092 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
1.0280e+004 1.8276e+003 -1.5077e+007 -5.4827e+006

(Cv Tv)
2.2829e-006 -1.6168e-004 -4.9616e-001 4.8403e-001

100

Tv Cv Cv

1.0280e+004 1.8276e+003 -1.5077e+007 -5.4827e+006

0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

252/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT093 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT093 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Half portal frame (clamped, support) with horizontal force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

253/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT093 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 4000 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT093 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
7.0000e+003 -1.1200e+007 -1.6800e+007 -9.3132e-010

(Cv Tv)
3.5532e-006 9.8987e-001 -1.0041e+000 -9.3132e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

7.0000e+003 -1.1200e+007 -1.6800e+007 0.0000e+000

0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

254/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT094 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT094 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Closed rectangular Frame with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

255/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT094 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 4000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT094 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.8550e+003 2.5418e+005 -2.5418e+005 -1.0802e+006

(Cv Tv)
-9.0949e-013 -1.1550e-001 1.1550e-001 1.1573e-001

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.8550e+003 2.5418e+005 -2.5418e+005 -1.0802e+006

-0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

256/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT095 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT095 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Two-spans frame with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

257/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT095 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 4000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT095 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 6000=3000+3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 5. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-3.0978e+002 -2.3548e-010 4.1304e+005 8.2608e+005

(Cv Tv)
-2.2420e-003 -2.3548e-010 2.8731e+000 6.0947e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

-3.0978e+002 0.0000e+000 4.1304e+005 8.2607e+005

0.0007 -0.0000 0.0007 0.0007

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

258/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT096 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT096 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Three-spans frame with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

259/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT096 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 4000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT096 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 9000=3x3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 7. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 4. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.3078e+002 8.8208e+005 4.4104e+005 8.8208e+005

(Cv Tv)
1.5225e-003 4.2322e+000 1.8577e+000 4.2322e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.3078e+002 8.8208e+005 4.4104e+005 8.8208e+005

0.0005 0.0005 0.0004 0.0005

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

260/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT097 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT097 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Hinged portal frame, double supported cantilever, distributed constant load.

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

261/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT097 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 4000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT097 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 9000=3x3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 4. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-4.4619e+001 0.0000e+000 3.1292e+006 -3.3077e+006

(Cv Tv)
-1.1158e-003 0.0000e+000 -7.4334e+000 2.9701e+000

100

Tv Cv Cv

-4.4618e+001 0.0000e+000 3.1292e+006 -3.3077e+006

0.0025 0.0000 -0.0002 -0.0001

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

262/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT098 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT098 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Two-floors frame with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

263/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT098 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 8000=4000+4000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT098 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 5. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-1.5944e+002 7.2281e+005 0.0000e+000 6.3778e+005

(Cv Tv)
-1.2372e-005 -7.7355e-002 0.0000e+000 4.9388e-002

100

Tv Cv Cv

-1.5944e+002 7.2281e+005 0.0000e+000 6.3778e+005

0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

264/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT099 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT099 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
Two-floors frame with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

265/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT099 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 8000=4000+4000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT099 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 5. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
4.7833e+001 3.6141e+005 -1.4552e-011 -1.9133e+005

(Cv Tv)
-4.4954e-005 -2.3599e-001 -1.4552e-011 1.7981e-001

100

Tv Cv Cv

4.7833e+001 3.6141e+005 0.0000e+000 -1.9133e+005

-0.0001 -0.0001 -0.0000 -0.0001

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

266/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT100 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT100 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
3 hinges portal with distributed constant load

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

267/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT100 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 4000 Value 2.570e+000 SOL.SAR.STAT100 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type force distributed

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 4. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
-7.2281e+002 3.8550e+003 -2.3283e-010 2.8912e+006

(Cv Tv)
4.5475e-013 -3.6380e-012 -2.3283e-010 -9.3132e-010

100

Tv Cv Cv

-7.2281e+002 3.8550e+003 0.0000e+000 2.8913e+006

-0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

268/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT101 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER SOL.SAR.STAT101 CLEVER (SARGON

Problem description:
3 hinges portal with horizontal force

Keywords (english): Keywords (italian): Editorial note:

validation, benchmark, statics, finite elements, fem, solver, precision, reliability, quality control, beam, error measure validazione, benchmark, statica, elementi finiti, fem, solutore, precisione, affidabilit, controllo qualit, travi, misura di errore

Pictures are from program CESCOPLUS, a plane frame program by Castalia srl. CESCOPLUS uses its own solver to compute displacement and stresses. Target values are based on theoretical values, cross check values or accepted values. Where theoretical values are used, target values have been computed using well known formulae and/or published results, they have absolutely not been taken equal to those shown in pictures, which have been obtained by CESCOPLUS (since this schedule tests Sargon, the check would have otherwise been a cross check between CESCOPLUS and SARGON). Target values equalness with picture values if shown - is thus a consequence of CESCOPLUS precision, the assessment of which is not the main goal of this schedule. CESCOPLUS results are shown to easy the careful cheking of stress state and the understanding of the test itself. Since Sargon is a 3D program its graphical conventions about constraints are not as easy to understand as those of CESCOPLUS, thats why CESCOPLUS pictures have been used to describe the problem.

Note:
Shear area is not used, that is shear energy neglected. Dxi and Dzi are the offsets from lower Z alignment leftmost available node.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

269/270

TEST SCHEDULE CASTALIA_STAT101 SOLVING FINITE ELEMENT BEAM PROBLEM SOLVER GEOMETRY & CONSTRAINTS Full Height [mm] 4000 Value 7.000e+003 SOL.SAR.STAT101 CLEVER (SARGON

Full Length [mm] 3000 LOAD Type NODAL FORCE

Point of application -

Constraints As shown

MATERIAL fy [N/mm2] 2.350e+002

fu [N/mm ] 3.600e+002

E [N/mm ] 2.060e+005

Fe360 v 3.000e-001 1.200e-005 W 2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 i t [mm] 1.000e+000 Sezione1 W 3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

CROSS-SECTION A [mm2] 1.000e+000 W pl2 [mm3] 1.000e+000 OTHER DATA

J2[mm4] 1.000e+000 W pl3 [mm3] 1.000e+000

J3 [mm4] 1.000e+000 i2 [mm] 1.000e+000

J t [mm4] 1.000e+000 i3 [mm] 1.000e+000

TARGET VALUES Description


Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 1. Load case # 1 Shear T3, I extreme. Beam # 2. Load case # 1 Bending M2, I extreme. Beam # 3. Load case # 1 Bending M2, J extreme. Beam # 4. Load case # 1

vs Tv

COMPUTED VALUES TvK


Th Th Th Th

Cv
3.5000e+003 -9.3333e+003 4.6566e-010 1.4000e+007

(Cv Tv)
-5.2418e-006 1.3645e-005 4.6566e-010 -2.0967e-002

100

Tv Cv Cv

3.5000e+003 -9.3333e+003 0.0000e+000 1.4000e+007

-0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 -0.0000

Cv Tv TvK

100(Tv Cv) / Cv

computed value target value target value kind (theoretical, cross check, accepted). Th theoretical value Cr cross check value (theoretical target value is not known, results obtained with a different program are used as target values). Ac accepted value (a value which, on the basis of some argument, can be considered acceptable). relative error percentage

Computational notes: Authors: Computed errors: Ing. Marco Croci, Ing. Paolo Rugarli checksolvers.exe, by Castalia srl.

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

270/270

Copyright Castalia srl - Milan - Italy - 2007 All rights reserved: data may be used but citing the source and informing Castalia srl. http://www.castaliaweb.com staff@castaliaweb.com

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen