Demand Assessment for Automated Parking Facility at Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), New Delhi : Synopsis

Demand Assessment for

Parking Facility
Case Study: Shastri Park (Karol Bagh)

Synopsis

SimPark Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd.

12/1B, Nellie Sengupta Sarani, Kolkata

August 2007

Demand Assessment for Automated Parking Facility at Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), New Delhi : Synopsis

Contents

AREA INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................... 4

Major Locations of High Commercial Activity .............................................................. 4
Proposed Location for the Automated Parking Facility ............................................... 4
Survey Locations ................................................................................................................. 5
Parking Accumulation for Cars for all Locations (Highest & Lowest Values) .......... 6
PARKING ACCUMULATION FOR TWO-WHEELERS .............................................. 7
Parking Accumulation for Two-wheelers at Shastri Park (Karol Bagh) ..................... 7
PARKING DURATION FOR CARS................................................................................. 8
Parking Duration for Cars for All Locations................................................................... 8
Pie-chart for Duration of car parking for all locations................................................... 8
PARKING DURATION FOR TWO-WHEELERS......................................................... 10
Parking Duration for Two-wheelers for all Locations................................................. 10
Pie-chart for Duration of Two wheelers for all locations ........................................... 10
PARKING TURNOVER FOR CARS .............................................................................. 12
PARKING TURNOVER FOR 2-WHEELERS................................................................ 13
WILLINGNESS TO PAY FOR CARS & TWO-WHEELERS ....................................... 14
Willingness to pay for Car Parkers (Traders Response) ............................................ 14
Willingness to pay for Car Parkers (Visitors Response) ............................................ 14
Willingness to Pay for 2-wheelers Users (Traders Response) ................................... 15
Willingness to Pay for 2-wheelers Users (Visitors Response) ................................... 15
ARRIVAL RATE OF CARS.............................................................................................. 16
Arrival of Cars in 30 min Interval................................................................................... 16
Arrival of Cars for First 2 min of every Interval........................................................... 16
Arrival of Two-wheelers in 30 min Interval.................................................................. 17
Arrival of 2W for First 2 min of every Interval............................................................. 17

Demand Assessment for Automated Parking Facility at Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), New Delhi : Synopsis

Brief: SHASTRI PARK (KAROL BAGH)

Site

Shastri Park (Karol Bagh)

Locations

Off-street parking (Shastri Park)

On-street parking on nearby roads

Access

Pusa Road to Abdul Aziz Road/ Gurudwara Road

Landmarks

Jessa Ram Hospital

Surveys

Reconnaissance (personal observation)

Parking Usage for 30 minute intervals (Registration
Number Method)
Willingness to Pay (Interview Survey)

Parking Type

On-street paid & unpaid, Off-Street unpaid

Existing Parking Fees

On Street

Rs. 10 for 12 hours for cars

Rs. 5 for 12 hours for two wheelers

Off Street

Off-Street free parking

(Maintained by Traders association)

Survey Duration

9:00 am to 9:00 pm (12 hours)

Survey Days

Day 1: 24th Aug., 2007 (Friday)

Day 2: 25th Aug., 2007 (Saturday)
Day 3: 26th Aug., 2007 (Sunday)

Modes Surveyed

Cars & two-wheelers

Weekly Off

Monday

Demand Assessment for Automated Parking Facility at Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), New Delhi : Synopsis

AREA INTRODUCTION
Major Locations of High Commercial Activity

Proposed Location for the Automated Parking Facility

Demand Assessment for Automated Parking Facility at Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), New Delhi : Synopsis

Survey Locations

Demand Assessment for Automated Parking Facility at Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), New Delhi : Synopsis

PARKING ACCUMULATION FOR CARS

Parking Accumulation for Cars for all Locations (Highest & Lowest Values)

Highest

Time Period

Lowest

Time Period

Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), Off-Street Parking

Day 1

296

1400 - 1430

54

1000 -1030
2030 -2100

Day 2

314

1630 - 1700

45

1000 -1030

Day 3

347

1730 - 1800

33

1000 -1030

Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), Area 1

Day 1

295

1830 -1900

97

1000 -1030

Day 2

362

1830 -1900

100

1000 -1030

Day 3

445

1900 -1930

101

1000 -1030

Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), Area 2

Day 1

270

1830 -1900

112

1000 -1030

Day 2

240

1830 -1900

114

1000 -1030

Day 3

220

1430 -1500

113

1000 -1030

Parking Accumulation, Shastri Park (Karol Bagh) for all 3 days

1000

Parking Accumulation

900
800
700
600
500
400
300
200

09:00- 09:30- 10:00- 10:30- 11:00- 11:30- 12:00- 12:30- 13:00- 13:30- 14:00- 14:30- 15:00- 15:30- 16:00- 16:30- 17:00- 17:30- 18:00- 18:30- 19:00- 19:30- 20:00- 20:3009:30 10:00 10:30 11:00

11:30 12:00

12:30 13:00 13:30 14:00 14:30 15:00 15:30 16:00 16:30 17:00 17:30 18:00 18:30 19:00 19:30 20:00 20:30 21:00

Day 1, Friday 24 Aug. 08

209

265

350

514

655

758

771

765

747

751

768

759

745

842

795

774

801

785

740

795

664

599

555

Day 2, Sat urday 25 Aug 08

214

281

395

553

684

755

779

820

828

838

853

858

817

890

852

841

876

876

852

875

802

703

611

564

Day 3, Sunday 26 Aug. 08

214

262

424

586

707

746

781

863

897

914

927

945

876

927

898

897

939

979

976

968

952

819

679

663

Day 1, Friday 24 Aug. 08

Day 2, Saturday 25 Aug 08

477

Day 3, Sunday 26 Aug. 08

Demand Assessment for Automated Parking Facility at Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), New Delhi : Synopsis

PARKING ACCUMULATION FOR TWO-WHEELERS

Parking Accumulation for Two-wheelers at Shastri Park (Karol Bagh)

Highest

Time Period

Lowest

Time Period

Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), Off-Street Parking

Day 1

17

1300- 1330

Day 2

18

1300- 1330

Day 3

15

1300- 1330

1000 -1030

1000 -1030
2030 -2100
1930 -2000
2030 -2100

Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), Area 1

Day 1

154

1700 -1730

57

1000 -1030

Day 2

211

1200 -1230

63

1000 -1030

Day 3

292

1300 -1330

66

1000 -1030

Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), Area 2

Day 1

107

1100 -1130

48

2030 -2100

Day 2

89

1430 -1500

45

2030 -2100

Day 3

85

1430 -1500

32

1000 -1030

Parking Accumulation, Shastri Park (Karol Bagh) for all 3 days

400

Parking Accumulation

360
320
280
240
200
160
120
80

09:00- 09:30- 10:00- 10:30- 11:00- 11:30- 12:00- 12:30- 13:00- 13:30- 14:00- 14:30- 15:00- 15:30- 16:00- 16:30- 17:00- 17:30- 18:00- 18:30- 19:00- 19:30- 20:00- 20:3011:30 12:00

12:30 13:00 13:30 14:00 14:30 15:00 15:30 16:00 16:30 17:00 17:30 18:00 18:30 19:00 19:30 20:00 20:30 21:00

Day 1, Friday 24 Aug. 08

09:30 10:00 10:30 11:00

120

154

180

192

246

254

239

249

233

228

224

212

220

230

233

241

254

237

206

212

198

157

157

Day 2, Sat urday 25 Aug 08

109

139

155

215

261

285

298

304

314

301

267

276

272

292

266

261

264

266

223

248

234

203

195

177

Day 3, Sunday 26 Aug. 08

93

120

157

207

270

310

351

348

383

361

299

328

312

343

287

269

263

307

252

297

283

262

241

236

Day 1, Friday 24 Aug. 08

Day 2, Saturday 25 Aug 08

128

Day 3, Sunday 26 Aug. 08

Demand Assessment for Automated Parking Facility at Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), New Delhi : Synopsis

PARKING DURATION FOR CARS

Parking Duration for Cars for All Locations

ALL LOCATIONS
Day 1

Day 2

Day 3

TOTAL

Cars

% share

Cars

% share

Cars

% share

Cars

% share

< 1 Hr

403

10%

337

8%

373

7%

1113

8%

1 - 2 Hrs

868

21%

1023

23%

1112

21%

3002

22%

2 - 4 Hrs

792

19%

879

20%

1006

19%

2677

19%

4 - 8 Hrs

1402

34%

1380

31%

1454

28%

4235

31%

> 8 Hrs

664

16%

866

19%

1238

24%

2768

20%

Total

4128

100%

4485

100%

5182

100%

13795

100%

Pie-chart for Duration of car parking for all locations

Parking Duration for Cars on Day 1,

Shastri Park (Karol Bagh)
< 1 Hr, 10%
> 8 Hrs, 16%

1 - 2 Hrs, 21%

4 - 8 Hrs, 34%
2 - 4 Hrs, 19%

Demand Assessment for Automated Parking Facility at Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), New Delhi : Synopsis

Parking Duration for Cars on Day 2,

Shastri Park (Karol Bagh)
< 1 Hr, 8%
> 8 Hrs, 19%

1 - 2 Hrs, 23%

4 - 8 Hrs, 31%
2 - 4 Hrs, 20%

Parking Duration for Cars on Day 3,

Shastri Park (Karol Bagh)
< 1 Hr, 7%
> 8 Hrs, 24%
1 - 2 Hrs, 21%

4 - 8 Hrs, 28%

2 - 4 Hrs, 19%

Demand Assessment for Automated Parking Facility at Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), New Delhi : Synopsis

PARKING DURATION FOR TWO-WHEELERS

Parking Duration for Two-wheelers for all Locations

ALL LOCATIONS
Day 1

Day 2

Day 3

TOTAL

2Ws

% share

2Ws

% share

2Ws

% share

2Ws

% share

< 1 Hr

971

41%

678

37%

668

36%

2317

38%

1 - 2 Hrs

919

38%

609

34%

711

38%

2239

37%

2 - 4 Hrs

288

12%

252

14%

264

14%

804

13%

4 - 8 Hrs

183

8%

205

11%

177

10%

565

9%

> 8 Hrs

31

1%

67

4%

39

2%

137

2%

Total

2392

100%

1811

100%

1859

100%

6062

100%

Pie-chart for Duration of Two wheelers for all locations

Parking Duration for Two Wheelers on Day 1,

Shastri Park (Karol Bagh)
4 - 8 Hrs, 8%

> 8 Hrs, 1%

2 - 4 Hrs, 12%

< 1 Hr, 41%

1 - 2 Hrs, 38%

10

Demand Assessment for Automated Parking Facility at Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), New Delhi : Synopsis

Parking Duration for Two Wheelers on Day 2,

Shastri Park (Karol Bagh)
> 8 Hrs, 4%
4 - 8 Hrs, 11%

< 1 Hr, 37%

2 - 4 Hrs, 14%

1 - 2 Hrs, 34%

Parking Duration for Two Wheelers on Day 3,

Shastri Park (Karol Bagh)
4 - 8 Hrs, 10%

2 - 4 Hrs, 14%

> 8 Hrs, 2%

< 1 Hr, 36%

1 - 2 Hrs, 38%

11

Demand Assessment for Automated Parking Facility at Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), New Delhi : Synopsis

PARKING TURNOVER FOR CARS

Turnover on Day 1 (24th Aug., 2007 Friday)

4128

Turnover on Day 2 (25th Aug., 2007 Saturday)

4485

Turnover on Day 3 (26th Aug., 2007 Sunday)

5182

Share of Parking for Cars Average for all three days

Share of Cars Parked at Different Areas

Average of 3 days
OFFSTREET, 9%

AREA 2, 41%

AREA 1, 50%

12

Demand Assessment for Automated Parking Facility at Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), New Delhi : Synopsis

PARKING TURNOVER FOR 2-WHEELERS

Turnover on Day 1 (24th Aug., 2007 Friday)

2392

Turnover on Day 2 (25th Aug., 2007 Saturday)

1811

Turnover on Day 3 (26th Aug., 2007 Sunday)

1859

Share of Parking for Two-wheelers at Shastri Park: average for all three days

Share of 2Ws Parked at Different Areas

Average of 3 days

OFFSTREET, 1%

AREA 2, 47%

AREA 1, 51%

13

Demand Assessment for Automated Parking Facility at Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), New Delhi : Synopsis

WILLINGNESS TO PAY FOR CARS & TWO-WHEELERS

Willingness to pay for Car Parkers (Traders Response)

Willingness to Pay (Cars)

Traders' Response

100%
80%
Maybe

60%

No

40%

Yes

20%
0%
Day 1

Day 2

Day 2

Willingness to pay for Car Parkers (Visitors Response)

Willingness to Pay (Cars)

Visitors' Response

100%
80%
Maybe

60%

No

40%

Yes

20%
0%
Day 1

Day 2

Day 2

14

Demand Assessment for Automated Parking Facility at Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), New Delhi : Synopsis

Willingness to Pay for 2-wheelers Users (Traders Response)

Willingness to Pay (2W)

Traders' Response

100%
80%
Maybe

60%

No

40%

Yes

20%
0%
Day 1

Day 2

Day 2

Willingness to Pay for 2-wheelers Users (Visitors Response)

Willingness to Pay (2W)

Visitors' Response

100%
80%
Maybe

60%

No

40%

Yes

20%
0%
Day 1

Day 2

Day 2

15

Demand Assessment for Automated Parking Facility at Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), New Delhi : Synopsis

ARRIVAL RATE OF CARS

Arrival of Cars in 30 min Interval

Day 1

Day 2

Day 3

Maximum

254

278

335

Minimum

59

71

60

Average

172

187

216

Day 1

Day 2

Day 3

Maximum

11

12

17

Minimum

Average

11

Arrival of Cars for First 2 min of every Interval

Arrival Rate of Cars on Day 1, 2 & 3

(For First two minutes of every half hour interval)
18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0

09:00- 09:30- 10:00- 10:30- 11:00- 11:30- 12:00- 12:30- 13:00- 13:30- 14:00- 14:30- 15:00- 15:30- 16:00- 16:30- 17:00- 17:30- 18:00- 18:30- 19:00- 19:30- 20:00- 20:3009:30 10:00 10:30 11:00

11:30 12:00

12:30 13:00 13:30 14:00 14:30 15:00 15:30 16:00 16:30 17:00 17:30 18:00 18:30 19:00 19:30 20:00 20:30 21:00

Day 1

10

11

10

10

10

Day 2

10

10

10

12

11

10

10

Day 3

11

14

10

11

13

12

11

13

16

10

10

17

13

12

10

16

16

Demand Assessment for Automated Parking Facility at Shastri Park (Karol Bagh), New Delhi : Synopsis

ARRIVAL RATE OF TWO-WHEELERS

Arrival of Two-wheelers in 30 min Interval

Day 1

Day 2

Day 3

Maximum

191

127

126

Minimum

34

29

28

Average

100

75

77

Day 1

Day 2

Day 3

Maximum

Minimum

Average

Arrival of 2W for First 2 min of every Interval

Arrival Rate of 2Ws on Day 1, 2 & 3

(For First two minutes of every half hour interval)
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0

09:00- 09:30- 10:00- 10:30- 11:00- 11:30- 12:00- 12:30- 13:00- 13:30- 14:00- 14:30- 15:00- 15:30- 16:00- 16:30- 17:00- 17:30- 18:00- 18:30- 19:00- 19:30- 20:00- 20:3009:30 10:00 10:30 11:00

11:30 12:00

12:30 13:00 13:30 14:00 14:30 15:00 15:30 16:00 16:30 17:00 17:30 18:00 18:30 19:00 19:30 20:00 20:30 21:00

Day 1

Day 2

Day 3

17