Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Queer Grits
IN THIS ISSUE
Issue 2012-02
Our Government did not choose to free speech; it chose to free hate. We will fight to ensure adequate protections from hate. True justice demands it. page 2 Will you join us? Hate propoganda represents a serious threat to society. It undermines the dignity and self-worth of target group members and more generally, contributes to disharmonious relations among various racial, cultural and religious groups, as a result eroding the tolerance and open-mindedness that must flourish in a multicultural society which is committed to the idea of equality. Supreme Court of Canada, in Canada (Human Rights Commission) v Taylor
Tri Pride
page 1
On Wednesday, June 6th, the dream of a Just Society in Canada grew dimmer still with the passage in the House of Commons of Bill c-304, an act repealing Section 13, among others, of the Canadian Human Rights Act (CHRA). Introduced in Parliament in October 2011 as a private members bill by Conservative MP Brian Storseth, Bill c-304 - An Act to amend the Canadian Human Rights Act - vaingloriously nicknamed Protecting Freedom, will limit prosecutions of hate speech in Canada by forcing victims to seek recourse under the Criminal Code. The Criminal Code is not well equipped to deal with matters of hate speech. Sections 318 to 320 of the code which relate to hate speech effectively limit corrective action to inciting hatred towards specified protected groups. Such narrow definitions ensure that very few prosecutions will occur and hate speech in Canada will be unfettered unless it specifically calls for violence against minorities. Furthermore, discrimination stemming from opinions based on a religious text is considered a legitimate defense under Section 320 of the Code. Prosecutions are also subject to Attorney General approval, further limiting victims recourse to justice through the Code and politicizing the social-conservative disdain for the protection of minority rights. Section 13 of the Canadian Human Rights Act provides an alternative to the overburdened justice system and the strict definitions of hate speech laws under the Criminal Code. Empowered to investigate claims of discrimination under the Act, the Canadian Human Rights Commission (CHRC) bases itself on principles of conciliation and mediation. The CHRC presents an avenue through which targets of online hate can seek redress. Investigations made by the CHRC allow for both claimants and respondents to present evidence and provide responses to claims made. Once an investigation is complete, the CHRC makes a recommendation to the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal (CHRT) on whether the case should be considered. The Canadian Human Rights Tribunal (CHRT) is an adjudicative body which considers cases recommended by the CHRC, including Section 13 cases. It conducts hearings and makes a decision based on the application of the law following the impartial examination of the evidence presented by the complainant and the respondent. The CHRC and CRHT, have been maligned by misconceptions and false truths put out by their detractors. These quasi-judicial bodies, like so many others operating in Canada and the provinces, allow for a more efficient, expeditious and accessible form of justice to take place, adjudicated by experts in the field. To suggest that they are all-powerful and unaccountable bodies is unreflective of reality. CRHT decisions are reviewable by the Federal Court, the Federal Court of Appeal, and ultimately, by the Supreme Court of Canada. Bill c-304 opens the door for hate of all kind to be spread online with impunity. Although imperfect in its application, Section 13 offered a means of settling manners in a generally conciliatory fashion and empowered the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal to issue cease and desist orders to posters of online hate. Most importantly, Section 13 sent a clear message that hatred is not to be tolerated in a diverse and multicultural Canada. The Supreme Court of Canada has affirmed that freedom of speech is not without its limits; there may be, to paraphrase the Constitution, reasonable limitations to any right in Canada given a sound justification for doing so in a free and democratic society. Stamping out hate and protecting the integrity of Canadian society from the divisive language of anti-Semites, racists, sexists, homophobes and other peddlers of hate is a sound enough justification for restricting free speech. Conservatives chose to side with the freedoms of expression for hate mongers over the freedoms of upstanding Canadian minorities. This week, our Government did not choose to free speech; it chose to free hate. Unless we work to reverse this, we as a society will suffer for it. The time has come to stand up and defend the integrity of Canadian society. We will fight to ensure adequate protections from hate. True justice demands it. Will you join us? Email: queerliberals@gmail.com to get involved
page 2
To VOLUNTEER during the Community Fair on Saturday and Sunday, or to PARTICIPATE in any of the above, please email us.
Brad Rubinoff and other Liberals wearing Liberal and Pride colours at the LPO Booth, Above-right: QL Co-Presidents Brad and Penny with fellow Liberal Pride revelers at Tri Pride
Pictured here at Me & Suzies patio in Port Stanley are (left to right) Richard Francella, Jessica Stark, Peter Maloney (hidden-sorry Peter well do better next time) Kimberley Love, Cole Davidson, Frank Find us on facebook! Tersigni, Sam Miceli. We are thrilled for the new Queer Liberals Share your wealth with QL by donating at: chapter to be up and running and look forward to continuing to queerliberals.nationbuilder.com/donation work together. Congratulations! Follow us on twitter: queerliberals
page 3
page 4
page 5
Quick Facts:
The Canadian Human Rights Act was passed in 1977, under the Liberal Government of Pierre Elliott Trudeau, with the express objective of ensuring equal opportunity unhindered by discrimintory practices.
QL in the news:
On June 1st, political affairs commentator Zach Paikin had this to say about Queer Liberals on the well-known news and blog site, www.ipolitics.ca:
The Queer Liberals (QL) are on a mission to demonstrate that it is the Liberal Party that has done and will do the most for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Queer (LGBTQ) Canadians. More importantly, they are on a mission to make the party fun again. From fun trivia and In 1996, the Liberal Government of pub nights to events celebrating the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, QL has been more consistently active than most riding associations. Best of Jean Chrtien amended the Act to include sexual orientation as an enumer- all, its founders and most-involved members all emanate from the partys grassroots. ated ground of discrimination. Then, in 2001 the prohibition to communicate hate over the internet was added, also under the Liberal Government of Jean Chrtien. Now, in 2012, in the age of social me dia, and thanks to the Conservative Government of Stephen Harper, hate can once again be communicated over the internet. Why, thank you for noticing Zach. We certainly do try to keep it fun.
Be it resolved:
that the Liberal Party be made accessible to all. Good designers would likely agree that form should not be an obstacle to function. Therefore, let our form be clear and accessible so that we are all, regardless of our present preparation, circumstance or aptitude, free to function effectively within and move forward with, the Party. Thats the essence of a resolution proposed by Queer Liberals, and passed at the LPC(O) AGM. The LPC (O) has the stated goals of attracting new members and of encouraging the participation of non-members using the new Supporter Category. To facilitate this, the motion asked that the LPC (O) Executive Board commit to achieving those goals by ensuring that the structure, organization, make-up, and Constitution of the LPC (O) be made clear and accessible to all LPC (O) members, regardless of Party experience, age, level of education, technological ability, official language of choice or region of residence. The Executive Board, according to the resolution, shall be charged with delegating an authority to oversee the process of clarifying and making accessible the aforementioned aspects of the party. Furthermore, it is also to ensure that the roles and responsibilities of elected officials of the LPC (O) are publicly available. It certainly likely that those who understand the Partys workings will be more likely to support it, work with it, and join it, and that those who join it, will find space to grow within it. ((QL)) Thank you to Maryanne Kampouris, an advocate of ours, who spoke in support of the motion.
Past Rebuilding
event at YMCA on May 27th: Two themes of the day which resonated with Queer Liberal Co-Presidents Penny and Brad were that the party needs to engage with youth, and excel at issuesbased engagement. The Liberal Party has always succeeded when it focused on advancing clear, progressive policies that responded to issues of the time. Youth are often at the forefront of these issues. Queer Liberals have been tirelessly working on progressive responses to issues of the day and creatively re-engaging the LGBT community. When it comes to rebuilding were on it!
page 6
QL Director of Communications, Corey Turnbull, David Bertschi, QL Co-President Brad Lister, QL Director of Operations and Toronto Region Director Area 1 Kelly Foote, and Richard Francella at the QL pub at Quinns on the LPC (O) AGM
Back, left to right, Kelly Foote, VP Policy for Trinity Spadina Ryan Davey, Corey Turnbull, Front, Brandon Sage and Brad Lister at the QL pub Quinns on the LPC (O) AGM weekend
Follow us on twitter: queerliberals Find us on facebook! Share your wealth with QL by donating at: queerliberals.nationbuilder.com/donation
page 7
page 8