Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
------------------------------x
HEARING
Rockville, Maryland
DEPOSITION SERVICES, INC., 12321 Middlebrook Road, Suite 210 Germantown, Maryland 20874 (301) 881-3344
) ""') i~]
------------------------------x
BRETT KIMBERLIN, Plaintiff,
v.
AARON JUSTIN WALKER, Defendant.
------------------------------x
WHEREUPON, the proceedings in the above-entitled matter commenced BEFORE: THE HONORABLE CORNELIUS J. VAUGHEY, JUDGE
I
Bethesda, Maryland FOR THE RESPONDENT:
I
20817
I N D E X
WITNESSES For the Petitioner: Br'ett Kimberlin For the Respondent: Aaron Justin Walker
DIRECT
CROSS
REDIRECT
RECROSS
21
40
kc 1 2 3
4
PRO C E E DIN G 8 THE COURT: Case No 01979, and it's Br'ett Kimberlin
versus Aaron Justin Walker. MR. WALKER: Your' Honor, before we begin, I have a
5 6
7
8
disposi tive motion I'd like to present, a motion to dismiss, and it's a memorandum of law and the facts-THE COURT: MR . WALKER: MR. KIMBERLIN: THE COURT: Certainly . so far in this case. I object . It's a motion to dismiss. That comes first.
9 10 11
12
13
I've got to listen to, hear what he says. Go ahead, s i r MR. WALKER: very long. Don't worry..
14
15 16 17
18
sign this for your benefit, Your Honor.. This is the actual motion to dismiss. including some on disk, even includes
(unintelligible)
alleged
19 20
21
videos to show that they were not threats . THE COURT: MR. WALKER:
80 what's your motion?
Mr..
22 23 24
Kimberlin has, he has petitioned for a peace order, contains numerous flaws in it.. claim -THE COURT: That's a fact I don't want to hear The one thing he continually tries to
25
kc 1 2 3 4
5
the face of it that it is, that he is making assertions that it is harassment to speak badly about him on the Internet, (Unintelligible) that is har'assment, In Galloway v. State,
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13
they made it absolutely clear that pure expression, unless it is a threat, unless it is somehow directed contact, such as an
e-mail.aletter.oraphonecall.anyofthosethings.itis just pure expression, THE COURT: until I hear from him? MR face, WALKER: Well, I think it's pretty obvious on the it's not harassment" How do I know it's not pure expression
14 15
16
17
it is obvious on the face, THE COURT: We'll proceed to trial MR" WALKER: Okay" All right, sir, Thank you, Your Honor, I' m going to deny your mot.ion, counsel,
18 19
20
KIMBERLIN:
THE COURT:
All those who are going to testify, raise Other right hand There you go,
21 22 23 24 25
BRETT KIMBERLIN the petitioner, having been fir'St duly sworn, was examined and testified as follows: DIRECT EXAMINATION
kc 1 2
3
A
Q
He's the man that's been stalking me for' a long time, Where does he live? In Manassas, Virginia. His name is -- okay" What's your, how do you know
A
Q
4 5
6
him?
A
7 8
9
showed up in a court case that I had in front of the Circuit Court, and -Q
10
11
life A
Q
Never"
12
13
- - and then
Never,
- -
- -
A
Q
14 15 16
17
all of a sudden
- -
A
Q
Never " - - this started happening? Yes, Okay, So you never met., and then you met him when? He
A
Q
18 19 20 21 22
23
showed up in - Q
A
What year? This year" Okay, And he showed up where? Judge Rupp,
Q
A
24 25
kc 1 2 3 4 5 6
7
What kind of a hearing was this? It was a contempt hearing on a -MR . WALKER: Your Honor, we could get this along a
lot faster if we confined his testimony, this discussion of what supposed harassment I've committed to the last 30 days before he filed his petition. THE COURT: MR . WALKER: THE COURT: Okay.. -- so -- overrule you now, because I'm just He filed this on May 19th -Yes, but I'm going to --
8 9 10
11
12
13
trying to get some background MR. WALKER: THE COURT: MR . WALKER: THE COURT: THE WITNESS: BY THE COURT:
Q
14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
Yes . - - so I understand what's going on here . All right, Your Honor Okay So he was --
It was a contempt? Yeah, but -You were being, you were the defendant? No, I was the plaintiff in the case, and All right.. So contempt -- just a second .
Q
A
Q
kc 1
2
3 4
5
because he -Q
And it was, who were you trying to hold in contempt? There was a man! this man's a lawyer - I won't hold that against him. I know. Okay. Go ahead .
A
Q
A
Q
7
8 9
man that I was, had been stalking me, and the Judge Jordan had issued a judgment against this man for -Q
10
Just one
11
12
13
second..
A
Q
Now, tell me what's happened in the last 30 days. Okay. Well, I just want to get to one little part of He followed me out of the courtroom
14
15 16
17
and he assaulted me right there -MR. WALKER: THE COURT: that. THE WITNESS: BY THE COURT:
Q
A
18
19
20 21
I understand
I understand.
22
23 24
I want to know what happened in the last 30 days . The only thing, it's relevant is because No, wait a second. I just said in the last 30 days .
25
Don't --
kc 1 2 3
4
10 A
Q
Yes .
- -
Don't change what I ask you, sir. In the last 30 days Okay Go ahead, give me the last 30 days .
A
Q
5
6
7
A
Q
In the last Give me the date In the last 30 days, after April 28th or 27th - April 28th, what happened?
- -
A
Q
8 9 10
11
Framed? That I framed him for this assault, and that I -Framed for, and --- forged the documents from Suburban Hospital, and
12
13
Q
A
14
15
16
Let me see
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24
that there?
A
Absolutely..
Oh, this is, now, wait a second, this is Well, I'm just saying, he said that I framed him for
25
11
2
3
4
MR . WALKER: (unintelligible) THE COURT: MR . WALKER: THE COURT: THE WITNESS: MR . WALKER: THE WITNESS:
Yes
Hang on, sport . Yes, sir. Sit down . Okay . Yes, sir.
5
6
7
8 9
We had a case in front of Judge Eric Judge Johnson said, That occurred.. "An assault
10 11 12
Johnson in the Circuit Court.. did occur. you . " Judge BY THE COURT:
Q
He assaulted you..
He assaulted
13
14
Okay .
15
happened.. A
Q
Let's see what he raises . Okay . And I ' l l come back to you . Okay . Otherwise, you'll bring in the moon -Okay . -- and you'll bring in the Right . Okay. I'm just -You see? And I don't
16 17 18
19 20
A
Q
A
Q
21
22
23
24
A
Q
want that .
A
25
All right .
kc
1
Q
12 I just want, and let him bring it in, and then we'll
2
3
4
5
Okay. Because you guys seem like you're going throw kumquat
And I
6 7
8
don't, I'm too old, I'm going on my 34th year on the bench, so I can handle this .
A
Q
Okay . Okay? So just give me the facts, and I'll cut right
10 11 12
13
through it .
A
All right..
Frame job, okay . I framed -On an assault charge? On an assaul t charge.. And he went on the Internet,
14 15 16 17
18
Q
A
and he started Tweeting thousands, over 14,000 Tweets had been made on Twitter, saying that I framed him for this -Q
19
A
Q
20 21 22 23 24 25 on in
14,000 contacts he made with this? 14,000 MR.. WALKER: THE WITNESS: Your Honor, no -14,000, I mean, they go on and on and
BY THE COURT:
kc
1
2
13
Q
A
Is it the same message? These are saying that he framed me, and he wants
3
4
to
Q
A
No, I don't, I can't follow you, okay? He framed -I'm back in the Royal typewriter age, okay? Okay . I'm sorry.
5
6
Q
A
7 8
9
Q
A
So just come on slowly. Okay . He got on the thing and he did a little Twit there to
10 11 12
13
A
Q
No.
- -
Oh, okay, that's a whole - Or had It's a whole different Or had others Tweet 14,000 times/ saying that I
14 15, 16
17
A
Q
A framed him
Q
18 19 20' 21 22 23 24 25
So the
14,000
A
Q
A
Q
A
Q
kc 1 2
3
14 A And, oh, thousands, thousands, definitely thousands. MR.. WALKER: THE COURT: THE WITNESS: Mr.. Walker himself. BY THE COURT:
Q
Your Honor', not wi thin the last 30 days . Hang on. I'll--
4 5 6 7
8 9
A
Q
10
11
it also A
Q
No, this is all -then you're going to -within the last have to prove a relationship there.. This is all within the last 30 days. There's how many -This is last, this is last week on a single day . Okay? That, and most of What --
12
13
A
Q
14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
A
Q
How do you get this? How do I get it? I'm the director of several non-
We work with, on Human Rights issues and And so it's part of my job
kc 1 2
3
15 mentioning my organizations, my name, what work we do. these Google alerts come -Q
And
And you can just go ahead into what he does? Excuse me? You can go into his private -No, this is Twitter, this is public . Oh, it's public stuff? Yes.. Okay.. He's So okay He's Tweeting this about me . So he did 54 pages, and how many on a page roughly? Well, this is 54 pages of his, and then this was just This is all public . All right .
4 5 6
7
A
Q
A
Q
8 9 10 11 12
13
A
Q
A
Q
A
Q
14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23
A a -Q
No, I just want to know how many on a page? Oh, it's probably 10 . Six or eight? Probably at least 10. 10, so okay, all right, that's 500 and MR . WALKER:
- -
A
Q
A
Q
Your Honor. THE COURT: Sure, okay, I'll give you a minute, sir
24 25
Q
kc
1 A
Q
16
And here' s his post Different Tweets? Here' s his post . "Brett Kimberlin tried to And he wrote this
2
3
4 5 6
7
8 9
3 0 -page document that he put on his blog, saying I framed him for an assault.
Q
People honestly read this stuff? I guess so.. MR . WALKER: THE WITNESS: MR . WALKER: THE COURT: And I'm going to object at this point -And--- if I can. Hold on, hold on.. You could have this
10
11
12
13
14 15
16
54 pages?
17
18 19
A
Q
20
21
What the heck's going on out there in this world? So not, so on last week, he got all these bloggers
22 23 24 25
allover the country to create "Let's blog about Brett Kimberlin day," over 350 blogs blogged that I framed him.. And
that led to a number of, probably scores of death threats to me. They threatened my daughter, who's a preteen; my mother,
kc
1 2 3 4 5
6
17
they had called on the phone and threatened SWAT teams . MR. WALKER: Your Honor, I would 1 ike to obj ect here
He is characterizing the statements of third parties who -THE COURT: MR WALKER: You got any clients? At the moment, sir, I have been
unemployed because of THE COURT: MR . WALKER: THE COURT: THE WITNESS: THE COURT: crazy . THE WITNESS: into the record, please? BY THE COURT:
Q
7 8 9 10 11 12
13
Yes, I'm going to say that --- Mr.. Kimberlin's conduct . -- reading something like -And can I --- that's going to sound like that's
14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
Q
And if they come from him? Yeah, well, the first one says MR . WALKER: THE WITNESS: BY THE COURT: One from who? "Message from Aaron" MR WALKER: Message from Aaron? Yes, "Message from Aaron . " No . - - "Message from Aaron. "
kc 1 2 3 4 5
6
7
A e-mail .
8 9 10
11
Okay.
Wait.
12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
Well, right it could have been my grandchild. It could have been, except out of these thousands and
Attack your what? My funders, foundations MR WALKER: And, Your Honoy/ I would object Okay . Wait
- -
to that characterization. No, hang on a second . I would like him to show where I told
kc
1
19
THE COURT: THE WITNESS: THE COURT: MR. WALKER: THE COURT: MR . WALKER:
2
3
Sport, where'd you go to law school? Yale Law School . What'd they tell you about the judge? Well, not to upset him if that's what
4
5
7
8
you're trying to get at . THE COURT: And no, I'm not saying, I said, you don't
9
10
11
interrupt when I'm running something. MR . WALKER: THE COURT: MR . WALKER: THE COURT: My apologies, sir. So just have yourself a seat, sir . All right, sir. Because if you keep it up, I got a spot
12
13
14
15
for you in the courthouse . MR WALKER: All right . "Don't show up in court Tuesday or "This is your only
16
17
18
19 20
Well, who wrote that? No, wait a, hang on, you, calm down, son. Well, but WelL hang on. Yes. Just hang on. Grab a pencil or so there,
21
22
23
24
25
THE COURT:
kc 1 2 3
4
20 Just relax. We'll get this thing through.. And if you got to
5
6
I've read the file Okay.. No threats . "We know who you are, we' r'e He had said many times on
9 10
11
"Make Brett Kimberlin pay for framing me . " MR.. WALKER: THE WITNESS: Your Honor, I obj ect again. "Brett Kimberlin is done.. The hunter
12
13
is hunted
14 15 16
17
quit calling the police" - - I had to call the police last night, on a 911 call because I had some nut - BY THE COURT:
Q
Okay .
- -
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
A
Q
A
Q
A
Q
That's enough .
You've got the picture? THE COURT: You can ask him some questions. Go
kc
1
21
2
3
4
5
Okay..
Mr., Kimberlin, are you an honest person? I'll sustain that objection,
6
7
THE COURT:
BY MR, WALKER:
Q
8
9
10
11
Q
BY MR" WALKER: convicted of perjury, sir? THE COURT: proof? MR" WALKER: Honor THE COURT: MR WALKER: He's convicted of it? Convicted, Perjury? Convicted of perjury Convicted of perjury? Absolutely, sir Go ahead and ask it Judge, I was convicted when I was 18 or I can show you the court cases, Your' I'll sustain that" Go ahead., You got
12
13
14
15
16 17
18 19
20
THE COURT: MR, WALKER: THE COURT: MR" WALKER: THE COURT: THE WITNESS:
21 22
23
24
25
19 years old in a grand jury in -THE COURT: Grand juries don't convict,
kc
1
22
THE WITNESS: THE COURT: THE WITNESS: THE COURT: convict, THE WITNESS: uh-huh, THE COURT: Okay . Yeah, but it was 40 years ago roughly, -- so it was like 34 Petit juries convict . -- 40 years ago, something like that. Grand juries charge, petit juries
2
3 4
5
6 7 8 9
BY MR. WALKER:
Q
A
10
11
Wasn't it more like 34 years ago? No, it was, THE COURT: BY MR it was when I was 18 or 19 years old . Okay All right"
12
13
WALKER:
14 15
16
Q
A
Well, how old are you, sir? I'm 57, Okay., So 57 minus 18 is more like -- let's see Let me ask you another
17 18 19
20 21
bombs in Speedway,
A
22
23
24
No.,
No, no,
25
THE COURT:
kc
1 2
Yes,
I was,
3
4
5
6
7 8
not?
A
Q
I don't know that . You don't know if you were known -No . -- as the Speedway Bomber? You did not know that
10
11
12
13
I've read a lot of things in my life. Well, if you had a case called Kimberlin v. White,
14
15
16
17 18 19
20
decision involving your self, and you're claiming you did not read this case?
A
Q
No, never read it . So you were actually, this is you on the docket -MR . WALKER: And, Your Honor, I'd like to show you
21 22 23 24 25 this case
kc
1 2
24 THE WITNESS: THE COURT: THE WITNESS: THE COURT: MR.. WALKER: THE COURT: MR. WALKER: THE COURT: MR . WALKER: to -THE COURT: from. Okay.. Let me just take a look, see where it's That's literally from 30 years ago . But it goes to credibility, sir. Okay . I have to allow that. I think, can I approach or -(Unintelligible) All right Well, I'm honestly unsure
3
4
5
6
7
8 9
10
11
12 13 14 15
16
17
And all this occurred at how old, sir? Excuse me? How old were you when this occurred? 20-something. Go ahead, sir . And I did my time, and I got out, and
THE WITNESS: THE COURT: THE WITNESS: THE COURT: THE WITNESS:
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
I'm no longer subject to any of the conditions of that case. It's been resolved. BY MR. WALKER:
Q
When were you released? More than a decade ago. THE COURT: Okay. And that was in Texas? Texas?
kc 1 2
3
25 THE WITNESS: Your Honor. THE COURT: final, sir? MR . WALKER: Well, I have a lot more, Your Honor . All right Okay.. Go ahead.. Anything Well, it was, it was a federal case,
4
5
6
BY MR.. WALKER:
Q
Now,
8
9
Again, Okay..
that was more than a decade ago . (unintelligible) was that you had a
10 11 12
13
judgment against you involving the death, the suicide death of Carl DeLong,
A
Judge,
14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23
not
Q
lI
II
no II question"
It's not about the judgment -THE COURT: THE WITNESS: It was reversed? It's been nullified . I don't know what
But it wasn't nullified THE COURT: Well, I don't know what that --
BY MR.. WALKER:
Q
24 25
parole,
kc 1 2
3
4
5
26
A
In the parole case. THE COURT: THE WITNESS: Okay, He was indicted and sent to jail for 18
6
7
8
years, and -THE COURT: THE WITNESS: THE COURT: THE WITNESS: case That case -THE COURT: THE WITNESS: But what did that do in your case? Well, that case has been resolved, and Well, that's very good Yeah., I think that's wonderful" So that, that's what happened in that
10
11
12
13
14
15 16 17
that case is no longer, I have a THE COURT: THE WITNESS: THE COURT: conviction? THE WITNESS: "satisfied" It was considered, quote, considered Resolved, I have How did it terminate? With a reversal of How
18
19
20
21
I guess that's what they call it, I've never heard of that in a criminal
22
23
24
I know -- but imagine (unintelligible) It's not a criminal case, it's a civil
25
kc
1
27 case . THE COURT: THE WITNESS: the, where I was found MR . WALKER: THE WITNESS: Your Honor, if I can help maybe -Like I said, the judge solicited a A Parole Board thing? No, no, no, that was a civil case where
2
3
4
5
6
7 8
9
bribe, he went to jail 18 years, extortion, bribery, all a fact hearing . THE COURT: though. THE WITNESS: case . THE COURT: underlying facts
- -
10
11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
THE WITNESS: THE COURT: THE WITNESS: THE COURT: bribe . THE WITNESS: THE COURT: THE WITNESS: THE COURT: THE WITNESS: THE COURT:
- -
No, but the facts - of the case (unintell igible) But the facts - - it just means the judge solicited a
No. Dirty judge . A dirty judge . Strike (unintelligible) No, but I'm just saying But it doesn't change the facts of your
kc
1
28
case . THE WITNESS: THE COURT: THE WITNESS: The facts -How was that case resolved? The facts of that case are that it,
2
3
4
5 6
7
that judgment was not valid, it's not valid at this time, it's not enforceable, it's gone. THE COURT: ahead . MR.. WALKER: Okay Okay Ask him some more questions. Go
8 9
10
11
BY MR.. WALKER:
Q
12
13
wasn't it?
A
I don't know . You don't know whether it was valid and enforceable? I was st ill litigating it at that time . Okay.. Well, the fact is that the Parole Commission
14 15 16
Q
A
17 18 19 20 21
22
I don't know what they found Well, they made it a condition of your parole that
They did. And they found that -- and this is a quote from
23 24 25
decision - - "The examiner found that the petitioner used deceitful maneuvers to hide his ability to pay, and that his relatives and friends were obviously acting to help him by
kc
1
29
filing claims and liens to protect his money and property fr'om being available to satisfy the victim's judgment . " result, And as a
2 3 4
5
they took you into custody at the end of that hearing, sir?
didn't they,
A
Q
I don't know what hearing you're discussing, but -The parole revocation hearing But that, you know, again, that was over 10 years
8
9
ago, and
Q
Well, I would like an answer to that question, THE COURT: Okay.. Now, wai t a second
sir.
10 11
12 13
We're not
trying that . THE WITNESS: THE COURT: Yeah. This is only going to his credibility .
I
14 15 16 17
18
think we've gone into that one case enough MR. WALKER: Okay.
Go to some others .
That's okay .
19 20
21
I don't need all the details. That's all right, Your Honor.
BY MR. WALKER:
Q
22 23 24 25
also because what happened at the last bombing that you committed and you were convicted of, a man named Carl DeLong found a gym bag unattended --
kc
1
2
30
3 4
5
I've read it
sir .
BY MR.. WALKER:
Q
is that
8
9
correct? THE COURT: MR . WALKER: THE COURT: MR . WALKER: THE COURT: protection,
Sir
10
11
All right, sir . I'm worried about this peace order. Well, that's okay .
12
13
14 15 16
17
so go ahead Well, Sure . - - a true violent tendency toward him Now, let's see here I understand. Obviously, even --
18 19 20
21
would arise, would justify a peace order I apologize, Your Honor . BY MR. WALKER:
Q
Okay.
is that
22 23 24 25
correct? order?
A
kc
1
A
31
2
3
Q
A
It was when THE COURT: THE WITNESS: January the 9th . No, It was when Judge Rupp, I mean,
4
5
6
7
8 9
So that would be April 11th, isn't that correct? April 11th, That's right, uh-huh The
10
11
12
13
Under Galloway, I've asked you over and over No, no, no, Galloway is not a stalking case, it is I know -- a harassment case And I filed for harassment, I've asked you to
14 15 16 17
Q
A
18 19
20
21
leave -Q
But we're talking about stalking right now., I've asked you to leave me alone" I've written to I've had peace
22
23 24
will you answer' the question, sir? THE WITNESS: That's the thing, Over and over and
25
over'
kc 1 2 3 4 5 6
7
wants to destroy my non-profits, he wants to destroy my work with senators and congressmen.. He has people calling the State
Department right now, all weekend long, because I had a group of Muslims come over from the Middle East to study social networking at my non-profit last week And we posted this on
our site, you know, as a nice thing that we do, and he's out there threatening the State Department.. BY MR.. WALKER: Q The Department THE COURT: Okay.. Well-He's telling people
8 9 10
11
12
13
BY MR.. WALKER: Q What did I THE COURT: (unintelligible) the Department of? All right Go ahead.. Ask another - - now
14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
Q
wait, and let's not get into this tit for tat, okay. MR WALKER: No. Ask him another question Well, he did not answer the question I
BY MR. WALKER: How on earth did I stalk you within the last 30 days? Because you've got, you've ginned up thousands Did I follow you in any public place? You have ginned up thousands of people to come to my
A
Q
kc
1
2 3 4 5
6 7
to send me death threats, to call me and my mother on the phone-BY MR. WALKER:
Q
A
With what words did I say that? -- and say, you know, we've got a, we've got SWAT
8
9
teams out here that are going to put, blow your brains out . THE COURT: Okay.. Hang on a second.. Now, this is
10
11
not a valid question that. THE WITNESS: THE COURT: THE WITNESS: THE COURT: THE WITNESS: don't know I know . Why do you think he's doing this? Why do I what? Why's he doing it? I think he's obsessed. I think he's, I
12
13
14
15 16 17
18
somebody in a week -THE COURT: THE WITNESS: THE COURT: THE WITNESS: I'll answer your question.. called, Okay. Okay.. Now, just, okay, that's fine .
19
20 21
All right..
22 23
24
"Everyone Draw Muhammad." THE COURT: THE WITNESS: What? He's a publisher of a blog called,
25
kc 1
2
3
34
There is --
4 5 6 7
8
Muhammad on that blog in very insulting and vile depictions He's asking people to defile and defame the Prophet Muhammad, And-BY MR" WALKER:
Q
9 10 11
12
him?
A
He asked me a question, THE COURT: THE WITNESS: Hang on a second, Okay" As part of my work on human
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20
rights and supporting Muslim artists and activists overseas, I thought that this was wrong, The State Department has said The Government of Pakistan
that it's wrong for him to do this, has banned his blog,
Osama Bin Laden used his blog to recruit I felt this was wrong, And
so I filed a motion in this case, in front of Judge Jordan, on this contempt THE COURT: THE WITNESS: THE COURT: THE WITNESS: help Muslims
- -
Okay.,
21 22
23 24 25
THE COURT:
Okay.,
kc
1
35
THE WITNESS: THE COURT: THE WITNESS: THE COURT: THE WITNESS: THE COURT: ahead, sir" MR WALKER:
2
3
4
And he's --
5
6
He's got this hate blog out there, Okay" We'll get into i t All right " Go
7 8 9
Okay"
statute on stalking, and I'd like him to explain how exactly THE COURT: MR WALKER: No, you don't have to show it to him, Okay" I'm the authority" Huh? Well, I'd like I'll make the
10
11
12
13
THE COURT: MR., WALKER: THE COURT: decision, MR, WALKER: Moving on.,
14
15
16
Yes, okay, all right, Your Honor, I apologize, Your Honor, here"
17
18 19 20 21
BY MR" WALKER:
Q
22
23 24 25
No, you've filed criminal charges against me twice, I just asked one, a simple "yes" or "no" question., He's filed criminal charges against me twice, Judge,
kc
1
Okay..
3 4 5 6 7 8
9
didn't Judge Johnson instruct you specifically that he could not stop me or anybody else from discussing accurately your long and deplorable criminal record? you? A That's not what you're doing. You are harassing me, Did he not say that to
(unintelligible)
What specifically am I doing to harass you? You are ginning up people to send me death threats,
10
11
A and that
Q
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19
when you say that I've falsified records from Suburban Hospital, that I forged these documents from Suburban Hospital, and photo-shopped pictures of me with a black eye, and you're ginning up people to come after me.. works You know how the Internet A new
20 21 22 23 24 25
guy whistles at the Black girl and gets a lynch mob after him. That's what you're doing . me, and harm my family, funders, You're creating a lynch mob to harm
work with .
Q
therefore, anybody
kc
1
37
saying anything bad about you on the Internet, including t:ruthfully discussing your criminal :r'eco:rd, is the:refore inciting people to imminent lawless behavio:r, is that correct?
A
3
4
5
6
7
Galloway, there was 133 letters sent to the victim in that case" I've had 15,000 Tweets I've had sco:res of death
8 9 10
11
threats and calls to my mothe:r and my daughte:r, and my, and they're friending my daughte:r on Facebook, and trying to th:reaten he:r on Facebook,
Q
12
13
14 15
16
17 18 19
He
won't stop,
It's obsessive,
I have a right
to be a father,
Q
20 21 22 23 24 25
sir
Excuse me,
I have the Just answer the question" Okay, I'm getting ready, Finish up, finish up, Don't a:rgue
kc 1 2
3
38
4
5
Everyone Blog Brett, About Brett Kimberlin Day? THE WITNESS: Judge, he wrote on this thing, "How
6 7 8
9
Brett Kimberlin tried to frame me for a crime and how you can help . " BY MR.. WALKER:
Q
I'd like you to answer the question . THE WITNESS: "How you can help . " You know what he "Okay, go out and
10
11 12 13
14
says?
He says,
WALKER:
15 16
17
18
Court where I said that? THE WITNESS: and contact, he's talking in here You know, that's a veiled
19 20 21 22 23
24
about,
And all these, he's got these guys that are I'll read
reading his blog, they're all talking about this, them to you just for the, THE COURT: MR.. WALKER: THE WITNESS: just so you
25
Just so you --
kc 1
2
39
3
4
5
BY MR" WALKER:
Q
6
7
Because it's in a thread that you -And this was wr'itten by a third party, is that not
9 10 11 12
13
correct?
A
the wall,,"
Q
I'm sorry,
by a third party? A It's written by a man that you are in contact with,
14
15 16 17 18
19
that correct? THE COURT: THE WITNESS: THE COURT: MR WALKER: All right, sir" No, by harassing me, Okay All right, guys, that's enough,
20 21 22 23
24
No, but I What do you want to tell me? Well, I - AARON JUSTIN WALKER
25
the respondent, having been fir'St duly sworn, was examined and
kc
1
2
40
3
4
Come on,
5
6
A
Q
7
8
days pretty much writing on the Internet on topics of national interest and topics of, commenting on law, commenting on politics, and I believe that's ultimately what has brought me into this, into his spher'e, campaign against me, Mr, Kimberlin now says that he went to court in order to
Q
10
11
12
13
Mr"
14 15
16
17
18 19 20
He is in the campaign against me" MR, KIMBERLIN: THE COURT: Okay I've never blogged -Hey, how, that's the same that I
21 22
23
24
said to him, I say to you, you guys don't want to be cell mates up there" MR, KIMBERLIN: THE COURT: Okay,
It could be fun_,
25
BY THE COURT:
kc
1
Q
A
41
3 4
5
Isn't that more than 30 days ago? Well, I understand, Your Honor, but I -And haven't you been the one but we're asking who's screaming about the 30 days? We're asking who's So let's stay within the 30 days. I understand what you asked me, Who started this,
A
Q
A
7
8 9
Q
A
10
11
Q
A
12 13
14
There is nobody that started this" No, Your Honor, no, No, Your Honor,
It's like --
15
16
17
-- Adam and Eve started it probably, but go ahead" And I have, and he is angry because I have published
18 19 20 21 22 23
24
truthful information based on my own eyewitness testimony, based on numerous primary documents, demonstrated that Mr" Kimberlin has attempted to frame me for a cr'ime, Kimberlin
Q
A
But Mr,
25
Rupp' s courtroom?
kc
1
A
Q
42
Yes,
yes
- -
2
3
Got you .
-
A
Q
- i f you'd like to go
- -
4
5
But then we had a trial in that case, didn't we? We did not have a full trial, and that's one of the
6
7
I don't understand,
9 10
11
make enough of a pr'esentation to justify even requiring defense" MR, KIMBERLIN: THE COURT: THE WITNESS: show you BY THE COURT:
Q
12
13
Okay,
14 15
16 17 18
Wait.
A
Q
It was a civil court case. No, any criminal court, you're talking about a
19
20 21 22
conviction,
A
He filed, he did file -You're not convicted in civil court He did file false charges against me., When
Q
A
23
24 25
kc
1
43
Q
-- can't even get to the point. Were you convicted? I apologize, Your Honor.
I just asked a
2
3 4
5
simple question
A
No . What?
Q
A
I apologize, Your Honor . That's quite all right . No, I was not . Okay . Then what happened to the case?
- -
6
7
Q
A
8 9
Q
A
10
11
not by you and not by him, that's a State action That's all I want to know
A
Q
12
13
Nolle prossed,
14
15
16
17
limitations or whatever -A
Q
That's true, Your Honor, -- the time it becomes -- okay. So that's, okay. So
18
19
Okay
20 21 22
23
24
what this man did to me, but it's all I've done
Your' Honor, I know Your Honor, that when you tell, say to the world, "Someone has done something evil," that you do obviously It's
have a risk of things like violence and things like that., inescapable, But I have never incited violence.,
I have always
25
told people every time that they have said anything violent in
kc 1 2 3
4
44 my presence, joke . " I said, "I do not endorse violence even as a "Oh, wouldn't it be "That
funny if he went to prison and got raped," I would say, is not cool, that. On top of that, I'm not cool with that."
5
6 7
8
9
originally had his home address, had his phone number, had his e-mail address, etcetera, etcetera. single instance of that. I carefully redacted every
10
11
12
13
Did you send all those e-mails that he had there? I did not send any nasty e-mail to him .
I've never
14
15
16 17
Q
A
Did you send those e-mails? No, I didn't. I've never e-mailed him, period .
18
19
20
Q
A
So those 54 pages, 540 e-mails, never came from you? Well, the 54 pages he's talking about is Twitter, and
21 22 23 24 25
Twitter is something where you talk to the world, not to Brett Kimberlin . Brett Kimberlin believes that if you speak anywhere it is equivalent to putting a letter in his
kc
1
45
that case, that guy sent 122 letters to the add:ress of a woman he kidnaped and stalked previously, And Mr, Kimberlin is
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
trying to say it's equivalent to sending him a letter" He created Google alerts, as he just admitted, bring this stuff into his, Google, in the e-mail inbox, to
He has asked
"Please tell me when anyone in the wo:r'ld does this," He could ask one of them to look at it, He
He has employees.,
He chooses to b:ring this in and then And this matte:r has become an
pretends I'm intruding on him, issue of national debate, Hono:r., MR., KIMBERLIN: THE COURT: THE WITNESS:
10
11 12
13
14
15
16 17
appea:red in the Washington Examine:r, and this is about Brett Kimberl in and his conduct towa:rd me" MR ., KIMBERL IN : THE COURT: THE WITNESS: That -I believe he --
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
I don't know (unintelligible) -- :refers to me as, under the pen name, And he says at one point --
group Velvet Revolution, who was convicted in 1981 of exploding eight bombs --
kc 1
2
3
46
4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
name -- "and Robert Stacy McCain in Maryland, and Patrick Frey of Patterincas Pontifications.. Why? For publishing facts Kimberlin harasses
his targets by, among other things, filing false charges in courts that require expensive, time-consuming litigation, disrupting his targets' workplaces, dropping dark hints about spouses and kids." This is the kind of thing, this is part of the national debate that's going on right now about Mr . Kimberlin's conduct, because I came forward and told my story, and I told it peacefully I didn't ask anybody to do him any harm. I have done no such He
16
17 18 19
20
21 22 23 24 25
the news site known as The Blaze, and it talks again about it
Q
A
Q
- - tell me why .
conduct.
kc
1
A
47
Why?
2 3
me .
4
5
And I believe he --
6
7
Q
A
8
9
decision .
Q
So wait, and follow this now. Yeah . But you're not discussing the alleged incident that
10
11
12 13 14
15 16
that's not
the point -- so now, you go into somebody's past and you dig up whatever you can against them.
A
17
18
past
Q
Well, you've mentioned this bombing so many times. You know, I'm over 21 years old, not much, but I What do you think I am?
19 20 21
22
remember it.
Well, I apologize if I've -So you -over-emphasized it . Okay But go ahead, just, that's just, I'm just
23
A
Q
24
25
kc
1
A
48
Well, just to show you an example, this is the post I don't expect you to read all
3 4
5
of it, but I would like to show just the part where it talks about-Q
6
7
truth.
A
I would like to, or I could at least -You've got more stuff over there than is in the
9
10
11
Okay..
But what I have here, Your Honor, toward the I asked people to spread I asked people to talk
12
13
14 15
16
17
like
Q
A
Q
18 19
20
How do you want justice? I only want justice through the courts.. And I've I
21
22
I'm an attorney..
I'm dedicated to the Constitution . Mr. Kimberlin has done violence And I also
23 24 25
kc 1 2
3
49
Kimerlin.
This is
There wasn't charges against him, he had the charges You were the defendant .
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11
against you.. A
And they have not been prosecuted by -They have not, they have nolle prossed that, Your
A Honor.
Q
A
-- by Mr. McCarthy and company. Yeah. And I've asked for them to do that, I've asked
12 13 14 15
16
17
for people to donate to a defense fund as I deal with Mr . Kimberlin's numerous frivolous lawsuits. Yet, Mr . Kimberlin
has said that, "I have filed 100 lawsuits, and it'd be no sweat to file one more . "
Q
A
Hey, well, how's this going to end? I don't Help me along. Well How do you see it ending? I'm going to tell you the truth -I make all my money by predicting the future. Okay . And that's how I do it.. See, then I bet on Okay? How's it --
18 19
20
Q
A
Q
A
21
22 23 24
Q
A
25
something
kc 1
2
3
50
A
Q
A
Q
5
6
A
Q
7
8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15
No,
- -
A
Q
an individual?
A
16
17 18 19 20 21 22
23
Well no, it is not a desired -- Your Honor, what I Look at, for example, what happened A man named George His The
parents felt that he deserved to be charged with a crime.. police did not charge him.. And what happened? Now,
24 25
Zimmerman, but that is the model of what I am trying to do. I'm trying to create enough of a national uproar to create
kc
1
51 pressure on John McCarthy to finally charge him with the crimes related to him trying to frame me for a crime. get justice. debate " And he wants to shut me up. I'm trying to
2
3
4
We have a national
5
6
Q
Well,
think on
it, A else" But, Your Honor, he can do this again to someone Any time, he could go and claim some third party, he "Oh, Bob, he beat me up," And this time, maybe his Or maybe, what, his
8 9 10
11
could say,
buddy, Neal Rauhauser will back him up '. wife? I don't know"
12
13
history of getting people to lie for him. the Parole Commission" And so then this time,
14 15
16
17 18
19 20
to this Court -- his petition for a peace order was deceptive. He made the court believe that I'm e-mailing him, and I did not. I've never e-mailed him. I've never called him. I've
I've done no form of contact with him, And Your Honor, He's claimed
21 22
23
except sending service of process in the mail . you want to hear something pretty r'emarkable? that is harassment too Honor.
Q
24
25
Listen
kc
1
A
2
3
question, why
Q
Where do
4
5
7
8 9
10
11
12 13 14 15
16
That's my goal .
And how are you going to do this? By I've been raising awareness, that there is now You look up Google, you'll find And I believe probably at These
17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
least 300,000 of them are not very pleasant toward him . are people calling for him to file a new charge.
Q
A man in --
A
Q
Mr. Kimberlin
- -
A
Q
started this. No, no, no, you started it. How did I start this?
kc
1
53
2
3
4
But you're, okay, in that sense, Your Honor -The same way if a politician gets elected, he doesn't See, see
5 6
7
Well, I understand, Your Honor, but -And that you're just the same thing, only it deals in
9
10
11
something different.
A
12 13
14 15
16
17
reason .
A
Within reason? Within reason. I have had a crime committed against me. What is
18
19
20
21
You know, I shouldn't say this, but I think you got The one who decides to prosecute cr'imes is the
22 23
24
it twisted. government
A
25
kc
1
54
A
Q
Of course, Your Honor. And you're doing this, I think, under a guise, under You can't. You
2 3 4 5 6 7
8
9
Suppose you didn't like a girl, and you wanted to talk He feels the same way. He feels violated.
And then you have to look at the r'easonableness between the two of you and the conduct.. A
Q
Well, Your Honor This is going to you guys shooting each other, in my
10
11
opinion . A
Q
Well, Your Honor', that is absolutely not true. You claim to be peaceful . I think, you know,
I'm
12 13
14
Irish, okay?
And one of the things the Irish are best at in And a real good Irish middleweight is a
15 16
17 18
Well, Your Honor You decide to battle and he comes back And see,
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
you're the kind of guy, you don't want to get into this to settle it, mano y mano; you want to get all these friends who got nothing else to do with their time, in this Judge's
opinion, because my God, I'm a little bit older than you are, and I haven't got enough time in the day to do all the things I want to do. I got more. And I felt by retir'ement, I would have less to do.
kc
1 A
Q
55
Well, Your Honor -- - so they all come to me, But you are star'ting a
2 3
4
conflagration, for lack of a better wor'd, and you're just letting the thing go recklessly no matter where it goes,
A
5
6
7
8
freak somewhere out in Oklahoma got nothing better to do with his time, so he does the nastiest things in the wor ld he can to this poor gentleman., it?
A
10
11
He has no r'ight to do that, but Your Honor -Because you incited him, But Your Honor, I did not incite him within the
12
13
14
Brandenburg standard.,
Q
15
16
Well,
forget Brandenburg"
17 18
19
20 21
I'm not sure what that means, Your Honor" Very quickly, and I'm not going to talk about those it ended fast" I even can tell you when I grew
22 23 24 25
up in my community, you wanted to date an Italian girl, you had to get the Italian boys' permission, but that was the old neighborhoods back in the city, and it was really fair, someone did something unfair to you, your sister, your' When
kc
1 2
56
girlfriend, you got some friends, back of the truck . MR . WALKER: THE COURT:
3 4
Well, Your Honor, what the -But that ended it.. You guys have got
5 6 7
8
9
this new mechanical stuff out here, electronic stuff that you can just ruin somebody without doing anything. it.. Used to, you don't remember bailment MR.. WALKER: THE COURT: Your Honor -- when you were in bailments at Yale Law But you started
10
11
School, what the prof said about the bailments? MR . WALKER: THE COURT: Not fully . The one who starts that bad bailment is
12 13 14 15
16 17
the one with the problem . MR.. WALKER: THE COURT: MR. WALKER: THE COURT: But Your Honor -That's who you hold it against. He's-You can't keep saying, "He gave it to me,
18 19 20 21 22 23
24
he gave it to me, gave it to me." MR . WALKER: THE COURT: person to start with, MR WALKER: Pardon me, Your Honor. But if he didn't give it to the wrong it wouldn't happen Well, pardon me, Your Honor. He started
it when he committed a crime against me THE COURT: you . No, he did not commit a crime against
25
kc
1
57 MR, WALKER: evidence, THE COURT: He did not commit a crime against you, Your Honor, you haven't looked at the
2
3
4
5
He's innocent until proven guilty" MR, WALKER: THE COURT: Well, I'm in (unintelligible), you
7 8 9 10
11
is, and all these past things, JUDGE'S RULING I'm going to rule right now" don't need arguments" I could be 100, I've heard enough,
I
12 13 14 15 16 17
18
this case, and all I've learned is one guy hides behind the sheet and runs his little machine while the other man suffers" I don't care what his background is, also be raped" MR" WALKER: Of cour se, Your Honor, But what I care about is, he's an to his own privacy and not That's a prostitute can
THE COURT:
19 20 21 22
23 24
these death threats that ar'e coming, and his children are reading them MR That is nasty and raw, WALKER: But, Your Honor, I did not cause that,
Now, let's see, what year was it at Yale "Don't talk when a judge is talking"?
25
kc 1
2
3
58
MR, WALKER:
I --
Okay
And
THE COURT:
4 5 6
7
done it, you've just, you just, see, that's why these things keep continuing, I am going to pass the order because I find that they are worse than harassment, as far as I am concerned. It's a And,
8 9
10
quite frankly, if we were sitting in a criminal case, you'd get a sentence you would well, I'm known to be a heavy sentencer
11 12
13
anyway - - but you'd get a sentence that you wouldn't like, because you're trying to tear somebody down through almost, through innuendos" And you're not doing it directly, you're If it was
14
15
16
directly, he could come right on, you could come in a court of law, and we'd have this thing settled, one, two, three. But
17 18
19
you've got people allover writing these things, got 54 pages that he says comes directly from you, and he's got volumes over there of these people that are doing it., It's absolutely wrong, So what I'm going to do is I am going to pass this peace order" months " And it's going to r'emain in effect, sir, for six It's wrong, son"
20 21
22
23
24
25
July, August, September, October, November -MR" WALKER: Your Honor, if I can say one thing here,
kc
1
59 THE COURT: MR.. WALKER: THE COURT: No, you can't right now . All right. That's what you got to, as when I was
2
3
4
5 6
over in Munich in the appeals courts over there -MR. WALKER: THE COURT: Okay, Your Honor. -- appeal. All right, sir. This order During
7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
that period of time, you not shall commit any act that causes him, puts him in fear and apprehension of bodily harm, any act that places the gentleman in fear and apprehension of grave bodily harm, any assault, offense, rape, attempt to rape, sexual
malicious destruction of property Respondent shall not contact the person in perBon, by telephone, in writing, or any other means. And "any other
means" is putt.ing it on a blog, a Tweet, a megaphone, a smoke signals - - what else is out there - - sonar, radar, Nothing . MR WALKER: So, You speak about him for six months? How many times are you going to - What happened to the FirBt Amendment? How many times are you going to interrupt I'm not allowed to -laser.
19
20 21 22 23 24 25 me?
kc
1
60
And you shall not contact or har'ass him in any way, you shall not enter his residence, wherever' he may be living, you shall remain away from his place of employment wherever that may be. He may be employed .
2
3
4
5
6
Now, let me get to the -- now, should this, should you violate this order, sir, you are subj ect to being
7
8
prosecuted by the State's Attorney's Office as a cr'iminal case. And if found guilty, the maximum penalty, the first violation is 90 days in jail and/or,
$1,000 fine,
9 10
could be
11
12 13
necessary to keep you away from him, or e-mailing him, or Twitting him, or Googling him, or tooting him, or smoking him, whatever phrase you use - - I don't know what the phrases are. Thank you very kindly MR. KIMBERLIN: want to thank THE COURT: me . No, no, no, just don't say anyt.hing to Judge, I want to thank you, and I
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
(Unintelligible), Madam Clerk. MR. WALKER: (unintelligible) I'll stay here, Your Honor. I'm
22
23
24 25
I'm sorry..
kc 1 2
3
61 appeal, right? On (unintelligible)? Correct . Yes.. You know why I remember that?
4 5
6
7
That' s why I had this thing here to give to you . (The proceedings were concluded . )
8 9
10
11
12
13
14 15 16 17
18 19
20 21 22
23
24
25
kc
62
foregoing pages represent an accurate transcript of the duplicated electr'onic sound recording of the pr'oceedings in the District Court for Montgomery County in the matter of: Case No. 0601SP019792012
BRETT KIMBERLIN
v"
By: