You are on page 1of 13

Jetty distribution Comparison

Date : 30-01-2013

Phase-I Installation
Outdoor Lighting Transformer Rating --350kVA Connected Loads : (a) Phase-I outdoor lighting, Jetty under trestle & Jetty Trestle lighting up to Jetty S/S. (b) Approximate loading 200kW Three nos. LDB on the Trestle to feed Jetty trestle & under trestle Lighting

Details of Existing LDBs


LDB 11 : ( Loop No-1) : Fed directly from Main S/S MLDB, incoming cable 1 X 120sq.mm Length 720m. ( Jetty Trestle Lighting) LDB 12 : (Loop No-6) :Fed directly from Main S/S MLDB, incoming cable 1 X 240 sq. mm Length 2100m. (Jetty trestle lighting). LDB 20 : ( Loop No-6) : Fed directly from Main S/S MLDB, incoming cable 1 X 240 sq. mm Length 2150m. (Jetty Under trestle lighting).

Existing Jetty Distribution


MLDB
120 sq.mm 240sq.mm 240 sq.mm

(720m)

(2100m)

(2150m)

Loop # 6
Loop # 1

LDB 11

LDB 12

Loop # 6

LDB 20

Jetty Trestle

Jetty Trestle

Jetty Under Trestle

Stand by jetty Loads


Above trestle Load 19kW Under trestle load 20 kW. Lighting Transformer considered 50kVA.

OPTION # A

As per Phase-1 Philosophy


Cable size shall increased due to increase in length for Stand By Jetty compare to Existing Jetty
LDB # 11
Jetty -1 ( Cable Size) Jetty -1 ( Cable Length) Jetty -2 ( Cable Size) 120 sq mm 720 mts 150 sq mm

LDB #12
240 sq mm 2100 mts 300 sq mm

LDB #20 $$
240 sq mm 2150 mts 300 sq mm X 2

Jetty -2 ( Cable Length)

1100 mts

2380 mts

2150 mts

$$ Note : Not in TEIL Scope

Cost of Option #1
Cost of cable 150 sq mm : Rs 3.6 lacs Cost of Cable 300 Sq mm : Rs 17.2 lacs Total cost for TEIL : Rs 20.8 Lacs Future Cost for Under Trestle : Cost of cable 2 X 300 sq mm : Rs 31 lacs

Stand by Jetty Distribution Directly from main S/S as Phase-1 Philosophy

MLDB

150sq.mm (1100m)((10kW)

300sq.mm (2380m)((9 kW)

2 x 300sq.mm (2150m)((20kW))

LDB A

LDB B

LDB C

OPTION # 2

Proposal as per TEIL


Transformer 415 / 415 v shall be installed at loop no #2. 2 X 300 sq mm in-coming cable from substation to be connected. Further distribution from transfer for Trestle lighting. Under trestle lighting not to be done by TEIL

AS PER TEIL PROPOSAL


2 X 300 SQ MM 1250 MTS
TRESTLE LIGHT TRESTLE LIGHT
LDB - XX
MAIN SUBSTATION

TRANSFORMER 415V / 415V

UNDER TRESTLE LIGHT (BY PLL)

LOOP # 2

COST FOR TEIL PROPOSAL


Cost of cable two run 300 Sq mm Rs 18 lacs Change of Transfer cost Rs 0.5 lacs Total cost Rs 18.5 lacs Change order (expected) : Rs 18.5 lacs Rs 8.4 lacs = Rs 10.1 lacs No cable needed in future for under trestle lighting.