Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
CA Ganesh Rajgopalan
Article 1
This Convention shall apply to persons who are residents of one or both of the Contracting States.
Restricted scope OECD & UN MC identical, while US MC different Heading changed to Persons Covered from Personal Scope Earlier treaties applied to Citizens or taxpayers Exceptions Non discrimination, Exchange of Information
2-Nov-13 2
2-Nov-13
o Individual not a taxable unit under the UAE Decree o expressions "resident of the other contracting State" not defined o Means a person residing, dwelling or having an abode in UAE or a person staying regularly in UAE o For dividends/interest lower rate, residential status of the recipient not relevant o For capital gains, assessee not a Treaty Subject, not entitled to Treaty
UAE Treaty
Article 3(1) Person
(e) the term "person" includes an individual, a company, and any other entity which is treated as a taxable unit under the taxation laws in force in the respective Contracting States
1. Dividends paid by a company which is a resident of a Contracting State to a resident of the other Contracting State may be taxed in that other State. 2.However, such dividends may also be taxed in the Contracting State of which the company paying the dividends is a resident and according to the laws of that State, but if the recipient is the beneficial owner of the dividends, the tax so charged shall not exceed..
Article 10 - Dividends
India-Germany DTAA
ARTICLE 1 - Personal scope - This Agreement shall apply to persons who are residents of one or both of the Contracting States. ARTICLE 3(d)- General definitions - the term person includes an individual, a company and any other entity which is treated as a taxable unit under the taxation laws in force in the respective Contracting States. ARTICLE 4 - Resident - 1. For the purposes of this Agreement, the term resident of a Contracting State means any person who, under the laws of that State, is liable to tax therein by reason of his domicile, residence, place of management or any criterion of a similar nature. But this term does not include any person who is liable to tax in that State in respect only of income from sources in that State or capital situated therein. ARTICLE 2 - Taxes covered - 3. The existing taxes to which this Agreement shall apply are in particular- in Germany:
o o o o the Einkommensteuer (income-tax), the Korperschaftsteuer (corporation-tax), the Vermogensteuer (capital tax), and the Gewerbesteuer (trade tax)
2-Nov-13
2-Nov-13
2-Nov-13
2-Nov-13
Taxpayers arguments
o A partnership a 'company' or 'body of persons'. o Actual taxation in Switzerland is not necessary; Switzerland has the right to tax partnership. o All partners resident in Switzerland, entire income taxed in Switzerland o Fiscal domicile of the partnership lay in Switzerland . o OECD Comm Art 4 para 8.7 relied upon
Where partnership denied treaty, partners to be entitled
Ruling
o receiver of income & person taxed not the same o no definition of person in Swiss law o If a body of individuals or any other entity is not a taxable entity in the concerned state, it will not be a person. o India not accepted OECD Commentary that partnerships will be considered as persons either as company or body of persons. o Necessary that body of individuals is taxable in Switzerland
2-Nov-13
11
Linklaters LLP
Partnership Example: UK LLP established in UK. A & B, partners of UK LLP, are residents of UK. UK LLP earns royalties from India. Can UK LLP access the India-UK Tax Treaty?
UK India
UK LLP
FTS
Held Fact of taxation in the UK rather than its modality, relevant The entire income is liable to tax in the UK Hence the recipient of income is treaty resident
2-Nov-13
12
Revenues arguments
o Trade tax a turnover tax not tax on income o Assessee not liable to tax in Germany o Assessee not entitled to Treaty
Assessees contentions
o Assessee liable to trade tax in Germany o Trade tax covered under Art. 2 o Assessee entitled to Treaty
Assessee is entitled to Treaty aso Assessee is a person falling under the limb any other entity o Assessee is a partnership established under German Law, hence resident of Germany o Assessee is liable for trade tax o Trade tax is not a tax on turnover but a tax on income o Assessee filed its return of trade tax in its own name
2-Nov-13
14
US Branch
Canadian Income
Norsk s claimed to be entitled to Canada- US Treaty for concessional tax *(1995) 2 SCR 802
The basis of Norsks liability for taxation in the United States emanates from the fact that it conducts a trade or business which is effectively connected with the US and has income arising from that business. Although the fact that its "place of management" is located in the United States is one factor contributing to the finding that its trade or business is connected with the United States, it does not constitute the basis for Norsks tax liability in the first place. A factual proposition which merely informs domestic tax liability cannot constitute a residency criterion.
2-Nov-13 15
OECD MC Comm.
o Comprehensive (full-tax) liability to tax [Para 8 , Comm on Art. 4]
2-Nov-13 16
Green Emirates
UAE Residents can avail DTAA as there is a potential liability to tax
Linklaters LLP
Income of the firm is taxed in UK. Firm has fiscal domicile in UK thus resident
TVM Ltd.
Mauritian Co. Entitled to DTAA if it has paid tax in Mauritius
Meera Bhatia
UAE Individuals can access the DTAA as there is a potential liability to tax
Cyril Pereira
As no income-tax law on Individuals in UAE, they cannot access DTAA
ABA
Liability to tax is legal situation, Payment of tax is fiscal situation
2-Nov-13
17
Exempt Income
Exempt Entity
Potentially taxable Limited taxation
Non-taxability through which method depends on domestic law but determines treaty entitlement At which point the liable to tax not satisfied?
2-Nov-13
19
2-Nov-13
20
State S Income
State S1
State S2 Income
Income
State S to limit its taxation as per both R1-S and R2-S treaties.
State R to limit its taxation/grant relief as per both R-S1 and R-S2 treaties.
2-Nov-13 21
A Winner
A Loser
State S Income
2-Nov-13
22
2-Nov-13
23
2-Nov-13
24
2-Nov-13
25
Meaning of Source
State R1 A A State R2
A is resident of R1 after tiebreaker under R1-R2 Treaty Income sourced in State S but taxed in State R2.
PE Winner Loser
State S
Income
For example, shipping profits earned by enterprise of R2 (having its POEM in R1) may be sourced from outside State R2. State R2 taxes A (say, since A is incorporated there) on income sourced in State S Application of R2-S Treaty?
2-Nov-13
26
Aznavour case* - Source State taxation in France UK Co earns income from As performance in France and is taxed in the UK. A is not taxed in Switzerland on performance income as it accrues to UK Co. France taxes performance income in the hands of A and not UKCo. Both UKCo and A are tax residents of UK and Switzerland respectively.
*Conseil
Held: A taxed on income under domestic law Swiss-France Treaty examined, Art. 17(1) allowed France to tax the income UK Co.s entitlement to access Treaty considered irrelevant Whether Switzerland taxed A also not found relevant
Where one persons owns the income and liability to tax is imposed on another person; a potential claim for treaty entitlement is fragmented between two persons
2-Nov-13 27
Thank you!
2-Nov-13
28