Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Biology, then and now Mathematics Physics Linguistics the new science
As a Tool of expression? As a Social Institution, means of communication As Intellectual competence As World-views, as Mans means of discerning the world House of Being (Haus des Seins)? Language as a system
For Humboldt, as for many others before and since, a word does not stand directly for a thing, but rather for a concept. There can, accordingly, be a multiplicity of expressions for the same objects, each representing a way in which this object has been conceived through workings of the process of Spracherzeugung (20) Consequently, a language should not be regarded merely, or primarily, as a means of communication, and the instrumental use of language is derivative and subsidiary. (21) Schopenhauer: (PP-II-620) Polyglottism, neben seinen vielen mittelbaren Nutzen, auch ein direktes Bildungsmittel des Geistes ist.
4
Piaget:
Apel:
Descartes
Res extensa => Newton Res cogitans => Chomsky (the Newton of res cogitans)
8
Chomsky Critics
George Lakoff Cognitive Linguistics / core-periphery distinction Charles Fillmore case grammar William SY Wang Bresnan, Joan: "He revolutionized linguistics but did it in a divisive way," says former student Joan Bresnan, now a respected linguist at Stanford University, in California. He's a polarizer. He's created warring schools. http://www.geocities.com/CapitolHill/Senate/3761/profile.html Mason, Timothy, Could Chomsky be wrong? http://www.timothyjpmason.com/WebPages/LangTeach/CounterCho msky.htm
9
Dictionary entries of a word in a different language like shifted circles Learning of foreign languages
we learn not merely words, but gain concepts and ideas, ie. concept spheres arise where there were previously none Learning Latin: remoulded and recast connections and references, previously not known, are discovered we thus obtain a more comprehensive view of everything in every language we think differently through the study of each new language, our thinking undergoes a fresh modification and that polyglottism with its many indirect uses is, therefore, a direct means of mental culture 12