Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
A Statewide Movement
More than 100 CA community colleges have participated in CAP acceleration workshops hosted by 3CSN
42 colleges are now piloting accelerated courses as part of 3CSNs CAP Community of Practice, participating in three in-person workshops, ongoing coaching, and a large peer-to-peer network (applications available in early spring for the 2014-15 cycle)
CAP website with resources to support colleges implementing acceleration received more than 10,000 unique visits in 18 months http://cap.3csn.org
Overview of session
Illustrations of pedagogical changes faculty make as they shift to acceleration Findings from a new fiscal tool for comparing the costs of accelerated math pathways and traditional remedial curricula Early findings from an RP study of student completion in CAP accelerated pilots
Toward
In English, accelerated pedagogy gives under-prepared students experience with college-level reading, reasoning, and writing, with more in-class scaffolding and support than in a regular college course. Sub-skills in reading and writing are addressed as needed in the context of the more challenging work.
Teaching accelerated courses has changed my outlook on student capacity. I learned to trust in students ability to handle challenges and tackle meaningful academic work. - Caroline Minkowski, City College SF
Math
Away from One long developmental math pathway for all students. Toward A short pathway with remediation aligned with students field of study. For students in areas that are not math-intensive, align remediation with general education requirements, such as Statistics.
Away fromdecontextualized algebra, mimicry of symbolic procedures and template word problems
An apple falling from a tree is h feet above the ground t seconds after it begins to fall, where h=64-16t^2. How long does it take the apple to hit the ground?
Student Reflections
It was developing my critical thinking. Not just looking at a formula and learning how to solve it you know, where does this go, what are the rules.Its more about evaluating, its more about the analysisIts more about understanding how to make a conclusion about the data set. Describing her instructor s approach to the class: Its kind of likeYou dig in and get your hands dirty, however you feel you need to, and Im here for you to help clarify, to help understand, help get you along better. I like that. Its more like the instructor is a facilitator, as opposed to, Im spewing out all this information that I need you to regurgitate on an exam. -Accelerated Pre-Statistics Students at College of the Canyons
Faculty Reflections
I go to the board, and I start to lecture, and it kills the magic in the room.Theyre not enthusiastic, theyre not paying attention, theyre looking at their cell phones.I figure, If I just explain at bit more, itll be ok. But the more I tried to front-load, the worse it got. And then this kid in the class comes up after.and he goes, Now Terrie, Ive noticed that your pedagogical practices have been about us discovering what we need, and I think what happened today is that you failed to trust the process. -Terrie Nichols, Math Instructor, Cuyamaca I kind of started getting into this mindset, Well, if they dont care, I cant make them careI really just thought it was laziness. Now I realizeits just that students are intimidated. They dont want to act like they care because then they would be failures if they didnt succeed. -Evelyn Ngo, Math Instructor, College of the Canyons
What are we learning about the costs of accelerated pathways? Dr. Robert Johnstone
The Fiscal Implications of Accelerated Math Pathways
The California Acceleration Project: Using a Cost Efficiency Model to Investigate Key Outcomes and Fiscal Considerations
Dr. Rob Johnstone Strengthening Student Success Conference Burlingame, CA October 10, 2013
www.inquiry2improvement.com 22
www.inquiry2improvement.com
At the end of the day Most importantly and its really important not to forget this the bottom line is that CAP works. Significantly more students achieve success in transfer level courses
www.inquiry2improvement.com
24
www.inquiry2improvement.com
25
Summary of Findings
When the model was applied to real-world data from the seven initial CAP colleges, we found that:
CAP significantly increases student completion of transferable math courses see Terrence / Craig s presentation for specifics CAP significantly lowers cost per completer CAP reduces the cost of remediation and allows dollars to be reallocated to transferable courses
CAP results in a significant decrease in student tuition / books costs and an increase in wage gains by helping students complete sooner
National Center for Inquiry & Improvement www.inquiry2improvement.com 26
www.inquiry2improvement.com
www.inquiry2improvement.com
www.inquiry2improvement.com
Summary
Model shows significant improvements in:
Cost per completer Cost of pre-transfer math % of cost in pre-transfer math Student tuition & book savings Student wage gains
Model can be customized for use at any college BOTTOM LINE STILL: The actual improvement in students achievement of transfer-level math success
www.inquiry2improvement.com
31
www.inquiry2improvement.com
32
How are students performing in the accelerated English and math courses across the state?
Early data from an RP Group outcomes evaluation of colleges that began piloting accelerated courses with CAP in 2011-12
Craig Hayward Terrence Willett Strengthening Student Success 2013 Burlingame, California
English Math
Method
Accelerated students
compared to traditional Equated on placement level First time in discipline Outcome is passing the relevant transfer-level gatekeeper course Multivariate model includes time, placement, acceleration
CAP Evaluation Preliminary Results, SSSC October 2013
Accelerated Students
A series of hoops
Requirement Sample size: English
1,994 (100%) 1,608 (81%) 1,016 (51%)
All accelerated students in time frame with assessment scores and with no prior course in the discipline
15%
Iota
Pi
50%
40% 30% 20% 10%
0%
Mu Alpha Eta Theta Delta Lambda
25%
20% 15% 10% 5% 1% Transfer level One level Two levels below below Three levels below Four levels below 13% 11%
0%
Outcomes
W H O I S B E I N G A C C E L E R AT E D ?
Demographics
Gender
Accelerated
Traditional
48% 52%
Female Male
47% 53%
Ethnicity
60%
54% 50% 46% Asian African American Filipino Hispanic Multi Native American Pacific Islander White
40%
30% 20%
15%
25%
12%
9%
10% 0%
Accelerated
Traditional
Caveats
Still early in the analysis process Data issues kept four colleges out of analysis For the four levels below group, it is too soon to conclude that acceleration doesnt work
Significant effects of acceleration found Variations among colleges appear to be meaningful, still being assessed
In a partial analysis of the first year of CAP pilot colleges, student completion of transfer-level English and math has increased significantly. Variation in completion rates at individual colleges points to potentially significant implementation considerations.
Financially, accelerated math pathways reduce remediation costs, enable colleges to reallocate resources to transferable courses, and benefit students through reduced book/tuition expenses and wage increases from expedited completion.
Next Steps
Recruiting colleges for 2014-15 Applications for the Community of Practice in Acceleration will be available on the CAP website in early spring Addressing policy-level challenges of UC/CSU articulation for accelerated math pathways
Near-term, community colleges use Title 5-mandated prerequisite challenge processes to offer alternative math pathways Long-term, community college system needs to work with CSU/UC to re-examine the Intermediate Algebra pre-requisite policy for Statistics and Liberal Arts math and make space for promising pathway innovations
Join us!
One-day regional workshops:
November 15, Fresno (Central Valley) February 7, Chabot College (Bay Area) March 7, West LA College (Greater LA)
More information on all of todays session will be available through the CAP website in the coming months: http://cap.3csn.org
khern@chabotcollege.edu, msnell@losmedanos.edu
The California Acceleration Project is supported by the California Community Colleges Success Network (3CSN), through a professional development grant from the state Chancellor s Offices Basic Skills Initiative. Additional support has been provided by the Walter S. Johnson Foundation, LearningWorks, and the Scaling Innovation project of the Community College Research Center, funded by the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation.