Presented by: Mark Kartchner, PE, LEED Kartchner Engineering Energy Use Office Buildings Mechanical System Costs First Cost - Water cooled chillers beat Air cooled chillers at about 200 Tons (80,000 SF) SEL HQ VAV-$10.5/SF, FP-$1.9/SF, Plumb-$3.4/SF 90,000 SF CWC $12.5/SF WSHP & $3.5/SF Plumb 90,000 SF Mechanical System Costs (Provide & Install) 8 10.5 12 14 14.5 14.5 19 20 0 5 10 15 20 25 RTU-Gas/Air Cooled RTU-Heat Pumps VAV-Elec Heat Multi Zone RTU VAV-Hot Wtr Heat WSHP-HP, Boiler, Chiller, Cooling Tower DOAS w/ 4- Pipe Fan Coil Variable Ref rigerant Volume D o l l a r s
( $ ) HVAC Rules of Thumb Air - 1 CFM/SF Cooling (office) 300/400 SF/Ton Cooling (office) 400 CFM/Ton Heating 25-35 btuh/sf floor area Outside Air 20 CFM/person Toilet/Jan Closet 10 air changes/hour
HVAC Equipment/SF Mechanical Room (Boilers/Chillers/Pumps/Misc) = GU College Hall = 2000 SF/186,000 = 1.1%
Mechanical Room (Boilers/Pumps/Misc) = RTF (tight) 300 SF/28,000 SF = 1.1% Colbert Elementary 312 SF/ 40,000 SF = 0.8%
RTU (Gas/Electric/VAV) = SEL Office (35x12 (2))/95,000 SF
Building Envelope Load Calculations Heating and Cooling Accuracy important! Design conditions Building shell load R, U value Internal load Ventilation load Infiltration Occupancy schedules
Heat Transfer Conduction Convection Radiation Resistance (R-Value) U = 1 / R Q = U x A x T
U-Value is the rate of heat flow in Btu/h through a one ft 2 area when one side is 1 o F warmer
Actual R-Values Window Types The amount of solar heat energy allowed to pass through a window Example: SHGC = 0.40 Allows 40% through and turns 60% away Solar Heat Gain Coefficient Window Properties Energy Calculations in the Spokane region show that reflective, and tinted windows increase energy usage on an annual basis. Energy Saving Design Methods
Air Side Economizers Water Side Economizers Variable Frequency Drives Building Diversity Part Load Performance Thermal Storage Heat/Energy Recovery HVAC SYSTEMS Heating, Ventilation and Air Conditioning Provides comfort for people Allows humans to exist under adverse conditions. Basic Refrigeration Cycle System Types Packaged Rooftop Unit Split System Air to Air Heat Pump Water Source Heat Pump Geothermal VAV Variable Air Volume Under Floor Air Distribution (UFAD) Air to Air Hydronic (water) PTAC / PTHP Packaged Rooftop Units (RTU)
Split System Heat Pump (Air to Air) Operate on simple refrigeration cycle Reversing the cycle provides heating Temperature limitations Air to air Water source Geothermal Lake coupled Water Source Heat Pump Geothermal Heat Pump Systems (VAV) Variable Air Volume VAV Terminal Units Variable volume: Parallel
Constant volume: Series Under Floor Air Distribution (UFAD)
Advantages Individual Controllability Re-Configurability 2 Extra LEED Points Disadvantages More Expensive ($8/SF for raised floor) Flexible for Change 2 Extra LEED Points Inland Power & Light First UFAD in area
Hydronic systems Four Pipe Fan Coil VAV w/ HW Reheat
Hydronic System Major Equipment Chillers Boilers Cooling Towers Chilled Water System Economizers Air Side Water Side Economizers Free cooling source: When available, use cool outdoor air instead of mechanically cooled air. 55 o F 80 o F Minimum supply of outside air Normal Operation Outside air dampers are positioned to provide the minimum outside air Economizer Operation Outside air dampers are fully open. Maximum outside air is provided 80 o F 55 o F and up 85% outside air 85% exhaust HVAC-29 Enthalpy Wheels Air Distribution Grilles, Registers Many options GU Russell Theatre Return Grille Return Plenum Extra cost for plenum rated cable is less than cost of return ductwork No Combustables
Outside Air Louvers
Outside Air Louvers provide an opening in a building wall to push air out, or pull air in. Provide clean outdoor air, avoid: loading docks exhaust vents plumbing stacks waste collection stagnant water
Metal Ducts Square Ductwork Most common Low height Round Ductwork Less Expensive Easy to Install Lower static pressure Taller than Rectangular Higher pressure Less Sound Oval Ductwork Same advantages of round Height similar to rectangular More expensive than rectangular
Fabric Ducts Great for certain applications Gyms Pools Manufacturing Spokane Science Museum Advantages Great Diffusion Easily Cleaned Fun Same cost as metal
Saved $300,000 in cost at high school. Lowered chilled water temp, & air temperatures Additional Equipment Heat Exchangers Humidifiers Silencers
Kitchen Hoods Type 1: Hoods designed for grease exhaust applications Type 2: Hoods designed for heat and steam removal and other non grease applications. (NFPA 96 does not cover) Where are Type 1 Commercial Hoods Required? NFPA 96 Cooking equipment used in processes producing smoke and grease-laden vapors shall be equipped with NPFA 96-A-1-1 intended to include residential cooking equipment where used for purposes other than residential family use Type 1 Hood Clearances 18 inches to combustible material 3 inches to limited-combustible material 0 inches to noncombustible material
A restaurant with a commercial gas range is represented by the resteaurant owner to be used ony for the preparation of soups. What type hood is required? Type 1 hood is for collection and removal of grease laden vapors,and smoke. Type II hood is for removal of steam, odors, and vapors. It would be hard pressed to find a restaurant that only produces soups, with that commercial range. Hoods: where required, installed at or above all commercial- type deep fat fryers, broilers, fry grills, steam- jacketed kettles, hot-top ranges, ovens, barbeques, rotisseries, dishwashing machines, and similar equipment that produces comparable amounts of steam, smoke, grease, or heat in a food processing establishment. Food processing establishment shall include any building or portion used for the processing of food. Soup is a liquid food made up of simmering vegetables, seasonings, and often meat or fish. It is the potential of the equipment (Commercial gas range), rather than the utilization, that must be evaluated. So, what type of hood would be required for that commercial gas range in a restaurant would honestly be open for discussion. You will probably have some input from your local Fire Dept. through plan check as with the County Health dept. Requirements. I know of one City close to us that when a pizza parlor opens, no matter what, they require a type 1 hood. Depending on the type of pizza oven, we have allowed a type II.
Kitchen Hood Types Exhaust Hood w/ Supply Air Supplied by Space Exhaust Hood w/Supply Air on Outside of Hood Exhaust Hood w/Supply Air on Inside of Hood Vapor Hoods Simple hoods designed to remove minimal heat, and high vapor.
Comfort Comfort is primary intent of HVAC systems. Productivity Building Durability Health Mold
ASHRAE Comfort Zone Psychrometrics Dry bulb temp. Wet bulb temp. Humidity Dew point Moisture content Heating Cooling Humidify De-Humidify Historical Minimum Ventilation Rates (cfm/person) 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 1 8 3 5 1 8 4 2 1 8 4 9 1 8 5 6 1 8 6 3 1 8 7 0 1 8 7 7 1 8 8 4 1 8 9 1 1 8 9 8 1 9 0 5 1 9 1 2 1 9 1 9 1 9 2 6 1 9 3 3 1 9 4 0 1 9 4 7 1 9 5 4 1 9 6 1 1 9 6 8 1 9 7 5 1 9 8 2 1 9 8 9 1 9 9 6 Tredgold 1836 Nightengale 1865 Billings 1895 Flugge 1905 Yaglou 1938 ASHRAE 62-73 ASHRAE 62-81 Smoking 62-81 ASH- RAE 62-89 Smoking 62-89 Improved Ventilation Effectiveness Mechanically provide filtered and dehumidified outdoor air to the breathing space Vary ventilation based on the number of occupants and process loads - changes in occupancy can be measured by CO 2 sensors Consider designs that separate ventilation and space conditioning Utilize heat recovery systems to reduce system size and ventilation energy costs Improved Ventilation Effectiveness Effective mixing of ventilation air within space Net positive pressure in the southeast; exhaust from appropriate spaces Provide clean outdoor air, avoid: loading docks exhaust vents plumbing stacks waste collection stagnant water Acoustics Octave Band Directivity Factor LEED Products
LEED-NC New Construction & Major Renovations LEED-EB Existing Buildings LEED-CI Commercial Interiors LEED-CS Core & Shell LEED-H Houses LEED-ND Neighborhood Developments LEED-Schools: K-12 Schools LEED-Retail: Retail facilities- In pilot stage LEED-Healthcare: Healthcare facilities- In pilot stage
LEED Checklist http://www.metrokc.gov/dnrp/summit/documents/LEED-Spataro.pdf http://www.metrokc.gov/dnrp/summit/documents/LEED-Spataro.pdf THANK YOU! Additional Information / Resources ASHRAE The American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers www.ashrae.org Southface Energy Institute www.southface.org Geothermal heat pump consortium www.geoexchange.org www.buildingscience.com www.energycodes.gov HVAC Acoustics for Green Buildings Mike Filler. Ashrae technical committee for Sound and Vibration McQuay Application Guide AG 31-010 HVAC Acoustic Fundamentals Energy Efficiency in Buildings Dr. Sam C M Hui Department of Mechanical Engineering