Crude oil and its refined products The oil supply chain and key market participants Links between physical oil trading and paper instruments Global nature of oil markets and trading 2
Crude oil is refined into many products - their yields are dependent on the crude oil quality
Decreasing
boiling
point
Fuel Gas
Crude Oil LPG (Propane, Butane) Naphtha
Light Kero (Jet) Heavy Kero
Atmos Gasoil (AGO)
Light Vac Gasoil (LVGO)
Vaccum Gasoil (VGO)
Vac Resid
Crude A
Fuel Gas
LPG (Propane, Butane) Naphtha
Light Kero (Jet) Heavy Kero
Atmos Gasoil (AGO)
Light Vac Gasoil (LVGO)
Vaccum Gasoil (VGO)
Vac Resid
Crude B
3
The oil supply chain involves trading at every step
Production
Refining
Marketing sales
Integrated Oil Company
crude
purchases
crude
sales
components
product
purchase
s
3rd party product sales
Producer
Refining & Marketing Company
4
and companies choose to get involved in part or all of the whole the supply chain
Production
crude
purchases
crude
sales
Refining
Trading Houses
components
Marketing sales
product
purchases
3rd party product sales
Trading Houses
Wholesaler / Reseller
5
Paper Instruments
1. FUTURES
standardised contracts for forward delivery, traded on exchanges Common examples include ICE Brent Crude or ICE Gasoil, Nymex WTI Crude or Nymex Unleaded Gasoline
2. SWAPS
standardised contracts for forward delivery, usually traded over- the-counter (OTC) Common examples include Eurograde gasoline and High Sulfur Fuel Oil swaps
3. OPTIONS
buyer of an option acquires the right - but not the obligation - to buy or sell an underlying futures contract under certain conditions, in exchange for a payment (premium) for that right
6
Major Global Trade Flows for Fuel Oil
Net Long
Net Short
Russia
NW Europe
Canada
USA
Latin & South America
Source: Cera 2001 - ECM 2002
S Europe Middle East
Africa
Korea
Japan China
Singapore
7
Example of a crude arbitrage deal from Europe to US
North Sea producer has
1 million barrels crude
Local Price: Dec BF + 10 Refiner looking for
1 million barrels crude Willing to pay: Dec WTI -20 per barrel
8
Example of a crude arbitrage deal from Europe to US, executed on 1st October 2006
SELLER OWNS
1 million barrels (bbls) North Sea Crude Loading: 22 October in N. Sea Price: Dec BF + 10/bbl Pricing period: Oct 23-27 Transport N. Sea US GC: $1.50/bbl (Flat Rate = $11.54/mT, WS = 100) Dec BF on 1st October = $74.50/bbl
OPPORTUNITY VALUE
BUYER LOOKING FOR
1 million barrels N. Sea crude, delivered into US GC
Delivery: 6-8 November in US GC Will pay: Dec WTI - 20/bbl Pricing period: Nov 6-10 Dec WTI on 1st October = $76.50/bbl
Sellers Value of North Sea Crude = $74.60/bbl + Transport = $1.50/bbl. Lands in USGC at $76.10/bbl
Buyer willing to pay for North Sea Crude = $76.30/bbl.
Value available on 1st October = $76.30 - $74.60 - $1.50 = $0.20/bbl
But this value is NOT guaranteed without hedging using paper instruments
9
Europe to US GC crude arbitrage - locking in the value is done through use of paper instruments
SELLERS HEDGE On 1st October: Sell 1000 lots Dec WTI at $76.50 Buy 1000 lots Dec BF at $74.50
Buy Oct TD5 (freight swap) at WS 100 i.e. locking in freight @ $1.50/bbl
As cargo prices in 23-27 Oct, rateably sell out Dec BF (200 lots per day)
As cargo prices out 6-10 Nov, rateably buy back Dec WTI (200 lots per day)
Settle freight swap financially on 31 October
Remaining risk:
- Paper deal execution risk
- Physical operation risk
BUYERS HEDGE
*Assumes buyer is a refiner*
As cargo prices in 6-10 Nov, rateably sell Dec WTI (200 lots per day)
As cargo is consumed in November rateably buy back Dec WTI
Remaining risk: - Crude may not be consumed in November: would need to adjust paper hedge
- Physical operation risk - Changes in refining margins
10
Major Global Trade Balances for Gasoil
Net Long
Net Short
NW Europe
FSU
Canada
USA
Middle
East
Africa
South
America
Source: BP Stat Review - ECM 2002
China Japan
USWC
Korea
11
SUMMARY
Participants in the physical oil market choose to be active in parts or whole of the oil supply chain The physical and paper oil markets are inextricably linked, in the main due to price risk management The oil paper markets have a diverse set of participants Physical oil markets are global and linked through arbitrage activity
What Does Granger Causality Prove? A Critical Examination of The Interpretation of Granger Causality Results On Price Effects of Index Trading in Agricultural Commodity Markets