Sie sind auf Seite 1von 65

Security Level:

UMTS Speech Quality


Principles + Troubleshooting
Methods + Cases +
Deliverables
Prepared by: UMTS Maintenance
Department/UMTS Design Department
Reviewed by: Qi Haofeng

August 29, 2012

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

www.huawei.com

Abstract
Speech quality problems are classified into the following two types:
Problems that are measured by using the Mean Opinion Score (MOS). This type of problems
generally has a low MOS.
Problems that are measured through end users subjective perception of speech quality, including
one-way audio, silence, water running sound, and call drop.
This presentation describes the 11 prescribed actions and related cases for handling MOS
problems as well as six prescribed actions and related cases for handling perceptual speech
quality problems.
This presentation also offers deliverables that frontline engineers need to submit when feeding
back the preceding two types of speech quality problems, including analysis results of alarms,
traffic measurement, call history record (CHR), and drive test data. The typical cases in this
presentation showcase the importance and necessity for frontline engineers to execute prescribed
actions as well as the immediate effect of these actions.
If the speech quality problem persists after you execute the 11 prescribed actions for MOS
problems and the six prescribed actions (there is an entry criteria for each action) for perceptual
speech quality problems, submit this problem to R&D engineers directly.

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 2

Change History
Date

Version

2012-8-28

1.0

2012-10-26

1.01

Description

Reviewer

Author

Qi Haofeng, Tang Yuanxian, Gong Qian Lanying,


The draft was completed. Jie, Cui Chengxiao, Fan Jingchang, and Fan
and Yuan Qiang
Jingchang
Revised based on review
Qian Lanying
comments.

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 3

Contents
1

MOS Evaluation Standards and Principle

Factors That Affect MOS and MOS Problem Handling Process and Cases

Perceptual Speech Quality Problems

Silence and Noise Handling Process and Cases


Water Running Sound Handling Process and Cases

Appendix: Speech Quality Deliverables

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 4

MOS Evaluation Standards and Principle


Subjective Evaluation
The MOS (scaling 1 to 5) (ITU-T P800) is generated by averaging the results of a set of subjective tests
Objective Evaluation
The objective evaluation standards obtain the speech quality score by comparing the transmitted degraded signals with the
reference signals and adopting an algorithm. These standards include the perceptual analysis measurement system (PAMS)
(ITU-T P861), perceptual evaluation of speech quality (PESQ) (P862), PESQ-LQ, and PESQ-LQO(ITU-T P862.1).
Parameter Evaluation
The transmitted voice signals are estimated through some parameters of the wireless network, for example, the Speech Quality
Indicator (SPI) of Ericsson and the Voice Quality Indicator (VQI) of Huawei. This method has a broad prospect for application
on wireless networks.
Universal rating and acceptance standard

Nowadays carriers around the world use the MOS as a major network acceptance indicator. One of the widely used rating
standards is the PESQ-LQO (ITU-T P862.1) algorithm
PESQ-LQO scores lie between 1.0 and 4.5 and have five scales: Excellent, Good, Fair, Poor and Bad.

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 5

Speech Quality Testers

Third-party testers:

DSLA

Swissqual

Comarco

Rising/Dingli

Testers from equipment vendors:

Ericsson: Tems

Huawei: Probe

Nokia: Nemo

Carriers at present have high requirements for the speech quality test. Mainstream
carriers in Europe have used Swissqual as the drive test tool and opted for the PESQLQO(P862.1) standard in the speech quality acceptance test of several offices.
HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 6

Contents
1

MOS Evaluation Standards and Principle

Factors That Affect MOS and MOS Problem Handling Process and Cases

Perceptual Speech Quality Problems

Silence and Noise Handling Process and Cases


Water Running Sound Handling Process and Cases

Appendix: Speech Quality Deliverables

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 7

Factors That Affect MOS

Factors that affect the MOS include:

1. Test methods, PSTN, and tools (software and hardware), for example, reference signal and
software settings.
2. Network-related factors:

Codecs

Bit errors (coverage, interference, transmission, algorithm and equipment)

Handover

To optimize MOS, you need to adopt appropriate test methods, select the optimal codec, and
minimize the impact of bit error rate (BER) and handover on the speech quality.
In some scenarios, however, optimizing speech quality (for example, link reestablishment and
timer optimization) may affect such counters as call drop rate and hard handover success rate.

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 8

Factors That Affect MOS Data Analysis


and Statistics of Live Network
China Unicom live network has a low MOS. After analysis, you find that the low MOS is
caused by:
1. Test method and tool problems.
2. BER problems:

Coverage
Interference
Transmission
Algorithm
Equipment

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Time Point for


Problem Analysis

Cause

Number of
Problems

May 23

Coverage

June 1

Coverage

June 4

Equipment problem

June 5

Equipment problem

June 7

Equipment problem

June 7

Test method and


tool

June 10

Transmission

June 10

Coverage

June 10

Test method and


tool

June 11

Interference

June 12

Algorithm

Page 9

MOS Problem Evaluation Method

Drive test results are used to estimate the MOS.

The MOS baseline value of Huawei is 3.6.

The following table lists the benchmark data of all VXX offices.
If the drive test result is lower than 3.6, the speech quality problem needs to be located.
Projects Benchmark

Average MOS

Project1

3.6

Project2

3.9

Project2

3.9

Project3

3.7

Project4

3.9

Project5

3.9

Project6

3.8

Project7

3.9

Project8

3.9

Project9

3.9

Project10

3.9

Project11

3.9

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 10

MOS Problem Handling - Prescribed Action Checklist


Step
Step 1

Step 2

Step 3

Step 4

Step 5

Prescribed Action

Entry Condition

Purpose of Analysis

Action 1 Check MOS drive test


specifications

Unconditional

Check the drive test method and conduct


preliminary analysis.

Action 2 Check version known


problems on equipments

Unconditional

Check the version and equipment for


known problems.

Action 3 Check all parameters

The MOS is smaller than the baseline value or


benchmark.

Check whether there are known problems


that affect parameter configuration.

Action 4 Analyze characteristics of low


The MOS is smaller than 3
MOS

Analyze low MOS distribution and


characteristics. (special site, route..)

Action 5 Check encoding/decoding


problems

The MOS is smaller than 3.6 and the maximum


MOS is lower than 4.0.

Check speech encoding/decoding.

Action 6 Check BER-related coverage

The MOS is smaller than 3.6 and the average BLER


is higher than 1%. A linear relationship exists
Check the BER-related coverage problem.
between MOS and BLER.

Action 7 Check BER-related


interference

The MOS is smaller than 3.6 and the average BLER


is higher than 1%. A linear relationship exists
Check the interference problem.
between MOS and BLER.

Action 8 Check BER-related


transmission

The MOS is smaller than 3.6 and the average BLER


is higher than 1%. A linear relationship exists
Check transmission.
between MOS and BLER.

Action 9 Check BER-related algorithm

The MOS is smaller than 3.6 and the average BLER


Check the impact of other algorithms and
is higher than 1%. A linear relationship exists
functions on MOS.
between MOS and BLER.

Action 10 Check BER-related


equipment

The MOS is smaller than 3.6 and the average BLER


Check whether the problem is relevant to
is higher than 1%. A linear relationship exists
board load and faults.
between MOS and BLER.

Action 11 Analyze handovers

The hard handover success rate is higher than 35%.

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Check inter-frequency and inter-RAT hard


handovers.

Page 11

MOS Test Process

MOS acceptance standards include the following two types:

MOS acceptance: The MOS of the whole network must reach a given value.
For example, MOS must be higher than 3.6.

MOS distribution acceptance:


Ex. MOS must be higher than 3.8 and the proportion of MOSs lower than 3 must be less than 1%

Record and output the MOS DT Checklist.

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 12

Prescribed Action 1 for Handling MOS Problems


Check MOS Drive Test Specifications
Drive test specifications:
To ensure the effectiveness of drive test data, the drive test must be conducted in strict compliance with the drive test specifications.
When carrying out drive test, check all test items against the MOS DT Checklist:

Test instrument and voice sample: Different voice samples have varied MOSs. Select the appropriate voice samples based on
the test instruments.

PSTN: Identical core network (CN). Different CNs baseline configurations have a huge impact on the MOS distribution.
CN and RAN should use the same configuration

Traffic model: Identical (daytime or nighttime) time segments (avoid holidays or other special dates).

Vehicles and terminals: Identical vehicles and terminals, the same testing engineers, and identical terminal connection and
placement modes.

Test routes: Identical test routes (Prepare a GPS map and carry out drive test on the scheduled route) and driving directions.

Test vehicle speed: Identical and stable vehicle speed (Select appropriate time and vehicle speed).

Tool settings: Identical tool settings and statistics collection methods for front-end data collection and rear-end data output.

Statistical methods used by tool: Check such data as the number of samples and handovers, coverage, and MOS distribution
after test. If any discrepancy is found, carry out the drive test again.

Conform to the preceding drive test specifications and check the test items against the MOS DT Checklist.

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 13

Prescribed Action 2 for Handling MOS Problems


Check Equipment and Version for Known Problems
Check the equipment and version for known problems:

NodeB version discrepancies

The MOS speech quality problems that exist on the WBBP D board are solved in the following
versions:

R12 V200R012C00SPC440

R13 V200R013C00SPC310

WBBP Board: process board for coding and decoding

Use of the WBBP D board in earlier versions may lead to silence, noise and low MOS.

Output known problem check results of


equipment and version

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 14

Prescribed Action 3 for Handling MOS


Problems - Check All Parameters

Check all parameters:

The speech quality parameters that may affect the MOS include TRFO (Trans-coder Free
Operation) , AMRC (Adaptive Multi-Rate Control algorithm ), dynamic power control, link
reestablishment and water running sound. NPMater , FMA, OMStar..

Output parameter check results (weekly task):

MML command
SET
UCorrmalgoswitch

Parameter ID

Bitmap

Parameter Name

Baseline
Value

Impact

CsSwitch

CS_IUUP_V2_SUPPORT_SWITCH

WRFD-011600 TFO/TrFO.

1 (ENABLE)

Enabling this switch will increase MOS by 0.2 without


negative impact. (prevent speech quality deterioration)

CS_AMRC_SWITCH

AMRC

Enabling this switch will lead to silence or call drop as a


result of the UE compatibility issue. Can involve UE
Compatibility issue EX: IPhone 4

CMP_UU_AMR_DRD_HHO_COMPA
T_SWITCH

DRD HHO CMP Switch

This parameter specifies to enable both HHO and DRD to


avoid the water running sound caused by UE compatibility
issue.

Automatic Noise Correction


Switch (R13)

off

The water running sound is automatically corrected.


Can involve UE Compatibility => Disable it

CS Link Reestablishment
Switch

Enabling this switch helps decrease the call drop rate,


but will lead to a 6-second silence, compromising user
experience.

SRB OVER H Switch

None

The SRB OVER H switch will reduce to the water running


sound.

Silence Detect

Enable if Mos is bad for Silence is detected.

Dynamic Power Control

When cell load is light, turning on this switch enables a low


target BLER to be configured for UEs processing voice
services. This improves user experience but increases
load and shrinks cell coverage, increases the call drop
rate of UEs at the cell edge

CmpSwitch

SET UDPUCFGDATA AmrNoiseCorrectSwitch


SET
URRCTRLSWITCH

RsvdPara1=RSVDBIT1_BIT24

SET
UFRCCHLTYPEPAR
A

SrbChlType

SET
URRCTRLSWITCH

RsvdPara1

SET UCORRMPARA

RSVDBIT1_BIT15

RESERVED_SWITCH_0_BIT24

SET UUEA

EncryptionAlgo

RNC Supported Encryption


Algorithm

UEA01&UEA1-1

SET USTATETIMER

HoPhychRecfgTmr

HHO Physical Channel


Reconfiguration Timer

5000

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

This algorithm must be consistent with that used on the


CN. Otherwise, call drop may occur.
If this time is set to more than 10000, the water
running problem may occur.

Page 15

Prescribed Action 4 for Handling MOS Problems


Analyze Characteristics of low MOS

Check distribution of low MOS

If low MOS occurs continuously or massively on one side


during a drive test, the problem usually lies with the MOS
tester, audio cable connection or test method.

Analyze low MOS:


Analyze the drive test UE log. Check and filter out low MOSs
values and check the radio quality:

If the RSCP < -105 dBm or Ec/Io < -14 dB:


=> the low MOS is caused by poor quality of radio signals
and weak coverage, wireless network optimization is
required.
If the RTWP > -90 dBm, the low MOS is caused by
interference.
If the signal quality is good , RSCP < -95 dBm or their
Ec/Io < -12 dB, the problem may lie with products.

Output characteristics analysis


result of low MOS:

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 16

Prescribed Action 5 for Handling MOS Problems


Check Coding/Decoding Problems
MOS mean
Score

3.460

Mos Max

3.80

MOS<=1 rate

0%

MOS<=2 rate

0.5%

MOS<=3 rate

6.5%

MOS<=4 rate
MOS>4 rate

93.0%
0%

MOS samples

2135

Typical characteristics of encoding/decoding


problems: The MOS is larger than 3.6, and the
maximum MOS is smaller than 4.0.
Check speech encoding/decoding.
Data source: MML Script
Analysis tool: UltraEdit
Judgment criteria:
1. TRFO

TRFO affects speech encoding/decoding. Enabling TRFO


will increase MOS by 0.2. After TRFO is disabled, MOS
baseline value decreases to 3.4.
SET UCORRMALGOSWITCH:
CsSwitch:CS_IUUP_V2_SUPPORT_SWITCH=1;

2. AMRC

Enabling AMRC will affect encoding rate and have a


negative gain on the MOS.
SET UCORRMALGOSWITCH: CS_AMRC_SWITCH=0;

It is recommended that AMRC be disabled and TRFO be enabled.

Output encoding/decoding check result

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 17

Prescribed Action 6 for Handling MOS


Problems Check BER-Related Coverage

Typical characteristics of BER problems:


The MOS is smaller than 3.6 and average
BLER is larger than 1%.

A linear relationship exists between celllevel or top cell MOS and BLER.

MOS is closely related to BLER, as shown in the


MOSvsBLER figure.

The larger is the BLER, the smaller is the MOS.


Usually the average BLER should converge to

MOS Average

3.12

MOS samples

2135

Average BLER

3.13%

BLER (1) rate(0%-0.78%)

78.27%

BLER (2) rate(0.78%-1.56%)

10.54%

BLER (3) rate(1.56%-3.12%)

2.32%

BLER (4) rate(3.12%-6.24%)

0.28%

BLER (5) rate(6.24%-12.48%)

5.34%

BLER (6) rate(12.48%-100%)

3.25%

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

1% in the case of Outer Loop Power Control


(OLPC).

The BER is related to coverage, interference,


transmission, algorithms and equipment.

Huawei Confidential

Page 18

Prescribed Action 6 for Handling MOS Problems


Check BER-Related Coverage

Check list :

Perform BER-related analysis:


Data source: Traffic measurement and DT log
Analysis tool: Nastar and Probe Assistant

Judgment criteria:
1. Analyze traffic measurement:
Analyze whether the uplink BLER of TOP Cells with a low MOS is
> 1% by checking the traffic measurement counter
VS.ULBlerAMR > 1%.

2. Analyze the DT log:


Analyze whether the downlink BLER of cells with a low MOS is >
1% by checking the counter Uu_TrCh_Bler >1%.

DT Information
MOS mean Score
Average BLER
BLER (1) rate(0%-0.78%)
BLER (2) rate(0.78%-1.56%)
BLER (3) rate(1.56%-3.12%)
BLER (4) rate(3.12%-6.24%)
BLER (5) rate(6.24%-12.48%)
BLER (6) rate(12.48%-100%)
AverageRSCP
Average Ec/Io
Ec/Io<=-14 dB
-14 dB<Ec/Io<=-10 dB
-10 dB<Ec/Io<=-6 dB
Ec/Io>-6 dB

And :
Coverage: Ec/Io<-14 dBm, RSCP<-105 dBm

Output BER-related coverage


check result

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 19

Now

Before
3.65
0.01
82%
12%
2%
1%
1%
2%
65.00
-10.00
3.33%
46.30%
45.58%
4.78%

Prescribed Action 7 for Handling MOS Problems


Check BER-Related Interference
Perform BER-related analysis:
Data source: Traffic measurement and DT log
Analysis tool: Nastar and Probe Assistant
Judgment criteria:
1. BLER:
Analyze whether the uplink BLER of TOP Cells with a low MOS is
larger than 1% by checking the traffic measurement counter
VS.ULBlerAMR > 1%.
2. Interference:
VS.MeanRTWP>-90 dBm
VS.MaxRTWP>-75 dBm
VS.MinRTWP<-106 dBm
If the interference is relevant, judge whether the MOS problem is relevant to
traffic or caused by interference.
Check inter-modulation, cell cross-connection, and uplink and downlink
balance.

Output BER-related interference check result

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 20

Prescribed Action 8 for Handling MOS Problems


Check BER-Related Transmission
Perform BER-related analysis:
Data source: Traffic measurement and DT log
Analysis tool: Nastar and Probe Assistant
Judgment criteria:

1. BLER:
Analyze whether the uplink BLER of TOP Cells with a low MOS is larger than 1% by checking
the traffic measurement counter VS.ULBlerAMR > 1%.

2. Iub/IuCS interface transmission:


ATM interface judgment criteria:
If the number of lost ATM packets is more than 60 as a result of ATM header errors or
full ATM buffer, ATM links are abnormal.
VS.AAL2PATH.PVCLAYER.DROPFORHEADCELLS,
VS.AAL2PATH.PVCLAYER.DROPFORRXOVERFLOWCELLS,
VS.AAL2PATH.PVCLAYER.DROPFORTXOVERFLOWCELLS

IP interface with IPPM activated: If the peak packet loss rate of the IPPATH is more
than 1%, the IP link is abnormal.
VS.IPPM.Forword.Peak.DropRates

IP interface with IPPM not activated: If the number of lost packets on the IP layer is
more than 60, the IP link is abnormal.
VS.IPPATH.IPLAYER.TXDROPPACKETS,
VS.IPPATH.IPLAYER.RXDROPPACKETS
HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

IPPM detect IP performancelike packet drop, delay..

Huawei Confidential

Page 21

Prescribed Action 9 for Handling MOS Problems


Check BER-Related Algorithm
Perform BER-related analysis:
Data source: Traffic measurement and DT log
Analysis tool: Nastar and UltraEdit
Judgment criteria:
1. BLER:
Analyze whether the uplink BLER of TOP Cells with a low MOS
is larger than 1% by checking the traffic measurement counter
VS.ULBlerAMR > 1%.
2. Algorithm:
Script analysis > CS link reestablishment switch, and hard handover
waiting timer
Type

MML Command

Parameter ID

Bitmap

Default
Value/Recommended
Value/Baseline Value

CS Link
SET
RsvdPara1=RSV
Reestablishment
URRCTRLSWITCH
DBIT1_BIT24
Switch
Hard Handover
Physical Channel
HoPhychRecfgT
SET USTATETIMER
Reconfiguration
mr
Timer

5000

Output BER-related algorithm check result

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 22

Prescribed Action 10 for Handling MOS Problems


Check BER-Related Equipment
Perform BER-related analysis:
Data source: Traffic measurement, script, and CDT
Analysis tool: Nastar, UltraEdit, and Umat

ALM-22501
ALM-20275

Judgment criteria:
ALM-21352

1. BLER:
Analyze whether the uplink BLER of TOP Cells with a low

DSP CPU overload alarm


Interface board forwarding overload
alarm
IPPATH excessive packet loss
alarm

ALM-21221

IMA link out-of-frame alarm

ALM-21202

E1/T1 out-of-frame alarm

MOS is larger than 1% by checking the traffic


measurement counter VS.ULBlerAMR > 1%.
2. Equipment:

Equipment alarm analysis

Single-UE CDT analysis: FP layer, and statistics of IUUP


voice packet errors and transmitted and received frames.

Output BER-related equipment check result

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 23

Prescribed Action 11 for Handling MOS Problems


Analyze Handover
Typical characteristics of handover problems:
HHO Rate= HHO/MOS sample
We analyze the impact of hard handover on MOS through the
proportion of the number of hard handovers (HHOs) to the
number of MOS calls.

MOS mean Score


MOS samples
HHO numbers
HHO/ MOS sample rate

HHO analysis

Data source: Traffic measurement, script, and CDT

Analysis tool: Nastar, UltraEdit, and UMAT/FMA

Judgment criteria:

(Inter-frequency or inter-RAT) HHO may lead to loss of


voice frames, which will affect the MOS. Therefore, the
HHO rate during conversation needs to be calculated.
The smaller the HHR rate, the larger the MOS.

Generally the HHO rate is lower than 30%. The HHO


rate of higher than 35% is abnormal, and in that case,
you need to check whether the settings of neighboring
cells and handover parameters are appropriate.

Output handover check result

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 24

3.46
2135
838
39.25%

MOS Problem Handling Report


Develop an analysis report template that
contains the problem handling process and
all factors that may affect speech quality to
thoroughly analyze MOS problems and
inform relevant frontline Engineers.

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 25

Typical Case 1 - Test Tool Problem


Background: The rate of low MOSs (less than 3) in the drive test of an office is up to 6.19%.
Action 1: According to the data feedback checklist, recording files with size below 126 KB are found. The
size of a normal recording file should be 126 KB. The MOS of abnormal recording files is less than 3.
Root cause: Low MOSs are caused by exceptions of terminals or test tools, which is confirmed by the
tool vendor.

MOS mean Score

3.71

Mos Max

4.08

MOS<=1 rate

3.46%

MOS<=2 rate

2.73%

MOS<=3 rate

0.12%

MOS<=4 rate

81.13%

MOS>4 rate

12.56%

Recorded Speech Wave check

The size of
some files is
less than 126
KB.

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 26

Typical Case 2 - Parameter Setting Problem


Background: The 3G MOS of an office decreases by 0.2 after migration and this affects the FSA.
Action 1: OK Check test method. The test method conforms to the test specifications.
Action 2: OK Check equipment and version. Both the equipment and version are normal.
Action 3: Check parameters. The dynamic power control is disabled.
SET UCORRMPARA: ReservedSwitch0=RESERVED_SWITCH_0_BIT24-0;
Root cause: BLER is set to -20, which is equivalent to 1%. The dynamic power control is disabled (uplink BLER * 0.2 is not
performed), so the MOS decreases by 0.2. After the dynamic power control is enabled, the MOS reaches the standard
value.

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 27

Typical Case 3 - Board Failure


Background: The Ec/No in the drive test of an office is normal, but the UE BLER is quite high and low MOS is
detected in one site.

Action 1: OK Check the test method. The test method conforms to the test specifications.
Action 2: OK Check equipment and version. Both the equipment and version are normal.
Action 3: OK Check parameters. All parameters conform to recommended values.
Action 4: Analyze characteristics of low MOS. Low MOS is detected in one site.
Root cause: Top site problems are caused by a failure of the WBBP board rather than a software bug.

WBBP Board: process board for coding and decoding

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 28

Typical Case 4 - BER-related Coverage Problem


Background: The MOS of some top cells of an office is quite low, the downlink BLER is high, and
RSCP and Ec/Io are bad.
Action 1: OK Check test method and tool. They all conform to the test specifications.
Action 2: OK Check coding/decoding script. It conforms to the recommended value.
Action 3: Check BLER. The low MOS of top cells is relevant to the high BLER.
Root cause: The MOS increases and call drop rate decreases by increasing the maximum and
minimum downlink transmit power of the 12.2 kbit/s CS service of top cells with weak coverage by 3 dB.

Downlink
Minimum MOS
After
BLER After
Modification Modification

Sector ID

Minimum MOS
Before
Modification

DL BLER

RSCP

Ec/NO

30232

1.25

18%

-107.2

-13.1

3.24

3%

1.99

30221

1.41

18%

-111.1

-12.9

3.41

2%

1.99

30121

2.58

12%

-106.8

-11.1

0%

1.41

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 29

MOS Gain

Typical Case 5 - BER-Related Transmission Problem


Background: The MOS of some top cells of an office is low and the uplink BLER is high.
Action 1: OK Check test method and tool. They all conform to the test specifications.
Action 2: OK Check coding/decoding script. It conforms to the recommended value.
Action 3: Check BLER. The low MOS of top cells is relevant to the high uplink BLER .
Root cause: Packet loss occurs as a result of high transmission load. Check Alarm , RTWP,
KPI about capacity
Maximum ATM Uplink Bandwidth
Usage

Average ATM Uplink Bandwidth


Usage

Software Building in the south of WB city

0.990284

Oriental Business Building in the south of WB city

0.986082

MyKal in the south of WB city

0.972689

District government in the south of WB city

0.860557

CITIC Industrial in the north of WA city

0.847426

Building S Haier Industrial Park, Laoshan WB

0.829569

0.984769

0.766807

NODEBNAME

Xingye Building in the north of WB city

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 30

Typical Case 6 - Product Problem


Background: The average MOS of an office is only 3.47. The low MOS in the case of good signals is larger than that
in the case of poor signals.

Action 1: Check test method and tool. They all conform to the test specifications.
Action 2: Check coding/decoding script. It conforms to the recommended value.
Action 3: Check BLER. The MOS of top cells is irrelevant to the BLER.
Action 4: Check handover. The MOS of top cells is irrelevant to handover.
After checking all the preceding four factors, we think that the problem lies with equipment. The frontline engineers
need to perform single-UE CDT according to Single UE Tracing Guide to locate the root case.
Root cause: Through CDT, the multiplexed frame of NodeB WBBPD board is found abnormal.

Ec/Io

Num

0<=MOS<2

2<=MOS<3

3<=MOS<4

4<=MOS<5

<=-14 dB

78

16

13

45

-14 dB<Ec/Io<=-10 dB

362

25

40

243

54

-10 dB<Ec/Io<=-6 dB

356

34

16

259

47

>-6 dB

40

28

Total

836

80

70

575

111

Percentage

100%

10%

8%

69%

13%

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 31

Average MOS

3.472

Contents
MOS Evaluation Standards and Principle

Factors That Affect MOS and MOS Problem Handling Process and Cases

Perceptual Speech Quality Problems

Silence and Noise Handling Process and Cases


Water Running Sound Handling Process and Cases

Appendix: Speech Quality Delivery Guide

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 32

Factors That Affect Speech Quality and Classification of Perceptual


Speech Quality Problems (same steps than MOS)
Perceptual speech quality problems include:

One-way audio and silence: packet loss

Noise: packet error

Water running sound: audio encryption/decryption error

Call drop: speech service interruption

Voice service is an end-to-end user experience that involves multiple NEs. The factors that affect user
perceptions of voice service quality include: VIP complaint is a very important action to focus on !

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 33

Status Quo on Perceptual Speech Quality Problems in UMTS

Changes of speech quality problems in 20102012:


1.

In 2010, the major causes of speech quality problems are CN, RNC, and UE.

2.

In 2011, the major causes of speech quality problems are CN, RNC, and air interface.
The CN and RNC have a dominant impact.
With increase of UE capability and intelligent terminal penetration, the air interface transmission
quality deteriorates gradually, leading to increase of speech quality problems. So far, the air interface
transmission quality has become a major bottleneck around the world.

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 34

Handling Process of Perceptual Speech Quality Problems


According to the factors that may affect speech quality perceptions, focus on checking the alarm,
transmission, CN, product, air interface, and UE compatibility. The process of identifying a speech
quality problem is as follows:

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 35

Analysis and Summary of Perceptual Speech


Quality Problems Prescribed Action Checklist
Step

Step 1

Prescribed Action

Entry Condition

Action 1 Check alarms

Unconditional

1. Check whether the board is faulty.


2. Check whether the problem lies with transmission.

Action 2 Check version for


known problems

Unconditional

Check whether the problem is caused by known version


problems.

Action 2 Check parameters for


Unconditional
known problems

Check whether there are known problems that affect


parameter configuration.

Action 3 Check UEs

Check whether the problem is caused by abnormal UEs.

Unconditional

Action 4 Check and analyze


traffic measurement

When the problem is not


solved after execution of
actions 1, 2, 3, and 4

Action 5 Check and analyze


logs

When the problem is not


solved after execution of
actions 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5

Step 2

Step 3

Purpose of Analysis

Action 6 Make the fault recur


and analyze data
A. Make the fault recur and
check against the check list
B. Use of DTMF functions

When the problem is not


solved after execution of
actions 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

1. Check whether such exceptions as transmission fault or


high board load occur in the area where users lodge
complaints.
2. Check whether cells with a high call drop rate exist in the
area where users lodge complaints.
3. Check whether the RTWP is high in the area where
users lodge complaints.
1. Check whether the user who lodges a complaint about
the speech quality really has such problems as one-way
audio, noise and water running sound.
2. Check whether the user complaint about noise is caused
by high uplink BLER.
1. Check whether the user who lodges a complaint about
the speech quality has packet loss on the Iub or Iu interface.
2. Check whether the speech quality problem is caused in
a special process.

Huawei Confidential

Page 36

Prescribed Action 1 for Handling Perceptual


Speech Quality Problems Check Alarms
1. Check alarms
Data source: Alarm log
Analysis tool: FMA
Check area: Check the alarms regarding the cell, NodeB, board, and transmission equipment in the area where
users lodge complaints.
Voice calls will be affected by any of the following alarms. Identify the problem by checking alarms.
Classification of
Perceptual Speech Alarm Type
Quality Problems

Alarm ID

DSP CPU overload alarm ALM-22501 DSP CPU overload alarm


Interface board
ALM-20275 interface board forwarding
forwarding overload
overload alarm
alarm
ALM-21352 IPPATH excessive packet loss
alarm
ALM-21221 IMA link out-of-frame alarm
Transmission-related
One-way audio and
ALM-21202 E1/T1 out-of-frame alarm
alarms
silence
ALM-21208 E1/T1 excessive slip frame alarm
ALM-21223 IMA link remote receiving fault
alarm
ALM-20205 system clock source unavailable
alarm
ALM-20211 DSP time synchronization
Clock-related alarms
exception alarm
ALM-20209 clock phase-lock loop fault alarm
ALM-21351 excessive IP transport layer
Transmission-related
errored frame alarm
Noise
alarms
E1/T1 Confidential
excessive BER alarm
Huawei
HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD. ALM-21207

2. Output the alarm check results

Page 37

Prescribed Action 2 for Handling Perceptual Speech


Quality Problems Check Version and Parameters for
Known Problems
1. Check version and parameters for known problems:
Check the known version problems of a NodeB based on the NodeB version information in the area where users lodge
complaints.
Classification of Perceptual
Speech Quality Problems
Known noise problems

Known one-way audio and silence


problems

Known water running sound


problems

Version & Parameter


Check the NodeB D board version that has
speech quality problems

Impact
R12 V200R012C00SPC440 (earlier versions)
R13 V200R013C00SPC310 (earlier versions)

Check RNC parameters and enable the


AMRC switch

SET UCORRMALGOSWITCH: CsSwitch=CS_AMRC_SWITCH-1;

Check the 15s delay function of the CN

On the NSN CN, the call drops on one end and is released on the other
end with a delay of 15s.

Check RNC parameters and disable the


DRD HHO CMP switch

SET UCORRMALGOSWITCH:
CmpSwitch=CMP_UU_AMR_DRD_HHO_COMPAT_SWITCH-0;

Check RNC parameters and enable the SRB


OVER H switch

SET UFRCCHLTYPEPARA: SrbChlType=HSPA;

2. Output the version and parameter


check results for known problems

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 38

Prescribed Action 3 for Handling Perceptual


Speech Quality Problems Check UEs
1. Check UEs:
(1). Test UEs to check whether a certain type of UE has exceptions.
(2). Check UE compatibility against the bug list.
(3). Check logs by taking the following steps:

Import the PCHR logs generated during the complaint period, and set a filtering condition
ucAmrSilentNum>0. Collect a statistics on the UE types of different users to check whether the problem is caused by top UEs.
For example:

UE with One-way Audio

One-way Audio Count

UE Proportion

Nokia

254

48.75%

Apple

166

31.86%

SonyEricssion

32

6.14%

HTC

48

9.21%

Samsung

13

2.50%

Motorola

0.58%

LG

0.77%

Rim

0.19%

2. Output the UE check results

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 39

Prescribed Action 4 for Handling Perceptual Speech Quality Problems


Check and Analyze Traffic Measurement
1. Check traffic measurement:
Data source: Traffic measurement
Analysis tool: Nastar
Checking area: Check the traffic
measurement regarding the cell, NodeB,
board, and transmission equipment in the
area where users complaints.

One-way audio

Analysis of one-way audio:

Traffic
measurement

Noise

Analysis of
abnormal counter
values

Nastar

Water running
sound

1. Import the traffic measurement file generated during the complaint period, and output the DSP load performance counters: VS.DSP.UsagePeak
and VS.DSP.UsageAvg.
Judgment criteria: If VS.DSP.UsagePeak > 90% and VS.DSP.UsageAvg > 70%, one-way audio is related to high board load.
2. Import the traffic measurement file generated during the complaint period, and output the CS call drop rate counter of the cell in the area where
users complaints: VS.CS.CallDrop.Cell.Rate.
Judgment criteria: If VS.CS.CallDrop.Cell.Rate > 2%, one-way audio is related to the high call drop rate of the cell
3. Import the traffic measurement file generated during the complaint period, and output the Iub/IuCS interface transmission counters of the NodeB
in the area where users lodge complaints:
a. For ATM interface, output: VS.AAL2PATH.PVCLAYER.DROPFORHEADCELLS,
VS.AAL2PATH.PVCLAYER.DROPFORRXOVERFLOWCELLS, and VS.AAL2PATH.PVCLAYER.DROPFORTXOVERFLOWCELLS.
Judgment criteria: If more than 60 packets are lost due to ATM packet header error or insufficient space in ATM buffer area, one-way audio is
related to ATM link exceptions.

b. For IP interface with IPPM activated, output: VS.IPPM.Forword.Peak.DropRates.


Judgment criteria: If the IPPATH peak packet loss rate > 1%, one-way audio is related to transfer link exceptions.
c. For IP interface with IPPM not activated, output: VS.IPPATH.IPLAYER.TXDROPPACKETS & VS.IPPATH.IPLAYER.RXDROPPACKETS
Judgment criteria: If more than 60 packets are lost when transmitted on the IP layer, one-way audio is related to IP link exceptions.

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 40

Analysis of noise:
1. VQI counter: VS.Speech.VQI.Bad, VS.Speech.VQI.Accept, and VS.Speech.VQI.Good

2. BLER counter: VS.ULBlerAMR


Judgment criteria: If VS.Speech.VQI.Bad > 5%, VS.Speech.VQI.Accept < 90%, VS.Speech.VQI.Good < 90%, and
VS.ULBlerAMR>1%, the noise is related to uplink bit error.

Bit error may be caused by several factors. Analyze whether the bit error is related to uplink RTWP
according to traffic measurement, and view RTWP counter: VS.MeanRTWP&VS.MaxRTWP.

Judgment criteria: If VS.MeanRTWP > -90 dBm, the noise is caused by high uplink RTWP.
If the bit error is related to RTWP, judge whether the noise is related to traffic volume or caused by
interference according to the RTWPs in peak and off-peak hours.

Analysis of water running sound:


No performance counter

2. Output the traffic measurement check result

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Prescribed Action 5 for Handling Perceptual Speech Quality


Problems Check and Analyze Logs
One-way
audio

1. Check and analyze logs:

PCHR

Data source: PCHR


Noise

Analysis tool: NPMaster

Check
exception logs

NPMaster

Water running
sound

Analysis of one-way audio and silence:


Import the PCHR logs generated in the complaint period, and output the one-way audio count:
ucAmrSilentNum.
Judgment criteria: If ucAmrSilentNum > 0, one-way audio occurs in the call and the one-way audio count is X.

Analysis of noise:

BLER analysis
Uplink BLER count at rank 1: BLER_RANK1_TIMES. Uplink BLER count at rank 2: BLER_RANK2_TIMES.
Uplink BLER count at rank 3: BLER_RANK3_TIMES. Uplink BLER count at rank 4: BLER_RANK4_TIMES.
Uplink BLER count at rank 5: BLER_RANK5_TIMES. Uplink BLER count at rank 6: BLER_RANK6_TIMES.
Judgment criteria: If (rank 5+6)/(rank 1+2+3+4+5+6) > 5%, the noise is related to uplink bit error.

Analysis of water running sound:

Judgment criteria:
If ucSpeechNoiseStatusReport > 0 (subject to the AMR adjustment switch),
ucHfnAdjustState 4 (subject to the AMR adjustment switch),
and the start time of water running sound detection SpeechNoiseTime > 0,
=> there is a water running sound on the call at the time of XXX.

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 42

Prescribed Action 6 for Handling Perceptual Speech Quality Problems


Trace and Analyze Voice Transmission of a Single UE
1. Trace and analyze voice transmission of a single UE:
If a problem recurs, analyze it using the following process:

Data source: user plane CDT of a single UE

Analysis tool: UMAT/FMA

Noise: uplink bit error


Analyze the air interface transmission quality through user plane data and indentify packet errors based on the CRCI in the FP packet.
There is one Cyclic Redundancy Check Indicator (CRCI) bit in the FP frame with the value range of {0=Correct, 1=Not Correct}.
Judgment criteria: If usULCrciErrNum / ulULRcvTbNum > 1%, the noise is caused by uplink bit error.
Figure 1: A speech packet is received at an interval of 20 ms

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Figure 2: All speech packets and CRC error packets received in uplink

Huawei Confidential

Page 43

One-way audio -> Iub analysis


A speech packet is sent at a transmission time interval (TTI) of 20 ms based on UMTS speech features.
Check the FP layer according to uplink FP packet statistics, and isolate the NodeB and Iub transmission.
Judgment criteria: If any uplink FP packet is lost or all packet are empty, one-way audio problem is related to the Iub
interface transmission, RAN process, UEs or NodeB equipment.

The cumulative
number of uplink
speech packets
on the Iub
interface does
not increase in
8s.

One-way audio -> Iu analysis


A speech packet is sent at a TTI of 20 ms based on UMTS speech features.
Check the Iu layer according to uplink and downlink IUUP packet statistics, and isolate the CN and Iu transmission.
Judgment criteria: If any downlink FP packet is lost, one-way audio is related to the Iu interface transmission or CN.

The cumulative
number of
downlink
speech packets
on the Iu
interface does
not increase in
10s.

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 44

One-way audio -> process analysis


Analyze the problem to identify whether it is caused by process exceptions.
Judgment criteria: If any uplink FP packet is lost at the time point when a complaint is lodged, check whether during
this period:

The link is re-established.

The packet loss occurs before the call drops.

The local end is waiting for link disconnection on the CN.

The uplink Iub interface does


not receive any speech
packet within 6s.

2. Output the single UE


tracing and analyzing results
HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 45

Prescribed Action 7 for Handling Perceptual Speech Quality


Problems Take Active Actions
To support the analysis conclusion and understand user perceptions, you need to take
active actions to solve user complaints about perceptual speech quality problems.
Step 1:

Collect information about when


and where users lodge
complaints and about the
complained UE type.

According to the area where


users lodge complaints, check
whether the problem lies with:
a.Indoor / outdoor.
b.Common NodeBs or
transmission features.

According to the
complained UE type,
check whether the
problem lies with
certain types of UEs
or chips.

According to the
period of time when
users lodge
complaints, check
whether the problem
occurs in peak hours.

Step 2: Check against the checklist according to the information collected in step 1.

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 46

Test principle: Determine the test model according to the customer complaint scenario description and UE type.
Test model: Mutual CS calls, CS+PS(R99), PS (H)+CS, and third UE call
Test area: Perform tests in the areas where customers lodge complaints.
Test rules: Hang up each call only after both UEs confirm that there is no problem in each dialing test to avoid accidental hang-up when the fault recurs.
Type of Calling Calling UE Test
Called UE Test
Type of Called UE
Test Scenario
Test Duration
Test Result
Information Collection
UE
Area
Area
iPhone (UE type) Complaint area

iPhone (UE type)

Complaint area

Dialing test

100 dials in about


two hours

No one-way
audio or noise

Collect complete RNC CDT


and NodeB CDT

HuaweiU8800

Complaint area

iPhone (UE type)

Complaint area

Dialing test

100 dials in about


two hours

Noise recurs
twice on iPhone

HuaweiU8800

Complaint area

HuaweiU8800

Complaint area

Dialing test

100 dials in about


two hours

No one-way
audio or noise

HuaweiU8800

Complaint area

HuaweiU8800

Cross-RNC

Dialing test

100 dials in about


two hours

No one-way
audio or noise

HuaweiU8800

Complaint area

HuaweiU8800

Cross-MSC

Dialing test

100 dials in about


two hours

No one-way
audio or noise

HuaweiU8800

Complaint area

HuaweiU8800

Among carriers
(PSTN)

Dialing test

100 dials in about


two hours

No one-way
audio or noise

HuaweiU8800

Complaint area

HuaweiU8800

Complaint area

100 dials in about


two hours

One-way audio
recurs twice for
the calling UE

Collect complete RNC CDT,


NodeB CDT, and calling UE
tracing data
Collect complete RNC CDT,
NodeB CDT, and calling and
called UE tracing data
Collect complete RNC CDT,
NodeB CDT, and calling and
called UE tracing data
Collect complete RNC CDT,
NodeB CDT, and calling and
called UE tracing data
Collect complete RNC CDT,
NodeB CDT, and calling and
called UE tracing data
Collect complete RNC CDT,
NodeB CDT, and calling and
called UE tracing data

iPhone

Complaint area

iPhone

Complaint area

100 dials in about


two hours

No one-way
audio or noise

Collect complete RNC CDT


and NodeB CDT

iPhone

Complaint area

iPhone

Complaint area

100 dials in about


two hours

No one-way
audio or noise

Collect complete RNC CDT


and NodeB CDT

iPhone

Complaint area

iPhone

Complaint area

100 dials in about


two hours

No one-way
audio or noise

Collect complete RNC CDT


and NodeB CDT

iPhone

Complaint area

iPhone

Complaint area

100 dials in about


two hours

No one-way
audio or noise

Collect complete RNC CDT


and NodeB CDT

iPhone

Complaint area

iPhone

Complaint area

100 dials in about


two hours

No one-way
audio or noise

Collect complete RNC CDT


and NodeB CDT

iPhone

Complaint area

iPhone

Complaint area

100 dials in about


two hours

No one-way
audio or noise

Collect complete RNC CDT


and NodeB CDT

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Conduct a dialing test, and the


called UE removes the UE
battery.
Conduct a dialing test, and the
calling and called UEs
establish a PS service and
then originate a CS call.
Conduct a dialing test, and the
calling and called UEs
establish a PS service
respectively.
Conduct a dialing test, and
create inter-RAT, interfrequency, and DRD handover
scenarios.
Conduct a dialing test, and the
calling UE sends SMs to a
third UE.
Conduct a dialing test, and a
third UE calls the calling UE.
Conduct a dialing test, and the
calling UE performs DTMF
operations.

Huawei Confidential

Page 47

Take Active Actions Use of DTMF Functions


DTMF application scenario:
For the users with single-UE CDT activated, the DTMF functions do not work. For the users with single-UE CDT not activated,
they can use the DTMF functions to enable the RNC to automatically perform CDT of a single UE if one-way audio occurs
during calls.

Use Method:
Activation:
*270NN#: is used to enable the RNC to perform CDT of a UE, where * indicates the start-of-DTMF-command marker, 270
indicates a functional character, NN indicates the start duration, 01 indicates one hour, and # indicates the end-of-DTMFcommand marker. In the case of one-way audio, a user can type *27001# to enable CDT.

Deactivation:
(1) The DTMF task is deleted after the UE releases the call.
(2) The CDT lasts until the DTMF task is deleted.
(3) The UE reports the DTMF deletion command *18000#.

Trace the log directory:

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 48

Handling Report of Perceptual Speech


Quality Problems

Develop an analysis report template


that contains the problem handling
process and all factors that may affect
speech quality to thoroughly analyze
perceptual speech quality problems

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 49

Typical Case 1 - Silence (Transfer)


Silence caused by transfer exception

There is silence during calls in an office.

Analysis:
Action 1: Check alarms. According to log analysis, lots of link unavailable alarms are generated during Iub interface

transmission at the time point when users lodge complaints. The complaints are related to the Iub interface
transfer alarms.
Conclusion: Transfer exception leads to one-way audio. Users no longer experience silence on calls and there are no
complaints from users after engineers replace the onsite transmission equipment and conduct dialing tests.

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 50

Typical Case 2 - Silence (UE)


Silence caused by UE problems

An office tests the AMRC function (Adaptive Multi-Rate Control algorithm) of dozens of UEs and finds that HTC
G7 and Samsung Galaxy W occasionally generates silent call issue.
Analysis:
Action 1: Check alarms. There is no exception.
Action 2: Check known parameters : AMRC is enable
Conclusion: Some UEs have the one-way audio problem after AMRC is enabled.
According to the logs analysis, the uplink UE packet transmission becomes abnormal after AMRC is enabled.
No speech packets are transmitted at 12.2 kbit/s in the uplink. All packets are silent or empty frames.
For example, BLKSize9 indicates an empty frame, and BLKSize14 indicates silent frame.

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 51

Typical Case 3 - Silence (Board)


Silence caused by DSP overload

There is silence during calls in an office with about 10% probability. This severely affects user
experience and incurs complaints from users.
Analysis:
Action 1: Check alarms. There is no exception.
Action 2: Check known problems for version and parameters. There is no exception.
Action 3: Analyze traffic measurement. The average DSP utilization is over 80%.
Conclusion: The one-way audio is caused by DSP overload. The problem is solved through DSP expansion.

DSP Usage

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

A single UE receives 100


speech frames in every 2s

Huawei Confidential

Page 52

number of discarded frames.

Typical Case 4 - Silence (CN Process)


15 seconds of silence caused by NSN CN call re-establishment

Our VIP customer experiences about 10 seconds of silence during a call, and hangs up the call.

Analysis:
Action 1: Check alarms. There is no exception.
Action 2: Check known problems for version and parameters. There is no exception.
Action 3: Analyze traffic measurement. There is no exception.
Action 4: Analyze logs. There is no exception.
Action 5: Make the fault recur and trace the call of a single UE.
Conclusion:
1)

Compare and analyze the signaling of the calling and called UEs.
The called UE experienced a call drop at 14:52:39 due to coverage problems. The call drop process appeared before one-way audio, so
the silence is related to the call drop process. However, the calling UE receives a CN link release request after 15s (14:52:54),
The one-way audio is related to the CN link release process before the call drop

2) Through confirmation with the customer and NSN, the call re-establishment function is enabled on the NSN CN.

Calling UE

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Called UE

Huawei Confidential

Page 53

Typical Case 6 - Silence and Noise (Interference)


Silence and noise caused by large-scale external burst interference

The customer's network quality is unstable. The number of speech quality complaints increases sharply, and the RRC
connection success rate fluctuates wildly.
Analysis:
Action 1: Check alarms. There is no exception.
Action 2: Check known problems for version and parameters. There is no exception.
Action 3: Analyze traffic measurement. The number of high RTWP cells changes greatly : Sometime only few cells have high RTWP, while in other
time the RTWP rises abnormally at the same time in hundreds of cells.
Conclusion: The noise is related to a high RTWP, and external interference according to RTWP trend.

Proof: Cells with a high RTWP appear in clusters and the interference has an identical origin, that is, external interference.
According to interference signal analysis, there is strong narrowband interference that falls within a 5 Mbit/s bandwidth. Test speech
quality in the time segment when interference appears. Silence and noise frequently occur and the MOS is very low. Through
interference location test, a conclusion is drawn that the silence and noise are caused by self excitation of the customer's repeater.
After the interference disappears, the RRC connection success rate and speech quality test result become normal.
HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 54

Typical Case 6 - Noise (Product Exception)


Noise caused by WBBP D board problem

In an office , Users often experience noise.

Analysis:
Action 1: Check alarms. There is no exception.
Action 2: Check known problems for version and parameters. There is no exception.
Action 3: Analyze traffic measurement. There is no exception.
Action 4: Analyze logs. During calls, the uplink BLER is very high and there are massive packet errors, but signal quality is good.

Conclusion: The downlink signal quality on the air interface is good, the uplink RTWP is normal, and there is no packet loss during Iub interface
transmission. Therefore, the noise is caused by product exceptions.
Proof: Trace the call of a single UE and make the fault recur:
1) According to single-UE CDT, the RNC receives massive consecutive Uplink erroneous frames in the time segment when speech quality is poor.
This proves that the noise is related to uplink bit error.
2) The air interface transmission quality and the Ec/No and RSCP
Therefore, equipment exception leads to uplink bit error and therefore causes noise.

in

the

measurement

report

sent

by

the

UE

are

good.

3) According to NodeB log analysis, the uplink demodulation of D board results in a decoding exception. This problem is solved in a new NodeB version.

The uplink signal quality is good,


and there are massive packet errors.

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 55

Contents
1

MOS Evaluation Standards and Principle

Factors That Affect MOS and MOS Problem Handling Process and Cases

Perceptual Speech Quality Problems

Silence and Noise Handling Process and Cases


Water Running Sound Handling Process and Cases

Appendix: Speech Quality Delivery Guide

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 56

Water Running Sound Problems

What is water running sound? Please play the attached voice file.

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 57

Water Running Sound Detection and


Adjustment Principle

Water running sound detection is implemented in the RNC. Detect IUUP packets by using AMR encoding and decoding algorithms. Extract
key parameter information, for example, Linear Spectrum Frequency (LSF) and adaptive codebook index from three AMR sub-streams.

Check the incorrect mode at 3.4 KHz20 KHz based on certain rules. If the number of continuously detected nonconformities reaches a
threshold (for example, 7 abnormal frames out of 50), report the water running sound.

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 58

Water Running Sound Detection and Adjustment Function

In the processes that involve encryption information configuration or reconfiguration, such as AMR speech service setup, DRD, hard
handover, and cell update, the service data encryption and decryption parameter hyper frame number (HFN) may be set with different
values on RNC and UE sides, leading to water running sound. The water running sound detection and adjustment function aims to
accurately detect the water running sound in the scenarios above by using a specific detection algorithm and to eliminate the water
running sound when the difference of HFNs on RNC and UE sides is 1.

If ucSpeechNoiseStatus Report is a non-zero value in the CS service information in the PCHR RAB information block, there is water
running sound on calls. The time when water running sound is detected is also recorded and needs to be converted.

As shown in the figure below, the noise start time 321586992 is converted into a hexadecimal string 132B0730 where every two digits in the
same color represent Hour:Minute:Second (Tick) respectively. 132B0730 is converted into a time format 19:43:07:(48).

Enable the CS DRD compatibility switch and the water running sound detection and adjustment function to avoid noise and
improve user perception.

CS DRD compatibility switch:

SET UCORRMALGOSWITCH: CMPSWITCH=CMP_UU_AMR_DRD_HHO_COMPAT_SWITCH-1;

Water running sound adjustment switch:

SET UDPUCFGDATA: AMRNOISECORRECTSWITCH=ON;

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 59

Typical Case Water Running Sound (Configuration)


Water running sound caused by incorrect configuration

There is water running sound on calls in an office.

Analysis:
Step 1: Check known problems for version and parameters

The version is R13SPH510.

The DRD HHO CMP switch is enabled on the live network. (SET UCORRMALGOSWITCH:
CmpSwitch=CMP_UU_AMR_DRD_HHO_COMPAT_SWITCH-1;)

The SRB OVER H switch is also enabled (SET UFRCCHLTYPEPARA: SrbChlType=HSPA;), so the DRD HHO CMP switch is disabled.
Conclusion: The water running sound is cased by incorrect parameter configuration.
Proof:
(1) According to single-UE CDT, the CS service makes a DRD and the compatibility problem is not mitigated.

(2) According to signaling, identify the reason why DRD is not made. The UE originates a PS service request. An SRB is established on UPA.
The RB5 of TRB is released, and then the PS service is released.

(3) The SRB is not released, and no Iu interface is released. The UE originates a CS service, but RRC is not needed. In this case, DRD and hard
handover cannot be implemented. Therefore, the compatibility switch cannot be enabled.

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 60

Contents
1

MOS Evaluation Standards and Principle

Factors That Affect MOS and MOS Problem Handling Process and Cases

Perceptual Speech Quality Problems

Silence and Noise Handling Process and Cases


Water Running Sound Handling Process and Cases

Appendix: Speech Quality Deliverables

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 61

Speech Quality Related Parameters


Check script parameters:
Type

MML Command

Parameter ID

Default/Recommended/Baseline Value

Encryption Mode
AMRC

SET UUEA
SET UAMRC

EncryptionAlgo
DlThdE1

UEA0-1&UEA1-1
50

Broadband AMRC

SET UAMRCWB

DlThdE1

50

Speech Activating Factor

SET UADMCTRL

UlAmrConvAF

50

Speech QOS

SET QOSACT

AMRQosPerform

NO

Redirection

SET REDIRECTION

TRAFFICTYPE

AMR

Measurement Quality

SET UQUALITYMEAS

UlAmrTrigTime6A1

D320

Congestion Setting

SET UCALLSHOCKCTRL

SysAmrRrcNum

60

Alarm Setting

SET UKPIALMTHD

AmrRabEstabSuccRatioThd

60

Admission Control

ADD UCELLCAC

UlNonCtrlThdForAMR

75

Load Control

ADD UCELLLDR

DlLdrAMRRateReductionRabNum

HHO Physical Channel


Reconfiguration Timer

SET USTATETIMER

HoPhychRecfgTmr

5000

For the complete Baseline Settings of Speech Quality Related Parameters, see related deliverables.
HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 62

Speech Quality Related Switches


Check script parameters:
Type
TFO/TrFO
TFO/TrFO
AMRC

MML Command

SET
UCORRMALGOSW CfgSwitch
ITCH
CsSwitch

AMRC
DTX

CmpSwitch

VOIP service
Water running
sound
Automatic Noise
Correction Switch
(R13)
CS Link
Reestablishment
Switch

Bitmap

Default/Recommen
ded/Baseline Value

CFG_DL_BLIND_DETECTION_SWI
TCH

Parameter ID

CS_IUUP_V2_SUPPORT_SWITCH
CS_AMRC_SWITCH
CS_ZERO_C_AMR_CFG_TWO_CO
DCH_SWITCH
CMP_UU_AMR_SID_MUST_CFG_S
WITCH
CMP_UU_VOIP_UP_PROC_AS_NO
RMAL_PS_SWITCH
CMP_UU_AMR_DRD_HHO_COMPA
T_SWITCH

SET
UDPUCFGDATA
SET
URRCTRLSWITCH

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

AmrNoiseCorrectSwit
ch

1
0
0
0
1
0

off

RsvdPara1=RSVDBIT1_BIT24

Huawei Confidential

Page 63

Summary of Deliverables
For handling of speech quality problems including
MOS improvement and user complaints, see the
Guide to Troubleshooting Speech Quality.

For script parameters related to speech quality, see


the UMTS Parameter Check.

Offer the WCDMA Speech Quality Feedback


Checklist for frontline engineers to feed back
speech quality problems. For detail, see the
Analysis Report on MOS Problems in the XX Project.

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.

Huawei Confidential

Page 64

Thank you
www.huawei.com

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen