Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
byBillMcKibben
07/12/15
Source: Deep
Economy web site
Professor Wayne Hayes
Purpose
Theintentofthispresentationis
toguidethestudentthrough
DeepEconomybyBillMcKibben.
Theauthorbringsasubtledesigntothebook.
Trytograsphismessages.
Hestartswithavigorouscritiqueofeconomicgrowth
andmovestolocalismandcivilsocietyorganizations
asanalternativetoeconomicglobalization.
07/12/15
These themes
build an eco-economy.
1. Questioning growth derived from exports
2. Development > growth: Do better with less.
3. Promoting local economies around diversity and
within Nature.
07/12/15
07/12/15
07/12/15
07/12/15
07/12/15
07/12/15
10
Context:CosmopolitanLocalism
TothinkofBillMcKibbenasparochialbecauseheeatslocally,asin
chaptertwo,wouldmisshispoint.HestartsinVermont,butendsup
inAfghanistan,Bangladesh,India,andChina.Hegoesglobalwiththe
simplelessonsoflocaleconomies.Hebringstolifemanyofthe
themesthatcombineecology,economics,community,andethics.
Thatiswhatyoushouldtakeawayhere.
RememberthequotefromWendellBerrythatexplainedthatthework
ofsustainabilityissmallandhumble.McKibbendemonstratesthat
pointanddedicatesthisunpretentiousbooktohisfriend,Wendell
Berry.
McKibbenclaimsthatcommunityandlocalizationprovidethe
antidotetoeconomicgrowthbasedonglobalization.
07/12/15
11
ContextofDeepEconomy
1. Questioningthesystemicimperativetogrowthisfundamentalto
WorldSustainability.Wehavequestionedeconomicgrowthand
identifiedmuchoftheglobalcrisisonthedynamicsofgrowth.
TheLimitstoGrowthimplicitlyprovidesanunderlying
alternativeparadigm.
2. MoreisnotalwaysBetter,apivotbasictoDeepEconomy.We
mustdistinguishbetweenqualitativedevelopmentandphysical
growth,abasictenetoftheeconomicsunderlyingsustainability.
3. McKibbenwillartfullyconnecttheglobalwiththelocalandthe
GlobalNorthwiththeGlobalSouth.Hewillarguestronglyfor
decentralizedeconomicactivitywithinadurableeconomy.
McKibbendoesnotusetheterm,butthisisallaboutworld
sustainability.
07/12/15
12
EconomicAlchemy
"Howcantheeconomybeharnessedtoservesustainability?What
makesthisquestionsoironicisthatthegrowthinthephysicalscale
oftheeconomyundertheprevailingregimeofeconomic
globalizationhasdepletedresources,destroyedecosystems,
overwhelmednaturalwastedisposalsinks,wagedwaronsubsistence
cultures,andproducedshockingmaldistributionofwealthand
income.How,then,cantheeconomybeturnedaroundtoreinforce
sustainabledevelopmentratherthantodestroyecosystems,resource
endowments,andindigenouscultures?Thisalchemymustbe
resolvedtopromotesustainability."
07/12/15
13
EconomicAlchemy(continued)
McKibbencontributestowardthatalchemy.Hechallengeshead
ontheconsensusaroundandtheideologyofeconomicgrowth,the
mantraofeconomicglobalization.Hechartsanotherpath,onebased
onlocaleconomiesandcommunity.
Onlybygettingthroughthebooktoitsconclusionscanthereader
appreciatethevisionandthedeeperanalysisthatlieshiddenby
McKibbeninthisengagingbook.
Keepanopenmindandmakethevitalconnections.
Questioninggrowth
McKibbenoffersthreeobjectionstothestandardeconomistic
treatmentofgrowth,allofwhichshouldbefamiliartoyou:
1. Theallegedgainsofgrowth(totheextentthattheyreallyexist)
notonlygototheelitesbutfailtobenefitthemajority.Thisraises
questionsofinequalityandofinsecurity.
2. Theecologicallimitstogrowtharemounting:resourcesare
beingdepleted,sinksareoverwhelmed(e.g.,CO2),andcarrying
capacityexceeded.Thisdefinestheconditionofovershoot.
3. Significantly,economicwealthdoesnotproducehappinessor
fulfillmentgrowthisoverratedonitsownterms:"growthisno
longermakingushappy"(1).ThisassertionisbasictoDeep
Economyandshouldbeessentialtowhatyoutakeawayfromthis
book.
07/12/15
15
ThemesinDeepEconomy
Notesomeofthecontrastsimpliedinthebook:
Fromglobalizationtolocalization(butwithmarkets)
Frommasssociety,massproduction,massconsumptiontolocal
communitieswithinbioregionsatanappropriatescale
Fromhyperindividualismtocosmopolitancivicengagement
Fromexclusiveemphasisonprivatepropertytowhatisshared,
thecommons
Frompoliticalexclusivitytoinclusivityarounddirectdemocracy,
suchastownmeetings
Fromhighlevelsofexternalitiestolowsocialcoststhrough
communityinvolvementthatnegotiatesbigdecisions
Fromexportmaximizationtoadiverselocalandregional
economythatdirectlyservesthelocalpopulation.
07/12/15
17
ListentoBillMcKibben
07/12/15
18
Discuss:
ThelessonsfromDeepEconomycanbeliberating.McKibben
observesthat"greaterwealthnolongermakesushappier"(2).
Youcanleadasatisfyingandmeaningfullifewithoutcovetingriches.
Youcanlivewellandleadalifeofconsequence.
Thisessentialinsightopensupopportunitiesandpossibilities.
Askyourself:Howdoesthisinsightaffectme?
Letspausetotalkaboutthisinsight.
07/12/15
19
Ch.1:AfterGrowth:mainpoints
1. Growthisahistoricalinventionmadepossiblebycoalandother
fossilfuelsthatweassociatewiththeIndustrialRevolution.We
knowthisastheAnthropocene.GrowthisenshrinedintheWest,
particularlytheUSA.(Actuallyitisthelaw:TheEmploymentAct
of1945nodepressions,please.Theprincipleofeconomic
globalizationwasembeddedintheBrettonWoodsagreement.)
2. Readcarefullytheempiricalcasemadeonpages11and12.
3. Contrastthepositionsofthesetwoeconomists,LarrySummers
(26)andBobCostanza(27),onhowtounderstandgrowth.
4. McKibbengoesinternationalinmakinghiscase,pp.3442.
07/12/15
20
Ch.2:TheYearofEatingLocally
BillMcKibbentellshisstoryofeatinglocalproduceforayearinhis
homestate,Vermont.Alongtheway,hecritiquesthefoodand
agricultureindustries.Helearnsmuchfromtheexperience.
Hemakesasubtlepoint:You,too,canchangeyourlifeforthebetter
byproducingsomeofyourownfood,eatinglocally,andeating
smart.MakessensefortheGardenState.Thinkaboutit.
McKibbenmakesfoodthebasisofrebuildingtheeconomyandthe
culturearoundlocalism.Heenrichesoursenseofplace.
Giveattentiontohisconclusion,p.94.
07/12/15
21
07/12/15
22
Intervale, CSA
07/12/15
23
07/12/15
24
Food Day
07/12/15
25
07/12/15
26
07/12/15
27
07/12/15
28
07/12/15
29
Ch.3:AllforOne,orOneforAll
AgainspeakingasaVermonter,McKibbencritiquestheerosionof
thevaluedanduniquecharacteroflocalculture.Thiscontrastswith
hisstoryoneatinglocally.
Heoffersdatatomakethecaseofthefragmentationandthe
dysfunctionalityofhyperindividualism,pp.101104.
McKibbensmessageissimplyoneofcaringandsharingaround
community.Thisisbasictopromotingsustainabilityfromthe
groundup,fromlocalroots.
07/12/15
30
Theremedy:community,convivialityand
companionship
Contrastthefarmers'marketorCommunitySupportedAgriculture
(CSA)forcommunitybuilding.McKibbenurgesthatweturntothe
localforarichercommunitylifeandculturethatcomplement
nurturingthelocaleconomy.
Toomuchstuffandnotenoughcompanionship,saysMcKibben.Shift
theemphasisfrombeingaconsumertobeingacitizen.Participate.
Leadanactive,engagedlife.Thisisbestdonewhereyouliveand
work.Connect.Starttoday.
McKibbenbasesthischapterontheworkofRichardLayard,an
economist,andhisresearchinhisbook,Happiness.Seepages108
112.
07/12/15
31
Ch.4:TheWealthofCommunities
McKibbenusestheexamplesofClearChannelandWalmartto
illustratehowcommunitiesareeclipsed,withtangiblelossesthatare
noteasytoquantify.
Hisremedy,again,istherestorationofcommunitythroughre
buildinglocaleconomicactivitiesandinstitutions.Hespeaksagainas
aloyalandpatrioticVermonter.
HecitestheNewEnglandtownmeetingandtheintermediatelevelof
scalebetweentheindividualandthecommunity.Scaleandlocalism
resonatethroughoutthischapter.
07/12/15
32
Ch.5:DurableFuture
McKibbengoescosmopolitanhere,takingusallthewayfrom
VermonttoChina.(Whatheseesisconsistentwithandoften
informedbyLesterBrown.)Somepointstoconsider:
1. Everyyear,30millionpeopleleavetheruralareasandmigrateto
overcrowdedcities.
2. Waterhasbecomethelimitofthecarryingcapacitytosupport
growth.Soilis,aswell.
3. Everyyear,Chinaaddstheequivalentofthepopulationof
Californiatoitsenergygeneratingcapacitymostlybyburning
coal.(Wewillseelaterinourcoursethatthisischanging.
4. Chinadevotes10%ofGDPtodealwiththeenvironmentalside
effectsofeconomicgrowthandtopublichealth.
5. Since2005,Chinahasbeenanetimporterofgrain.
McKibbenasksonpage187:"howonearthdoyougrowattherate
theChinesearegrowinganddon'tcollapse?"
07/12/15
Professor Wayne Hayes
33
Dasgupta:WealthasLiquidation
McKibbenquotesfromtheresearchofSirParthaDasgupta,a
UniversityofCambridgeeconomist,thatwealthindeveloping
countriesactuallydeclineswitheconomicgrowththroughoutthe
world,page190.Chinaistheonlyexception.Dasgupta'sresearch
goesfrom19651993,capturingtheheydayoftheeconomicgrowth
oftheWashingtonConsensus.
Thisdramaticpointillustratesthefailureoftheorthodoxeconomistic
growthmodel.
Ofcourse,inequalityincreasessharplywitheconomicgrowth,p195.
07/12/15
34
Othercases
McKibbenquicklyreviewsothercasesinwhicheconomic
globalizationbackfires:
Mexico:corn;
Uganda:coffee;
Iraq:seeds.
07/12/15
35
DeepEconomyisLocallyRooted
McKibbendrawsagainonhisexperienceasacitizenoftheworld.
HiscasestudyofsuccessisfoundintheNayakrishiAndolan(New
Farming)movementinGorasin,Bangladesh.
Hisreport,pages200206,culminateswithatellingexampleoflocal
knowledgeusedtoincreaseproductivitywithecoecologicalmeans.
TechnicallythiscommunitybasedsubsistenceprojectreducesGDP,
sincethefoodandrestorationisnotproducedforthemarket.(No
wonderit'scalledgrosseconomicproduct!)
07/12/15
36
China:HeiferInternational
McKibbenprovidesanothersuccessstory,pages207210.This
comesfromSichuanprovinceinChina,wheretheNGOHeifer
Internationaldonatedrabbitsandtechnicaladvice.Theresultsare
stunning.Histakeawaylesson:
"It'sthattherearewaystomakeworkableeconomiesoutofalmost
anything,ifyouthinksmallandworkthroughcommunities"(207).
McKibbencallsthis"thekeytaskofourtime"(210).
07/12/15
37
FutureGenerations
McKibben'snextcaseisFutureGenerationsanditsdevelopment
expert,DanielTaylor,fromWestVirginia.Tayloradvocatesnot
investingmoney,butmobilizingandinvestingavailablehumantime
andenergythroughacommunitydesignedworkplan.
Thecasestudy,pages211216,occursinAfghanistan,certainlya
contestedandgeopoliticallysignificantcountry,andinHimalya,
India.
HefollowsupwithKerala,India,pages218221.
McKibbenconcludeswithacontrastoftheeconomicmodelofthe
USAversusthatofEurope,oneworthyofsomeconsideration,
especiallyaswestrugglethroughourepicrecessiontoday.
07/12/15
38
Happiness Index
07/12/15
39
Afterword
Theconcludingchapterbeginswithsomeofthethemesfoundearlier
inourcourseinBrown,PlanB4.0:
1. Peakoil;
2. Globalwarming:McKibben'searlierDeathofNaturewasa
harbinger;
07/12/15
40
Conclusion
Thebookmodestlyendswiththeessentialalchemy,theinversion
withintheeconomy:
"Localeconomiescanplayanimportantroleinreducingthese(peak
oilandglobalwarming)problems."
McKibbentellsusthatthepathtoadurableeconomycanbesweet
andaddjoyandfulfillmenttoourlives.Itthreatensandriskslittle.
Hehasaddressedthesystemicfaultsofeconomicgrowth:ecocide,
inequalityandinsecurity,andunhappiness.Smallwonderwhyhe
dedicatesthisinsightfullittlebooktoWendellBerry.
07/12/15
41
07/12/15
42
07/12/15
43
Sowhatdoyouthink?
DoesMcKibbenworkforyou?
WhatdidyougetfromDeepEconomy?
07/12/15
44