Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Postposing
Preposing:
Postposing:
Two
Existential there-sentences
Presentational there-sentences
The
Previous Studies
Most
Some
Existential there
I would like to concentrate on Florida
more than anything else to show you
what we see there now. Between 1981
and 1983, there were nine bombings
and seven attempted bombings and
one kidnapping carried out by terrorist
groups or alleged terrorist groups in
the Florida area. All 17 of these
incidents were in Miami, Florida.
[Challenger Commission transcripts,
2/7/86]
Presentational there
Daniel told me that shortly after
Grumman arrived at Wideview Chalet
there arrived also a man named
Sleeman.
[Upfield 1946:246]
of any structural
differences between them, the two
types of there-sentences are
pragmatically distinct with respect
to the information status of the
PVNP.
That is, whether the information is
(taken to be) new to the discourse
or new to the hearer.
Right-Dislocation
Time
Right-Dislocation
Cant write much, as Ive been away from
here for a week and have to keep up
appearances, but did Diana mention the
desk drama? Dad took your old desk over
to her house to have it sent out, but he
didnt check to see what was in it, and
forgot that I had been keeping all my vital
documents in there like my tax returns
and paystubs and bank statements.
Luckily Diana thought that stuff looked
important so she took it out before
giving the desk over to the movers. Phew!
Shes a smart cookie, that Diana.
Right-Dislocation
The
marked NP in an RD represents
information that is familiar within
the discourse.
The
information-structural
difference between RD and theresentences is due to the presence of
the anaphoric pronoun with which
the marked constituent is
coreferential.
Existential there
Existential
there-sentences are
sensitive to hearer-familiarity as
opposed to discourse-familiarity.
The
Existential there
Theres
The
Existential there
Similarly,
Existential there
If
These
Existential there
Similarly,
Thus,
Existential there
a. A: Im home. Anything interesting happen today?
B: Not really. Theres a dog running loose
somewhere in the neighborhood.
b. A: Have you seen the dog or the cat around?
B: Not lately. #Theres the dog running
loose somewhere in the neighborhood.
c. A: Have you seen the dog or the cat around?
B: Not lately. The dog is running loose somewhere
in the neighborhood.
When
the dog being referred to is hearernew, the use of the existential is acceptable
However, where the dog is hearer-old, the
use of the existential is infelicitous.
is it really, as we have argued, the hearerold information status of the PVNP thats
responsible for the infelicity?
Or is it, as others have argued, the morphosyntactic definiteness of the PVNP?
A: Im home. Anything interesting happen today?
B: Not really. Theres the funniest-looking dog
running
loose somewhere in the neighborhood .
Here
That
It
Note
That
Summary
Both
hearer-old/discourse-new PVNPs
and hearer-old/discourse-old PVNPs
are infelicitous in existential theresentences.
Hearer-Old
Hearer-New
Discourse-Old
Infelicitous
Discourse-New
Infelicitous
Felicitous
Thus,
Presentational theresentences
The
The
Presentational
Presentational theresentences
Presentational theresentences
b.
c.
Presentational theresentences
The
Moreover,
However,
Presentational theresentences
So,
Presentational theresentences
While
Presentational theresentences
a.
b.
Presentational theresentences
While
The
Presentational theresentences
Where
Discourse-new,
hearer-old PVNPs
disallowed in existential there, but not
presentational there:
I have some interesting news for you. At
todays press conference there appeared
President Bush.
I have some interesting news for you. #At
todays press conference there was
President Bush.
Presentational theresentences
Here,
As
We
However,
The
Instead,
Definiteness: An Example
the man sitting next to me on the train
For
That
We
In
It
Note
In
Since
Although
Since
Other
With
The
A Final Example of
Individuation
Again,
That
Right-Dislocation
Like
However,
Right-Dislocation
The
For
Since
Right-Dislocation
An
RD
Right-Dislocation
It
Information
Right-Dislocation
When
Here,
Thus,
However,
RD
In
to this morpho-syntactic
difference between RD and there-sentences is
a functional difference; RD is subject to an
entirely different pragmatic constraint:
In
Since
Thus,