Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Cases
Johanna M. Manzo
Ena M. Macabatao
Emily F. Rico
Reporters
F
O
T
C
E
L
G
E
N
S
S
O
Y
GR
T
DU
Respondent:
ALICIA K.
PAGADUAN
Complainant:
Comission on
Audit
On
July
23,
2009,
Pagaduan sent a letter to
the CSC-NCR requesting
that the case against her
for Gross Neglected of Duty
be dismissed.
DECISION
The administrative case
for Gross Neglect of
Duty filed against Alicia
K.
Pagaduan,
then
Cashier II ( now Chief
Administrative Officer),
Finance Division, DSWDNCR, Manila is hereby
DISMISSED.
APPEAL:
DISHONESTY AND
FALSIFICATION OF OFFICIAL
DOCUMENTS
RESPONDENT:
LILIBETH N.
RUBA
COMPLAINANT
: LAND BANK
OF THE
PHILIPPINES
The respondent committed the wrongful acts in 1998 while she was
still a contractual employee hired from the DBP Service Corp. She
was appointed a permanent employee of the Bank on March 1,
1999 as it appears that the Branch management was unaware of
her wrong-doings at that time.
The Respondents appeal for mercy and that she be meted out the
penalty of Reprimand may not be granted because:
Recommendation
Respondent Lilibeth N. Ruba be found guilty of Dishonesty and
Falsification of Official Documents and meted out the penalty of
DISMISSAL with forfeiture of retirement benefits."
financial distress
of her family in
the wake of the
huge expenses
attendant to the
medical treatment
of her sister, who
was allegedly
suffering from
congenital rheumatic
DECISION
The appeal of Lilibeth N. Ruba is hereby
dismissed. The decision of the Land Bank
of the Philippines (LBP) subject of the
present appeal is sustained in all respects.
Further, the LBP is directed to institute
against Ruba criminal action warranted
under the circumstances.
APPEAL: INSUBORDINATION
RESPONDENT
:
DELIA GARCIA
COMPLAINANT:
RODOLFO
NAYGA
To travel on
official Business
and to travel on
official time have
the same effect,
as when one
goes on leave
The
formal investigation
thereafter ensued, and on
May 24, 2000, the CSCRO
No. II issued a decision
finding Garcia guilty of
Insubordination
and
imposed upon her the penalty
of fine equivalent to her one
month salary. Garcia moved
for a reconsideration but the
same was denied by the
CSCRO No. II in a decision
dated September 12, 2000.
DECISIO
N
The appeal of Delia G. Garcia is hereby GRANTED.
Accordingly, the Decisions dated May 24, 2000, and
September 13, 2000, of the Civil Service Commission
Regional Office No. II are REVERSED and SET
ASIDE, and Delia G. Garcia is EXONERATED of the
charge of Insubordination. If Garcia was made to pay
a fine equivalent to her one (1) month salary, it is
ordered that she be restituted said amount.
Thank
you !!!