2 Ethical Theories

Ethical theories
Lecture 2, MS008A
Kirsten Ribu - Siri Fagernes - HiO 2005
Today
Ethical Theories of
Duty (Kant)
Virtue (Aristotle)
Consequence (Utilitarianism) John Stuart
Mill
Kirsten Ribu - Siri Fager

nes - HiO 2005
Ethical theories
The formal study of ethics goes back to

the greek philosopher Socrates.
Philosophers have proposed many
ethical theories
Why study these theories?
A useful ethical theory makes it possible

for us to examine moral problems, reach
conclusions through logical resoning and
defend the conclusions.
nes - HiO 2005
Moral Truths
Are there certain moral truths?
Human rights
The law of nature: the behaviour and doings of
humans that enable us to develop the potential
and talents that nature has given us
Deeds that create peace and harmony between
people
Moral truths are those that are accepted by
many people, despite differences in culture and
religion
nes - HiO 2005
The problems of Ethical

Behaviour
Not always a question of what is difficult to

decide, that is, the difference between right
and wrong, good and bad
Sometimes we are tempted to do something
knowing that it is not right
There is a thing called common sense
Although: Common sense is not so
common
nes - HiO 2005
Example
An obviously good deed: The classical

seeing an old woman across the road.
We do this good deed, encounter a friend
who says. Why did you do that? You have
other things to do, dont waste your time,
you should be out there making money!
The problem: You are forced to defend your
good deed.
The deed in itself is good, unquestionably.
nes - HiO 2005
Turning the tables
When the person doing good is made to

answer
Hypothesis: The scandals of WorldCom and
Enron.
Figures were manipulated, the people on
the inside got away with fortunes before the
crash
What if the responsible had said: No, we
will not do it. It is wrong! With no further
explanation.
nes - HiO 2005
How does it really work?
Many large companies today are being

pressured into acting morally
They are forced to take ethics seriously, as
a part of their culture
Attitudes change ethics are placed higher
than profit
Corruption will be more easily revealed
Insight: Good ethics will pay in the long run!
nes - HiO 2005

nes - HiO 2005
The Ethics of Duty

nes - HiO 2005
10
Immanuel Kant (1724 -1804).
Immanuel Kant was born at Knigsberg in East

Prussia, 22 April, 1724; died there, 12 February,
1804.
There are two periods of Kant's literary activity. The
first, the pre-critical period, extends from 1747 to
1781, the date of the epoch-making "Kritik der
reinen Vernunft"; the second, the critical period,
extends from 1781 to 1794.
Good Will and the Categorical Imperative
Peoples actions should be governed by moral laws
that are universal
Principles of morality must be based on reason
Kantianism explains why an action is right or wrong,
does not just state
that
so.
Kirsten
Ribuit -is
Siri
Fager
11
nes - HiO 2005
Good will
The only thing that can be called good

without qualification.
Is not the same as good deeds, but good in
itself.
Intelligence and courage are good qualities,
but can be used in harmful way: robbing
banks, fraud etc.
Focus is on what we ought to do, not what
we want to do =dutifulness = acting in a
certain way according to moral rules.
nes - HiO 2005
12
The Categorical Imperative
First formulation: Moral rules =

universal laws. Act only from moral
rules that you can at the same time will
to become universal laws.
Second formulation: Act so that you
always treat both yourself and other
people as ends in themselves, and
never only as a means to an end.
Example: The Carla case
nes - HiO 2005
13
The Carla story

nes - HiO 2005
14
Analysis:
Plagiarism evaluated using the

Categorical Imperative:
First formulation: Use the rule: I can

claim credit for a report written by
someone else. Reports would cease to
be valid as indicators of knowledge if
everyone followed this rule.
Second formulation: Carla is using her
professor as means to an end.
nes - HiO 2005
15
Utilitarianism (Theory of
Consequence)
A philosophy that is in contrast to duty ethics

Jeremy Bentham (1748-1832) and John Stuart
Mill (1806-1873) (english philosophers)
Two philosophies:
Act utilitarianism- an action is good if its overall effect is to

produce more happiness than unhappiness
Rule utilitarianism We ought to adopt those moral rules
which if everyone follows them, lead to greater increase in
total happiness
Utilitarianism by John Stuart Mill:

http://www.utilitarianism.com/mill1.htm
nes - HiO 2005
16
Utilitarianism
Utilitarianism (from the Latin utilis, useful)

is a theory of ethics based on quantitative
maximization of some good for society or
humanity.
It is a form of consequentialism.
This good is often happiness or pleasure,
Utilitarianism is sometimes summarized as
"The greatest happiness for the greatest
number."
Wikipedia
nes - HiO 2005
17
Cont
The philosopher John Stuart Mill:

[Utilitarianism is ] the creed which
accepts as the foundation of morals, utility
or the greatest happiness principle, holds
that actions are right in proportion as they
tend to promote happiness, wrong as they
tend to produce the reverse of happiness.
By happiness is intended pleasure and
the absence of pain; by unhappiness,
pain and the privation of pleasure
(Utilitarianism, ii, 1863).
nes - HiO 2005
18
Hume
The philosopher Hume did not see any religious

source or sanction of morality in utilitarianism
In his Inquiry concerning the Principles of
Morals (1751) he carried out an extensive
analysis of the various judgments which we
pass upon our own character and conduct and
on those of others
He drew the conclusion that virtue and
personal merit consist in those qualities
which are useful to ourselves and others.

nes - HiO 2005
19
Act Utilitarianism
Principles of Utility
An action has nothing to do with the
attitude behind the action
Bentham: No motive is in itself a
bad one. If motives are good or bad,
it is because of their effects.

nes - HiO 2005
20
Pros and cons of act

Utilitarianism
Pro:
It focuses on happiness
It is down to earth where to build a prison,
where to treat drug-addicts- the metadon
programme (but: Not in my back yard)
Con:
It is not practical- too much energy goen into

every moral decision
Ignores our sense of duty
The problem of moral luck the effect decides
whether the action is moral or not
nes - HiO 2005
21
Rule Utilitarianism
Weaknesses of Act Utilitarianism has lead

to Rule Utilitarianism
Everyone should follow rules that lead to
the greatest increase in total happiness
Applies the principle of happiness to the
effect of moral rules, act utilitarianism
applies the principles to individual actions
Focuses on rules like duty ethics:
Rules should be followed without exception

Rule utilitarianism looks at the consequenses
Duty ethics looks at the will motivating the action
nes - HiO 2005
22
Rule Utilitarianism - pros and

cons
Pro:
General consequences on society by adopting a universal

rule
Solves the problem of moral luck the occasional atypical
result does not affect the goodness of an action
Example sending flowers to a sick person is always a
good action (even though she may be allergic to
flowers)
Con:
We must use a single scale to evaluate completely

different kinds of consequences for instance building a
new motorway: cost and benefit in money, vs people
losing their homes
Think of more cons!
nes - HiO 2005
23
Virtue Ethics
Virtue ethics may be identified as the one

that emphasizes the virtues, or moral
character
In contrast to the approach which
emphasizes duties or rules (duty,
deontology)
or that which emphasizes the consequences
of actions (consequentialism).
nes - HiO 2005
24
Virtue ethics
In philosophy, the phrase virtue

ethics refers to ethical systems that
focus primarily on what sort of person
one should try to be.
According to virtue ethicists the aim of
all humans is to lead a good, happy
and fulfilling life.
nes - HiO 2005
25
Example
Suppose it is obvious that someone in need

should be helped:
A utilitarian will point to the fact that the

consequences of doing so will maximise wellbeing
A deontologist to the fact that, in doing so the
agent will be acting in accordance with a moral
rule such as "Do unto others as you would be
done by
A virtue ethicist to the fact that helping the
person would be charitable or benevolent.
nes - HiO 2005
26
Honesty
An honest person cannot be identified

simply as one who always tells the truth,
for one can have the virtue of honesty
without being tactless or indiscreet.
The honest person recognises "That would
be a lie" as a strong reason for not making
certain statements in certain circumstances

nes - HiO 2005
27
Relativism
There are no universal moral norms of

right and wrong
Different people/groups of people can
have opposite views of a moral
problem both can be right.
Two kinds of relativism:
Subjective relativism
Cultural relativism
nes - HiO 2005
28
Subjective relativism:
pro and con
Pro:
Each person creates his/her own
morality ( example: views on abortion).
If morality is relative, we do not have
to agree for instance if abortion is
right or wrong. Both sides are right.

nes - HiO 2005
29
Continued
Con:
A line of defense for doing what you want to do:

Who are you to tell me what to do and what not to
do? Morality = doing what you want to do
Doing what you want as long as it does not hurt
anybody: What does it mean to harm somebody?
The question is NOT subjective!
Tolerance is not the same as subjective relativism.
Does being tolerant mean that you accept that
others are intolerant, racist etc:
Relativism = no universal rules.

People ought to be tolerant = a universal rule.
Inconsistant.
nes - HiO 2005
30
Cultural relativism
Different views of right and wrong held by different

societies
The meaning of right and wrong rest with a societys
moral guideines
Right and wrong varies in time and place
Example: Circumcision of African women
Anthropologists have defended a cultures right to stick to

tradition
Cultural differences concerning truthfulness, stealing

and cheating:
Example: testifying to lower speed after a car accident.

90% of Norwegians would not, 10 % of Yugoslavians would
not. (Ethics for the Information age. Michael Quinn)
nes - HiO 2005
31
Cultural Relativism pro
Different social contexts demand different

moral guidelines
It is arrogant for one society to judge another
we have more technology than others, but
we are not better, more intelligent, more
moral etc.
Morality is reflected in actual behaviour: Do
as I say, do not do what I do but does this
work?
nes - HiO 2005
32
Cultural relativism: cons
Different views on right and wrong does not imply

that there ought to be different views
Societies share core values, therefore, they may

exist a universal ethical theory opposing cultural
relativism. Examples of core values:
Example: How to solve the drought problem:

Aquaduct vs. sacrifice to rain gods
care for newborn,

not telling lies,
prohibition against murder.
Moral guidelines are a result of tradition, not

necessarily based on reason.
nes - HiO 2005
33
Next week
Censorship and Freedom of Speech.

Intellectual Property.
Privacy.
Excercises: Find examples of good ethical conduct.
Use Wikipedia to find out more about ethics of duty,
consequence and virue, and criticism of these
theories. Write a page or so about the likenesses
and differences in these three theories.
To be discussed in class.

nes - HiO 2005
34

2 Ethical Theories

Hochgeladen von

Dokumentinformationen

Originalbeschreibung:

Copyright

Verfügbare Formate

Dieses Dokument teilen

Dokument teilen oder einbetten

Freigabeoptionen

Stufen Sie dieses Dokument als nützlich ein?

Sind diese Inhalte unangemessen?

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

2 Ethical Theories

Hochgeladen von

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

Ethical theories

Kirsten Ribu - Siri Fagernes - HiO 2005

Kirsten Ribu - Siri Fager

The formal study of ethics goes back to

A useful ethical theory makes it possible

Are there certain moral truths?

The problems of Ethical

Not always a question of what is difficult to

An obviously good deed: The classical

Turning the tables

When the person doing good is made to

How does it really work?

Many large companies today are being

Kirsten Ribu - Siri Fager

The Ethics of Duty

Kirsten Ribu - Siri Fager

Immanuel Kant (1724 -1804).

Immanuel Kant was born at Knigsberg in East

The only thing that can be called good

The Categorical Imperative

First formulation: Moral rules =

The Carla story

Kirsten Ribu - Siri Fager

Plagiarism evaluated using the

First formulation: Use the rule: I can

A philosophy that is in contrast to duty ethics

Act utilitarianism- an action is good if its overall effect is to

Utilitarianism by John Stuart Mill:

Utilitarianism (from the Latin utilis, useful)

The philosopher John Stuart Mill:

The philosopher Hume did not see any religious

Kirsten Ribu - Siri Fager

Kirsten Ribu - Siri Fager

Pros and cons of act

It is not practical- too much energy goen into

Weaknesses of Act Utilitarianism has lead

Rules should be followed without exception

Rule Utilitarianism - pros and

General consequences on society by adopting a universal

We must use a single scale to evaluate completely

Virtue ethics may be identified as the one

In philosophy, the phrase virtue

Suppose it is obvious that someone in need

A utilitarian will point to the fact that the

An honest person cannot be identified

Kirsten Ribu - Siri Fager

There are no universal moral norms of

Kirsten Ribu - Siri Fager

A line of defense for doing what you want to do:

Relativism = no universal rules.

Different views of right and wrong held by different

Anthropologists have defended a cultures right to stick to

Cultural differences concerning truthfulness, stealing

Example: testifying to lower speed after a car accident.

Cultural Relativism pro

Different social contexts demand different

Cultural relativism: cons

Different views on right and wrong does not imply

Societies share core values, therefore, they may

Example: How to solve the drought problem:

care for newborn,

Moral guidelines are a result of tradition, not

Censorship and Freedom of Speech.