Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
IN PAKISTAN
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The Source of the Facts, Figures, Viewpoints,
Arguments, etc., contained in this Presentation
is:
(A)
HISTORICAL BACKGROUND
o British appointed a Partition Committee
and an Arbitral Tribunal (life up to 31-031948) to resolve all issues arising out of
territorial division of Indus Basin waters
o On 01-04-1948 India cut off supplies in
every canal crossing into Pakistan
supplies restored on
04-05-1948 after
signing a joint statement
o But the dispute remained alive until signing
of Indus Basin Waters Treaty on 19-09-1960
between India and Pakistan through the 4
SALIENT PROVISIONS - I
o Supplies of three eastern rivers
Sutlej, Ravi & Beas unrestricted use
of India
o Supplies of three western rivers
Chenab, Jhelum & Indus unrestricted
use of Pakistan
o Transition period 10+3 years India
will release for Pakistan specified
quantity of waters of eastern rivers
no claim of Pakistan afterwards
SALIENT PROVISIONS - II
o Pakistan to construct Replacement
Works from Western Rivers & India to
pay 62 M to Pakistan
o Exchange of data between India-Pak
w.r.t. flow and utilization of Indus basin
waters
o Permanent Indus Commission
Commissioners (2) for settling matters
arising out of treaty
o Settlement of disputes by the
(B)
WATER
APPORTIONMENT
ACCORD (WAA), 1991
9
BACKGROUND
o
o
11
(C)
KALABAGH DAM PROJECT
(KBD)
NOTE:
The argument, in the presentation, largely supports
version of smaller provinces, particularly Sindh.
However, version of WAPDA / Punjab has also been
discussed. The candidates may take any stance, as per
their desire, but that should be properly substantiated.
12
OBJECTIVES
o The OBJECTIVES of the Project
as per WAPDA Version:
o Generate low cost hydroelectric power
near major load centers;
o Compensate for storage lost due to
silting up of existing reservoirs;
o Regulate and control the extreme flood
peaks;
13
14
PROJECT BENEFITS
o Project Benefits as per WAPDA Version
are:
APPREHENSIONS OF
NWFP
16
RESERVATIONS OF SINDH - I
o River flows are variable & declining
1 UN Environment Programme
2 Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change
17
RESERVATIONS OF SINDH - II
o Thus, if the dam is constructed it can
only be filled every 4 / 5 years.
investment!) or
o effort will be made to fill it every year to
recover the investment of US$ 15-17 B
o RESULT?
o Irrigation water supplies to Sindh will be
reduced;
18
19
RESERVATIONS OF SINDH IV
20
POSSIBILITY OF
RAPPROCHEMENT
WAY FORWARD - I
o The objectives are irrigation and power
generation.
WAY FORWARD - II
o
23
24
CONCLUSION
o
o
o
(D)
BAGHLIAR DAM
(CONFLICT WITH INDIA)
26
BACKGROUND
o In order to fill Baghliar Dam (on
Chenab River), India withheld 0.2
MAF water affecting supplies to
Marala Barrage
o Stored water from Mangla dam was
released to meet the demand of
fields in the Punjab
o Dams accrue benefits to upper
riparian areas while badly affect the
lower riparian areas therefore, the
27
CONFLICT RESOLUTION
o
COMPENSATION - I
o Claim of compensation very
complicated. Pakistan will have to
establish that:
barrage;
this shortage was caused due to filling of
Baghliar dam;
the losses accrued due to this shortage;
this much (claimed) loss has been
sustained by Pakistan
COMPENSATION - II
o
CONCLUSION
o
36