Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
ASSESSMENT
PARVATI-TALJAI
BY:
DIVYA BHANDARI
HINAL PAREKH
MAITREYEE JOSHI
PRASHANSHA
SRIVASTAVA
CHAULA TRIVEDI
LOCATION
MAHARASHTRA, PUNE
PARVATI-TALJAI STRETCH
PUNE
KNOW AS OXFORD OF THE EAST, AND CULTURAL CAPITAL OF
MAHARASHTRA
THE CENTRE OF TRADITIONAL MARATHI CULTURE AND KNOWN AS
THE SILICON VALLEY OF INDIA.
IT HAS ONE OF INDIA'S OLDEST UNIVERSITIES AND ITS NUMEROUS
COLLEGES ATTRACT BOTH INDIAN AND INTERNATIONAL STUDENTS.
CLIMATE
: MODERATE
HUMIDITY
: 40% TO 60%
PREVAILING WIND DIRECTION : WEST
TEMPERATURE RANGE
: 15C TO 35C
PUNE ECOLOGY
Considering the pace at which cities are expanding within a phenomenon called urbanization, we
need to ask if urban biodiversity really stand a chance of survival?
Any urban environment is a composite of every single natural and manmade unit.
Trees, birds, streams, open land, hills, water bodies, parks, lakes, institutional areas, public
areas, built-up areas and other open spaces are all part of the urban environment.
Pune city is endowed with a diverse and rich network of ecosystems. These provide
important ecological services for biodiversity, waste and pollution treatment, climate,
water and flood management.
PUNE ECOLOGY
PUNE ECOLOGY
Currently, the urban environment and the biodiversity of Pune are being threatened by
haphazard and poorly planned urban development.
Migration into the city has also increased, and the current facilities and infrastructure are
inadequate.
Pune also ranks as the thirteenth most pollute (air) city of India as per the Environment
Status Report (2006-2007) of the Pune Municipal Corporation.
PUNE ECOLOGY
PUNE ECOLOGY
1998
The vegetation on these hills supports nearly a fifth of the butterfly species.
These hills also exclusively host over a sixth of the bird species of Pune.
These are the lungs of the city as they clean up the air and the environment through their
complex ecological functioning.
PUNE ECOLOGY
PUNE ECOLOGY
PARVATI HILL:
Parvati Hill, a hillock located in Pune city in Maharashtra. Parvati hill covers the conical hill
along with the forest area behind called Pachgaon Parvati. It has historic, ecological and
cultural importance.
It has history of 250 years. The hillock rises up to 2,100 feet
(640 m) above sea level. Atop the hillock is the Parvati
Temples, which are one of the most scenic locations in Pune.
The temple is the oldest heritage structure in Pune and was
built in the Peshwa Dynasty rule. It is also used as an
observation spot for visitors of thepanorama of Pune.
It is the second highest point in Pune premises (after Vetal
Hill). Parvati isthe daily visiting place for a number of citizens
and for many people, going to Parvati (103 steps) forms a part
of their daily exercise routine.
In recent years it is started to fade away its beauty with growing
slum area around the hill. Forest cover on the Pachgaon Parvati is
decreasing day by day. The area needs development in
sustainable manner which will help to become the place as one of
the important tourism destination.
The Parvati gates open at 5.00 am and close at 8.00 pm. There are 103 steps to reach the
hilltop. The steps are an example of fine stone work of the Maratha period.
A special black quarry stone has been used for all these steps. It is weather-resistant and
except for a few places, the stone has survived for over two hundred and fifty years even
after being fully exposed to sun, wind and water .
There are 5 temples on the hill which includes Devdeveshwar temple, Vishnu
Temple, Kartikeya Temple, Shri Vittal Temple and Ramana Temple.
Temple complex
Temple complex
TALJAI HILL:
Taljai Hills is extending southern part of Parvati hill. The total area of the Parvati- Taljai hills is
about 4.25 sq.km. The hill is lush green during the monsoons. Panoramic view of Pune City
from the hill top is easily seen.
Environmental importance:
Taljai hill includes forestry with variety of trees. It also includes
variety of animals and birds.
Ela Foundation, a city-based non-governmental organization, has
recorded more than 300 species of flora and fauna, as well as
133 species of birds in 94 genera and 44 families in these hills.
A comprehensive checklist of several other taxa, a group of one
or
More populations of organisms, recorded at Taljai-Waghjai
foothills. These include 15 species of mammals, five of
amphibians, at least 13 of reptiles, butterflies, scorpions and
spiders, odonates, and flora. (Times of India April 17, 2013)
The hills provide for several winter migratory birds. Five species of birds recorded in the
foothills are endemic to India and are found nowhere else in the world.
Another species of mammals is native to the Indian subcontinent. Many of them are
sensitive to disturbances and will be forced to leave this habitat if there is traffic, noise and
pollution.
DEMOGRAPHIC COMPARISON:
PRIMARY DATA
Sushil Shah Nidhi Deshpande Namita Sharma Preksha Bohra Kamlesh Patel Arun Tripathi
32
24
28
19
45
52
yes
weekends
yes
weekend
yes
yes
morning
morning
evening
morning
both
morning
Nearby
Karve Road
Nearby
Nearby
Nearby
Swargate
Walking
Four Wheeler
Walking
Walking
Walking
Two wheeler
1-1.5 Hrs
2 Hrs
1 Hrs
1 Hrs
1-1.5 Hrs
2 Hrs
Jogging
Walking
Walking
Hangout
Yoga/Exercise
Walking
yes
yes
yes
no
yes
yes
sometimes no
sometimes
yes
yes
no
entry
entry
sometimes yes/peacock
no
yes/peacock
sometimes
yes/peacock
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
yes
yes
yes
no
no
no
no
yes
no
yes
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
alone
alone
alone
alone
alone
alone
yes
yes
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
yes
yes
dont know
dont know
I think yes
dont know
yes
no
yes
no
yes
no
yes
no
yes
no
yes
yes
PRIMARY DATA
Sandeep Verma
Pallavi kulkarni
Deepak Patil
Mohit Chaudhary
48
26
55
29
yes
thrice
yes
rarely
both
evening
morning
evening
Nearby
Tilak Road
Satara Road
Satara Road
Walking
Four Wheeler
Four Wheeler
Four Wheeler
30- 40 Min
30 Min
30- 40 Min
1-1.5 Hrs
Walking
Yoga
Yoga
Badminton
yes
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
sometimes
no
entry
entry
entry
sometimes
no
no
yes/Hoopooe
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
yes
no
yes
no
no
yes
no
yes
yes
no
yes
yes
yes
no
yes
alone
friends
friends
alone
no
yes
yes
yes
no
no
yes
no
no
no
yes
no
dont know
yes
dont know
I think yes
no
no
yes
no
yes
no
no
no
INTRODUCTION:
ENVIORNMENTAL IMPACT OCCURS DUE TO :
WATER
AIR
LAND
SECONDARY INFORMATION:
BIRDS OF THE PARVATI HILLS
ENVIORNMENTAL IMPACT
DUE TO FLORA
NOISE
FAUNA
Jasminum malabaricum
Habaneria grandiflorifloris
LAND ENVIRONMENT
Questionnaire
YES
NO
IMPACT
IMAGE
MINOR
MODERATE
MAJOR
MITIGATION
TREE PLANTATION
WASTE DISPOSAL
PROPER CONSTRUCTION
WASTE MANAGEMENT
TREE PLANTATION
CHECKLIST METHOD
LAND ENVIRONMENT
MAGNITUDE
SIGNIFICANCE
ACTIVITY
CONSTRUCTION
ACTIVITIES
VISITOR ACTIVITIES
COMMERCIAL ACTIVITIES
PLANTATION OF TREES
MATRICES
WASTE DISPOSAL
19
7
13
15
-12
LAND ENVIRONMENT
ANALYSIS:
LAND ENVIRONMENT AT PARVATI AND TALJAI IS EXTREMELY IMPORTANT FOR THE SUSTAINANCE
OF THE FLORA AND FAUNA.
CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES OF RESTING PERGOLAS AND BUIDINGS ARE PREVALENT ENROUTE
TALJAI CAUSING SIGNIFICANT IMPACT ON SOIL THROUGH EROSION AND SOIL QUALITY.
ENDOPEDONIC (INSIDE THE SOIL) ANIMALS ARE CONSIDERED WITH RESPECT TO TWELVE
ACTIVITIES: MOUNDING, MIXING, FORMING VOIDS, BACK-FILLING VOIDS, FORMING AND
DESTROYING PEDS, REGULATING SOIL EROSION, REGULATING MOVEMENT OF WATER AND AIR IN
SOIL, REGULATING PLANT LITTER, REGULATING NUTRIENT CYCLING, REGULATING BIOTA, AND
PRODUCING SPECIAL CONSTITUENTS. ANIMALS PARTICIPATE IN NUMEROUS PROCESSES OF SOIL
FORMATION AND EFFECT THE USEFULNESS OF SOILS.
TREES MIGHT AMELIORATE DEGRADED SOIL:
INCREASE THE AMOUNT OF SOIL N2, PARTICULARLY IF THE SPECIES FI X N2;
(II) ALTER THE QUANTITY AND QUALITY OF SOIL ORGANIC MATTER AND ASSOCIATED SOIL
PROPERTIES;
ENRICH SURFACE SOIL NUTRIENTS, PARTICULARLY IN DEEP-ROOTED SPECIES; AND
ALTER THE MICROCLIMATE BY REDUCING TEMPERATURE AND MOISTURE EXTREMES.
CULTURAL ACTIVITIES AFFECT SOIL QUALITY DUE TO RELIGIOUS RITUALS.
INFERENCES:
THE HIGHEST IMPACT ON THE LAND ENVIRONMENT IS DUE TO THE EXTENSIVE
CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES.ALSO THE WASTE GENERATED DUE TO COMMERCIAL
ACTIVITIES ADDS TO THE IMPACT ON SOIL QUALITY.
MITIGATION:
INCREASE IN PLANTATION OF NATIVE SPECIES AND IMPROVE SOILD WASTE MANAGEMENT OF
THE COMMERCIAL ACTIVITIES.
WATER POLLUTION
Questionnaire
YES
NO
IMPACT
IMAGE
MITIGATION
FROGS
MAJOR
MODERATE
MINOR
WATER ENVIRONMENT
MAGNITUDE
SIGNIFICANCE
GROUND
WATER
ACTIVITY
0
0
-6
CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES
7
0
VISITOR ACTIVITIES
0
-4
COMMERCIAL ACTIVITIES
5
WATER USAGE FOR
0
LANDSCAPE
0
0
WASTE DISPOSAL
0
0
FAUNA
0
0
CULTURAL ACTIVITIES
0
0
MUSEUM
0
0
TEMPLE
0
AQUATIC
ECOSYSTEM
WATER USAGE
MATRICES
SEASONAL
WASTE WATER WATER BODIES
-5
0
-5
-2
4
-5
7
-3
5
0
0
0
5
0
0
-3
5
0
0
-1
2
18
-4
4
-4
0
-14
-2
0
5
20
0
-6
-3
3
-18
-2
15
-3
-8
-5
16
-12
-3
33
-11
-1
-6
14
-27
-1
-1
-4
10
5
-5
-1
-6
-3
5
-6
-6
ANNUAL WATER
BODIES
8
-8
13
WATER ENVIRONMENT
THERE ARE SEASONAL AS WELL AS ANNUAL WATER BODIES IN THE PARVATI TALJAI AREA.
CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES CAUSE SOIL EROSION .THIS SOIL SETTLES IN THE NEARBY
WATER BODIES INCREASING ITS TURBIDITY.
CONSTRUCTION ON HILLS MEANS CUTTING INTO THE HILL FOR BUILDING FOUNDATIONS. THIS
SETS OFF A CHAIN REACTION DEVELOPING CRACKS IN THE ROCK STRATA. THIS LEADS
TO A WEAKENING OF THE HILLS BECAUSE THE MICROSCOPIC CRACK ALLOW WATER AND AIR
TO PENETRATE. THE HEATING AND COOLING OF WATER AND AIR LEADS TO WIDENING OF
CRACKS AND SPEEDS UP DECAY OF ROCK CONVERTING IT INTO SOIL.
THE SLUM ENCROACHMENT IN PARVATI HAS CAUSED SIGNIFICANT IMPACTS ON THE WATER
QUALITY OF THE WATER CANAL IN THE FOOTHILLS DUE TO SEWAGE EFFLUENTS.
WASTE DISPOSAL HAS CAUSED SIGNIFICANT IMPACT ON THE WATER QUALITY OF BOTH
ANNUAL AND SEASONAL WATER BODIES.
RELIGIOUS ACTIVITIES USE WATER FOR RITUALS AND SIMULTANEOUSLY CAUSE ITS
POLLUTION.
VISITOR ACTIVITIES TOO ALTHOUGH MINORLY BUT AFFECT THE QUALITY OF SURFACE
WATER BY IMPROPER WASTE DISPOSAL.
INFERENCES:
MAJOR IMPACT ON WATER ENVIRONMENT IS DUE TO CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES AND WASTE
DISPOSAL.
MITIGATION:
CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES NEED TO BE MANAGED APPROPRIATELY FOR REDUCTION OF SOIL
EROSION.SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL MANAGEMENT
AIR POLLUTION
Questionnaire
YES
NO
IMPACT
MINOR
MODERATE
MAJOR
MITIGATION
LIMITATION IN NO. OF
VEHICLES/ AFFORESTATION
TO IMPROVE AIR QUALITY
LIMITATION IN NO. OF
VEHICLES/ AFFORESTATION
TO IMPROVE AIR QUALITY
AFFECTS FAUNA
AFFECTS FAUNA
AIR ENVIRONMENT
MAGNITUDE
SIGNIFICANCE
ACTIVITY
SLUM ACTIVITIES
CONSTRUCTION
ACTIVITIES
VISITOR ACTIVITIES
COMMERCIAL
ACTIVITIES
GUARDS STAYING ON
SITE
WASTE DISPOSAL
CULTURAL ACTIVITIES
INCREASE IN
POLLUTION
PARTICLES
-6
8
-5
-4
5
-6
-5
-4
-6
-6
8
8
-1
-1
-5
MATRICES
-2
1
6
0
0
0
6
3
-3
0
-6
8
-3
FLORA (POLLEN)
TEMPLE
-5
8
MUSEUM
RESPIRATORY
DISEASES
-7
9
INCREASE IN
GREEN HOUSE INCREASE IN
GASES
TEMPERATURE
-6
-4
8
5
0
-7
9
-4
-4
-4
6
-2
-2
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
-23
30
-17
-14
-1
1
25
-10
-3
-17
13
21
-4
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
18
-18
5
-4
24
3
0
0
0
-13
0
17
NOISE POLLUTION
MAGNITUDE
ACTIVITY
SLUM ACTIVITIES
CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES
VISITOR ACTIVITIES
COMMERCIAL ACTIVITIES
GUARDS STAYING ON SITE
CULTURAL ACTIVITIES
MUSEUM
TEMPLE
FAUNA
MATRICES
INCREASE IN
IDEAL DECIBEL
LEVEL
-3
2
-7
8
-6
7
-4
5
-1
2
-7
8
-1
2
-4
3
-3
4
HEARING
DISABILITY
0
0
-1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
-3
2
-8
9
-6
7
-4
5
-1
2
-7
8
-1
2
-4
3
-3
4
SIGNIFICANCE
YES
NO
IMPACT
IMAGE
MINOR
MODERATE
MAJOR
EMPLOYMENT OF SECURITY
PERSSONEL
EMPLOYMENT OF SECURITY
PERSSONEL
APPROPRIATE FENCING
APPROPRIATE FENCING
AWARENESS REGARDING
ENDEMIC SPECIES
REDUCE LAND AND WATER
POLLUTION THROUGH
EFFECTIVE WASTE MANAGEMENT
MITIGATION
FLORA
MAGNITUDE
SIGNIFICANCE
PHYSICAL
ACTIVITY
DAMAGE
-1
EXOTIC FLORA
1
-3
EXOTIC FAUNA
4
-7
VISITOR ACTIVITIES
8
-8
COMMERCIAL ACTIVITIES
9
-4
WASTE DISPOSAL
6
-5
CULTURAL ACTIVITIES
7
0
MUSEUM
0
-3
TEMPLE
5
-7
SLUM DWELLERS
8
-5
LOCALS
5
MATRICES
NUTRIENT
DEFICIENCY
-3
5
3
5
-2
3
-2
3
-3
3
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
DISFUNCTION
IN GROWTH
PROCESSES
-3
5
0
0
-3
4
0
0
-4
5
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
ENDEMIC
SPECIES
-4
4
0
0
0
0
0
0
-2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
HARM TO LIFE
-7
8
0
0
-3
4
-1
2
-4
3
5
-2
4
0
0
-2
4
-7
8
-5
5
-18
23
0
9
-15
19
-11
14
-17
22
-7
13
0
0
-5
9
-14
16
-10
10
FAUNA
MAGNITUDE
SIGNIFICANCE
ACTIVITY
EXOTIC FLORA
EXOTIC FAUNA
VISITOR ACTIVITIES
COMMERCIAL
ACTIVITIES
WASTE DISPOSAL
CULTURAL ACTIVITIES
MUSEUM
0
0
-6
8
-6
8
-5
6
-4
5
0
0
0
MATRICES
0
-4
5
-3
4
-6
8
-8
9
-3
3
-6
8
0
0
-4
3
-2
4
-6
8
-6
8
0
0
-6
8
0
0
0
0
-6
8
-6
8
-6
7
-2
7
0
0
0
0
-8
8
-17
24
-24
32
-25
28
-9
15
-12
16
0
0
LAND
-17
IMPACTS ON LAND
66
-87
IMAPCTS ON WATER
MATRICES
140
-116
INTRODUCTION
IN THE RECENT YEARS THESE HILLS ARE UNDER THREATS. SLUM
AREAS AROUND THE PARVATI HILL INCREASING DAY BY DAY. NOW
THE HILL IS TOTALLY SURROUNDED BY SLUM. ILLEGAL TREE
CUTTING, LIQUOR CONSUMPTION, OBSCENE ACTS BY COUPLES
AND ENCROACHMENT OF LAND ON THE TALJAI HILL ARE ALSO
THREATENING PROBLEMS.
These are the activities which have
a social impact on Taljai and
Parvarti hills.
TRANSPOR
T
TOURIS MUSEUM
M
TEMPLE SLUM
DWELLERS
TRAINNING
PROGRAMME
CULTURAL
RECREATIONAL
BIO-DIVERSITY
ACTIVITIES
ACTIVITY
PARK
IN THIS CASE PEOPLE HAVE STRONG ATTACHMENT WITH THE PARVATITALJAI HILLS. WITH THIS ATTACHMENT, IDENTITY AND DEPENDENCY PEOPLE
ARE WELL AWARE ABOUT THE PROBLEMS AND READY TO CONTRIBUTE FOR
THE PRESERVATION OF THE SITES.
SOCIAL IMPACT
SOCIAL
ACTIVITY
HEALTH
-6
TRANSPORT
5
0
TOURISM
0
9
BIODIVERSITY PARK
10
0
MUSEUM
0
0
TEMPLE
0
2
CULTURAL ACTIVITIES
2
-5
SLUM DWELLERS
6
RECREATIONAL
5
ACTIVITY
6
0
TRAINING PROGRAME
0
MATRICES
LIFESTYLE
7
6
7
8
7
7
1
1
1
1
4
4
-3
4
7
8
2
3
ECONOMY
8
8
8
8
7
8
8
8
2
3
2
3
0
0
2
3
4
4
AWARENESS
0
0
7
8
6
8
7
5
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
6
8
SOCIAL
MAGNITUDE
SIGNIFICANCE
ACTIVITY
POLITICAL
0
TRANSPORT
0
3
TOURISM
5
0
BIODIVERSITY PARK
0
0
MUSEUM
0
0
TEMPLE
0
3
CULTURAL ACTIVITIES
5
0
SLUM DWELLERS
0
RECREATIONAL
0
ACTIVITY
0
MATRICES
INDUSTRIAL
-4
3
5
5
2
3
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
EMPLOYMENT
7
8
8
9
6
6
4
4
TOTAL
1
1
4
5
0
0
0
0
`12
30
36
43
28
44
20
13718
4
207
5
15
19
-8
10
16
17
Sachin
40
Nearby
Volunteering
Manisha Gupta
35
Nearby
No
Jaiswal Singh
42
Nearby
No
Gargi Tambe
45
Nearby
Asking for alms
Shalan
40
Nearby
No
Arjun Karande
38
Nearby
No
Surendra
21
Nearby
No
Social worker
Tea, Snacks,
Fresh
Tea, Snacks
Vegetable
Dry fruit
Fruits and
Vendor
Vendor
vendor
vegetable
stall owner
Coconut Water
Anna Thorat
N. A.
16 to 17 years
No peak hours
stall owner
Anna Thorat
N. A.
30 to 35 years
No peak hours
Anna Thorat
N.A.
16 to 17 years
No peak hours
Anna Thorat
N. A.
8-10 years
No peak hours
Anna Thorat
N. A.
2-3 years
No peak hours
juice vendor
Anna Thorat
N. A.
2-3 years
No peak hours
Barricade provision
Every Purnima
Every Purnima
Every Purnima
Every Purnima
No idea
No idea
No idea
6 am to 11 am
6 am to 11 am
6 am to 11 am
6 am to 11 am
6 am to 11 am
6 am to 11 am
6 am to 11 am
6 pm to 8 pm
Jogger's Park
PMC
No Construction
6 pm to 8 pm
Jogger's Park
PMC
No idea
6 pm to 8 pm
Jogger's Park
PMC
No idea
6 pm to 8 pm
Jogger's Park
No idea
No idea
6 pm to 8 pm
Jogger's Park
No idea
No idea
Jogger's Park
No idea
No idea
Jogger's Park
No idea
No idea
Nor agriculture
No
No Idea
No idea
No idea
No idea
No idea
No idea
No idea
No idea
No idea
No idea
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
Anna Thorat
Yes
1 to 2 years
Manageable crowd
in the temple
ECONOMICAL IMPACT
From the environmental impact assessment done for the Parvati and Talzai, done by the Checklist
and Leopold method, the impact of human intervention on the land and water can be understood
on an urban scale. The magnitude and significance of the impact on the environment is clearly
indicated. The Land environment is mainly affected due to the commercial activities like
construction, buying and selling of the commodities, religious activities, etc.
The reason that Parvati is less polluted is that the access to the top of the hill is defined. Yes we
have to climb 103 steps to pollute it. Though in every month of Shraavan, Maha Shivratri festival
and weekends, Parvati does get polluted.
Talzai is more prone to the pollution because one can go right upto the top on a vehicle. The Pune
Municipal Corporation has prohibited any construction or agricultural activities here, due to the
presence of the biodiversity park. Also, for all the vegetable, fruit and other vendors, they have
been given the stalls on rent basis. Had it been given on ownership Basis, the scenario would be
different. Vendors have to throw the waste generated in the Biogas plant provided by the PMC at
the foot of Talzai. Due to the biodiversity park, there are people coming in the early hours of the
day and in the evenings for walking, trekking and jogging which is the main cause for pollution.
Due to the presence of Talzai Mata temple, every Purnima and 5 days after that the peak season
for the temple starts. And
Hence the quantum of pollution is more in Talzai.
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
STATEMENT