HARVARD BUSINESS SC

BRIEF CA
SES

Cottle-Taylor:
Expanding the Oral
Care Group in
India
 HARVARD BUSINESS SC

BRIEF CA
SES

Problem Statement:

1. What factors determine demand for

toothbrushes? How can the demand be
increased?
2. How is Cottle doing in India? What are the
challenges faced?
3. How should Cottle accelerate the
development of toothbrush market in India?
Suggest a Marketing mix strategy?
 HARVARD BUSINESS SC

BRIEF CA
SES

Table of content:

Factors Determining the demand.

Methods to increase the demand.
Cottle in India.
Toothbrush market in India.
Marketing Mix Strategy.
 HARVARD BUSINESS SC

BRIEF CA
SES

Factors Determining Demand:

Affordability
Oral hygiene awareness
Distribution
Accessibility
Price of the product
Brand awareness
Competition in industry
Population
 HARVARD BUSINESS SC

BRIEF CA
SES

Methods To Increase Demand:

Awareness

Promotion

Distribution Strategy
Product Features(Quality, Design, Cost)

Competitors in the market

 HARVARD BUSINESS SC

BRIEF CA
SES

Cottle India:
Product Category:

Toothpaste

Toothpowder

Toothbrushes
 HARVARD BUSINESS SC

BRIEF CA
SES

Cottle India:

Products were sold in more than 45,000 retail

outlets.
Introduced ancillary products including
mouthwash and dental floss.
 HARVARD BUSINESS SC

BRIEF CA
SES

Sales and Revenues

600

500

400

300

200

100

2008($) 2009($) 2010 E($)

 HARVARD BUSINESS SC

BRIEF CA
SES

Market Share 2009

Hindia-Daltan

22% 21% SarIndia

11% Cottle-Taylor

46% Low cost products imported

from China and Vietnam
 HARVARD BUSINESS SC

BRIEF CA
SES

Challenges Faced By Cottle in India:

FACTS:
50% of Indians were not concerned with
dental problems.
Rural people are 5 times more reluctant to
use modern oral care than urban
counterparts.
80% of population lives on less than 2$ a
day.
 HARVARD BUSINESS SC

BRIEF CA
SES

Challenges Faced By Cottle in India:

PURCHASE ACCURACY:
8.6% of the toothbrush users replaced their
brush within 3 months.
4 out of 5 toothbrush users used the same
brush well beyond 3 months.
 HARVARD BUSINESS SC

BRIEF CA
SES

Challenges Faced By Cottle in India:

DISTRIBUTION DIFFICULTIES:

Distributors did not always understand the

key selling points of Cottle's toothbrushes.
Difficulty in communicating in rural
locations.
 HARVARD BUSINESS SC

BRIEF CA
SES

Marketing Mix Strategy:

Product:

Low end manual: Mid range Battery-operated:

The Complete manual: The Swirl
The Sensitooth The Zagger Swirl refills
The FreshGum Directionflex
The Surround
The Kidsie
 HARVARD BUSINESS SC

BRIEF CA
SES

Marketing Mix Strategy:

Price:

The majority of Indians wanted to upgrade from

home grown dental remedies to inexpensive
modern oral care products. So they should keep
the price of their products low, since majority of
Indians lived in Rural towns and villages.
 HARVARD BUSINESS SC

BRIEF CA
SES

Marketing Mix Strategy:

Promotion:

Cottle should provide free dental checkups, free

product samples, and basic instructions for
proper oral care. Rising awareness of dental
health benefits.
Cottle should partner with IDA for research
studies and dental health outreach campaigns.
 HARVARD BUSINESS SC

BRIEF CA
SES

Marketing Mix Strategy:

Place:

It should have multiple distribution strategies.

Cottle should have more outlets in small
villages and roughly 300 distributors serving
wholesalers and retailers in semi urban areas
and few distributors focused on retail outlets in
urban area.
 HARVARD BUSINESS SC

BRIEF CA
SES

Thank you..