Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Revisited
What is PDRI?
How broadly used by CII members?
How organizations using PDRI?
What is the value of using PDRI?
How to use PDRI?
Lessons learned since the tools introduction?
What Is PDRI?
PDRI The Definition
An Acronym
Project Definition Rating Index
An Index
Score along a continuum representing the level
of scope definition
Born on date
Industrial Buildings
Sections: 3 3
Categories: 15 11
Elements: 70 64
Score: 70-1000 70-1000
SECTION I - BASIS OF PROJECT DECISION
Definition Level
CATEGORY Score
0 1 2 3 4 5
Element
A. MANUFACTURING OBJECTIVES CRITERIA (Maximum Score = 45)
A1. Reliability Philosophy 0 1 5 9 14 20
A2. Maintenance Philosophy 0 1 3 5 7 9
A3. Operating Philosophy 0 1 4 7 12 16
CATEGORY A TOTAL
B. BUSINESS OBJECTIVES (Maximum Score = 213)
B1. Products 0 1 11 22 33 56
B2. Market Strategy 0 2 5 10 16 26
B3. Project Strategy 0 1 5 9 14 23
B4. Affordability/Feasibility 0 1 3 6 9 16
B5. Capacities 0 2 11 21 33 55
B6. Future Expansion Considerations 0 2 3 6 10 17
B7. Expected Project Life Cycle 0 1 2 3 5 8
B8. Social Issues 0 1 2 5 7 12
CATEGORY B TOTAL
C. BASIC DATA RESEARCH & DEVELOPMENT (Maximum Score = 94)
C1. Technology 0 2 10 21 39 54
C2. Processes 0 2 8 17 28 40
CATEGORY C TOTAL
D. PROJECT SCOPE (Maximum Score = 120)
D1. Project Objectives Statement 0 2 25
D2. Project Design Criteria 0 3 6 11 16 22
D3. Site Characteristics Available vs. Required 0 2 29
D4. Dismantling and Demolition Requirements 0 2 5 8 12 15
D5. Lead/Discipline Scope of Work 0 1 4 7 10 13
D6. Project Schedule 0 2 16
CATEGORY D TOTAL
E. VALUE ENGINEERING (Maximum Score = 27)
E1. Process Simplification 0 0 8
E2. Design & Material Alternatives Considered/Rejected 0 0 7
E3. Design for Constructability Analysis 0 0 3 5 8 12
CATEGORY E TOTAL
Definition Levels
0 = Not Applicable 2 = Minor Deficiencies 4 = Major Deficiencies
1 = Complete Definition 3 = Some Deficiencies 5 = Incomplete or Poor Definition
PDRI Element Descriptions
(Example)
A1. Reliability Philosophy
Definition Levels
0 = Not Applicable 2 = Minor Deficiencies 4 = Major Deficiencies
1 = Complete Definition 3 = Some Deficiencies 5 = Incomplete or Poor Definition
How Broadly Used?
PDRI Usage Among CII Members
Not Used
(24)
Used Industrial Only
(43) (22)
Building Only
(6)
N = 70
How Being Used?
Usage
Others:
As an audit tool (42%)
In a modified form for small or unusual projects
(33%)
To help capture lessons-learned (28%)
With the help of an outside facilitator (19%)
The Value
Understanding PDRI Scores
1000 Points
0 Points
LOWER IS BETTER!!
What does a score mean?
A continuum
Relative to timing
Only as valid as effort/seriousness
Accuracy (the real score) can be improved
with facilitation
Perhaps is not the most important output
of the assessment
Comparison of Projects with PDRI
Above and Below 200 Industrial Projects
PDRI Score
(N=62) (N=44)
PDRI The Results
EXAMPLE:
$55 Million Industrial Project, 24-Month Schedule
PDRI Score
(N=18) (N=74)
How to Use
Assessing a Project
What it SHOULDNT BE
Performed
in a
vacuum
Time Needed for Assessing a Project
PDRI works!
http://construction-institute.org/pdri/
Implementation Session
Participants
Location: Georgia B