Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
org
The Aesthetics of St. Augustine:
Whereas Plato and Aristotle approach the arts from a
metaphysical starting point with its implications on the
community in mind (both vertical and horizontal),
Augustines starting point is Scripture (vertical). For
Augustine, he considers the arts in relation to the church
(horizontal).
Aesthetics & church in Historical
Context:
Appreciation for aesthetic activities (worship) but not for the arts themselves an
expression of the arts. Why?
Impact of Plato (Book X of The Republic)
Artistic activity is concerned with the sensible realm.
The sensible realm can distract us from focusing on God.
The arts were historically linked and seen in relation to the cultures and mythos
of Greece and Rome.
Tertullian (3rd century), for example, rejected studies that were
profane. He characterized literature as foolishness in the eyes
of God.
But other, like Origen, Clement of Alexandria, and Basil the Great
believed that an appreciation of the arts may have a positive use
in education.
The Arts in Christian Context.
Visual arts represented gods and emperors. Thus, they were objects of idolatry, even
demanded by Rome to worship such images. Those who did not worship them, were,
at times, executed for treason or martyred.
But by the sixth century, Gregory defended the arts as necessary tools of instruction
for people. Why? Most people were illiterate. Thus, the arts may be used to lead
people to God.
1. Distinction between that which is beautiful in itself and that which is beautiful in
virtue of being applied to something else.
a. A complex may beautiful in that it is a kind of a whole, and beauty is a property of the
whole.
b. Part (e.g., a particular color or a sound) which its not beautiful by itself may be called
beautiful when it is part of a complex whole.
From City of God:
the beauty of the course of the world is achieved
by the opposition of contraries arranged, as it
were, by an eloquence not of words, but of
things City of God, XI, xviii.
Neo-Platonic Worldview:
Augustine assumes a Neo-Platonic worldview. He contends:
1. Unity is the form of all beauty
2. Infinite goodness, truth, and beauty are attributes of God.
3. Platonic Themes:
conception of beauty,
vision of God,
the need for divine illumination,
emphasis on the soul,
purification of the mind as a requirement for understanding
truth,
View of evil as corruption,
conception of time and eternity, &
desire for spiritual and intellectual.
Differences:
Differences with Plotinus:
1. Embraces Tenets of Orthodox Christianity
a. The Incarnation of Jesus Christ
b. The Resurrection of Jesus Christ
c. The Promise of Redemption from Sin through Grace
d. Conception of the Trinity
e. Communion with God through Jesus Christ.
f. Depravity of humanity
g. God is personal, not impersonal.
h. Soul is created, not eternal.
i. Encounters with God is not rare when one knows Christ.
j. Knowing Christ is the rest and permanence for which Augustine
longed.
Augustine:
1. What is the purpose of art?
2. What is the function of art?
3. How are to understand artistic
creativity?
4. How do we evaluate art?
-------------------------------------------
5. What do the Scripture teach us
about the arts?
6. What is the relationship between
God, the Creator, we, the objects
of His affections?
7. What is the mission of the church
and how can the arts assist us to
that end?
Key Themes: 1. Clear distinction in creation of
objects:
6. Order:
Order is the distribution which allots things equal
and unequal, each to its own place (City of God,
XIX, xiii). Thus, the more order (proper place), the
more beautiful they are.
Key Theme # 3:
Art is not imitation because animals imitate; they do
not have not art (De Musica I, iv, 5-7).
Bibliography:
Aesthetics: From Classical Greece to the Present by Monroe C. Beardsley.
Philosophies of Art & Beauty: Selected Readings in Aesthetics from Plato to Heidegger,
edited by Albert Hofstadter and Richard Kuhns
Medieval Theories of Aesthetics by Michael Spicher In Internet Encyclopedia of
Philosophy (December 11, 2010).
Perspective in Aesthetics: Plato to Camus, edited by Peyton E. Richter