Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Article reviewed
Barriers and enablers of health system
adoption of kangaroo mother care: a
systematic review of caregiver perspectives.
Emily R. Smith, Ilana Bergelson et al.
BMC Pediatrics, 2017.
Objectives
Explain overview of the study.
Findings
1515
1360
716
644
546
98
Critique
The researcher identified a gap, there was no
systematic review in the past regarding KMC
and caregivers perspective.
Searched more no. of databases.
Identified different themes / frameworks and
collected data accordingly.
Could list out barriers and enablers clearly.
Majority of the studies were of past 5 years.
The review included majority of American
studies. (1/3rd )
Most of the studies had sample size of 50 or
less.
Majority of the studies included the areas with
NMR of <15 deaths per 1000 live births.
Africa and south east Asia where KMC is very
important, there were very less studies.
Conclusion
KMC is very important intervention to prevent
complications related to pre term birth.
By knowing care givers perspectives enablers
should be promoted and barriers should be
reduced.
KMC team should insure that the experience
should be positive and valuable from
caregivers side.
What is the level of evidence for this
study?
Evidence
Level 5 1 Systematic review & meta-analysis of randomized controlled
trials; clinical guidelines based on systematic reviews or meta-
analyses
2 One or more randomized controlled trials
Controlled trial (no randomization); quasi-experimental
4 Case-control or cohort study
5 Systematic review of descriptive studies; systematic review of
qualitative studies (metasynthesis)
6 Single descriptive or qualitative study