Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
→ The cause
→ The process
→ The recovery
DSM-5 Trauma Definition
A health system
consists of all
organizations,
people and actions
whose primary
interest is to
promote, restore or
maintain health
(WHO, 2017)
Our Health System Practices
May Contribute to Trauma
What is Medical Trauma?
▶ Gap in the literature on trauma caused by psychical and mental health systems
▶ Magazine/social media articles on the effect of medical and psychological
mistreatment/maltreatment/negligence/abuse of health systems and their implications BUT
NOT scientific papers
▶ Study on psychiatric hospital setting indicates that 82% of patients reported that institutional
events and procedures caused trauma and harm (Trauma Within the Psychiatric Setting,
2003).
▶ Studies indicate that mental health consumers have experienced traumatic, humiliating, or
distressing events during their hospitalization (Trauma Within the Psychiatric Setting, 2003)
▶ Medical and psychological specialists avoid or stop providing care for high-risk or
complicated case/patients due to fears of lawsuits or clients’ complaints (Zuger, 2004)
What Can Prevent Medical Trauma?
➤ Good health services (effective, safe, quality personal and non-personal health
interventions to those who need them, when and where needed, with minimum waste of
resources).
➤ A well-performing health workforce -Being responsive, fair and efficient to achieve the
best health outcomes possible, given available resources and circumstances.
➤ A well-functioning health information system (ensures the production, analysis,
dissemination and use of reliable and timely information on health determinants, health
systems performance and health status).
➤ A well-functioning health system (equitable access to essential medical products ,
vaccines and technologies: quality, safety, efficacy and cost-effectiveness)
➤ A good health financing system (adequate funds for health, people protected from
financial catastrophe or impoverishment associated with receiving medical services)
▶ Lack of time→Dugdale, Epstein & Pantilat (1999) suggest that a physician's risk of malpractice
claims is related with visit length. A study by Levinson et al. (1997)found that physicians with
less than two claims of malpractice over their lifetime, had longer routine visits with clients than
those physicians with more than two claims which had shorter routine visits.
▶ Misdiagnosis→Misdiagnosis can lead to serious harm to a patient and their family. Pinaccle
Care (2016) reported on a survey that found that 64% of doctors said that up to 10% of the
misdiagnoses they have experienced directly resulted in harm to the patient; and another
study that “found that 28% of 538 reported diagnostic errors were life-threatening or resulted in
the patient’s death or permanent disability” (p. 1).
General Practitioners: Gate Keepers
▶ Medical Errors→ Errors to treatment can leave patients permanently mentally and physically
disabled and afraid of seeking further interventions. In the case of Mrs. Edwards vs. Dr. Howells
(1992) the patient suffered brain damage as result of being prescribed an overdose of a Vitamin
D supplement (British Medical Journal, 1992) Similar case was in 1988, with Predergast vs. Sam &
Ltd where brain damage occurred due to a pharmacist misreading a doctor's’ prescription (BMJ,
1992)
▶ Sexual Abuse→ there exists an inherent power imbalance between patients and healthcare
professionals largely because the patient seeks the health care professional for help, which
places the professional in a position of power (Perez, 2013)
▶ Abuse of power -Penfold (1998) describes the impact of the abuse of power in that “victims as
result of life circumstances of interactions with others realize that the relationship is damaging and
that they must leave it. Terminating the relationship rarely end the victims problems. Often they
are left with more difficulties and distress than they started out. The after effects of sexual abuse
by a professional can be extreme, and many victims suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder” (p.
12)
General Practitioners: Gate Keepers
▶ Are often the first point of entry into the health care system.
▶ Experiences: “I didn’t know where else to go”. No time for complex issues, only quick fixes.
▶ Patients can feel staff being judgmental, abrupt, and cold. Are staff on power trips? Or is
their behavior a result of complex trauma they have experienced?
▶ Staff rely on bias instead of concern towards the number of visits on record. What’s the
actual root of their problem? Are we meeting their needs?
▶ Is a well known way to cue jump, consult a surgeon or specialist. Some GP’s suggest it by
telling patients to “Say you have chest pain”
▶ The Triage process can trump critical thinking about patient needs, especially if mental
health in nature without proper “psych room”. The lack of space and staff in departments
mean long waits for assessment and treatment, causing some to suffer in waiting rooms.
Recall the women miscarrying in the ER waiting room bathroom reported in the news? It
was awful. I remember saying to my coworkers “Imagine this was you!”.
Specialists and Programs
▶ It is hard to convince your GP to refer you onto a specialist when you lose
confidence in their skills. Patients can feel undeserving or are too loyal.
▶ Some GP’s hold complex patients much too long, causing irreversible damage,
while others don’t even try to find solutions before referring out, essentially
“dumping” patients onto specialists out of frustration or due to a lack of skill..
▶ GP suggests urgency level on referrals, often “URGENT” when it’s routine, and
often after patient has waited years for the referral and is in dire straits.
▶ In my department GIM, Central Access and Triage staff often guess at referral
status. As a result, I have my doctors re-triage our referrals that include doing
testing so we can “meet and treat” vs “meet and greet”.
▶ Long Waitlists: Screening programs, diagnostic Tests, Some treatment, including
programs and even for surgery.
Organizational Culture
▶ Organizations that serve traumatized clients can use prevention and interventional strategies that
surround vicarious trauma by focusing on organizational culture, workload, environment,
education, group support, supervision, and resources for self care. Bell et al. (2003).
▶ Maintaining the status quo is easier than to accept organizational change.
▶ Poorly defined or over-defined roles. “I don’t know WHO does that, I don’t DO that”, instead of
pulling together to get the job done.
▶ Power struggles between everyone. In my role I’ve noticed that people will make excuses to not
help one another.
▶ Lack of interdisciplinary cohesion, and between departments.
▶ Traditional power struggles between medicine and nursing (and SW?) regarding advocacy roles
for patients. (Mallik, 1998).
▶ Management seems non-existent, replaced by administration who can’t/ don’t relate to staff
concerns. Who recalls the Code of Conduct that came out when Stephen Ducket was in
charge?
▶ Underfunded, lack of resources = frustration.
Policies, Procedures and Protocols are great but...
▶ Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) and other manifestations of trauma are under recognized
in routine clinical practice and settings (Zimmerman & Mattia, 1999)
▶ Anxiety disorders, characterized by somatic symptoms (restlessness, fatigue, poor
concentration, irritability, muscle tension, or sleep disturbances) coupled with excessive
worrying, apprehension, or fear--are among the most common psychiatric conditions
encountered in primary care settings and are still underdiagnosed and undertreated (Zanni,
2012)
Mental Health Over Diagnosed
▶ Pathologizing discourses
▶ Key to get resources (i.e.
insurance, funding)
▶ Ket to get the “right” treatment
or intervention
▶ Ket to avoid mistreatment
▶ Influences identity and self-
stigma
Lack of Multidisciplinary Teams
▶ Risk of understanding
the situation from one
angle
▶ Risk of misinterpreting
the information
▶ Risk of not offering a
comprehensive
treatment plan
▶ Lack of communication
among specialists
Insurance Companies
▶ Indigenous peoples experience significantly higher rates of ill health and have
dramatically shorter life expectancies than other groups living in the same countries,
all of which are influenced by the negative and traumatic impacts of historical and
ongoing colonialism (Browne et. al, 2016)
▶ Jacklin et. al (2017) present a study in which Indigenous participants with diabetes felt
that diabetes care was mediated by “traumatic historical relations between
Indigenous people in Canada and the government, most often materializing in
avoidance of health care systems, mistrust of physicians and resistance to other
service providers” (pE108).
▶ The participants furthermore avoided and resisted health care providers when their
interaction triggered and brought back memories of negative childhood experiences
from residential schools (Jacklin et. al, 2017).
▶ Refugees entering the system may not fully trust the system due to
circumstances in their countries of origin; and therefore, building and
establishing a relationship may take time.
▶ The assessment process during questioning may catch clients off guard who
may experience unease at the questions posed during assessment.
▶ Patients can be unfamiliar with the biomedical practice of preventative
medicine such as in regards to immunizations and their children (Jackson et.
al, 2016) Expand
▶ Clients who have experienced torture such as but not limited to: forced stress
positions, pulling teeth out with pliers, pull out nails out of hands and feet,
beaten with blunt objects etc. (Jackson et. al, 2016) may find medical
procedures as triggering and frightening to these past experiences.
LGBTQ2
▶ LGBTQ populations experience a variety of health issues that are unique to
their demographics to which therefore require specific care.(Whitehead et.
al, 2016)
▶ Health care providers may lack the knowledge of these health issues
because of a personal reluctance to delve into this area (i.e. religious views),
meaning that such clients may be misdiagnosed and/or not have these
health issues addressed.
▶ Studies in the area of sexual abuse have discovered a relationship between child sexual
abuse and “serious and chronic adult physical effects i.e liver disease, obesity, cancer etc.
(Having, 2008).
▶ The relationship between abuse and health/mental health means that survivors of CSA will
most likely be in contact with the health care system; and such contact may result in
retraumatization.
▶ Sexual assault is complicated by social stigma and stereotypes and victims of the assault can
sometimes receive criticism and blaming for the event. Such blame and shaming can
sometimes come from professional contacts (i.e ER visit) during interactions in the health care
system (Esposito, 2008).
▶ Esposito (2008) explains that patients with PTSD from sexual assault, healthcare visits can be
reminders of a sexual assault; and that “routine dental work or Papanicolaou examination
which is intrusive to the body and may evoke hidden reminders and intense distress” (p. 70)
▶ Labour and delivery can evoke symptoms PTSD when a woman with a history of SA trauma
goes into labour (Esposito, 2008).
Pediatric Medical Traumatic Stress
▶ McGarry et. al (2013) define Paediatric medical traumatic stress as: “the psychological and
physical responses experienced by children and their families as a result of encountering
pain, injury, serious illness and invasive medical procedures” (p. 1115)
▶ Parents also experience stress as they watch their child and pain and have to make difficult
decisions to their child’s medical treatment in the context of the concern for their child’s
future Therefore parents are also tasked with helping their child cope as an inpatient in
hospital settings (McGarry et. al, 2013).
▶ Families who are exposed to traumatic stress from a health care experience often fall into
two groups which are resilient families, and families who struggle with the treatment process
(Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, n.d.)
▶ The Pediatric Traumatic Stress Toolkit (2004) is a toolkit provided to professionals with a guide
to be able to effectively assess and treat medical traumatic stress in children and their
families; and focuses on addressing the emotional and physical side of trauma (National
Child Traumatic Stress Network, n.d)
Specific Patient Populations
▶ Hall & Hall (2013) mention that patients experiencing specific treatment regarding HIV;
stays in ICU; heart attacks and strokes; grief and depression; and
childbirth/gynecological treatment are all at risk for developing medical trauma
▶ Patients with pre-existing mental health conditions, specifically from past traumas can
also be at risk for developing trauma symptoms; however, this can be difficult to isolate
and identify the medical trauma as a cause for symptoms of trauma because of the
previous trauma history (Hall & Hall, 2013)
▶ Psychiatric patients who have experienced childhood abuse in which (Hammer et. al,
2010) explain that through the trauma-informed care perspective, it is suggested that
“the use of S/R (seclusion and restraint) with previously abused inpatients may result in
retraumatization due to mental associations between childhood trauma and the
experience during S/R” (p. 568).
▶ Carmen and Rieker (1998) explained that “many survivors of abuse reported personal
experiences with abusers who had restrained them and locked them away in closets,
car trunks, and rooms,” (p. 192)
Chronic Illnesses
(Mortimer, 2015)
Healthcare Workers
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LWTesIihoQY
Ethical or Practice Issues
→ The cause
→ The process
→ The recovery
Reflection
American Counseling Association’s Taskforce on Counselor Impairment (n.d.). ACA taskforce on counselor wellness and impairment. Retrieved from:
http://www.counseling.org/wellness_taskforce/index.htm
Bell, H., Kulkarni, S., & Dalton, L. (2003). The Journal of Contemporary Human Services, (84), 4, 463-470.
Cayton, H. (2006). The alienating language of health care: Editorial. Journal of the royal society of medicine, 99, 484.
Devilly, G. J., Wright, R. & Varker, T. (2009). Vicarious trauma, secondary traumatic stress or simply burnout? Effect of trauma therapy on mental health professionals. Australian and New
Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 43, 373-385.
Epping-Jordan, J. E., Pruitt, S. D., Bengoa, R. & Wagner, E. H. (2004). Improving the quality of health care for chronic conditions. Qual Saf Health Care, 13, 299-305. Retrieved from:
http://quality safety.bmj.com/
Hall, M. F. & Hall, S. E. (2013, March). When treatment becomes trauma: Defining, preventing, and transforming medical trauma. Paper based on a program presented at the 2013
American Counseling Association Conference, Cincinnati, OH.
Jennings, A. (1994). On Being Invisible in the Mental Health System. Retrieved February 28, 2015, from http://www.theannainstitute.org/obi.html
Lally, R. M. (2009). Bullies aren’t only on the playground: a look at nurse-on-nurse violence. Oncology Nursing Society, 24, (2).
Mallik, M. (1998). Advocacy in nursing: perceptions and attitudes of the nursing elite in the United Kingdom. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 28(5), 1001-1011.
Mortimer, S. (2015). The dark gift of chronic illness, is intimacy. Retrieved from: http://www.womenswellnesscircle.com/the-dark-gift-of-chronic-illness-is-intimacy/
Trauma Within the Psychiatric Setting a Preliminary Empirical Report (2003). Administration and Policy in Mental Health, 30(5), 453-460. Retrieved February 28, 2015, from
http://www.psychrights.org/Articles/PsychiatricTrauma.pdf
Zanni, G. R. (2012). Anxiety disorders: underdiagnosed and undertreated: during counseling, pharmacists can assess adherence and provide needed mental health referrals. Pharmacy
Times, 58-59.
Zuger, A. (2004). Dissatisfaction with medical practice. New England Journal of Medicine, 350, 69-75.
References
BMJ (1992) Doctors Who Sexually Abuse Patients. British Medical Journal, 304 (6830), 799.
Browne, A.J., Varcoe, C., Lavoie, J., Smye, V., Wong, S.T., Krause, M., Tu, D., Godwin, O., Khan, K., Fridkin, A. (2016) Enhancing health care equity with Indigenous
populations: evidence-based strategies from an ethnographic study. BMC Health Services Research, 16 (544),1-17.
Carmen, E., & Rieker, P. P. (1998). Rethinking the use of restraint and seclusion for mentally ill women with abuse histories. Journal of the American Medical Women’s
Association, 53, 192-197
Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia (n.d). Pediatric Traumatic Stress. Retrieved from http://www.chop.edu/conditions-diseases/pediatric-traumatic-stress
Dugdale, D.C., Epstein, R., Pantilat, S.Z (1999). Time and the Patient-Physician Relationship. Journal of General Internal Medicine,14 (1), 34-40.
Epping-Jordan, J. E., Pruitt, S. D., Bengoa, R. & Wagner, E. H. (2004). Improving the quality of health care for chronic conditions. Qual Saf Health Care, 13, 299-305.
Retrieved from: http://quality safety.bmj.com/
Esposito, N. (2006). Living with Illness: Women with a History of Sexual Assault. The American Journal of Nursing, 106 (3), 69-71.
Hammer, J.H.,Springer, J., Beck N.C., Menditto, A., & Coleman, J.(2011).The Relationship Between Seclusion and Restrain Use and Childhood Abuse Among
Psychiatric Inpatients. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 26 (3), 567-579.
Having, K(2008). Health Care Experiences of Adult Survivors. Trauma, Violence, & Abuse, 19-33.
References
Jacklin, K.M., Henderson, R.I., Green, M.E., Walker, L.M., Calam, B., Crowshoe, L.J.(2017).Health care experiences of Indigenous people living with type 2 diabetes in Canada.
CMAJ, 189(3), E106-E112.
Jackson, J.C., Haider, M., Owens, C.W., Ahrenholz, N., Farmer, B., Terasaki, G. (2016). Healthcare Recommendations For Recently Arrived Refugees: Observations from EthnoMed.
Harvard Public Health Review, 7. Retrieved from http://harvardpublichealthreview.org/case-based-recommendations-for-the-health-care-of-recently-arrived-refugees-
observations-from-ethnomed/
McGarry, S., Girdler, S., McDonald, A., Valentine, J;, Wood, F., & Elliott, C(2013). Paediatric medical trauma: The impact on parents of burn survivors. Journal of the International
Society for Burn Injuries, 39, 1114-1121.
Nesrallah, H.A. (2017) Cause and Effect in Bipolar Depression: Misdiagnosis Leads to Inappropriate Treatment, Clinical Complications, and Adverse Outcomes. CME Institute.
Retrieved from http://www.cmeinstitute.com/Psychlopedia/Pages/BipolarDisorder/11cebd/sec2/section.aspx
Penfold, P.S. (1995) Sexual Abuse by Health Professionals: A Personal Search for Meaning and Healing. University of Toronto Press Incorporated
Perez, J. (2013) Keeping Sex Out of the Doctor’s Office: A California Proposal to Stop Patient Sexual Abuse. Whitter Law Review, 34 (3), 421-444.
Pinnacle Care (2016) The Human Cost and Financial Impact of Misdiagnosis. Retrieved from https://www.pinnaclecare.com/download/Human-Cost-Financial-Impact-
Whitepaper.pdf
The National Child Traumatic Stress Network (n.d). Pediatric Medical Traumatic Stress Toolkit for Health Care Providers. Retrieved from http://www.nctsn.org/trauma-
types/pediatric-medical-traumatic-stress-toolkit-for-health-care-providers
Whitehead, J., Shaver, J., Stephenson, R. (2016) Outness, Stigma, and Primary Health Care Utilization among Rural LGBT Populations. PLos ONE, 11(1),1-17.