Cultural Assimilationism Versus Cultural Pluralism CULTURAL ASSIMILATIONISM Also known as mono-cultural perspective that pushes the concept of “melting pot” to address diversity issues by creating one homogenous culture from the different cultural groups.
Culturally different groups must be socialized into the
dominant culture so that all can function in an appropriate behavior. CULTURAL PLURALISM Also known as multicultural perspective saying that different ethnic cultures have the right to maintain their own identity and culture within the greater society.
This perspective uses the “salad bowl” analogy. In
order to have a nutritious salad (society), it is essential to include a variety of cultures. Multicultural Education Multicultural education uses learning about other cultures in order to produce acceptance, or at least tolerance of these cultures (Faas, 2011).
Ornstein and Levine (1982) defined multicultural
education as education that advocates differential instructional approaches to teaching students with different ethnic and racial background. Cushner et al. (2006) also defined multicultural education as a process of educational reform that ensures all students from all groups experience educational equality, success, and social ability.
Multicultural education is a comprehensive
school reform and basic education for all (Nieto, 2002). 7 KEY PRINCIPLES OF MULTICULTURAL EDUCATION (Nieto, 2002) 1. Multicultural Education is anti-racist education The purpose of multicultural education is to challenge and reject racism, prejudice, biases, stereotyping, and all forms of discrimination in school and society due emanating from differences in ethnic origin/background, religious beliefs, economic status, and gender. 2. Multicultural education is basic education Multicultural literacy is a very essential part of living in the 21st century.
It opens the curriculum to a variety of cultural
perspectives and experiences or inclusions of more “voices” reflective of multiple realities of many different people rather than a dominant group. 3. Multicultural education is a political movement This reveals that education is not politically neutral, which is then reflected in the power of teachers and school administrators to play a dominant role in the teaching and learning process.
If this will comprehensively be implemented,
transformation and enrichment of schooling will be achieved leading to a more critical and socially active members of the society. 4. Multicultural education is a wide-ranging school reform It is a movement or reform that calls for overhauling of school climate, physical environment, curriculum, and relationships among teachers and students.
Multicultural education asserts the abolition of social
injustice, inequality, and oppression through a logical critique of the system and analysis of the mechanism used in domination, as well as power and privilege. 5. Multicultural education is critical pedagogy Multicultural education works on basic assumption that a realistic and wide-ranging reform can be accomplished only through analyzing the system of power and privilege in a given community or nation.
It critically questions, for example, “Who dominates
in school?”; “Whose culture is favored?”; “Whose values are written and valued in school?” 6. Multicultural education is education for social justice Multicultural education is one approach to address problems that ethnic groups experience within the school system.
Class discussions must be centered on concerns that
affect culturally diverse communities, such as poverty, marginalization, discrimination, and what students can do to change them. 7. Multicultural education is important for all students Multicultural education is not only for culturally different and disadvantaged students but also for the students in the dominant culture who are generally the most miseducated about diversity. GOALS OF MULTICULTURAL EDUCATION 1. The supreme aim of multicultural education is to assist learners obtain better self-understanding by looking at themselves from the standpoint of other cultures. 2. Multicultural education presupposes that with the proper orientation and understanding of diversity, respect may follow. 3. Multicultural education provides students with cultural and ethnic alternatives. 4. To afford all learners with the essential knowledge, skills, and values needed to function within their ethnic culture, within mainstream culture, and within and across other ethnic cultures. 5. To lessen the pain and inequality that members of some ethnic and racial groups experience because of their unique physical, ethnic, racial, and cultural characteristics. DIMENSIONS OF MULTICULTURAL EDUCATION 1. Content Integration
The use of examples and content from a
wide variety of cultures to illustrate important concepts, generalizations, and issues within the discipline being taught. 2. Knowledge Construction Process
Refers to the way the teacher helps the
students understand and determine rationalization and inferences within a discipline 3. Prejudice Reduction
Lessons and activities used by teachers help
students develop positive attitudes toward different racial, ethnic, and cultural groups. These lessons and activities include the use of content about the different racial and ethnic groups. 4. Equity Pedagogy
Teachers modify ways of teaching to facilitate
student academic achievement from diverse racial, cultural, and social class groups.
Cooperative teaching enhances academic
achievement rather than competitive ones. 5. Empowering school culture and social structure
This dimension is created when the culture and
organization of the school are transformed in ways that enable students from diverse racial, ethnic, and gender groups experience equality and equal status. GROWTH OF STUDENT SUBCULTURE Subculture A cultural group within a larger culture, after having beliefs or interests at variance with those of the larger culture.
Sociologists define subculture as cultural
patterns that set apart some segment of a society’s population. Subculture can be based on a variety of factors, including religion, race, ethnicity, age, and sexual orientation.
Members of subcultures do not necessarily
reject the dominant culture, but they embrace their own culture as valid and important. We can the example of being part of a “college student subculture.” By becoming a college student, you have chosen to join a particular subcultural group with it’s own particular way of life.
Being part of a subculture does not mean you
cannot be part of other subcultural groups or the society as a whole. A person’s place in the society can be looked at on two basic levels:
★ In terms of a generic sense of culture
What it means to people.
★ In terms of a specific sense of subculture
Particular sets of norms applicable only to the group Tensions sometimes develop between members of the dominant culture and one or more subcultures, especially subcultures that directly oppose the dominant culture.
This is called “deviant” by the dominant group.
Example of this is a homosexual subculture
(Calhoun, et al., 1994). FUNCTIONS OF SUBCULTURE Subcultures perform specific functions such as: 1. Permitting specialized activity
Subcultures are essential to the division of
labor which is essential in any society which is becoming larger and more complex. 2. Identity in Mass society
People want to distinguish themselves
from the crowd in order to feel that “I am somebody.” Subcultures permit this by enabling people with a common interest, situation, or set of experiences to stand out from the crowd. 3. Cultural adaptation and change
Subculture serves as a source of
adaptation to society. It is a mechanism through which cultural diffusion occurs.
This happens when the values of these
subcultures spread to the larger society. CULTURAL DIMENSIONS OF EDUCATIONAL PROCESSES Sociocultural influences on development stresses that cultures differ in their views of acceptable child-rearing practices. As a result of these differing beliefs, children of various cultures may think and act differently and carry these differences into the classroom. Cultural differences imply the transmission of ideas from generation to generation by significant members of the older generation (parents, teachers, religious leaders, eductional leaders, etc.) What is a culturally-responsive teaching? Culturally responsive instruction covers areas related to:
1. Inclusive content in the curriculum
2. Students’ prior knowledge that includes their culture 3. The idea that culture is central to student learning Culture is central to learning. It plays a role not only in communicating and receiving information, but also in shaping the thinking process of groups and individuals.