Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
BBA DEPARTMENT
Organizational Behavior
Lecturer : M Bilal Atta
Mobile: 0782076248
Email : bilalsaleematta@gmail.com
Organizational Behavior
Organization:
A group of two or more people who work on continuous basis
for a common goal, and who have coordination.
Why do we study organisational
behaviour?
. Understand
organizational
events
Organisational
behavior
research
Influence Predict
organisational organisational
events events
4
Sam Walton founder of Wal-Mart and the richest
person of the world said about the successful
organizations, “People are the key!”
1.Globalization
Now a day’s organization or businesses are not limited by the
national boundaries. For Example Mc Donald is present in
almost every country. Due to globalization the problems
faced by Mc Donald are:
Managing people with different attitude and culture.
There is difference in Business Motives for example US,
Australia and Hong Kong are capitalist which means they
focus on growth and profit these are not acceptable in
countries like France and Middle East.
In every country the Cost Of Production varies with
availability of resources.
Challenges Facing Management
2. Workforce Diversity
It means that organizations are becoming more heterogeneous/mixed
of people in terms of gender age, culture, etc. For example women
and men of different regions come together and work together in an
organization.
3. Customer satisfaction
Customer satisfaction today is your competitive advantage. Majority
of employees in developed countries work in service jobs. For
example technical support fast food counters. The main
characteristics required for this job is constant interaction with
customer for feedback.
4. Team management or people management
This is the most challenging thing because if you cannot manage a
team of people you can’t get your work done.
Challenges Facing Management
5. Recruitment
– Recruiting employees of right kind of knowledge, skills, and
ability was a challenge and is a challenge.
6. Effective Communication:
– In todays globalized and multi-cultural world, managers need
strong and effective communication skills.
7. Laws and Regulations
– Managers must be aware of the International and national laws,
otherwise they can’t get the work done.
8. Attrition
Attrition occurs when an employee retires or when the
company eliminates his job. Downsizings due to insufficient
budgets or financial crises are also challenges to deal with in
todays uncertain economy.
Undergoing a Paradigm Shift
Paradeigma meaning “model, or example.”
Greek
Thomas Kuhn introduced the term Paradigm
which is now used to mean a broad model for understanding an
issue, or it is a way of thinking.
Joel Barker defines Paradigm as:
“ paradigm simply establishes the rules (written or unwritten),
defines the boundaries, and tells one how to behave within the
boundaries to be successful.”
.
Paradigm Shift
It means for today’s and tomorrow's organizations and
management, there are new rules with different boundaries
requiring new and different behavior inside the boundaries
for organizations and management to be successful.”
Paradigm Effect
“ a situation in which people in the existing paradigm may not
even see- through their logic, reason and perception- the
changes that are occurring.”
This effect explains why it is difficult to move from old
management paradigm to new.
A New Perspective For Management
Management
Skills
Organizational Citizenship
Behavior (OCB)
It also called sense of ownership, means
doing Something extra for your organization
and it is not in your job description.
The Knowing Doing Gap
Stanford professor Jeff Pfeffor gave the idea of
“one-eighth” situation, and “the knowing-doing
gap”.
So it is ½*½*½ = 1/8th
Reasons of the “knowing-doing gap”:
1924 in Chicago
Purpose of Study
to see the effect of light on employees productivity
Result (No Effect)
Second Study 1927 by Elton Mayo
Six female employees team was made and were kept
in separate room
Work hours, break times, temperature etc., were
changed and an observer was noting their work who
was not supervisor
Productivity increased
Result (The Hawthorn Effect)
The Hawthorn Studies
The Hawthorn Effect
The attention and interest of supervisor or manager in
your work increases the performance.
Third Study
A mixed team of workers with 1 observer
Result (No increase in productivity)
Reason
Workers developed team and made their own rules &
standards for work as not to work hard
Theoretical Frameworks
OB uses three theoretical frameworks:
1. Cognitive Framework
2. Behaviorist Framework
3. Social Cognitive Framework
Cognitive Framework
• This framework says that behavior is mainly driven by “Cognition”.
• Cognition simply means the act of knowing and item of information or more
simply the thought process, understanding and information processing.
• Our behavior is directed towards a goal and we are conscious and aware of the
goal.
Classical Conditioning
Operant Conditioning
1) Classical Conditioning
This theory was developed by a Russian psychologist Ivan Pavlov.
Classical Conditioning.
A type of learning in which a neutral
stimulus comes to bring about a response after it is paired with a
stimulus that naturally brings about that response.
Classical conditioning
Pavlov started ringing a bell before presenting the dog
with meat. This pairing occurred repeatedly that first he rang
the bell and then presented the dog with meat. After repeated
experiences that dog started salivating at the sound of the bell,
even though Pavlov stopped presenting the meat.
Classical conditioning
Basics of classical conditioning
Unconditional stimulus.
A stimulus that brings about a response without having been learned. E.g., dark,
food, water
Unconditional response.
A response that is natural and needs no learning. E.g., getting hungry, thirsty and
fear etc.
Conditional stimulus
The neutral stimulus which is paired with an unconditional stimulus to
bring about a response. formerly caused only by the unconditional stimulus.
Conditional response.
A response that after conditioning follows previously neutral stimulus.
Applying classical conditioning
to behavior
How we learn to feel fear from creeping animals, although they are harmless,
or why we feel fear from darkness or dark objects.
Organizational Influence
Organizational
Behavior Environment
Self-efficacy
self-efficacy beliefs, "people's judgments of their capabilities to
organize and execute courses of action required to attain
designated types of performances"
"people's level of motivation, emotional states, and actions are based more
on what they believe than on what is objectively true" (Bandura)
Self-efficacy effects human thinking process, effort, skills and
outcomes of an activity.
Self-efficacy is developed from an individual previous experience,
modeling, social persuasion and emotional states during an
activity.
Mintzberg’s Managerial Roles
Interpersonal Roles
Figurehead.
when a manager is supervising a department then he is the figurehead of that
department.
Leadership.
this role includes hiring, training and motivating and disciplining the employees.
LIASION
develops and maintains a network of external contacts to gather information
Managerial Roles
Informational Roles
Monitor
This role includes collecting information by reading
magazines and talking to other people to know about the public taste,
planning of the competitors etc.
Disseminator
When the managers transmit this information to
organizational members they are playing the role of disseminator.
Spokesperson
When the manager is making any announcement
regarding the organization then he is playing the role of a
spokesperson.
Managerial Roles
Decisional Roles
Entrepreneur
As entrepreneur the manager initiates and oversees
the new activities that will improve organizational performance
Disturbance Handler
The manager takes corrective actions in
response to erasing problems
Resource Allocator.
Allocating resources to different departments
Negotiator.
They discuss issues and bargain with other firms to
get advantage for their own unit.
Diversity and Ethics
Diversity
Definition: (R. Roosevelt Thomas)
It is an all inclusive mixture of differences and similarities.
At micro level, we look at the differences and at macro level
we find similarities.
Age
Gender
Ethnicity
Education
Specific Characteristics of Diversity
Age:
1.Productivity
Older employees bring a number of qualities to work i.e. experience,
commitment, judgment, strong work ethics etc, and therefore increase
productivity.
Some organizations continue downsizing to reduce costs and increase productivity
and hire newly educated and trained employees.
Age discrimination laws also permits old employees in workforce.
2.Turn Over
Because of higher wage rates, longer paid vacations, and more attractive pension
benefits, old employees have lower turn over rate.
Young employees due to energy, and opportunities available may have high turn
over rate.
Specific Characteristics of Diversity
3.Absenteeism
Avoidable absence are made more by young employees and unavoidable absence ratio is high
in old people because of poor health and longer recovery periods.
4.Job Satisfaction
Job satisfaction increases with age due to commitment, pension, high wages etc.
Gender
In US women comprise 50% of workforce as compared to 40% in 1975.
Women employment may change the policies and day to day practices of organization
Glass Ceiling Effect:
The resistance to promotion of women to higher positions
Specific Characteristics of Diversity
Gender and Productivity
There are no consistent differences in problem solving skill, analytical skill, motivation, or
learning skill between male and female employees.
Both male and female are equal in productivity.
Ethnicity
Ethnicity means the ethnic composition of a group or organization.
Inclusion of different ethnic groups in workforce need a little bit changes in work
practices and rules.
Normally around the world minorities are treated differentially.
Education
Education level of female and minorities is increasing with the passage of time and
they are joining jobs in greater numbers now.
To train employees and educate due to competitive global economy, is a challenge
for todays organizations.
Managing Diversity
Developing Multicultural Organization
Multicultural organization is the one which recognizes the interests and
contributions of diverse cultural and social groups in its operation.
Eradicate (to get rid of completely) social oppression in all forms.
Includes members of diverse cultural and social groups in decisions of
organization.
Individual Approach to Managing Diversity
Learning
Empathy
Managing Diversity
Learning
Getting experience and one-on-one communication regardless of age, gender,
ethnicity, religion or country etc., can help prepare manager better to deal with
diverse groups.
E.g., with disable people after interaction, manager may come to know that they
don’t need special attention, they just need to be treated as normal employees.
Empathy
The ability to put one’s self in other place to see things from that person’s point of view.
Sometimes also called emotional intelligence, is very important for peaceful
environment in organizations.
Women harassment cases may result or ideological or cultural clashes may develop
due to insufficient understanding of others feeling and views.
Managing Diversity
Organizational Approach to Managing Diversity
Testing
Job specific tests rather than traditional knowledge and intelligence test, can help
remove bias and focus on the specific job.
Carefully conducted interviews and role plays can be helpful in assessing the applicant
interpersonal and communication skills.
Training
Diversity trainings can be either delivered to diverse groups or to the diversity
managers and employees who work with diverse groups.
The trainees of one group are asked to describe the other group and then the other one
is shown how they have been described by the first one.
Groups also describe problems they face while working with other groups
Games are also arranged to develop understanding among diverse groups regarding
each other.
But these trainings will only yield results if the objectives are linked to outcomes.
Managing Diversity
Mentoring
Mentor is a trusted counselor, or advisor who provides an assistance.
Mentoring is used for women and minorities.
Benefits of Mentoring
Identify skills and interests of the employees
Instruction on specific skills and knowledge necessary for successful job
performance.
Help understanding the unwritten rules (informal organization) to avoid saying or
doing the wrong things
Offering emotional support
Serving as role model
Ethics
Definition (Fred Luthons)
“Ethics involves moral issues and choices and deals with right and wrong
behavior.”
Cultural, organizational and external environmental factors influence ethical
behavior.
Cultural influences on ethical behavior come from: family, friends, neighbors, education, religion,
and media
Organizational influences come from: ethical codes, role models, policies and practices, and
reward and punishment.
External environmental influences include: political, legal, economic, and international
developments.
The perception of ethical behavior may differ even with in one organization, i.e., the same
issue may be viewed by the faculty members as ethical while the executives my view it as
unethical.
Due to ethical issues relating to the protection of the environment, use of bribes, price
fixing, illegal accounting practices, ethics has become an important concern for
international management.
Ethics
Impact of Ethics on Outcomes
Besides morality issues, ethics also affect the outcomes of business in positive way.
Different studies have found that ethical commitment leads to increase market value added
(MVA) and increase financial outcomes.
Another study found that pollution control and reduction of hazardous waste programs
positively influence profitability gains.
Springfield Remanufacturing Corporation is an ideal organization based on trust, total
transparency and ethical organizational culture.
Springfield Remanufacturing Corporation uses this quick test when employees are faced with
ethical issues.
1. Is the action legal?
2. Is it right.?
3. Who will be affected?
4. Does it fit the companies values?
5. How I would feel afterwards? Islam is the complete code
of life and it’s ethics are the
6. How would I look in the newspaper?
best in the world.
7. Will it reflect poorly on company?
Ethics
Employee Privacy Issues
Internet
Due to internet employees can have password identification codes.
Surveys indicate increase in employer storage and review of e-mail messages.
U.S. Nissan company two trainers sued against their employer because of checking their
personal emails.
Another ethical issue is how to monitor employees using internet
Cyberloafing and downloading virus-infected softwares is also a reason given sometimes to
keep check on employees use of internet.
Employees drug testing
It is also an ethical issue e.g., Motorola take drug tests of all employees every three year.
Personal Life Style
A relatively new threat to privacy is companies dictating personal life style e.g., weight,
smoking,
Groups
Definition
Two or more individuals,
interacting and interdependent, who come
together to achieve particular objectives.
Formal and informal groups
Command Groups
(1).Formal group
Task Groups
Interest Groups
(2).Informal group
Friendship Groups
70 Chapter 8 Prentice Hall, 2001
Four Types of Groups
Command group.
– determined by the organization chart. It is
composed of individuals who directly report to a given manager.
Example
An elementary school principal and her 18 teachers is a command
group. or the area sales manager along with his sales force.
Four Types of Groups
Task group
– it is also organizationally determined represent those
working together to complete a job task, however a task group’s
boundaries are not limited to its immediate hierarchical superior.
Example
The hiring of new employees can be a task which can involve GM, HR
manager and a particular functional manager.
Four Types of Groups
Interest group
are such groups that affiliate to attain a specific objective
of shared interest. for example employees who come together to have
their vacations schedules altered, to support a colleague who has been
fired or to seek improvement in working conditions is an interest
group.
Friendship group – members have one or more common
characteristics. for example similar age or holding similar political
views
Why people join groups ?
Security Status
What
Makes
Self-
Esteem People Affiliation
Join
Groups?
Goal
Power
Achievement
Why People Join Groups?
Security
By joining groups people feel stronger, less in self doubt and are more safe from threats.
Status
Joining group gives status and recognition.
Self-esteem
Conveying status to outsiders, group gives a feeling of self-worth to it’s members.
Affiliation
Groups fulfill social needs. On-the-job interactions are primary source of fulfillment of affiliation
need for many people.
Power
What cannot be accomplished individually becomes possible through group.
Goal Achievement
Task accomplishment is sometimes impossible without group. So, the management relies on the
formal group for different knowledge & expertise etc.
Stages of Group Development
Stage I Stage II
Forming Storming
The group structure becomes fully functional and group energy moves
from getting to know and understand each other to perform a task at
hand.
For permanent work groups performing is the last stage of their
development, however for temporary committees, task forces or
other similar groups that have a limited task to perform, there is an
adjourning stage.
Stages of Group Development
5. Adjourning stage.
In this stage the group prepares for its disbandment,
where high task performance is no longer the group’s priority, instead
attention is directed toward wrapping up activities.
Team Work Group
Has collective work-products- collective Individual work product
work product is what two or more
members must work on together.
Group
Roles
Conflict Perception
Group Roles
According to Shakespeare all the world is a stage and all the men and
women are players. similarly all the group members are actors.
Role is defined as……to engage in a set of expected
behavior that are related to occupying a given position in a social unit.
Group Roles
1. Role Identity
Attitudes and behaviors consistent/matching with a role.
When workers are promoted to supervisory positions vital/important
changes are observed in their behavior with other workers.
Group Roles
2.Role Perception
Our view of how we’re supposed to act in a given situation is called role perception.
3.Role Expectations
How others believe you should act in a given situation is called role expectation.
4.Role Conflict
Person having conflicting tasks or task that is against person’s personal values.
Cohesiveness
The degree to which members of the
group
are attracted to each
other and motivated to
stay in the group.
Related to the group’s
productivity intact (whole) group.
Group Decision Making
Advantages Disadvantages
3. Social Loafing
“Low effort and performance while and working in group.”
Causes are lack of feedback, and “sucker effect” which means that an employee
doesn’t work more than what he thinks.
Collectivist societies have less social loafing while individualistic societies
experience more social loafing.
Social Loafing normally occurs in large groups.
Teams in Modern Workplace
1. Cross-Functional Teams
Teams made up of individuals from various departments.
2. Virtual Teams
Group with non-face to face interaction or communication at distance through electronic means such
as e-mail, chat rooms, phone and video conferencing, faxes, satellite transmissions and websites.
Synchronous technologies
That allow people to interact at the same time or in real time e.g., audio-video conferencing
Asynchronous technologies
For jobs of lower complexity delayed interaction through e-mails, chat rooms, Web pages, bulletin
boards etc.
3. Self-Managed Teams
• A group of employees who are responsible for managing and performing technical tasks.”
• Some times they are empowered to hire, organize and manage without direct approval of the
management.
Managing Performance
through Job Design
and Goal Setting
Scientific Management
A set of principles and practices designed to increase the
performance of individual workers by stressing job
simplification and job specialization.
Job simplification:
The breaking up of the work that needs to be performed in an
organization into the smallest identifiable tasks.
Job specialization:
The assignment of workers to perform small, simple tasks.
Time and motion studies:
Studies that reveal exactly how long it takes to perform a task
and the best way to perform it.
Scientific Management in Practice
Pay is the principal outcome used to motivate workers to
contribute their inputs.
Specific disadvantages:
Workers may feel that they have lost control over their work
behaviors.
Workers may feel as if they are part of a machine and are
treated as such.
Workers have no opportunity to develop and acquire new skills.
Job Design
“Methods that management uses to develop the content of a job, including all
relevant tasks, as well as the process by which jobs are constructed and revised.”
Job Design determines: What task are done How the task are done How many task
are done and In what order the job is done
Central to OB study due to the intrusion of recent trends changing nature of work
most importantly due to:
Internet, intranet, e-business.
Two new developments emerged due to the advanced IT
1st
Blurred boundaries between on-work and off-work, carrying cell phone, personal
digital assistant (PDA), home office containing fax machine and being “on call”
practically every moment of the day.
2nd
Telecommuting Jobs or Teleworking, in which employees do substantial amounts of
work at home.
Job Design
Job Design
Job Engineering
The work of every employee is fully planned by the management at least one day in advance
Each man received in most cases complete written instructions, describing in details the task
which he is to accomplish.
This task specifies not only what is to be done but how it is to be done and the exact time
allowed for doing it
Work should be arranged so that workers can be efficient.
Employees selected for work should be matched to the demands of the job.
Employees should be trained to perform the job.
Monetary compensation should be used to reward successful performance of the job
Specialization and regularization of work leads to high levels of output and employees
becoming more experts.
Demerits of Job Engineering Approach
Repetition
Mechanistic
Little social interaction
No effect on turn over and absenteeism, satisfaction
Increased alienation and frustration
Job Design
Job Rotation
It’s a form job redesign that involves moving employees from one
relatively simple job to another after short time periods (one hour, half-
days, every day).
E.g., McDonald’s
Benefits
Employees become more flexible & are able to cover another employee’s job in
case of his/her absence.
Another advantage is that in McDonald’s e.g., a manager promoted only after 6
months to a rank has probably exposed to every production task.
Some research proves it’s good in sense of cross-training the employees and
broadened responsibility.
Disadvantage
With the passage of time, each individual task becomes boring as rest of the simple
task, so no significance impact on satisfaction.
Job Design
Job Enlargement
Increasing the number of tasks that an employee performs.
Benefits
Employees are able to use more skills in performing their tasks.
Cost-effective
Disadvantages
Low efficiency with which tasks are completed individually
Increased anxiety and dissatisfaction especially in cases of downsizing
Job Design
Job Enrichment
It’s the application of Herzberg’s two-factor theory.
According to this technique jobs are designed in a way that employees
have:
Variety of work content
Autonomy and responsibility in terms of planning
Opportunity for personal growth and meaningful work experience.
Disadvantages
Some times employees don’t want to change job.
Some employees have on high priority the pay.
Some employees like their on-the-job socialization and friendship rather than
increased responsibility and autonomy.
Advantages
More employee satisfaction, customer service, fewer employee errors.
Job Characteristic Model of Job Design
Job Characteristic Model of Job
Design
Example of Applying Job Characteristics
Model of Job Design
Skill variety
The sales people were asked to think of and use
Different selling approaches
New merchandise displays
Better ways of recording sales and keeping records
Task Identity
The sales people are asked to
Keeping a personal record of daily sales volume in dollars
Keep a record of number of sales/customers
Task Significance
Sales people are reminded that
Selling a product is the basic overall objective of the store
Courtesy and pleasantness helps build the store’s reputation
Example of Applying Job Characteristics
Model of Job Design
Autonomy
Sales people are encouraged to
Develop and use their own unique sales approach
Have freedom of selecting their own break and lunch times
Make suggestions for making changes in all phases of policy and operations
Feedback from the Job Itself
Sales persons keep personal record of their own sales volume
Good rapport with customers and satisfied customer is employee success.
Feedback from Agents
Observe and help each other with techniques of selling
Seek out information from boss and relevant departments on all phases of their
job
Invite customers’ reaction concerning merchandise, service etc.
Advice to Managers
Realize that increasing intrinsic motivation decreases your need for
extrinsic motivation & control.
To increase levels of intrinsic motivation, increase levels of the five
core dimensions.
Assess workers’ desire for personal growth and development at work
first.
Make sure the extrinsic motivation & satisfaction prior to redesigning
jobs.
Assess workers’ abilities & skills before redesigning their jobs.
Periodically assess workers’ perceptions of the core dimensions of
their jobs as well as their levels of job satisfaction and intrinsic
motivation.
Engagement, Disengagement, and Social
Information Processing
Psychological/Personal Engagement (William Kahn)
When employees physically, cognitively and emotionally are involved in job performance.
E.g., Study of Youth Camp compared to Architectural Firm
How to enhance personal engagement?
1. Meaningfulness (feeling that task is valuable and useful)
2. Safety (work without fear of self-image, status or career)
3. Availability (feeling that sufficient physical, cognitive and emotional resources are
available for a job)
Psychological Disengagement
Psychologically distant from performing a job and withdrawing from a job.
Gallup studies show that about one in five U.S employees reported being disengaged.
Main reasons are poor pay and working conditions, strict supervision, but recent studies
show that lack of job fit, poor management, and lack of person-environment fit are the
main reasons.
Engagement, Disengagement, and Social
Information Processing
Social Information Processing (SIP by Salancik &
Pfeffer)
According to SIP Three major causes of employee behavior on
the job are:
Cognitive perceptions of real job environment or how they think about the
job environment
Past job experience: positive or negative
The feedback received from managers, co-workers & customers etc.
So, social information and social cues (feedback and
comments of managers, workers and customers) in organization
have major influence on employees attitude towards, and
behavior on their job and their engagement and disengagement).
Quality of Work Life, Sociotechnical
Design
Quality of Work Life (QWL)
The concern about the impact of Job on people and organizational effectiveness plus the
emphasis on the participation and problem solving.
Recent research shows that QWL has positive impact on employee turn over and
productivity, even across cultures.
The practical application of QWL & what is exactly meant by quality is still under question,
(quality means good pay or personal engagement).
In HRM, job sharing, flextime and four day, 10 hour work weeks are examples of QWL.
In OB Sociotechnical Design & HPWPs are important approaches to QWL
Sociotechnical Design
Background
This approach came from, Swedish Saab & Volvo Automobile Plants.
Employees wanted more meaningful jobs and there was need of efficient car building
process for company.
Employees absenteeism & turn over increased.
Quality of Work Life, Sociotechnical Design
Sociotechnical Design
Definition:
“Natural work modules served by autonomous work groups , assigning &
inspecting their own work, and each member of the group working towards the
same group goals and all are paid the same except the leader.”
Employees turn over & absenteeism decreased and cost savings increased.
This approach was also used in USA General Foods (Kansas).
Shared responsibility, autonomous work groups, coaches instead of supervisors
were used.
Result was positive attitude & efficiency, but later on due to lowering the authority
of the managers, they became against this approach, and it resulted in failure.
Previously Proctor & Gamble used this approach now general Mills, FedEx,
Hewlett- Packard use this approach of autonomy and empowerment.
Quality of Work Life, Sociotechnical Design, High-
Performance Work Practices (HPWPs)
High-Performance Work Practices/Systems (HPWPs)
“An organization system that adjusts its strategy, goals, objectives, and internal operations
with the demands of external environment to maximize organizational performance.”
Primary objective of HPWPs is to achieve fit among people, technology, information, and
work.
Total organizational culture must include:
Organization’s strategy
Encouragement of innovation
Measures of internal & external customer service
Cooperation
Teamwork
Open communication
Trust
HPWPs emphasize empowerment and disadvantages associated with people doing jobs that
do not match their skills.
HPWPs emphasize multiple selectors and training of selectors and innovative performance
evaluations and feedback e.g., 360-degree feedback.
International Perspectives on the Design of
Work
The Japanese Approach
Emphasizes strategic level
Encourages collective and cooperative working arrangements
Emphasizes lean production
Lean Production
Net production with zero waste while ensuring quality
International Perspectives on the Design
of Work
Specificity
Often quantitative
Difficulty
Should be hard but not impossible for most workers to achieve
Acceptability
Especially important when managers set goals for subordinates
Feedback
So that workers know how well they are doing
Mechanisms:
Specific, Difficult Goals leading to Motivation and
Performance
Advice to Managers
Be sure that a worker’s goals are specific and difficult,
whether set by you, by the worker, or by both of you.
Express confidence in your subordinates’ abilities to
attain their goals, and give subordinates regular feedback
on the extent of goal attainment.
When workers are performing difficult and complex
tasks that involve learning, do not set goals until the
workers gain some mastery over the task.
The End