Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
1
Contact Information
2
My Research Background
As grad student trained in experimental
design and statistics
Dissertation and early research projects all
used statistical procedures
Learned case study methods from research
in written composition (e.g., Flower and
Hayes; Emig, etc.)
Conducted case study research when
research assistant in grad school
1997 begin 11 year program of research on
pre-service teachers’ learning and
development
3
My Teacher Education Research
Focused on OSU teacher education program
Master’s of Education (MED) with Initial Licensure
Studies of transfer of theories from course work into
classroom practice
Several short-term studies and one longitudinal (4
year study)
Had to develop expertise in case study methods due
to theoretical framework, common sense, and
constraints of my teaching schedule
Learned from other researchers such as Peter
Smagorinsky and Pamela Grossman.
4
What I am going to talk about
Use of case study in educational
research
When to use case study methods
What case methods include
How case study differs from other
approaches to educational research
Applying case study methods to a
research project
Strengths and limitations
5
A Research Problem: “A Research
Project in Need of a Plan”
We will use what we learn about case
study methods
Receive handout
Read description
Ask me clarifying questions now
We will return later to work on a
design for this project
6
Using Experimental Design to
Study Effects of Training
Some background: the field of teacher
education research as example
Before mid-1980s most educational
research used experimental methods
Example question: How do particular
training approaches affect pre-service
teachers’ ability to analyze teaching?
Post-tests: paper and pencil tests,
questionnaire, etc.
Experimental and control groups compared.
7
Experimental Method
Control of variables by the design—
example: same amount of time for
each approach
Two or three different approaches:
training on how to introduce lesson
Pre- and post-tests
Selection of statistical test
8
Problems with Experimental
Approach in Learning Studies
Not possible to control variables such as
teachers’ backgrounds, instructional time,
etc.
Teaching redefined as more than a set of
easily measured skills.
Performance on post-tests may not be
related to actual teaching experience.
None of these studies considered if
teachers actually transferred teaching skills
into classroom settings.
9
From Training to Learning
The “new” teacher education.
Training model too simplistic—not just what
teachers do but what they understand and
believe.
Learning to teach includes considering what
teachers already know
Teaching develops over time
People learn to teach in social settings such
as schools
Where teachers teach affects how they
teach
10
Why Case Studies?
From Training Studies to
Studies of Learning
To study the process of learning how
to teach
To consider the effects of prior
knowledge and experiences
To examine effects of contexts:
teacher education programs,
classrooms, and schools
To analyze why teachers believe in
some ideas but dismiss others
11
Comparison of Case Study and
Experimental Approach
Experimental Case Study
Control of Difficult to control
variables—context variables—
created by the complexities of
study context is central
Assumes Assumes that
treatment will be teachers’ beliefs
effective shape what is
Issues regarding effective
use in school Study issues
contexts related to school
contexts
12
Defining a Case: Single, Bounded
Individual System?
13
Designing the Study
The research design gets you “from
here to there, where here may be
defined as an initial set of questions
to be answered, and there is some
set of conclusions (answers) about
these questions” (Yin 1994, p. 19).
14
Developing a Research Problem
Where do problems come from?
Range of sources
Own experience
Previous research
Current issues in one’s field
Be sure you know if problem has been
studied before
Be sure to understand how you might
contribute to understanding the problem—
what is gap between what is known and
what needs to be known.
15
Developing the Research Problem (1)
When Dr. Jones searched for studies
of the effects of teacher education
programs on teacher learning, he
found that the findings were very
mixed and confusing—different
studies blamed the problems on
different institutions
16
Developing the Research Problem (2)
Given that Dr. Jones wanted to
understand the kinds of experiences
preservice teachers encounter have in
the program, he decided to use case
study methods.
17
Theoretical Framework
Research questions are derived from
the theoretical framework.
Let’s look at the theoretical frame for
“A Research Project in Need of a
Plan.”
Review the theoretical framework
Review the research questions.
18
Theoretical Framework
Sociocultural theory provides a way to
study how people learn in social settings.
Focus on the different social settings (high
school classrooms, university courses, etc.)
Learning to teach involves learning to take
tool-mediated action (e.g., lesson planning)
in social settings
Tools are the lessons plans, activities, and
curriculum materials that teachers use.
19
Research Questions
1. What were the principal social settings or
contexts in which the 6 student teachers
learned to teach reading and writing?
2. What were the goals and approaches to
reading and writing that shaped the student
teachers’ learning in these settings, and what
instructional tools encouraged approaches to
reach those goals?
3. Within these contexts or settings, what
influenced the 6 student teachers learning to
teach high school reading and writing, and how
did their reading and writing instruction
develop within these contexts?
20
Sample Selection
(Selecting Participants and Settings)
Purposive sampling: to discover and
understand, so select sample
carefully
Information rich cases for in-depth
study
Begin with criteria: create a list of the
attributes essential to study
Find people and settings that match
your list
21
Types of Purposeful Sampling
Typical: reflects average person
Unique: captures special features
Maximum variation: diverse people
Network (chain): asking others for
referrals
Convenience: people and settings
that are available
22
Sampling Example
Settings
Accessible and friendly
Willing participants reside there
Participants
How many do I need?
How many can I include?
Selecting Preservice Teachers
Available and willing
Different gender, ethnicity, age?
Successful students preferred
23
Collecting Data
Interviews
Classroom observations
Collecting documents
24
Small Group Discussion
Groups of 5
Re-read “A Research Project in Need
of a Plan”
Answer questions (30 minutes)
Go over questions
Time to work on questions
Let’s discuss your ideas.
25
Case Study Research Reconsidered
Strengths Limitations
In–depth Cannot generalize
understanding of findings to other
processes and contexts
context Single case may be
misleading
Focus on a single
representation
case and then
We need studies of
study in depth
what we think works
Valuable for
studying new areas
of concern
26
Case Study Research Reconsidered (2)
Strengths Limitations
Excellent when Experimental and
studying social quasi-experimental
process over which studies needed to see
we have little control if things work
Ground work for We need balance
further study between exploratory
Tool for sorting out studies and studies
complex and that are confirmatory
confusing factors Need to build upon
shaping teaching and case studies rather
learning than conducting more
and more—what are
we learning?
27
Case Study Research Reconsidered (3)
Strengths Limitations
Has face validity as Need to study a large
a method for range of other
studying one’s own programs and not
students just the researcher’s
We need to see what
Enables us to study usually happens as
uniqueness— well
“Image of the We need studies to
Possible” convince
Has given us many stakeholders that
valuable insights teacher ed makes a
that shape practice difference.
28
Thank you!!
29