Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
FOR DESIGNERS
(III YEAR ARCHITECTURE)
S. RAJAGOPALAN Ph.D.
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 1
• Based on Architectural Acoustic Theory
and Practice
• Will deal with physics and perception of
sound, characteristics and their influence
on design concepts
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 2
• Fact: Change is Constant
• Develop and attitude; mind training
• Problems as challenges NOT as hurdles
• (Feynman: radio repairs)
• Top-notch work from young minds; out of
the box thinking
• Triggers (blue skies ?)
• Intuitions: can come only from trained
minds.
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 3
• Communication, Distance, Propagation
• Amphitheatre
• Sound perception in spaces:
• Direct
• Reflected
• Mix of reflected: reverberant
• Delayed reflections: echo
• Required reflections: Ancient idea
• Rising Steps and stage reflectors
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 4
Sound Travel
• Fastest in solids. High velocities in Steel,
Concrete etc. But low in wood
• If speed is high, attenuation (absorption) is
low
• In liquids velocity is lower compared to
solids
• In gases the velocity is least
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 5
Octave Band Filters
Sound signal
Frequency
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 6
Some basics…..
• Velocity, Frequency and Wavelength
c or v, f and λ
c=fλ f is a number, λ is in units of
length, and c is in length/time
What changes with what?
When f changes does c change?
Human hearing range: 20 Hz to 20,000 Hz.
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 7
Basic contd……….
• Velocities:
In gases / air ~ 330 ms-1
In liquids ~ 2000 ms-1
In solids ~ 5000 ms-1
Do they change? Newton: c = (E/ρ)½
Importance of ambience: T and P
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 8
Echo
• Distinct and separated and sufficiently
loud. Fluttering and ringing
+10
Annoyance
0
-20
No annoyance
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 9
Decibel (dB)
• Dr. Weber suggested after several
experiments subjective response R is
proportional to the fractional change of
stimulus S:
δR ∞ δS/S
• Integrating: R = k log S
• Dealing with Intensity I and now
looking at it with reference to a
international standard intensity I0
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 10
dB……..
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 11
• Intensity ∞ p2 = p2 / ρc, ρ is the
density, and c is the velocity in the
medium
• ρc = 410 rayls for air
• Threshold Intensity I0 = (2 x 10-5)2 / 410
which is = 10-12 w/m2
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 12
dB……..
• When we consider pressures created by
an acoustic signal: I ∞ P2 . Thus,
Int. Lvl.(SIL) = 10 log I/I0 = 10 log P2/ P02
= 20 log P/P which is the Sound Pressure
0
Level (SPL). Threshold pressure P0 is
2x10-5 N/m2
SIL = SPL in value.
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 13
How much SPL increase when I gets
doubled?
10 Log (I/I0) ~ 10 log (2I/I0) = 10 x 0.3
which is 3 dB.
When p is doubled? SPL increase =
20 log (p / p0) ~ 20 log (2p / p0)
= 20 x 0.3 = 6 dB
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 14
• Ex: The RMS pressure of sound signal is
200 N/m2. Sound Pressure Level?
SPL = 20 log10 200/(2 x 10-5) = 140 dB
How about Intensity? I = p2/ρc = 98 W/m2
Take I = 0.01 W/m2; SPL = SIL
= 10 Log I / I0 = 100 dB (still quite high)
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 15
Filter weightages
SPL meter to behave as human ear: apply A
filter
For additional frequency C
L
Recognition: FilterB E
B
For low frequency V
E A
Recognition: FilterC L
Frequency
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 16
Weighting
• A-weighting: the measuring equipment
will behave exactly like human ear. The
equipment normally would give a flat
response. To obtain how the human ear
perceives apply the following correction:
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 17
Addition of noises from multiple
sources
• Combine to produce noise of higher level
• Two equally intense sounds will produce a
level 3 dB higher than the source level.
This is due to logarithmic addition.
dB W/m2
130 ---- 10+1 Threshold of pain
I
LI ------
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 18
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 19
Fletcher-Munson …
Equal loudness contours
Very high loudness
S
P
loudness
L
dB
Frequency
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 20
Sensitivity of hearing
140 dB: Jet engine 20 M away; Painful & dangerous
Threshold of pain
>110
Speech + Symphony
25 dB
Threshold of Very faint
feeling 0 dB; Threshold of hearing
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 22
• Siren source. Barely hear at
40M. How much Int at 20 M? 20 M
40 M
95 dB
Not to exceed 40 dB
@7M
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 23
• I = W/4πr2; I1/I2 = (r2 /r1)2
Find how far a noisy chiller be
kept away from the building porch
(max. level allowed 40 dBA). Given measured
value 95 dBA at 7M away.
Intensity at 7M from chiller, calculate.
Calculate Intensity corresponding to 40 dB at porch.
Use inverse law to obtain distance of chiller from porch
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 24
Add dBs….
• Cannot be added arithmetically
• Intensities can be added arithmetically
• Square of pressures could be added
DIFFERENCE
5 9 16 19
0 1 2 3 4
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 26
Yet another example….
• In a factory SPL with all machines running = 101
dB. One particular machine itself generates 99
dB. SPL of all other machines put together?
Difference 2 dB, corresponds to correction 2 dB
To be subtracted from lower value:
99 – 2 = 97 dB.
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 27
DECIBELS DECREASING WITH DISTANCE
90dB 84 dB 78 dB 72 dB
10 M 20M 40 M 80M
When two decibel values differ by add the value to higher level
0 or 1 3
2 or 3 2
4 to 8 1
9 or more 0
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 28
Reducing with distance ?
• Intensity being power per unit area, when
distance doubles, intensity is ¼ th.
4πR2
*
d d
d 2d
R 2R
NR, dB Spherical spreading:
point source
Cylindrical spreading:
Line source
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 29
Distance from source
Performing arts Theatre
Is a collaborative form of fine art that uses live performers
to present the experience of a real or imagined event
before a live audience in a specific place, often a stage.
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 30
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 31
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 32
Noise exposure
120 dB : not allowed
Prepared by OSHA of USA
115 dB Upper limit after careful research
90 dB have created this
80 dB
criterion for exposure.
Decibel levels are
measured by Sound
Level Meters (SLM)
4 8 24 Impulsive noise like gunfire
duration per day or impact noise from
heavy machinery not to
exceed 140 dB
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 33
ACOUSTIC MATERIALS
• Gypsum board: Fine gypsum powder compressed,
covered with special tough paper for protection.
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 34
Wool media: Say, cotton wool, glass fibre-
wool.
Broadband absorption.
Vibrational form of energy transfer to fibre.
Concept of heat conversion and dissipation
to cause absorption.
Low weight and easy to handle.
But large volume due to low density.
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 35
Wood: Natural, Engineered, Ply, chip-board,
MDF board, Reinforced, Formatted in
different forms.
Additional support taken using superior
absorbers………………….
Good absorption in the MF and moderate
absorption in HF.
Poor LF absorption unless in thin sheets,
and by process of resonances.
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 36
Fabrics, carpets, Soft-boards (jute based,
banana fibre-based etc.).
Thin Wood-strips glued together (wood-wool
boards) and modified versions. (broad-band
absorption)
Compressed fibre-glass-wool, mineral-wool.
Rockwool. (important: density & thickness)
Good absorption at mid and high
frequencies.
Combinations of the above.
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 37
Even air can be used as an absorber.
Resonator.
Helmholtz resonator.
Air column resonance. Trapped air column.
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 38
Shapes………
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 39
Reverberation
• Origin from steady broadband source
Source stopped
Important for music
• L Echoes
e
v
e Shot Terminal decay:
l Important for
organ
Background noise
• Time, ms
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 40
Hall shapes
Floor level
SECTION: Prosc. op
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 41
Reverb……………
Absorption coefficient α; Average α’
Balance is reflection: 1-α’
Yet another reflection: (1-α’)2
Yet another: (1-α’)3
Reverberation time is for 60 dB decay
After n reflections: (1-α’)n I0 = Io 10-6
…..Leads to 0.16V / -S log (1-α’)
Expanding (1-α’), RT = 0.16V/SA
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 42
Reverb……..
Correction due to air absorption: xV where x
is the air-absorption / unit volume
X has dependence on RH
Calculation: V, S and A.
S will be ∑areas. A will be ∑absorptions
Absorption = abs. coefft. X area
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 43
Reverberation Time
Echoes
60 dB
R.T Time, ms
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 44
SWL
Sound Power levels of ventilating fans:
PWL or SWL = 10 log W / W0; Wo = 10-12 watts
= 10 log W + 120
Intensity I = W/4πr2 and so SIL=SPL= 10 Log I / I0
10 log W / (4πr2/10-12) = 10 logW +120-10 log 4πr2
= SWL – 20 log r – 11
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 45
SWL
Sound Power levels of ventilating fans:
PWL or SWL = 10 log W / W0; Wo = 10-12 watts
= 10 log W + 120
Intensity I = W/4πr2 and so SIL=SPL= 10 Log I / I0
10 log W / (4πr2/10-12) = 10 logW +120-10 log 4πr2
= SWL – 20 log r – 11
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 46
Noise Criteria
SPL,dB Pivoting criteria for acoustically
sensitive ambients. For example,
for auditoriums NC30.
NC80
Recording studios: NC10
Concert halls: Best NC10
Normal NC20
NC60
Offices: NC35 to NC40
Bedrooms: NC30
NC40 Classrooms: NC25 to NC30
Hotel bed: NC25 to 30
NC20
Restaurants: NC 40 to 45
20 75 600 2400 4800
Churches: NC25
75 150 1200 4800 9600
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 47
DEAD ROOM
Characterized by very very low RT.
High noise isolation to provide low noise
intrusion
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 49
ARTICULATION INDEX
• Basic theory path breaking work: Lochner
& Burger: J. Soun & Vib 1964.
• Modulation ACCEPT
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 50
• Modulation loss
• Loss of clarity and intelligence
• For symphony music: 0.4-0.5
• For organ: 0.3
• For drama, academic: 0.6 and above
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 51
Criteria
Deafness risk criteria: 150 dB results in
instant hearing damage.
140 dB for < 1 minute exposure
For more than 5 hours working/day, Wilson
report suggests: 38-150 band (100dB),
150-300(90); 300-600(85); 600-1200(85);
1200-2400(80); 2400(80).
Temporary threshold shift: recovery
overnight.
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 52
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 53
Reflection, Absorption…
• Reflection, Absorption and Transmission
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 54
Transmission loss
or
Sound Reduction
STL or R = 10 log (1/t); t= transmission coefficient
If t= 0.001 then STL = 30 dB
For composite partition, Addable
S1t1 + S2t2 + …. = S tav property
Published TL value does not include flanking paths
Fixing method may be different from lab method
Partition size can affect TL value; for ex. Resonance
Lab reverb condition may not exist in actual field situation
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 55
STL contd………..
Level diff between two rooms is
SPL1 – SPL2 = TL – 10 log S – 10 log A
S is partition area; A = abs. in receiving room
Does not include flanking transmission
Ex: Discotheque noise level = 88 dB in 1 KHz band; Calculate
expected level for the same band for 10m x 5m partition of TL/R =
47dB. Absorption in the receiving room estimated is 32 m2.
SPL-SPL’ = 47-10 log50 – 10 log 32 = 45 dB
Receiving room level = 88-45 = 43 dB. Similar calculation for other
band levels for estimation for predicting overall Noise reduction.
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 56
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 57
Examples: STC of items
• #150 mm solid concrete with 12 thk plaster
• on both sides: STC52 to STC53
• #115 thk high density brick wall plastered: STC44
• #10 mm plywood: STC21
• #12 thk gypsum board: STC27
• #2 layers of 12 thk gypsum board firmly joined: STC30
• #0.8 mm thk Lead sheet (banned item): STC31
• #50x100 studs, 15 thk gypsum board on either side
staggered screw-fitted: STC32
• #Lightweight concrete block 200 thk: STC45
• #Above concrete block with 15 thk gypsum board
• On resilient channels: STC51
• #100 mm RCC slab: STC42
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 58
REALITY
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 60
In laboratory test, the only path
between rooms is through the
wall or floor being tested, but
not true in buildings
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 61
STC
• Modern Sound Transmission Class rates
the Transmission Loss curve at speech
frequencies from 125 Hz to 4000 Hz.
• Uses a standard contour as reference.
• Drawback: Not good for frequencies below
125 Hz, where many mechanical
equipment noise exist.
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 62
STC graph
• T
r STC Class value
a
n
s
m
i
s
s
i
o
n
L
o
s
s
,
d
B
• 125 Hz 400 1250 4000 Hz
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 63
COMPOSITE TL
• TL1 = 10 log (1/t1) TL2 = 10 log (1/t2)
• Calculate t1 and t2.
• Areas S1 and S2.
W
• Total value of area A= Summation of S
• Sum of Sxt i.e. B = S1t1 + S2t2
• Composite TL = 10 log (A/B)
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 64
TRANSONDENT FACINGS
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 67
MASS LAW
• For Homogeneous building materials (e.g
wood, glass, concrete…) the transmission
loss (TL) increase by ~5dB for each
doubling of surface weight (wt./area).
STC
5 dB
m 2m
Surface weight wt/area
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 68
Mass Law……….
• 3 thk float glass = STC26
• 6 thk float glass= STC30
• 50 thk solid core wooden door with
gaskets and drop seal = STC32
• 50 thk hollow core, no gasketing=STC17
• It is the initial doubling that provides most
practical improvement.
• High STC needs complex designs
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 69
Coincidence dip……….
• Sound isolation efficiency depends on
stiffness as well as mass. Less stiff layer
has much better TL performance,
especially at MF and HF range.
TL Ribbed material >15 dB dip
Frequency
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 70
Good transmission loss due to.
• Heaviness of material (mass based TL)
• Limpness (flexibility, say Lead !!!)
• Airtight (trap based)
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 71
Reflection Patterns
• Flat reflector
• Concave reflector
• Convex reflector
SPREAD
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 72
Useful ceiling areas
Average ceiling ht = (6.2 x RT) in Meters
Useful reflections are those coming from the
same direction as the source and delayed
by less than 30 ms.
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 73
CLASS ROOMS
• Raked up
• Ceiling slope
• Diffusive walls
• Scattering/absorbing backwall
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 74
Volumes etc……..
• D:H (balcony overhang) recommendation
• Concerts 1:1
• Drama, Opera: 2:1
• Volumes: 7.5 – 12.5 per seat for speech…
• 20 to 30 per seat for concert halls (treat
hall & stage as one unit)
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 75
SPL Meter
Mic Attenuator
Block Schematic
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 76
PERCEIVED NOISE LEVEL, PNL
• of a particular noise is the SPL of band
900-1100 that sounds as noisy as the
noise under comparison.
• Noisiness: in noy; Graph available on
SPL vs frequency at various noys.
Compute ΣN and Nmax
• International table available for conversion
from noys to PNL.
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 77
• Especially important when considering
noise survey around airports
Average peak noise level
= 10 log (1/N)Σ10L/10
Here L is in perceived units of PNdB
Noise & Number Index (NNI) = Avg.PNLevel + 15 logN-80
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 78
Risk criteria contd….
When exposed to intense noise, recovery
becomes slow; next day’s exposure is on
top of the residual damage. Leads to
“persistent” threshold shift and leads to
“PERMANENT threshold shift”.
Ear muff solution: Maximum attenuation in
HF region.
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 79
SPEECH INTERFERENCE
CRITERIA
Necessity for speech communication will set
a severe limit on max. levels of ambient
noise.
Arithmetic mean of SPLs at 600-1200,
1200-2400, 2400-4800 known as Speech
Interferebce Level SIL. Distance between
speaker and listener is also important.
Examples:
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 80
SIL examples
Max. sound levels(dB) of ambience to ensure good
speech intelligibility
Distance Normal voice Raised voice Loud voice Shout
0.1 73 79 85 91
1.0 54 60 66 72
3.0 45 51 57 63
8.0 35 41 47 53
16.0 29 35 41 47
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 81
Vehicles noise
Increase in noise is almost 1.5 dB per year
mainly due to increase in number of
vehicles
Limit to noise reduction in individual vehicles
and hence alternate methods to be used
Time based measurements due to large
fluctuations. AT 1 M from facade of bldg.
Traffic noise index TNI = (4xL10) – (3xL90) - 30
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 82
Noise from HVAC systems
Main source of noise: motion of fan blades, turbulence,
velocity of air, air cutting exit grill elements.
Additional paths: through walls of duct (duct breakout),
airborne noise from fan, fan casing and motor
Regenerated noise increases rapidly with flow velocity,
bends, change of duct cross-section, obstacles
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 83
HVAC noise…..
Oct band
levels
Axial flow fans
35 dB
Centrifugal fans
63 1K 8K
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 84
SWL
Sound Power levels of ventilating fans:
PWL or SWL = 10 log W / W0; Wo = 10-12 watts
= 10 log W + 120
Intensity I = W/4πr2 and so SIL=SPL= 10 Log I / I0
10 log W / (4πr2/10-12) = 10 log W +120-10 log 4πr2
= SWL – 20 log r – 11
If source is near a reflecting surface
SPL = SWL – 20 log r – 8
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 85
HVAC….
Main steps in control of noise from ventilation
system: Correct choice of fan; Correct
installation of fan; Use of extra noise
attenuation; proper coupling to duct.
flexible Duct
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 86
Noise control of plant rooms
Duct running through noise-sensitive areas
Duct insulation (internal & external)
Attenuation/m R1 = (P/S) α1.4. P= perimeter
and S = cross-section area
Break out
Break-in
Noise
source
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 87
Grille attenuation
Reduction of sound at the opening is
dependent on the grill area and room
absorption
R2 = 10 log A / S A= absorption
S = grill area
Since A varies with frequency, a number of
calculations are required.
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 88
HVAC………….
Attenuation due to bends:
Depends on f, duct size, lining
Attenuation at right angled bend for lined square ducts
Octave band 0.1 m2 area 1 m2 area
----------------- ---------------- -------------
125 1 3
500 3 8
1K 6 16
4K 17 18
8K 18 18
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 89
Silencers
Absorptive
Acoustic energy is converted into
Heat by absorbing process. Much efficient at MF and HF.
Reactive
By providing mismatch of impedance and destructive
interference. Absorption depends on dimensions of pipes
and chambers of silencer. Quite efficient at low
frequencies. Multiple chambers can enhance absorption
Many silencers use both mechanisms to get good effect.
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 90
• Problem on HVAC noise:
blower
Duct
SWL r SPL
BASE
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 92
Noise Control Program
Plan & Predict Measure levels
Apply criteria Assess target noise
Is there a noise problem? NO exit
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 93
Floor / ceiling / roof isolation
Ceiling isolation
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 94
Quantitative Measurement Techniques
Acoustics: (i) Absorption by surfaces etc.; (ii) Isolation by various media
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 95
B L A CK CURTAIN
L IG HT B AR
CURTA I N FO R LIGHT BAR
L IG HT B AR
L IG HT B AR
S TA GE FOREG RO UND
CURTA I N LINE
STAGE
HALL
L IG HT B AR
BLACK CURTAIN
WHITE CURTAIN FOR PROJECTION
ROD FOR BANNERS/ SCENES
LIGHT BAR
CURTAIN /APRON FOR LIGHT BAR
LIGHT BAR
CURTAIN /APRON FOR LIGHT BAR
LIGHT BAR
CURTAIN /APRON FOR
WOODEN CLADDING
LIGHT BAR
(BIRCH WOOD OR
LIGHT BAR ALTERNATIVE)
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 96
COMPOSITE TL
• TL1 = 10 log (1/t1) TL2 = 10 log (1/t2)
• Calculate t1 and t2.
• Areas S1 and S2.
W
• Total value of area A= Summation of S
• Sum of Sxt i.e. B = S1t1 + S2t2
• Composite TL = 10 log (A/B)
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 97
Ceiling line……..
Rear wall
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 98
Cinemas:
Difference in basic philosophy. How the sound must be
heard by the audience is already decided.
Audio spectrum is truncated to roll off at 10 KHz onwards.
Low R.T. of the order of 1 sec. Good quality NC value.
Loud sound levels: use of multiple loudspeakers.
High level of contrast to provide bright viewing.
Treated surfaces to be non-light-reflective.
Sidewalls in total remains highly absorbing. Effect speakers
Rear wall must be highly absorbing.
Raked up seating to avoid grazing absorption (3 dB/row)
9/27/2019 S. RAJAGOPALAN 99
SOUND REINFORCEMENT SYSTEM
• Microphones…..Mixing…..Processing…
• ...Amplification….Delivery
Level
Time
Isolation pad
Concrete structural slab