Workshop on

Certification in Monitoring & evaluation For

GPP, Government of Baluchistan
Held on December 17 & 22, 2018
Feedback
Dr. Adnan Haider
Feedback
 Strongly Agree Agree Uncertain Disagree Strongly Disagree

Used the time available effectively 5 0 2 0

The Instructor

Encouraged us to actively participate during the course 4 3 0

Discussed individual questions/ problems to our satisfactions 4 3 0

Had adequate knowledge about the topics discussed 5 2 0

The Presentation

The material presented was readable 3 3 1 0

The examples used to illustrate the topic were relevant and interesting 4 2 1 0

The concepts and techniques were explained clearly 2 5 0

Overall it was interesting and enjoyable 3 4 0

Was structured in a logical way 2 5 0

Session

Was easy to follow 3 3 1 0

Contained sufficient amount of information 5 2 0

Enhanced my knowledge and skills 4 2 1 0

 Average Score (on the scale of 5): 4.5
Average Score

Used the time available effectively 4.43

The Instructor

Encouraged us to actively participate during the course 4.57

Discussed individual questions/ problems to our satisfactions 4.57

Had adequate knowledge about the topics discussed 4.71

The Presentation

The material presented was readable 4.29

The examples used to illustrate the topic were relevant and interesting 4.43

The concepts and techniques were explained clearly 4.29

Overall it was interesting and enjoyable 4.43

Was structured in a logical way 4.29

Session

Was easy to follow 4.29

Contained sufficient amount of information 4.71

Enhanced my knowledge and skills 4.43

 Additional Comments – About Dr. Adnan Haider
• knowledge able , Enjoyable to catch to grab an idea easily. (Ambreen Gul )
• DR Adnan haider is a great intellectual encourage each individual to participate wish to attend some other session from him. (Imran Wahid )
• Compare business information interesting knowledge able tanning course. (Dr. Fauzia Hashmi )
• All the lectures delivered by Adnan haider during 6 days session was knowledge able and interesting and enjoyable the delivery of lectures was very good we gained more knowledge and information
during the about six days certification particularly form the lectures of DR Adnan hider. (Sabzal Khan )
• Overall knowledge able and very interesting.(Mehmood Khan )
• He was sufficient knowledge about the topic and good deliverable techniques. (Ghulam Nabi Gola )
• He is best as and as an experienced person with a lot of information and knowledge's. (Summiaya Hamza)
• Enhanced over session and DR Adnan concepts were clear and he explained every things clearly. (Waqar ul Malik )
• satisfactory helpful. (Nazneen Aslam )
• He is a good speaker and having sufficient information in his field he tried is best make it them understandable. (Rafiq Ahmed)
• Satisfactory. (Abdul Manan )
• Excellent delivery very competent we learnt a lot from this tanning and to use new ideas methodology concept and techniques. (Waqar Uz Zaman Kayani )
• DR Adnan Haider Gave us very effective knowledge related to M & E and its dimensions I am satisfied and strongly recommend to have such trains for Baluchistan. (Rukhsana Baloch )
• DR Adnan Haider have experience and many skills M & E and new techniques & frame work we had a great time with DR Adnan Hider may Allah give him more success in his life. (Aamir Aziz)
• Transfer of advance knowledge to practices , needed to guide audience with examples was missing. (Abdul Ali )
• Sir DR Adnan Haider It among the best professors of Pakistan and its my privilege to be taught and trained by such a great personal of IBA Thanks. (Faisal Abdullah )
• Mr. Adnan have adequate teaching & presenting skills he clearly states the concepts and well explained . He is much civilized and I really enjoyed and teach so many use full knowledge & skills in his session.
(Uzma Gilani )
• The course was very informative and interesting . I have learn a lot during six days about monitoring and evaluation the resources person deliver in participatory method but the durations of training was
only six days it should be more than 15 days because some topics need more classification. (Salma Akhtar )
• Good delivery of the subject great knowledge enthusiastic for teach quoted good examples and the most important very polite and selected good words. (Safia Jehangir )
• I would like to attend his more session. (Zahoor Ahmed )
• Informative well talented and well explained , participating. (Dr Kamila Baluch )
• Dr. Adnan Hyder is very excellent person economist he has complete informative in details give us regarding monitoring evaluation in the very short time we have skilled , Insha'Allah after tanning we have
go to parents copy as skilled and performance could be delivered to Department. (Muhammad Ali )
Mr. Mohsin Chandna
Feedback
 Strongly Agree Agree Uncertain Disagree Strongly Disagree

Used the time available effectively 4 3 0

The Instructor

Encouraged us to actively participate during the course 3 4 0

Discussed individual questions/ problems to our satisfactions 1 6 0

Had adequate knowledge about the topics discussed 2 5 0

The Presentation

The material presented was readable 1 5 0

The examples used to illustrate the topic were relevant and interesting 1 6 0

The concepts and techniques were explained clearly 2 5 0

Overall it was interesting and enjoyable 3 4 0

Was structured in a logical way 5 2 0

Session

Was easy to follow 2 5 0

Contained sufficient amount of information 3 4 0

Enhanced my knowledge and skills 2 5 0

 Average Score (on the scale of 5): 4.3
Average Score

Used the time available effectively 4.57

The Instructor

Encouraged us to actively participate during the course 4.43

Discussed individual questions/ problems to our satisfactions 4.14

Had adequate knowledge about the topics discussed 4.29

The Presentation

The material presented was readable 4.17

The examples used to illustrate the topic were relevant and interesting 4.14

The concepts and techniques were explained clearly 4.29

Overall it was interesting and enjoyable 4.43

Was structured in a logical way 4.71

Session

Was easy to follow 4.29

Contained sufficient amount of information 4.43

Enhanced my knowledge and skills 4.29

 Additional Comments – About Mr. Mohsin Chandna
• Overall classes and session were well prepared and delivered in u. professional way, but were covered in a fast and furious way at least some of us including
me were facing difficulty as were new topics. (Dawood Khan )
• He was well experiential facilitator with west knowledge. (Ghulam Nabi Gola)
• Overall it was good. (Rukhsana Baloch )
• Average & satisfactory Knowledgeable and very informative overall the lecture was good and very helpful for me. (Sabzal Khan )
• Very experienced person recommended for future lectures. (Zahoor Ahmed )
• All me information's knowledge were delivered in a very well manner . As I mention my answer in trainer's evaluation Sheet. (Samina Ehsan )
• It was an honors to be blessed with such an opportunity as lectured and taught by sir Mohsin Chandna. (Faisal Abdullah )
• Clarified many conceptual terminologies. Connected themes with surroundings, Impressive. (Ambreen Gull )
• Mohsin Chandna sb such a intelligent & well informed person. (Nazish Naseer )
• Overall satisfactory and interesting. (Mehmood Khan )
• No comment. (Nazneen Aslam )
• Time was short therefore the facilitators can not complete their session Facilitator had knowledge the topic. (Aamir Aziz )
• There was a time limitation and the topic were not covered on time. (Roomana Murad Khoso )
• Sir plz prepared relative examples if the topic would relates the provincial ADP then it will be beneficial. (Engr. Rafiq Muhammad )
• Mr. Mohsin Chandna is a great Intellectual and wish to learn from him again. (Imran Wahid )
• Knowledgeable interesting information , presentation. (Dr. Fouzia Hashim )
• Well it was quit informative session with respected sir. (Sommaiaya Hamza )
• The officer has provided us information very useful and we have understand regarding functional of monitoring and evaluation and suggested that to give us
more time period so that we gave trained and skilled. (M Ali )
• Less interactive as was expected and topic relevancy with m & E lacking or nominally connected.(Abdul Ali )
• Excellent workshop learned a great deal and inspired to learn more. (Sajida )
• Moderate level of information was provided present was clean to the point and had knowledge regarding the topic.(Sabina Baluch )
• Excellent session but if the participants are also allowed planned ground to visit M & E system of Government of Sindh and a private sector entity. (Waqar uz
Zaman Kayani )
• Yes he tried his best to explain the course however the case has economic background I don't understand the term logy. (Rafique Ahmed )
Mr. Shoaib Mir Memon
Feedback
 Strongly Agree Agree Uncertain Disagree Strongly Disagree

Used the time available effectively 5 2 0

The Instructor

Encouraged us to actively participate during the course 6 1 0

Discussed individual questions/ problems to our satisfactions 3 4 0

Had adequate knowledge about the topics discussed 5 2 0

The Presentation

The material presented was readable 3 4 0

The examples used to illustrate the topic were relevant and interesting 3 3 1 0

The concepts and techniques were explained clearly 3 4 0

Overall it was interesting and enjoyable 2 5 0

Was structured in a logical way 3 3 1 0

Session

Was easy to follow 2 5 0

Contained sufficient amount of information 5 2 0

Enhanced my knowledge and skills 4 2 1 0

 Average Score (on the scale of 5): 4.5
Average Score

Used the time available effectively 4.71

The Instructor

Encouraged us to actively participate during the course 4.86

Discussed individual questions/ problems to our satisfactions 4.43

Had adequate knowledge about the topics discussed 4.71

The Presentation

The material presented was readable 4.43

The examples used to illustrate the topic were relevant and interesting 4.29

The concepts and techniques were explained clearly 4.43

Overall it was interesting and enjoyable 4.29

Was structured in a logical way 4.29

Session

Was easy to follow 4.29

Contained sufficient amount of information 4.71

Enhanced my knowledge and skills 4.43

 Additional Comments – About Mr. Shoaib Mir Memon
• Shoaib Mir is one of finest instructors I have ever listened to. Wish to listen and learn from him again. (Imran Wahid)
• He is good trainer and well-educated trainer. (Ghulam Nabi Gul)
• Knowledge full, informative, interesting, enjoyable session. Clear justification and involvement of the participants. (Dr. Fauzia Hashmi)
• That was excellent session conducted / presented by Shoaib Mir Memon, we learnt a lot as he is excellent speaker & presenter with sufficient
knowledge. (Waqaruz Zaman Kayani)
• Shoaib Mir Sb, being senior officer, prepared for discussion and loaded with much knowledge gave a very interesting lecture. He surely knows the
problems of Baluchistan. I wish he could further come and join this group during further training sessions.(Zahoor Ahmed)
• He is really a knowledgeable and competent person. (Summiaya Hmaza Nousherwani)
• Overall, I found the course useful and valuable. Thank you. (Ambreen Gul)
• No one.(Samina Ellahi)
• Sir, Please kindly give him another task related to his field of study in this session please arrange a mandate of development in other provinces to
him by presenting with the practical way. (Faqir Muhammad)
• Very good session, gave background information in context explanation of various current issues were highlighted in Planning and Development.
(Dr. Rabia Baluch)
• The lecture was very good and easy to learn. New knowledgeable topic was discussed. I learnt very much useful an helps from the topics. It was
also useful for performing official job. (Sabzal Khan)
• Mr. Shoaib Mir served as Chief Secretary Baluchistan briefly. He is a senior officer of PAS/ group and a decent officer. (Rafiq Ahmed)
• Mr. Shoaib Mir Memon is a great instructor time given to complete presentation/ session was more but was completed early. He should have
been left to speak more so that we have achieved/ got more from his session but members were talking irrelevant that wasted precious time.
(Eng. Dawood Khan Mandokhail)
• Mr. Shoaib Mir Baluchistan For a brief stint Mr. Shoaib Mir served as Chief Secretary Baluchistan. Before as CS he also served as PA and Principal
Secretary to CM, Add: Secretary. He is a decent officer.
• Overall it was excellent and keen knowledge and grip on all topics and he clearly explained each and every points which I like the most in addition
he involved participants in discussion which is the good teaching for better learning.(Rukhsana Baluch )
Ms. Shadia Jaffer
Feedback
 Strongly Agree Agree Uncertain Disagree Strongly Disagree

Used the time available effectively 3 4 0

The Instructor

Encouraged us to actively participate during the course 3 2 2 0

Discussed individual questions/ problems to our satisfactions 2 3 2 0

Had adequate knowledge about the topics discussed 1 5 1 0

The Presentation

The material presented was readable 1 6 0

The examples used to illustrate the topic were relevant and interesting 1 5 1 0

The concepts and techniques were explained clearly 2 5 0

Overall it was interesting and enjoyable 2 4 1 0

Was structured in a logical way 2 5 0

Session

Was easy to follow 2 4 1 0

Contained sufficient amount of information 2 4 1 0

Enhanced my knowledge and skills 1 6 0

 Average Score (on the scale of 5): 4.2
Average Score

Used the time available effectively 4.43

The Instructor

Encouraged us to actively participate during the course 4.14

Discussed individual questions/ problems to our satisfactions 4.00

Had adequate knowledge about the topics discussed 4.00

The Presentation

The material presented was readable 4.14

The examples used to illustrate the topic were relevant and interesting 4.00

The concepts and techniques were explained clearly 4.29

Overall it was interesting and enjoyable 4.14

Was structured in a logical way 4.29

Session

Was easy to follow 4.14

Contained sufficient amount of information 4.14

Enhanced my knowledge and skills 4.14

 Additional Comments – About Ms. Shadia Jaffer
• Very good & satisfactory.(Abdul Manan)
• Overall normal but not too much informative regarding the M & E in the other field & not supportive to government sectors as well. (Mehmood Khan )
• It was totally very informative and interesting session we learned so much things from this session.(Samina Ehsan )
• Overall it was good and the knowledge shared could help us to develop our own system of monitoring and evaluation.(Rukhsana Baloch )
• A very excellent session and more relevant to M & E certification. (Waqar uz Zaman Kiyani )
• Impressive knowledge with additional information. (Summiaya Hamza )
• Session was good, interesting and interactive. It was informative which was experienced based. (Salma Akhtar )
• Interesting session very interactive participating and more lands on experience in this session was well knowledgeable and provide sufficient
information. (Dr Sabir Baluch )
• We have satisfy and give us details information regarding M & E especially education sector. (Muhammad Ali )
• Was an enjoyable session love to attend another session from her. (Imran Wahid )
• Overall knowledgeable interesting. (Ambreen Gul )
• Overall lecture was very informative and related to training topic monitoring & evaluation. I like it very much. (Nazneen Aslam )
• I am very honored to be taught and trained by Ms. Shadia Jaffer. (Faisal Abdullah)
• Satisfactory. (Nazish Naseer )
• Session was interactive and have level of knowledge although it didn’t have its implication in perspective of Baluchistan. I have should be RTSM system
application with compare with replicate or even Sindh M & E so batter to copy this have some intervention sample in Baluchistan. (Uzma Gilani )
• The lecture was very good interested enjoyable and very informative we learned many information about M & E Sindh education . The lecture delivered
by Ms. Shadia Jaffer was very excellent. (Sabzal Khan )
• She was well knowledge about the subject and great skill of deliverance of lecture. (Ghulam Nabi Gola)
• Much interactive but not providing equal opportunity each one. (Abdul Ali )
• Very interesting the resource person delivered the functioning of M & E directive of education department Sindh very informative. (Zahor Ahmed )
• Interesting & informative session. (Dr Fauzai Hashmi )
• Excellent working learnt a great deal and inspired to learn more. (Sajida )
Overall Evaluation
Feedback
 Strongly Agree Agree Uncertain Disagree Strongly Disagree

The level of material covered was satisfactory 5 5 5 1 0

The length of the training was satisfactory 3 7 3 1 2

General Comments

I felt comfortable during the course 10 5 0

I think the venue was suitable 9 5 2 0

I will be able to use the course materials as a reference 8 8 0

I believe the skills I have learned will help me improve my performance on the job 9 6 1 0

I feel I have gained new skills and knowledge 10 5 1 0

All our needs were taken care of satisfactorily 5 10 1 0

The Facilities

Materials were clearly readable 5 11 0

Technical support was readily available 6 9 0

Quality of refreshments / lunches / dinners served was satisfactory 6 7 2 0 1

Were conducive to learning 8 7 1 0

 Average Score (on the scale of 5): 4.3
Average Score

The level of material covered was satisfactory 3.88

The length of the training was satisfactory 3.50

General Comments

I felt comfortable during the course 4.67

I think the venue was suitable 4.44

I will be able to use the course materials as a reference 4.50

I believe the skills I have learned will help me improve my performance on the job 4.50

I feel I have gained new skills and knowledge 4.56

All our needs were taken care of satisfactorily 4.25

The Facilities

Materials were clearly readable 4.31

Technical support was readily available 4.40

Quality of refreshments / lunches / dinners served was satisfactory 4.06

Were conducive to learning 4.44

I wish we would have spent more time
discussing:
• Field Visit , data collection Moral norms is social policy. (Ambreen Gul )

• I am a civil engineer and wished to discussed PC 1, PC2, PC 3 more. (Imran Wahid )

• Recreating health department problems. (Dr Fauzia Hashmi )

• Duration should be enhanced. (Sabzal Khan )

• The monitoring and evaluation the main concern regarding as well as the steps forward. (Mehmood Khan )

• Yes. (Amanullah Khan )

• Yes we spent more time on discussion the topics. (Ghulam Nabi Gola )

• I could force more an efficiency were be done. (Summiaya Hamza)

• Monitoring & evaluation specially in schools. Management & supervision in public schools. (Nazneen Aslam )

• As these topics are of due important to the failures in policy and schemes therefore the time for the tanning should be converted into proper policy in particular along with the stakeholder of Got. (Roomana Murad Khan )

• Yes for many topic the shortage of time is the reason couldn’t discuss the things. (Samina )

• Current M & E system & tools which are available. By keeping the things available. M & E tools which are applicable in over province. (Engr Faqir Muhammad )

• Compare the complete pictures of M & E in Baluchistan and then compare it with rest of provinces. (M Irfan )

• A suitable time was consumed on discussed the topics as well as relevant areas in group through case studies and variable discussion. (Abdul Razzaq)

• Yes. (Rafiq Ahmed)

• Yes especially in monitoring models and cost benefit analysis. (Abdul Manan )

• Such tanning should have to planned for 15 days will live field visit instead of bookish material is to se presented as various research of studies can easily thought interesting . (Waqar Uz Zaman Kayani )

• M & E and frame work. (Aamir Aziz)

• Practically filling the monitor formed, evaluation is required more time and session to understand. (Abdul Ali )

• consistent and lengthily topics creates the boring environment that handles the learning process as I suggest that there should be diversely in topics. (Faisal Abdullah ).

• Framework and case studies. PSDP fund allocations. (Uzma Gilani )

• Evaluation is most important component of monitoring there should be more sessions of evaluation .(Salma Akhtar )

• Cost benefit technique different b/w the M & E models . (Safia Jehangir )

• In developing framework and identifying indicators. (Zahoor Ahmed )

Next time, we should include additional topics such as:
• We can include more incentives in monitoring and evaluation global examples, material more provincial in nature. (Ambreen Gul )

• Field techniques for civil engineers. (Imran Wahid )

• Topic were enough to understand but it seems for short duration. (Dr Fauzia Hashmi )

• Field visit & practical work on field visit of at least two or three schemes visit. (Sabzal Khan )

• Not as such overall satisfactory. (Mehmood Khan )

• Making of PC1, PC2, PC 3. (Nazish Naseer )

• Examples on infrastructure project. (Amanullah Khan )

• Practical visits of some projects programed. (Ghulam Nabi Gola ).

• Practical survey of the dashboard project while if is operational and the operating system. (Summiaya Hamza)

• Project style ( PC 1 , to PC- 5 ). (Waqar ul Malik )

• Need of consoling secondary level for generals. (Nazneen Aslam )

• More visit to be included along with the partial success examples. (Roomana Murad Khan )

• Topic are adequate but time was to much short.(Samina )

• You should so. (You should so )

• As desired but visit of different offices department concerned should be exercised. (M Irfan)

• I will recommend that there must be more practical tanning and field visit instead of whole tanning based on theory further the candidate should be new fresh appointee of not more then 5 year experience selecting for training so that he may provide this input for more then 20
years at least to Govt.(Abdul Razzaq)

• It is recommended that next time the IBA administration make efforts to make the such courses more interested. (Rafiq Ahmed)

• Project management, economic evaluation of the project feasibility. (Abdul Manan )

• Live field visit. (Waqar Uz Zaman Kayani )

• M & E finance work and automation & PSOP and dashboard of projects cycle of PC 1 of PC 5 department. (Aamir Aziz)

• Uses of M & E Equipment need to be considered. (Abdul Ali )

• Detailed monitoring based on ground realities not only theoretical aspect as monitoring include different department belonging different field officers so the topic should not be specific to single field. (Faisal Abdullah )

• Evaluation techniques, evaluation process in different department any software related to evaluation. (Uzma Gilani )

• Next time a training on preparing budget and utilization of budget should also be conducted.(Salma Akhtar )

• Models with some examples. (Safia Jehangir )

• Next time we hope site visit be done. (Muhammad Ali )

If you rated your experience as anything less than
excellent, please tell us what we could do to improve
our efforts:
• Make information short and precise, Try to cover the topics with in prescribed time limit to pose full efficiency in performance. (Ambreen Gul )

• Should have decreased the timing and the overall days should have been more. (Imran Wahid )

• Overall satisfaction. (Dr Fauzia Hashmi )

• Excellent. (Sabzal Khan )

• Almost knowledgeable activities were so much satisfaction but the visit should also be conducted for the practical experiences. (Mehmood Khan )

• Satisfactory efforts. (Nazish Naseer )

• Time of course may be reduced / rationalized. (Ghulam Nabi Gola )

• As it was my first experience which constitute on informative attempt for me. (Summiaya Hamza)

• I think length of days should be enhanced and timing must be short as it is way tiring to be sealed full time shows working. (Nazneen Aslam )

• It was overall very good. (Samina )

• It was excellent indeed introduction of participants was not done in the beginning similarity in some sessions questions and answer were not given proper time. (M Irfan )

• Overall the teaching as well as the supportive staff was very cooperative. (Abdul Razzaq)

• The IBA may arrange such courses for the officers of less development area learn some thing.(Rafiq Ahmed)

• I wish to learn any thing of every things in short but effectively. (Abdul Manan )

• Excellent. (Waqar Uz Zaman Kayani )

• Kindly something or make smoke face in IBA. (Aamir Aziz)

• Already elucidated in 4 and 5. (Faisal Abdullah )

• Sitting arrangement long sitting make. Do random activities like learning one day training session and one passive day field visit and things duration should be 10 - 12 days. (Uzma Gilani )

• There should be field visits during the tanning. (Salma Akhtar )

• Some existing programs and M / S should be used as an examples and also is there any space of improvement of the program. (Safia Jehangir )

• Please consider in duration of lectured. (Zahoor Ahmed )

• We have learn regarding M & E functions as indicators input activities output outcomes then come input. (Muhammad Ali )
Your testimonials for this course; what did you like
about this course and your experience with IBA CEE?
• Coverall it was useful and knowledgeable course no doubt very valuable for M & E unit with on my department. (Ambreen Gul )

• I liked the way Dr Adnan Haider engaged everyone . I liked the framework lectures. (Imran Wahid )

• Nice experience. (Dr Fauzia Hashmi )

• Yes. (Sabzal Khan )

• Satisfactory. (Mehmood Khan )

• Course was relevant and gained lots of knowledge of skills. (Ghulam Nabi Gola )

• This course was quite supportive for us in order to over as principles. (Summiaya Hamzav)

• I think the presented lectures the most the new techniques and methodologies will help me to improve my performance regarding my field. (Nazneen Aslam )

• IBA is already a mark of excellent there fore it always believe it best however that management should also work establishing a campus at Quetta. (Roomana Murad Khan )

• Yes I learned so many things. (Samina )

• Neat environment, professors resources persons like Shoaib Meer Sir and Mohsin Chandna sir a complete department economist like sir Adnan Haider. (M Irfan )

• IBA is a prestigious institution in the field of business and management studies I recommend to my govt to provide management tanning in the field of management in collaborating of IBA. (Abdul Razzaq)

• Actively good. (Rafiq Ahmed)

• The entire course was excellent all the topics areas of the program were relevant to our official business and it was great time we spend in IBA . (Abdul Manan )

• A very good institute if the management of IBA may consider establishment of IBA sub campus at Quetta. (Waqar Uz Zaman Kayani)

• I have a good experience with IBA. (Aamir Aziz)

• Satisfactory. (Abdul Ali )

• Knowledge is ocean and I am standing at the beach playing with skills. (Faisal Abdullah )

• Good conducive learning environment very skillful and expert resource person. (Uzma Gilani )

• It was an excellent tanning the resources person were very expects and knowledgeable. (Salma Akhtar )

• This course aid to my knowledge very comfortable working with CEE the theoretical part was informative but want to see the implementation part. (Safia Jehangir )

• The lectures thought real practitioners.(Zahoor Ahmed )

• The all lectures are very excellent. (Muhammad Ali )

Thank You