Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
MANAGEMENT
BY:
MARY JUNE ESPAÑOLA
ANDREA JONA DEVARAS
KYLE NICOLE DEMINGOY
ROBIE FAILAGO
CHAPTER 4: Product Strategy
PRODUCT
“For the poor majority, the downscale consumers, the
issue is not product quality. It is simply product. It is not
quality of life that matters for them. What matters is
simply life. Survival.”
a low-priced brand may satisfy a physiological need of just keeping hair clean.
Procter and Gamble’s Ivory being mild may satisfy the safety need of those
who cannot use other kinds of shampoo because they have sensitive hair or
skin.
Head and Shoulders anti-dandruff shampoo may satisfy a social need of
avoiding embarrassing situations in a group setting.
Kerastase special care shampoo may satisfy an ego need of being able to use a
branded product.
Alterna Terna, at US$60 for an 8.5 oz bottle, is one of the most expensive
shampoos that promises beautiful soft hair inspired from enzyme therapy may
satisfy self-actualization where one can achieve perfect hair.
The key, therefore, is to understand that consumers have different
levels of needs, and each segment (needs) of the market may be an
opportunity for the firm to launch new products and dominate
3 TYPES OF PRODUCTS
Basically, there are three types of products, which can be distinguished via consumption and tangibility. These are:
1. Durables – which have a long interval between repeat purchases because of the long-lasting nature of the product.
Some examples are:
• Floor polishers like Wilson and GE.
• Cars like Mitsubishi and Nissan.
• TV sets like Panasonic and Samsung.
2. Non-durables – which have stronger repeat purchases because products are consumable . Examples are:
• Detergents like Surf and Pride
• Processed meats like Pampanga’s Best and CDO
• Snacks like Boy Bawang and Voice Biscuits
3. Services – which are essentially intangible because there are no physical products involved. Examples are as follows:
• Auto service centers such as Ambassador Inmogo or Zafra Motors
• Beauty parlors like David’s Salon or Reyes Haircutters
• Training services provided by Mansmith and Fielders, Inc. or the Corporate Achievers Institute (Coach)
Since consumer satisfaction is evaluated in terms of benefits expected minus
costs incurred (Murphy and Enis, 1986), these costs should be conceptualized
on two independent dimensions wherein products can further be distinguished.
1. Effort – which is the amount of money, time, and energy the buyer is willing to spend to
purchase a given product. It is an objective measurement of the value the consumer places on
the product. Since there is an expectation of future value, there is also risk that the product will
not deliver the benefits sought.
2. Risk – this is the buyer's subjective feeling about the consequences of making a purchasing
mistake.
By combining products using effort and risk, we end up with four categories:
1. Convenience products
2. Preference products
3. Shopping products
4. Specialty products
Exhibit 4-2: Four categories of product according to customer’s effort and risk `
Exhibit 4-5: Ten learning lessons about “Quality and Customer Satisfaction”
1. Before a disappointing experience, consumers take a broad general concept of quality. It is stated
almost like the statistician’s “null hypothesis” – “In a quality product, nothing must go wrong.
2. It is when something goes wrong that consumers are able to go into the specific quality elements.
3. It is also when consumers are able to compare that they are able to say something about specific
quality elements.
4. With the consumer, there is such a thing as the right amount of quality. More is not necessarily
better. Neither is lesser. Just right is the right amount.
5. When consumers do go into the specific quality elements, they often need to be probed in order that
their concept of quality becomes truly specific.
6. To the consumer, there is such a thing as the right kind of quality. Each kind defines a need segment
that must be satisfied.
7. It is the product’s unexpected quality characteristic that impresses the consumer the most. The more
unexpected that quality characteristic is, the deeper the consumer’s favorable impression and
satisfaction.
8. There is a certain kind of customer satisfaction that they may be called lower order because it
results in, at most, a retrial. Once another product offers something a little better than what it provides,
the consumer is ready to switch immediately.
9. There is a second kind of customer satisfaction that is longer lasting. It is a satisfaction that brings
the consumer to a committed usage of the product. It results in consumer loyalty.
10. For the poor majority, the downscale consumers, the issue in targeting marketing perfection is not
product quality. It is simply product. It is not quality of life that matters to them. What matters is simply
life. Survival.
COST OF QUALITY AND NON-QUALITY
ISO
An important development in quality is the ISO family of standards, which was formulated by the
Geneva-based International Organization for Standardization (ISO). It is a series of quality
management and assurance standards which define the elements required to achieved a quality
system regardless of the product manufactured or the technology used. By adopting ISO standards,
a compay is able to establish its reliability as a supplier with a quality system that conforms to
international standards. This becomes more relevant with the global trend to increasingly
deregulate foreign trade as can be seen in the formation of European Economic Community (EEC)
among European nations; North American Free Trade Area (NAFTA) among the United States,
Canada, and Mexico; and the Asian Free Trade (AFTA) among countries in the ASEAN region in
the early 1990s.
NEW PRODUCT OPPURTUNITY
What product should be launched in the marketplace? Let’s review the basic
framework for internally generated marketing growth opportunities.
Note that the product could come either as a totally new product in an existing
market (Product Development) or as an existing product in an existing market (Market
Penetration) or as product which may or may not need some modification to enter a new
market (Market Development).
Market development concentrates on new market segments. An example is RFM Corporation prioritizing the food
service (hotel, restaurants, and other institutions) market starting 1985 in addition to their existing consumer
market. Quite obviously, selling to industrial markets like the food service industry is different from selling to
consumers because of the differences in purchase decision criteria like quickness of service, assured availability,
and profitability, among others.
A list of “assumptions’ as to why new products are needed is given in the next section. This list will help
marketers in forecasting future sales and profit.
NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
Two sets of needs must be met in new product development. One is internal
which looks at the company’s objectives and resources, while the other is
external which looks at the customer’s needs and wants.
• PLDT launched the Tele-Tipid prepaid cards for their landlines not only to expand
their base of users to the broad C and D income classes by encouraging them to
avail of a telephone at a relatively low cost but also to shield the company from
potential collection problems in the future.
• Bounty Agro officially launched Chooks To Go oven baked chicken in 2008,
anticipating the reduction of import tariff of dresses chicken from 30% in 2007 to
only 5% in2010, which may attract lower cost countries like Thailand to ship their
dressed chicken to the Philippines. This innovative move turned out to be a
winning value-adding formula as they are to give consumers delicious rotisserie
chicken at lower prices but with superior profit for Bounty Agro because they are
the manufacturer/producer of chicken.
Exhibit 4-8: Factors to consider in new product development
Internal External
Just look at products that exist today that did not exist five years ago. Would you have
been able to guess back then that they would ever exist? What about new products that
would be launched five years from now?
Marketing strategy formulation must begin outside of the firm so that the business is
constantly focused on marketing opportunities. In order to do this, environmental analysis
and assumptions that can predict demand should be done as defined in exhibit 4-9.
Exhibit 4-9: Environmental analysis and assumptions for product development
1. Customer lifestyle
The trend toward smaller families , working women, reduction of the number of household
maids, social networking, late marriages, healthier routines and other lifestyle changes have very
impact on consumer buying behavior. Home delivery of food products for instance, has seen
unprecedented growth and is expected to outgrow the dine-in segment.
2. Macro and micro economics
Consumers are guided by the real income they have as well as their expected future income. A
good harvest by farmers will increase their disposable income which commensurately increases
their purchasing ability for products and services. It is also noteworthy that there is a trend
towards having dual income among employees in the middle lower class income bracket, which
popularized the office four-gives or “hulugan” payment system. This got accelerated with entry
of several network marketing companies in the mid-1990s.
3. Raw materials costs, availability and limitations
Non-biodegradable materials will suffer increasing environmentalist moves against
them. For instance, plastic bottles take 600 years to decompose on landfill while
Styrofoam takes 2,000 years. Another example is the oil crisis in the early 1970s, which
changed the design of automobiles making it more efficient in terms of gasoline
consumption.
4. Competition
A look at the newspaper and TV advertisements would immediately tell you the extent of
the rivalry between Globe and Smart in the telecom industry. They are always trying to
be better than the other.
Malls also keep upgrading their facilities to avoid what happened to Escolta which was
once the center of commerce during its old glory days. Cubao has its Gateway Mall
while Greenhills has upgraded and rebranded Virra Mall (now V-mall) and Promenade.
5. Technology
The internet has changed the way people buy. For example, books and electronic items can be
bought from Amazon.com and even music can now be ordered and downloaded online via iTunes.
Even how people read books and other publications has changed with the entry of Kindle and Ipad.
6. Social forces
The government program on the use condoms to fight against worldwide spread of AIDS, which
started in late 1992, drew strong protests from the Catholic Church. The church feels this may
permanently influence the sexual behavior (or misbehavior) of some people, although the church’s
stand against contraception did not affect the sales of condom as much.
7. Government
One of the first things President Fidel V. Ramos did in his first 100 days office in 1992 was to
deregulate foreign exchange. This attracted foreign money to flow in due to our higher interest
rates for money placement. This, however, lead to the appreciation of the peso which exporters
strongly complained about as this decreased their earnings.
NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS
A seven-step process (Taylor, 1984) for developing new products is shown in
exhibit 4-10. The process may be revised and adapted to the unique needs of each
company.
A product “champion” is needed for each product or group of products. A
product champion is a person who initiates or revives a new product concept,
who believes in it and sees to it that the new product development reaches a
successful and profitable commercialization stage within the least possible time.
Ideally, a product champion should not only be a good analyzer but should also
be good at getting things done. This will reduce the likelihood of either analyzing
a project too much or rushing into the market without careful evaluation.
Exhibit 4-10: New product development process
Process criteria
Idea Generation
Idea Screening
Business Analysis
Prototype Development
Market Test
Full Commercialization
Product Criteria
Product criteria define the kinds of products a firm will be selling, or won’t be
selling. This, in turn, defines the business in the future. As any strategy should
match a company’s relative strengths to customer’s needs and wants, developing
product criteria is no different. The marketer should identify their relevant strengths
to customer’s needs and wants, developing the product criteria. By “relevant”, we
are referring to the key factors for success or the limited number of functions,
activities, factors, or even bottlenecks that must be managed well to outperform
competition.
Product criteria can be divided into “Must” and “Wants”. The “Must” criteria are
mandatory or non-negotiable while the “Wants” criteria are desirable but negotiable.
It is dangerous to choose products without any product criteria.
Exhibit 4-11: Product criteria for a consumer durable direct
selling company
MUST:
1. Potential for market dominance
2. At least 50% gross margins
3. Around P10,000 to P30,000 in end user pricking
WANTS
4. Unique benefits
5. Good product quality
6. Minimal after sales service
7. A menu of potential product criteria is presented in exhibit 4-12.
Exhibit 4-12: Menu of Possible product criteria
1. Corporate image fit 1. Low break-even point
2. Product standardization 2. Payback period
3. Product line compatibility 3. Market share potential
4. Stage in product life cycle 4. Sales volume potential
5. Unique benefits 5. Sales trends for the last few years
6. Few substitutes 6. Repetitive needs / purchase
7. Affordable development cost 7. No sales seasonality
8. Fast development period 8. Distribution compatibility
9. Production capability and capacity 9. Existing management / marketing skills
10. Raw materials availability and affordability 10. No government restriction
11. Minimal after sales service requirements 11. No legal restrictions
12. Affordable capital requirements
13. New product in
Profitability criteria
% need not be limited to manufacturing companies. Retailers and direct selling
companies, for instance, can come up with new product criteria to guide them whether they should accept
the new products being offered to them by manufacturers and importers. Some suggestions are given in
exhibits 4-13and 4-14.
Exhibit 4-13: Possible product criteria for retail stores
1. Product Uniqueness
Untapped demand obviously brings in additional sales. The unique features may
convince consumers to upgrade their present standard. Extraderm offered retail stores
the opportunity to increase total sales revenues by way of its unique therapeutic features
versus regular astringent as well as better margins for the store.
2. Good Value
No “junk” items shall be carried that may affect store image. Pricing must be reasonable
vis-à-vis quality. SM has the reputation of carrying products that must affordable to the
middle class.
3. Advertising Support
Consumers will not purchase new products unless they are aware of their existence. No
products will be purchased unless the supplier can show relevant support levels for
creating awareness and merchandising. Multinational marketers like J&J, Colgate-
Palmolive and P&G’s business models involve offering superior products and promoting
the benefits by way of heavy advertising expenditures.
4. Profitability
Different product lines have different margins. Monde’s Lucky Me is considered a traffic
builder because supermarkets only make about 3-5% in profit, while its biscuits line is
considered a profit generator because supermarkets make about 8-10% from them.
5. Introductory Discounts or Allowances
New products may not move as fast as older products and deny the store faster turnover
and better return on shelf space. Zuellig Pharma offers an extended 90-day term their
drugstores for any new products launched in the market. SM expects an introductory
discount for a few months on all new products while major retailers now charge a listing
fee per product model.
6. Company Reputation
Some companies enjoy a reputation for marketing winners. The probability of buying
from reputable suppliers decreases the risk of having non-moving items. Multinational
companies Nestle, Del Monte, L’Oreal, Procter and Gamble, Unilever, Johnson and
Johnson and San Miguel Corporation are some of the companies looked up to by retailer
not only in marketing products but also in partnering with the stores in building their
businesses.
Exhibit 4-14: Possible product criteria for a direct selling company
1. Not widely distributed at the retail stores 4. Affordable pricing
A good reason to buy directly from a salesman is its non- Cash prices should be reasonably attractive for consumers to buy.
availability in retail stores. Nikken promotes its magnet-based The price must be comparable with what is available in the retail
products that are hardly available in the stores. stores, feature for feature. Avon offers prices that are competitive
against other brands available in the retail stores.
2. Not widely advertised in mass media
5. Requires educational / demonstration effort to sell
A well-advertised product increases the chance of a prospect to
inquire from other sources instead of buying from the direct Products that require educational or demonstration effort enable
salesman. Tupperware sells unique plastic containers that are not the salesman to explain the differentiated features of the product
promoted in the mass media by other companies. they are selling. Noah Ion Cell Cleanse gives free foot detox to
prospects and customers while explaining the need to remove
excesses from food and vices like smoking.
3. Attractive profit margins
High income potential is offered to independent salesman (called 6. Almost everyone can use and use continuously
dealers or associates). The margins of the product should be large
enough to compensate for the efforts of the salesman as well as The selling of consumables that can be used by almost everybody
leave a decent profit for the company. NU Skin and Amway offer can capture a market for repeat purchases assuming customers are
a total commission of over 50%of the retail price for their sales happy with the product, service, as well as price. Sara Lee offers
leaders. a range of products like cosmetics, undergarments and clothes
that enable their dealers to continue doing business with their
clients.
Idea Generation
Lamoiyan Corporation came about when its owner’s former company was faced with an empty
plant, potential retrenchment of employees and an empty pocket, when major multinational customers
shifted from the aluminum tubes they have been supplying since 1987 to the more convenient
laminated plastic toothpaste tubes in 1997. Left with a huge inventory of aluminum tubes, Cecilio
Pedro (the owner) chose to go into toothpaste manufacturing and thus was born Hapee toothpaste.
Ideas need not always come from crisis situations. Lamoiyan’s relative success in the Philippine
market was exceptional. Luck and timing also played a major role. There must be systematic ways to
regularly get new product ideas aside from using a company’s suggestion box to attract ideas from any
employee. A creative source of new product ideas is available by simply talking to customers and the
sales force often, most especially about problems both groups are encountering with existing products.
Other opportunities can come from sourcing new inventions or by attending trade shows in other
countries. Marketers can also get new product ideas by analyzing and anticipating changes in industry,
technology, or environment. From a marketing standpoint, new ideas can be sourced by combining
answers to the questions “who” (target market), “what” (value proposition), “how and where”
(business system). The following marketing techniques can also be used to get new products ideas:
1. Mission Statement
2. Focus Group Discussions
3. Competitive Products Segmentation
4. Perceptual Mapping
5. Items by Use
Mission Statement
A mission statement answers the question “what business are we in?” The mission
Statement of any company will dictate what type of products or services they will offer.
But instead of stating the products such as “we sell air conditioners”, it is the benefits
of the products that are mentioned.
For example:
Carrier includes in their definition of business: “Ensuring Comfort and Peace of Mind Everywhere
A round the World”. This will not limit them in promoting only air conditioners but they may also
promote heaters in cold countries like the United States.
Exhibit 4-15: Examples of new product ideas from mission statement
• Photocopier
• Seatbelts, Car fire
• Crayons
• Consumer healthy lifestyle extinguishers
• Office productivity • Air purifiers, Foot detox, No-
• Bus oil cookware, Food
• Inspiring creative self- supplements, Exercisers
expression
• Computers, Facsimile
machines, paper shredders,
PABX System
A three-dimensional mission structure identifying customer
benefit, customer groups, and substitutes is suggested to define
possible mission statement products. An example is shown in
exhibit 4-16 for travel product.
Originally based on clinical psychology and altered for use in marketing, this
popular qualitative research method involves gathering together several small
groups of six to twelve people who all have some similar characteristics of
interest to the marketer. Usually, the FGD panellists are existing customers or
potential customers of a products category.
Idea Screening
A process used to evaluate innovative product ideas, strategies and marketing
trends.
Existing New
Brand
Existing Line Extension Franchise Extension
Since market segments usually overlap. It is difficult to position in different
segments independently. The overlap may result from a group of customers
who shift between segments or from media or channels of distribution that
impact both segment.
This multi-brand strategy may also be considered products where consumers
may not have as much consumer loyalty.
Using line or existing brands for existing products would be logic extensional
for products with various models or options.
For a new company’s product, marketers have to decide whether to use a
totally new brand (new innovation) or use an existing brand (brand franchise
extension). Both have advantages and disadvantages.
Using an existing popular brand may make it easier to enter a market in
the short term, especially with an increasingly crowded and expensive
media. It can also own a key word or benefit in the consumer’s mind.
Care must, however, be exercised in brand franchise extensions,
otherwise, it may dilute the parent brand.
David Arnold (1992) provided four criteria for successful franchise
extension of brands:
1. The brand essence (or identity) is still applicable.
2. The brand property
3. The brand variants could be promoted and distributed together
4. When repertoires (brand switching) are a hallmark of consumer behavior in
the category.
Using a new brand on the other hand, when done successfully, in
introducing a new product may earn it place in a product category.
No Meaning Brand Names
Decades ago there was much lesser competition so it was easier and
cheaper to launch products and be recognized. No-meaning names
became known because they represented something in the consumer
mind. The situation in today’s “crowded communication” market is
totally different
Brand Concept Management
A brand concept is not the same as a product concept. Product concept refers
to a new product idea while a brand concept reflects a general meaning or
associated with the brand.
1. Protection
2. Display Value
3. Cost
4. Convenience
5. Size
Performance Requirements
III. Primary Target Competition: RENO liver spread hold about 70% of the market. Other
more visible low-priced liver spread products are Rio, Rica, and Honey while the more
expensive ones locally are Swifts, Purefoods, Argentina and Lady’s Choice.
IV. Primary Target Market: Middle income broad C and lower income D.
V. Performance Objectives: The label design should meet the following requirements:
1. Display Value – Since canned liver spreads are usually sold thru supermarkets, groceries and sari-sari
store, we want to capture the immediate attention of consumers especially since we are new in the
market. Reinforcement will come from our point-of- purchase shelf- takers designed to create
interest and a good reason to buy by emphasizing “Kaisarap ng Lasa, Kaigaan sa Bulsa”.
2. It is observed that most labels of canned liver spread do not show product in use. We suggest a
sample design to include product in-use for distinction and consistency with our labels, which show
our products in use.
3. The size of the label is 21 cms. In length x 3 cms. In width.
4. To help target consumers stretch their food budget, various one-color food recipes using “888” liver
spread will be printed at the back of our label during the initial six months of launch.
5. Text of labels such as details of ingredients, weight, and manufacturer’s name and address as
required by the Bureau of Foods and Drugs, is attached for your layout.
VI. Timetable: We expect to see at least three recommendations, side by side with our competition, in 30
days time. As usual, our final choice or choices will be validated by our consumer panel.
I. Overall Objective: Describes the result expected such as designing label for a new product or
improving existing packaging.
II. Rationale: Discusses the background of the project.
III. Primary Target Competition: Identifies the principal competition, as well as other competition
for reference.
IV. Primary Target Market: Defines the expected or most logical volume of the product.
V. Performance Objectives: Outlines a priority list of packaging or attributes. Details unlit pack
or the outer pack, considering usage in the factory, in transit, in the retail level, in the
customer’s location. May include the image or emotional feelings that customers would
associate with the product.
VI. Timetable: Defines when product is needed for evaluation and estimated launch date.
Label Development Process
The BGC model gives weight to a competing brand's position in the market. Brands,
therefore, can be characterized as market leaders, challengers, or followers.
A market leader's Relative Market Share ( RMS) is computed
by dividing the leader's market share with the market
challenger's market share. A non-market leader's market share
by the market leader's market share.
The higher the RMS, the more dominant the company.
In the absence of a high RMS, a low RMS means that the
company is vulnerable to market challengers. Having a RMS
0.1 means that the company's sales volume is 10% of the
market leader's sales volume. While having 1 RMS means the
company has the same sales volume as their nearest competitor
Cash Cows are commonly referred to as "Today's Businesses".
Cash Cos are cash contributors to the company because of their
large market shares and relatively lower funding requirements to
finance further expansions.
So as not to oversimplify, BCG grid, we must qualify that not all Cash
Cows are in an ideal situation. A company may have only one Cash Cow
but several Question Marks or Doga which will make them vulnerable
when the Cash Cow needs some of the cash to defend its market shares
from aggressive competitor's attack.
General Electric Matrix
General Electricamd McKinsey and attractiveness business
strength matrix called the General Electric model.
Exhibit 4-40:
Green Marketing
"Social responsibility is not only responsibility to people but
also responsibility for making people PEOPLE."
-Prof. Emmanuel Fernandez
Consumer worldwide are now more educated and have better access to
information and choices making them demand products, packages and
processes that are safer to the environment.
Marketers should take a proactive role and assume responsibility for their
products and packages after use and disposal.
An ecological misstep can mean customer disapproval and even boycotts,
government fines, massive clean-up costs, and wasted time and effort.
Companies may suffer long term losses if they market products that are not
safe and have a high environmental risk.
Green Products