A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS

OF SELECTED MUTUAL
Introductio
FUNDS IN INDIA
Literature

motivation
Literature

Research
review
review

Name: Md Zaid Ansari

n

Roll No. : 3-28-17-0032

Reg. No. : A01-1142-2049-17
Introductio

motivation
Literature
Literature

Research
review
review

Why this topic?

Mutual funds are an under-tapped market in India. In spite of being
accessible in the market under 10% of Indian family units have put
resources into common assets. During my internship in Reliance AMC,
I was awestruck by the vastness and depth of the portfolio of products
offered. This project gives me the opportunity to learn more about
Mutual funds in detail.
 A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF
SELECTED MUTUAL FUNDS IN INDIA

• This project talks about the past and present scenario of Mutual

Introductio
Funds.

motivation
Literature
Literature

Research
• Mutual funds have seen a significant growth in the Indian market
review
review

since its inception in 1963.

n
• To understand how much mutual funds have grown , comparative
analysis of selected mutual funds have been done.
• This project further helps to understand which mutual fund to
select for better returns.
 Year & Author Title of the paper Objective Finding & Analysis
1966(J. TREYNOR AND A report on Can Mutual Fund Through their
K. MAUZY) performance of the outguess the market. research paper they
funds and their tried to answer the
sensitivity to market question, “ Are
fluctuations. Mutual Fund
managers successfully
anticipating major

Introductio
turns in stock

Literature

motivation
Literature

market?” They used

Research
review
57 mutual funds for
review

their study .

n
Their study reported
no statistical evidence
that the investment
managers of any of
the 57 funds have
successfully
outguessed the
market.
 Year & Author Title of the paper Objective Finding & Analysis
1968(Michael C. The performance of Evaluating a portfolio Through his study MC
Jensen) mutual funds in the manager's predictive Jensen derived “a risk-
period 1945-1964. ability. adjusted measure of
portfolio performance
(Jensen's alpha) that
estimates how much a
manager’s forecasting
ability contributes to
fund’s returns.”

Introductio
Literature
Literature

In his paper he

Literature
showed that on

review
review

review
average the funds
apparently were
not quite successful
enough in their
trading activities to
recoup even their
brokerage
expenses.
(diversification not
taken into account)
 Year & Author Title of the paper Objective Finding & Analysis
2003(SN Rao) Performance The objective of this His study consisted of a
Evaluation of Indian study was to evaluate sample of 269 open
Mutual Funds the performance of ended schemes (out of
Indian Mutual Fund total schemes of 433)
Schemes during bear for computing relative
market through performance index,
relative performance after excluding the
index (RPI), risk- funds whose returns
return analysis, are less than risk-free
Treynor’s ratio, returns, 58 schemes

Introductio
were used for further
Objective

Literature
Sharpe’s ratio, Sharp’s

Literature
measure, Jensen’s analysis. The results of

review
performance measures

review
measure, and Fama’s
measure suggest that most of
the mutual fund
schemes in the sample
of 58 were able to
satisfy investor’s
expectations by giving
excess returns over
expected returns based
on both premium for
systematic risk and
total risk.
 A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
OF SELECTED MUTUAL
Primary Secondary
FUNDS IN INDIA
methodology
1 2
Analysis &
Analysis &

Objective
Research
Findings
Findings

Name: Md Zaid Ansari

An in-depth
analysis of
to analyse the
performance of
Mutual Fund mutual fund
Portfolio by
taking sample of
Roll No. : 3-28-17-0032
scheme on the
basis of various
funds and parameters.
comparing it with
others.
 A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
OF SELECTED MUTUAL
FUNDS IN INDIA

methodology
Analysis &
Analysis &

Objective
Research
Findings
Findings

Name: Md Zaid Ansari

Data source Period of No.Methodology
study
Roll : 3-28-17-0032
Secondary data 1963-64 to 2018-19 Simple statistical
Graphs, Charts , pie charts
obtained from company
websites , brochures ,
tools
journals and magazines.
 AXIS LONG TERM EQUITY FUND (G)
 

A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
OBJECTIVE – The scheme seeks aggressive growth and to provide long term capital appreciation
through investing in different shares such as HDFC , KOTAK , MAHINDRA , LARSEN , TCS, HDFC
BANK ETC . OF SELECTED MUTUAL
Fund class ELSS
Fund type FUNDS IN INDIA
Open – ended

methodology
Option Growth
Analysis &

Analysis &

Objective
Research
Findings

Findings
Launch date 29-Dec-2009
Face value
Fund manager
Name: Md Zaid Ansari
10
Jinesh Gopani
NAV (01-04-2020) Roll No. : 3-28-17-0032
37.1961
AUM 21658.58 cr.
52 Week high 52.35
52 Week low 34.78
Entry load Nil
Exit load Nil

SOURCE : www.moneycontrol.com
 HDFC TOP 100 FUND (G)
OBJECTIVE – The scheme seeks aggressive growth and aims to provide long term capital
A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
appreciation through investment in shares such as STATE BANK OF INDIA , INFOSYS , ICICI BANK ,
LARSEN , RELIANCE ETC .
Type of scheme OF SELECTED MUTUAL
LARGE CAP
Fund type
Option
FUNDS IN INDIA
Open – ended
Growth

methodology
Analysis &

Analysis &

Objective
Launch date 11-Oct-1996

Research
Findings

Findings
Name: Md Zaid Ansari
Face value 10
Fund manager Prashant Jain
NAV (01-04-2020) 332.449
AUM
Roll No. : 3-28-17-0032
16,819 cr.

52 week high 521.12

52 week low 307.24
Entry load NIL
Exit load 1% on or before 1 Year ; Nil after 1 Year

SOURCE : www.moneycontrol.com
 ICICI Prudential Multicap Fund
OBJECTIVE – The scheme seeks aggressive growth and aims to provide medium and long term
A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
capital appreciation through investment in shares such as HDFC BANK , POWER GRID , WIPRO ,
ICICI BANK ETC .
Type of scheme OF SELECTED MUTUAL
LARGE CAP

FUNDS IN INDIA
Fund type Open – ended
Option Growth

methodology
Launch date 01-Oct-1994
Analysis &

Analysis &

Objective
Research
Findings

Findings
Face value 10
Fund manager
NAV (01-04-2020)
Name: Md Zaid Ansari
Sankaran Naren
199.15
AUM Roll No. : 3-28-17-0032
5081.52 cr
52 week high 307.67
52 week low 187.76
Entry load NIL
Exit load 1% if the investor redeem it before a span of 1 year .

SOURCE : www.moneycontrol.com
 COMPARISION OF RETURNS
PERIOD AXIS LONG TERM HDFC TOP 100 FUND ICICI Prudential Multicap

A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
EQUITY FUND (%) (%) Fund
3Months -24.53% -33.75% -33.66%

OF SELECTED MUTUAL
6 Months -20.33% -29.40% -28.69%
1 Year -15.38% -34.13% -33.07%
2 years
3 Years
-7.76%
7.73% FUNDS IN INDIA -22.52%
-17.27%
-26.02%
-21.83%

methodology
5 Years 18.33% -3.99% -0.47%
Analysis &

Analysis &

Objective
Research
Findings

Findings
AXIS LONG TERM EQUITY FUND (%)
Name: Md Zaid Ansari
Chart Title
HDFC TOP 100 FUND (%) ICICI Prudential Multicap Fund

18.33%
Roll No. : 3-28-17-0032

7.73%

-0.47%
3 M ont hs 6 M ont hs 1 Year 2 ye a r s 3 Years 5 Years

-3.99%
-7.76%
-15.38%

-17.27%
-20.33%

-21.83%
-22.52%
-24.53%

-26.02%
-28.69%
-29.40%

-33.07%
-33.66%
-33.75%

-34.13%

ANALYSIS: The above table and graphical representation shows return given by these
three funds . the best performing fund is AXIS LONG TERM EQUITY FUND because of
the stock selection by the fund manager.
 ASSET ALLOCATION

  AXIS LONG
A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
HDFC TOP 100 ICICI
TERM EQUITY FUND (G) Prudential
FUND (%) Multicap Fund
Equity 93.71 OF SELECTED MUTUAL
98.16 96.85
Debt 5.19
FUNDS IN INDIA
Chart Title
1.81 1.03

methodology
Analysis &

Analysis &

Objective
120

Research
Findings

Findings
100

80

60
Name: Md Zaid Ansari
40
Roll No. : 3-28-17-0032
20

0
AXIS LONG TERM EQUITY FUND (%) HDFC TOP 100 FUND (G) ICICI Prudential Multicap Fund

Equity Debt
Analysis- Since these funds are equity funds , the investment in equity should be more than 65% .
Anything below this would make it a debt fund . So from this table and bar chart we can clearly
see that these funds have a majorly invested in equity which is far above the minimum requisite
 SECTORAL ALLOCATION: AXIS LONG TERM EQUITY FUND

A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
AXIS LONG TERM AXIS LONG TERM EQUITY FUND
Sectors
OF SELECTED MUTUAL
EQUITY FUND 21%

37%

Financial Services 37.00

Consumer Goods
FUNDS IN INDIA
17.00
5%

methodology
Analysis &

Analysis &

Objective
Research
Findings

Findings
8%
IT 12.00

Automobile Name: Md Zaid Ansari

8.00 12%
17%

Chemicals 5.00
Roll No. : 3-28-17-0032
Financial Services
Automobile
Consumer Goods
Chemicals
IT
others

SOURCE :https://www.axismf.com
 SECTORAL ALLOCATION: HDFC TOP 100 FUND (G)

A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
HDFC TOP 100 FUND HDFC TOP 100 FUND (G)
Sectors

Banks (Private sector)

OF SELECTED MUTUAL
(G)

35.8% 13%

FUNDS IN INDIA
Banks (Private sector)

Computer-Software
Computer-Software 18.3 36%

methodology
16%
Analysis &

Analysis &

Objective
Refineries

Research
Findings

Findings
Refineries 17.5%

Name: Md Zaid Ansari

Banks (Public sector)

Banks (Public sector) 15.89 Power generation & supply

18%

Roll No. : 3-28-17-0032

18%
Power generation & 12.51
supply

SOURCE :https://www.hdfcsec.com/
 SECTORAL ALLOCATION: ICICI Prudential Multicap Fund

A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
ICICI Prudential Multicap Fund
Sectors ICICI Prudential
Multicap Fund

Banks - Private Sector

OF SELECTED MUTUAL
35.17%
15%
13%

35%

Power Generation And

Supply FUNDS IN INDIA
18.69%
18%

methodology
19%
Analysis &

Analysis &

Objective
Telecommunications -

Research
Findings

Findings
Service Provider 18.44%

Finance & Investments Name: Md Zaid Ansari

14.6%

Pharmaceuticals - Indian 13.10%

Roll No. : 3-28-17-0032
- Bulk Drugs & Formln Banks - Private Sector Power Generation And Supply
Telecommunications - Service Provider Finance & Investments
Pharmaceuticals - Indian - Bulk Drugs & Formln

SOURCE :https://www.hdfcsec.com/

ANALYSIS – It is evident from the above table & pie chart that all these mutual
funds house have biggest investment in the banking sector followed by the IT
sectors .
 FINDINGS

• Active management of funds is a far better approach than passive management

of funds because portfolios are continuously checked & revised to take
appropriate measures .
Conclusion
• Diversifying a portfolio is necessary to manage risk.
Bibliograph

Limitation

Findings
• Before Investing , the past performance of several years should be considered and
y

consistency should be checked rather than going for higher return in recent
period.
• Portfolio is created as per Investor’s tolerance level of risk .
 Literature
review
Literature
review
Introductio
Research
n
motivation

YOU
THANK