Sie sind auf Seite 1von 25

MZUMBE UNIVERSITY

Business research methods course: BUS 5032

Lecture 1 Introduction to scientific business and management research


Philibert C. Ndunguru B.A; M.B.A.; Ph.D. Professor of Business Administration and Statistics

Why MBA/MSc?
Desire to join the Club of Scientific Community Fascinated by the scientists expertise in solving puzzles through a research activity Admiring scientists eloquent style of investigating and explaining real world puzzles in their discipline: business, public admin, economics, sociology, politics, law, physics, biology, etc.
2

Science and scientists


Science as a discipline with its paradigm set of theories, methods of measurement instruments and instrumentation Science as an approach or style of comprehending, investigating and explaining puzzles that engulf mankind Scientists articulate and develop an approach in attempting to account for and accommodate behaviour of relevant aspects of the real world as revealed by results of experimentation
3

Scientific approach 1/3


Science = logic Logic = rationalism, or that makes sense and is reasonable Rationalism = opinions be logical + formal proof process for verifying stated assertions The opposite of rationalism is existentialism = informal proof process Not all logic is science
4

Scientific approach 2/3


Logic must be verified by empirical evidence through process of observation Observation = experience, empiricism, able to be verified by sense organs of seeing, touching, feeling, hearing, or smelling Science = logic + observation

Scientific approach 3/3


Empiricism = only material things exist; observed concrete data; The anti-thesis of empiricism is idealism = data based on interpretive ideas e.g., dreams Styles of acquiring knowledge based on rationalism and empiricism (see figure 1-1): Quadrant 1: scientific method Quadrant 2: ???? Quadrant 3: method of authority or dogma Quadrant 4: ????
6

Styles of acquiring knowledge


Figure 1-1:
empiricism Scientific method

existentialism

rationalism

Method of authority/ dogma idealism


7

Assumptions of Scientific method


Nature is orderly Nature can be understood Knowledge is superior to ignorance Natural phenomenon has a natural cause Nothing is self-evident Knowledge is derived from acquisition of experience that is associated with perceptions and observations
8

Scientists cardinal problems


Scientific method is about acquiring knowledge: theories, laws, hypotheses, principles, etc Search for invariance (theory-building) Search for explanation of invariance (theory-testing) The search is a continuous and everlasting throughout history of mankind The search generates, accumulates, and expands frontiers of knowledge
9

Goals in scientific research


Theory-building (by assumptions nature is orderly, and it can be understood) this is the idea of searching for invariance Theory-testing (by assumptions every effect has a cause, nothing is self-evident) this is the outcome of searching explanation of invariance Nominal goal of research is to expand frontiers of knowledge (by assumptions knowledge is superior to ignorance, experience associated with perceptions and observations leads to knowledge)
10

How scientists do their work


Steps to accomplish goals of the searching: Determining a puzzle to be searched Defining concepts for communicating Setting-up research questions and tentative statements of truth hypotheses or propositions Collecting data Data analysis: validating each statement if not empirically verifiable science is sceptical Present results and findings
11

Research problem
A puzzle is of a theoretical and/or empirical nature; and is referred to as a research problem. Definition 1-1: A scientific research problem is an observation statement or set of statements that contradicts or is enigmatic in the light of some theory or background knowledge of the time Knowledge gap is implied in the definition above and research activity is meant to fill the gap
12

Knowledge gap for research


Gap 1 observation statements not adequately described, explained, or predicted by existing theories or laws Gap 2 existence of contradicting theoretical constructs that logically describe, explain or predict the same phenomenon Gap 3 failure of theories to stand up observational tests; failure of theories to predict events
13

Management research process


Business entity is a conglomeration of GCS, IS, OS defined by a STRUCTURE Management research problems are about a gap in efficiency and effectiveness of a business entity A gap means a problem in form of undesirable effect/impact, or an opportunity for better performance Such problems may be at the GCS, IS, OS, or STRUCTURE levels
14

GCS problems
Vision Mission Operating philosophy core values Strategy Structure -

15

IS problems
IS concerned with information and communication without which rational management is impossible Integration: the extent to which MIS is integrated within the organization (trade-off between centralization and decentralization); Neutrality - info is power and there is a struggle to control it: reflecting placement of MIS Note: IS = total; MIS = formal part of the IS

16

OS problems
OS converts inputs into outputs Decision making Execution, monitoring and evaluation Equipment design Role allocation Estimating capacity Production planning Time management
17

STRUCTURE problems
Vertical sub-division of tasks: lines of authority versus staff functions Horizontal sub-division of tasks: span of control versus specialization The conflicts together they lead to communication problems

18

Typology of research
Pure basic tackling theoretical problem Basic objective tackling practical problems: how participation enhances rural development strategies Evaluation assessing some aspect of performance Applied - solving problem by applying existing knowledge: how good governance leads to economic growth or MIS enhancing performance Action management research/consulting
19

Science, theory and research


Figure 1-2:
Theories and laws Falsifiable hypotheses granted status of theory or law science research New facts and relationships in form of practice derived from research Research problem derived from theories

20

The learning cycle


The science-theory-research relationship above corroborates Kolbs experiential learning cycle from psychology Concrete experience (practice) in form of observations and reflections form abstract concepts and generalization (theories) which are tested in new situations (research) under concrete experience
21

Kolbs experiential learning cycle


Figure 1-3:
Concrete experience

Testing implications of concepts in new situations

Observation s and reflections

Formation of abstract concepts and generalization


22

Research process in perspective 2/2


Theory and practice are the corner points of conceptualizing a research project and for undertaking a scientific research; Logic and Observation guides a scientific research Problem statement; hypotheses, design, measurement, data collection, data analysis, generalizations and conclusions are all linked to theory and practice See Figure 1-4 in the Lectures
23

Research process in perspective 1/2


problem hypotheses Generalization and conclusions THEORY and PRACTICE Data analysis

Research design

Data collection

measurement
24

Getting a research topic in practice


Current debates in society, profession, discipline, business, etc reflect gaps in knowledge between theory and practice Academic forums, news-media, journals, etc are sources to get current debates Be conversant with theories and current theoretical and methodological debates in your discipline Marketing, finance, accounting, banking, human resources, entrepreneurship, SMEs, internal trade systems, international business, ICT, best practices in business systems, corporate planning, etc
25