Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
MFS
MFS
MFS
MFS
MFS
Sit Back,
Relax, Enjoy,
The Presentation
Difference between tangible and financial services marketing, Characteristics of services, Why is planning essential for banks? Benefits of planning, Strategic and marketing plans, Factors affecting banks strategy, Changes in banks strategy in the 1980s, New approach to banks marketing style, Elements of a marketing plan, Marketing mix in financial services, Planning corporate account strategy, Pricing decisions and strategy, and The future of marketing for banks.
One of the major problems facing the promoters of financial services as opposed to tangible products, is that services cannot be experienced in a tangible manner. Services cannot be: (a) touched, (b) tasted, (c) handled, or (d) purchased in bulk like tangible products.
The Acronym (HIPI) will help you remember the characteristics of services. Heterogeneity
Although all bank branches sell the same services, the standard of service is not uniform from branch to branch.
Intangibility
Marketing of financial services must necessarily stress the Benefits because services cannot be touched, tasted or in Any way experienced by the senses. While a service may have some tangible representations like: cheque book covers, bank statements, plastic cards, these represent only a small part of the intangible service. Purchase of financial services often involves a highly emotive decision. Different services also present a different level of risk to the customer.
e.g current account may be considered low risk mortgage account may be considered high risk.
Perishability
Services are highly perishable since they cannot be stored (e.g. time when sales persons are not serving customers cannot be utilized to expand service at peak periods.) Demand for services fluctuates from day to day, week to week, month to month, especially for branches in tourist areas.
Inseparability
Most of the time services cannot be separated from the sales consultants (e.g. investment advisor, corporate manager).
If a customers need investment advice, they must go to an investment advisor duly authorized by the bank to provide an advisory service. Services are frequently created at the time they are used, unlike the tangible products, which must be produced before they can be sold to customers.
A bank without a formal planning process is like a ship without a destination. Quotation: A bank that fails to plan is planning to fail. Any commercial organization, which fails to plan its future will quickly become out of touch with its environment, thus leaving itself vulnerable to competitor activity aimed at gaining a dominant place in the market.
The value of planning lies in the bank or financial institution, being in a position to control its own future.
This is principally due that the bank should be in constant touch with a fast changing environment. A systematic appraisal is developed and incorporated in a written plan, which will provide continuity of thought and action from one year to the next.
(a)Executives are forced to set corporate objectives thus providing guidance for the banks operations (b) Planning identifies the resource needs of each activity, balances these needs against available resources, and allocates these resources in the most efficient way,
(c) A good planning process should make all staff more aware of their own roles and responsibilities
(d) A formal plan forces banks or other organizations to considers its own Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats (e.g. SWOT Analysis).
(e) A good plan will enable a bank or financial services provider to identify the customers needs and wants, thus enabling the bank to build strategies for any profitable segment identified, (f) The bottom line of any planning process is to monitor new development in the business environment, and try to be in control.
Marketing Plan Financial Plan Human Resources Plan Risk Management Plan
With the growing level of competition, and the rapid pace of change, banks started to focus their attention on strategic planning, Marketing plan emerged as an essential tool in the overall strategic plan, In spite of this new development, some traditional banks remained with the old banking business concept instead of employing modern management business skills within the banking business. Unfortunately, some traditional banks went out of Business earlier than expected.
1. Mission Statement
It states the overall purpose of bank or any organization.
2. Key Objectives
Objectives are cited for variables such as: (a) financial return expected, (b) degree of efficiency required, size of loans or credit on offer, and (d) service quality
3. Market Assumptions
These contain explicit statements about future trends in strategic market segments, which may affect the banks freedom to act.
5. Assessment of Opportunities
The plan should assess the threats and opportunities for each market segment. This is important in order to achieve the mission & objectives
7. Strategic Changes
Objectives & goals for action plans stating changes in capabilities or resources under the control of unit management and selected as most likely for achieving the desired market results.
Mission Statement Key Objectives Environment & Market Assumptions Competitive Strengths Evaluation Market Portfolio Strategy Assessment of Opportunities
Strategic Changes Action Plans For Implementation Evaluation Process Action Plans For Implementation
The banking industry around the world has been changing very rapidly since the early 1970s. The industry has experienced a substantial change in competitive conditions as a result of a number of factors: the industry tended to go international, led by the
leading US commercial banks, new competitors entering the financial services market new approaches to servicing corporate clients new capital markets emerged as a result transformed traditional funding of banks & MNCs a wide range of sophisticated products were introduced under packaged sales
to build up their own multi-national presence through their own brand name, banks began to channel their marketing resources towards diversification, by the end of 1970s, banks operations had become more complex with the range of services on offer, while margins on lending were eroded through competition, fee-based services were increasing, non-bank financial institutions were also providing financial services hence, more competition, (e.g. General Motors, Shell Co, American Express. Large stores, and Supermarkets)
operations of the banks and became one of the key drivers, (e.g. back office became automated),
savings and loans associations initiated interest-
bearing transaction accounts and brought direct competition to commercial banks, and
professionals like accountants, lawyers, real estate
In the 1980s the banking industry experienced an acceleration in the pace of change in both: (a) retail, and (b) wholesale market. Retail Banking Increased Segmentation of Consumer Groups
and provided Specialist Private Banking Services (e.g. rich individuals, High-Net-Worth customers) Stratified Accounts (e.g. personal loans, credit finance,
insurance products, 1st & 2nd line mortgages, deposits FD & S/Term)
Replacement of Paper-Based Accounting Systems, Increased competition for loans and deposits
Banks portray themselves as a One Stop Financial Services Centre. Banks no longer remain in their traditional service market. They are now more aggressive in providing a full menu of services that will cater for its customers needs. The competition is so fierce that they can offer any type of service provided their customers are satisfied with the speed efficiency & costs involved. Banks in certain industrial countries are now mobile in such a manner, that they will visit you at your doorsteps.
Technology is one considered as one of the key drivers that enables banks to cope with the intensity of competition.
Overdraft, Fixed Rate Short Term Loan, Acceptance Finance, Multi-currency Lending, Hire Purchase, Tax Leasing, Leverage Leasing, Parallel Loans, Commodity & Stock Loan, Variable Term Loan, Syndicated Loan, Secured Equipment Loan, Merchandise Loan, Property Construction Loan, Merger & Acquisition Finance, Mortgage Finance Loan.
Domestic Transfers Cheques, Banker payments, Standing orders instruction, Credit transfers, Bank-to-bank transfers, Direct debits,
Commercial Credits Clean credits, Documentary credits, Import & Export credits.
Trust Services Executorships, Share registrars, Safe deposit services, Estate planning, Tax planning, Life insurance, Trusteeships, Shares & Bonds purchases, Pension fund management, Corporate trustee services, Investment advice, and Dividend payments.
Consultancy Services Invoicing centres, Treasury management, Pension Fund advice, Insurance Man advice, Forex forecasting, Training in finance, and Financial plan & money management service.
Payroll management & accounting, Factoring of commercial invoices, Travel arrangements, Life Insurance planning, Economic & strategic studies, Correspondent banking services, Data processing services, Non-life insurance planning, and Consumer banking services
Low
PROBLEM CHILD
Strategy Build or Harvest or Divest
DOG
Strategy Harvest or Divest
Star
Where the bank would make investments in order to build up or expand its Business Units (BU),
Problem Child
Where the bank allows market share to decline in order to maximize short-term profitability & cash flow, regardless of the long-term effect,
MARKET
CURRENT MARKET C U R R E N T NEW MARKET
P R O D U C T
Market Penetration
Market Development
N E W
Product Development
Source: Ansoff Matrix
Diversification
(1) Market Penetration This strategy is the least risky of the 4 strategies because it involves increasing market share in existing markets.
(4) Diversification
With this strategy, the bank is moving into new market with new products.
The McKinsey model argues that businesses should develop their growth strategies based on:
Operational skills,
Privileged assets,
Growth can be achieved by looking at business opportunities along several dimensions, summarized in the diagram. The McKinsey Model resembles the Ansoff Model.
Acquisitions
Joint Ventures
How?
New Delivery Systems New Products & Services
Existing Products to new customers Existing Products to existing customers
Operational Skills
They are the core competences that a business has which can provide the foundation for a growth strategy. (e.g. the business may have strong competencies in customer service; distribution, technology).
Privileged Assets
Those assets are held by the business that are hard to replicate by competitors. (e.g. in a direct marketing-based business these assets might
include a particularly large customer database, or a wellestablished brand).
Growth Skills
These are the skills that businesses need if they are to successfully manage a growth strategy.
These include the skills of new product development, or negotiating and integrating acquisitions.
Special Relationships
Such relationships are those that can open up new options. (e.g. the business may have specially string relationships with
trade bodies in the industry that can make the process of growing in export markets easier than for the competition) .
The model outlines seven ways of achieving growth, which are summarized as follows: Existing products to existing customers Existing products to new customers New products and services
Existing products to existing customers The lowest-risk option; try to increase sales to the existing customer base; this is about increasing the frequency of purchase and maintaining customer loyalty. Existing products to new customers Taking the existing customer base, the objective is to find entirely new products that these customers might buy, or start to provide products that existing customers currently buy from competitors
A combination of Ansoffs market development & diversification strategy taking a risk by developing and marketing new products. Some of these can be sold to existing customers who may trust the business (and its brands) to deliver; entirely new customers may need more persuasion New delivery systems
This option focuses on the use of distribution channels as a possible source of growth. Are there ways in which existing products and services can be sold via new or emerging channels which might boost sales?
New geographic areas With this method, businesses are encouraged to consider new geographic areas into which to sell their products. Geographical expansion is one of the most powerful options for growth but also one of the most difficult. New industry structure This option considers the possibility of acquiring troubled competitors or consolidating the industry through a general acquisition programme. New competitive arenas This option requires a business to think about opportunities to integrate vertically or consider whether the skills of the business could be used in other industries.
Desired Revenue
Revenue
50 40 30 20 10 0 Time
GAP analysis can be used at a number of levels of Planning strategic, operational, product & market.
The resultant gap analysis will enable the bank to choose between one or two courses of action: (a) plan strategies to close the gap, and (b) redefine the objective so that they produce the same result as the current projected trends.
Changes in the external environment can affect the desirability of the potential strategies of a bank due to changes in its relative position in the market.
The changes follow the acronym (LePESTCo): External Factors (1) Le Legal (2) P Political (3) E Economic (4) S Social (5) T Technological (6) Co Competition
POLITICAL
Attitude of the Government towards the local banks, Attitude of the Government towards foreign banks & non-bank financial institutions.
ECONOMIC CONDITIONS
Industry Structure, Gross Domestic Product (GDP), National Rate of Inflation & Money Supply, Foreign Exchange Rates, Interest Rates, and Unemployment Levels.
TECHNOLOGY
Development in Integrated Technology, Changes in Technological Industry, Levels of Investment Required, and Customers attitudes towards new technology.
COMPETITION
Existing players in the Market, New Entrants penetrating the Market, Pricing of Financial Services/Products, Marketing Style, and Consolidation within the Banks.
COMPETITOR ANALYSIS
Market share, Financial position, Reputation among suppliers and creditors, Composition of the clientele, Menu of product/service range, Strategies for segmentation, key accounts, Pricing, Image & service quality standards & performance, Efficiency of service delivery, Promotion aspects (e.g. spending, timing & reach), Technology used for service delivery, Planning, information & control systems, Ability to attract qualified personnel, Training, morale, union relations, Commitment to research & development, and Plan to diversify within, and/or, outside the industry.
A sound marketing plan should also considers the impact of internal factors such as: (a) Employees, (b) Premises, (c) Systems, and (d) Financial resources needed to back the plan.
Employees
Does the bank have adequate qualified employees to handle the marketing campaign? Are the employees fully aware of the marketing plan and their respective responsibilities? In the event of a shortage of employees will they be recruited from the banks competitors or given internal training? Will the employees be given a marketing target to achieve within a specific period of time?
Premises
Where will the marketing campaign be executed - Head Office, or Branch Level?
Are the current premise visible or adequate to promote the marketing campaign?
Will there be any additional cost to be incurred to make the premises more user friendly and appealing? How are the premises styled open plan or closed counters?
Systems
Are the present systems adequate or robust enough to handle the marketing campaign? Are the systems user friendly?
Financial Resources
Is there a specific budget allocation for the marketing campaign? Who will be responsible to manage the budget? Has adequate provisions made to include cost overrun of the campaign? Does the budget time frame match the marketing campaign period? Is the marketing campaign costs built into the service costs?
Market Characteristics
Assess the market size, Test for historic growth rate, Make a projection of the growth rate, Count the number of accounts in total, Evaluate the trend in market concentration, Consider the buying decision process, Evaluate the service delivery process, and Assess the characteristics of customers.
Service Characteristics
Relative capital intensity, Work out the degree of service differentiation, What is the Value Added? Consider the level and type of risk faced by the bank, Test the relative profitability of the service, What are the potential for cross-selling opportunities?, The impact of shared-cost structures, Rate of service change and innovation, Service integration with other bank services, and Attitude of customers to new services/products.
Environmental Characteristics
Political stance and their impact on the industry, Impact of new technology and trends, Impact of social attitudes, and Economic dynamics and its impact on the industry.
Identify the existing competitors and their market share (to include non-bank financial institutions), Evaluate the banks market share towards its competitors, Consider the impact of changes of competitors, What is the major trend in the market share?, Evaluate the degree of competitor concentration in the market, Test for relative service price, cost, and marketing effort, Assess the relative capital intensity, What is the position regarding entry or exit barriers?, Work out the relative employee skills required, Consider the relative resource availability to the bank, and Assess the systems capability, and Evaluate the services life cycle of the industry.
Demand
Embryonic
Growth
Shakeout
Maturity
Decline
Time
Competitive Rivalry
C O M P E T I T I V E S C O P E
1. COST LEADERSHIP
Broad Target
2. DIFFERENTIATION
Cost Leadership
This can be achieved through market leadership, or from economies of scale (e.g. with high sales and aggressive costs
control).
The bank can try to achieve lower costs by means of encouraging customers to use products in a way that is cheaper for the bank (e.g. ATMs, SWITCH, DELTA cards). The bank will also have to promote the benefits such as convenience to the customers. Depending on the type of market, cost leadership may be difficult to maintain in banking, because many services are broadly similar. For a small market, diversification for cost leadership strategy may not be feasible.
Differentiation
This is where a bank seeks to be unique in the financial services sector by producing a product/service, delivery system or image that is distinctive from its competitors. Differentiation is only successful if the customers perceive the difference. Banks would tend to use marketing slogan such as:
Youre better of talking to Barclays, The bank that says Yes The listening bank Your partner in development Your solutions bank
The major problem with differentiation as a strategy is that financial services can be easily copied and adapted by other competitors using slight different wordings.
Cost Focus
While the cost leadership and differentiation strategies aim at a broad target, the focus strategies aim at a narrow target. The bank would normally select a target market (s) & tailors its strategy to the specific need of the target market (s). (e.g. select a quoted MNCs as its target market, and aim to serve them
to the virtual exclusion of other target markets).
Differentiation Focus
This approach can be described as finding a niche in the market place and developing services that matches the niche market. If the target market is too small, the bank may be left with a service menu that is not profitable.
Product
Price
People
Place
Promotion
Product/Service
This concerned with the features of the bank products, and any option available to the customer. (e.g. bank lending would include the term of loans fixed or variable
rate and option to switch from variable to fixed rate or vice versa).
Place
Where the product or service is being made available to the customer, or how can the customer obtain the service.
(e.g. branch network, ATMs, Internet banking).
Price
This refers to the interest rates offered to depositors and borrowers, bank charges, commissions for services.
Promotion
It is concerned with advertising, direct sales, tele-marketing, internet, personal visits to the customer.
People
In view of the heavy competition, banks expect their staff to take a pro-active selling or customer service role. In fact, bankers are more sales persons these days than two decade ago. It requires training or re-training and in many cases a profound cultural change in the bank as a whole, as people adjust to new selling roles. In the marketing of financial services, it is imperative that the staff (people) takes the centre stage in order to achieve success.
In planning to target the corporate market, a bank would necessarily have to consider the following factors:
Financial Data * Sales, * Gross margin, * Sales growth rate potential, * Net margin, * Trend in the margin for the other banks, * Sales percentage by the major line of business, * Stock turnover, * Debtors ageing trend, * Creditors facilities, * Trends in working capital for the corporate, * Demand for plant & equipment, * Trends in fixed asset investments, * Short-term & long-term debts profile, * Debt maturity schedule, * Interest rate charged & paid, * Equity capital injected, and * Major shareholders.
General Screening
Prospecting Needs Identification Strategy Assessment A/Cs Action Planning Review Relationship Dev
Competitor Analysis
Existing lead bankers, Other bankers.
Advisors
o Accountants, o Lawyers, o Consultants
Pricing decisions are not only made in relation to new products, but also in relation to the existing products.
Pricing decisions must be made, taking into account the banks environment & how the factors constituting the environment can be controlled. The factors can be divided into (a) internal & (b) external.
Internal factors marketing objectives, marketing mix strategy, costs involved, and organization for pricing.
External factors nature of the market & demand, competition, and LePEST
Once a new product/service has been developed, a bank will need to decide upon the price to charge, and to test the acceptability by the target market using market research approach. Three of the most important strategies for pricing new Products/services are as follows: (1) Skimming Pricing,
Skimming Pricing
This involves setting a high initial price for the product/ service so as to just skim the cream of demand for the product/service. It is especially suitable for new products because: (a) new products are less affected by price until the competition arrives, (b) a high initial price many help the product gain an image of prestige and quality, (c) a high initial price often produces more revenue in the early days, thus bringing in funds to finance expansion into larger markets, (d) there are sufficient buyers to pay the high price, (i.e. demand is inelastic), and (e) a skimming price can be means for testing demand.
Penetration Pricing
This the opposite of skimming pricing; it sets a low price in order to capture a large share of the market quickly. This is a valid policy if one of more of the following conditions apply: (1)The intention is to capture a large share in a mass market, (2) Strong competition will emerge soon after introduction, (3) When the market appears price sensitive, and (4) Substantial economies in production, and/or, distribution costs can be achieved with a large sales volume.
A bank must consider changing the price of the existing products/services in certain circumstances. The strategies may be considered along those lines: (a) Cost Plus Pricing, (b) Break-Even Pricing, (c) Relationship Pricing, (d) Loss-leader Pricing, (e) Competitive Pricing, (f) Pricing for Market Share, and (g) Differential Pricing. The marketing committee or team is usually responsible to feed the strategist or the management team of the best approach, considering the market circumstances.
The methodology is practically similar to the sales of tangible commodities. For such a strategy to be very productive, it is essential that the true cost is obtained from the outset before the final price is determined. No business wants to operate at a loss, let alone, a bank or financial institution.
Break-even Pricing
Such a pricing strategy speaks for itself break-even where the product/service sold does not realized a profit or loss. Both the fixed and variable costs are taken into account when such a price is determined by the management. One would ask, this is not in line with sound commercial practice? This strategy can be used by management to adjust the price to fit in with expected demand and customer sensitivity until a price is arrived that fits the target sales and equally produces the desired profit result. Unless, this practice is closely monitored by the marketers and report to the management the bank can loose a lot of money within a short period of time.
Relationship Pricing
This is particularly important when a bank is trying to deal with the corporate clientele and high net worth individuals. In order to cross-sell other services, other prices may be adjusted downwards in order to keep the business, while increasing the profits overall from these customers. It is an important development that the management of a bank must be able to track down the trend in the revenue generation process. Otherwise, the bank will be placed at a serious disadvantage which can cost the shareholders very dearly.
Loss-leader Pricing
The term loss-leader means that you need to sell one particular product at loss, which is necessarily linked to other more profitable products/services. This is not a bad strategy, subject that the marketing team together with the management team are in control of the entire campaign. In the case, a bank would know that it is operating a service at a loss, but on the other side, it provide the bank with the opportunity to cross-sell other services. The loss-leader service would be usually a service that is not mutually exclusive (i.e. standing on its own). This strategy resembles buy one item- get one free
Competitive Pricing
It is absolutely crucial that when a bank is considering its marketing plan, which is embodied in the strategic plan, the various pricing strategies are considered. Customers normally would base their buying decisions after considering all the built-in features including the price. The typical psychological behaviour I will buy it if the price is right. Financial services marketing is not different from the other commodities. If the market is fiercely competitive, then the bank may have to price its products/services at the price that the market is expected to bear.
Differential Pricing
What does differential means? It means to be different! Different from whom? Externally, different from your competitors, and internally, different from service-service. Internally, certain methods of conducting business transactions are cheaper for the bank & customers. It encourages customers to move away from voluminous payment of say salaries by cheques, but by means of electronic transfer. It is less expensive for the bank to handle thousands of salaried payments electronically, than by cheques due to the time involved.
The marketing campaign of banks services has always been dynamic since de-regulation of the financial services sector took effect in the 80s. The competitive pressure by various players in the financial services sector will not diminished in any form or substance. Instead, it is expected that as competition intensified from all fronts, the marketing campaign by banks to retain, let alone, increase their market share will equally become more aggressive.
Banks can only retain customers loyalty through the delivery of service quality combined with risk-based pricing method. Banks must also pay attention to their customers needs.